Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

Actions

Work Header

Father's Shame

Summary:

Frodo Baggins grows up a bit odd compared to most hobbit children—taller, broader, and even capable of growing facial hair. Curious about his unusual traits, he wonders if his other father might be a Stoor hobbit. His suspicion deepens as bearded visitors arrive at Bag End each year, reinforcing his belief that there’s more to his heritage than he’s been told.

Written by DrakeShadeDShadowheart; art by SavioBriion.

Notes:

I promise you this is sweet but it will hurt at first! Thank you SavioBriion for being my artist again and for betaing this! Fic 24 for Thorin's Spring Forge 2025!

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Work Text:

A-Fathers-Shame.png

Frodo’s first memory of his Adad is a foggy one. When he opens his eyes for the first time, he sees his Papa’s copper curls, round freckled cheeks, and a soft smile looking down at him. Papa is sweaty and looks incredibly tired, but Frodo notices he is very happy. Why? Frodo doesn’t know. All he knows is the urge to reach for him, because he feels safe. Papa Bilbo leans closer, letting Frodo’s tiny fingers wrap around his.

“Welcome to the world, my little miracle,” Papa Bilbo says softly, his voice full of joy. Frodo coos in response, drawn to the warmth in his  voice. That’s when he notices another face. This one has black hair streaked with silver, a square bearded jaw, and beautiful blue eyes. Frodo squeals with delight.

“You did it, Bilbo. Our little boy…” the new face says. Frodo doesn’t yet know who this person is, but when the bearded face takes him in his arms, Frodo feels the same safety he feels with Papa Bilbo. Something inside him knows this is his other parent.

“What should we name him?” the bearded face asks.

“Frodo, Frodo Baggins. It means wise, you see,” Papa Bilbo replies softly. The bearded face smiles and nods.

“Frodo… I love it. You shall be Frodo then, my sweet pebble,” the bearded face says, smiling down at him with such happiness. But then the smile fades, replaced by a deep sadness. “Frodo… I will not always be here for you. I won’t be able to help your Papa Bilbo raise you. But remember this, I love him, and I love you. And I will always come back.”

Frodo doesn’t understand the words, but he feels the sadness between his parents. He begins to cry, his tiny wails filling the room, until Papa Bilbo gently takes him back into his arms. Something soft is placed into his mouth, and he begins to suckle, tasting sweetness for the first time. He suckles happily, the sadness forgotten.

As he feeds, Frodo watches the bearded face kiss Papa Bilbo. “Farewell, amrâlimê. I will come back. I promise you this. Write to me often, for I shall do the same. I will miss you and our dashat dearly.”

“I will miss you as well. Safe travels, my love,” Papa Bilbo replies, kissing the bearded face once more. When they part, tears stream down both their faces. Frodo notices the tears briefly, but the sweetness in his mouth distracts him, soothing him. All he knows is that he is safe here.

He yawns for the first time in his life, his small body surrendering to weariness, and soon drifts into a peaceful sleep.


His next memory is one of pure joy. Frodo giggles as he toddles around Bag End with a wide smile on his face, while Papa Bilbo busies himself in the kitchen. Ever since Frodo mastered walking without toppling over, he has begun to explore the smial beyond his usual space. With a delighted, loud laugh,  he scampers into the living room, flapping his little arms like the black birds that often visit Bag End. He runs in circles, delighted by his own game, until something catches his eye: the fireplace.

He stops abruptly and stares. He remembers the fireplace being bright and warm, but now it sits dark and cold. Curious, he crawls closer to inspect it. Reaching into the hearth, he grabs a handful of something soft, powdery, and fine to the touch. He examines it, giggling as his hand turns black. Frodo begins playing in the ashes, patting them onto the floor and smearing them on his clothes.

A few moments later, Papa Bilbo walks into the living room, smiling after finishing his kitchen task. “Frodo! Where are you, my little sprout? Won’t you come help your Papa- YAVANNA’S GREEN GARDENS, WHAT ARE YOU DOING?!”

Papa Bilbo’s horrified exclamation startles Frodo for a moment, but then he looks up, his face and hands covered in ash, and beams brightly. “Papa! Papa!”

“Oh, you naughty little faunt,” Papa Bilbo says with an exaggerated sigh, rolling his eyes playfully. He strides over and scoops Frodo up into his arms. Frodo giggles, snuggling into his Papa, leaving streaks of black soot all over Bilbo’s vest.

“Ugh, another vest ruined! Oh, what would your grandpapa say?” Bilbo cries out dramatically, which only makes Frodo laugh harder.

“It looks like you need a bath, my little seedling. Come here,” Bilbo says with mock sternness. Frodo squeals with laughter as Papa Bilbo carries him to the bathroom. Once there, Bilbo hums a soft tune while he begins preparing a bath. He carefully tests  the water’s temperature, ensuring it’s just right, before he starts removing Frodo’s sooty clothes.

As he works, he gently scolds, “Not only did you make a mess of your own clothes, but you’ve turned the whole living room into a disaster. I suppose I should have expected this, considering who your Adad is.”

Frodo giggles at the teasing tone, sensing no real frustration in Papa Bilbo’s voice. His laughter makes Bilbo chuckle in return. “Oh, you think this is funny, do you, you young rascal? Why, I should punish you! Perhaps by making you help me in the kitchen.”

“No!” Frodo cries out gleefully, his laughter bubbling up again as Bilbo lifts him into the tub. The water is shallow and safe, and Frodo immediately begins splashing, sending droplets flying everywhere. His laughter fills the small room, making  Bilbo shake his head fondly.

Watching Frodo’s joy, Bilbo smiles to himself. He suspects his son will be a swimmer, a rarity among hobbits. Frodo’s love for water is unlike any fauntling he’s ever known.

Still humming, Papa Bilbo scrubs Frodo clean, his hands gentle yet efficient. Frodo leans into his touch, pressing his soft, fuzzy  cheek against Bilbo’s palm as he  brushes away the soot. He seems utterly content, and Bilbo can’t help but smile.

“Do you know who is coming over today?” Papa Bilbo asks with a soft smile. Frodo shakes his head, prompting Papa Bilbo to chuckle. “Our birthday will be here in a week. That means your family will be visiting! They’ll bring you presents, and you’ll get to give them presents too! And then we’ll have a party! You’d like that, wouldn’t you?”

“Food?” Frodo asks eagerly, his eyes lighting up. Papa Bilbo laughs as he rinses Frodo off in the bath.

“Yes, there will be food, lots of it!” Papa Bilbo replies, making Frodo squeal in delight. “So much food that you won’t even be able to eat it all!”

“Eat!” Frodo declares happily, splashing in the water. Papa Bilbo chuckles again at his enthusiasm.

After finishing the bath, Bilbo lifts Frodo out and wraps him in a towel, drying him off gently. “Now, my son, you need to dress properly. A proper Baggins should greet friends and family with a clean face and a polite smile, your grandpapa always used to say that. Now, what would you like to wear today?”

Papa Bilbo lays out three sets of clothes, each one meticulously tailored with geometric and floral patterns in various shades of blue. Frodo studies them carefully before pointing to the set that looks the most like what Papa Bilbo is wearing. “This!”

“Good choice!” Papa Bilbo says as he helps Frodo into the clothes. Once dressed, the faunt happily admires himself in the mirror. Meanwhile, Bilbo swaps out his own stained vest for a clean one. Frodo pouts when he notices they no longer match and is about to voice his complaint, but then a knock sounds at the door.

“Oh! That must be them!” Papa Bilbo exclaims, scooping Frodo up into his arms as he heads for the front door. “Oh, my sprout, you’re getting heavy!” he teases, making Frodo giggle.

When they open the door, a large group of bearded hobbits, all taller than Bilbo, stands outside. They erupt in cheerful hellos and greetings, their joy filling the air. Frodo squeals with delight at the sight of them.

“Hello, Frodo! Remember me?” asks a young hobbit whose stubble barely qualifies as a beard. He smiles hopefully, but when Frodo shyly shakes his head, the young hobbit clutches his chest dramatically. “Oh, Fee! Our cousin doesn’t remember me!” he cries out in mock anguish.

“Too bad, Kee! But he totally remembers me, right?” another hobbit with golden hair and a short beard declares proudly, pushing the first one aside. The first hobbit huffs in annoyance. “Frodo! It’s me, Cousin Fíli! You remember your favorite cousin, don’t you?”

“Hey, no fair! Don’t tell him your name!” The first hobbit protests, feigning outrage. He bursts into laughter, however, when Frodo shakes his head again.

“Can you two please behave yourselves? I want to say hello too!” a hobbit with an impressively thick red beard complains, stepping forward. Frodo’s eyes light up with recognition.

“Gimli!” Frodo cries out joyfully, reaching for him. The red-bearded hobbit sputters and blushes as Frodo eagerly stretches toward him, while the first two cousins glare in disbelief. Papa Bilbo chuckles and hands Frodo over to Gimli, who cradles him gently in his arms.

“Aye, it’s me, young cousin. You’re growing fast,” Gimli says, his voice warm, though he pointedly ignores the glares from Fíli and Kíli.

An older version of Gimli, his father, perhaps, laughs heartily alongside a bearded hobbit with wispy grey hair.

“Seems like the little prince has a favorite cousin,” a white-haired hobbit teases, his eyes twinkling with mischief.

“Aye, seems so. Well, out of the three of them, at least Gimli has some sense,” adds a bald hobbit with a thick beard, grinning broadly.

A hobbit with a star-like hairdo suddenly cries out, “Alright! Hand over the coins! I knew he’d remember Gimli first!”

“Brother, stop that,” chides another hobbit, this one with a neatly groomed beard and hair, shaking his head in exasperation.

“Um, hi, Frodo…” says a hobbit with a thin, short brown beard, shyly waving at Frodo. Still in Gimli’s arms, Frodo waves back shyly, his large smile warming everyone’s hearts.

“Here’s your early birthday present!” a hobbit wearing a funny hat steps forward, handing Frodo a maraca. When Frodo shakes it, the instrument rattles loudly, making him giggle with delight.

“Here, take this too!” The fattest of the hobbits cheerfully hands Frodo a pouch filled with baked goods. Frodo claps his hands together, crying out a thank you before eagerly munching on the treats.

“Bombur, you’re going to ruin his tea time,” Papa Bilbo teases playfully, though the hefty hobbit merely shrugs with a wide grin.

A bearded hobbit with a large scar on his head then steps forward, offering Frodo a wind-up wooden frog. When activated, the frog croaks loudly, causing Frodo to squeal with happiness.

But then, a hush falls over the group as another hobbit steps forward and gently takes Frodo into his arms. This hobbit has the same striking blue eyes as Frodo, a neatly groomed beard, and long dark hair streaked with grey. His voice is deep yet soft as he asks, “Hello, my Frodo. Did you miss me?”

Frodo stares up at his face, saying nothing. But he feels a deep sense of comfort in his arms. Smiling softly, Frodo cuddles closer, burying his face in the hobbit’s chest. The bearded hobbit chuckles and presses a gentle kiss to Frodo’s forehead before leaning down to kiss Papa Bilbo softly on the lips.

“Welcome home, Thorin. Come inside, let me tell you all about how Frodo has been doing,” Bilbo says warmly, leading the group of bearded hobbits into Bag End.


Frodo’s next memory is of his first days at school. He hums a tune as he carefully draws his Stoor side of the family. He learns from his teacher that Stoors are the only type of hobbits who can grow beards, so his family must be Stoors. He also learns that they live beyond the river, far from Hobbiton, which explains why they can’t stay for long visits.

Frodo giggles as he admires his drawing, a satisfied smile spreading across his face. He plans to show it to his cousins and uncles when they come for his birthday. But then he frowns, pouting as he realizes he’s forgotten someone important. With a sudden gasp, he grabs his coal and begins to draw the missing figure, his Adad Thorin. Frodo makes him the largest figure in the picture because Adad is the biggest and strongest person he knows.

“Alright, everyone! Have you all finished your drawings? Who would like to share theirs with the class and explain what they drew?” the teacher calls out cheerfully.

At once, many fauntlings, including Frodo, raise their hands, waving them enthusiastically and shouting to be picked.

Despite Frodo’s excitement, he isn’t chosen first. He sits back in his chair and listens as his classmates share their drawings. Most of them talk about their pets, their homes, their favorite games, flowers, or family. Whenever someone talks about their family, Frodo feels a little sad. Unlike theirs, his family isn’t always together. He rarely gets to see his Adad Thorin. But his sadness melts away when the teacher finally calls his name.

“Frodo Baggins, why don’t you share your drawing with us? Would you like to take your turn now?” the teacher asks with a kind smile.

“Yes, please!” Frodo exclaims, running to the front of the class. He proudly holds up his drawing for everyone to see.

“I have a lot of uncles and cousins!” Frodo begins with excitement, pointing to the different figures on his drawing. “This here is Cousin Fíli and Cousin Kíli! They’re my fun cousins! They’re really loud but super kind! And this one is Cousin Gimli! He isn’t as loud, but he’s really brave! He even protected me from an orc!”

The class collectively gasps, while the teacher hides a knowing smile, assuming it must be an imaginary orc… right?

“And this is Uncle Balin. He’s really smart! And here’s Uncle Dwalin, he doesn’t have hair like the others, only the ones on his chin, but he’s super strong! Uncle Bombur makes amazing snacks, but not as good as my Papa’s! Uncle Bofur is so funny, he loves to tell jokes! Uncle Bifur looks kinda scary, but he’s really nice, and he loves making me toys! Uncle Dori talks a lot! Uncle Nori says he’s chatty, and Uncle Nori is a wizard! He made a coin disappear in front of my eyes and then pulled it right out of my ear!”

The class gasps again, and the teacher raises an eyebrow, recognizing the common parlor trick but smiling at Frodo’s enthusiasm anyway.

“Uncle Ori loves telling stories, and he knows so many!” Frodo takes a deep breath, eager to continue. “And then there’s my Adad Thorin! He’s really strong, way stronger than Uncle Dwalin! Uncle Ori says he’s a hero! He fought in battles and won! Uncle Bofur says he even fought a dragon! Adad Thorin is so cool! And he always makes my Papa Bilbo really happy! When Adad Thorin is around, he even lets me stay up late!”

Frodo beams as he finishes, his smile stretching from ear to ear. He talks a little more about his Stoor family, his excitement contagious. By the time he returns to his seat, the entire class is smiling, and even the teacher looks charmed by his story.

One of Frodo’s classmates leans over and asks, “Can we meet them?”

Frodo frowns and shakes his head. “No. They aren’t here yet. But they will be!” he adds quickly, trying to sound cheerful. Still, his frown returns when he sees the disappointed look on his classmate’s face. This little exchange makes Frodo wonder why his family isn’t here yet, and the thought makes him sadder by the moment. By the time school is over and Papa Bilbo picks him up, Bilbo immediately notices his downcast mood.

“My little miracle, what’s wrong? Did someone tease you about your whiskers? Remember, they’re just jealous because they can’t grow any,” Papa Bilbo teases gently, scratching Frodo’s hairy cheeks. Frodo giggles for a moment but then frowns again.

“Papa... when will Adad come? Will they come?” Frodo asks, his blue eyes starting to water. Papa Bilbo kneels down and wraps his son in a comforting hug.

“Of course he will, my boy. Of course they will. They’ve never missed our birthday, and they never will. All we have to do is wait, okay?” Papa Bilbo soothes, rubbing soft circles on Frodo’s back. Frodo nods and rubs his eyes.

“Alright, Papa,” he says softly, taking Bilbo’s hand as they begin walking back to Bag End. Frodo feels a little better; it’s true, they’ve never missed his birthday, so they won’t miss it now. As they walk, Frodo chatters about his day at school, sharing what he learned, the games he played, and mentioning the drawing he made, which he keeps hidden in his bag. “Can I show it to Adad when he comes?” he asks.

“ Of course you can, Frodo. He’ll love it,” Papa Bilbo replies with a warm smile. “Do you want to  show it to your cousins and uncles too?”

“Of course! They’re in it too, so they have to see it!” Frodo says happily, his grin returning. Bilbo chuckles at his enthusiasm.

“I’m sure they’ll adore it, Frodo! Why, you’re an amazing artist! We should go to the market and have it framed, don’t you think?” Papa Bilbo suggests with a twinkle in his eye. Frodo eagerly nods.

Frodo later remembers that Papa Bilbo is right. When his Adad Thorin and the rest of his Stoor family arrive that year for his birthday, they all love his drawing and shower him with praise. His Adad Thorin, in particular, gently presses a kiss to Frodo’s forehead and tells him how proud he is of him. It becomes one of Frodo’s happiest memories.


One of Frodo’s memories, bittersweet yet cherished, is of writing a letter to his Adad Thorin.

 

“Dear Adad,

It’s me, Frodo! I hope Roac gives you my letter! It’s spring here! Flowers are blooming! Many baby animals have arrived! And soon it’ll be the Flower Dance Festival! Everyone will dress up and get covered in flowers! We even wear these tiny bells around our wrists and ankles! And Adad, I know it’s not my birthday, but can you join us for it? Please? I promise I’ll eat my vegetables!”

 

Frodo writes eagerly, his small hand carefully forming each letter. When he finishes, he hands the letter to Papa Bilbo to check his spelling.

Papa Bilbo reads the letter and his face softens into a sad expression, one that confuses Frodo. Why would Papa look like that? After a deep breath, Papa Bilbo begins to write his own letter alongside Frodo’s. Curious, Frodo tries to peek at what his Papa is writing, but Bilbo gently stops him with a smile.

“My little sapling, can you be a dear and give Roac some nuts while I finish this?” he asks.

“Of course I can!” Frodo chirps, running off to the pantry. He returns moments later with a small bowl of nuts, heading straight to the window where Roac, their ever-reliable raven messenger, waits patiently. “Here you go, Roac! Enjoy!”

“Thank you, little prince,” Roac says, his voice deep and kind as he begins to eat. Frodo always finds Roac fascinating; he’s the only animal Frodo knows that can talk.

“Roac, what do you think Adad is doing right now?” Frodo wonders aloud, sitting cross-legged on the floor near the raven.

“If I know your Adad well, and I do, little prince, I believe he is lamenting his position in Erebor,” Roac replies with a chuckle.

“Lamenting? What does that mean?” Frodo asked, confused.

Roac smiled, as much as a raven could smile, anyway. “Regretting, I suppose.”

“Why would he be regretting it?” Frodo asks, tilting his head in curiosity.

“Because he isn’t here with you and your Papa. Your Adad loves you both very much, and it pains him deeply to be apart from you,” Roac answers, his tone gentle as he picks at another nut.

Frodo’s eyes light up with hope. “Does that mean he’ll come for the Flower Dance Festival?”

At this, Roac pauses. Even Bilbo’s writing comes to a halt as he looks at the raven. Roac straightens himself, meeting Frodo’s hopeful gaze, and answers carefully. “... He would love to come, if he can.”

Frodo smiles at the thought, his heart lighter with hope. He doesn’t notice the sadness that flickers across Papa Bilbo’s face or the sorrowful look in Roac’s eyes. Despite being just a bird, the raw emotion in the raven’s expression is unmistakable.

Bilbo gently ties the letters, including Frodo’s, to the small container strapped to Roac’s legs. “Go, Roac. Take our love to the Company and to Thorin. Once again, thank you for making this journey. Farewell, dear friend.”

“Goodbye, Bilbo. Goodbye, Frodo. I shall return with news and letters from your loved ones. And once again, no thanks are necessary,” Roac replies with a respectful bow before spreading his wings and taking to the skies.

“Goodbye, Roac! Come back soon!” Frodo waves enthusiastically, his large smile full of excitement and hope. Beside him, Bilbo waves too, but his expression remains bittersweet, knowing the reply Thorin sends may not be what Frodo hopes to hear.

Frodo remembers the weeks leading up to the Flower Dance Festival, filled with excitement as he tells his friends about how his Adad will be coming this year. He doesn’t understand why Papa Bilbo and the adults around him keep giving him those sad smiles during those moments. “I’m going to teach Adad how to dance! It’ll be fun!” he says with boundless enthusiasm.

“Oh, Frodo…” Aunt Primula gently pulls him close, stroking his hair. “I’ll dance with you during the Flower Dance Festival. Would you like that?”

“And me! I’ll dance with you too, young Frodo!” Uncle Drogo adds with a wide smile, rubbing Frodo’s hairy cheeks. Frodo beams happily at the offer.

“Yes! We can teach my Adad how to dance together! It’ll be so much fun!” Frodo laughs, his joy infectious. But Aunt Primula and Uncle Drogo exchange a glance, their smiles faltering for a moment as they look toward Papa Bilbo, who stands nearby, covering his mouth as if holding back something.

“Drogo, Primula, could I ask you two to take Frodo with you to the market? I believe I have some work to finish,” Papa Bilbo asks, his voice soft but steady.

“Of course, cousin,” Uncle Drogo answers without hesitation.

“Come, take my hand, Frodo,” Aunt Primula offers warmly, holding out her hand. “You and I will go on a small adventure to the market.”

“I love adventures! Bye, Papa! I’ll come back with something sweet!” Frodo waves enthusiastically as they leave Bag End.

The market is loud and lively, filled with kind hobbits who greet Frodo with warm smiles and cheerful words. Frodo enjoys the bustling energy, but he notices something odd. Every time he mentions his Adad coming for the festival, the adults give him that same sad smile that he has been seeing a lot lately. Without a word, they hand him a snack or a small treat, but no one explains why they react this way.

When Frodo, Aunt Primula, and Uncle Drogo return to Bag End, Frodo notices something else. Papa Bilbo’s eyes are red, his voice sounds slightly nasal, and there’s an odd stain on his cheeks, as if he’s been crying.

“It’ll be fine, Bilbo. Frodo will understand,” Aunt Primula whispers to Papa Bilbo, her voice low but soothing. Uncle Drogo pats Papa Bilbo’s back reassuringly, though they all seem to believe Frodo isn’t listening.

“I hope you’re right…” Papa Bilbo whispers back, his voice thick with emotion. Then he takes a deep breath and turns to Frodo with a soft smile. “Now, my little sapling, tell me all about your adventure at the market. What did you buy? Who did you meet?”

Frodo, oblivious to the undercurrent of sadness in the room, launches into an animated retelling of everything that happened. He describes the market stalls, the snacks he received, and the friendly hobbits he met, bringing a smile back to Papa Bilbo’s face, though it doesn’t quite reach his eyes.

Looking back on it now, Frodo realizes he should have seen the signs. He reads the letter Roac delivered a day before the Flower Dance Festival, the words heavy in his heart:

 

“My dear Frodo,

As much as I would love to join you for this festival, I must admit I cannot. There are duties I must fulfill here in Erebor that keep me away from you and your Papa. Please forgive your Adad. I know it is no replacement, but I crafted these bells for you and your Papa to wear for the Flower Dance Festival. In this way, at least a part of me will dance with you. I hope that you enjoy them.”

 

Frodo looks at the tiny bells his Adad Thorin sent. They are beautiful silver bells, intricately crafted to resemble campanula flowers, bellflowers, as they are also called. More importantly, Frodo knows that in the language of flowers, campanula means dedicated love. He takes a deep, shaky breath and begins to cry softly, the weight of his Adad’s absence overwhelming him.

Papa Bilbo, who has been watching Frodo read the letter, kneels beside him and gently pulls him into a tight embrace. “Your Adad loves you, Frodo. Never forget that. He will never stop loving you, even when you’re far apart.”

“I want Adad!” Frodo cries, his small fists clutching the letter as his tears stream down his face. Roac, perched by the window, watches with a crestfallen look. The raven remembers how sorrowful Thorin was when he wrote the letter, his hand trembling as if each word pained him. Roac hadn’t enjoyed delivering it but  found he hated witnessing Frodo’s heartbreak even more.

“I know, Frodo. I want your Adad Thorin to be here too,” Papa Bilbo sighs softly, stroking his son’s curly black hair. “But he has responsibilities back in Erebor. Many people need him there. We can’t be selfish, my dear boy. But here, look. Remember what he wrote about the bells.” Bilbo picks up the delicate silver flowers and places one in Frodo’s hands. “These bells, Frodo, were made for you and me. A part of him is with us now. It’s not the same, I know, but it means he is here with us in his own way.”

Frodo sniffs, his tears slowing as he studies the bells more closely. They are perfect, each one meticulously shaped, the silver petals so lifelike they almost seem to shimmer in the light. He holds one to his chest and takes a deep breath. For a moment, it feels as though the metal hums in his hands, the bell singing to him in an ancient song. The sensation, though strange, calms him, and his sobs gradually fade into silence.

“Frodo, your Adad Thorin is still going to dance with us, just not in the way we imagined. And that’s alright. One day, he’ll be here to dance with us himself, all of him. Do you believe me, my little miracle?” Papa Bilbo asks gently, his eyes searching Frodo’s face.

Frodo nods slowly, pressing the bells closer to his chest. He just has to be patient. His Adad, and the rest of his family, will come back soon. They will be together again, and they will dance. It may not happen during the Flower Dance Festival, but he will still get to dance with his Adad.

Frodo remembers how, during that festival, the campanula bells seemed to jingle and chime in time with his movements. The sound reminds him of his Adad Thorin’s laughter, as if a part of him truly does dance alongside them. Frodo smiles at the memory, holding on to the belief that his Adad will come home soon.


His next memory is of the first time he begins training, with his family staying longer to guide him. During this period, Frodo learns something surprising: the other half of his family, whom he rarely sees, aren’t Stoor hobbits at all. They are dwarrows of Erebor, a grand kingdom beyond the Misty Mountains. No wonder they can only visit once a year. It also explains why he is taller than other hobbits and why he has facial hair even as a child. He is a dwobbit, half hobbit, half dwarf.

Uncle Balin teaches him how to read and write Khuzdul, the language of the dwarrows. With a soft smile, Balin patiently instructs him, pointing to the Cirth script on the scroll.  “Now, translate that for me, little prince.”

Frodo pauses, muttering the words under his breath as he pieces them together. Then he speaks confidently:

“When the Dwarrows of Nogrod assembled a great host of Dwarrows to attack Doriath, the Dwarrows of Belegost tried to dissuade them from war, but their brethren from Nogrod did not heed their advice. These Dwarrows went on to fight a battle in the Thousand Caves, and later met their demise at the Battle of Sarn Athrad. After this tragedy, the Dwarrows of Belegost started leaving for Khazad-dûm, for fear of reprisal from the Elves. There was much loathing between Elves and Dwarrows from then on.”

Seeing Uncle Balin’s approving smile fills Frodo with pride. He beams, knowing he’s done well, and eagerly hurries off to his next lesson.

Uncle Dwalin takes over, teaching him how to fight. Their graden turned training yard echoes with shouts as Dwalin bellows instructions while slashing at Frodo with wooden axes. Frodo wields a heavy wooden sword, crafted to build his strength. He focuses on his footwork, darting out of the way of Dwalin’s swings, looking for an opening. Spotting a weak point, Frodo lunges forward, aiming a strike.

But it’s a trap. Uncle Dwalin grins as he blocks Frodo’s sword with one axe and slams the other handle into Frodo’s side.

“Ow! Uncle Dwalin! That hurt!” Frodo complains, clutching his ribs.

Dwalin rolls his eyes but chuckles, his fondness clear. “If you’ve got the energy to whine, you’ve got the energy for more training. Now, get up!”

Despite his frustration, Frodo obeys picking himself up with a glare and gripping his sword again.

After training with Dwalin, Frodo always visits Uncle Óin, who patches him up while teaching him how to tend to his own wounds. Uncle Óin speaks as he works, his tone firm but instructive. “Two tablespoons of dried arnica flowers to reduce inflammation and swelling. One tablespoon of dried calendula flower to promote skin healing. One tablespoon of dried comfrey leaves, they aid with tissue repair. And one teaspoon of dried chamomile flowers for what?”

“To soothe irritation, Uncle Óin,” Frodo replies without hesitation.

“Good lad,” Óin nods, satisfied, as he applies the herbal ointment to Frodo’s bruises. The soothing mixture works quickly.

After his lessons with Uncle Óin, Frodo heads to Uncle Glóin to learn math. Frodo is certain the type of math Uncle Glóin teaches is far more complicated than what he learns in school, but he still finds it enjoyable.

“Now, Frodo! Your father stores grain in large silos to ensure food security. The amount of grain consumed by the population is modeled by the function:

Where C(t) is the cumulative grain consumed (in tons) after t months. At the same time, the kingdom replenishes its grain stores at a rate modeled by: R(t) =800 e −0.1 t

Where R(t) is the rate of grain replenishment (in tons per month) at time t . Now that we have all the information we need, answer these questions. At what time tt does the grain consumption exceed the replenishment? How much grain has been consumed and replenished by that time, and what is the total grain deficit by that point?”

Frodo doesn’t hesitate. “Grain consumption exceeds replenishment after 4.83 months. By that time, 966.6 tons of grain have been consumed, and 3112 tons have been replenished. The total grain deficit is 2145.4 tons.”

He answers without even looking up, causing Uncle Glóin to raise an eyebrow.

“You want to tell me how you got those answers?” Uncle Glóin asks with a smirk.

“No,” Frodo replies with a mischievous grin, earning a hearty laugh from Uncle Glóin.

Frodo usually goes to Uncle Dori for his next lesson, but before he can, Cousin Fíli, Cousin Kíli, and a reluctant Cousin Gimli whisk him away.

“It’s time for some fun!” Cousin Fíli announces gleefully.

“Yeah! Come on, cousin! You’re too good, be naughty with us!” Cousin Kíli chimes in, laughing loudly.

“We’re going to get in trouble,” Cousin Gimli mutters with a resigned sigh, but he follows them anyway.

Frodo laughs and eagerly joins his cousins. They lead him to a clearing filled with random wooden objects scattered about. The cousins chatter and laugh as they get to work, turning the haphazard materials into a surprisingly sturdy fortress. They slot the pieces together by crafting cavities in some pieces and creating protrusions in others, which fit perfectly into the cavities. This clever technique keeps the structure secure without the need for nails.

Just as they’re planning to add a defense system to their makeshift fort, Uncle Dori’s voice rings out. “Frodo! Your lessons!”

“Sorry, guys, I have to go,” Frodo says, waving goodbye to his cousins.

“Bye, Frodo! Don’t let him work you too hard!” Cousin Fíli calls out as they wave him off with big grins.

“My apologies, Uncle Dori. I was-” Frodo begins to apologize, but Uncle Dori shakes his head with a gentle smile.

“It’s fine, Frodo. Pebbles need to have fun. Now, why don’t you help me fill your Papa’s pantry?” Uncle Dori leads Frodo to the market. While it might look like a simple errand, it’s really a lesson. Uncle Dori teaches him how to read people, to observe their motivations and goals in the moment.

“See that chap there? Notice how his eyes keep shifting toward that apple? What do you think he’s trying to do?”

Frodo focuses on the chap in question, who turns out to be none other than his own Uncle Nori. It’s obvious he’s about to steal the apple. “Uncle Nori! No!”

“Ah!” Uncle Nori glares at his brother and nephew for ruining his attempt, but his expression softens into a grin as he strolls over to them. “Brother, you know better than to distract me when I’m working.”

“You’re not,” Uncle Dori replies with an exaggerated eye roll.

“Caught,” Uncle Nori admits casually before throwing an arm around Frodo. “Anyway, it’s my turn to teach the little prince! Bye!”

Uncle Dori sighs but waves them off, watching as his brother and nephew disappear into the crowd. Once they’re far enough away, Uncle Nori hands Frodo the apple he somehow managed to swipe earlier without either Frodo or Uncle Dori noticing.

“How did you-?” Frodo starts, staring at the apple in amazement.

“Oh, my darling nephew! Let me share some of my secrets with you,” Uncle Nori says with a sly grin.

“Just some? Not all of them?” Frodo asks, matching his uncle’s mischievous look.

“Nice try,” Uncle Nori laughs before leading Frodo on a very different kind of lesson—pickpocketing, lock picking, and, of course, sneaking. Frodo might have felt guilty about practicing these skills, but they choose the Sackville-Bagginses as their targets, so any guilt is immediately replaced with gleeful satisfaction.

“There’s my brother. Why don’t you try stealing his quill?” Uncle Nori points out Uncle Ori, who sits on a fallen log reading one of Papa Bilbo’s Elvish books. The quill is in his hand, but Frodo recalls Uncle Nori’s lessons and knows he can do it.

Steeling himself, Frodo moves stealthily toward Uncle Ori. He taps one side of Uncle Ori’s shoulder, making him glance in that direction. As Uncle Ori turns, Frodo circles to the other side, slipping the quill from his hand while he’s distracted. Without noticing anything amiss, Uncle Ori resumes reading. Frodo sneaks back to Uncle Nori, who gives him a proud thumbs-up.

“I did it!” Frodo blurts out excitedly, only to realize his mistake as Uncle Nori’s eyes widen in alarm. Frodo quickly covers his mouth, but it’s too late.

“Did what, little prince?” Uncle Ori’s voice comes from behind him, calm but knowing. Frodo stiffens, then turns slowly to face his uncle. Uncle Ori holds out his hand expectantly. With a sheepish grin, Frodo hands the quill back.

“Nori, you know Dori and Bilbo won’t approve of you teaching Frodo your certain set of skills,” Uncle Ori says, giving his brother a pointed look, though there’s no real anger in it.

“Oh, but it’s useful!” Uncle Nori counters, grinning in a way that shows he feels absolutely no guilt.

Uncle Ori sighs fondly and gently takes Frodo by the shoulder. “Come on, little prince. It’s time for your lesson with me.”

Frodo waves goodbye to Uncle Nori and follows Uncle Ori back to the fallen log. Once they’re seated, Uncle Ori begins his lesson, weaving myths and legends into Frodo’s Khuzdul practice. If Uncle Balin loves history, then Uncle Ori loves storytelling. “Now translate that for me, Frodo,” Uncle Ori says, pointing to the Cirth text on one of his scrolls.

Frodo takes a deep breath and recites,

“Then Aulë answered: ‘I did not desire such lordship. I desired things other than I am, to love and to teach them, so that they too might perceive the beauty of Eä, which thou hast caused to be. For it seemed to me that there is great room in Arda for many things that might rejoice in it, yet it is for the most part empty still, and dumb. And in my impatience, I have fallen into folly. Yet the making of things is in my heart from my own making by thee; and the child of little understanding that makes a play of the deeds of his father may do so without thought of mockery, but because he is the son of his father. But what shall I do now, so that thou be not angry with me forever? As a child to his father I offer to thee these things, the work of the hands which thou hast made. Do with them what thou wilt. But should I not rather destroy the work of my presumption?’”

“Did I get it right?” Frodo asks with a hopeful smile.

Uncle Ori nods in approval, and Frodo beams. After his lesson, he waves goodbye and heads to where Uncle Bifur waits for him.

Uncle Bifur greets him with a series of hand gestures, speaking through Iglishmêk, and Westron at the same time. “Hello, little prince. How are you?”

Frodo pauses, carefully recalling the proper gestures for what he wants to say. “I am fine, Uncle Bifur. My shoulder is a bit sore from training with Uncle Dwalin, but overall I feel…fine. Uncle Óin patched me up.”

Uncle Bifur shakes his head with a gentle chuckle and takes Frodo’s hands in a firm yet kind grip, guiding them into the correct gestures. “This is the Iglishmêk for ‘training.’ What you did earlier was the gesture for ‘sex.’”

Frodo’s face turns bright red, his mortification clear, but Uncle Bifur only laughs softly. “It’s alright. We learn from our mistakes.”

They continue their conversation through gestures, in time with their words, Uncle Bifur correcting him as needed with patient instruction. Frodo has always thought Uncle Bifur to be the quietest of his dwarvish uncles. The scar on his forehead used to make him seem intimidating, but Frodo has long since learned that Uncle Bifur is truly kind and gentle, with a warm heart.

Frodo is in the middle of recounting a story about one of his Took cousins, who had gotten stuck at the top of a tree while being chased by Farmer Maggot’s dogs, when Uncle Bofur arrives.

“Oh, it seems it’s time for my lessons with Uncle Bofur. Goodbye, Uncle Bifur,” Frodo says, smiling as he waves.

“Goodbye, Frodo,” Uncle Bifur replies with a warm smile, waving back. Uncle Bofur, arriving just in time, also waves to his cousin before turning to Frodo with a grin.

“Now I hope you’ve still got enough energy, because we’re going to go a long way!” Uncle Bofur exclaims, his excitement infectious as he leads Frodo out of Bag End and across the Shire.

They walk until they come upon a large boulder sitting in the grass. The stone is covered in moss and etched with carvings left behind by hobbit fauntlings over the years. Uncle Bofur gestures to it with a knowing smile. “Can you tell me the story of this boulder, Frodo?”

“I’ll try, Uncle Bofur,” Frodo replies, taking a deep breath.

His lesson with Uncle Bofur is stonesensing, an ability unique to dwarrows. As a dwobbit, Frodo shares this gift, much to the surprise and delight of his dwarvish family, who had assumed his hobbit blood might prevent him from inheriting it.

Frodo approaches the boulder and presses his hands against its rough, mossy surface. He closes his eyes, focusing on the boulder’s song. Images and emotions flow through his mind. He sees a group of hobbit fauntlings climbing the stone, their laughter echoing as they pretend it is so many things: a grand tower where a princess is trapped, a fortress protecting its people, and even a boat sailing toward distant adventures.

Frodo pulls his hands away slowly, a soft smile lighting up his face. “Uncle Bofur, I think this boulder enjoys its time here in the Shire. It has been so many things.”

“Indeed it has,” Uncle Bofur says with a proud smile. “And we’ll leave it here so it can become even more. I wonder what it’ll be next.”

Uncle Bofur leads Frodo back to Bag End, where Uncle Bombur is already waiting to begin Frodo’s next lesson.

“Frodo! Are you ready for the next dish I’ll be teaching you?” Uncle Bombur greets him with a wide grin as he steps into Bag Ends. “Bofur, go call the others and let them know dinner will be ready soon.”

“Will do!” Uncle Bofur waves cheerfully and hurries off to find the others. Uncle Bombur leads Frodo into the kitchen.

“Are Papa and Adad still busy?” Frodo asks as they pass by his Papa’s room.

“They, um... yes, they’re still busy,” Uncle Bombur replies, quickening his pace. Frodo hears a soft moan escape from the room, making him blink in confusion.

Once in the kitchen, Uncle Bombur brightens and happily lays out the ingredients, ensuring every item is accounted for. “Six pounds of scrubbed potatoes, two cups of virgin olive oil, kosher salt, freshly ground black pepper, eight leeks, white and light green parts, halved lengthwise and cut into four-inch pieces. Thirty-two pork sausages, four pounds of large cherry tomatoes, and eight tablespoons of chopped fresh parsley. Today, Frodo, I’ll be teaching you how to make Jezerkarâl Ra Galth-khalâf Mamashbul!”Frodo with his recent Khuzdul lessons understands what it means: ‘Bangers and Smash’.

“First, we preheat the oven. While I handle that, can you place the potatoes on the baking stone tablets? We’ll roast them for about forty minutes until they’re tender.”

Uncle Bombur sets to work lighting the very large oven in Bag End, a special feature built by Frodo’s grandpapa with the ability to feed a veritable army of fauntlings in mind. Frodo starts placing the potatoes onto one of their oversized stone baking tablets, the kind they only use for large gatherings or feasts, given the sheer volume of potatoes to be roasted.

Once the potatoes are in the oven, Uncle Bombur begins recounting stories from Erebor to pass the time. “Your Uncle Bofur still claims the scar on his leg is from the Battle of the Five Armies, but everyone in the Company knows he got it from stepping on a jagged rock while trying to imitate your Papa with his bare feet. Never took his boots off again after that!”

Frodo laughs, the image of Uncle Bofur’s misadventure clear in his mind. Then he grows quieter and asks, “Uncle Bombur, is Adad Thorin really that important in Erebor? Why can’t he stay here with us?”

Uncle Bombur’s smile softens as he kneels down to Frodo’s height, placing a gentle hand on his shoulder. Pressing his forehead against Frodo’s in a traditional dwarvish gesture of affection, he says, “Your Adad is very important in Erebor, Frodo. So important, in fact, that he can’t escape his duty. Visiting here every year for your and your Papa’s birthdays is something he really shouldn’t do, but he comes anyway because he loves you both so, so much. I hope you never forget how much he loves you.”

Frodo feels the warmth of the gesture and nods, his heart lighter. “Papa says Adad is so important that many people depend on him. What exactly does he do?”

Uncle Bombur rubs his back gently and replies, “He is a leader, someone every Ereborian looks up to. He helped us reclaim our home from the worm, and you know all the stories about that.”

Frodo nods slowly, and just then, Uncle Bombur sniffs the air and exclaims, “It smells like the potatoes are ready! Let’s check on them.”

They work together to pull the large baking stone tablet from the oven. Uncle Bombur keeps the oven going as they set the potatoes aside to cool for about ten minutes. Then, they brush the baking stone tablet with olive oil and sprinkle it lightly with salt and pepper. They return the potatoes to the tablet, spacing them about two inches apart. Using the bottom of another baking stone tablet, they press down on the potatoes, breaking their skins and compressing the flesh to about an inch thick.

Next, they brush the potatoes with olive oil, put them back into the oven, and roast them for another fifteen minutes. When they remove the tablet again, Uncle Bombur flips the potatoes over, rearranging them to cover about half the baking surface.

In the now-empty bowl, they toss the leeks with a few tablespoons of olive oil, season them with salt and pepper, and spread them on the other half of the tablet. The sausages go into the bowl next, tossed with olive oil before being arranged over the leeks.

After roasting for eight minutes, they remove the baking stone tablet, shift the sausages to the side, stir the leeks, and spread them over two-thirds of the empty space. The sausages are then replaced atop the leeks.

Finally, in the empty bowl, they toss the tomatoes with the remaining oil, sprinkle them lightly with salt and pepper, and spread them on the remaining space of the baking tablet. The mixture roasts until the tomato skins burst, the sausages are warmed through, and the potatoes turn crisp in about ten more minutes.

Once done, Uncle Bombur and Frodo transfer the potatoes, sausages, tomatoes, and leeks to a serving platter. They sprinkle everything with fresh parsley, and the dish is ready to serve.

“If you ever need to remember the recipe, I wrote it down for you,” Uncle Bombur says, handing Frodo a parchment. “But your Uncle Balin told me to write it in Khuzdul.”

Frodo groans playfully as he takes the parchment. “Thank you, Uncle Bombur.”

He heads to his room to store the recipe safely, but on the way, he spots Papa Bilbo and Adad Thorin stepping out of the room they’d been in earlier. Papa Bilbo has a faint red mark on his neck, while Adad Thorin’s neck is covered in multiple red marks.

“Papa! Adad!” Frodo exclaims, throwing his arms around both of his parents in a tight hug. They laugh warmly and hug him back.

“How are you, my boy? Did you have fun today?” Papa Bilbo asks with a soft smile, his eyes twinkling.

Frodo nods eagerly. “I did! There was this boulder that had so many stories to share! And Uncle Nori helped me swipe-”

Papa Bilbo gasps, but Frodo quickly continues, “-the Sackville-Baggins pottery.” Papa Bilbo relaxes at that. “And then Uncle Ori told me the story of how Mahal made the dwarrows…”

Frodo chatters happily, recounting his day as his parents follow him to his room. He carefully tucks Uncle Bombur’s recipe into one of his drawers before slowing down. He turns to Adad Thorin, his voice shy but hopeful. “Um... Adad... I know it’s late, but I still have some energy. Can we still have my lesson?”

Adad Thorin’s stern face softens into a smile, and he kneels to press his forehead against Frodo’s in another dwarvish gesture of affection. “Of course we can. Nothing brings me more joy. I’m so proud of how well you’re taking to these lessons, I was worried it might overwhelm you.”

“Well, he is my son,” Papa Bilbo interjects with a chuckle, ruffling Frodo’s curls. Frodo giggles at the gesture.

“But before you two hole up in the smithy, you’d better eat first. Did Bombur make sure there were vegetables?”

Frodo laughs. “Yes, Papa. Uncle Bombur added plenty - tomatoes, leeks, and, um, more tomatoes.”

“Good,” Papa Bilbo says with a mock-serious nod. Then he smiles and takes Frodo’s hand, reaching for Thorin’s as well. “Now let’s make sure your uncles and cousins don’t break any of your grandmama’s china.”

They walk to the dining room, where the rest of the family is gathered, filling the air with laughter and chaos. Plates and cups clatter loudly, and even Uncle Drogo and Aunt Primula have come to visit.

“Oh! That almost hit my head!” Uncle Drogo exclaims, ducking just in time as a plate flies over him.

“This reminds me of meal times at Brandy Hall,” Aunt Primula laughs before spotting Adad Thorin and Papa Bilbo entering the room. Her grin widens. “Ah, that’s what you mean by being busy, cousin.”

“Oh, hush,” Papa Bilbo retorts, rolling his eyes as he takes a seat at the table. “My husband is gone most of the year, so I’ll enjoy him while I can.”

Frodo squeezes into the seat beside his Papa, while Adad Thorin takes the one on his other side. The dinner is bright and lively, filled with laughter, songs, and even a little dancing. Despite the whirlwind of activity, the dining room somehow ends up as spotless as it was before the meal—a small miracle, considering the chaos of their meal times.

“Oh, that’s not like Brandy Hall,” Aunt Primula remarks, marveling at the clean room after the feast.

“I don’t think I’d survive another dinner with your hooligans, cousin,” Uncle Drogo says playfully, making Papa Bilbo laugh.

“Well, feel free to visit anytime. And now, my two big boys need to head to the smithy. They can’t seem to stay away from it lately.” Papa Bilbo chuckles, leaning over to kiss Frodo’s hairy cheek and then pressing a soft kiss on Adad Thorin’s lips. “Stay safe, you two. And Thorin, remember, our son’s hands are more sensitive than yours. He doesn’t burn as easily as me, but be careful with him.”

“I know, amrâlimê. I promise you, Frodo won’t be hurt,” Adad Thorin says with a smile before leading Frodo to the smithy at the back of Bag End. It is an addition his uncles and cousins built during one of their stays. Frodo remembers the process involving rituals and blessings, as a smithy is also considered a shrine to Mahal. Papa Bilbo always ensures it is kept clean when Frodo’s uncles and cousins are away, and Frodo helps him, finding it comforting and a way to feel close to their absent family.

“What would you like to make this time, my little prince?” Adad Thorin asks as they enter the smithy, quickly lighting the forge.

“Well, Papa Bilbo has been complaining about the knife set he bought recently in Bree. They turned out to be dull and incredibly brittle,” Frodo says, thinking aloud. He notices his Adad Thorin’s blue eyes suddenly turn icy, a glint of anger flashing in them.

“Did you get the name of the merchant who sold him such a defective product?” Thorin asks, his tone betraying the retribution he likely imagines.

“No, Adad. And you know Papa will scold you if you do anything to them,” Frodo says firmly, well aware of his Adad’s overprotectiveness, despite their limited time together. Thorin mutters something in Khuzdul that Frodo is fairly certain would make Uncle Dori and Papa Bilbo scold him.

They move to the workbench, and Adad Thorin shows him what they need to do.

First, they sketch the designs for the blades, handles, and fittings. This is easy enough; they both know Papa Bilbo’s preferences. He loves floral patterns but doesn’t mind a touch of dwarven geometric designs.

Next, they prepare the materials. Adad Thorin retrieves ingots of high-carbon crucible steel, the distinctive patterns on its surface resembling flowing water. “As much as I’d love to make this with mithril, dashat, we don’t have any. Damascus steel will do.”

“It’s just a kitchen knife set, Adad. I don’t think we need mithril for that,” Frodo chuckles.

Adad Thorin gives him a bewildered look, as if using anything less than mithril for Papa Bilbo is unthinkable.

Frodo laughs. “Papa knows mithril is rare and precious. He’d rather see you draped in armor made of it than have a mithril kitchen knife. You know how he is.”

Thorin sighs, then chuckles, shaking his head. “That I do.”

They begin their work. They heat the metal in the forge, shaping it, and then normalize the steel. They profile the blades, bevel the edges, and drill holes for the tangs. Together, they heat-treat the blades, hardening and tempering them.

Once the blades are ready, they refine the geometry, polish and sand them, then turn to the handles. They cut two pieces of ironwood, sanding them down to create handle scales. Using casein glue, they attach the scales to the tangs and secure them with damascus steel pins. With a file, they shape the handles, sanding them until smooth before applying oil to give them a durable finish.

They test each blade to ensure it is balanced and sharp, then polish both the blade and handle to a professional finish. By supper time, they have managed to complete only one knife, due to the meticulous attention to detail that dwarvish smithing demands.

Papa Bilbo ensures they have a light meal waiting for them. He serves fresh mixed greens tossed with olive oil, lemon juice, and a sprinkle of sea salt. Alongside it, there is crusty whole-grain bread spread with creamy goat cheese, a handful of cherry tomatoes and sliced cucumbers, a small bowl of warm vegetable soup, and slices of ripe pear with a few berries.

“Now, boys,” Papa Bilbo says, watching them eat, “you can continue smithing tomorrow. It’s getting late, alright?”

“Yes, Papa.”

“Yes, amrâlimê.”

They answer in unison, making Bilbo chuckle as he rolls his eyes fondly.

Days pass as Frodo continues his lessons, learning all he can under his dwarvish family’s guidance. By the time their shared birthday arrives, both Frodo and Papa Bilbo have crafted gifts for everyone attending the celebration. Their dwarven family, in turn, showers them with gifts.

Unlike hobbits, who traditionally give gifts on their birthdays, dwarrows celebrate by receiving them. Among the many treasures Frodo receives, the one from Adad Thorin stands out, a beautiful smiting kit, complete with hammers, tongs, charcoal, rags, a whetstone, and even more once the party dies down and their guests have left.

Frodo’s heart fills with gratitude, but also guilt as he looks at the gift. He hesitates, then gathers his courage and speaks.

“Adad… I know after today, everyone is going back to Erebor, like they do every year… but can you stay a while longer? Just for a little while? A week or two?” Frodo asks, his voice quivering.

Adad Thorin smiles sadly, his heart heavy. “Frodo… you know I can’t.” He gently pulls Frodo into an embrace, holding his dwobbit son close, trying to soothe him.

“If you can’t, then let me go with you! Papa and I can go! Please! I promise I’ll be good! I’ve been training! Papa still has his sword, Sting, and the mithril shirt you gave him! So-” Frodo stops when Thorin gently shakes his head.

“You can’t. Papa can’t either. It’s not safe,” Adad Thorin says softly, his voice steady but filled with regret. “As much as I want you and your Papa to be with me in Erebor, it simply cannot be.”

“Why not?” Frodo asks, his voice breaking as tears begin to fall.

Thorin takes a deep breath, his chest tightening. He cups Frodo’s cheek, his thumb wiping away a tear, and answers carefully. “Erebor will never welcome outsiders.”

Frodo freezes, stunned by his Adad’s words. He struggles to process them as Thorin continues. “The mountain is the home of dwarrows and dwarrows alone. Those who are not of Mahal’s children are forbidden to step into its halls. It is our sacred home, and it belongs only to us.”

Frodo shudders at the revelation, feeling his heart shatter. Thorin pulls him closer, holding him tightly, as though trying to keep him from falling apart.

“When I fell in love with your Papa,” Thorin says, his voice quiet and pained, “I was disgusted with myself. I tried to convince myself that what I felt was nothing more than curiosity, interest in a creature who, despite all odds, had managed to keep up with me and my kin.”

Thorin pauses, taking a deep breath before continuing. “But then things happened…”

Frodo knows this story all too well. Smaug, the dragon sickness, the Arkenstone, Papa Bilbo’s betrayal, Adad Thorin’s near-murder of Papa Bilbo, the exile, the Battle of the Five Armies, and Thorin’s near-death alongside Cousin Fíli and Cousin Kíli. Frodo thought all of that was in the past, long forgiven and healed. But now, hearing these words, doubts creep in. Does Adad Thorin still hold onto those memories? Does he not fully trust Papa Bilbo?

“Because of your Papa’s heroism during the journey, I could have convinced the council and the general populace of Erebor to allow him to stay,” Thorin admits. “But after the whole debacle with the Arkenstone… I couldn’t. For us dwarrows, the greatest offense is theft, an insult to Mahal’s gift of creation. And so I-”

“You’re ashamed of Papa,” Frodo suddenly interrupts, his voice trembling. “You’re ashamed of me. That’s why you’ve been hiding us here!”

Thorin’s eyes widen with alarm. “Frodo, no! That is not what I-”

But Frodo doesn’t wait to hear any more. He pulls free from Thorin’s grasp and runs. Tears blur his vision as he sprints away, not knowing where he’s going, only that he has to escape. He hears Thorin and Papa Bilbo, along with the rest of his family, calling after him. But Frodo runs faster, his sobs echoing in his ears, his heart breaking as he flees into the unknown.


Frodo searches his memories, looking for the signs he must have missed, all the ways his own Adad might have been ashamed of him. How Thorin always leaves as soon as his and Papa’s birthday is over. How he never comes to celebrate anything else. How he only visits once a year, never more. It feels so obvious now: Adad is just doing the bare minimum of what a father should. But why? A sense of duty? A hollow attempt at honor? Was Papa just some fleeting pleasure for him?

The more Frodo dwells on it, the darker his thoughts become. He doesn’t know where he is anymore. All he sees are the tall, looming trees of the forest surrounding him, no signs of life nearby. With a gut full of anger and despair, Frodo screams. He curses in every language he knows: Westron, Hobbitish, and Khuzdul.

Khuzdul. What good is knowing anything about dwarrow culture if he’ll never truly be part of it?

He collapses onto a fallen log, his body wracked with sobs. His voice grows hoarse as he screams into the emptiness, tears spilling like an endless river. He feels utterly abandoned by a father who was never truly there.

That’s when he feels it: something small and cold in his pocket. He pulls it out, a tiny cluster of silver campanula bells. They symbolize dedication and love. A gift from his Adad.

Another lie.

Frodo’s grip tightens on the bells before he throws them with all his might, releasing a frustrated scream.

Only for them to be caught by a tall, gray-robed figure.

“Frodo Baggins, that is no way to treat a gift from someone you love,” Gandalf, or Tharkûn as the dwarrow call him, gently chides with a soft smile.

“Leave me alone, Gandalf,” Frodo mutters, turning away and curling into himself.

The wizard sighs but doesn’t leave. Instead, he walks over and sits down beside Frodo, resting his staff on the ground. “What happened, Frodo? Where has my sweet little prince gone?” he asks, rubbing Frodo’s back in soothing circles.

Frodo bites the inside of his cheek. He knows Gandalf can be cryptic and confusing, but the wizard never lies. The words tumble out before Frodo can stop them.

“Gandalf… I’m Adad’s greatest shame, aren’t I?” Frodo sobs, his voice cracking as he tries to hold back fresh tears. It doesn’t work.

Gandalf says nothing at first. He simply pulls a handkerchief from his robes and gently wipes Frodo’s face. Then, he places the bells back into Frodo’s trembling hand.

“Your Adad is ashamed of many things,” Gandalf begins softly. “The way he treated your Papa. The way he couldn’t save his brother Frerin. How your cousins Fíli and Kíli grew up without their own Adad, Víli. But his greatest shame right now, Frodo, is that he is rarely here, helping your Papa raise you.”

Frodo looks up, confused. “What?” That doesn’t sound anything like what Adad Thorin said earlier.

“Frodo Baggins, you are a Durin through and through,” Gandalf says with a small chuckle. “Jumping to conclusions before letting someone finish. Go back and talk to them. Listen. That is a skill both of your parents had to learn before they had you, my boy.”

Gandalf smiles as he stands. He raises his staff high and sends a bolt of light into the sky. It explodes in a shower of sparkles, lighting up the forest.

Frodo watches in awe, Gandalf always has the best fireworks. But this time, it seems the display serves a purpose beyond mere spectacle. In moments, he hears the sound of hurried footsteps approaching. Frodo turns to see his Adad Thorin and Papa Bilbo, followed closely by his dwarven family, rushing toward him.

“Ada-” Frodo begins, about to apologize, but Adad Thorin pulls him into a crushing hug, so tight he feels the air pushed from his lungs.

“Maura Labingi! Don’t you ever do that again, do you hear me?!” Adad Thorin roars, his voice thick with distress and tears.

“What were you thinking, running off like that?!” Papa Bilbo asks, wrapping Frodo in a hug as well, his eyes glistening with unshed tears.

Despite having already teared up, Frodo feels the urge to cry again. Clinging to them both, he stammers, “I’m sorry! I’m sorry, Adad! I’m sorry, Papa! I didn’t mean to-I was just… I-I…”

The family clings to one another, their emotions spilling over while the rest of the group maintains a respectful distance. After the tears subside, Gandalf somehow produces a wineskin of water for their sore throats, as if by magic. Seated on a fallen log, Adad Thorin pulls Frodo onto his lap, just as he used to when Frodo was younger, while Papa Bilbo sits beside them, holding Frodo’s hand.

“Can I continue where I left off, or are you going to run away again?” Adad Thorin asks, his tone shifting to one of familiar sternness. Frodo laughs nervously, recognizing the disciplinary tone usually reserved for Cousin Fíli and Cousin Kíli. This is the first time Adad Thorin has ever used it on him.

“Y-you can continue, Adad. I won’t run away again,” Frodo replies softly.

Adad Thorin glances at Papa Bilbo, who nods in approval. Taking a deep breath, Thorin continues, his voice steady.

“I love your Papa so much, Frodo. So much that I was willing to let Fíli take the throne and run away with him to the Shire. But… Fíli is not ready. Erebor is still being restored. The other dwarven clans eye the riches of the Lonely Mountain greedily. Many dwarrows seeking a home in Erebor would find only a tomb instead. Do you know why your Papa Bilbo helped us on my foolish quest?”

“Because home is important, and he wanted to give you all your homes back,” Frodo says softly, recalling the stories. Papa Bilbo smiles and presses a gentle kiss on his fuzzy cheek.

“That is correct. Your brave, heroic, self-sacrificing Papa decided I should stay in Erebor until Fíli is ready to be king. That he could wait until I could stay with him, without guilt,” Adad Thorin’s breath hitches as though he’s holding back tears. “It would have been fine. But then we realized you were coming. You were inside your Papa. Oh, Frodo, the news of your arrival brought us so much joy. But I’ll admit it complicated our plans.”

“As the royal line of Durin, and because you’re not a full dwarf… if they knew I sired you, they’d call for my head, your Papa’s head, and even yours. To them, they couldn’t see you for what you truly are, a treasure. So I had to hide you, or the kingdom would fall onto Fíli’s shoulders before he was ready. Even though I wanted to be the Adad you deserved, I just couldn’t. I know your Papa is strong, stronger than the mithril I gave him, that he would endure the test of time. But you… you deserved to know who I am, to know that I love you, not just through letters. I didn’t want you to feel like I didn’t love you. And yet, it seems in the end, I made you feel like I was ashamed of you.” Thorin holds Frodo tighter, his voice trembling with regret.

“Just a few more years, Frodo. A few more years, and your Adad will never leave you or Papa ever again. Can you wait just a little longer, dashatimê?” Adad Thorin pleads, his voice filled with desperation and love.

Frodo feels torn. On one hand, he understands why Adad Thorin is doing this, the dwarrows are only acting on what they believe is right. But on the other hand, he can’t ignore that his father is making these sacrifices for those same dwarrows who refuse to accept his parents’ love or even his existence. Why should he accept it?

But then, Frodo remembers the one thing he’s always found incredible: his parents’ love for each other. Papa Bilbo betrayed Adad Thorin with the Arkenstone. Adad Thorin nearly killed Papa Bilbo. Years apart didn’t break them, they remained faithful and loving to each other. If they can manage to be kind to one another and sacrifice so much for those who don’t accept them, perhaps he can, too.

Just as Frodo is about to answer, Fíli, who has been standing at a distance with the rest of the group, suddenly steps forward.

“Irak’adad, no. You can’t make Frodo wait any longer,” Fíli says, his voice unsteady. “I’m ready now.”

“Irakdashat, what are you saying?” Thorin asks, his surprise evident. He’s not alone—everyone else looks equally shocked at Fíli’s sudden declaration.

“I remember my Adad Víli,” Fíli begins, his voice soft but growing stronger. “I remember laughing as he lifted me high into the air, giggling at his jokes, and falling asleep to the songs he sang. I remember the day he suddenly died, and how desperately I wished he hadn’t. How I wished Kíli here could know what he looked like, beyond just paintings and sketches.” Fíli’s voice gains strength, but tears stream down his face. Kíli quickly reaches for his hand, holding it tightly.

“And now I have an Iraknadad… their Adad, still alive but unable to be with them because of me.” Fíli turns to Frodo, his voice breaking. “Frodo, I’m sorry… I’m so sorry. I know what it’s like to lose your Adad. I managed to move on because I knew mine died loving me. But because of me, you had to grow up thinking your Adad didn’t love you, because he stayed behind to help prepare me to be king.”

“Erebor is restored. Our alliances with the other dwarven clans are strong. The dwarrows of Erebor are happy and content,” Fíli continues, his conviction growing. “Amad and Kíli will help me rule, as will Dwalin, Balin, and the rest.”

“We can fake your death now, Irak’adad!” Kíli adds, his voice trembling but steady as he soothes Fíli, though his own tears shimmer in his eyes.

“I’m sorry? Death?” Frodo blinks in surprise.

Papa Bilbo steps in to explain. “Dwarrows don’t retire, Frodo. For them, their work is their life. If your Adad wants to leave and be with us, they have to believe he died.”

Fíli steps forward and presses his forehead against Frodo’s. “Please forgive me, Frodo. I never meant to keep your Adad away from you…”

Frodo gently holds Fíli’s arms, his gaze soft. “Fíli… just promise me one thing?”

“Anything,” Fíli says, his voice trembling.

“Promise me you’ll all keep visiting.”

“Of course we will! How could I not visit my favorite cousin?” Fíli laughs, pulling Frodo into a tight hug. Frodo laughs too, tears spilling as they hold each other. Kíli joins in, wrapping his arms around both of them.

Adad Thorin watches quietly, seeing how much his Irakdashshat have grown. Finally, he speaks. “Alright, Fíli. I’ll step down. But you two will be the ones to explain to your Amad Dís why I’m not returning.”

Fíli and Kíli groan in unison, prompting laughter from the others. Soon, they all huddle together for a group hug. Gandalf looks on with a soft smile.

The next morning, Frodo waves goodbye to his dwarven family, standing beside Papa Bilbo and Adad Thorin. Taking a deep breath, he clings to Adad Thorin’s side and asks, “So, Adad… um… can we dance?”

“Of course we can,” Adad Thorin replies, smiling. Papa Bilbo chuckles, leading the way into Bag End. Moments later, cheerful music filters through the open windows, filling the Shire with the sound of joy.

Notes:

Hopefully that didn't hurted anyone too badly! Hope you all enjoyed it! I have two other fics here in this year's Thorin's Forge if you haven't checked it out! Translations!

Amrâlimê - love of mine
Dashat - son
Adad - father
Dashatimê - son of mine
Irak’adad - uncle
Irakdashat - nephew
Amad - mother