Chapter Text
Steve refuses to admit to himself just how excited he is to see Billy again when he clocks in for work on Friday. He tries to keep his voice flat when he says goodnight to Elaina and Kevin but barely manages; the second shift security lead gives him a curious look on her way through the door but Kevin doesn’t give two shits about why Steve’s in such a good mood. The grouchy older man heads out as soon as they’re done exchanging pleasantries. Steve watches them go, crossing from one screen to another until they reach the no-man’s land of the parking lot.
The sun sets less than an hour later. The night is warm, borderline balmy with the addition of Lake Michigan humidity.
Perfect for an evening swim.
Perfect for his definitely-not-a-date with Billy.
“Shit, I should have given him my number. Why didn’t I give him my number!?” The anxious brunette paces back and forth across the tiny office, hands wringing at his sides. It’s nearly midnight and there’s still no sign of the cute merman. “Would it have been weird to hand him my phone and ask? Probably. Jeez, Harrington, take a fucking chill pill before you pass out.”
“Yeah, Harrington,” a smooth voice comes from just outside the door and Steve jumps. “Take a fucking chill pill.”
“Billy? Is that you?”
“Duh. Were you expecting someone else?”
“N-No, of course not!”
“Good, cause I hate sharing. Now are you coming out or what? I thought we had plans.”
Steve flings the door open, making no attempt to hide his joyful grin now that the object of his stifled affection is right in front of him. “You came back!”
Billy raises an eyebrow slowly, theatrically. “You invited me back. Again I say duh, pretty boy . ”
“I-” Steve coughs into his fist and slowly leans his hip against the doorframe. He’s trying hard to seem nonchalant but it’s not going very well. “I wasn’t sure if you’d take me up on my offer.”
“It’s not often I get a free pass to stretch my tail in a saltwater tank this large. Or uninhabited.”
“You swim with the animals!?”
“Sometimes there aren’t any other options,” Billy shrugs. “The dolphins at the Shedd Aquarium are nice enough but the ones at SeaWorld in California are bitches. Probably has to do with the size of their pools.”
“And you can just… talk to them? For real?”
“Yeah. I don’t know why or how, since Mom didn’t really stick around long enough to explain everything, but… Dick around for enough hours trying to chat with a sea turtle and stuff just happens, I guess.”
“Huh,” Steve blinks stupidly as this wealth of new information sinks in. He pushes away from the doorframe and leads Billy back through the park to the empty dolphin enclosure. “Are you messing with me right now?”
“No. I promise I’m not messing with you, Steve; I’ve actually gone swimming with some really rude sea life. Turns out I’m a terrible conversationalist when it comes to historical turtle facts. Now, do you mind?” Billy flicks his wrist, gesturing for Steve to turn around. “This is not a Disney-approved transformation sequence, unfortunately. Two human legs becoming one singular scaled tail actually looks pretty fucked up.”
“Oh! About that. I- I, uh…” Steve points over Billy’s right shoulder to a few extra-long towels strung up to form a makeshift changing room right along the edge of the tank. “So you can get nude or whatever in private and slip right in. I’ll go around the corner and stay out of sight. Just whistle when you’re decent, i-if you want to hang out. Otherwise you can just tell me to piss off right now and I’ll leave you alone to go do my rounds. It’s fine if-”
“This isn’t a date, then?”
Steve is somewhat surprised to hear a note of disappointment in Billy’s question, so he responds with a question of his own: “Do you want it to be?”
“Well you said ‘it’s a date’ when I was leaving last time, so… I kind of assumed it was.”
Steve chuckles and runs his fingers through his hair, a nervous habit he can never seem to shake. “Cool, because I brought some snacks and romantic lighting.”
“Romantic lighting?”
Billy steps behind the towels and starts shuffling around; Steve slams his hands over his eyes and turns away. “Okay, so it’s a battery-powered camping lantern, but at least it’s better than nothing.”
“That’s sweet of you, pretty boy. I might get spoiled at this rate.”
“Don’t get your heart set on expensive dinners or fancy bottles of wine just yet,” Steve snarks. “My paycheck covers my rent, my phone, and car insurance. When I said that I brought snacks, I meant that there’s cubed cheese and some slightly watery fruit salad from the local deli in my lunchbox that you’re welcome to share. I wasn’t sure about your dietary needs so I didn’t go all out this time…”
“You should give me your number tonight, by the way,” Billy says. His words are followed by a quick splash and then some quiet, mildly pained grunting. Steve wants to turn around and offer comfort, but Billy continues before he can open his mouth to ask if that’s okay. “Then I can text ahead and make sure you’ve chosen to show up for work. What if I show up for my next night swim and you’ve had to call in sick? I would for sure get arrested.”
“So I’ve earned a second date, then?”
“We’ll see.” Steve can hear the smirk in Billy’s voice. “The evening is still young. Now, come on over here and keep me company, Harrington. Swimming laps gets boring when you do it all alone.”
Steve spins on his heel and hurries to find a seat at the water’s edge. As close as he can get to the merman without being in Billy’s accidental splash zone. Too curious to stay quiet for more than the time it takes to get comfortable, he starts down his laundry list of questions with something simple: “So, Billy, what’s your favorite movie?”
Billy visits Steve nearly every other shift for the next three weeks.
They spend innumerable hours chatting and trading jokes beneath the cover of (mostly) darkness. Steve flirts badly and Billy flirts back expertly, always ready with a snarky reply or witty comment. The number of literary and film references thrown around between them proves to Steve on night two that his mysterious crush intentionally hides his incredible intellect behind brawny shoulders and tan skin.
The merman always shows off when he swims laps in front of Steve, cutting back-and-forth through the water with ease, a vision of wild danger and grace. The muscles of Billy’s back and abdomen flex with every sweep of his powerful tail, rippling sinuously beneath acres of golden skin. He has to know how it makes Steve’s mouth water and his uniform khakis go tight, right? Maybe mer-people’s superpowers include the ability to notice the strokes and poses that drive exhausted bisexual human men craziest, because those in particular seem to be growing more frequent with every visit.
Whenever he gets done with his “workout” for the night, Billy will prop his crossed arms up on the concrete and let his tail float out behind him. Sometimes, while Steve listens to the merman tell him about his interests or about the movie he saw last weekend (they still haven’t met up outside Wally’s yet) the older boy lets his eyes linger on the way Billy’s torso melds seamlessly from skin to scales, or the way his long aquamarine fins flutter gracefully through the water. It’s mesmerizing, and if he didn’t think it would get him slapped he would ask to touch them.
Steve realizes, a few days before the dolphin is meant to arrive from Florida, just how heartbroken he’ll be when his midnight trysts with Billy come to an end. So he figures out a way to keep them together and he surprises Billy on what may still end up being their last night together (if things don’t go the way Steve hopes):
“The dolphin arrives tomorrow,” the human says, after Billy transforms and gives him the all-clear to take a seat. Steve tucks his legs against his chest and wraps his arms around his knees. “So you won’t be able to use this tank for workouts anymore unless you don’t mind the company of Flipper.”
“Well, that’s damn unfortunate. Looks like I’ll be back to risking arrest by sneaking into that shitty hotel pool in Indianapolis.”
“There’s a saltwater pool in a hotel in this state?”
“One, but security is lax and their cameras don’t work so...”
“Huh.” Steve inhales deeply and decides to shoot his shot, staring straight at Billy. The merman is floating on his back, his arms crossed beneath his head to keep his ears above the water. “What if I had a better idea?”
“Yeah, pretty boy, what’s that?”
“I have access to a house with a pool back in Hawkins. I could retrofit it for saltwater and you could… Move in?”
Billy turns red, from his forehead all the way down to his chest. Still, his expression doesn’t shift or twitch, “Are you being for real right now?”
Steve nods eagerly, voice verging on pleading, “I’ve spent years running from that nasty shit I told you about when we first met; living on my own, scared out of my mind and constantly looking over my shoulder… I can’t do it anymore. I work jobs that I hate for people I like even less– Except Wally, he’s pretty cool. But Billy, for you it would be easy to face that town again. My parents don’t want their old house anymore and I have a hedge fund set up by my grandparents. All it does is sit around gathering interest when it could be put to use making you happy. Making us happy.”
Billy just stares at him, luminous blue eyes open wide.
Steve swallows thickly, his tongue stubbornly heavy in his mouth: “B-Billy?”
“You would go back to Hawkins, a place you once called the Indiana shitstain, just because there’s a convenient pool there for me?”
The brunette nods. “In a heartbeat.”
“Oh.”
Steve bites his lip and runs his fingers through his slightly sweaty bangs. “It’s just an offer. You can say no, and I would totally understand wh–”
“When can we leave?” Billy interrupts. He’s grinning from ear to ear and his tail is fluttering excitedly beneath the water, forming small but powerful waves that splash against the far wall of the tank. Then the merman ducks his head and licks his lips (a habit that drives Steve up the wall). “Not to sound pushy or anything, that’s just… Wow.”
Steve knows his own face is bright pink when he shrugs and smiles back. “You’re pretty wow yourself, hot stuff.”
Billy’s fins flicker nervously and he rolls sideways to tap his fingertips against the pool’s edge. “Do you– Are you asking me to move in as your roommate or as, as something else?”
“W-Would you be interested in moving in another way? Because I wouldn’t be opposed to taking things up a level to, like, boyfriends or something. I’m sure you already know that I’m fairly attracted to mermen. Just one merman, I guess. Just you.”
“Your crush has been pretty obvious, yeah. I never thought anyone would spend so many hours staring at my tail or my face or me and sighing like a lovesick idiot.”
“I am a lovesick idiot, Billy. I just openly admitted it and everything.”
Billy throws his head back and laughs brightly, every droplet of water on his face and torso thrown into relief by the flickering park lights. Steve’s heart does a backflip. “Then let me assure you the feelings are mutual. I would be proud to call you my boyfriend, Steve Harrington.”
Steve is happily surprised by the number of familiar faces present at his “Welcome Home” party. Of course all the kids arrive at once, now a bunch of rowdy high school juniors, piled into the back of Will’s van. The large sliding panel doors were spray painted by Will and Jonathan to depict a wizard in purple fighting a large red dragon. Joyce is there beside her doting husband, Police Chief Hopper, and Mrs. Henderson brings three types of cake.
Hopper and Joyce get to the house first, neither one commenting on the way Steve and Billy casually touch as they move around each other to finish preparing the backyard – a hand on the waist here, a tap on the shoulder there, seamlessly flowing around each other in a way that can only mean one thing. They’re in love. The adults notice but choose to voice their silent support by setting out paper plates and lugging out the heavy red cooler full of ice and pop.
The biggest surprise of the day comes when Max climbs out of the van and first sets eyes on Billy.
“Steve, where the hell did you find him?” she asks, staring down the blonde merman from halfway down their driveway. “ How the hell did you find him?”
“He was– Uh,” Steve glances around, but it’s only him and Billy and the teens. “I found him in the dolphin tank at Wacky Wally’s Water World.”
“Put him back.”
“Excuse me?” the brunette frowns, hands already on his hips. However, before Steve can start lecturing the redhead about manners and civility in front of strangers, especially super attractive ‘strangers’ that he’s just moved into his old house, Billy bursts into gleeful laughter.
“What’s going on?” Dustin stage-whispers and Lucas shrugs.
“Hey, shitbird. I should have figured you’d end up surrounded by a bunch of dorks wherever you moved.”
“Where were you, dude?! Neil said–”
“He’s a fuckin’ liar and we both know it; come on in and I’ll tell you everything.”
“Babe?” Steve murmurs, turning to look at the shorter boy beside him. Billy pulls Max into a warm hug, smiling over her head at his boyfriend.
“You know how I mentioned having a little sister somewhere in the state?”
“Yeah, but you didn’t– No fucking way! ”
“Guess I really managed to get the whole package on my first try,” the merman smirks. “A sweet boyfriend, a nice house with a pool, and a family.”
“Welcome home,” Steve offers, shuffling the kids inside while Max continues clinging to her brother. Billy goes on tiptoe to kiss Steve quickly on the lips.
“You too, pretty boy. Welcome home.”
Max wrinkles her nose and disengages from the hug, “Gross! I’ll be destroying the chips if you need me, bro. And I still expect an explanation when you get a few minutes.”
Billy nods and she disappears after the other teens, already trying to locate Dustin and Lucas before they can get into trouble.
Steve wraps his arms around Billy in Max's stead, so their chests are flush together in the dim entryway. The merman’s hands find purchase on Steve's thinner hips but their embrace is quickly disrupted by Steve hitching his arms lower and scooping Billy up by the butt. “Hey!”
“Do it,” Steve demands, grinning like a fool. Billy shakes his hair out of his eyes and groans.
“Baaaaabe.”
“Just once, just for me. C’mon, it’s a special occasion,” the human pouts.
“Fine,” Billy smiles like he isn’t equally amused. He places both hands firmly on Steve’s shoulders and arches his back while Steve spins him around, humming Part of Your World from The Little Mermaid under his breath. When he’s back on his feet, dizzy and delighted, Billy demands another kiss. Then another.
“Shouldn't we head back to the party and supervise? We’re kind of the hosts, you know.”
“One more kiss won’t hurt them,” Billy whispers, and Steve can’t argue with that.
