Chapter Text
Doctor Lecter received her call and promptly invited her over to dinner, which she was all too happy to accept. Brody remembered their meals onboard the Jonah , and still dreamed about them at night. So while it felt strange to be dining together without Will, she accepted the invitation eagerly and found herself seated at Hannibal Lecter’s table a few hours later.
His house was exactly as she had imagined it would be: opulent, rich, and and as odd and eccentric as the man himself. The pile of skulls in the foyer and other examples of taxidermy decorating the adjacent rooms were somewhat surprising. She had been prepared for weirdness, a lot of creepy marble statues and what not, but this a step beyond that.
“I never stopped being a student of anatomy even after I left my practice,” he explained as she peered into the empty eye sockets of a wolf’s skull that sat on a bed of polished stones and leafy bunches of hemlock at the center of the table. “I hope you don’t think me terribly morbid.”
“I wouldn’t say morbid,” she said. But calling it “creepy as fuck” seemed unconscionably rude, and Will had always warned her how much Doctor hated rudeness. But at the end of the day, who was she to judge? This strange affection Doctor Lecter held for anatomy was probably just one more thing that made him a good match for her friend. Only someone with an iron stomach and a mind as strange as Doctor Lecter’s could tolerate being with someone in Will’s line of work.
Brody sipped the home brew Doctor Lecter had poured for her. According to him, it had been fermented in a barrel salvaged from a shipwreck, accounting for the subtle brininess of the ale. Brody thought the whole story sounded like bullshit, but if anyone was going to buy salvage with a fancy pedigree just to brew beer with it would be Doctor Lecter.
Other surprises awaited her in Doctor Lecter’s home. A pair of muddy boots stood guard beside the umbrella stand. A can of instant coffee kept company with the tea chest in the kitchen. Doctor Lecter seemed as happy to display these small sign’s of Will presence in his space as he was with his taxidermy collection. It was ridiculously cute if a little upsetting given the state she’d left Will in earlier. Will did not seem nearly as happy and confident in their relationship as Doctor Lecter clearly did.
It made Brody hesitate. Should she have involved herself at all? What if she made it worse between them?
'Sometimes when the fish aren't biting you’ve got to change the bait,’ Will’s words tugged at her detective’s mind again. No, she had to come. Something was wrong. And if someone didn’t stop him, she worried Will was about to do something very stupid if he hadn't already.
“So how have you been, Doc? And I'm not talking about the usual pleasantries. How have you been really .” She asked when they finally sat down to dinner.
“Never better,” he said only barely wincing in response to the abbreviated honorific he hated so much.
By all appearances it was true though. The summer had been far kinder to him than to Will. He had a glow about him and a flounce in his step like a man deeply in love. He was also back in his full regalia of waistcoats and silk ties looking more comfortable than she’d ever seen him in Georgia. No more bucket hats for him. Here was Hannibal Lecter in his natural habitat. He seemed happy. He seemed at peace.
Brody thought he had invited her over, insisting that it be tonight, because he was worried about Will too. But to her surprise, he danced around the subject of Will’s mental health refusing to believe anything was amiss.
“You might want to get your eyes checked, Doc. Love’s made you blind,” she said finishing the first course, a plate of crostini topped with iron rich organ meat and olives. “He looks like death warmed over.”
“Appearances can be deceiving, Chief Brody. Judge not a book by its cover nor a man,” he winked as he cleared the plates. “Will is fine and stronger than he's ever been. Surely you must agree that he was far worse off when he was so often taken by those fevers last spring. The worries that trouble him now will soon be resolved. He is making such remarkable progress in therapy.”
Doctor Lecter was right about one thing, Will had looked dreadful then, but he hadn’t frightened her like he did now. Will’s former spells took him away to some distant place in his imagination. What she had seen in the aquarium felt different, colder somehow.
“You’re still his therapist? How does that work.”
“It’s unconventional, I grant you, but so is my patient.”
Unbelievable. The FBI really was going to let this continue? The Ripper situation must be worse than she realized if they needed Doctor Lecter and Will this badly.
During the entrée, Doctor Lecter repeated his assurances that everything was fine, that the Ripper posed no immediate threat to either of them, and that Will was suffering from no more than a bit of sleeplessness due to the pressures of his work. He said it with such confidence and showmanship that Brody almost began to forget the specifics of why she’d come.
She was halfway through her second helping of roast beef when his phone went off.
Doctor Lecter blushed as he checked the number at the table. “Will. Pardon me, Chief Brody, I must take this,” he said and excused himself.
His home was abnormally silent lacking even the natural creaks and groans of a house as it settles. She tried not to eavesdrop, but the quietude made that impossible.
“It isn’t time,” she heard Doctor Lecter say to Will over the phone from the next room over. Was it her imagination or did he seem alarmed?
There was a pause.
“You told them what!?”
Another pause.
“So that is your answer then?” he said and all but growled the words. “I….I must go, Will. I have a guest to attend to, an old friend from out of town whom I believe you know.”
The man who returned to the dining room was much changed in demeanor and appearance. The energy was gone out of him like a spent candle, and his bangs, which had previously been swept back, now hung in his face as if a hand had been wrung through them in agitation.
Doctor Lecter plopped into his seat as graceless and tired as an old hog. “You must forgive me, Chief Brody. Love makes me rude,” he said.
“It's okay. Is Will alright?”
“No, I don’t think he is.” Doctor Lecter stabbed the meat on the plate with his fork and expounded no further. Whatever Will had said had clearly upset him greatly.
“Should I go? I don't want to get in your way if you'd rather be alone.”
Doctor Lecter’s head snapped up. “No!” he said practically shouting, and then, more calmly. “No, please, don’t let my sour mood spoil this meal. I will get over it. I always do, and it is a trifling thing between us.”
An awkward silence entered room as they scratched at their meals with their utensils. Neither person knew what to say to the other.
In the end, Doctor Lecter cracked first asking if she would mind staring their earlier conversation over. “Tell me again exactly what Will said today at the aquarium and how he looked to you. Leave nothing out ,” he said. It wasn’t a command, not in the gentle way he spoke it, but it wasn’t NOT a command either.
Brody picked at a loose thread on her napkin trying to plan an escape from this conversation. She stopped when she caught glaring at her from across the table.
“I really don’t have anything else to say that you haven’t already heard before. Will seemed upset. I was hoping you knew why.”
Doctor Lecter picked up his glass of red wine and twirled it beneath his nose before responding. “On the contrary, Chief Brody. I think there is a lot more you can add to my current understanding of the situation.”
…
After dinner they retired to the kitchen because desert required Doctor Lecter’s full attention. He made Brody a cup of coffee then peeled two pears while melting some caramel on the stove. He seemed calmer after the rest of their conversation, and much more like himself.
The coffee he served her was a thick, black mixture that smelled of smoke and tasted like cinnamon, molasses, and copper. “What is this?” She asked breathing in the rich smell. It was unlike anything she’d ever tasted before.
“A special blend. I thought it up myself last spring.”
“It’s wonderful. Did you roast the beans yourself?”
“I always do,” he chirped in his usual high spirits. “I'm glad somone appreciates it. Will only drinks instant,” he admitted sourly.
“Do you want to talk about it? About what’s going on between you and Will? I don't mean to pry, but as a therapist, surely you would agree that talking helps.”
“Drink your coffee, Chief Brody. You don’t want it to get cold.”
She was trying to, but it was slow work. The coffee must be decaf because it was putting her out instead of waking her up. She should probably go home soon. Bed sounded heavenly right now.
Halfway through her glass, she started feeling dizzy. “Doctor Lecter, I don’t feel so well,” she said rising to her feet. “Where’s your restroom?”
“No, Chief Brody, I don’t expect you do.” Doctor Lecter placed his knife onto the counter and turned off the stove. “You should sit down before you lose consciousness. No sense cracking your head open before I get the chance to do it for you.”
His words did immediately register to Brody. It...it sounded like he was threatening her! “Excuse me?”
But Doctor Lecer ignored her question and kept his eyes pointed away from her when he spoke. “Do you know that most people get attacked by sharks in three feet of water about ten feet from the beach? Doesn’t that seem strange to you?”
“What are you talking about?”
Doctor Lecter removed his, apron, waistcoat, and tie. Free from the trappings of a scholar and socialite, she saw for the first time the telltale markings of a hard life. Broad shoulders. Rough hands. A wide stance, ready for battle. “People are always the most vulnerable when they think they safe,” he continued. “I deeply respect the shark for this lesson. They have been great mentors to me, and to Will too, I dare say, although he may not want to admit it.”
Brody tried to rise but fell backwards as soon as her weight settled onto her feet. He’d drugged her! That bitchass had drugged her! And whatever he had put in her coffee was acting fast. She had to get out.
Her head struck the countertop on her way to the floor. The blow caused her vision to go dark for a moment, and when she could see again, Doctor Lecter stood over her with a knife and his silk tie in his hands.
“Have you figured it out yet? Do you know who I am, Chief Brody?”
Oh, she knew. She had seen enough sharks to recognize them at this distance. This was Will’s maneater.
“The Ripper,” she mouthed because she longer had the energy for speech. Brody wasn’t sure whether he had poisoned her or merely sedated her, but if Doctor Lecter really was the Ripper, she better hope for the quick death.
…
There was a thick smell of iron in the air when Brody came to. For a moment, she thought she was back onboard the Jonah sloughing chum into the waters of the Georgian coast.
But when her mind cleared, she saw that she was in an immaculately stocked pantry. There was blood of her face and shoulders from a deep laceration across her forehead, and for the moment, she was alone.
Well this was a fine mess she had gotten herself into. So Doctor Lecter was the Chesapeake Ripper...great. ‘Do no harm, my ass.’
Brody lay on the floor on her side. Her hands were tied behind her back by a length of soft material. His tie perhaps? When she tried to stand another wave struck dizziness and forced her to take a break. It was clear Brody would go no further until the sedative wore off, but least she was sitting up now.
Why had Lecter done it in the first place? She was still a cop after all and a high risk target. Taking her hostage or worse was a monumentally stupid move.
Unless he didn't plan to escape...
‘Doesn't matter,’ she reminded herself. He'd be coming back as soon as he finished his preparations, and then she was shark bait. She wouldn't let herself think about the specifics of those plans. She couldn't! She would need all her wits to get out of this alive, but her wits were in short supply due to the lingering effects of the sedative.
‘Am I going to get out of this alive?’
“Bullshit,” she spat trying to snap out of it. Fatalist thinking never did anyone any good. She'd learned that in Iraq. She was going to get out of this pantry. She was going to get out of this house, and then Lecter was going to pay for everything.
There were noises outside, then a cry, and the loud, wet thump of a body crumpling to the floor.
Lecter or Will she imagined. Will was the only one who could be coming.
‘Please let it be Lecter,’ she prayed.
But speak of the devil and he shall appear. The door opened and it was Lecter’s body that filled the portal. He shut the door behind him and ignored Brody while he thumbed through the spice rack. He didn't look injured, but when he suddenly sagged against the rows of flour bags and spices and buried his face in his sleeve, her heart gave a little flutter of glee. Good job, Will! At least he hand landed a few good punches before he fell.
It wasn’t until she heard the muffled sob that she understood what was really happening.
Lecter was crying.
Will had given him his answer, and the answer was no.
‘But why would the Ripper be crying...oh, God, no.’
The pieces snapped together like the clip of a gun. Will’s misery at the aquarium. His hesitancy in his relationship. It all made sense. Will had known that Lecter was the Ripper, for how long she couldn’t say. But that wasn't the worst of it.
‘The copycat doesn’t matter,' Will had said, but of course the copycat mattered. The copycat, the Ripper’s dance partner...it had to have been someone close to him. Someone who knew how he thought and knew his crimes intimately enough to recreate them.
The copycat...was Will.
It made sense now: Will’s choice of victims, criminals who had escaped the justice system, and the effect every successful murder by the copycat had on the Ripper’s intensity. Lecter was in love with Will, and he had thought that the copycat’s actions was proof that Will loved him back. Every murder had been a coded message between them. ‘I know you. I see you. And I understand.’
“Please, you don’t have to do this. Will loves you, I swear it,” she begged. She actually wasn't sure if Will really loved him or not. The man she'd met with this afternoon had seemed conflicted on that point, but frankly she didn't care about the truth right now. She didn’t think she could stomach any more of it today.
In any hostage system, it paid to humanize yourself and bond with your captor, and if the Ripper had a heart at all, love was the way to appeal to it. None of his previous victims had held this advantage. Perhaps she wasn't chum yet! “He’ll come around if you explain it to him again. I'm sure of it! He just wasn't ready yet.”
Lecter was silent, but he had stopped crying. Brody didn't know whether that was a good or bad sign, but he was listening to her at least. That had to count for something.
“I won’t tell anyone. Please, take him and go.”
“Go?” He asked and finally turned to face her. Blood soaked the front of his shirt, a lot of blood. “Go? With Will? Look at me. That’s not possible anymore.”
Brody looked, but not at his shirt. It was his eyes that held her attention, his black; impassive; lifeless eyes.... like a doll’s eyes.
Unbidden one of Quints old fish tales floated to the surface of her mind, of a fishing accident he had survived.
“We formed ourselves into tight groups. You know, it was kinda like old squares in the battle like you see in the calendar named “The Battle of Waterloo, and the idea was: shark comes to the nearest man, that man he starts poundin’ and hollerin’ and screamin’ and sometimes the shark will go away…but sometimes the shark wouldn't go away.
Sometimes that shark he looks right into ya. Right into your eyes. And the thing about a shark is he’s got lifeless eyes. Black eyes. Like a doll’s eyes. When he comes at ya, he doesn’t even seem to be livin’… ’til he bites ya, and those black eyes roll over white and then… ah then you hear that terrible high-pitched screamin’. The ocean turns red, and despite all your poundin’ and your hollerin’ those sharks come in and… they rip you to pieces.”
In his story, it hadn't ended well for most of the sailors aboard that vessel. Only Quint and a handful of others had escaped with their lives if not their sanity, but the lesson was clear: divert the shark’s attention and make him less interested in you to the disadvantage of the next guy.
“Did you kill him?” Broday asked a;though she was afraid of the answer. Will was her diversion, and if he was dead so was she.
Lecter gave her a pained expression looking as if he had swallowed something sharp. “Why don’t we go see?” he said and dragged her up to her feet.
In the kitchen, Will sat in a pool of his own blood, alive but in agony. He looked like a fish that had been gutted and prepped to be eaten, and maybe he was. Maybe they both were.
“You were supposed to go,” Will said through clenched teeth. He looked at Lecter and then at Brody. His eyes held an apology, but she wasn't sure who it was meant for.
It was strange seeing Will like this. He was her friend, and now...he was a murderer too. He was also dying. But maybe he deserve to die? He had killed people for Christ’s sake! And stood by while Lecter murdered more. He was a killer, a serial killer. TattleCrime had been right about him all along. Will wasn't a forensic genius, and he wasn't Superman either. He was a psychopath. Just a psychopath. And he had played them all for fools whether he realized it consciously or not.
“No, WE were supposed to go together, Will.” Lecter growled. “Or do you not remember what you told me last week when I proposed my plan to you after we killed that dog fighter you were so fluffed about?”
Brody raised an eyebrow. They were killing as a team now? These sons of bitches...
Will caught Brody glaring at him and looked away in shame. “I didn’t give you my answer, Hannibal.”
“You said you enjoyed it. You called it beautiful! You lied. You lied...to me.”
“I didn't,” Will whispered and then to Brody, “God, help me, I didn't lie.”
If Will was was expecting some sort absolution, he wasn’t going to find it from either Brody or Lecter. She could see that Will was telling the truth, even if Lecter was too hurt to see it too, but the knowledge made her sick and furious. She didn't recognize the man bleeding to death at her feet. Her friend had been a tortured but virtuous soul, and Lecter had fed that man to the sharks.
“More lies! What was it all for, Will? Revenge? Revenge for what I did to you before I knew what we could be together? I didn't know!” Lecter was vibrating with anger like a live wire. Brody felt his grip slip as he laid into Will with his hurt feelings. Her chance was around the corner.
“But I never lied about my feelings for you, Will. Never . And this is how you return them? You’d have put me in a cage, taken away my freedom.”
“No, no, no,” Will mumbled, his voice growing fainter. “I gave it back. Told you to run. You were supposed to be gone by the time the FBI arrived.”
“And leave without you, a clean break? What were you going to do, Will? Turn yourself in? How magnanimous of you,” Lecter snarled.
‘I’ll show you a clean break,’ Brody thought and slammed her head back into Lecter’s face.
Lecter cursed in his native tongue as his nose broke, and he released his hold over Brody.
She ran but only made it five steps before her legs gave out. She fell knowing Lecter would be on her in a moment.
“Margret!” Will shouted. Something metallic skittered across the floor toward her, Will’s sidearm.
She rolled into her back, reached for the gun, and fired.
Lecter was already in mid-pounce leaving her little time to aim. She hit him, but the bullet missed his heart and tore through his shoulder instead. It was not enough to stop him, just enough to to hurt. He fell on her howling like a mad dog.
They grappled, but he was stronger and high on adrenaline. Lecter ripped the gun from her hands and tossed it, far from either her or Will’s reach. Then he grabbed her by the collar and slammed her head against the floor: once, twice, three time. She saw stars when he pulled her to her feet.
“You’ll pay for that, Margret,” Lecter whispered emphasizing her name as if to suggest that he was annoyed that she and Will were on a first name basis.
“That’s Chief Brody to you, asshole,” she coughed out.
He huffed and reached for a knife from the block on the counter. He laid the blade against her throat and wrapped his other arm around her waist so she could not flee again.
“Hannibal...don't,” Will begged.
“I let you know me. See me,” Lecter said leaning over Brody’s shoulder so she could not hit him in the nose again. “I gave you a rare gift, Will, but you didn't want it.”
Will tried to laugh, but coughed up blood instead. “Didn't I? Didn't I though?”
Lecter began to rock, swaying like he and Brody were dance partners, and then, because God had a cruel sense of humor, he began to sing. “Farewell and adieu to you Spanish ladies. Farewell and adieu you ladies of Spain.” Unlike Will's voice had been, his voice was smooth and even. There was no madness in it, and no emotion. It undulated like the deep swells of the ocean on those calm days that generally preceded a hurricane.
Brody struggled as Lecter slid the blade across her throat.
“NO!” Will screamed as her body dropped to the floor in a bloody heap.
Lecter tossed the knife towards Will, daring his star-crossed lover to defy him again. But the knife fell just outside Will’s reach and with it, Brody’s last hope of taking Lecter to hell with her.
Lecter, meanwhile, resumed his song as Brody fought for air that wouldn’t come, like a fish out of water.
“For we've received orders to sail for Boston, and we may never see you fair ladies again..."
