Chapter Text
Óin is extremely annoyed when he gets dragged out of bed. He is no spring chicken and stayed up the whole night tending to various elf-related trouble.
"They are immortal for Mahal's sake; they should be healthy as goats. And if they have suddenly turned frail, they should bring their own healers, someone that actually knows something about Elves."
Both fainted elves and Gandalf are lying on the benches and Óin looks at them as if they were especially suspect fish. The benches look uncomfortable, but the Erebor staterooms are designed to be stately and not cosy.
They should have something upholstered and more pleasant to sit on, but the dwarves believe that official occasions should be uncomfortable, otherwise some overzealous lord will find a way to make the official part of any event even longer than it otherwise needs to be.
"I told her that screaming, and ranting is bad for the baby, but no one listens to me. What is wrong with him?"
Thranduil has fallen asleep again. He must have had a truly excellent wedding night. He perhaps should make some sly remarks on Bard’s prowess to bolster his reputation. Killing dragons is of course pretty great in itself, but reputation as a very attentive husband surpasses everything at least in the Shire and not only among the ladies.
"He got married yesterday."
"Marriage is not a disease, although it sometimes is catching."
He tries to mouth to Óin that the elven king had not been having any for a thousand year or so and has probably been nailed to the bed like a carpentry class if the fodgo induced frenzy earlier in the afternoon had been anything to go.
"Speak up, young man, I am a bit hard of hearing in my other ear.”
He shrugs. "There is nothing wrong with him that a pot of ointment wouldn't cure."
Bard coughs in a way he probably considers discreet.
"Actually, we have ointment of our own, a nice big jar of it. He came very well prepared. I tried to be a gentleman, but he was having none of it."
In the probably vain hope of not having to discuss Bard's marital issues in the future, he contemplates telling the King of Dale that his husband wants a rogue, a swashbuckler, and a dragon slayer well versed in the skills described in the Book instead of goody-two-shoes complaining about the state of his knees and the purity of children. But this is not the time or the place, especially as Bard looks quite mournful.
"I think you should worry about the others, there seems to be something actually wrong with the happy couple."
Reluctantly, Óin returns to the other two elves and the wizard, Gandalf and Lady Galadriel seem to be rather peacefully asleep but not reacting to shaking or smelling salts. Elrond is whining and fidgeting, and his father is trying to calm him down without much success.
"I am sure it is that bloody ring, it oozes evil, and trust me, I am familiar with that kind of thing."
There is a certain look of disbelief he is very familiar with on the face of all dwarves attending.
"Evil? It looks quite well forged for such a simple thing. I find it mildly annoying that its design doesn't correspond the craftsmanship shown," Thorin rubs his nose, "But if it indeed oozes something, we need to put it somewhere else so that we can continue the meeting with everyone fully conscious, just take it to the treasure chamber, it can be evil there."
The dwarves may find the ring just an irritant, but they do have other people in Erebor, and even if the treasure chamber is well guarded and secure, he is certain that eventually someone determined enough will show up and try to claim it. Before he has time to protest that a mere treasure chamber is not safe for this ring, Nori speaks up.
"I think we should put the ring into the leaden chest, you know the one where we keep the other dodgy stuff we have come by, it should keep it temporarily safe, until we decide what to do with it."
This is the first time he hears of such a box, but if he had something like that for dangerous things, he would not blabber about its existence to all and sundry. When the box makes an appearance, dragged in by two sturdy guards, it looks like any other metal chest, but when opened, there is an eerie green light shining out of it.
Thorin drops the ring in, the box is closed and bolted quickly. He can still feel the disquiet the ring brings out of him, but it is not actively tempting him. Apparently, Gandalf, Lord Elrond and Lady Galadriel feel something too because they start to wake up.
"What was that?"
Gandalf rummages the countless pockets of his robes, Galadriel clasps something under her dress, and Elrond looks at his finger.
"Are you wearing it like that?"
Elrond grimaces.
"It is a ring. It is best hidden among other rings. Especially as it doesn't ooze anything. Our relative at least had the grace of not forcing his soul to where it didn't belong."
Everyone opens their mouth.
“The second rule of the meeting is that if you have nothing good to say about your relatives, you don't mention them."
"I think it is rather a sub-rule, as relatives are a sub-group of everyone." Balin sounds exceptionally prim.
Thorin looks like he wants to bash or even bludgeon Balin, but probably thinks that the Elves do not need any encouragement.
He also begs to differ on the matter of relatives, they are a category outside the normal denizens of Arda. Furthermore, if his complaints about his relatives are half as annoying as all the Elvish griping about theirs, he will never mention a single one of them again in the future.
"Can someone explain what is happening in small easily understandable words and without any long-winded tales and Mahal forbid songs. Gandalf?"
The wizard takes a long draught of beer.
"There are rings, some of them are evil, some of them are good, and some are apparently not very efficient. Bilbo’s ring is obviously an evil and efficient one, because the good ones reacted that way. So, we need to figure out what to do with it."
Gandalf returns to his chicken.
"And that is all?"
"Rings of Power are not my expertise, but the Head of our Brotherhood, Saruman the White has a bee in his bonnet about them. And you wanted a short and concise explanation, and you got one, O King Thorin. There are some good poems about them, though."
“Am I right in supposing that you have some of the good rings? What do they do?”
Gandalf, Elrond, and Galadriel share a glance, and Galadriel seems to draw the short straw. “Basically, they keep things the way they are.”
“And that is a good thing?” Dear Thorin is at the end of his tether, frowning and tight-lipped.
“Well, it depends on whether you think it is a good thing.”
That was it, in a flash he understood why his mother was so keen on the Elves, they were fond of similar not-so-subtle subtle arguments. Having to deal with elf-on-elf strife, they do not need an all-out dwarf-on-elf airing of ancient grudges. So, he gallops into action like the fool he is.
“Why is it good for you then?”
“She doesn’t want to go home.” Maglor is for once matter of fact rather than combative. But Galadriel is having none of it and points to Elrond.
“He doesn’t want to leave you alone.”
“I don't want to be left alone.” Elrond is sitting straight up and seems to be mostly back to his normal self.
“What is home?” Gandalf has finished his chicken and is seeking for his pipe.
“This is not very helpful. So how do we get rid of the ring? Leaden box notwithstanding, I do not think we want to have it here.”
After Thorin nods, all dwarves in the room do the same, as does Bard.
“For that we need to find out more about it, there are many classes of evil and efficient rings, so we need to talk with Saruman about that. Yes, I know you think he is an incompetent fool with questionable taste in choosing places to live.”
“Not to forget his dithering in the Dol Guldur matter.”
“I am not forgetting it, Lord Elrond, but eventually he understood the wisdom of getting rid of the Necromancer, and this is not a Council Meeting. I can travel to Isengard and talk with him, o well, I need to drop in Gondor first, the crown prince of Rohan is getting married, and I am invited to the wedding, but I will be in Isengard before the end of the year.
"What should we do with it while we wait for Saruman's, that was the name wasn't it, judgement? Cannot we just melt it, and do something different from the gold? Or in the first case just keep the molten piece in the box until we know the proper way of disposing of it."
Gandalf doesn’t have any problem looking relaxed on the bench. It is hard even for his bottom, which is beginning to be comfortably padded again.
"Like I say, I am no expert, and indeed some evil objects lose their power when broken. Sometimes they need to be broken in a special way for them to fulfill their purpose. And sometimes becoming broken is its purpose, and it unleashes its evil on everyone at present at the moment of breaking. Even if we are not at our best behaviour now, I am certain that we do not want to see each other killed or possessed by evil, or do we?"
Everyone is shaking their head, some a bit hesitantly, and king Thranduil snores in a meaningful way.
"Some evil things cannot be destroyed at all, except in specific ways or by the hand of their maker. As we are not the makers, and don’t know about any specific tools, I suggest that the rest of you will do nothing, except of course telling nothing to anyone outside this room."
He has stretched his resolve to a breaking point already once with the dratted ring and doesn't want to do it a second time. There has to be something that can be done to keep it from pestering him and every other person except the dwarves.
“I was hasty about the box; can't the ring rot in there?"
This time it is not Gandalf pretending he is thinking and can't hear anything, but Maglor who answers.
“Having many evil things together is dangerous, they feed on each other. And if the wizard is not very fast in his movements, it could easily take months before he is back with any useful knowledge."
His tone implies that he does not believe in Gandalf doing anything hastily, but the wizard ploughs on.
"Even the rings you called inefficiently evil could do something like that. If we had Thraín's ring in the box, for example, it would definitely cause further harm there. Actually, King Thorin, you probably should do separate boxes for each object you have in the chest now."
"WHAT?"
He has not heard Thorin shout that loud since what could easily have been his last call for battle; he will take care that it indeed was Thorin's last battle.
"I guess you did not tell Thorin about the ring." Galadriel’s tone is drier than the northern wastes.
"There was so much happening at that time when I met him and the ring was not around anyway, so I forgot. Thorin, your father had inherited one of those evil but mostly inefficient rings, and it was stolen by the Necromancer."
"When you say mostly inefficient, what do you mean?" Every dwarf in the room is staring at Thorin.
"The ring seemed to make dwarves, well more dwarflike the way people think the dwarves are, more irascible and perhaps even more possessive. Not evil as such, but more prone to make decisions that start courses of action ending up badly."
Maglor sighs, and it is Elrond's turn to comfort his father. Even Lady Galadriel looks wistful and keeps her peace.
"Well, it is probably good that I did not inherit it then as I am quite capable of making bad decisions all by myself."
He wants to jump on Thorin, kiss him soaking wet, braid flowers in his hair and make a right fool of himself. His husband is both surprised and relieved at his own words.
"So, if we cannot just destroy it, and throwing it away seems a dangerous idea, what should we do? Does anyone have any ideas?"
The only idea he has is hiding it among other rings like Lord Elrond did with his ring keeping-the-world-the-same. Keeping everything the same is a curious idea for an immortal to have, one would imagine that they would eventually get bored with the same.
On the other hand, most Hobbits, who seldom live more than a hundred year don’t have any problem sitting on their ample bottoms and talking rubbish for most of that time. But no, he is not supposed to complain about his relatives ever again.
"You know the sinkers, the ones keeping fishing nets from floating on the surface. They are made of lead, we buy them from you, the little round things."
Bard has propped the still sleeping Thranduil against his side, it looks uncomfortable, but the King of Dale is animated for the first time since their meeting had begun.
"You could cast the ring into a bigger lead ball, it wouldn't harm it would it, King Thorin?"
"Not much, but we still have to keep it somewhere safe, a ball of lead is even easier to misplace than a ring."
The whole idea is of course mad, but what else has there been but madness lately.
"If we make a whole lot of them and build a work of art of them. Stick them into the wall and call it a bubbling mountain or something.”
It has been a while since everyone in the room has looked at him as if he had lost his mind. It is oddly encouraging.
"They could be decorated with gemstones and fixed to a wall in such a way that if someone tries to remove them, everyone would be alarmed."
"But why would anyone use lead and gemstones, you never set gems on lead."
"It is the contrast, combining something of little worth with something valuable. All works of art need contrast."
"Hear, hear!" Balin doesn’t even raise his eyes from the notes
As Nori the master poet is getting to be recognised as the reliable judge in matters artistic, it is decided that it sounds a reasonable course of action.
So, an order of 899 lead spheres is sent downstairs, Thorin is going to make the one with the ring inside. This time they also decide that no one should know which ball is the right one
The most popular decision of the day is to move over to have some dinner, with the decision to send the protesting Gandalf to pack for an early departure to Gondor a close second.
