Actions

Work Header

Under The Oaken Tree

Chapter 2: Roots

Summary:

Thorin’s ghost watches Bilbo grow and move on. But Thorin is dead and so is his family and there’s no way to escape death. Nevertheless, he finds himself wanting to move on too.

Chapter Text

Thorin knew he was dead because he felt very light. Which might have been an odd thing to notice but when one wore heavy armors and furs all of their life a lack of weight was quite easy to notice. 

But the rest was familiar. Mahal’s Halls looked like the stones of Erebor and the fires of the forges looked exactly like the fires on Middle Earth. Dwarves looked like they had when they were alive. 

This discovery was made when a large group of them barreled into Thorin after he opened his eyes. He saw his mother and grandmother with their wrinkled faces and perfectly braided hair. His younger brother looked just as young as when he died and just as joyful as when he lived. Two more figures hugged him from behind and Thorin had to look over his shoulder to see their faces. 

The taste in his mouth soured as he saw the two figures hugging him from behind were none other than Fíli and Kíli, his sistersons who he led to their untimely deaths. 

Thorin couldn’t bear to hold their gazes so he looked behind them. There was a group of three dwarves off to the side. Vili, his sister’s husband, stood ramrod still and didn’t have the softness in his eyes that Thorin remembered. Next to him were Thorin’s father and grandfather. 

Thrain and Thror were as stoic as ever. The sight of them made a fire burn in his chest. He knew it was because they must hate him. Thorin looked at the group of men who had expected him to look after their home and loved ones when they died, a group that he had failed. 

Despite not being able to feel the weight of those hugging him, Thorin could still feel the rot of guilt and the burning in his chest. 

⚔⚔❦⚔⚔

The hammer made the same metallic clang as it hit the metal of what would become a sword. 

It was in the familiarity of the forge that Thorin felt the most foreign. No matter how much he swung his hammer, his muscles did not ache. No matter how bright the fires, he did not sweat. 

Time never seemed to reach this place. Thorin could have been there for days and he would have no way of knowing. Staying in the forge was probably for the best, which is why he ignored the knocks on his door that happened periodically. 

He hoped the listlessness would be better than the guilt, even if that had yet to be proven true. 

His thoughts were broken by a sudden and harsh tug on his heart. He dropped his hammer. There was a pulling sensation that told Thorin he had to be somewhere else. He squeezed his eyes shut to adjust to the sensation and when he opened his eyes, he was no longer in the forge. 

Thorin opened his eyes to lush greenery and rolling hills. There was no place in Mahal’s domain that looked like this. Had he been summoned to Yavanna’s? 

Thorin’s eyes swept over the landscape to find that this place was much more familiar than he originally believed. This was the Shire. 

“This is ridiculous.” 

Thorin knew that voice. He had not been summoned by Yavanna but one of Yavanna’s children. He turned to see Bilbo Baggins kneeling in the dirt in front of a small hole occupied by an acorn. 

No. It couldn’t be. Thorin couldn’t allow himself to hope for that. 

“Bilbo?” Thorin called. But his hobbit didn’t answer. He knew then that Bilbo couldn’t hear him. 

Bilbo filled the hole with dirt before speaking again. 

“You’d find this absurd. You gave me all these fine metals and yet…”

Thorin looked around the front yard of Bag End but there was no one else around. Who was Bilbo talking to? 

“I can’t stop thinking of the look on your face when you saw this acorn.”

If Thorin could still breathe, he’d have found himself lacking air. Bilbo was talking to him, to Thorin . Even after death, Bilbo still had a hold of Thorin’s heart and squeezed. 

“You saved me,” Thorin whispered. Desperation colored his voice but Bilbo showed no reaction. The hobbit simply lit his pipe and stared through Thorin. He couldn’t see Thorin either.

Life after death could be surprisingly cruel. 

Bilbo spoke, “I went to the market the other day. You’d think I had sprouted a second head with the way people were staring! Then there was the gossipping, which I could hear, and you’d really think they’d be more professional about it and speak quietly. As if it’s so wrong to go on an adventure!”

Thorin watched as the hobbit waved his hands around to dramatically make a point and couldn’t stop the smile from forming on his face. He felt another tug on his heart. He was forever bound to Bilbo Baggins, his only anchor. 

“There is nothing wrong with any part of you.” Thorin said, despite knowing that Bilbo would not hear. An ache filled Thorin. He wanted to give his One comfort but had no means of doing so. Instead, he sat with Bilbo as the sun set, so he could soak in the sight of the hobbit. 

Bilbo puffed out rings of smoke in various sizes. Lost in the simple spectacle, Thorin almost missed Bilbo’s next words. 

“I could never talk to anyone the way I could talk to you, Thorin.” 

Thorin’s shoulders sagged. His mind wandered to his actions since his death, all spent hiding in his forge. 

“I feel the same about you, Ghivashel.” 

When day turned to night, Thorin blinked and found himself back in his forge.

⚔⚔❦⚔⚔

Over the next year, Thorin was sporadically pulled to the growing oak tree. He and Bilbo didn’t talk every time. Often, he simply watched the hobbit drink his tea or read his books. In between those visits, his brother Frerin pounded at his door. 

The guilt still festered, the fire still burned. 

⚔⚔❦⚔⚔

Without knowing, Bilbo left enough space on the bench for Thorin to sit next to him. For a moment the former dwarven king could pretend that he felt more than the memory of his One’s warmth. 

“Thorin, you’ll never believe who I’ve been talking to recently.” 

“Oh?” Thorin played along. “And who’s that?” 

“My cousin, Primula.” Bilbo replied, staring at the sapling. “Of course, you never got to meet her but I think you would’ve liked her. She’s quite taken with all of the stories I have of you.” 

Thorin angled his body so he could look directly at Bilbo.

“If she’s taken with stories of me, you haven’t been telling her everything.”

Bilbo didn’t see Thorin’s wry smile. He simply continued staring at the young oak tree and continued. 

“I never thought anyone would love me like you did. Er, well–” 

Thorin watched with fascination as Bilbo’s cheeks turned rosy. The flustered hobbit continued past his blunder. 

“Not the exact same way of course. I meant it’s nice for someone to like you for who you are instead of who they want you to be. That’s all.” 

Thorin felt relief unknot his shoulders. So Bilbo had known. That was good. Even if nothing could be done about it now, Bilbo should have known that he was loved. 

Thorin gathered his thoughts as Bilbo lit his pipe. 

“I don’t know what I would have done if she hadn’t approached me. I never even thought to talk to someone after, well, everything.”

Bilbo blew his smoke rings and Thorin gathered courage to talk to a man who could not hear him. 

“Ghivashel, you have no way of knowing what these talks mean to me. I am… so grateful there is someone alive to stand by you.” 

He didn’t get the response he was expecting– which had been none.  

“Thank Yavanna for stubborn family members that love you unconditionally.”

There was a moment where the echoes of Frerin banging on his door rang through Thorin’s head. For the first time, Thorin felt a tug away from Bilbo. 

“Yes. And thank Mahal, too.”

Thorin stood up and stood before Bilbo. He reached a finger out to one of the smoke circles and cut through it, dragging the top of the circle down into a heart. 

Thorin’s cheeks then heated with embarrassment and he walked away from the bench. He stopped and turned to Bilbo. 

“Until next time.” He whispered. 

Then Thorin closed his eyes and focused on the knocks on his door. When he opened his eyes, he was back in his forge and the knocking was much louder. 

Thorin flung open the door to be met with a fist thumping against his chest. Frerin looked up in surprise. 

“You opened the door?” Frerin asked with a rude amount of surprise.

“You knocked. Loudly.” Thorin replied.

“And you haven’t opened the door for two years!” 

“It’s been two years?!” 

“Oh, Thorin.” Frerin exhaled and rubbed his forehead. “I suppose it’s comforting to see some things never change.” 

“Like your height?” Thorin ribbed. He felt a stab of regret. Frerin had died when he– 

“Yeah, that’s the worst part of dying young.” Frerin readily agreed. 

“The worst part? Truly?” 

“Well, it’s the only part that’s still my problem.” 

Thorin had no idea why he found the statement so humorous but he found himself laughing in spite of himself. 

When Thorin finally regained control of himself he looked up to see Frerin’s smile. 

“How long have you been holding that in, Thorin?” 

Thorin intended to deflect from the question, but then he thought of his talk with Bilbo. He had been relieved to know that Bilbo understood how he felt about him. The embarrassment of being honest in the afterlife was dwarfed by the enormity of that relief.

“It became harder to laugh without you.”  

Frerin’s smile dimmed but didn’t disappear. He held a wisdom much older than himself, or at least much older than he appeared. 

“You know that wasn’t your fault right?”

Thorin’s lips thinned and Frerin rolled his eyes at the sight. 

“Oh, right. Everything is your fault. How could I forget?” 

Thorin glared at Frerin, only to be met with a smile. Thorin couldn’t help but to return it. 

“I missed you, nadad.” Thorin whispered. Frerin touched his forehead to Thorin’s. 

“I missed you, too.” Frerin said. “But I was hoping to have to wait for you a little longer.” 

“As had I, but perhaps this was the ending I was meant to have.” 

“I’m not the Valar, so I won’t speak to that. I was saddened that you had died the way you did. There also was a part of me that has been dreaming of catching up with my brother since I saw him last.” 

Frerin held Thorin’s shoulders so Thorin had no choice but to look his brother in the eye. 

“Please, step outside.” 

Thorin felt the sour taste on his tongue once more and he forced his mouth to speak around it. 

“There are those I should not see. Not– not after everything–” 

Frerin gave Thorin’s shoulders a quick squeeze to stop him from talking. Frerin sighed.

“Lucky we have eternity to get that sorted out. For now, can you at least let me in?” 

Thorin was once more reminded of Bilbo and how excited the hobbit was to have family to talk to, to connect with. 

Thorin nodded and was promptly pulled down into a hug. 

⚔⚔❦⚔⚔

The more time Thorin spent outside of his forge, the less weightless he felt. His feet felt solid on the ground. He finally felt the force of his hammer when it swung. 

He spent much of his time with Bilbo Baggins. The tight hold on his heart loosened and settled into warmth. 

There were different knocks on his door from time to time. Those knocks were always followed by voices that Thorin couldn’t make out. During those times, Thorin found himself unable to grasp the handle, unable to push it open. 

Before he knew it, forty years had passed. The guilt still clung to his tongue and the heat in his chest hadn’t died down.

⚔⚔❦⚔⚔

The next time Thorin saw Bilbo Baggins, he had the thought that Bilbo aged very gracefully. The hobbit had gray around his temples and deeper laugh lines etched into his face. Except his hobbit wasn’t laughing or smiling. The corner’s of Bilbo’s lips were pulled down and there were tears in his eyes. 

“Oh, Thorin. I’m afraid there’s terrible news.” 

Thorin felt dread fill his stomach. He reached out but pulled his hands back, remembering himself.  

“Primula and Drogo passed. It was an accident, they drowned.” 

Thorin’s lips thinned and his heart ached for his One. 

“I don’t know what to do.” Bilbo whispered.

Thorin sighed, “Oh Bilbo, I’m terribly sorry.”

Thorin moved to stand next to Bilbo as he looked up the tree.

“I know how much they meant to you, Ghivashel.” 

“I’m glad I got what time I had with them.” Bilbo smiled bitterly, “It was more time than we had.” 

Thorin nodded solemnly. “I hate seeing you so alone.” 

Thorin's fingers itched with the desire to touch Bilbo. Thorin knew, however, that if Bilbo could not see or hear him, touch was out of the question. Thorin’s musing was interrupted when Bilbo suddenly burst out laughing.

“Oh dear!” The hobbit chuckled as tears ran down his cheeks. “I’m a mess.” 

Bilbo wiped the streaks with his handkerchief and Thorin felt a swell of affection in his chest. His fingers itched again.

“There’s so much going on.” Bilbo continued. “I just– After the battle, it was so quiet. And now I’m… I’m supposed to be a parent!” 

Thorin’s heart sank. Bilbo had never mentioned finding someone else, but why would he? Thorin was a dead man and Bilbo was someone who deserved to be loved.  

“I’m not with anyone. It’s…” Bilbo smiled, “No one compares to you. I don’t find myself wanting to be with anyone else if it’s not you.” 

Thorin, for once, was grateful that he was dead so no one could see the flush on his face. The dwarf pressed a hand against his own mouth, hiding from somehow no one and everyone. 

“Ever the wordsmith, Master Burglar.” Thorin whispered with a fond smile. 

His melancholy matched his relief in equal measure. But perhaps Bilbo felt Thorin’s love from across realms and found it to be enough to last him a lifetime. 

“They left Frodo in my care. I was so terrified that I almost said no but…” Bilbo sighed. “I couldn’t leave him alone.” 

“Of course not,” Thorin replied. “You always do what’s right.” 

It was part of why Thorin fell in love with him. 

Bilbo leaned down and picked up the fallen acorn. Thorin admired Bilbo’s profile as the hobbit examined the small nut. 

“I hope I’m as good of an uncle as you were,” Bilbo mumbled. 

Thorin immediately balked at the statement. 

“Have you gotten so old that you’ve forgotten the battle? You had to bury my sistersons for me.” 

The guilt contorted the smile on Thorin’s face into a scowl. He was not angry at Bilbo. He couldn’t be. Thorin hadn’t stopped being angry with himself. 

Bilbo scoffed, “Ugh, I can almost hear you denying it. Stubborn fool.” 

Even in the afterlife, Thorin could not avoid Bilbo Baggins chastising him. In spite of himself, his smile grew to match his One’s. 

Bilbo spoke with a wistful voice, “Those boys loved you. Even with all of their teasing, they respected you so very much.”

Thorin, with all of his stubbornness, was unable to argue with that. Those boys loved him. They loved him so much that he found himself completely unsurprised that he now knew the muffled voices that knocked on his forge door belonged to Fíli and Kíli. 

If anyone asked, Thorin would tell them he had no idea where they got their stubborn streak from. However, the most annoying part of dying, Thorin decided, was being unable to keep lying to oneself. 

Fíli and Kíli took after him in many ways. Because he had raised them along with his sister after Vili died. Those were his boys and they would pardon him of his wrongdoings even if no one else would. 

“I want to raise Frodo the way you helped raise Fíli.” Bilbo confessed. “He was ready to be an heir, to be responsible and good, but you also let him be a boy. It was so heartening to see him act like the young lad he was.” 

Thorin smiled. He would have been very proud of Fíli, had he been able to be king. The next words out of Bilbo’s mouth cut through to the dwarf’s heart.

“You did a very good job.” 

If Thorin still needed air, he would have found himself out of breath. A simple sentence, and yet Thorin found his eyes were wet with unshed tears.  

“Thank you, Ghivashel.”

Thorin went unheard, as he always did, but he let himself be swept up in Bilbo’s monologue. 

“Yes, that’s right. I don’t want to raise Frodo the way I was raised. My parents were wonderful! Don’t misunderstand, but I want Frodo to be… to have more freedom.” 

That seemed to be the contradiction of raising a child. To be responsible meant to help shape a child into the adult they would become. But they would become adults, so the children had to be the ones to pick the mold. 

Fíli and Kíli had wanted to go to Erebor, so much so that their own mother couldn’t stop them. Now, they wanted to see Thorin; they wanted to be with their uncle. Thorin would not punish their bravery and sacrifice with his own guilt. 

Bilbo looked at the oak tree. “Do you think I’ll raise him well?”

If Thorin could do it, surely Bilbo would be better. But Thorin still heard whispers of worry in the hobbit’s voice. 

Thorin wrapped his arms around Bilbo and prayed the sentiment would be felt, even if his touch wasn’t. 

⚔⚔❦⚔⚔

Kíli’s reaction to Thorin apologizing for getting him killed was to laugh in his face. At least Fíli proved, even after death, to be Thorin’s rightful heir by being more mature. Fíli thanked Thorin for his apology and then laughed in his face. 

Thorin put up with the needling and reminders that Fíli and Kíli had been adults, young as they were. Thorin paid his due diligence and nodded along with all of the barbs. 

He didn’t speak until the teasing died down, “I am sorry about Tauriel, Kíli. She seemed like an incredible woman.” 

Kíli’s eyes watered at that and he tried to hide it with a cough. 

Fíli redirected, “We’re sorry about Bilbo, Uncle. He was a good fit for you.” 

Thorin smiled and pulled Fíli into a short hug. He saw Kíli wipe his eyes before wildly grinning and gearing up to tease Thorin. 

“Mister Boggins was a good influence on you. I never thought I’d see you approve of an elf. All it took was you dying!”

Thorin groaned and felt the prickle of embarrassment on his skin, but he allowed the boys to get their jokes in. He had agreed to this when they were born and when their father died; he would agree to it in death, too. 

A voice cut through the laughter, “I see you’ve reunited.” 

The voice was familiar but the coldness in it was not. Thorin looked to the doorway of his forge to see Vili standing there, stiff with displeasure. Thorin had an errant thought. ‘Fíli would have looked exactly like his father if he had lived long enough’. He was sure Vili knew that as well. 

Fíli and Kíli took steps to stand between the two older dwarves. Thorin grasped their arms and held them back. 

The boys looked to Thorin, awaiting his word. Thorin gave their arms a quick squeeze.

“Go ahead,” Thorin said. “Your father and I need to talk.” 

Fíli and Kíli hesitated but then Fíli nodded and escorted his brother out of the room. Vili stepped closer to Thorin.

“They’re my sons,” Vili began. “But they rushed to your defense even after you got them killed.” 

Thorin stood tall and anchored his feet to the floor. When Thorin was a traveling king, he had weathered many storms. What was one more? 

“I know,” Thorin replied. Vili took more steps forward until they were face to face.

“I trusted you to take care of them, to take care of Dis.” Vili spat. 

“I know,” Thorin repeated. 

“Fíli and Kíli were supposed to outlive all of us.” Vili jabbed his finger against Thorin’s chest.

“I know.” Thorin agreed. 

“They shouldn’t have died,” Vili said with a venomous rasp. “She shouldn’t be alone.” 

“I know , ” Thorin whispered. Silence hung between them. Vili’s body trembled. Thorin couldn’t tell if it was from anger or tears. Maybe Vili didn’t know either. 

For a moment, Thorin wondered if Vili was tied to Dis the way Thorin was tied to Bilbo. After all, Thorin’s sister had been Vili’s One. Were there times where Vili wanted to reach out to comfort Dis and she couldn’t hear him? 

Vili looked just like an older Fíli, and Thorin knew his heir better than anyone. Thorin placed a hand between Vili’s shoulder blades and pulled him close. Instinctually, Vili dropped his head on Thorin’s chest. 

“Dis is the strongest of us.” Thorin spoke softly. “She will ache with the loss but she will endure. We’ll hurt more once she enters these halls.” 

Vili huffed out a breath. “She’ll never let us hear the end of it. You Durins are always so stubborn.” 

“We are.” Thorin smiled.

Vili wrinkled his nose. “You were never this agreeable when you were alive.” 

“Well, that’s because I died,” Thorin said glibly. “It would be rather disappointing if I hadn’t learned anything from that.”

“It would have made being mad at you easier,” Vili grumbled into Thorin’s shirt. Hearing this was an echo from the past, one Thorin couldn’t help but laugh at. 

Vili raised his head to give Thorin a mystified look. 

“Fíli acted just like that when he was sixty during his history lessons.” 

Vili’s eyes glowed with a hunger for more information and Thorin was suddenly reminded that Vili never got to see his sons grow up. Maybe, just maybe, Vili had been feeling as disconnected from his family as Thorin had been when he first died. 

“I will tell you all of the stories I have,” Thorin promised. “The boys will be so embarrassed.” 

Vili lifted an eyebrow, “You’ll tell me the stories in front of them?”

Thorin motioned to the door with his head. Vili turned around to see Fíli and Kíli peeking in. Thorin shook his head fondly. Typical. 

“Go on.” Thorin said, pushing Vili toward the door. “Fathers should talk with their sons.”

Vili smirked, “So when are you going to talk to your father?” 

Thorin’s shoulders rose to touch his ears. Vili pat Thorin’s back and Thorin jostled from the force. 

“Maybe don’t let it take longer than a decade this time?” 

Thorin intoned, “Ugh, now I remember why Dis married you.”

This startled a laugh out of Vili. The laugh was so contagious that it traveled to Fíli and Kíli, their laughs harmonized with their father’s. Thorin felt his lips curl into a smile.

The guilt no longer cloyed his mouth. 

⚔⚔❦⚔⚔

Thorin was used to the calm camaraderie his time at Bag End offered him. His talks with Bilbo were comforting, even if his hobbit was unaware of the impact he had on Thorin. 

Considering this, Thorin’s shock at seeing a shrill hobbit make snide remarks at Bilbo in his own front yard was understandable. 

The woman spewed a cascade of insults that, if Thorin had a physical body and a sword, he would have made her pay for. To Thorin’s complete bafflement, Bilbo just stood there taking the insults. 

But then the woman finished with, “And Bag End is just too big for just the two of you!” 

Something in Bilbo’s gaze sharpened. The hobbit turned to look at the oak tree and for a moment Thorin thought Bilbo was looking in Thorin’s eyes. But the moment passed as soon as it came.

Bilbo turned to the woman and spat, “Bag End is a home for the Baggins family, Lobelia Sackville.”  

Oh. So that was Lobelia. Now all of Bilbo’s complaints over the decades made sense. 

“Do you know what they say about you?” Lobelia seethed. “They’re calling you Mad Baggins!” 

Bilbo had been very aware, to the distress of Thorin who could do nothing about it. But Bilbo simply laughed at her remark. 

“Even when I’m being insulted, I’m still a Baggins. So is Frodo, it’ll be his house one day and no one else's!” 

Bilbo then gave a smile and threatened, “So get off my property before I show you what kind of hobbit fights a dragon and wins.” 

Thorin could barely hear the woman’s reply as Bilbo’s sharp tongue made him feel something he hadn’t felt since he was alive. Something he wouldn’t examine until he was alone. 

After Lobelia left, Bilbo walked to the oak tree and sat at its base, back to the trunk. Thorin walked closer and lowered a knee to be next to the hobbit. He gave the leaves a grin Thorin hadn’t seen since the dungeons of Mirkwood. 

“Did you see that, Thorin? The look on her face was priceless!” 

Bilbo cackled and Thorin lost himself in the sound. The laugh eventually died down and ended in a pleasant smile. 

“I’m not the gentlehobbit I used to be, that’s for sure. I even spent a whole day without a handkerchief or caring about doilies!” 

“Yes,” Thorin agreed. “But I am glad that you still love your books and your armchair.” 

Bilbo toyed with the blades of grass between their hands and once more Thorin had the urge to touch something out of his reach. 

“Yes… I think I’m quite content with who I am. Happy, even.” 

Bilbo looked back up at the branches and Thorin’s gaze remained on Bilbo’s face.

“I wonder if you’d like who I’ve become.” He whispered to the trees. But Thorin heard it. 

His hobbit was once a gentleman, then a burglar, then an adventurer, then a friend as well as something more, and he returned home a writer, an uncle, a hero. Bilbo Baggins had fought goblins and spiders and stayed to have a battle of wits with a dragon. 

Which led to Thorin realizing that he himself had fought a dragon and was somehow afraid of talking to his father and grandfather. Maybe facing their ire would make the burning in his chest come to a simmer.

Giving in to temptation, Thorin leaned down and kissed Bilbo’s lips. It was no more than a peck but it allowed Thorin a small relief of the emotions that threatened to flood him.

⚔⚔❦⚔⚔

Then the dam broke. 

At the time, Thorin had believed that he could handle anything his father or grandfather had to say. Thrain and Thror had been strong leaders and Thorin had been all that remained of their legacy. Thorin was ready to accept the consequences of his failures. 

His knuckles thudded against the thick wooden doors of Thrain’s room. It only took one knock for the door to open. Thrain had opened the door. His movements were rigid and overly practiced. Thorin wondered just how much trouble he was in. 

Thrain crossed the room towards a hearth. Thror sat in one of the two chairs next to the fire and Thrain lowered himself into the other. For a moment, the three dwarves just stared at each other, unsure of how to proceed. 

Well, a voice that sounded suspiciously like Bilbo whispered in Thorin’s mind, no time like the present.  

“Adad… My King–” 

“I stopped being your king when I died,” Thror said, his voice as deep as the caves of Erebor. Despite the sentiment, Thorin felt like a child standing before his throne once more. His fists clenched as he gathered the courage to start over. 

“The line of Durin… I know the importance of our legacy. I… I was the king after you both passed and I-I…” 

Thorin found himself struggling to articulate his point. A raised hand stopped him from continuing. The hand belonged to his father and Thorin widened his stance to prepare himself for the tongue lashing. 

“I am sorry, my son,” Thrain said, deep regret painting his voice. 

The mine cart was not on the track Thorin expected it to be on. He could only blink in response. 

“I know the reason you haven’t come to speak with us,” Thrain continued. ‘To avoid your judgment’ Thorin thought, for he could judge himself quite well without anyone’s help. But then his grandfather spoke. 

“We failed you.” Thror said. His face was unmoving but his hand gripped the chair until his knuckles were white. “You were left with the curse we weren’t strong enough to break. We know how you must resent us.” 

Thorin couldn’t speak. He wanted to assure them that they were wrong. He wanted to say that he was a coward and he was hiding from them.

But the burning in his chest was a raging inferno. Now he knew why. He was angry at them, furious even. Thorin couldn’t recognize it because he always turned it inward. 

This is when the dam broke. 

Thorin rasped, “I followed all of your commands.” 

When Thorin was young, he looked up to the pedestal Thrain stood on and the throne where Thror sat. Now, he stood towering above the two men sitting in simple chairs. He couldn’t look at them so he turned his glare to the floor.

“I was a dutiful son and prince and when you died I was only a hundred and four years old. And while I was an adult, no king before me had to govern citizens without a kingdom, without a home. ” 

Thorin felt tears stream down his face but he couldn’t move his hands to wipe them. His fists were too tight, too intent on retaining some control. 

“I had no coronation and I could not hold your funerals. I felt weak because I could not have what you had before me. I could not achieve your accomplishments. I hated myself for not being either of you.” 

Worst of all, Thorin could not lift his head to see the reactions of Thror or Thrain. 

“I hated that I was not the king either of you wanted for so long and the only person that made me not hate myself wasn’t a dwarf. Because the dwarves needed a king, needed a leader, needed someone larger than he was. But a hobbit wanted me, just for myself.” 

Thorin smiled ruefully. “And I can’t be with him. I love him, I love him like Mahal loves Yavanna– I love him more than anything. But I died before I could be with him. I fought a dragon you enticed to our home and died in a war with orcs that you started.” 

Thorin’s eyes clenched shut and his deepest confession fell from his lips. 

“I hate myself for hating you. I love you. I never wanted to hate you. It felt so wrong to blame the dead for the problems of the living. But now I’m dead, so who am I supposed to blame? Am I allowed to blame anyone?” 

Thorin’s shoulders rounded forward with each word and he felt smaller than he was. The fire in his heart finally extinguished. Thorin waited to see what it cost.

Silence filled the spaces that Thorin’s words didn’t occupy. Thorin wondered if he would have to spend eternity separated from his father and grandfather. 

Then a rough palm enveloped his fist. Thorin looked up to see his father standing before him. Thorin’s mother often commented on how Thorin had Thrain’s eyes and now Thorin could see it. 

Thrain’s eyes also became bluer when he was crying. 

Thorin’s eyes flickered to track Thror’s movement as he stood up and walked towards Thorin. His wrinkles looked more defined than Thorin had remembered and his eyes shared Thrain’s sadness. 

Thror touched his forehead to Thorin’s and whispered apologies as long as their lineage. Thorin’s shoulders relaxed under Thrain’s touch as Thorin’s father pulled him into a tight embrace. 

“I understand if you can never forgive us.” Thrain whispered into Thorin’s hair. “But please… can you forgive yourself?” 

The question seeped into Thorin’s soul. Could he forgive himself? Had he taken every step towards redemption that he could? 

The thought of his time with Frerin. His apology to his sistersons, the joy it brought them. He remembered comforting Vili during his fit of anger. He thought of hours spent listening to Bilbo as an oak tree grew from a seed to a sanctuary. 

The queries made Thorin aware of himself in a way he never had been before. Thorin’s body felt immovable and grounded, his conscience was clear and light. 

“I forgive you,” Thorin whispered to his father and to his grandfather.

“I forgive you,” He promised to himself.

⚔⚔❦⚔⚔

Over the next decades, Thorin would visit the oak tree many times. He would listen to Bilbo speak and, to his delight, Frodo sometimes played along and spoke to the dwarven king he never got to meet.  

Thorin visited as often as he could until Bilbo left Bag End for the last time. His One had a standing invitation to sail away with the elves to a place where Mahal’s fires could not reach. Thorin thought saying his final goodbye would be sadder.

But then a tug on his heart pulled him back to Mahal’s Halls and into the warm and weighty embrace of his family. And all was well.

Notes:

Thank you so much to Pan and Alana for the emotional support and proofreading during 2023 and into 2024 as I got this whole personal challenge done.

Series this work belongs to: