Chapter Text
Bilbo disliked being proven wrong. Not that he was a terribly arrogant sort, but he’d lost count of the number of times his rationality and hobbit-ish common sense had saved the day—quite literally, in several instances.
Bilbo had firmly believed—still did, in fact—that indulging Thorin the time to dedicate to his music would bring him happiness, especially after those first couple gruelling months of rebuilding Erebor. He had only harboured a small, niggling doubt that was triggered by seeing Thorin’s eyes glow with—-no, he dare not say obsession—passion at providing musical accompaniment during that first spring wedding.
He loved watching his husband be so consumed by something that brought him true joy. He had thought that such joy would not come at the expense of the tasks of rebuilding a kingdom.
Unfortunately, Bilbo was wrong. Thorin could be afforded breaks from kinging no longer.
Bilbo huffed. This was exactly why he had asked to not be directly involved with The Intervention—yes, he heard the capitalised letters even if Balin had never written the unimaginative name of that failed operation down—or put himself forward as their Plan B—despite protests of “But your name is Bilbo, and that completely fits Plan B for Bilbo!”, squashed with “And you are called Bofur, dear friend, but I don’t see you volunteering your services!”—but rather elected to be the last resort.
In hindsight, he should have known The Intervention would run as chaotically as it did, including Thorin’s utter misunderstanding and subsequent Sunday recital. He had had more hope for Dís, but he ought to have guessed that Thorin would find a way to misconstrue his sister’s meaning as well.
No use regretting that now. Bilbo had been wrong, and now he needed to fix things.
But how to do that without breaking his heart? Bilbo wondered miserably. He sat cross-legged in his armchair, a light fur thrown over his head and blanketing his knees to ward off the mountain’s midnight spring chill.
Thorin was due back any minute. Over the past few weeks, he had taken to practising in his study near the throne room until just after midnight. Bilbo was usually in bed by then, accustomed by now to the interruption to his sleep by jostled blankets as his husband settled in with a murmured apology and a gentle kiss to his head.
That Thorin was typically gone to the day’s agenda before Bilbo, an early riser himself, awoke in the morning had been chalked up to the demands of kinging. It was only when Balin cornered him into confronting Thorin that Bilbo finally admitted to himself how much the new chaos was bothering him.
Yes, Bilbo could concede that: He was starting to personally feel the effects of Thorin’s attempt to brutally mash together the demands of a professed Musician with those of Erebor’s King.
“Bilbo? Why are you still awake?”
Bilbo started slightly, having not heard Thorin enter. “Just felt like waiting up,” he fibbed, watching Thorin tow his harp to the corner of the sitting room and gently adjust the ties on its silk cover. “How was your evening?”
Thorin hummed pleasantly, crossing over to Bilbo and pulling him up to stand. “Productive,” he said. “I have been making good progress on my composition.”
“Oh? You didn’t tell me you were writing anything.”
“It is a recent undertaking.” Thorin’s brow furrowed. “I apologise that I haven’t yet shared this with you. I’ve been meaning to bring it up, but…” He paused.
Bilbo finished the thought. “But we haven’t had much time to ourselves lately, have we?”
Thorin let out a deep breath. “Dís has been reminding me of this shortcoming. It is unfair to you.”
“Shortcoming? Dear me, you two are so melodramatic sometimes.” Bilbo hooked his hands around Thorin’s neck. “We’re together now, aren’t we?”
Common sense should have warned Bilbo that such a rhetorical question would not segue into a wholesome conversation, as he had initially planned upon Thorin’s return. One kiss became many, and standing became collapsing into bed, and only when Bilbo raced to catch his breath as Thorin peppered kisses into his collarbone did he remember that kissing needed to become talking.
“Wait, wait! Thorin, stop!” Bilbo panted.
Thorin swore, jolting up with a jerk of his shoulders. “Is something the matter?” he asked, clearly worried.
An immediate wave of regret washed over Bilbo at his husband’s genuine concern. “No!” Blast it. “Sorry, no, no! Nothing that serious.” He moved positions so that they were sitting in front of each other. “Well, perhaps it is a little serious. No! Bother, don’t make that face.”
“You’re worrying me.” Thorin stretched his hands out to gently prod at Bilbo’s neck. “Have I hurt you?”
“No, I promise you haven’t, oh, bother Thorin, that tickles!” Bilbo grabbed Thorin’s hands, making him stop. He took a deep breath. “We need to have a talk.”
The dwarf frowned. “A talk?”
“Yes,” said Bilbo, cringing. “I’m sorry I have to bring it up now, but there really isn’t a fantastic time to have this conversation. It’s just… something I really need to talk about.”
“Whatever the cause of your worry, ghivashel, I am here to listen and help in whatever way I can.” Thorin freed a hand to stroke Bilbo’s cheek. “I would have you speak plainly to me, as always.”
“That’s why I’m worried.” Bilbo gulped. “We need to talk about you.”
The hand on his cheek stilled. “What about me?”
Bilbo took another great inhale. “We need to address your musicianship, love. I know how dedicated you are to it, but we still need your full commitment to other duties. Your duties as King, as role model for the boys…” He trailed off, before he could add and as husband to that list and let his own selfishness mar the earnest moment. “Erebor needs you totally present again, Thorin, as her leader.”
“Neglected… that is what Dís said, the other day.” Thorin made an odd, aborted movement of hands. “Is that how you feel?”
“It’s how everyone has felt, Thorin.”
“But the lessons? Dís assured me that she was enjoying those, and the citizens have greatly benefited from learning what basics they could since I’ve opened those up.” The frown on Thorin’s face deepened. “It’s not enough, is it? They still feel neglected.”
“No! I mean, no, that’s not it, Thorin, I have it on personal authority that your lessons are immensely popular.” Bilbo stifled a groan, remembering when Bombur cornered him just yesterday, asking why his kitchen staff were disappearing mid-meal preparation times, coming back waxing poetic about the new scales they’ve learned and why is His Majesty insisting on draining the kitchens of not just food, but helping hands as well?! “Too popular, it would seem.”
“I must… increase their number, then?”
“No! That is not what I meant about you being more fully present!” Bilbo yelped. Feeling antsy all of a sudden, he clambered off the bed and started to pace back and forth.
No use beating around it. Better to be direct then. “Thorin, my love. You simply do not have enough hours in the day to achieve mastery of the harp, even if by my own, perhaps untrained ear, you play well enough to leave anyone with the slightest appreciation for music slack-jawed. No, the fact of this matter is that you are the bloody King Under the Mountain, and not one year ago I remember trailing behind your daft ass in the wilderness as you went on and on about how there would be endless tasks to complete once you reclaimed Erebor and began her restoration.”
Bilbo’s pace was quickening alongside his words. “But now, now, Thorin, it seems the only tasks you are willing to complete have to do with your music. I know Balin manages your agenda and acts as secretary for your council, but all your requests to change things or rearrange meetings amount to no small matter, not at the rate you compel them from him. Dear old Balin broke a guard’s axe in frustration the other day, can you believe that? Every rearrangement of your schedule has repercussions, Thorin. Ha! And the rest of the Company that helped you reclaim Erebor has had more than a rough go of trying to pick up the pieces. A mighty rough go of it!”
He knew he should slow down, stop even, but a part of couldn’t bear to see what Thorin’s face would look like now. The other half suddenly couldn’t stop the barrage of words from tumbling out. “Your approval of trading orders is backlogged by at least three weeks, and the kitchens and bloody infirmary cannot continue functioning with the just-in-time resource allocation that your approval delay has been causing. Our guards are near zombies with how little sleep they’ve been getting, ever since Dwalin had to rearrange for your new training schedules. And, ah, have you spoken to either Fíli or Kíli lately? Oh, who am I kidding, of course not, none of us have with how bone-weary they’ve grown from trying to step into your gargantuan boots much too early! It is, why….I swear it is as if…”
Bilbo sighed then, staring at the carpet on the floor. “It is as if you no longer care about what is happening around Erebor, which I know is not true. That is not you, but we can’t keep running the kingdom as if it is. So we need to decide what to do.” With a long exhale, he finally looked at Thorin.
And oh but he should have known that having this conversation, having Thorin listen to Bilbo of all people break the news so directly like this, would break his heart.
The look on Thorin’s face was crestfallen, but most of all it was disappointed—and Bilbo knew that Thorin was disappointed in himself.
Bilbo threw all caution out the door and crowded into Thorin’s space once again, coming to a kneeling position on the bedspread in front of the dwarf. “Thorin? I’m sorry, Thorin, I didn’t mean for it all to come out like that,” he pattered. “I’m only saying this out of love, Thorin—my own, and that of everyone else in the Company.”
At that, Thorin met his gaze distantly. “The Company? That day in the Dining Hall…”
Bilbo unsuccessfully suppressed a snort. “Yes, if you recall, they were trying to bring up the same points, even if it turned less tactful than planned.” He winced, remembering the pitcher of juice that was knocked into Balin’s face; the advisor had looked as if he had emerged from battle with a blood-stained beard, though the only casualties that day were a load of breakfast scones, much to Bilbo’s annoyance.
“They were only asking for appreciation, though,” Thorin said questioningly.
Bilbo winced. “I didn’t write the script.”
“Aye, but the following day, I called that assembly…” Pink flooded Thorin’s cheeks. “They wouldn’t have seen it as a display of appreciation at all. Mahal, what they must have thought of me, to be so ignorant—”
Bilbo cut Thorin off before he could self-flagellate more. “Thorin, do not go down that rabbit hole,” he chided. “It was a lovely performance no matter what. Why! If I recall, I heard nothing but enraptured praise from the audience that entire afternoon, and the week following!”
Thorin perked up at those last words, and suddenly, it all hit Bilbo with the force of dragonfire. That’s just it, isn’t it? he mused, heart aching. My great love, my dear sweet dwarf… “Thorin,” Bilbo began, before the dwarf could say anything further, “save for myself, the Company, and your sister, has anyone raised the matter of your music to you? In a… negative way?”
“No,” Thorin replied, meeting Bilbo’s eyes squarely. “I have never received any complaints.”
Bilbo felt his nose twitch uncomfortably, feeling as if he deserved that subtle jab. “We are not complaining about your music, love, only about the time it takes away from your duties as King. And I suppose that if the kingdom has only shown admiration for your talents, well, it was in your best interest to indulge them, yes?”
“These halls once sang with music at every turn,” Thorin said in reply, “horns trilling, drums beating, fiddles chorusing with the sounds of merriment that rejoiced every day in the splendour of this kingdom.” He sighed wistfully, and to Bilbo it sounded like the resignation of an aged ruler far beyond Thorin’s years. “I had hoped that I was reigniting those celebrations of prosperity once more, meagre though my attempts were as one sole harpist.”
“That is a noble goal,” Bilbo put in, “and quite an ambitious one, at that. That is why you have your council, Thorin,” he paused, then added, “why you have me, to listen and to help you realise such grand plans if you believe them to be pivotal to restoring Erebor to her former glory.”
“Ghivashel,” Thorin whispered, reaching to tuck an errant curl behind Bilbo’s ear. His hand stoked down his cheek gently. “I have neglected you as well, haven’t I?”
Bilbo bit his lip. “I will not lie and say I’ve enjoyed spending time apart as you increase your hours for harp practice and lessen your time for, erm, other activities that require your particular dexterity,” he said, aiming for a touch of playfulness that was met by a light chuckle from Thorin. “But besides that, I do wish you had told me about wanting to breathe music back into the kingdom. Isn’t that what I’m here for?”
Thorin inclined his head slightly. “Aye, it is,” he breathed. “Perhaps I had thought you to be uninterested in such affairs.”
“Uninterested!” Bilbo scoffed, batting away Thorin’s hand in mock sarcasm. “You forget how much hobbits love their music as well!”
“Dwarven music is different from that of hobbits.”
“But no less central to our culture!”
Thorin heaved a great sigh. “You are correct as always, my heart.” He nodded once before sitting up straighter. “Then it is decided.”
Bilbo cocked his head, confused. “What now?”
“It is as you described. If I continue pursuing the harp in earnest, then Erebor suffers, which is the last thing I had ever intended to come out of my music. I cannot fail this kingdom again.”
“Again?” Bilbo shook his head, unwilling to stir up memories of their first days in Erebor, but seeing no way to avoid it. “Thorin, that was in the past, and we’ve gone over this endlessly but you were not yourself.”
“No. I was obsessed,” Thorin hissed the word out coldly, “and it clouded all hope of my judging what is best for this kingdom. If things are as you say, then I fear a similar compulsion has taken hold, though it is my music this time which afflicts me.” He levelled Bilbo with an intent gaze. “As of tomorrow, my days with the harp are behind me.”
Bilbo held his husband’s look steadily, hating that this discussion was coming to a bittersweet end. Would the chaos end and daily routines return to normal? Yes.
Would Thorin lose a real, genuine outlet for happiness that—even Balin could be convinced to admit—had the undisputed effect of enlivening Erebor’s spirits? Also yes, absolutely.
Bilbo reached for Thorin’s hair to curl it around his finger, a movement he knew endeared his husband to no end. “You silly, impassioned dwarf,” he tutted. “We cannot have you cut something you love so completely out of your life.”
Thorin was watching the end of his hair coil around Bilbo’s finger amusedly. “I admire your sympathy, ghivashel, but I fear that it must be done if I am to avoid taking on my duties in half measures.”
Bilbo shook his head. “Do you trust me?” he asked.
“With my life.”
“Well, this is nothing so dramatic as that, love. First, I’ll just need your help sending some letters tomorrow.”
That ravens were such efficient emissaries never ceased to amaze Bilbo. He broke off another chunk of the bread in his pocket and fed it to the bird settling in to roost after its long journey. Thinking the raven was owed more for the spot of good news it bore, Bilbo tossed the whole loaf in its nest before happily bounding back to the mountain.
It had only been three days since Bilbo suggested to Thorin that they write to Ered Luin and formally request that any Musicians come and live in Erebor: They would be incentivised by the proclamation of a new Musicians guild upon their arrival, with the first apprentices plucked from among the pool of Thorin’s early students. The raven had carried with it several messages from Musicians accepting the offer, and Bilbo’s heart swelled with fondness from thinking about how Thorin would love the news.
Bilbo raced through the halls and, on a wild guess, burst into the council chambers, sighing in relief at seeing Thorin standing there, with Balin at his side. “Bilbo?” his husband asked, whatever he had been discussing momentarily forgotten. “Is something wrong?”
“No! Everything is fan-tastic!” Bilbo gasped. He strode up to the two dwarrow and grasped their shoulders tightly. “I have news from Ered Luin.”
Naturally, once word was spread around the mountain, Bilbo was approached by several dwarrow who had come to Erebor in earlier caravans and were, in fact, Musicians themselves. They had been itching for public rehearsal and performance opportunities and had even drafted a request to begin their guild and train others in their craft, but Thorin’s lessons and enthusiasm in playing around the mountain served as complicated deterrents.
When he brought the matter up at council, he was startled by a sharp bark of laughter from Balin. “Aye, if only they knew how truly complicated it was!” he cried.
The other lords on the council seemed to shift uneasily at the lack of decorum from the usually stoic advisor, but from his seat at the head of the table, Thorin only joined in the laughter. “Indeed, it seems that Mahal has eluded all his musically-inclined children from the ability to make rational conclusions!”
Mood lightened and Balin undeniably cheered up, plans were made for the Musicians guild to be formed the very next morning.
Bilbo only had one request more to make of the advisor. When he broached the topic at the next day’s breakfast, he was surprised to see Balin acquiesce so easily. “A very good morning this is!” the dwarf chirped happily, as even the ends of his beard seemed to curl up in glee.
Bilbo toasted with his breakfast scone. “Thank you! I daresay we have finally found ourselves a compromise for our dear Thorin.”
The compromise was arranged more easily and accepted more readily than Bilbo had bargained for: With the Musicians guild running full-time, Thorin’s many hours of private lessons were opened and taken over by the guildmasters. Still eager to participate in his kingdom’s education, Balin arranged for a bi-weekly evening King’s Class—it only took a couple-back-and-forths to convince Thorin that calling it a Masterclass would incorrectly describe his station, not to mention undermine those who had actually achieved mastery in the guild—wherein students could assemble for a group lesson with Thorin.
The Musicians guild also took responsibility for the bevy of future performances and accompaniment jobs that Thorin had lined up previously. It freed up nearly a half-day’s schedule each day for the foreseeable weeks of spring between handing off the commitments plus their rehearsal times.
Bilbo saw Thorin fretting at first upon realising this, but he was instantly cheered when Balin pencilled in time for Thorin to spend with the Musicians guild—either in performance or rehearsal—every two or three days.
“What did I tell you about trusting me?” Bilbo teased during the first time he and Thorin walked together to a guild rehearsal.
“It was pure luck that Musicians had already moved here. The Ered Luin caravan is still weeks away.” Thorin arched an eyebrow. “Come to think of it, didn’t Dis say you were responsible for welcoming in all new citizens?”
“I cannot presume to read minds! If they chose to withhold their profession from fear of stealing away your grandeur, how would I have known!” Bilbo chided, swatting Thorin softly. They had reached the guild entrance, and muffled tuning notes could be heard from within. He gestured towards the door and stood on tiptoe to plant a soft kiss on his husband’s cheek. “Now go on, before they think twice about letting you in!”
Not long afterwards, the compromised schedule saw its effects trickling through the mountain to the rest of the Company as well. And yes, Bilbo could wholeheartedly admit that included his own self.
Less chaotic schedule scrambles meant better, deeper sleeps where both he and Thorin could wake in the morning together, fully rested. If better sleeps also meant more energy to start the day with a quick tumble in the sheets, well, Bilbo was hardly one to complain.
“Off to the arena, then?” Bilbo asked, after rolling off his husband on one such morning.
“Aye,” Thorin assented, moving to stand and shuck a tunic on. “Dwalin will have my head if I am late again.”
Dwalin, actually, had been in a more chipper mood since Thorin started sparring with him first thing in the morning once more, regardless of whether or not their early bedroom activities caused their practice to start a few minutes later.
“There ain’t no axe being lobbed at my skull anymore, that’s for sure!” the guard laughed when Bilbo sheepishly apologised for making Thorin late that morning. “I’ll be honest with you—-keep it up! Keeps the old boy’s stamina spiked and ready for battle!”
“I, er, thank you, Dwalin,” Bilbo stammered in reply.
Glóin was similarly enthusiastic in his thanks to Bilbo. A late dinner feast saw long hours of dancing well into the night, and Glóin twirled his wife endlessly across the dance floor, raucous laughter booming and shouting for Thorin to get yer ‘arp and join the Musicians already!
“She’s been sleeping well again, is what it is,” Óin hollered at Bilbo over the swelling music. “No more buggering about her nighttime draughts.”
“Your stores are full once again, I take it?” Bilbo asked, clapping his hands to the horn tune Thorin had picked up.
“Full? Near bursting!” Óin threw his mug in the air with a joyous shout. “Bring on the plagues!”
Bilbo decided the healer had quite enough to drink after that and sent him off with an aide and a stern instruction to begin brewing the famous recovery tea at once.
Bombur had a much less morbid attitude to his fully restocked kitchens. “I almost can’t keep up with the wagons that come in each day!” he told Bilbo when the hobbit stopped by.
“Our stomachs have no complaints, I assure you!” Bilbo chuckled.
“Thorin’s been negotiating extra trades, too, it looks like.”
“Ah, yes, that was at my particular urging! We can’t miss out on those peak spring harvests.”
“Ha! Trust a hobbit to have the foresight to plan for the rest of our season’s desserts!”
Well, Bilbo could concede that. Whenever Thorin now scheduled late night practice, he set up in their private quarters. And Bilbo would be lying if he said feeding Thorin strawberries as a reward for getting a particular section right wasn’t downright magnificent.
A slightly less brilliant side effect was that Thorin began returning borrowed scores to the Musicians guild with the odd drop of fruit juice speckled throughout. Bilbo levelled his husband with a bemused expression when he recounted the flustered Master who had a difficult time scolding his King for the blemishes.
“Then I am quite lucky that they moved all the music to their own library!” Ori said when he heard. “It has been quite peaceful without His Majesty tromping around, let alone squirting strawberry juice everywhere!”
Of course, Nori couldn’t help butting in. “Oi, Bilbo, what you and Thorin get up to squirting about in the bedroom ain’t very polite dinner table conversation.”
“What is this about the royal bedchambers?” Dori joined them, half-hidden behind a pile of heavy-looking fabric rolls.
Bilbo rolled his eyes, aiming to move beyond this conversation. “What have you got there, Dori?” he asked.
“Ah! For the commission to decorate the end of month’s feast!” Dori exclaimed proudly, batting away Nori’s curious hands.
Bilbo gasped in delight. “Oh! How quickly those have arrived!”
“All thanks to His Majesty, really. He found it more efficient to have me join his last meeting with the textile traders!” Dori leaned in. “I say, you’ve really worked a marvel with his new schedule. He’s almost more agreeable now he knows the value of leisure!”
Ori nodded enthusiastically. “Everyone’s been saying it!”
Bilbo tutted away the honorific. “Only ever helping us all find our happiness,” he chuckled.
Everyone, though, had been saying it. Even the very youngest in the mountain felt the effects of the change.
“These,” said Bofur, “are selling like wildfire.” He slapped a small figurine on the table.
Bilbo gaped at the toy. It was a carving of Thorin, seated with his hands outstretched as if holding something. “Where—” he began.
“This comes separately!” Bofur declared. He pulled out a miniature harp carving and fitted into the Thorin-figurine’s hands perfectly. “Initially they were sold as one piece, but they got so darn popular that we couldn’t resist splitting them up!”
“Swindling poor dwarflings!” Bilbo scoffed, still slightly bewildered at the unexpected merchandising of his husband.
Bifur grunted in Khuzdul, which Bofur translated happily: “We don’t profit that much, mind.” He patted Bilbo on the shoulder. “When we asked Thorin if he’d mind the carvings, he told us he wouldn’t, so long as a portion of the sales go to funding young’uns’s lessons at the Musicians guild.”
“Did he indeed!”
Unsurprisingly, the most vocal about their delight with the compromised schedule were Fíli and Kíli. So vocal, in fact, that the month’s end feast saw the boys calling for silence throughout the entire Dining Hall after dinner was cleared.
“A toast!” Fíli exclaimed. “To our dear Uncle, for shepherding eras of music back to Erebor once more!”
“And,” Kíli cried out, “a toast as well to our beloved royal Consort, for making sure he didn’t destroy the Mountain in the process!”
A loud cheer from all dwarrow gathered in the hall went up then. Thorin was shaking his head resignedly from beside Bilbo. “They’re not busy enough anymore,” he muttered under the noise.
“Oh, hush,” Bilbo replied. “Best let them get up to trouble without any major repercussions. Cheers, love!”
One of the greatest perks of having a thriving Musicians guild meant that Bilbo could dance with Thorin as much as their tiring legs would allow them. If Fíli was correct, Thorin’s unanticipated interludes from kinging were a very small price to pay for an Erebor bursting with song and life for generations to come.
As Bilbo and Thorin took a dancing break and joined their family and friends at the side of the hall, Dís raised her voice to them. “Thorin! Why don’t you join the Musicians for a number or two?”
“Not tonight, I’m afraid,” Thorin answered, stretching out an arm to tuck Bilbo into his side. “Tonight, I am here to simply enjoy their songs.”
“Why not try out that piece you’ve been writing?” said Dís, a mischievous look flitting across her face.
Bilbo felt Thorin stiffen. “You know as well as I do that this is not the occasion for it.”
Dís grinned. “Does he know, though?” She winked at Bilbo before waltzing away to join the rest of the party.
In Dís’s absence, the few members of the Company who weren’t dancing and were gathered around them looked at Thorin in astonishment. “Lad, you haven’t told him?” Balin asked.
At Thorin’s flustered look, they all sighed heavily. “Figures,” Dwalin groused.
“Thorin?” Bilbo poked his husband in the side. “What are they talking about?”
Thorin glowered at their friends for a moment before relaxing, turning to look Bilbo in the eye. “That piece I am composing… I mean to have it played at our wedding ceremony.”
Bilbo felt his eyebrows shoot to his hairline. “Wedding ceremony? But, no! We agreed we would wait until the mountain is thriving once again.”
Thorin cleared his throat. “Look around you, ghivashel. Would you not say that it is?”
And how could Bilbo argue with that?
Beaming, Bilbo grasped his husband’s hand tight. “When do I get to hear it?”
“Ah, well, I haven’t had much time to run it through with the chamber ensemble,” Thorin mused, “but they have the music.”
Bilbo turned to Balin, excitement and nerves and impatience waving off all previous concerns about too many accommodations from the old advisor. “Balin, is there any way to fit some time in this week for the ensemble to play for Thorin and me?”
Balin smiled fondly. “I’m sure that can be arranged.”
