Chapter Text
Garret grows up a stone's throw from the woods, right on the edge of town. The house is too big for just the four of them, but they make do. A lot of the rooms just stay closed up, but his sister likes to dig through the old clothes and things left behind, even though she knows she'll get a whuppin' if she leaves a mess. Sometimes she tries to get him to play dress-up too, but his uncle's mothballed uniform doesn't come close to fitting him, not like the scads of dresses his sister's got to pick from fit her.
Aunt Claudia's clothes are ugly but cheerful, so colorful an ice cream shop must've thrown up on them, and her pants legs are dumb, like someone forgot they were making jeans and tried to make a skirt instead. Great-Aunt Rose's are prettier, but much, much plainer, though he's not sure what to make of the dog skirt. Grauntie Brenda's dresses are both the nicest and the strangest, with fringes and sequins and glass jewels and feathers. The material is stiff with age, leaves their hands feeling greasy, though there's nothing left behind that they can see.
"Are you two playing in those back rooms again?" their mom will yell down the hall if they've been quiet too long. Garret's always grateful, even if it means a mad scramble to get clear before she can snap their butts with a dishrag. He'd rather be outside, down at the creek or lying in wait for lizards by the woodpile, pretty much anywhere but here.
"Why does she keep all that stuff if she doesn't want us playing with it?" his sister grumbles every time. It's a dumb question. Uncle-Davey-who-died-of-the-drink (rest his soul) was their mom's kin.
The girls came with the house.
***
When Garret is five, his dad gives him his first gun. It's not a really-real rifle, just a BB gun, but he carries it with him everywhere. Mom doesn't like that--"Gods' sakes, George, can't you at least keep hold of the shot?"--but she's not really arguing, just complaining.
"Don't worry 'bout your Ma. Hunting's in her blood too," his dad says in a rumbling undertone, leaning in over the breakfast table as pots and pans clatter in the kitchen. His sister keeps her eyes on her plate. She never asks to go when their dad fetches out his coat and rifle, even though she's way past old enough. Garret's as confused as he is jealous.
With dire predictions of what it'll get him if he shoots out a window from his mom and a steady supply of pellets from his dad, Garret practices until he can plug a line of cans as neat as you please, or fill up a bullseye if someone's feeling fancy. When his dad's friends come over to drink, they like to sit out on the back porch to watch, whooping encouragement with every pull.
"Gonna be a deadeye like your dad, huh, sport?" Sheriff Goodnight says with a grin, the base of his beer can drawing wet circles where it rests on his knee.
"Yes, sir," Garret says, puffing his chest out proudly.
"Yep. You're a Hobbs boy, all right. Blessed, all'a ya."
Garret doesn't know about that. They kneel at the right moons and set out the right offerings, but he's never seen what happens to the carcasses they leave or what might've come to take them. His sister says that means they're doing it right.
No one's ever said anything about any kind of blessing, though.
***
Soon it's not just tin cans; it's rabbits and squirrels, and Garret's dad shows him patiently how to skin and gut his kills. 'Dressing,' he calls it, but it's nothing like the games his big sister still wants to play.
("Aren't you too old for this?" their mother scolds, hands on her hips.
"Never," his sister says with a cheeky grin, twirling in Grauntie Brenda's shiniest dress. It almost fits her perfectly.)
Garret doesn't mind the messy parts, except for where they lead.
"Squirrel again?" he dares to mumble, picking at his dinner. He's sure other kids get pizza and hamburgers every night.
"If you don't want it," his mom says tartly, "stop bringing it home. In this house, what you hunt, you eat."
"Your Ma's right," his dad agrees before Garret can protest. "You take a life, you better put it to good use. 'Sides, there's a lot of hungry creatures in this world. Ain't right to take food out of their mouths if you're not gonna eat it yourself."
He's more careful after that, brings home only what they need. His sister makes a face when she's presented with a plate of beef liver and onions, but Garret digs in without complaint. It's something new.
And anyway, it's all meat in the end.
***
The first time his dad takes him hunting for real, it's magic. His dad has never come back empty-handed from the woods, so Garret's always guessed in a dim sort of way that he must be good at it. Watching the way his dad moves through the trees, every step silent and sure, makes him think the sheriff may have been right.
Garret's concentrating so hard on his own feet, trying to be a fraction as quiet as his dad, that he doesn't see the deer at all until his dad stops him. It's a doe, both enormous and somehow smaller than he'd expected. Her nostrils flare as she steps with ginger care past a tangle of brush, but the early fall wind buffets their faces, not their backs. Garret fumbles on instinct to bring his rifle up, but his dad pushes the barrel back down with a tiny headshake.
"She's got a fawn with her," his dad murmurs almost too quietly to hear. "See?"
Sure enough, a baby trots out a moment later, kicking up its heels as a bug zips by its ear. It still has its spots, but it's nimble and brave, snuffling curiously at everything it sees.
"We don't hunt the mothers," his dad adds quietly, smiling a little at the pair. "They're special."
They come back with meat for the table anyway: a pair of boring old rabbits, but his dad doesn't seem to mind. Garret guesses he wouldn't. He could've bagged that doe if he'd wanted to; could've just walked right up and touched her, his dad's that quiet. He's like a ghost. The whole forest is his for the taking, and Garret burns in mingled pride and determination. He's going to have that kind of skill one day. He's going to walk the forest like he owns it, like he's one with it, just like his dad.
"How'd you get so good?" Garret asks as they start back home. There's got to be some trick he can learn, some knack he can study.
"Well, uh...." His dad ducks his head, rubbing at the tip of his nose. His eyes are fixed on the ground ahead, distant and unblinking. "I guess you could say it's a gift."
***
In the winter his sister starts looking at colleges. She wants to go into fashion design, or maybe do costuming for some big theater company. It kind of makes sense, except Garret's seen her drawings, and they're terrible. Their mom fusses, asks which colleges she's looking at, if she's sure she wants to move that far, and are any of her friends looking at the same cities?
Never much for talking, their dad goes all but mute, moping around the house with a face as long as a week of Sundays. No amount of hugs or cajoling smiles can cheer him out of it. Mom tries to talk him around, but it goes about as well as you'd expect.
"It's not too late," Mom says late one night, so quiet Garret wouldn't have heard her if he hadn't been tiptoeing past their bedroom on the way to the bathroom. "She might...settle if we found something close."
Dad sighs. "That might work for a little while, 'least if she stays put, but she won't. You know she won't. That girl wasn't ever gonna be the one who stayed."
He's never heard his dad sound so tired, and it wakes a squirmy feeling of panic in his stomach. He creeps past their door in a hurry, breath held, so careful not even the ancient floorboards creak under his weight. He's a ghost, just like his dad.
He wants to beg his sister to change her plans, but he knows it won't do any good. All her life she's been racing to grow up and leave another room full of memories for someone else to find. It's far too late to talk her out of it now.
***
On the last moonless night of the year, they light their candles and walk out into the trees, Dad in the lead, Mom bringing up the rear. Garret winces each time a branch snaps under his sister's careless feet, but it's like she can't even hear herself. Her head's a million miles away, her body going through the motions. Maybe that's all she's ever done.
The big rock where they leave their offerings wears a thin veil of snow, the ground beneath a mire of wet mulch. The battered chalice that sometimes sits atop the low boulder has fallen off again, so Dad fishes it out of the leaves and wipes it clean with the tail of his shirt. Mom holds his candle as he fills the cup from his hip flask, all the way to the brim.
Dad's the man of the house, and mothers are sacred, but Garret's sister is their firstborn. The chalice goes to her, and she takes it with a grin Garret doesn't like. They're both too young for wine, but it's not like it actually tastes good, so why is she smirking like she's getting away with something?
She drinks deep, but Dad doesn't tell her to knock it off this time, and Mom doesn't clear her throat or arch a brow. Dad just eases behind her while she's got the chalice tipped back, his mouth a grave line as he reaches around her shoulder, candlelight running like sun-chased water down the edge of his hunting knife.
Garret's eyes widen slowly as his sister gasps, chokes, and drops the chalice into the leaves at her feet. It spills everywhere, but it's hard to tell which of the dark patches soaking into the leaves are wine or blood. Dad doesn't let go, right arm wrapping firmly around her chest while his free hand covers her eyes, tipping her head back to rest on his shoulder. Cheek-to-cheek, he holds her until her clawing hands drop to her sides and presses a kiss to the crown of her head.
Lightheaded, breath hitching too fast in his chest, Garret flinches when his mom pulls him close against her hip. Dad doesn't look at him, lifting the limp body in his arms to drape across the altar rock, and--
Oh. They hadn't brought any meat with them. Somehow he's only just noticed.
"For you, Mother," Dad murmurs, smoothing stray wisps of dark hair away from a shocked, pale face. "We won't forget what we owe."
Questions boil inside Garret's head, but they remain locked behind his teeth even as his mother turns him bodily around, clicking her tongue in annoyance at his noisy stumble. He doesn't understand. Why are rabbits and deer suddenly not enough? Haven't they been doing everything right? He doesn't understand any of this. But his parents are leaving--leaving his sister behind--and he totters blindly in step, too numb to even look back for a final glimpse.
They haven't gone very far, only just out of sight of the clearing, when Garret flinches again, hitching his shoulders up around his ears as formless dread crawls down his spine. His parents move as one to blow out their own candles, his father reaching over to pinch out the wick of Garret's in the same breath. Darkness closes in on them like the jaws of a trap, and in the breathless silence that follows, Garret can just make out the hiss of leaves displaced, the stealthy approach of something--somethings--through the trees.
He squints his eyes shut tight, heart rabbiting in his chest, waiting for the bite of claws and teeth. There's a laugh at his back instead--back at the clearing where they'd left his sister--and it's answered by a pleased growl. Neither voice sounds human. None of the sounds that follow do either.
The shredding of cloth. The slick rip of meat tearing. The splintering of bone.
His mother's fingers dig into his cheeks as she covers his mouth. He hadn't even realized he'd opened it.
Taking his free hand, his dad crouches before him, his grip patient and fearless. Garret blinks and finds he can see, just a little. Just enough.
Dad puts a finger to his lips, and Garret nods as best he can.
When he straightens, his dad doesn't let go, tugging Garret to follow as he leads them out of the woods again, picking his way past rocks and deadfalls as if he's got a personal spotlight shining on the path. His mom keeps one hand on Garret's shoulder, nudging him now and then when he threatens to drift off course. None of them speak. Garret doesn't think he's the only one listening, holding his breath in case he misses the rustle of footsteps creeping up behind them.
The house is still lit up when they return, just the way they left it, but nothing's ever going to be the same again.
He goes to his room without arguing when his dad leads him back there, the two of them sitting side-by-side at the edge of the bed for a long moment. When his dad hesitantly loops an arm around his shoulders, Garret leans into his side with a sob.
"Why?" he asks, voice mostly breath. He's terrified the things back in the clearing will hear him speak of them and know. "Why did...why was she...?"
His dad sighs. Though his eyes are red, his face is composed. "The Great Mother...She's been good to our family. We've made it through war, famine and drought on the strength of Her gifts, and when someone gives you something...well, it's only right that you give something back.
"Your sister was paid a great honor, son. The Mother has a thousand mouths to feed, and She does all right, you know, but sometimes...sometimes we can lighten Her load. Never more than once in a generation. First fruits, if they can be spared. She's not cruel with it," his dad insists with a hitch in his voice. "Only the ones who aren't right by Her. We let them grow, live their lives, and when they're old enough, we make it quick. They're marked, you see, and it's not just the Mother's children who can sense it. At least this way...it's almost like we're keeping a part of her, through the Mother's gifts."
Garret nods, swallowing hard around the lump in his throat. "How do I know if someone isn't right? By the Mother?" Maybe he shouldn't have gone along with all those games of dress-up. If they'd spent more time together in the woods, would things have gone differently?
"You'll know," his dad says heavily, old regret thickening his voice. "The first time you hold them, you'll know. But you understand, don't you? About giving back?"
"Yessir," Garret says, but then he can't hold his tongue. "It's just not fair. Why did she have to be marked? Couldn't--couldn't we have found--"
"Oh, honey." He sounds like Garret's breaking his heart. "It's not that simple. I could've offered sacrifice every month in her place for the rest of her life, but only if she stayed put to let us hide her." He shakes his head, shoulders sagging, defeated. "She'd have hated that, and you know it. Besides...promised is promised. She was never ours to keep."
***
They call Sheriff Goodnight in the morning. Garret expects trouble, for a lot of pointed questions to be asked, but when he finally comes around late in the afternoon, the sheriff just looks tired.
"Yeah, it's a bad one, this year," the sheriff says, accepting a mug of coffee and a seat at the kitchen table. "You're my third missing persons, and--uh...well, you'll read about it in the paper soon enough."
He asks a few more questions, but Garret doesn't think he really expects to find anything. He's not sure the sheriff even intends to look.
"Small towns," his mother says with a rueful headshake, watching the cruiser roll away.
"Small mercies," his dad counters, and that's the last Garret ever hears about the matter.
***
He's away at college when it happens. The Great Mother's gifts may protect them from ambush and discovery, might keep food in their bellies while the rest of the world starves, but they can't keep a drunk driver in his lane. When the call comes, they tell him his parents died instantly. Maybe that's karma: at least it was quick.
He only plans to take a few weeks off, but there's just so much to do. The house is his now, but the first time he walks past his sister's closed door, he knows he doesn't want it. He understands now that these rooms are monuments to the ones who paid in blood what they couldn't pay in devotion, but he wants a family of his own someday, can't bear the thought of any child of his playing amongst these ghosts.
He packs everything up, drops most of it off to be donated and drives the rest to the dump. The house goes up for sale as-is; his dad was always good about keeping up with repairs.
The next moonless night is still a week away when he treks out to the clearing in the woods. In the bright light of day, the altar rock looks smaller than he remembers, though it's still big enough to lay a carcass out on neatly. It always surprises him how clean it looks when not in use, but the rain and sun have done their jobs, washing away all evidence that this has ever been a place of worship.
There aren't even any bones left. Whoever's been honoring their sacrifices, they haven't wasted a single part.
***
He doesn't go back to college. He finds a trade school, picks up a few courses in welding on a whim and joins the pipefitters union two years later. It's not the white collar work his mom had hoped he'd be drawn to, but Minnesota is a fresh start in more ways than one.
He meets Louise on his first jobsite when he goes in to fill out his new-hire forms. She's funny and smart, and there's a stillness about her he likes, patient and sure. He can't ask her out, not with her in HR, but that just gives them time to make certain of each other, to ask without asking the questions that need answering most.
It takes a year, but when the project runs out, he finds a different job, finds a nice house in a good neighborhood at the edge of the trees, and tries not to fidget too nervously when he shows her the place. Louise just laughs. Yes, of course she loves it, of course it's perfect for raising a family, and of course she'll marry him.
Their friends think they're crazy for rushing things, but they've known they'd suit each other from the moment they met. It's nothing his dad ever thought to mention, but like calls to like, and hunting's in their blood.
***
Maybe it's disloyal of him. Maybe that disloyalty, that little sliver of selfishness, is what makes it take so long in the first place. He knows Louise expects to start their family immediately, but a year passes, then a few more. It's not that they're not trying--and no sir, he is not complaining about how often they try--but it's just not happening.
And then one day Louise comes out of the bathroom with a huge grin and a little stick she brandishes like a sword, and Garret learns what fear really tastes like.
Lying in bed that night, with Louise curled into his side, her head pillowed on his shoulder, he finds himself thinking of loopholes and contingencies, his mind racing too fast to let him sleep. Their child is barely a possibility, but already all he can think about is everything he stands to lose.
"You're thinking awfully loud," Louise murmurs sleepily, splaying her fingers across his chest.
"Sorry, hon," he says, turning his head to press his lips into her hair, the better to stop his questions before he can speak. Louise is a good girl, soon to be a mother herself. He doesn't want to disappoint her, but-- "It was always the firstborn. In my family."
Picking up her head, Louise studies him for a long moment, seeing him clearly even in the dark. "Is that...important to you? To keep that tradition?"
They've never talked specifics. They make their sacrifices and say their prayers, and he's never really taken the time to consider how lucky they are in their similarities, but in that moment he feels like a condemned man given a last-minute reprieve.
"No, it--no. Just...how did your folks do it?"
"Only the ones that don't have the Mother's spark," Louise explains, voice as hushed as his had been many years ago, as if something might be drawn to the mention of it, even in the most hazy of terms. "Sometimes it skipped a generation. Sometimes there'd be more than one. Good husbandry, my gram called it," she adds with a rueful twist of her mouth. "Mom always hated that."
Garret doesn't blame her. They're faithful, not domesticated. "Then we might...."
"We might keep this one," Louise finishes for him, voice soft and fond. "And the next." And then she laughs. "You're really looking forward to being a dad, aren't you?"
"Be nice to have a full house again," he hedges, sensing danger in that line of talk.
Louise grins. "Then you picked the right Mother to worship, didn't you?"
***
They go for the hospital delivery because it'd look weird otherwise, but Garret's on pins and needles the entire time. He keeps waiting for something to go wrong, for complications to arise or for Child Services to storm in and tell him they know, and he's not sure he wouldn't fling the kid right into their arms if they did.
It all goes off without a hitch, and as the nurses congratulate her on a surprisingly easy labor for a first-time mother, they place his daughter in Louise's arms.
She's a red-faced little thing, features squashed like she's screwing her face up in disgust at this strange new environment, and Garret falls in love, just like that. Tiny as she is, her arms and legs flail strongly as Louise draws a glyph on her forehead with the pad of her thumb, but she doesn't cry. He's never been present at a dedication before, but he can feel the change in the air as their little girl becomes a child of the Great Mother, the sensation so subtle he'd never have noticed if he hadn't recognized that kinship in someone new once before. She feels like Louise does now, the way he must to others that share their faith. And if he can sense it--
Louise kisses Abigail's wispy hair, but her eyes are serious when they find his. In that instant, without ever having held her, Garret knows. His little Abigail isn't really his, promised away before he had any say in the matter. He could have argued. Could have taken Abigail and run.
Louise has always been too smart for the likes of him.
***
He tries not to get attached, but that's over from the moment Abigail learns to crawl. Noisier and more clumsy than he ever remembers being, she refuses to stay put, and wherever he is is the one place she wants to be. She's a happy kid, always babbling excitedly about something, but she'll start to fuss if he's been out of sight too long.
Louise shakes her head over him when he insists on carrying Abigail to the worship site, even after she's old enough to walk. What else is he supposed to do? She's not quiet enough on her own, and he can't risk anything hearing her and coming to investigate. He's going to lose her, he knows that, but not just yet. Not when he can help it.
He spends a lot of time tramping the woods, leaves a lot of sacrifices on the altar. He knows it's stupid whenever he looks at the thought directly, but some part of him hopes that if he keeps the Mother's brood full and happy, maybe She'll decide he's done enough.
He's not sure why he's surprised, but when a small hand latches onto his coat one Saturday and stops him at the door, he expects to be asked to stay. Instead Abigail fixes him with those big blue eyes, puts on her most trustworthy expression, and asks, "Daddy? Can I go with you?"
All his words desert him, but the kneejerk refusal he wants to voice stays trapped behind his teeth. She's the same age he was when his dad first let him tag along, and she's got her mom's smarts and level head. Why shouldn't she come with him? Normal families--normal people--go hunting all the time.
And maybe with enough practice, enough opportunity, maybe she'll discover the wild thing inside her lying dormant. He at least has to try.
***
Louise doesn't say one word about how he's fooling himself, and she never once gives Abigail any reason to think she's less than the best hunter she can be. She's a good mom, even if Garret still hasn't entirely forgiven her for taking the hardest task on herself. It's not even a lie; any normal father would have every reason to brag. If his girl finds a trail, she can track it, however cold, can shave the whiskers off a field mouse with her shooting. She's a natural, and Garret--he doesn't understand. How can Abigail be so quick to pick up everything he teaches her and still not have the Mother's spark?
He's hurting Louise with his obsession and he knows it, but this isn't how he wanted things to go.
Abigail's seventeenth birthday flies past, and day by day, Garret feels an icy fist start to close around his throat. He can't feel them yet, not clearly, but something has started to circle at the edge of his notice, slinking closer with every rising of the moon. Though the year's only just begun, December looms large in his thoughts. One more year--less than that--and it'll all be over.
Unless.
She might settle, he recalls his mother saying, if we found something close.
He'd thought at the time she meant his sister. He knows better now.
***
The first time is almost an accident. Abigail had wanted to visit a nearby college, so close she could have driven home for the weekends, and of course he hadn't said no. If there's one thing he does agree with, it's keeping his damn mouth shut about what's coming. He doesn't want her scared, can't stand the thought of her living in dread. He doesn't even consider that he might not be half the actor he thinks he is until they run into a girl who could be Abigail's twin in the campus parking lot and he's struck dumb by the possibilities.
Abigail takes one look at him, and before he can pull himself back together, she pastes on a bright grin and fakes a gasp. "Oh, wow--I've heard everybody has a twin, but--you're not from Litchfield, are you?"
"No? Um...wow," the other girl echoes, distracted from his odd response by Abigail's quick thinking. "You know, you're right?" She grins suddenly with a spark of mischief, every trick every pair of twins has ever played dancing in her eyes. They're brown, not a perfect match, but...maybe they're close enough. "Are you enrolled here?"
"Not yet," Abigail says with a sly look of her own, leaning fractionally closer. "I'm here for the tour, though. Maybe you can tell me what it's like?"
He's torn between pride and despair, because his girl is brilliant, but this isn't anything he's ever coached her on, and he has no idea where it's coming from. He'd think she was just smoothing over his awkwardness--she's good at that--but he can hear where her questions are leading, even if the other girl can't.
So where are you from? Is that close enough you can go home a lot? Oh, this weekend? Lucky.
It really is. There's still a sliver of moon tonight, but tomorrow...?
He can't do this on a full moon. He doesn't want Louise to try to talk him out of it. But tomorrow will be just fine.
The drive back is quiet. He wants to ask how much she knows, wants to swear he'll fix this, but he's scared to open that can of worms. Even if she's wrong, whatever sort of monster she thinks he is, it can't be worse than the truth.
The stars are just coming out as they pull in at the house, yellow light from the windows spilling out warm and welcoming. The car engine ticks quietly as it cools, but neither of them move to get out. Hands still curled around the wheel, Garret clears his throat, but the only words that emerge are, "I love you, honey."
Abigail's smile is sad but kind. "I know, Dad," she says, leaning over to kiss his cheek. "I love you, too."
He has to fix this. He has to. Whatever it takes.
***
It's almost too easy to track his target with all the work Abigail did in setting up the blind. He's so proud of her, it's a tender ache behind his ribs. Any fool can snare a rabbit, but his girl could be so much better. He almost asks if she wants to accompany him on this hunt as well, but there can't be any confusion as to which girl he means to honor. He needs Abigail to stay far, far away from this, where she's safe.
Louise squeezes his hand hard before he leaves, pulls him down to press a fierce kiss to his brow: a mother's blessing. She might not approve of his hesitance, but she loves their daughter too.
Everything goes according to plan, almost like it's meant to happen. He catches the girl on her way home from the movies--on foot, because her parents' house is close enough for her to walk--and he's as gentle as he can be when he knocks her out. He feels bad about loading her into the trunk after trussing her up, but it's a fair drive back, and he doesn't want the meat to spoil. She's already doing him a favor he can never repay; he'll never forgive himself if it's all for nothing.
A nice, flat rock had always been altar enough for Garret's family, but Louise's kin did things a bit differently. There wasn't one rock but a tumble of heavy stones heaped waist-high, a stag's skull braced amongst the boulders. Mostly they left their offerings cradled in the tines of its rack, but for larger sacrifices, a bit more strength of arm is required.
It seems a little sacrilegious to just drive to their worship site, but it's better than being seen. Knowing the Old Ones are there is one thing, but most people just try to keep their heads down, avoid notice, and even the devout would give him hell for what he's doing. Promised is promised, and you live up to your word; you don't take your messes out on other families who may have gods of their own. You don't give more, out of the appointed time and season, unless you're up to no good.
He takes the back roads, lifts an old cattle gate off its hinges instead of fiddling with the rusted lock and chain, and takes a pitted dirt track as close as he can get to the altar. It's pretty damn close, and when he shuts the engine off, he leaves the headlights on, lighting up the clearing just past the final trees. Even without a moon, he doesn't need any light to see, but if she's awake, the girl might. She might appreciate one last look, not going out in the dark.
Another small light clicks on when he pops the trunk, illuminating terrified eyes, a pale face streaked with tears. It's the moment of truth, in a way. He knows Louise has wondered, because he wonders too: is he a father who loves his child too much, or is he just a coward, too squeamish for what they do?
Looking at the girl--shaking, pleading with him in muffled gasps from behind a gag--he feels nothing but gratitude.
"I'm sorry," he says, ignoring the fresh tears that overflow at his words. "It's nothing you did. I just need you to intercede for my little girl." She shakes her head frantically in denial, but he ignores that too. No deer ever went willingly to the table; it won't change the quality of the meat. "Thank you."
She doesn't need to see the altar or the antlers, to see what's coming next. He's not going to be cruel about it. He puts his hands to her throat, and it's just...easy. A little pressure, a little patience, and it's done.
Mounting the body on the sharp tines, he cuts the cords binding wrists and ankles, unfolding her arms to stretch wide in supplication. Before sketching the glyph of dedication on the girl's brow with his thumb, he checks again for a pulse. He's had night terrors of dedicating his sacrifice only to have it found worthy of life where his own daughter was not. He wants to avoid that possibility at all costs.
When he's done, he waits, but there's no sign from the heavens, no movement from the trees. He tries to shout his intentions, but his voice checks and chokes. "For Abigail," emerges in a whisper as the back of his neck begins to tingle.
He doesn't hurry as he gathers the cut ropes and closes the trunk, climbing behind the wheel. If the Mother decides it's time to call him home, there's nothing he can do about it anyway. Nothing tries to stop him as he leaves; maybe by now Her children have learned to recognize him as a source of devotion.
He just hopes they understand the trade he's trying to make, a life for a life.
He greets Louise with a nod when he returns, and she welcomes him back with relief, but Abigail won't meet his eyes, staring thoughtfully into the distance. He tries not to let it hurt.
"Did you tell her?" he asks Louise that night, but she shakes her head.
Abigail's a smart girl. She'll figure it out, enough to understand. She has to.
He's doing this for her.
***
He goes back in the morning, just to make sure, but things are different this time. He can tell the sacrifice was accepted, but gods, they've left a mess. Part of it is because he just didn't think, and it occurs to him belatedly that his parents must have returned for his sister's shoes, the rags of her clothes. He just can't tell what he's supposed to make of the pieces arranged like decorations on the sharpened antler points: a spill of dark hair still attached to the scalp, the greyish-pink sponge of a lung, a strip of muscle that might have come from a thigh. Is he just supposed to leave them there? Or is this some strange form of politeness, a show of generosity?
You shared with us. We'll share with you.
Shaking out two black plastic bags, he puts the clothes in one along with the splinters of bone he gathers up, then hesitates over the rest. He could be disturbing something he knows nothing about, but...someone should honor that girl for what she's done for his family. They should honor every part.
***
For an entire week, he lets himself hope that maybe what he's done is enough, but then the feeling comes back, stronger than before. There's something circling out there, waiting for the chance to strike and take what's owed. Every month, his father had said, and Garret fights it for a little while, now that Abigail's looking at him again. He fights, but if that's what it's going to come down to, so be it.
Abigail's subdued the second time, at least until they spot their prey, and it's like a switch gets thrown. She's shy at first, but soon the two girls are giggling together in a campus café, a party-girl flightiness slowly emerging in Abigail's manner as Garret fakes good-natured resignation. In no time at all, he has what he needs: an upcoming wedding, a three-day trip, a little silver Camry that needs some engine work.
He doesn't wait until quite so late in the morning to go back that time. That first gift of meat had still been good, but the days aren't getting any cooler. It's the same mess as before--shoes and jeans and a drenched cotton shirt, because he'd been too uncomfortable with the idea of undressing that girl to spare any of them the trouble--bones and a tithe of flesh, and a neatly-hung wig stiff with blood. He cleans it all up without complaint, still not certain if doing that is right, but secure at least in knowing he has another month to wonder on it.
***
Abigail doesn't ask. She's mousy and quiet with the next one, who takes her under her wing with sisterly concern, bold and confident with the one after that. An asset. A bookworm. Anything they need her to be.
In the summer before her senior year, she starts making his lunch, bringing it to him on the job now that she's got her license. The other guys ride him a little, jealous that his teenager even wants to be seen within five miles of her old man, but he stares at that first insulated bag with a throat gone painfully tight.
He doesn't need the perfect daughter. He doesn't need anything but for her to stay alive.
***
It's not until the eighth that he messes up. He goes out the next morning with his two thick trash bags, and his heart just about stops. She's still there, almost exactly the way he left her, except her belly's been sliced open and someone's been rummaging around inside.
There's something resting on her stomach--her liver, from the looks of it--but he's pretty sure it's not supposed to look quite like that.
Panic sings down his spine, spreading through his limbs as it sets his nerves alight, but worse than that is the guilt. He did this. He wasted this, for nothing. The thought teases him briefly that he could just...make the best of it, make use of what he can, but his own cowardice sickens him. He can't disrespect her like that. He'd meant to honor her, and if he can't, then he should let her family do it in his place.
"Gods," he breathes in defeat. It's going to be such a nightmare taking her back where she belongs, but at least the Mother's blessing will see him through.
He's less certain where he's going to find another proxy, and the Mother's children will be waiting. Hungry.
***
He knows something's up when he walks into the family room just a couple of evenings later to find Louise and Abigail staring at the television with different degrees of consternation. Louise's frown is a little judgmental, mouth pursed in a disapproving line, but Abigail stares with the queasy fascination of someone studying an accident they narrowly avoided.
The news story is another one about the missing girls, only...he's never even seen that field before, and who the hell is the Minnesota Shrike?
His brows shoot up as a grainy photograph flashes on the screen: a sacrifice arranged for the taking, right out in the open where any outsider or hungry beast could come stumbling across it. He almost feels like he's being mocked, but they do things differently here. What does he know?
"Do you have any kin in Hibbing?" he asks carefully. He's trying to be respectful, but--
"None that crass," Louise huffs. "Or stupid."
He nods to placate her, but he's not so sure about the stupid. The reporter's going on about an intelligent psychopath in that way people have when they just like the sound of a thing. It sounds big and impressive, but she doesn't really get what it means.
Garret does. He took a few classes way back, hoping to gain some kind of understanding, and he still remembers what he read. There wouldn't have been any feeling behind that sacrifice, no worship to make it a proper offering. It's nothing more or less than what it is: a shocking picture someone staged to send a message, and he's pretty sure the intended recipient is him.
As to what it says...he doesn't know. But he can guess.
If it's one of them--a fast, strong hunter arrogantly certain of not getting caught--then it's a warning. We can get our own meat.
They're telling him, Hurry up.
***
"This weekend?" Louise asks as they move around the kitchen in tandem, her working at the stove, him in charge of pancakes on the counter grill. She's been taking more time off this last year, and Garret appreciates these family breakfasts more than he can say. "Again? Already?"
He doesn't want to say too much in front of Abigail, but just then the phone rings, and Abigail goes to answer it. "If someone else has got the same idea...."
"Yes, I know, but--"
"Dad?" Abigail interrupts, frowning at the phone as she holds it out. "It's for you."
He hopes he isn't being called in on a new job. Probably it's a telemarketer, and he can just hang up and get on with his day.
"Mr. Garret Jacob Hobbs?"
He's so bemused by being full named over the phone by a voice so official that he barely listens to the next few words, wondering if he's somehow run afoul of the government.
"Are you listening?"
"Yes." Yeah, he's definitely listening, his attention well and truly snared, but--
"They know."
The man on the other end hangs up before Garret can recover enough to demand who--who knows, and what do they know, and who is this stranger to tell him anything? His first thought is for the hungry ones, but that doesn't make any sense. It's not like one of them would call him on the phone; that's a human thing. But that just means this is a human thing too, and the only thing they could know--
"Honey?" Louise asks, eying him strangely as the blood drains from his face. "Who was that?"
"Wrong number," he says, though he doesn't believe it. It couldn't have been the cops, though, because they wouldn't have warned him. They'd have just...taken him in, stopped him from ever finding another proxy, leaving his daughter to fend for herself.
Gods.
Because that's how it's going to go, isn't it? Louise loves Abigail, but she won't fight for her, not like Garret will. With him out of the picture, it's only a matter of time before something finds her, or before Louise leads her out to the altar and does the job herself. As hard as he's fought to keep her safe, this isn't how he'd ever thought it would end, but what can he do? He could run, but he can't leave her here, and he doesn't know if Louise would let him betray both their families and take her. Or he could....
He could turn himself in. Wait for the cops to show up and hope none of them are consecrated themselves, that they'll be brave enough to want to save a sacrifice instead of washing their hands of the whole thing. There are hotlines for this, but he's never trusted them enough to be anything but traps until now, when he has no other choice.
He grimaces back when Abigail gives him a worried smile, but he knows now what he has to do.
Louise watches him like a hawk as they sit down to eat, but he's got nothing to say. It's all going to be over in just a little while; he just has to keep his mouth shut and wait. They might even let Abigail see him after, or at least write to him. As long as she's okay--
He drops a plate back into the dishwater as he's cleaning up, his head snapping up with a jerk.
There's.
Something.
Coming.
"Garret," Louise says flatly as the feeling hits her too. "What's going on?" It's not a question.
At the table, Abigail stays still as a fawn, eyes flicking back and forth between them as her brows crease in confusion. He doesn't know whether it's a blessing or a curse that she has no idea what's happening.
"Nothing," he insists. "It's nothing."
"That is not nothing. If there's a--gods," Louise spits in sudden realization. "Were you rejected? Tell me you didn't refuse to take a clear fucking hint--"
"I wasn't rejected!" Garret roars, only modulating his tone at Abigail's flinch. "There was just a problem with the meat, okay? I made a bad choice, but I was fixing it--"
Louise's eyes narrow, that pretty blue he used to love like chips of ice. "Seems to me like you'll be fixing it right now."
Garret reels back a step, but gods, she's right. That awareness of some hungry presence has grown into a pressure, terrifyingly close, like that night when he could have run back to the clearing. Fifteen steps, and he'd have seen them, and he's never been so close to death again in his life until now.
He just doesn't care.
"No," he says, automatic at first, but then stronger. "No." He's not going to let that happen.
"Garret." Louise clenches her jaw.
Honestly he just means to move her, shove her into the hall and out of his way, but Louise doesn't see it like that. Or maybe it's always been in the back of her mind that she's going to have to take care of things herself. He isn't even thinking of the hunting knife holding down a stack of bills on the counter, but when she lunges for it, he knows he has a choice.
It's a gamble at best, but maybe the hungry creature fast approaching can still be convinced to take something else in trade.
A car pulls up just as he yanks the front door open and pushes Louise out, but he doesn't give a damn who they are. If they survive what's coming, he'll worry about it then. The Mother's child is so close he can practically smell it, and while he hopes it'll be attracted by the blood he just spilled, he can't know for certain.
He retreats back to the kitchen and Abigail, who isn't screaming any more, at least. "I'm sorry," he says over her near-silent sobs. "I'm so sorry, honey, and I swear I'll explain it all if we get a chance, but...I need you to just come here, please."
She shakes her head, more from bafflement than denial. "What--?"
He wishes he could set her mind at ease, but there isn't time. He holds out a hand. "Abigail."
She isn't the only one crying as he sets his knife to her throat, but even if he's failed in every other way, he can at least do this. If his proxy is rejected again, he can still make it quick.
They both flinch as something kicks the front door in, but the words he hears fill him with hope. "Garret Jacob Hobbs? FBI!"
Gods, they might actually have a chance. That's a human voice, and it's a human man who bursts into their kitchen, gun drawn, and if the monster out there will just take its due and fucking leave--
He sobs into Abigail's hair as he hears the front door swing wide with a creak, the first quiet footstep on the hardwood floor. The poor, dumb bastard standing between them and it has no idea what's coming, and that popgun he's waving won't do any of them a lick of good.
He won't stand to see her suffer. He can give her that at least.
The stroke of the knife hurts worse than the bullets that slam into him, not that he expects his killer to understand. His own daughter won't understand, and that might be what hurts the most. Staggering back as he's plugged again and again, he fetches up hard against the kitchen counter and slides down, his legs turning to water beneath him.
The FBI man drops to his knees at Abigail's side, dropping his gun to frantically try to stop the bleeding. Garret didn't do a good job, but the agent's so panicked he's not making things any better. It stings, though, knowing they think this is what he wanted, that he was just killing to kill, like a rabid dog.
"See?" he says as the footsteps come closer, measured and unhurried. It won't be long now, for any of them. "See?"
And he...can't anymore, himself. It's strange. There's no cinematic fade to black, only a creeping strangeness that falls over his eyes when he blinks, like trying to stare through sunspots. He blinks again as his head lists to the side, and...he's tired. He's really tired.
And then he's nothing at all.
***
Hannibal steps into the kitchen slowly, struggling to keep the curiosity from his expression. This isn't the first time he's felt some hint of strangeness in a human, but it's only the second time he's recognized it as kin. Diluted, to be sure, barely a molecule left of what it once might have been, the product of some long-ago coupling that somehow hadn't ended in a feast. It was stronger in the woman, less so in the man. In the daughter's blood, he smells it not at all.
And yet.
She radiates with purpose to his other senses, much the same way a stag once had after his chosen mother marked it with her knife. No longer only meat, the girl bleeding out under Will's shaking hands has been branded a sacrifice, to One he knows.
With Will's insight to guide him, he takes it all in at a glance: two worshippers, one child, but the father grows attached. He tries to make up what's owed in quantity over quality, but he's wrong from the start. His gifts are no boon, only an accident of blood, and Hannibal's Mother....
His Mother doesn't care. Not about sacrifices made in Her name, not about Her children nor any promised to Her. Hobbs could have hidden his daughter forever if he'd had the sense to flee to the city, but now, if she lives....
"No," Will moans, despair and encouragement mixing oddly in his voice. "No, no, no...."
Hannibal stills. He could...it wouldn't be unheard of. His Mother may not care about sacrifice, but the magic is still there, ungrounded until given a direction. His chosen mother had done much the same: made an offering to an indifferent power for the hope of children. It wouldn't have worked, except the right sort of children happened along to accept the sacrifice in that power's name.
The Hobbs girl belongs to his Mother. Or any of Her blood who cares to claim her and set the focus of her fate.
Kneeling on the girl's other side, he brushes Will's hands away to apply more useful pressure, cupping her nape to better align the soft tissues severed by Hobbs' knife. He has no magic in his hands, only skill, but he believes he can keep her alive. And after....
He's never thought to be a father. He's not at all certain he'd enjoy it.
There's just something about Will Graham that makes him think of things like family, and he thinks it might be interesting to try.
