Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Category:
Fandom:
Relationship:
Characters:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Series:
Part 1 of Scales
Collections:
Stranger Things Mermay 2025
Stats:
Published:
2025-05-13
Words:
2,050
Chapters:
1/1
Kudos:
43
Hits:
0

Midnight blue

Summary:

Steve can't forget about the legend about mermaids, it's even following him into his dreams, causing him to have the worst nightmare. Will he ever know the truth about Billy or will he have to let it go for good? (A part 2 to 'One last swim'

Notes:

An unexpected part two for "One last Swim"
For the Stranger Things Mermay 2025 Bingo! Here I used the prompts: Eldritch, Hunt, Aquarium, Merrow, Naiads and Hermaphrodite + the prompts I used it part one already. I hope you like it! =)

Work Text:

 

***

 

Steve was running to the ocean. It wasn’t a beautiful night as most of the nights at the resort. It was cold and stormy and the moon was only a vague idea behind thick layers of dramatic clouds, blocking the view to the stars Billy loved so much.

Footprints in the sand were leading to the shore, but no one was there. Steve was running faster.
Hard gusts of wind, slapping his face, mixed with his biggest fear growing bigger, caused him to tear up.

“BILLY”, he yelled against the wind, but it swallowed up his voice.

“Please don’t.. please don’t leave me..” Steve whined and dropped on his knees where the waves hit the sand and buried his fists in the muddy mix, feeling little stones and shells cutting his fingers. It didn’t hurt as much as the thought of everything he had heard to be true and knowing that Billy decided against him and for the ocean, his home.. Of course he decided to return home..
Steve sobbed quietly, remaining like that until the storm faded and the sea calmed down and the sun started to rise far in the distance.
It was Billy’s favorite time of the day. It was his favorite wonder to witness and he wasn’t here.

Steve’s body ached when he forced himself back on his feet. He was crouching in the cold for hours, he was cold and the warm sunlight wouldn’t change that. Nothing won’t ever change that. Billy was gone. He would never see him again, never hear his voice again… never fall asleep in his warm embrace and wake up to a crumpled sheet, but knowing for sure where to find him..

Steve stayed at the resort for the rest of the summer. Though he knew that Billy was gone, he couldn’t get closure because he just vanished. He didn’t see him go, he never said good-bye, he was just gone and it felt unreal.
Steve spent the days working his shifts at the pool bar and the nights, he went to the little hidden bay, where they met for the first time and all through their first summer. He was sitting on that same little rock every night, having a smoke, with his feet dangling in the water. Sometimes, something rushed by, gently touching his legs and he imagined it was Billy, because it felt familiar.

No one at the resort ever asked where Billy was. It was like everyone knew, but no one said a word.
Like Billy had never been never part of the team or even part of this world. Maybe their memories of him had vanished with him? Just the idea he could wake up one day and the memory of Billy and their time together was just erased from his mind scared him so much, it made him feel sick.

Maybe it was supposed to be like that. If humans knew for sure mermaids existed, they would hunt them down, right? Abuse them for science, put them into an aquarium for their own entertainment..
They would probably build a whole theme park with captured creatures from the sea, from lakes, rivers and waterfalls… Steve had done some research after he felt something was different about Billy for the first time and read stories about the Merrows from Irish folklore, but Billy never wore a hat to walk with him, so he ruled that out. There were Naiads, but Billy was only connected to the ocean, so he wasn’t looking further into that direction, but the theme park… It would have whole sections with sea-folks from all over the world. All myths were most certainly true and they all would have a miserable life and humans would breed them and sell them to private homes of bored billionaires… Steve felt sick by that thought.
Maybe it was a memory only to be kept by people who fell in love with a sea creature and would never hurt them or their kind. That’s how the stories stayed stories and no one would ever know the truth.

When Steve packed his stuff on his final day, he knew it was for the last time. There wouldn’t be a next summer. There would be no seeing Billy again. Billy was gone. He was with the ocean again and for all time. Steve would take the memory of him and keep it in his heart forever. Coming back here would hurt too much. The connection was too strong here and feeling that while knowing he would never actually see Billy again was killing him inside.

He left his luggage at the reception and went to the cafeteria to have breakfast for the last time. The crew knew him well and friendly faces greeted him all along the way.

“Steve! Have a seat!” It was a familiar waiter called Phillip who greeted him. “Your order will come in a minute!” he announced and Steve frowned a little because he hadn’t ordered anything yet, but it also wasn’t unusual that he got something special as a good bye gift, so he sat down and his food came right away.

Steve stared at his plate in horror, because the plate stared back at him. Eyes so familiar, he would recognize them always and forever. The grilled fish on the plate opened it’s mouth and said:

Steve jolted up with a scream. He was sweaty and shaking and breathing heavily.

“Holy shit, Steve… what the hell..” Billy groaned next to him, but came to his senses quickly, when he realized the state his boyfriend was in.

“Hey..” he said softly and the moment Steve looked at him he started to sob. “Shit.. Stevie-babe, what happened?” Billy asked softly and wrapped his arms around the trembling, hiccuping mess.

“Shhh, it’s okay.. it was just a dream..” Billy whispered, assuming Steve must have had a terrible nightmare and rocked him gently in his arms, continuing to whisper sweet nothings into his ear until he finally calmed down.

“Billy..” Steve said in a whimper and Billy wiped his tears away. “That bad?” he asked and Steve shook his head. “Worse..”

“You wanna tell me?” Billy pushed a strand of hair out of Steve’s face, noticing he couldn’t even look him into the eyes.

“You remember your birthday?” Steve asked after he collected himself a little, his voice hoarse and still a little shaky.

“Would be weird if I wouldn’t.” Billy joked to ease up the situation but it wasn’t working, Steve was still a complete mess.

“That story about mermaids.. I dreamed that I woke up at the resort and you were gone, but it was stormy outside and you would never go out in a storm, so I ran to the beach, following your footprints in the sand, but you just vanished and I knew you left me. I just knew it.. You were gone… I stayed at the resort and … at the last day, I got breakfast and…”

Tears started to roll down Steve’s cheeks again, but Billy quickly kissed them away. He loved the salty taste, but he didn’t love to see Steve hurting over a stupid dream. “And what?” he asked and leaned his forehead against Steve’s, eyes closed.

“I.. can’t say.” Steve stuttered because it was too horrible and fresh of a memory.

“What? What did you get for breakfast?”

“A grilled fish…” Steve needed a moment to get the next part out, “and it had your eyes.. and I woke up before it spoke but I swear it was about to say Steeeeve..”

It was quiet for a moment, only Steve’s little sniffing disturbed the silence until Billy burst into laughter.
Steve couldn’t laugh first but then he realized how stupid that all sounded, causing a soft chuckle to escape his throat and he wiped over his nose.

“That story really messed you up, huh?” Billy scoffed affectionately after he had calmed down and ruffled through Steve’s hair.

“It was awful. I think they only managed to catch you because you still came to meet me at our spot… in fish form.. I killed you..”

“Hey. Look at me.” Billy ordered and Steve looked up hesitatingly.

“I’m right here. Okay. I’m not a fish and I won’t turn into one. No one’s gonna hunt me or cook me into a breakfast dish and most important thing of all, I won’t leave you. Ever. Okay? Can we go back to sleep now?” he asked, followed by a little kiss, but Steve still didn’t look happy.

“So you really were..” he asked slowly because Billy had never confirmed or denied that he was in fact a creature from the sea and that the fairytale was true.

“I’m a human and I am tired.” Billy said as a matter of fact and sank back into the mattress but opened his arms so Steve could snuggle up.

“You can’t say it, right? To protect the merfolk from being hunted down and thrown into a theme park.”

“Babe, your imagination is wild, but I still love you.” Billy mumbled into his boyfriend’s mess of hair and closed his eyes.

“Don’t make fun of me.” Steve whispered and Billy sighed.

“What would change if I said I was or I wasn’t? It doesn’t matter what I say because you already made up your mind, haven’t you?”

“But I would have so many questions…” Steve whispered and drew little circles on Billy’s chest.

“Like what?”

“Like what you looked like… Would you transform into one of those creepy creatures from some myths and the scary stories or just look like in the movie… the cartoon, you know. Is your body working more like a human or a fish? Are you even male or female or both or like a seahorse? What color were your scales.. stuff like that.”

“I’d look like whatever you would want me to look like, it’s your fantasy.” Billy said, ignoring all the other questions and Steve rolled his eyes.

“Why can’t you just tell me.. You know I would never tell. I just want to know for sure, Billy.. I want to know if I’m losing my mind or if I’m dating a mermaid. It’s a man’s dream.”

Billy snorted because Steve was so cute, but he knew he also had to take him seriously, because he was in fact dead serious.

“You’re losing your mind if you don’t stop thinking about this.” he said softly, kissed his temple and pulled him closer. “If you let me sleep now, I draw you a picture in the morning.” he promised halfheartedly and Steve frowned with a little pout. “You just say that so I leave you alone.”

“That’s correct.”

Steve sighed and closed his eyes, asking himself if it was really that important. Billy was here with him, that was all that mattered. He must have had reasons to not be able to tell Steve and maybe he would have to let it go. Like Billy had to let go of the ocean and his old life. He opened his mouth to tell Billy he won’t ask again, but Billy broke the silence first.

“Midnight blue.”

Steve fell silent before he could even say a word. It was all Billy said and it was all Steve needed to know. He needed a moment to process the information and let it sink. He had been right all the time, so he shouldn’t be surprised, but have it confirmed still hit him and left him terrified for a split second, followed by a big rush of relief. He finally could stop wondering and nothing would change. Billy was Billy and he was his. After five years of spending their summers together, Billy made his choice. What he would give to just have seen it once. Just one time, seeing Billy dash through the water in his true form, to burn it into his memory forever, before he gave it all up for him. He blinked away a tear and Billy caught it with his lips. It tasted like the ocean and it made him smile.

“You still going to draw me a picture, right?” he whispered sleepily against Billy’s neck, when he snuggled up closer and closed his eyes again.

“Good night, Steve.”

 

***The End***

 

Series this work belongs to: