Preface

variations
Posted originally on the Archive of Kristin at https://aok.janreinhardt.me/works/651.

Rating:
Teen And Up Audiences
Archive Warning:
No Archive Warnings Apply
Category:
M/M
Fandom:
The Hobbit - All Media Types
Relationship:
Bilbo Baggins/Thorin Oakenshield
Characters:
Fíli (Tolkien), Kíli (Tolkien), Bofur (Tolkien), Bombur (Tolkien), Bifur (Tolkien), Balin (Tolkien), Dwalin (Tolkien), Ori (Tolkien), Nori (Tolkien), Dori (Tolkien), Glóin (Tolkien), Óin (Tolkien)
Additional Tags:
Erebor Dwarves (Tolkien), Snowed In, Mutual Pining, Reclaiming a mountain is hard work, Self-Acceptance, Found Family, losing yourself and then finding yourself along the way, Cold Weather, Survival
Language:
English
Collections:
BBC Midwinter Gift Exchange 2025
Stats:
Published: 2025-12-04 Words: 24,100 Chapters: 4/4

variations

Summary

It is the turning point in the year, Erebor is trapped by an unrelenting snow and within the mountain, the dwarves have to survive the bitter season any way they can. Bilbo is determined to help them, and not just because it is a good distraction from his own thoughts.

Chapter 1: quartet 1

Bilbo had been certain he would return to the Shire for the winter.

Not that first winter, of course: the battle had taken place in those last tremulous days of autumn, and only the desperate would have fled across the Misty Mountains again in the early days of the shortest season, even if the mountains had been emptied of goblins by the battle. Besides, Thorin and his nephews had been unconscious, their injuries from the battle so severe that they lay for months unmoving, sustained only by broth and water. Kili had woken first, around Yuletide, but his brother had followed only a few days later, as if unwilling to leave each other alone. Thorin, though, would take another six weeks, and Bilbo could not have brought himself to leave without speaking to the King Under the Mountain once again, not after the last time they had spoken and everything that had gone wrong between them.

It had been a mild enough winter, by the standards of the region. Bilbo had spent a lot of it in the ruins of Dale, helping Balin with negotiating a number of complex treaties with the people of Laketown and the elves, who remained a strange but necessary ally. Dain had left a garrison of dwarves to support Thorin’s Company in holding the mountain, but it would have been folly to attempt to clear the ancient city of Erebor proper before the first caravans arrived from the Blue Mountains in the spring, so the Company had taken a house inside the mountain but near the gates of Erebor, one that had remained relatively intact despite the passage of both time and dragon.

It had been survival mode: bedrolls, strict rations, small fires, and long, desperate nights staring at Thorin’s unconscious face, trying not to invent movement from the flicker of firelight shadows across the planes of his bones. The time had passed, and before any of them knew it the crocuses were blooming on the mountainside, and the ravens were building their spring nests in every available crevice in the rock. One morning, Bilbo had looked out the window and realised that spring had arrived, and he did not know who he was anymore.

Bilbo Baggins of the Shire would not know the creature he had become, the hardy soul with calluses on his hands and scars across a body that had been cut leaner than ever before. He would not have known this hobbit with dirt under his nails and hair grown too long, often found with braids in it courtesy of the dwarves with whom he kept company, who broke bread with him and who he understood perhaps better than any of his many exhausting relatives. 

Bilbo Baggins of the Shire had been lost: some strange ghost of who he was walked now in his place, confused and tired.

Even when the first caravan was delayed, Bilbo had been certain his time in Erebor would soon come to an end. That first mild winter led to a torrential spring, the paths through the mountains flooding and impassible for the heavy caravans full of dwarves and supplies. There was no real development within the Lonely Mountain: they cleared some houses, prepared barracks ready to house the first colony of dwarves, and began the laborious process of shifting colossal amounts of rubble and debris, aided by the men of Dale in exchange for the future labour of the incoming dwarves in rebuilding Dale. Bilbo had been surprised to learn that he had a head for both politics and speculative negotiation, though he supposed long years spent navigating the complexities of the Shire’s social landscape had helped. The stone was sorted and piled, ready to be used for rebuilding, but the work was slow. Some days it felt like every shovel unearthed bones of those lost to the original desolation of Smaug, and each was removed with great care to be interred in the great crypts below the city, once the entrance to them was uncovered. In the interim, they sat in boxes, carefully scavenged or made from leftover timber. Onto each Bilbo placed a flower, until the rooms they stored them in smelled like meadows, and he found himself weeping for people he had never met and would never know.

Then Thorin woke, and with him came a renewed sense of hope: they had survived their first winter, their Company was complete, and a future in the mountain felt suddenly possible.

Time passed: the first caravan finally arrived in the earliest days of the summer, four months late. Their numbers grew, but then Dain’s garrisons returned to the Iron Mountains, and suddenly their numbers felt small again. Bilbo started to pack his things: things in the mountain were stable enough, and this would be a good time to leave, before the turning of the year.

Another caravan was due to arrive in the autumn, but word reached them that they had been trapped by a series of landslides, rocks laid loose by the flooding of the spring. A group of dwarves from the first caravan set off to try and free them, and once again, the mountain felt cavernously empty. Several hundred dwarves sounded like a lot, but the more dwarves there were, the larger Bilbo started to realise the mountain was: not a village, or even a town like Michel Delving, but a city in truth, the kind he had only ever read stories about.

Big, and echoing, and unfamiliar. No place for a proper Hobbit, Bilbo told himself. And he was still a proper Hobbit, wasn’t he? He still longed for handkerchiefs and a teapot, and a good quality apron. He still felt the call of growth and soil and the whisper of summer breezes in his bones. Sure, other parts of him ached for things he did not dare to name, but there had to be a way back to the creature he had been before. And as for that other stuff, well, it was best not to think of that kind of thing.

Even then, at the tail end of the summer, Bilbo had thought he would still have time to return to the Shire. He was counting on it, in fact: surely then he would finally begin to feel like himself again, would rediscover the Bilbo he had once been, and everything unsettled inside himself would once again make sense. He had planned to go with the party returning back to the Blue Mountains in the summer, to shore up the route for the next caravan – but then Balin and Bofur had come to him with all manner of thigns they needed his help with, and Fili and Kili had said that he simply had to stay for the next feast day, and Thorin had stared at him with such a strange and desolate expression when he had talked of leaving despite saying nothing at all, so he had delayed.

He had chosen to stay a little longer despite the quiet fear building within himself: it didn't need to be much longer. Another month or two, perhaps. They needed his advice, he reassured himself – Thorin had told him many times how vital his contributions were to the trade agreements being drafted, to the positive relationships being built between the elves, men and the dwarves. Yes, autumn wasn’t the best season to travel, but surely there would be time. They had travelled here at a similar point in the year, after all. If he left early enough, before the weather turned, it would be fine. The second caravan would arrive, and another group would go back to aid the third, a constant shuffling of dwarves across the realms of the world, a great migration that would carry Bilbo along like a piece of driftwood in a flooded river, moving quickly enough not to have to think about what he was doing, or why he was doing it.

In his mind, he would reach the Shire just in time to air his house out before the worst of the season set in. He would make the evergreen wreath for his door that had hung there every winter since his father had first built it in an act of devotion so lingering that Bilbo could feel it in the doorframes, the windowsills, the mantlepieces. He would walk those familiar floors once more and burn dried sage at each window to keep the spirits of the season at bay, and trim the candles left from the previous year so he could keep all rooms lit and shadows at bay. He would stain his fingertips with holly berries and spread the colour of them on cards to send to kindly neighbours and distant relatives. He would collect fallen branches from pine trees in the grove where he had buried a lock of his mother’s hair, and make a crown of it, and wear it to all the celebrations.

The clean resinous scent of the needles would flood his nose at every turn, and the sharpness of them against his skin would distract him from any thoughts of grief and loss and a Company of dwarves half a world away.

Bilbo would be himself once again.

He had to be, once he was back in the Shire.

But before the second caravan could arrive, winter came.

 


 

It had been a normal day in a colder-than-usual autumn, the main gates of Erebor closed to preserve heat. High above the lofty peak of the mountain the sky dulled to hammered steel, clouds thick and dense, rolling in with an as-yet unnoticed threat. The wind came like a thief in the dark, imperceptible until suddenly undeniable, descending the slopes of the mountain in sharp, whistling bursts, rattling through stone terraces and long forgotten crevasses and gaps. Pennants were torn from their moorings, and in Dale shutters made a raucous symphony before being latched and silenced. Before anyone realised, snow had swept across the plains and was hammering the slopes of the mountain and slow-recovering desolation around it, erasing crag and road in moments, turning everything into a blanketing grey as far as the eye could see.

Bilbo had been entertained by the snow that evening: yes it was early, but he thought it would just be a brief flurry, gone by the next morning and the early thaw of a golden sunrise. They had many such snowfalls in the Shire in his youth, always joyous in the moment and disappointing only for faunts in its brevity. After all, winter was still weeks off, and cold fronts blow away as swiftly as they come, particularly this far north. It would be here, perhaps for a day or so, and then in a blink it would be gone. In the meantime, he might be able to coax Fili and Kili and Ori and Bofur into building a snow-hobbit with him, though he suspected they would try to give it a beard.

But overnight, the cold set in. A deep, biting cold, the kind that comes only once in a generation, the kind your skin almost can't believe. Bilbo woke in the night to the sound of groaning, echoing through the mountain as the stone itself began to freeze. His hair felt brittle against his head, his breath visible in the low light from a sputtering candle. The heating pipes that warmed the mountain seemed to be doing little to hold the worst of things at bay, and beneath his blankets, he shivered.

He stayed beneath the covers, drifting in and out of an uncomfortable sleep until he heard movement from across the hall, the sound of dwarven heavy boots in corridors that never failed to rouse him. Disoriented, uncertain of the time, he chose to join them, letting out a hiss when he swung his legs out of the bed in shock from the terrible cold against his feet, even through his hardy skin. To his displeasure, he was even forced to pull on the boots that the dwarves had given him, never before needed, as he padded out dressed in what felt like every layer of clothing he owned, bedding wrapped around his shoulders like a cape.

They didn’t know it yet, but outside the mountain the snow had covered every inch of the land, and the sudden freeze had hardened it to an impenetrable armour over the mountainside. Flags had petrified mid-flutter, and the gates of Erebor had frozen shut. The great forge, relit just months ago to great acclaim, had dimmed under the wave of cold air, and the ventilation shafts and light tunnels had been partially clogged by the mass of snow on the mountain. There would be no contact with the outside world, no supplies that could make it into the Mountain, and no sign of when the siege would end. But right now, the Company of Thorin Oakenshield did not know that, and they were laughing at each other as they came together in their communal space, all wrapped up in quite the most unusual combination of clothing.

Dwalin looked like he had stuffed half a straw mattress underneath the top layer of his tunic, causing him to rustle dramatically every time he moved more than an inch. Oin had wrapped what appeared to be half an old, torn blanket around his head, which wasn’t helping with his hearing at all. Fili had repurposed one of the eyepatches he had worn over his lost eye while it was healing to hold down a piece of fabric over his nose to keep it warm, although Bilbo was quite certain it was more for comedic effect than anything actually practical. Ori was wearing every piece of knitting he seemed to have created, and Balin, quite ingeniously, had wrapped multiple layers of cloth around his legs, which looked like it was keeping him very warm, although he was having to walk in a bow-legged fashion to compensate. Bofur looked to be the same size as Bombur with the number of layers he had piled on, giving him the appearance of a stuffed sausage. Nori clicked when he walked, and after some pressure, finally admitted to carrying heated stones in his pockets to help keep him warm (smart, but Bilbo did catch a mild whiff of scorched fabric from Nori when he passed by closely that suggested the stones might have been a touch too hot to begin with).

Thorin was looking quite put out, and Bilbo suspected that it was because Kili had somehow managed to steal his uncle’s favourite fur-lined cloak, despite the fact that the sheer quantity of fur around the collar didn’t sit quite as well on his much narrower shoulders. In fact, Kili’s head looked rather like it was sticking out of a cloud, and not in a flattering way.

But laughter stopped quite abruptly when Lir, Bombur’s wife, came to find them, frowning and looking severe enough to startle them out of their good humour. She had clearly been out early, and the leathers she wore were rimed with frost and moving stiffly. She had led the first caravan to Erebor, put in charge of this first and essential group by Dis. Lir was one of the most intimidating people Bilbo had ever met, and he counted her now as a friend after many months spent working together. As the chief engineer of the resettlement, she was often dashing from one place to another, and could be counted on to know every problem in the mountain, often before anyone else.

“I need all hands on deck,” she said, without preamble. “We need to take stock, and we need to plan as if we are going to be trapped here a while – and how in the blazes we are going to do that needs more heads than mine.”

“It won’t be that bad, surely,” said Fili, glancing between Lir and his uncle. “It’s early enough in the year yet – it’ll blow over, right?”

“It might be a bit worse than that,” Lir said, her mouth twisting. “But it is best that you come with me – Dorinbar wants to speak with you, when you are able.”

Ominous missive delivered, the group agreed to follow immediately, and Lir led the way through the Mountain halls to one of the ancient guard posts. An old dwarf that Bilbo knew well stood at the window, silver hair so still it could have been carved from stone. Dorinbar was the oldest dwarf in the Mountain by some years, and had arrived in the first caravan, having insisted that he be allowed to return and aid in the restoration as the head of the stonemason’s guild in the Blue Mountains. His knowledge of the Mountain’s infrastructure and design outstripped everyone else, and he had a particular affinity with the ravens of Erebor, one of which seemed to be currently nesting in his beard. A hobbit of comparable age would have been content in a gentle retirement, but Bilbo had learned that dwarves - particularly those wedded to a craft, like Dorinbar - would whither away without the ability to focus on their skills, and would often stay working until their last years, albeit sometimes in a more gentle capacity. 

“They’re cold,” he replied to Thorin’s enquiring look at his beard and the raven huddled within it, pecking gently at his braids as if trying to tidy them. “We should ask them to stay inside with us. There’s an old dovecote I have in mind – the one built by your great-grandmother. It'll get heat from the pipes.”

Thorin nodded. “Of course, I’ll speak to Roäc. Thank you for thinking of it.”

Dorinbar inclined his head, his hair moving stiffly in the cold. His braids were some of the most complex Bilbo had ever seen, weaving in multi-stranded steel patterns too complicated for the eye to fully understand. They were held and decorated only with small iron clasps, worn smooth from decades of handling. His broad shoulders were draped in a deep, coal-grey cloak, trimmed with fur for warmth. Beneath it, there was the edge of a tremble, as if the cold was deep in his bones. He had been standing here too long, Bilbo realised, speaking with the ravens and watching the snow fall.

The window was a tall, narrow opening cut deep into the stone, its frame carved with angular patterns. Beyond it, all was white, the daylight muted and dreamlike through the swirling eddies. Dorinbar rested one weathered hand on the stone sill, staring out once more.

“This will be a bad one, my King,” he said, voice low. “Snows like this have not been seen since myself and your Grandfather were children. They called it the Bitter Season afterwards. Erebor was snowed in for two months, and hundreds of dwarves starved or froze to death.”

He said it so calmly that for a moment Bilbo didn’t fully understand the words.

“Months?” he echoed.

“I remember Grandfather telling me the stories,” Thorin said. “But we have had many a snowstorm since. How do you know this one is different?”

The raven stuck his head out of Durinbar’s beard, and Bilbo realised it was Tark, a granddaughter of Roäc, a wise young bird who often brought Roäc’s news to them.

“The air has told us it is so, King Under the Mountain. Just as you feel the songs of the stone, so too do we hear the callings of the wind, and this storm is a long elegy that will not be content until its song has been heard across the world. You must prepare, King of Dwarves. My grandfather asks that you heed his warning and not close your ears to the truths we bring as your ancestors once did.”

Bilbo wondered what the himself of a year ago would have made of the situation. He thought about it a little as the day went on, and they all began to act on the mystical words of a talking bird, which in and of itself was a fantastic enough statement to make. The old him would have scoffed, he couldn’t help but think – or more likely would have retired to his pantry to eat a comforting slice of pie and not think too much about it. The old him, he was forced to acknowledge, didn’t like to think too much about difficult things, and avoided them whenever he could. 

He didn't like confronting himself in this kind of way. It made the strange sensation of being a ghost rise to the surface again, and Lir had been right: there were many complicated and tricky things to be considered. 

It was a difficult day, a strange and uncomfortable experience, not just because of the temperatures. The heavy snow and dim light made the familiar halls eerie and strange, a world of muted echoes and drifting cold. Between the dwarves of Erebor there sparked a frenetic energy, a strange panic that left Bilbo feeling hollow and disconnected. Clearly the dwarves all knew the stories of the so-called Bitter Season, and were reacting with great concern – but Bilbo himself couldn’t quite believe what he was being told, and even the idea of it seemed a little unbelievable to him, who had never been snowed in for more than a couple of hours at a time (and only, of course, with a well-stocked pantry and woodpile).

But as he had learned, he was good in a crisis. Bilbo’s previous knowledge of the heating systems of Erebor had been shaky that morning: by the time the Company reconvened in the late afternoon they were much more detailed and inspired much more concern. Erebor had an extensive series of heating pipes running through the walls and floors, many miles of which had been laid down by the original settlers of the Mountain. There were hundreds of furnaces scattered throughout that heated great tanks filled with water (either snow melt or rain from the surface for the most part, though some of the deeper tanks were filled via pump from water sources deep beneath Erebor). That hot water was then pumped through labyrinthine miles of pipes to regulate the temperature of the stone. Many of those furnaces served dual purposes as well – an efficient system minimising all potential waste.

Much of the pipework had been closed off pending more detailed surveyance. This would come with time as they resettled – it was unclear how much damage both the dragon and the passage of time had done, and priorities needed to be on the immediate area the dwarves were living in. As more dwarves came, and more space was needed, they could focus outwards. At the moment, there were four lit furnaces, and all served dual practical functions: one was used for smelting ore, particularly iron; one was used for maintenance and repair of both tools and weapons; a much larger one was used for repairing larger equipment and the fourth was the great communal ovens that were currently being used by the settlers.

If they were to be trapped, they would need to conserve fuel. Bilbo had listened to many dwarves today as he had trailed behind Balin, taking notes on what would need to be done. Dwarves had spent the day desperately working to try and maintain warmth and clear the snow enough to ensure fresh air and light were coming through the ventilation shafts and light-mirror channels, but the task had been a brutal one – as soon as a tunnel was cleared, it began to fill again. The dwarves were hardy, but they were fighting against elemental forces beyond anything that a couple of hundred dwarves could hope to challenge, like ants battling the sun.

When they sat down once again in their shared living room, Balin placed a dark cloth over his eyes, overwhelmed with one of the terrible headaches he’d had since the battle, when he had taken a hard hit to the back of the head. It was why Bilbo had started supporting him so much with his work, instead of aimlessly sitting at Thorin’s bedside, wondering if the dwarf would ever wake up.

Bifur and Bombur were the only dwarves who got there before them, and Bifur began signing at him quickly enough that Bombur had to step in and help translate.

"He's saying he's sorry we asked you to stay for longer," Bombur said, but then frowned at what Bifur was signing. Bilbo was trying hard to follow, but his own grasp of the language was rudimentary, and Bifur was agitated, signing quickly. He caught the word for winter, which he knew, and something about telling someone - he lost it for a bit then, because Bombur also started signing, and Bilbo made the error of trying to follow both of them at once. He caught the sign for his own name, and Thorin's, and the first sign that could mean movement or travel or change, but missed the second that would provide further context for which. 

"We know we all put a bit of pressure on you not to go back to the Shire so soon," Bombur said eventually, not quite meeting his eyes. "And... well, maybe that wasn't fair of us, given everything. And now you're stuck here during this winter. I'm sorry for that, and so is Bifur."

Bilbo stared at him in bewilderment: he wasn't sure what to say, and generic platitudes tasted like ash in his mouth. He got the feeling that there was more to it than that, but Bombur was striding off, mumbling something about hot drinks. Bifur gave him a baleful look, signed a simple apology, but would not be drawn further on the matter, even when Bilbo asked. Instead, the hobbit turned back to his notes while he waited for the rest of the Company to arrive, deciding that the mysteries of dwarves were the least of his concerns right now.

“Alright,” Bilbo said once everyone had arrived, staring at the notes he had been taking all day. “Balin and I have been running the numbers on the assumption that we need to be self-sufficient for at least two months. If we hit pause on all significant metalworking, we can prioritise the fuel storage for warming the domestic spaces and cooking ovens. If we ask people to exclusively cook communally - most people do anyway, really – then we could save quite a bit of fuel and be able to keep on top of rationing as well. We’ve got a fair stock of dried goods, grains, beans… if we are careful with everything, we should have food enough for five weeks. We are still finding some old stores of things, so we might be able to supplement those stocks. And if we stretch things out – maybe fuel enough for six weeks, though several dwarves have been very insistant that it is difficult to make precise estimations.”

“We should ask people to bunk together,” Balin added, from beneath his cloth. “Most of us have been keeping our own rooms since the spring, but it isn’t too much of a hardship to move beds around. We could fit more bodies in if we went back to bedrolls, but then we'd be losing heat to the floor. Multiple bodies in a room will keep it warmer and if we can limit the number of rooms we need to heat through the furnaces, then we can stretch out the fuel for longer.”

“That makes sense,” Bilbo agreed. “Lir, we should speak about which rooms make the most sense, in terms of the furnaces – if we can shut down some sections of the heating pipes, then we will be in a much better position. It’ll be helpful if we can find a way to align it with the water pipes that have been cleaned and are approved as potable. We’ll need to limit the use of hot water – well, I doubt we will get it above tepid, anyway. But we will be reliant on those pipes for drinking water, and we can’t afford to let them freeze and burst.”

He blinked at his notes. Who was this hobbit speaking with such authority and confidence, as if he knew things and was someone important? The thought pulled him from his task, and he glanced up from his notes only to see Kili’s face, ashen and drained. The young dwarf looked lost, and more than a little overwhelmed – and to be honest, he wasn’t the only one. Lir was leaning against Bombur, and Dori was hovering around his brothers in a way that made him look a little like a mother bird. Everyone looked tired and worn.

“Look, it probably won’t go on for that long,” Bilbo added, meeting Thorin’s eyes before glancing away again. “We’re probably just panicking and preparing for a worst-case scenario that won’t happen. But better safe than sorry, I think. Start thinking about who you are going to bunk with – one problem at a time.”

He said the latter to Kili, who smiled at him – a little thin, but still there. “I’ll share with Fili,” Kili told him, to no one’s surprise.

“You end up falling asleep in my rooms half the time anyway,” Fili replied, scrubbing his knuckles across his brother’s head. Bilbo quirked a smile at them, but turned back to his notes, begging the numbers before him to somehow shift and give him additional weeks of resources. As such he missed several minutes of conversation, only tuning back in once he noticed the strange silence that had sunk over the room. Several people were staring at him meaningfully: the rest at Thorin, who seemed to be glaring in the general direction of the Company, the tips of his ears having turned slightly pink.

“What did I miss?” he asked, and Fili nudged him, sharp elbows mitigated by layers of clothing.

“We’re just working out who will bunk with who,” Bilbo was informed. “You don’t mind sharing with Thorin, do you?”

 


 

Of course, he didn’t mind sharing with Thorin. Thorin was – well, not exactly Bilbo’s closest friend in the Company, that title would probably go to Bofur. Or Balin, possibly. Maybe Nori. Well, it was difficult to work out, wasn’t it? He loved all the Company, all in slightly different ways, but his feelings for them all were unmistakable. A companionship, all of them bonded together by their experiences and a strange journey across the world, facing impossible odds.

And Thorin was – well, he was their leader, of course. Their king now, properly, even if they did all share one of the wings of the old palace, mucking in together and sharing meals and all living in slightly closer proximity than was probably appropriate for royalty. He was their king, but he was also their friend, and it was probably a bit unorthodox, but it worked for them. He trusted Thorin with his life: he would put everything he was or had or could ever hope to be in Thorin’s hands without hesitation.

But Thorin was – well, it was complicated.

He wouldn’t have been Bilbo’s first choice of roommate, let's put it that way. That would have been Bofur, but he would bunk with Bifur – and that made sense, they were cousins and well used to sharing. Gloin and Rimli, who had also come on the first caravan, of course already shared a room, as did Bombur and Lir. Fili and Kili were more than happy to bunk together and had decided that young Gimli would join them, and Bilbo had a feeling that the three of them would get into mischief enough that he was content to be well away from it. No one really ever acknowledged the strange relationship between Dwalin and Nori, but everyone took it for granted that they would share – they were often seen emerging from each other’s rooms in the mornings, or talking in low voices in shadowed corners. After that, Dori and Ori were another natural pair, and Balin and Oin had seemed content enough as cousins and old friends to bed down together.

So, he supposed that sleeping with Thorin – well, no, not sleeping with obviously – made sense. It still didn’t stop his chest tightening with some anxiety as he finally made his way to their allocated room at the end of a very long, cold day.

He would die for Thorin, and he was fairly confident that Thorin would do the same for him, but they weren't what you would call close.

There was too much between them now, too much that had been said and too much that never had. He didn't know how to be around Thorin anymore. He supposed perhaps they should speak about it, the what might have been that seemed to have withered away somewhere between battle and throne. But the thought of having that conversation, of setting those words into reality, felt impossible. What was the line, from that old book of his mother's? Words strain, crack and sometimes break, under the burden, under the tension? No, he could not speak of it, could not turn his feelings to words and set them free into the air. Besides, he was leaving soon, returning to the Shire and his pine crown and his parents' graves; he was going, going, and then those words would have been liberated for no purpose.

He took a deep breath before the door. 

Inside, the small chamber lay quiet except for the low rumblings of the pipes in the walls. Thorin was seated on a heavy chest, his fur-lined cloak having been reclaimed from his nephew at some point over the course of the day. He was brushing snowmelt from the ends of his hair, looking wearier than Bilbo had seen him since those first weeks after waking from the battle.

Bilbo hovered by the door, feeling very much like an intruder even though this room did not belong to either of them. Neither of their rooms had been deemed practical enough by their head engineer, and so chests of their belongings had been relocated here earlier in the day.

“Come in, Master Baggins,” Thorin rumbled without looking up. “You are letting the warmth out.”

“Oh! Yes, quite right.” Bilbo shut the door quickly and rubbed his hands together. “Terribly sorry. Was distracted by the, uh, bed.”

Thorin turned a raised eyebrow towards it.

“Yes, I’ve been informed it is more efficient to share, and it saves them from having to relocate two separate beds. Apparently. Dwalin and Bofur were quite insistent.”

Bilbo shouldn’t be thrown off by it – after all, he had shared beds and bedrolls with every member of the company before at one time or another, this shouldn’t be any different. But though he refused to let his show on his face, he was thrown. Very thrown. Like a fine pebble skipped across the surface of a lake, only to sink to unfathomable depths once its brief moment in the air was done.

“Are you alright?” Thorin asked, looking slightly concerned, and Bilbo realised he’d been staring into space, thinking about pebbles, for a beat too long.

“As well as I can be,” Bilbo replied, before hurrying off to the bathroom.  

When he returned, Thorin was in the bed, propped up against the pillows, covered by heavy blankets. He had a charmingly knitted hat over his hair which Bilbo raised his eyebrows at, covering the awkwardness he felt as he slipped into the bed beside him.

“Nice hat,” Bilbo remarked, wriggling a little to get comfortable.

“Even kings must concede to the winter,” Thorin said, in response, not looking up from the scroll in his hands. “Snow does not bend to titles, and crowns are poor substitutes for good quality knitwear.”

Bilbo smiled wanly in response, pulling the covers up further around himself, awkward as he tried not to dislodge Thorin. The warmth in the room was thin, but better than the corridors. For a few heartbeats, neither of them spoke.

Outside, the wind roared against the rock, the call of a wolf winter.

Thorin’s voice broke the silence, quieter this time. “My people have weathered poor winters before. Many times, and in far worse places. But I can’t help but wonder if it is an ill omen, for it to have come during my first winter awake under the mountain again.” His eyes were on the distant wall, lost in shadows and dust. “Perhaps it is a judgment, against me.”

Bilbo dared to nudge him beneath the covers. “Or perhaps you’re just assuming coincidence as fate,” he answered. “And being a bit egotistical with it. Seasons don’t care for mortal kings; winter storms have never paid much attention to what we are up to. I don’t know why they would care now.”

Thorin made a low sound, something that might have been a laugh or a noise of disagreement; it was hard to tell.

“I suppose it just feels like I have more to lose now than I ever have before,” he said again, voice quiet. “And I can’t lose Erebor again. Not now I know how it feels to have it back.”

Bilbo tried not to look at him, staring instead at the shape of his legs under the blankets, the soft lines of their bodies covered, abstract. “Having something to lose just means it matters,” he said quietly. “And Erebor matters—to all of you. I – I don’t know, really, what it was like for you in the Blue Mountains, but it seems to me that you carry the weight not just of your own crown, but that of your father and grandfather’s – and your heirs, as well. That is a heavy burden.”

Thorin’s jaw shifted, the faintest hint of movement, the quietest click of the joint betraying him. “I forget, sometimes, how much you see.”

“Well, I am very observant,” Bilbo said, trying for lightness that didn’t quite hold. “Hobbits notice things. Unless there is a very fine pie on offer, we might be distracted at that point. But luckily none of you have a deft enough hand for good quality pastry, so I’m quite able to keep an eye on things.”

“Hmph.”

Another silence, but warmer this time. Thorin leaned over, and blew out the lantern.

“Rest, Bilbo. Perhaps the storm will have passed by the morning, and all this worrying will have been for nothing.”

“Do you think?” Bilbo said, half-laughing, as he buried his face against the pillow.

“Perhaps.” A pause. “And if it does not… well, we’ll face it together, I suppose.”

Bilbo felt a warmth rise to his face—part embarrassment, part something else entirely. He pulled the blanket a little higher and breathed deep the musty smell of the linens, layered with some mountain herb whose name he did not know.

“Well,” he said quietly, “I suppose that’s not so bad.”

Thorin’s answering hum, low and steady in the dim room, was warm and gentle.

It was better to share a bed, Bilbo was content to admit to himself as he fell asleep. There was warmth here that, despite the freezing temperatures outside, made this safe space under the covers feel cosier than even his own lonely bed did at the height of summer.

The next morning he woke content, warm and languid, until his brain sparked enough to realise that his back was pressed firmly against Thorin’s chest. Thankfully, his knees were tucked up, preventing him from having made contact with anything further down, but there was a hot weight braced around his ribs that he was certain must be an arm, and he could feel the soft movement of Thorin’s breath against the back of his neck, stirring his own hair a little.

Bugger, he thought to himself. He doubted he could extract himself from this without Thorin waking, and he wasn’t sure he could bear the embarrassment of having that conversation right now. Not when the air outside the bed felt so chill, and the day stretched ahead of him with so much uncertainty and activity. Luckily, before he could make a decision about what to do, he felt Thorin tense behind him. He closed his eyes quickly and let Thorin ease away from him, before tactfully rolling to lie face down on his side of the bed, where he feigned sleep until Thorin accidentally knocked something over while dressing, allowing him to pretend to awaken.

If this did go on for months, Bilbo thought, he might take his chances in the snow.

Chapter 2: quartet 2

For six days and nights the winds howled unrelentingly. Snow piled against the ramparts, growing deeper and deeper until opening even windows became next to impossible (not that you’d want to: even just a moment in front of an open window was apt to leave you coated in a layer of snow). By the end of the first week, the dwarves (and hobbit) of Erebor had resigned themselves to a long, cold winter and finding ways to manage the heavy cloak of snow and ice that Erebor now wore around its shoulders. Each dawn brought only more clouds, an endless shroud obscuring everything beyond the mountain.

Inside Erebor the air grew thin, and morale fell despite itself. The light-and-mirror tunnels, another of Erebor’s ancient marvels of engineering, remained partially clogged with snow despite the best efforts of the labouring dwarves. Some corridors were now so dim that you needed old oil lamps to find your way along them: others were only partially clogged, which left the halls in a grey and unpleasant twilight, cold and unwelcoming. The air was chill enough that breath fogged in front of the face all hours of the day, gathering in cold, damp droplets on any fabric held too close to the skin, making things all the worse. Clothing layers were shared out, but no matter how well wrapped you were there was always the sensation of never quite being warm enough. 

The dwarves of the young re-settlement – barely two hundred strong, besides the original company – learned swiftly the measure of their rations and the cost of this strange confinement. During the first week, the disruption was most obvious in the forges. Several had been closed down as per Bilbo’s planning, but key ones remained for heating the pipes, and they needed constant feeding. The air-shafts that kept the furnaces breathing were narrowed by ice, and they found themselves forced to keep clearing it as best they could, in the meantime keeping the fires low to avoid smoke backing up, gathering in rooms and staining stone dark and oily. The glow of the furnaces was dimmed and the rooms darker than normal, and although no dwarf would have dreamed of complaining, you could feel the restless energy, like static in the air. The dwarves in the first caravans were hard workers, those used to physical toil and complex activity. Most found themselves unable to complete their normal activities and wandered aimlessly unless they were needed to clear snow, idle for the first time in decades. It was at first mildly amusing, and then increasingly alarming to Bilbo as he watched tempers fray. In the end, he sought out who he knew could be best trusted to lift spirits.

Bofur's hat flaps were now tied under his chin in his efforts to keep warm, but in all other regards seemed to be handling the low temperatures well. Bilbo wasn't sure if that was because he didn't feel the cold much, or if it was because of some secret layering of clothes he wasn't privy to. Either way, Bofur took to the task that Bilbo had brought to him with good cheer. He seemed to know every dwarf by name and spent the days finding those who looked in need of some company, either to vent or just for some reassurance and kindness. He diffused tensions in groups with his songs – some old and steeped in tradition, some improvised in the moment. They filled the halls in the evening, easing tempers and relaxing those in the worst of moods. He encouraged some of the others too: at his request, Balin told long tales when the evenings were stretching long—old histories of Durin’s line, tales of Moria before its fall, stories seeped in the warmth of history and shared belonging that never failed to make something ache deep in Bilbo’s chest.

“You’re very good with people,” Bilbo told him, quite sincerely. “You know how to talk to everyone, and make them feel better. It’s really quite impressive. I could have done with you in some difficult family situations, you know. I’ll have to make sure you have invitations to all the Shire functions when I return.”

Bofur grinned, though there was an edge of tension to it. “Well, don’t rush off home then. No doubt I’ll be needed here a time.”

Bilbo didn't have an answer to that: he could feel the real request to stay buried underneath, and he didn't know how to respond to it.

Bofur made sure to stop by wherever Bilbo was at least once a day, to share a cup of tea and a chat, and it took Bilbo an embarrassing amount of time to realise that Bofur was checking in on him as well.

The snow finally eased at the end of the first week: one morning, they awoke to a strange quiet, almost unnatural compared to the winds that had been their constant companion for the last seven nights. Looking out of some of the few windows that remained unblocked showed them a landscape transformed in shades of grey and white and blue: a vast, pale sky above them, and a world around them carpeted in snow so deep that in some places entire familiar trees had been covered. Distant smoke was the only marker of Dale, hidden by this deep blanket: Bilbo worried for them, but at the end of the day, they might have been in another world for all the help he could give them right now. For a brief moment, the dwarves celebrated their freedom, until they realised that the great gates of Erebor were absolutely impassable. All other known exits were equally sealed by ice or buried, and though some windows could be forced open, to what end? The land outside was impassable, and it would be impossible to bring back any substantial supplies. Even worse was the temperature. The dwarves dug out old thermometers and assumed at first they must be broken, as the temperature they showed was bitterly low. It was only when the ravens confirmed that one of their own had perished, freezing instantly to death when risking leaving their new home in the dovecote, that they realised they read true. The risk to any one person was significant enough that Thorin refused to allow any dwarf to leave the mountain (though no one was particularly keen to do so in the first pla).

A team of dwarves was dispatched to explore whether any external doors could be opened, but the main gates were quickly abandoned. Instead, they focused on the smaller doors (and Bilbo had been surprised to realise that there had been other doors into the Mountain, after all the faff with the secret door (although in hindsight, what kind of a city would only have one exit?), but it had emerged that most of the other entrances had either been destroyed in the dragon attack or in subsequent rockslides caused by the movements of the dragon, so would have been impossible for the Company to use. This had been what had caused such a huge number of deaths, as dwarves in large sections of the city had no route to evacuate. Clearing those entrances had been one of the earliest priorities of the Ereborians. Miners, builders and engineers examined routes, some of them only recently cleared, to ascertain what their options were. No one was saying it, but all were concerned about what would happen if there were a fire. It might seem unlikely with the cold, but on the off-chance that something caught, they needed to know that there was a way to escape the Mountain.  

The dwarves of Erebor were cautious about fire.

Two routes were cleared by the end of the second week, both slightly awkward and narrow, but enough to reassure the dwarves that they would be able to get out should they need it in the event of an emergency. Some of the younger dwarves tried to venture outside, just to see what it was like, only to sink into snow banks taller than they were. It seemed fun and games for a brief moment until the snow collapsed onto one of them, and a panicked ten minutes was spent digging them out, thankfully none the worse for wear.

Thorin had not been impressed.

The cold did not shift the next day, nor the next. Frost gathered on the edges of stone pillars. The youngest dwarves wrapped woollen scarves around their beards as they shuffled through the corridors, breath steaming. The stores of food, carefully laid but not meant for a siege from the very elements, dwindled slowly despite the careful eye kept on them. Salted meats were carved thin. The cave mushrooms, coaxed from trays in a side-hall under deliberately dim lamps, grew slower in the cold. Stews and porridges were made thin, and bowls small. That, coupled with the cold which made sleeping a struggle for many dwarves, were also impacting the health of the dwarves.

One day Bilbo and Oin, exploring the old medical buildings, found several crates of dried pine needles, stored for burning, Oin explained: the resin in the pine kept illnesses at bay and purified the air.

“Is that something we should be worried about?” Bilbo asked, seeing the considering look in Oin’s eyes. The old dwarf looked tired: he had been pressed into caring for a huge number of the dwarves, whose bones were struck by the cold. Muscles seized in the night, cold water made teeth and heads ache, and frostbite was a legitimate concern. He was particularly gruff about the cold, muttering loudly about how no dwarf ought to be able to see his breath inside his own home. Still, he had a knack for concocting warming salves, and though dwarves were hardy, they understood well enough that their bodies were their most essential tool, and they reported to Oin for advice and care.

“Cold weather keeps a lot away,” Oin replied thoughtfully. “But large numbers of bodies close together, and air that doesn’t move much, is always a risk.”

They started burning them in the evening, when the dwarves were gathered together. The smell of it made him think of home, of those pine wreaths in his hair and branches burning on the fire, of old yuletide hobbit traditions, of warm drinks and hot food and the press of familiar bodies on either side of him as he walked, hand-in-hand with his parents, through an array of hobbit festivals and events. When he closed his eyes and breathed deep he was that same hobbit again, now so unfamiliar it might have been a dream, fussy and easily tired, alone and content. Sometimes, when he opened his eyes again, he didn’t know who he was, or where in time. Disconsolate and alone he would sneak away early, sometimes using his ring to avoid his friends, and hide under the covers in the bed he now awkwardly shared with Thorin. 

As for Thorin, the King held council each morning beneath on the surviving statues of Durin, in an old council room. He spoke in low, calm tones with different dwarves, those who brought him updates. Balin was a great help, with a keen mind for strategy and a good understanding of how best to manage the overall situation, and Thorin looked to him often for advice. Gloin had taken overall responsibility for resource management and had an excellent head for numbers. He managed the tracking of fuel, and daily checked in with every team managing the furnaces. His reports were long and frustrated and surprisingly hilarious, each one with sections written in the style of ancient poems detailing the ongoing battle against the nefarious enemy, insufficient fuel. When the mood grew too serious, he would often launch into these – quite poorly written – poems, dramatic enough to make even Thorin laugh.

“Has he always been like this?” Bilbo asked Balin, as Gloin laughed with Thorin. “He seemed much more serious during the journey – though I suppose there wasn’t as much to laugh at.”

Balin stroked his beard, smiling to himself. “It’s been odd, those of us related to Thorin and Dis. We’re part of the line of Durin, enough to have responsibility but distant enough that the brunt of the burden never fell on us. When we were younger, it was always Gloin that would make my younger cousins sneak out and have some fun – I had to cover for them more than once. He had less of a chance to do that, of late. Perhaps he’s taking the opportunity to do that again, now Thorin has reclaimed our home.”

Ledgers littered the great table that served as the command centre, numerous eyes reviewing the numbers of the fuel, the food, the levels of the water tanks, the updates from the guards and ravens and the dwarves made responsible for ensuring that the furnaces didn’t fail. Fili stayed carefully by his shoulder, watching everything through his one good eye, always just a touch too close to his uncle as if he were afraid that one of them would falter and need propping up. Bilbo wondered, sometimes, which one of them Fili was afraid for. They were all of them transforming, each dwarf he knew so well growing and changing to fit the world around them, but despite the changes, they still felt like the dwarves he knew and loved, only somehow more so.

In the evenings, Bilbo saw a different version of the king than the one presented to the rest of the dwarves.

Sharing a room was awkward at first. Bilbo would often come in to find Thorin standing stiffly, arms crossed, as if he were guarding the room from intruders or simply didn’t know what to do with himself. Bilbo found himself fussing more in response, despite himself, as if trying to prove that he was not unsettled by Thorin’s presence. He found himself worrying over the straightness of the blankets, the cleanliness of the floor, muttering aloud about the lack of hobbit amenities and good quality tea, speaking aloud his inane concerns to fill the strange silence between them. He didn’t even care about these things, not really: they belonged to a past life, to a version of himself that had died somewhere between mountain road and darkened wood, but pulling the coat of a past-self on again felt like an easy disguise for his own disquiet. Silence stretched and ached between them when they could not think of what to say, and for the first few nights sometimes they went to bed without exchanging words, though often Bilbo found himself waking wrapped in Thorin’s arms.

But eventually they fell into a comfortable rhythm. Bilbo had been sent a chest of dried leaves from Bard shortly before the storm hit, a wide range of herbs exchanged with different travellers or harvested from the local lands. It was a gift in silent thanks for Bilbo’s support and the Arkenstone, though they didn’t speak of it. None of them were really fit for the kitchens or he would have given them over, but the cooks had declined when they were offered.

Bilbo was trying different combinations to find ideal tea blends, and to his surprise, Thorin was happy to assist him with the task. After the long days spent meeting with dwarves, working through complex logistics, supporting other dwarves and trying to maintain morale, there was a comfort in retreating to the small, warm-ish room. Bilbo would heat water on the closest furnace, and then run the old iron kettle back, wrapped in blankets to try and conserve the heat. They would steep whatever leaves Bilbo had mixed for the occasion, and as their silences became more comfortable, their conversations came more easily.

They spoke mostly of small things at first—of Dale’s latest trade methods, of the food cellars Bilbo insisted needed better labelling, of the stories Balin had told the night before. But as the snow lay thicker and the days blurred together, the conversations deepened. Thorin told him of his childhood, a prince of a plentiful kingdom, of adventures sought with brother and sister through the echoing halls of the palace. He told Bilbo about his brother, who had Fili's hair and Dis' smile, and who Thorin missed every day. He spoke of his sister, his fear of seeing her once again warring with how desperately he longed to embrace her, and how he didn't know how he would face her after nearly killing her sons. He spoke of his mother, and the silver chains of her beard, and the great pearl she had worn from the tip of it that glowed a thousand colours in different lights. He talked of his apprenticeships and learning, hours spent with old masters who did not tolerate poor behaviour just because he wore an heir’s coronet, and how much he had appreciated that. He did not speak much of his father or grandfather, but sometimes things slipped through, and Bilbo could hear the old ache in his voice.

It was easy to listen to Thorin: something in the tone of his voice made some deep pain in his chest settle. It had been Thorin’s voice, all that time ago, that had made a fussy old hobbit believe he could be someone else, someone who went on adventures and saw the world.

In return Bilbo told him tales of the Shire, of his own youth spent running through gentle landscapes, dipping his feet into the quiet, slow waters of the Brandywine. He told him about his mother’s herb lore, imparted to him as he peered over the top of the kitchen counter, and his father’s vegetable patch, and numerous relatives that pinched his cheeks and showed him how to braid flowers into his hair. He told him how he had longed for siblings but had learned to enjoy his own company instead, and the way as a child he had once walked through Bag End trying to find every bit of wood that his father had carved two entwined B's onto, for Bungo and Belladonna. He told him of the high days and traditions of the Shire, and what the earth there felt like underfoot when the root vegetables were ready for digging up. He told him of harvest festivals, corn dolls, and the crop burnings, and watching the fleet-footed wild hares speed across the fields like the shadows of birds to escape the smoke.

When they spoke to each other like this, in the quiet late nights, Bilbo was reminded of the soft intimacy his parents had shared. He remembered seeing them, sat in their armchairs in front of the fire, his mother’s feet curled up underneath her and his father’s pipe smouldering in his hands, and the way the firelight caught the planes of their faces, painting them in coppers and golds, in a world of their own. But there wasn’t anything between him and Thorin, Bilbo knew. Sure, he sometimes dreamed of the way Thorin’s arms had felt around him that moment on the Carrock. And that soft, distant memory of Thorin’s voice haunted his quiet moments, when he was lost in his own mind and thinking of his home and who had been.

And yes, perhaps he had thought that there might be something between them, before the Arkenstone and the battle, when Thorin had handed him that mithril shirt and looked at him like he was the only person in the world. But then Bilbo had betrayed him and Thorin had slipped into that strange madness, and though they had settled everything between them since, things had changed. Water passes under the bridge, but that means that the water is no longer the same.

They had what they had, and that would be enough. Besides, he was planning on leaving soon, and returning to the Shire, and all of this would turn into a distant memory. Better to leave things sweet and unspoken, and be glad that they had slowly regained being comfortable together, than dwell on what else they might have once become, in a different time. 

One evening, Thorin brought with him a bundle wrapped in dark cloth and sat on the floor despite the chill coming through the stone. Inside was a set of small, delicate tools, and a selection of jewellery, tarnished now and damaged.

“I went to find my mother’s rooms today,” he said quietly. “I hadn’t thought much of them until recently, and they were in quite a poor state. But I found some of her jewels, among the debris. I couldn’t find her pearl – I suppose she must have been wearing it. But there were other things I recognised, even if they are damaged now.”

He didn’t say anything more as he laid out the tools, and then, with a precision that seemed almost like magic to Bilbo, began to repair things, and Bilbo remembered what Thorin had told him, that he had been apprenticed to the jeweller’s guild, as his father had been before him. His movements were sure and steady, and there was something almost automatic in them, as if he had done this so many times that he was able to slip into that quiet, ground space in your mind, where your thoughts simmer down to a background rumble and everything feels calm and peaceful.

“Do you find it calming?” Bilbo asked, immediately regretting disturbing the moment, but Thorin only paused to glance up at him, his expression softening.

“Aye,” was his answer. “Grounding, perhaps. I’d forgotten that. When we were in the Blue Mountains, I would do blacksmithing work for coin - men never require the great skills of masters, and even a poor dwarven blacksmith is better than a good one of theirs. But the work did not speak to me, in my heart, and I did not find the joy in it that I did with this kind of fine work, or music. That's when it is the best, when there is skill in the work that rests your soul. It is good for the hands to have something to do so that the mind can rest. Sometimes ruling goes too far in the other direction.”

Bilbo smiled into his mug. “I suppose it’s a bit like growing plants and herbs then. Except my rosemary doesn’t glitter.”

“Perhaps you just haven’t found the right variety then,” was the response, a joke that would have felt unfathomable just a few days before.

 


 

A strangely festive mood started the third week. Rimli had found an old stash of honey from before Smaug, and with the miracle that honey was, it was still sweet and pure, albeit cloudy and crystalline now in the cold. The decision was made to use a chunk of it to create something to make everyone feel a bit better, and Bilbo had assisted in baking a number of honey cakes, a sweetness that seemed to lift everyone’s spirits. The younger dwarves had found an old corridor where the ice had formed so thickly on the stone slabs that a dwarf could slide across if given enough momentum, and Kili had started a competition to see which dwarf could propel themselves the furthest, a record that was currently held by Gloin.

The guards on post duty started swapping out shifts more frequently, for the cold that crept through the outer stone was sharper than any blade, and none envied the dwarves stationed near the frost-bound upper tunnels: this seemed to improve their moods, and the changing rotation of dwarves through the halls kept things feeling lively. Several dwarves had dug out musical instruments and were trying to find ways to tune them despite the deep cold, practising together to both perfect old songs and compose new. Kili took to this too with some pleasure, trying to act as composer and conductor at the same time, to varied success. It didn’t take long for him to be ousted by Dori, who Bilbo learned was what the dwarves called a songsmith by trade: a composer of songs for the royal court.

“I haven’t had much chance to use those skills in decades,” Dori confided to Bilbo, staring into a mirror as he neatened his braids the morning before his first performance. “In the Blue Mountains there wasn’t much call for new songs, and besides which the royal family could hardly afford to keep songsmiths on staff as they did in Erebor. I made my living in the fabric trade instead – that was my father’s trade and I’ve always had a good eye for quality. But it is good to find that part of myself again: it makes me feel younger, like the dwarf I thought I might be.”

Dori’s song was in Khuzdul, and Bilbo couldn’t understand the words, but it was beautiful. He could feel the slow, deep-voiced melodies in his bones, sounding like the heartbeat of the mountain, the roar of winter, the joy of living. Even the gruffest dwarf could be seen to shed a tear when it was first performed for the settlement. There was something in the melody that spoke of fear and waiting and wanting, of raw emotions and the real living essence of things, and it did not matter that he did not understand the words, because he felt them, deep inside his old and tired bones.

It made him think of Laketown, of the night before they were due to leave to undertake the last stretch of their long and perilous journey, from lake to mountain proper. The Company had been subdued, thinking of the mountain and the task ahead of them and that great and unspoken sleeping dragon they knew they had to wake. Kili had been injured of course, and all of them still nursing bruises from their unappealing barrel ride. They had food in their bellies and warm beds to sleep in, but Laketown had come with its own challenges, and all of them were ill at ease there and ready to leave at first light.

He had found Thorin standing on one of the small balconies, overlooking the water. A pipe was in Thorin’s hand, burning low, the bitter smell of acrid leaf hot in Bilbo’s nostrils as he approached. All day he had felt Thorin’s eyes on him, bright and hot, but every time he had looked in the dwarf’s direction he had glanced away again.

He stood next to Thorin, and took the pipe from him without saying a word, inhaling a mouthful of smoke.

“You don’t have to come with us,” Thorin said, quietly. “You have already done so much for us, and risked your life more times than I can count. If not for you, I fear I would be dead already, or trapped in some elven prison for the rest of my miserable days.”

Bilbo stared at him, at the hard lines of his profile lit by weak moonlight and the low warmth of a lantern strung overhead. Thorin’s face was a map of places Bilbo felt he would never know, but wanted to. When he had first met Thorin, the dwarf had been unknowable, terrifying in a way Bilbo didn’t know how to explain. Hearing his voice, that low song echoing through his smial, had woken something in him that he didn’t know how to put to sleep again. Over the course of the journey, he had thought Thorin rude, and impulsive, and reckless, and undeserving, and beautiful and noble and heartbreakingly good. His father's voice, reading aloud, echoed through his mind: home is where one starts from. As we grow older, the world becomes stranger, the pattern more complicated. 

“I’m coming with you,” he replied, chewing on the end of the pipe, quite forgetting it was not his. Thorin looked at him, his eyes impossible to read.

“You have already met the terms of your contract,” was his reply. “You have successfully stolen – me and my Company, from the elves. No one would think less of you if you chose to leave now.”

“I’m not leaving you,” was his answer, and Thorin’s gaze was full of old forgotten songs, ancient and aching. There was hope and fear and a strange, lingering joy in that expression, as if the dwarf had been walking a thousand years in search of water, and had finally found a lake. A lifetime burning in every moment, he thought to himself. And not the lifetime of one man only, but of old stones that cannot be deciphered. Thorin was a riddle, and a mystery, and Bilbo could hardly dare to dream of solving it.

The corner of Thorin's mouth had tilted upwards, as if he was trying not to smile, and the way he looked at Bilbo in the coold night air made him think of his father, and Bag End, and acts of devotion that lasted for generations to come. 

“Very well,” Thorin said, and his hand touched Bilbo’s, a heavy weight on his own on the wooden balustrade. It was a gentle touch, full of promise. “Perhaps when this is over – well, we will see.”

Bilbo had known, then, what Thorin chose not to say – or perhaps he had merely been hoping. It was always too hard to know for certain. And now, a year on, he sat and watched Thorin from across a hall of dwarves, settled into his home once more, alive and hale and still with them. They had never had that conversation, probably never would now – but he was content enough to see Thorin here.

He had to be content enough with that, he thought as he breathed deep the smell of burning pine needles. If he wasn’t, he didn’t know what else to be.

Chapter 3: quartet 3

Their brief joy passed as quickly as the sweetness of honey on the tongue: it had been a brittle thing, forged more from the mortal desire for brightness than from anything real or substantive.

The end of the third week also brought dangerous news: the erratic winds blowing down the ventilation shafts had caused fuel to burn more quickly than anticipated, and their stores of fuel were growing lower than planned. There seemed to be no break in the cold, and so eyes turned inwards to see where further fuel might be found. Ori had needed and received immediate reassurance that there was no intention to look to the surviving manuscripts in the old libraries (not in the least because parchment really doesn’t have a long enough burn time to be worth it).

Dwalin had been surprisingly calm throughout the whole situation. If you’d asked Bilbo in advance, he would have thought that Dwalin would have been one of the dwarves who would struggle the most with the lack of action, but instead, the tall dwarf had been remarkably composed and circumspect. Perhaps it was something innate to a good guardsman: the willingness to sit and watch and wait, not letting tension and emotion take over, remaining centred and focused while waiting for something to happen that would require action. So it was with Dwalin, and when the emergency came he sprang to action like a well-oiled machine, and rallied groups to begin scouring the still unexcavated parts of the city for further timber or coal to burn.

And there was one place that it made the most sense to look. Colloquially, it had become known as Old Erebor. These were the ancient levels of the city, buried deep below surface level, where the first dwarves had settled. Over time, the city had expanded upwards through the mountain proper, exploiting veins of minerals and ore and opening up new parts of the city as they went. There were deep mines too, feeding off the city, but down in Old Erebor the line between domestic and industrial was blurred, houses built into abandoned mine shafts and old rock repurposed to create taverns and shops between different mine entrances. This was a long way from the fine palaces and royal buildings in the middle of the mountain, or the merchants' buildings and guildhalls closest to the entrances.

When they had returned, they had made a conscious decision not to try and clear Old Erebor immediately. It had suffered badly under the dragon, and there were still concerns about the structural security of these lower tunnels after decades of bearing the weight of both the dragon and the decaying structures above it. It would need securing and renovating, but for now could wait until more dwarves arrived and the space was required. Thorin had confessed to Bilbo that he wasn't sure it ever would be, not for housing at least, but that they would need to access the old mines again eventually.

However, it did mean that there was potentially a large amount of fuel still to be found, wood and coal, perhaps even preserved peat stocks cut from the heather outside, always a popular source of fuel for the working class of the city in previous times. 

Bilbo had not planned to join the expedition: it wasn’t exactly his skill set, after all. But as the dwarves were gathering, he realised that Ori was among them, which prompted him to ask why.

Ori had been busy these last weeks, recording the activities and events of the storm. He was still officially the scribe of the Company of Thorin Oakenshield, responsible for chronicling the retaking of Erebor: the battle had been won, but you would be hard pressed to say that the city had been fully resettled, so Ori continued with his work. Before the storm, he had spent most of his time tucked up in warm corners of the old archives, organising old records no one had touched since before Smaug’s reign. Surrounded by scrolls and dusty ledgers, he had seemed very content. Since then, it was more common to see him roaming the halls, writing notes in his quick script about frozen doorways, collapsing passages, and the strange groans of the mountain at night, complete with sketches of snowdrifts, diagrams of blocked tunnels, and the occasional small portrait of dwarves when he thought no one would notice.

Now, Ori had his notebook gripped tightly to his chest, and despite the cold, wore fingerless gloves to give him enough flexibility to write. He was glaring across the room at his brother Nori, who was doing a very good job of pretending not to notice.

“I need to chronicle what we find down there,” Ori told Bilbo. “Not just for the story, but so that we can tell people when we need to resettle it. And-” he broke off, looking a bit unhappy. “No one wants to admit it, but the losses were the worst down there. Very few dwarves could get out – the dragon was literally on top of them. The dwarves we find deserve to have their beads marked, even if they have no living relatives, even if we can't retrieve their bones yet.”

He was referring to the tradition of personal bead marks: every dwarf had their own personal markings that indicated their identity, which they wore on one bead in their beard. Bilbo had heard the dwarves talking in the lead up to the battle: he knew that tradition dictated that beads should be returned to the family if bodies could not be retrieved, and the Company had all left theirs in the Mountain for survivors to pass on, in case they did not make it. They had been speaking of it since Laketown: Thorin had quietly offered to carve one for Bilbo, before the gold and the strangeness distracted him. 

“And I keep telling him that the dead can wait, because it is going to be damned dangerous down there, and Dori would skin him alive if he knew our little brother was planning on going along.”

The only reason Bilbo didn’t jump at the sound of Nori’s voice was because he had already trained himself not to.

Nori was, to Bilbo’s mind, probably the oddest member of the Company of Thorin Oakenshield. He hadn’t noticed this much during the journey: he’d been too focused on trying not to get eaten or die to pay too much attention to the quiet dwarf with a gaze as sharp as a blade. But after the battle, when he’d started to learn about all the dwarves’ normal lives and day-to-day personalities when they weren't at immediate risk of dying, Nori had remained an enigma. He did not talk about his past, and what Bilbo knew he had learned only through vague comments and offhand remarks from other people. He, Dori and Ori all had different fathers (not hugely uncommon among dwarves, where monogamous marriage was viewed more as an option than an obligation, as it was in the Shire) and had all spent time away from each other at different times, learning their trades. Nori had spent a lot of time travelling, and was the only member of the Company other than Thorin who had ever been to the Iron Mountains. He had been to the far Southron lands as well, and had seen the frozen seas of the far north. Quite what he did was unclear, and certainly, he did not give the impression of a trader or merchant.

Dori had been raised in Erebor: Ori had been born in the Blue Mountains. Somewhere between them came Nori, whose eyes were cunning and whose wrists bore manacle scars.

Once, Gloin had made a joke about Nori being a thief, but the reaction from the group (except for Bifur, Bombur and Bofur, who were as in the dark as Bilbo) made him suspect that there was more to the story than that.

“Dori can go sharpen a hammer,” Ori said, with surprising alacrity. “And so can you. I’m a grown dwarf who's earned my mastery, and I can go where I please.”

Nori seemed quite as taken aback by this as Bilbo, and watched Ori storm off with an irritated twist of his mouth.

“I can’t keep an eye on him,” he told Bilbo. “I’ve got to – well, it doesn’t matter, but I need to be doing something else. And you know what he’s like when he’s writing – head buried in the paper, not paying a bit of attention to where he’s going or reading the rock. He’s as likely to fall through a mineshaft as he is anything else.”

Nori wasn’t wrong, Bilbo admitted to himself. “Alright,” he acquiesced. “I’ll come along, and stick with him. Can’t say I’ll be much use for anything else, so I might as well try to stop him walking into any holes.”

To his surprise, Nori wrapped a brief arm around Bilbo’s shoulders, sideways-on, and squeezed. It was over as soon as it happened, but Bilbo rather thought it was as close to a hug as anyone was likely to receive from Nori.

The gathered group stood in the half-lit passage outside a sealed stairwell, fifty dwarves (and one hobbit) wrapped in cloaks stiff with frost, breath rising like ghosts in front of their faces. Down here, far from the freezing walls of the mountain, the temperature felt strange. Still cold, unimaginably so, but with some barely definable warmth rising from the deep rock. The air was still, and heavy, too long unstirred, and tasted almost metallic, the slow thickness of blood on the tongue. Old Erebor seemed to keep its own atmosphere, as if it were a whole other world.

A crowbar was used to open a door that had been sealed months before to stop anyone from wandering into unsafe areas. It groaned like something waking, and Bilbo felt a chill run down his spine. The draft that rolled out brought the smell of dry earth, burned wood, and lost things. The light of the lanterns pooled around them, lighting up the old tunnels and casting long shadows before them.

“Keep close,” Thorin said, from the front of the group, as Nori slipped away from Bilbo into the darkness ahead.

They began the descent, and Bilbo found Ori again quickly in the group, sticking close. It was not particularly precarious at first: the hallway sloped downwards at a gentle camber, and the sound of their breathing was a welcome respite from the old, stale quiet. The walls, once carved with reliefs, were furred over with a thick layer of old soot and ash, the residue of the dragon not yet cleaned away. Bilbo dragged one finger through it, revealing beneath a startling pair of eyes cut into the rock.

“Old spirits,” Ori told him, quietly. “The deep dwarves believed that there were spirits in the rock that would keep their eyes on the mines, and look after the dwarves that worked them.”

“Do you not keep the same faith?” Bilbo asked, glancing at Ori out of the corner of his eyes.

“I’m a historian,” was Ori’s reply. “It is my job to document, not to believe.”

They reached the end of the corridor relatively quickly, and the passageway widened out into the edge of Old Erebor, a twisting network of ancient stone-front dwellings, small rooms cut directly into the rock, doors now hanging at all angles or missing altogether. Rubble had poured across the roadways like frozen waves, and above them, low roofs stood intact but in places bowed and cracked, as if weighed down. Huge sheets of ice frosted the walls, as thick as the width of a palm in places, shimmering and distorting the lamplight. Formed by the meltwater, one dwarf explained quietly, and with some concern in his voice. Meltwater caused by their own, slightly warmer floors of the mountain: there was enough ventilation for them to breathe, but the old air pumps were not enough to move the warm air they exhaled. It sank, and once the temperature dropped, it froze again. The results down here were obvious.

Ori drifted between different groups, scribbling as he went. Nori had been right to be concerned: several times Bilbo had to take his arm and steer him around debris and potholes. It was a strange and perilous place: doorframes crumbled away beneath incautious hands, and often the stonework was duplicitous, fragile when it appeared otherwise. The ice had done no end of damage, worming its way into cracks and expanding them. Even the old mining supports, thick beams of seasoned pine, felt as though they might disintegrate if pulled too sharply.

Ori paused to sketch something, and Bilbo was distracted by another group of dwarves approaching. Their movements were slow and careful, and they already carried large amounts of wood on their backs and piled onto the sledges they were pulling, fashioned from old shields.

“Bilbo?”

It was Thorin, leading another group and looking concerned. Bilbo raised a hand in an awkward wave, as the dwarf came close, belatedly realising that Thorin had not known that Bilbo was down here with them. Thorin raised his own hand, a half-aborted motion as if he had been reaching to cup Bilbo’s face, gentle, reverently.

But he didn’t do that. Instead, he tried to disguise the movement by running his hand through his own hair. There was a look in his eyes that made Bilbo think that he wanted to say something, but was stopping himself. 

“I told Nori I’d keep an eye on Ori,” he said, pre-empting the inevitable question.

“Quiet,” growled Dwalin suddenly, and Bilbo flinched for a moment before realising that Dwalin wasn’t speaking to him but to the group as a whole. All lanterns stopped moving. Every dwarf held his breath.

Something was shifting in the dark: nothing tangible, nothing clear. Not footsteps or bodies, more like the granular sigh of a cave in, but far away – but the shifting of the air felt close, and strange. The sound ebbed and flowed around them for a moment, then an almost alarming creak, and then everything fell silent once again. Even Ori stopped writing, his notebook disappearing back into his layers as he looked around, disquieted.

“Stone settling,” muttered Dwalin into that silence, though his voice betrayed his unease.

A section of wall not far from them cracked, shedding a mist of powdered rock. The dwarves did not flinch at it (though Bilbo did): these were hardy dwarves, used to the dangers of the deep earth. The Blue Mountains had not sent dwarves faint of heart on the first caravan to resettle Erebor: these dwarves were all experienced, but also calm in the face of emergencies and used to dealing with problems. Despite that, none of them looked completely confident in these surroundings, Bilbo couldn’t help but note.

“We should not stay down here much longer,” Thorin said quietly. His voice carried differently than other people’s, as if the stone were breathing in to listen to him. “We misjudged the ice. Old Erebor is not ready for us.”

Working faster now, Bilbo watched as they pried loose several beams from a collapsed workshop near an abandoned tavern. Bilbo did not offer to help – he knew well enough that he was more likely to hinder progress than he was to aid it. The dwarves bundled the wood, careful not to make sudden movements, not speaking much at all.

Their sledges were full now, and they moved back to the rendezvous point. Bilbo kept close to Ori, even though the dwarf seemed much less keen on writing now. Thorin stuck close to Bilbo, close enough that the lines of their arms brushed against each other now and again, barely felt through the many layers they were wearing. On their way back, they passed a side tunnel, barely of interest: Dwalin flicked the light of his lantern towards it half-heartedly, revealing a floor thick with dust, and another pair of carved eyes.

For a moment, they seemed to flicker with movement. Despite himself, Bilbo hesitated, staring at them as the rest of the group moved forward.

“What is it?” Thorin asked, his voice quiet.

“The eyes,” was Bilbo’s response, uncertain what he was planning to say.

“Leave them,” said Thorin softly. “Shadows are but a thought and a moment in time, but best to leave them as they are.”

From nowhere came once again that strange and terrible sound, surrounding them, vibrating through the soles of his feet. A wind, so light it was barely a caress against their faces, brought a deep chill, and Bilbo turned, despite himself, his lantern light glittering in a wall rimed with a thick sheet of ice that had grown cloudy and veined like marble, and something that seemed to glitter in the air: it took him a moment to realise that it was dust, tiny fragments of ground stone, and that the ceiling above them was cracking.

“Thorin!”

He spun on his heels, using the momentum to propel himself forward, into Thorin’s body and knocking them both to the side of the corridor, where they hit the wall hard enough to ricochet off and collapse to the floor. The dwarves further down the corridor shouted, but the sound was swallowed by the crashing noise around them, huge and echoing in the narrow corridor. Chunks of ice and stone slammed around them, and a terrible pain radiated from his shoulder, appearing so suddenly he wasn’t even sure when it had happened. Beneath him was the pale warmth of Thorin’s body, arms reaching up to wrap around him, and he screamed as those safe arms pressed against his shoulder, his face buried in Thorin’s chest.

It could have lasted a moment; it could have lasted hours.

Eventually, the noise subsided, and Bilbo raised his head. Where they had been standing was now heavy rock and huge shards of ice. Had Bilbo been a moment slower, both he and Thorin would now be crushed under the weight of it. 

“Bilbo? Bilbo!”

Thorin’s voice was faint, and Bilbo realised that his ears were ringing.

“I’m alright,” he said, as beneath him, Thorin shifted, trying to get them both to their feet. He winced at the movement and tried to roll off him, only to jar his shoulder in the process. He was forced to bite back another scream as he stumbled to his feet. They had been hit by the tail end of the rockslide, and around them lay rubble that had fortuitously avoided them, and he found himself staring at it in an absent sort of horror.

“Bilbo!” Thorin’s voice was rough, and Bilbo realised that he still hadn’t answered Thorin, who was already on his feet. “Are you hurt? Let me see.”

Bilbo tried to wave him off with his uninjured arm. “It’s fine-”

“It’s not fine!”

He could feel the argument they were about to have, and even the thought of having to talk about the amount of pain he was in made him want to cry. This was not a place he could show that part of himself. 

“Thorin. It is not the time. We need to get out of here, not stand around. You can fret about it once you've led your dwarves out of this damned place.”

Thorin stared at him. They were both breathing heavily, and the sound of settling stone seemed suddenly very loud in the quiet. Thorin nodded stiffly, once, before turning back to the other dwarves and picking his way across the rubble to join them. Bilbo lagged after them, one hand on his injured shoulder. It didn’t feel wet, but then there were many layers between his hands and his skin, so if there was blood, perhaps he would not know. For now, he tried to ignore the way the flesh and bone ached, deep and brutal and angry beneath his skin.

“You look pale,” was Nori’s greeting when they rejoined the other dwarves. “And Ori told me you not only stopped him from falling down a hole into the depths of the mountain, you also threw yourself between our king and certain death-by-stone, which I have to tell you, would have been a really bad morale-wise.”

Bilbo glanced at him, frowning.

“Of course I’m pale,” he snapped back. “It’s the middle of winter, and I’m freezing cold.”

Nori rolled his eyes. “No need to be tetchy. I’m not going to ask you why you were so willing to risk your own life to save Thorin’s.”

“I’d save any of your lives!” was Bilbo’s response, through gritted teeth. “I’d jump in front of a warg for any member of the Company. I don’t know what you are implying.”

Nori grinned, and Bilbo remembered that the dwarf always loved the bite of conversations like this, of push and pull, always leaning on the edge of a knife blade.

“Not implying anything you don’t already know,” Nori told him, all bared teeth and razor expression. But his arm slipped around Bilbo’s waist, propping him up as Bilbo put his uninjured arm around Nori’s shoulders, enough to keep him upright as they followed the rest of the dwarves.

“No one’s going to say anything,” Nori said, and his voice was quiet now. “About what there is between the two of you-”

“There’s nothing like that,” Bilbo hissed between his teeth.

Nori rolled his eyes. “Sure, nothing at all.”

“Just like there’s nothing between you and Dwalin, right?”

Nori glanced at him from the corner of his eye, and said nothing, though it looked a little like he was trying not to grin, just a little bit.

 


 

The door to their room had a weight to it beyond that of the wood itself. As it closed, Bilbo felt his shoulders slumping, and he exhaled heavily; the rest of the world blocked out. The pain had sunk into that deep, throbbing ache that it suggestive of damage much worse than you want to acknowledge, and he had a horrible feeling that it was going to get feel worse before it got better.

He had almost been glad, once they had returned to the warmer halls of the mountain, when Thorin had scowled at him and nodded in the direction of their room. The pain was the kind that made it hard for him to focus on anything else, and it brought with it a tiredness that seemed to sink into his bones.

Trying to get his layers off was more of a challenge than he was up for at this exact moment. Thorin stripped him of the outer layers with an efficiency that might have been brutal but for the warmth in his eyes, and the careful way that he pulled each layer of fabric away from his shoulder. Bilbo grew colder as Thorin went, and he realised that he wasn’t breathing only when he had to take a sudden, sharp inhale.

Thorin glanced at him, lips parting as if to speak, before looking away again. It was strangely awkward, as if he wasn’t sure of his welcome.

Bilbo blinked, realising.

“Sorry for snapping before,” he said to the quiet. “I just – I couldn’t stop and fuss about it, not when we needed to get out of there. Not in front of everyone. Not when I’m already not sure what people think of me being here half the time. I don’t – I don’t want to be a burden. That’s all it was.”

Thorin sighed, and then his hands were on Bilbo’s face, thumbs tucked into the hollow of his cheekbones, palms cupping the curve of his jaw.

“I have a terrible suspicion that you saved my life down there today,” Thorin told him. “And I have no idea why you feel like you should apologise for doing so once again. The only thing that concerns me is that I now owe you multiple life-debts, and I have no way of repaying you for that.”

Bilbo felt the corner of his mouth twitch upwards, and he dared to meet Thorin’s eyes. They were warm, and a little sad.

“No debts between us, I think,” was his reply. “Or if there must be, I will take repayment in honey cakes and tea once we manage to open the gates of this blasted rock again. But nothing more than that.”

Thorin held his face a moment longer before returning to his task. As he eased a layer over Bilbo’s head, he spoke again, contemplative.

“I’ve heard no dwarf utter a negative word against you being here, you know. Often the opposite. The Company sing only your praises, and my sister writes that your reports were the only ones she was interested in reading – apparently, you’re the only person she trusts to be honest with her about what I am doing, and she hasn’t even met you. The chief engineer called you invaluable last week-”

“The chief engineer is Bombur’s wife, and is hardly impartial.”

“Lir may be married to Bombur, but if she didn’t like you, she would have no problem telling you that to your face. Dorinbar trusts you with the care of the ravens, and more dwarves than I can name have remarked on how essential you have been these last months. And I know that while I slept, it was only thanks to you that peace was forged and settled with so little incident.”

The last layer was pulled from Bilbo’s back, and he hissed at the tacky, pulling sting of it.

“It’s just a scrape,” Thorin said, sounding relieved. "Deep bruising already, and we should have Oin look at it to see how long you should rest it, but it doesn’t look too bad. I think it will ache, though, for a long time, particularly with the cold. Can I bind it for you? I have some compresses.”

Bilbo nodded, silently. A salve of some kind was gently applied with warm, careful fingers, and he inhaled the deep herbal scent, like pine leaves and rosemary and something else he could not name.

“We haven’t really talked about the fact that you want to leave,” Thorin said, into the silence. “Once the snow clears, I mean. I just - I need you to know that you can do what you like, what your heart is telling you do. You are the most important thing, Bilbo. I know it is dangerous here – and hardly a fit home for a hobbit. There will be little in the way of comfort for some time. Priorities will remain on essentials – and I don’t blame you for wanting to go back to your own home, where you can be safe and warm, and the ceiling doesn’t collapse on you.”

“It’s not- that’s not why I have to go back to the Shire,” Bilbo replied, eyes at half-mast, already tired. “It’s not because I need things, or anything like that. It’s just-”

“Just what?”

But Bilbo did not have the words. How could he express the deep longing for home, the feeling of his mother’s travelling cloak, still hanging by the front door, between his fingers? The smell of burning hay, and the dried herbs in the pantry, and the familiar creak of wooden floorboards beneath his feet? What words could shape the resounding knowledge that his longing for home was due to the terrible sensation that he needed to reclaim the person that he had once been, and nothing at all to do with wanting to leave here, this strange mountain that had welcomed him? The fear, deep inside, that if he went home, he might learn that he didn’t fit there either anymore, which was why he kept agreeing to stay for longer – because if he didn’t fit the mould of the Shire, then what would he do, and where would he go? Who was he, if he did not fit there? Who was he, now that he had travelled so far, and seen so many things? What shadow would he need to force himself to become in order to make his life work again?

The fear that what he was missing was a home that wouldn’t fit him anymore?

The knowledge that if he left, when he left, he would be tearing a part of himself out in the process.

“You could stay,” Thorin said, and his voice was so quiet, quiet enough that Bilbo could pretend not to hear it if he wanted. “I know – I thought that, maybe once, you might care for me as I do for you. And I know that I – I changed. And it changed everything that was between us, what we might have become. But the one thing that didn’t change is how I feel. I just wanted you to know that.”

And what could Bilbo say? That yes, Thorin was right, that there was a ghost that stood between them of a potential future that they had lost, of a home that they might have found together but had both burned down with poor decisions? That if they had trusted each other a little more they would not have broken what was once between them? That Bilbo loved Thorin, loved him so much that sometimes he thought that if you carved him open you would see the chords of Thorin’s voice carved into his ribs, but that it is impossible to give yourself when you don’t know who you are, when you feel so lost, when you may need to leave and travel a world away just to find the skin you had shed and return to something that felt safe, and normal?

So, he closed his eyes, and didn’t say anything, and let Thorin wrap his shoulder and lead him to bed, hating himself a little.

Thorin vanished, and he half-fell asleep despite the early hour and the pain in his shoulder. He drifted in and out until the sound of Oin’s voice woke him, cool, gentle hands pressing and pulling.

“Hurts,” he said, and Oin laughed quietly.

“Aye, that it would,” came the reply. “But I’ve a draught for that, and there’s no real damage, though I hear there might have been if you’d have been slower.”

“Felt slow enough,” Bilbo mumbled. “Like trying to throw a sack of potatoes across the room.”

“Am I the potatoes in this analogy, or you?” asked Thorin, and Bilbo realised he was sitting on the bed beside him, a warm hand in his hair and another on the ball of his shoulder, holding him gently in place while Oin looked at his injury. He had become so used to the warmth of Thorin’s skin that he hadn’t even noticed. Thorin’s voice was kind, and in it Bilbo could hear the unspoken words: let’s forget I said anything, don’t let me have burned that fragile peace we were rebuilding again.

So Bilbo smiled, and made a joke in response, and tried not to wonder at the strange masks they both seemed so happy to wear.

Eventually, he was sat up enough to be given a bitter herbal drink that warmed him through and left him feeling lethargic but just too awake to sleep, the pain dulled to something faint enough to ignore. Without him needing to ask, Thorin returned to bed beside him. He had with him a book, old and dusty, clearly something that had been brought in one of the caravans (the texts that had survived Smaug were understandably fragile, and Ori wouldn’t have let them out of the library for love nor money, not even for a King. He had grand plans for having them all transcribed and restored, but understood well enough that there was not yet the manpower to devote to such a task.

Thorin read aloud from it as Bilbo drifted in and out of sleep, some sections in Westron and others not, the sound of his voice melodic and low. He didn’t really follow what it was about – something to do with lost halls, and ancient kings, and dark winters endured against the odds, and finding a home where you thought you might not.

Fare forward, travellers! Not escaping from the past into different lives, or into any future; you are not the same people who left that station or who will arrive at any terminus came a voice, and to his tired mind he didn't know who it belonged to, whether it was his mother or his father or Gandalf or Thorin or even his own, echoing through his mind. What was real and what wasn't bled together, a haze of soft sound and warmth and aching loneliness in his chest.

He wasn’t sure if he dreamed the feeling on Thorin’s hands in his hair, or his soft voice calling his name, over and over again.

Chapter 4: quartet 4

Chapter Notes

Bilbo spent the next couple of days in bed before announcing himself recovered enough to return to his daily tasks. In truth, his shoulder felt like it was on fire, but he could not stand to be idle any longer. He wasn’t sure what was worse – the long hours spent alone while everyone else was busy, or being fussed over by friends when they stopped by to check in on him and try to keep him company. Both felt like an itch under his skin that he could not find relief for.

Being out and about didn’t stop the fussing – in fact, there were now even more dwarves who wanted to stop by and wish him well – but at least he could now thank them and feign an emergency that he was just on his way to deal with, and slip away quickly before he started to feel too terribly awkward at their kindness and gratitude. He spent several days like this, running errands and picking up extra tasks from the rest of the Company, double-checking lists and reports. The ache in his shoulder grew less, and he fell into bed each night tired enough that he fell asleep immediately, managing to avoid anything other than general pleasantries exchanged with Thorin. He felt like a hare in those childhood memories: fleet of foot but running to exhaustion in their attempts to outrun smoke and flame. The days passed swiftly enough this way that he missed entirely that it had been a full month since first they had been trapped in the mountain. 

The first sign that something was wrong – well, at least more wrong than anything else – came upon them slowly enough that none of the dwarves had realised at first. Like a knife in the dark it had been subtle, enough so that most of them dismissed it as the ordinary groaning of an old, storm-buried mountain-city: after all, there had been many strange sounds as the mountain had settled into the cold. But then the sounds grew worse. A low, muffled rumble somewhere, like a distant avalanche caught inside stone, echoing through the pipework like the cries of the dead.

It was Lir who finally called them to one of the forges. She looked tired, Bilbo couldn’t help but think, and thinner than she had been a month ago. Not just the rations – she had been stretching herself trying to ensure that everything was holding together. Butter scraped over too much bread, that's what Bilbo thought when he looked at her, illuminated by the low light of the furnace. 

The bellows pumped dutifully, but each stroke sounded choked, as though forcing breath through a too-narrow throat.

One by one, the dwarves gathered around the central furnace, listening to its faltering roar. Fili crouched beside the intake vents, his face grim as he pressed a palm to the metal grille.

“It should be warmer than that,” he said. “Hot, too hot to touch by this point in the morning. The air should be moving. But feel this—there’s hardly a draft at all.”

Lir nodded.

“Look,” she said, as she pulled back the shutters to reveal the fire within.

Inside, wood sputtered. Kindling stood blackened but not burned through, and the fire was far smaller than it ought to have been, as if it had retreated from the fuel left out for it. Even as they watched it danced and wavered, whole pieces of timber not catching as they should.

Gloin frowned at it. “That,” he muttered, “is not right.”

It was starving, Bilbo realised as it watched it closely: the erratic winds that had caused the wood to burn too quickly were now not present enough, and the fire could not catch it properly. The other dwarves had come to the same conclusion: he could tell from the sudden tension in the room and the way that all eyes had turned to Thorin, waiting for him to say something. But their king, for once, seemed to be at a loss.

“What’s causing it?” asked Fili, voice subdued. His hair was pulled back, unbraided today, as if he simply could not be bothered. Bilbo could see the tiredness sitting heavy around his eyes, the thin skin beneath them almost yellowed like old bruises. He looked so much older than the dwarf Bilbo had met all that time ago, like a year had aged him a hundred. Bilbo couldn’t help but think of him as an unruly child, but right now he looked like an adult, and the thought made him feel sad.

“Best guess?” Lir replied. “The ventilation shafts are old, I think. All records I can find on them date back centuries, and the metalwork is rudimentary compared to what was being made in Erebor by the reign of Thror. The old plans show that they are narrow, and follow some odd routes, with tight corners in places.”

Around them, the forge gave a shuddering pop, followed by a sickly gasp of a sound as the flame shrank again. The dwarves exchanged worried glances.

Lir cleared her throat. “Best case scenario, meltwater has gotten in, and then frozen in places, slowly narrowing them until they’ve choked up. Worst case-”

“The metal has collapsed,” Fili finished, tugging at his beard. “Blocked the airways entirely.”

A heavy silence fell.

“If the furnaces fail,” Gloin said quietly, “we won’t last long in this cold.”

“The shafts were old even in my grandfather’s day,” Balin added. “With a long period where they weren’t being used properly or maintained. They could be damaged. But they could also just be blocked – I don’t think there is any need for us to jump to the worst case scenario until we have properly investigated.”

Thorin nodded, slowly. His eyes were on the walls, where the air channels came out from, feeding the furnace, as he could see the shafts beyond, the veins buried deep within the mountain itself.

“Then we must look,” he said, and his voice was low. “We must look and act as quickly as possible.”

The ‘or else’ didn’t need to be said. The dwarves sprang into action. Bilbo trailed to the old libraries with Ori to see what documentation they could find on the routes the old ventilation shafts took, where he received a speedy lesson in this essential piece of mountain infrastructure. Many of the ventilation shafts, contrary to what he would have believed, ran horizontally and at strange diagonals to find entrances in the mountainside. They formed a latticework through the entire mountain, and he wondered at the ingenuity of it all. Hobbit smials were small enough things: what minds could forge cities like this, and build them, and make them work enough to shelter thousands of bodies as Erebor once had? 

Luckily they would not need to search all the ventilation shafts: he and Ori brought as many maps of them through as they could find, and Lir and the other structural engineers spent hours trying to match older records with newer, to see where changes may have been made over centuries, and to understand which shafts fed their section of the city, and the furnaces that they were using.

He sat back and watched them work from a niche in the wall, where once a tall column had stood. Now only its base remained, and it was a good Hobbit-sized base, a decent spot to tuck himself into and observe. Normally he would be alone as he watched, but today he found himself with company.

“Are you alright?” he asked Fili, after the young dwarf had propped himself up next to the old column base, frowning and silent. He was standing with his arms crossed, and wasn’t staring at anything in particular.

“As well as any of us, I suppose,” was Fili’s response, before he tilted his head to smile at Bilbo, who had a rare (albeit slight) height advantage from sitting on the base. “Just contemplating what will happen if Thorin collapses from the stress of it all and I have to take command. We’ll probably all die terribly, just so you know.”

Bilbo swatted at his head, but Fili pushed up into his hand, and Bilbo found himself rubbing the crown of Fili’s head instead, a gentle back and forth.

“I think you will do a wonderful job of it, when the time comes,” Bilbo replied, quietly. “Watching Thorin always feels intimidating, I think: it’s always hard watching anyone who is so confident and calm on the surface. But that does not mean he doesn’t struggle, and find things difficult and confusing. And you will too, once you are King, but I have faith in you, and so does your uncle and your mother. You will be a great King. But I don’t think it will be for some time yet.”

Fili’s eyes flickered towards him, just for a moment, and then he sighed.

“I owe you an apology, Bilbo,” he said, and he sounded tired and a little lost. “The others all feel bad about it, as well. We’ve been coming up with reasons to keep you here, Bilbo. Bofur and Kili and me in particular, but all of us have been doing it. None of us wanted you to leave, and we were all hoping you and Thorin would…”

Bilbo kept his eyes fixed on the wall ahead. His heart felt full, and breaking. Hearing it wasn’t really a surprise – he’d known, really, the reason the dwarves kept coming up with reasons for him to stay. He’d just never wanted to call them on it, because… well, it was complicated.  

“Kili’s been annoyed at Thorin, too,” Fili added. “He thinks Thorin should say something, to try and keep you here. I think I agreed with him, for a time, but – oh, I don’t know. I keep thinking about how my mother didn’t want us to come with the Company, and all the fights there were back in the Blue Mountains before we left. There was one evening, and she was just laying into Uncle Thorin – she wasn’t being fair, not really, but she was hurting, and she brought up Uncle Frerin. And Thorin just turned to look at her with the strangest look on his face, like I’ve never seen him before, and he just said to her that if he started locking up the people he loved because he was afraid of losing them then he’d be the first step down the same road as their grandfather.”

Bilbo swallowed, and his throat felt terribly tight. He had known this, deep in his heart, but hearing it from Fili made it feel so much more.

“And that makes me really afraid,” Fili continued, voice still low and quiet against the background of murmurs from the other dwarves assembled around the maps. “Because I’ve realised my first instinct was to try and keep you here, because you’re a part of this family, and the thought of losing you – and how much it would hurt Uncle Thorin, and Kili and everyone else, was something I couldn’t stand.”

Bilbo took a strand of his hair, and tugged. Fili’s head came backwards, so he was staring up at where Bilbo was perched half-behind him.

“You are nothing like your grandfather,” Bilbo told him. “Wanting to keep the people you love safe and close is not the same as the goldsickness, as long as you don’t take it too far. You didn’t lock me up, or do anything terrible.”

Fili smiled, a little sad. “I am still sorry though.”

Bilbo leaned down, and pressed a quick kiss to his forehead, like he had once kissed young cousins when they had scraped their knees, fill of comfort and surety.

“I forgive you,” Bilbo said. Some warmth came back to Fili’s eyes, and then he closed them as Bilbo began putting clumsy braids in his hair, both of them lulled by the movement and the sounds of the dwarves trying to find their salvation in old blueprints and structural reports.

It took some time, but finally they had a map, and about twenty miles of shafts to explore where a blockage could be found. Lir explained that the tunnels created a complex interweaving of air that fed in and out of many different bellows: the block could be anywhere in their isolated area, and they would have needed days of complex work in order to map the airflows enough to narrow it down further, which they simply did not have. A manual search would be quicker and, perhaps more importantly, would give the worrying dwarves something to do. Thorin organised teams, splitting the sections of the map and allocating them to different groups to explore so that they could cover the ground as quickly as possible. Bilbo tagged along behind the group Thorin was leading, too tense to stay behind and wait for news.

The ventilation shafts were wider than he expected: for the most part, all but the tallest of the dwarves were able to walk upright, although they had to walk in single file. They were carved from rock but reinforced by metal: one dwarf explained in hushed tones that they needed to do this where there were fault lines in the rock, or other weaknesses that needed to be reinforced. Apparently, this was made worse by deep mining equipment, which often sent vibrations through the rock, worsening fractures over time. 

They followed long passageways, carefully checking them and knocking ice off the walls where they could. At points they would hit sharp vertical shafts that were impossible to climb in the front, and they would be forced to retreat and loop around, finding another service entrance into the shaft at the next level. It was long, dull work, but Bilbo could feel the relief settling into the dwarves as mile after mile was covered with no signs of collapse and no word from other groups that they had found disaster. 

They were nearing the end of their allotted search area when they came across another vertical: they retreated as before and followed their rudimentary map to where the service hatch was supposed to be, in a small side room off a minor thoroughfare near the edge of the mountain. The streets around them were quiet and dusty, barely disturbed by the dragon, a section of the mountain that felt more like a ghost town than any of the more ruinous ones. No one wanted to mention how much colder it was out here, where the heating pipes had been cut off to preserve their fuel. Their own quarters might soon be similar if they were unable to fix the ventilation, and that was a thought no one wanted to vocalise. 

The dwarves in their group stopped around the doorway to the service room: Bilbo frowned at their backs for a moment before elbowing his way in to see what the problem was. 

Once, dwarves had built these shafts, and had needed to place a service hatch here. The murmurs of the dwarves immediately told Bilbo everything he needed to know: it had been a stupid idea. 

Rock was rock to Bilbo, but dwarves knew stone, and along the way he had learned that there was some rock that even dwarves struggled to tame: the densest, strongest rocks would yield only to time, patience, good stone-sense and specialised tools. A huge slab of such rock sat here, and the dwarves at the time and clearly given up on trying to cut through it. The hatch for the shaft was visible, down a narrow tunnel, but the gap to get into that tunnel was so small that Bilbo doubted any of the dwarves would be able to get through it. Old marks in the slab of stone that partially blocked it showed that they had tried to cut through, before eventually giving up and making do with what they could. Bilbo wasn’t sure if there had been a particularly small dwarf doing the work here ages ago, or if the rock had shifted making the entrance impossible to navigate, but either way they were at an impasse.

The dwarves around him were debating their options: they could try and loop around, find another entrance (though there were none on the map). They could go and find tools (with no guarantee that it would work) or call other dwarves in to consult (time, when they had perilously little of it). Expressions were strained: they could not leave it, not when there was a chance that this was where the problem was, but neither could they get into it. 

Bilbo tugged his cloak tighter around himself as a draft of cold slithered through the room. His shoulder ached again, but compared to the furnace trouble, his own bruises seemed terribly small.

“It’s going to have to be me,” he said to no one in particular. “I know what you’re all going to say, but you know as well as I do that I’m the only person in this mountain that can fit through that gap.”

Thorin stood beside the stone protrusion, face set and shadowed in the low light. “No,” he said, and his voice was cold marble, implacable. “It’s too narrow. Too unstable. Those shafts were never meant to be traversed in winter conditions. The ice shifts. The ceiling could collapse – again, Bilbo.”

Bilbo crouched, brushing frost from the edge of the rock as he stared down the narrow gap to the entrance to the ventilation shaft. “We've been walking through them all day Thorin. The only difference is that there will be only one of me. And if we don’t clear them, we’ll freeze to death. The furnaces need air. You know they do. I can go through, and I can check for myself whether there is something we can save, or whether we will need to abandon the mountain and try to find shelter elsewhere.”

Thorin’s jaw was set, and his eyes would not meet Bilbo’s. “We will find another way.”

“We don’t have time for another way,” Bilbo replied, frustrated. “Most of the tunnels have been checked by now, and no word has come that another team has found the problem, which means there is a strong chance it is in one of these unexplored tunnels. Every hour the fires weaken. The mountain without air will become our tomb, Thorin.”

Thorin flinched, just barely. It hit too close to memory, and though Bilbo regretted the hurt he could not bring himself to retract it. Bilbo softened his voice. “I’m small. I can fit where the rest of you can’t. I’ve done worse things for you, Thorin Oakenshield.”

Thorin met his eyes, finally, and his expression was devastating.

“Give us the room,” he said, and for a moment Bilbo didn’t know who he was speaking to: he had forgotten their audience, that there were twenty dwarves standing watching them, now glancing at each other awkwardly as they shuffled out of the room, closing the door behind them.

The room seemed strangely smaller now it was just the two of them in there. Thorin’s next words came rough and low.

"There were rumours there was a tunnel built between Erebor and Dale," Thorin said. "Down in Old Erebor. My father said something about it to me once. It wasn't - Thror ordered it, I think. I think he might have had the dwarves that dug it killed afterwards, though I don't know that for certain, but my father said there were secret marks that could show you the way. I wanted Nori to see if he could find it - he knows a lot of the secret marks, more than anyone else I know."

“Did he find it?”

Thorin flinched.

“He thinks he’s found some of the markings. With enough time-”

“Which we don’t have,” Bilbo replied. “And even if he did, we have no guarantee that the tunnels down there are intact, or that they will hold enough to move everyone through it. And if we do, we will become Dale’s problem – and we don’t know if they have food or fuel enough to keep us.”

Thorin swallowed. The sound was audible in the quiet room, and Bilbo could see the movement of it. Every tiny motion Thorin made was familiar to him, as seen and known as the lines on his own palm. He reached out, and took Thorin’s hand in his.

“I want to tell you that I forbid you, and that I cannot bear to lose you or see you hurt again.”

Bilbo nodded. “I know.”

“But-” and Thorin rubbed his free hand across his face, hiding his expression. “I can’t say any of that, because I know who you are, Bilbo Baggins. You are stubborn and wonderful and wilful and you are not mine to command.”

For a heartbeat, neither spoke. Snowmelt dripped somewhere in the dark, a slow metronome. A guttering sigh cut across it, and Bilbo realised that it had come from him.

“I owe you an apology,” Thorin said. “For telling you I loved you. It was not fair of me to do that to you, to put you in that position. Your forgiveness has already been more than I deserve.”

Footfalls echo in the memory, down the passage we did not take, towards the door we never opened Bilbo thought, absently. Where was that from? Something his mother had read him once, perhaps.

“It’s not that I don’t feel the same,” Bilbo replied, voice quiet enough that you could almost have missed it. “And it's not that I haven’t forgiven you. It isn’t even that I don’t want to stay here, or that I have to go back to the Shire – it’s more complicated than all of that-”

He broke off, and glanced into the darkness at the corners of the room. There were more words he needed to say, but they were bitter. He cleared his throat, looking down at his feet.

 “But that doesn’t matter right now.” he said, attempting a smile. “I’ll be back before you know it.”

“Bilbo.” Thorin’s voice held warning, plea, frustration—far too many things. But Bilbo only gave a small bow, slung one of the small pick-axes brought by the dwarves over his shoulder, and ducked into the narrow throat of the shaft, disappearing into the dark.

 


 

The thing about tunnels, Bilbo was realising, is that he really didn't like them.

It had been easy enough to get to the hatch, which had opened with some ease: dwarves made good doors, even when they were centuries old. The darkness within had swallowed him almost at once. Bilbo had known it would be narrow, as all of the shafts were, but he hadn’t expected this—a stone throat scarcely wide enough for his shoulders, forcing him to push his way through. Thorin's protests had been for nothing, he realised: even if they had got through to the hatch, none of the dwarves would have fit. These shafts must have been forced small by the rock around them: probably more of that dense, uncuttable stone. His lantern was held ahead of him, the flame stable and true, but it lit hardly anything, and every shift caused shadows to climb the walls that sent his heart racing at the sight of them. A thin film of ice glittered on the walls, brushing off against him as he went, patterns in the hoarfrost marking the way. 

The silence was the worst of it. It pressed against him like another layer of stone.

He inched forward, feeling the air grow thinner, the cold sharper. Every time he thought he heard something he paused, listening. Any crack, any shift of ice or stone could mean disaster, and now he was alone in here the thought dying alone in the dark felt somehow magnified. He imagined the shaft collapsing in on him, imagined the mountain sealing its lungs for good, and his throat tightened. He wanted to leave. He wanted to turn and run and return to Thorin where it was safe and he could be looked after.

But if it was blocked, further down, then he was their only chance. 

He carried the echoes of Thorin's words with him, the apology that Bilbo didn't need, his voice rough with worry and concern. To Bilbo's surprise, the thought of it steadied him. He squeezed himself through a tighter section, ribs brushing stone, breath shallow. Claustrophobia clawed at him. The shaft seemed to narrow with every foot of progress, darkness thickening behind and ahead. Which dwarf had built this? It seemed impossible, and he couldn't see any metal plates, any mark of axe or pick in the wall. Had they re-purposed natural tunnels for this section?

But his hands did not tremble. Brave, he thought, almost surprised. When did I grow brave?

A faint glimmer caught his eye ahead, and he pushed forward, to find his way blocked by ice, a strange and translucent sheet of it, stretched across a section of the tunnel. Water had got in here, he thought absently: this was running water, frozen still. He angled his lantern, and for a moment his own face stared back at him, before the light shifted and it was gone. Through the ice, he thought he could see the way forward. Hesitantly, he started at it with his pick, and it surrendered quickly.

The shards of it crunched underfoot. The air was still here, he realised: it tasted strange, and musty against his tongue.

The air wasn’t moving.

Bilbo ran.

Well, ran might be a bit of an exaggeration, but he certainly moved as fast as he could through the dark, narrow tunnel, sudden hope clawing at his throat, his heart a war drum in his chest. The shadows leapt around him, but they no longer set his heart to racing: all he could think was that here, somewhere here-

There.

The lantern light against the wall of ice was a sudden and blinding flash and he skidded to a halt. The ice had bedded in a point in the tunnel where it was naturally narrow, where Bilbo himself would have struggled to fit through. A rockslide at some point in history had narrowed it, and now the ice had found its way in. He pressed his palm against it and felt how solid it was, how long it must have been growing. It felt impossible to break.

In the silence he could feel the vibrations of what he knew to be the bellows, straining; he could almost hear the distant groan of the forges starving for air.

The dwarves would never reach this place in time. Not with the passages this narrow, not without finding a work around. The day was already drawing to a close, and if the furnaces failed overnight – well, it didn’t bear thinking about.

Bilbo Baggins stared at the ice, a small hobbit such a long way from home, and then hefted his pick.

He hacked at the ice with numb fingers and a tool he didn’t really know how to use, the vibration running straight up his arms until his shoulder throbbed, until the rest of him ached alongside it. Shards broke away reluctantly, splintering, crashing around his feet and causing him to skid every time he had to reposition himself. He felt frenetic, wild, even as the palms of his hands split and his gloves soaked through with blood. Every time he thought he couldn’t do it any more, when the pain in his shoulders and arms grew too great, he leant against that ice, for moment, panting, before forcing himself to raise that pick up again.

By the time the blockage finally gave way, he was shaking, his arms limp and his head aching. But he was met with the sweetest sensation: a rush of air tore through the tunnel, cold and fresh, moving through him like a ghost. Bilbo staggered at the feeling of it, at the cold and the sudden rush of euphoria. He had done this. Beneath his feet he could feel the bellows picking up, the deep heartbeat of the mountain.

He dropped the pick and simply stood there, chest heaving, exhausted, his head hanging.

The ice lay around him in splinters and shards: in their surfaces he could see himself, broken apart into a thousand different fragments. There were his eyes, older and more lined than he remembered, but holding steady. There was his hair, longer than it had ever been. There were his shoulders, and the burdens they carried. The curve of his cheek, bloodied gloves, a smudge of dirt and what he dearly hoped was lichen on his on his forehead.

"That's who I am, isn't it?" he said, to himself. 

Stubborn and wilful and wonderful, that's what Thorin had called him. Him, not the hobbit he had once been. That hobbit would have hidden from the world, would never have seen its wonders. That hobbit was so afraid of hurting that he never let himself feel anything at all. That hobbit had suffocated himself underneath layers of so many things that didn't matter that he didn't know what did. He didn’t fit the shape of the person he used to be –

But why did he want to?

The thought was hot in his mind in the cold aftermath of the pain in his body, of the stark realisation. The thought landed with a new weight in him, filling him like air. He realised - suddenly, sharply - that he had been searching for an older version of himself as if it were something he could reclaim, something he could find and become again. As if it were something lost rather than something outgrown. The ink fades on old letters, even the ones you love and keep safely. You can’t walk the same roads again. You will never be the person you used to be.

He had been so busy worrying about how to become his old self that he hadn’t ever stopped to ask himself why.

This version of himself was not a mistake. He wasn’t a failure for having changed.

Blood dripped from his hand to the ice below, obscuring his view of himself, and Bilbo realised he was smiling.

The air was moving freely. Bilbo exhaled, long and slow, and turned back down the tunnel.

He was smiling, and he kept glancing down at himself, as if he was seeing his body for the first time. That must have been why he didn’t notice when he turned down the wrong passage, a narrow offshoot that he had missed in his panicked dash in the dark. He only realised that he was not going the way he thought he was when the passageway opened abruptly into a space.

Was it a room or was it a cave? He wasn’t sure. Half the space was carved, the angles precise but worn; the other half was natural cave, flowing and uneven. The room had been made into a chamber of sorts, octagonal and ancient feeling. The floor was marble, grimy with years of dirt and water moving through, but beneath that it shone in the light from his torch, tessellated with quartz that Bilbo didn’t have names for. In the centre of the room stood an ancient statue, once clearly a dwarf but now so eroded by centuries of dripping water that it was more stalagmite than sculpture. Mineral clouded its surface, catching the torchlight until it glowed softly.

He lifted the light, and inhaled audibly.

All around him, on every surface of the room, eyes were carved. Hundreds of them, watching from every direction and angle. What had this place been, long ago? A shrine, some sacred space, lost to time and history? These were the eyes from Old Erebor – old spirits, Ori had called them.

The Shire had old spirits too, he knew. They lived in pine trees and ancient oaks, in fields and furrows. They watched over the people of the Shire, over traditions and people rooted so deep in the soil that moving away felt next to impossible.

“See me,” he said to the spirits, if any were there to listen.  

Things had hurt. He had changed.

That was good.

If he hadn’t changed, he wouldn’t be here. He wouldn’t have survived. He wouldn’t have been able to save the mountain and the dwarves from the cold. Things had hurt, but maybe that was okay. He liked who he was. All the dwarves were changing too, rediscovering parts of themselves that they had lost and growing into the people they would become, and he loved them, all of them. They were his family – a new family, after losing his parents, and not everyone was lucky enough to get that in life. He’d been so afraid of change, of allowing himself to be happy, afraid that if he allowed himself to settle and stay in Erebor then it would be taken away from him again. He’d been pulling away before the ground beneath him could feel solid.

And Thorin – he had Thorin here. And just because they had once lost each other, to gold and pride and the Arkenstone, did not mean they would again. And even if they did… they had found each other once before. They could do it again. They could do it a thousand times, if they had to. He would know the sound of Thorin’s breathing in the darkness. He would know his heartbeat across a room, could find his eyes across a battlefield. He loved him.

What was he doing?

He looked up at the carved eyes and swallowed.

“Look at me, see me,” he whispered again.

There were old traditions here, ancient places that did not belong to him—but perhaps they could. Just as much as pine wreaths and fleeing hares and holly berries and the carved overlapping B’s of his old life once had. This mountain, with its tall ceilings and stone floors and his new family, could become everything he needed as well: he just needed to let go of all the things holding him back.

He could carry his home with him, every step of the way, and still find a home somewhere else. He could carry the person he had once been, without it compromising the person he was now. He could love the people he had lost, and love those who were with him now as well. He could contain multitudes.

He was smiling still, but Bilbo found that his cheeks were wet as well. He could smell the resinous pine, could see a constellation of stars behind his closed eyes.

“Alright,” he said to the dark.

It was only when he opened his eyes that he realised he wasn’t just imagining the smell of pine: it was there, the smoke hazy and milky in the light. Fresh and sharp, and unmistakable: the pine needles he and Oin had found, that had been burning every day since. He laughed, and turned his back on the eyes, and followed the smoke. It led him through a different narrow passage, and another, the shafts growing warmer until he finally found a hatch that led him out. The corridor was dimly lit, but when he pressed a hand against the stone he felt the warmth from the heating pipes, already roaring to life again.

The first person he nearly collided with was Dwalin.

Dwalin grabbed him by the shoulders, then pulled him into a crushing embrace without hesitation. It stole the breath from Bilbo’s lungs, but he clung back just as tightly, laughing a little.

“You vanished,” Dwalin said, voice more of a rumble from where Bilbo was held against his chest. “We heard the air change, knew you’d done it then. But then you didn’t come back – Thorin’s going spare.”

Bilbo pulled away, blinking. “Sorry. I… got turned around.”

Dwalin was staring down at him now, and he was frowning a little. The thing with Dwalin, Bilbo thought, is that people underestimated him. They saw his bulk and his axes and didn’t look past them to the extremely astute dwarf underneath, the one who had been managing the security of the royal family for years, the one who could read dwarves like books.

“You look happy,” Dwalin said, and it was neutral, deliberately so. Bilbo knew he could leave it if he was so inclined – but he wasn’t, not really.

Bilbo nodded, and patted Dwalin’s arm. “I think I needed a bit of time to come to terms with some things,” he said, after a moment of reflection. “And I think I have.”

Dwalin nodded, almost smiling. “Sounds like some time in the dark did you good.”

Bilbo smiled back, tired but lighter than he had felt in a long while. “I’m going to warm up. Could you let everyone know I’m back? And tell Thorin if he’s panicking, he can come find me back at home, but that I’m perfectly alright.”

Dwalin clapped his shoulder. “Gladly.”

He wandered back at a gentle pace, running his hands along the stonework, feeling with pleasure the warmth coming through the stone again. The storm outside had them in its grip still, but at least for now, everything was okay again. He passed the door of the room he was sharing with Thorin, hesitating only a moment before deciding against it. Instead he headed for the communal living room they shared and curled up in an armchair in the corner. If he focused, he could hear the pipes in the walls on either side of him, rattling happily at the increased airflow and warmth, relaxing the metal.

Bilbo could feel it seeping into his bones, his ribs expanding as he breathed in for the first time in what felt like months.

 He barely had time to settle before the doors burst open. Thorin strode in, his face pale and rock dust scuffing his coat. He looked equal parts frustrated and worried, and those warring emotions seemed to meld and then disintegrate as his eyes found Bilbo’s.

“You scared me,” Thorin said, rubbing at his eyes. “Next time you go on a perilous mission alone to save the lives of every dwarf in a twenty-mile radius and my newly reclaimed kingdom, try not to disappear, would you?”

Bilbo stood up, and walked over to Thorin, and took his face in his hands. Thorin’s beard was soft beneath his fingers, and so were his eyes. This close, Bilbo could see that they were tired, and a little red, and so terribly familiar.

“I didn’t give you an answer,” he said, quietly. “When you told me I could stay.”

Thorin was still beneath his hands: Bilbo could feel his own heartbeat in his fingertips, and he smiled. There was no easy way to say hard things, he was coming to realise, but he thought Thorin understood him anyway, from the tentative way that the dwarf was beginning to smile, from the cautious warmth coming into his eyes.

“I’d like to make my home here,” Bilbo told him, because even if Thorin understood he deserved the words as well, after so many silences. “With the Company, and with you. I’m sorry I had to make you wait a while – I just needed a bit of time to work out who I am.”

Thorin shook his head. “I would have waited for the rest of my life,” he said quietly, confessional. “Though I’m glad that I do not have to do so, I will admit.”

Bilbo pulled him down for that, and kissed him, trying hard not to laugh – right up until the moment that Thorin wrapped his arms around him, hauling him close, and suddenly laughing was the last thing on his mind.

 


 

In a couple of weeks the storm would pass: Bilbo would wake in Thorin’s arms and realise that he was, much to his dismay, too warm. There would be huge amounts of work to do: the lost caravan would need to be contacted, missives would need to be sent to Dale, they would need to restock everything and work out what had been damaged. New trade deals would need to be worked out to resupply the mountain, and they would need to talk to Dale about any potential damage to crops that had been planted in advance of the spring. Hunting and fishing parties would need to be arranged, and they would need to start migrating people back to their own rooms to prevent close quarters stretching tempers any more than already. They needed to restart work in a hundred different areas around the mountain, and they would need to work out which areas got immediate priority and which would have to wait, and they needed to make sure that Lir took a holiday.

All that would come. In those first moments after the storm passed, however, Bilbo simply rolled over, and pressed his face to the warm skin over his sternum, smiling as Thorin stirred, and tightened his arms around him.

 


 

We shall not cease from exploration
And the end of all our exploring
Will be to arrive where we started
And know the place for the first time.

Chapter End Notes

all quotes (and general vibe inspiration) from T. S. Eliot's Four Quartets.

My contribution to this year's BBC midwinter gift exchange (general prompt: snowed in). I was really happy to be gifting to the lovely Peregrine, who also organised the whole event - thank you for all your hard work!

Afterword

Please drop by the Archive and comment to let the creator know if you enjoyed their work!