Actions

Work Header

Everything I Feel Returns To You Somehow

Summary:

Will thinks they need a little time and space, while Hannibal thinks they also need another body.

Notes:

It’s obvious that I’ve read too many of Raymond Carver’s stories during the maintenance.

The title comes from the song The Only Thing by Sufjan Stevens.

Work Text:

Will Graham was reclining in the creaking rocking chair in the backyard, with a cactus of uncertain vitality to his left and a side table that might well have been older than he was to his right. His coffee cup sat close to the edge of the table. The smell of black coffee mingled with the salt-laden breeze as it drifted through his three-day-old beard. He could smell his own aftershave.

 

It wasn’t that he had no time to look after himself. Quite the opposite: he was so idle that it was beginning to make him restless. Had you ever been bored with your own boredom? That was precisely how he felt at the moment. There was also a pile of timber, nearly as tall as a man, waiting for him at the other end of the backyard, and a box of fishing bait in the kitchen that needed to be secured to the lines. He could even find something else to occupy himself with, if he really wanted to.

 

The problem was that he didn’t.

 

This state of lethargy had persisted from the day he arrived here right up until this afternoon, much like those dreadful strains of influenza described in books, settling into your respiratory tract and feeding on your strength while you slept, until one day you quietly withered away without ever quite realizing it. Perhaps it was the wind along the coastal highway. Perhaps it was the cigar he had smoked while negotiating the rent with his landlord, or the deep breath he had taken in the grocery store before asking for nylon fishing line.

 

Or perhaps it had begun a little earlier, when he had stormed out of the house, driven off in that second-hand car, and disappeared beyond the fields, with the wind blowing across the horizon.

 

It didn’t matter. He didn’t really care. He didn’t have the energy to care whether this was actually influenza, or even whether he would live or die here. His landlord liked to spend a little time at the only bar in town with a beer tap before sunset. He had a few former colleagues, and a collection of stories he had told hundreds of times but continued to repeat. Will had never been there, but whenever his landlord came home, he would mutter to himself in the corridor outside Will’s room about their former sailor, about how the man had grown despondent after separating from his wife, and how he had eventually died without a word in his own car, undiscovered until the following day.

 

What a pointless way to die, Will would always hear his landlord complain. Not even a woman to shed a tear for you.

 

Not even a woman to shed a tear for you. What an interesting set of values. In this place, the troubles of a man’s entire life seemed to amount to children, women, cigarettes, alcohol, and death. Their values swayed accordingly, as though life were as simple a matter as being a fisherman: have one of those things, earn a point. Lack one, lose a point, until eventually you had nothing left. Then Death would walk into your house and take your final breath.

 

There were no serial killers in their world, let alone cannibals. The only time he had ever heard anyone mention the FBI was when his landlord, watching a film, had remarked, “That’s all made up. They invented it to steal my tax money.” Will had looked at the sandwich in his hand, then at the film’s spectacularly unconvincing images, and said nothing. He had simply returned to his room and closed the door.

 

Nobody here knew him. Nobody had seen their wanted posters, and nobody believed that there could actually be someone in this world who enjoyed eating the flesh of his own kind. Perhaps that was precisely why he was here. This might well be his final stop. He had spent his life drifting from place to place, never putting down roots, and there was hardly anything more fitting than dying in a remote little town where no one had the slightest idea who he was. He lifted his coffee cup. As he took a sip, his upper lip and tongue made a loud, wet sound. He glanced down at his cup. How strange. He hadn’t heard that particular noise in six or seven years.

 

When his father was still alive, he had always liked his coffee scalding hot. The coffee maker at home was perpetually set to its highest temperature, and young Will had been forced to spend most of his time blowing on his coffee to cool it down. Eventually, that had developed into this peculiar way of drinking. His father, however, had never had the time to pay attention to his son's little coffee-drinking ritual. His father had hardly ever had time for anything concerning him. After Will moved out on his own, his dogs naturally cared even less. Only the youngest occasionally gave him a reproachful look at his childishness, but no dog had ever asked him why he still drank his coffee scalding hot.

 

Naturally, neither had anyone else. He had had a few friends, or people he could at least claim to have been on speaking terms with, but they had never cared how he drank his coffee, either. His former psychiatrist might have asked him something along those lines, but he hadn’t answered. To be fair, he had never cared how his friends and colleagues took their coffee, either. He didn’t even know whether they drank it at all. Their relationships had always been too limited, and more than a little awkward.

 

Perhaps that was why psychiatrists were always so popular: people were so desperate for an audience that they were willing to pay someone to listen to them speak. Sometimes he thought that ninety-nine percent of a person's life was meaningless, much like his landlord’s stories, repeated hundreds of times and still being told. All of it was merely loneliness made tangible, an attempt to find the small comfort of having someone care. Who among us doesn’t want understanding and acceptance? Just as Jack Crawford had said all those years ago.

 

Will lifted his coffee again, but this time he made no sound at all.

 

His landlord certainly didn’t care. The retired fisherman hadn’t even asked about his work or his life. He had only asked whether he had a partner, whether he had children, and whether he would be interested in joining the other retired workers at the bar for a game of charades. Will’s answer to all of it had been no. He had never been particularly fond of sharing stories about his life, and besides, he wouldn’t have known where to begin. There was a long, conspicuous scar on his landlord’s right arm. When the man reached out to collect Will’s rent, there had been a quiet eagerness in his eyes as he looked at him. But Will hadn’t asked. Not only because he had already known what sort of man his landlord was the moment they met, but also because he had absolutely no inclination to care about anyone else’s stories.

 

That’s precisely why people turn to psychiatrists, a voice inside him remarked.

 

Will set down his coffee and looked towards the river in the distance. He ought to have a psychiatrist, too—assuming the person who had put him through all of this wasn’t his psychiatrist, and assuming that everything they had been through together hadn’t left such profound and lasting consequences. Or perhaps if they had reached some kind of compromise earlier, and simply run away together.

 

But he knew that none of it could ever really have happened. The other man knew it, too. Everything they had now was inevitable, just as his decision to leave without saying goodbye had been inevitable, just as the drive that had brought him here had been inevitable, just as this house becoming his temporary home was all part of the same design.

 

It was a house he had taken to at first sight while looking for somewhere to stay. The front yard faced the Atlantic, and there was a narrow river behind it. The landlord had assured him that the fishing was better there than anywhere else he could find in the country. That was why he had bought a packet of fine fishing line. It wasn’t nylon, but he wasn’t particular about such things. Somewhere to fish, a bed to sleep in, something to eat, whatever happened to be available. That was all he had ever wanted from life.

 

Some people might call it giving up on himself. To which he would say that this someone was not meant to live with him.

 

A cool breeze passed through, carrying the damp scent of earth and sand. The sun had gone down, and the day’s heat was beginning to falter.

 

Will tapped his fingers against the handle of his coffee cup, producing a dull little sound. During a few sleepless nights earlier that week, he had chewed his once perfectly shaped nails into uneven, ragged edges. He knew that the other man would be displeased when he got home. Those immaculate curves had been his handiwork, after all, and he would naturally interpret their destruction as a deliberate provocation.

 

But Will didn’t care. He hadn’t cared then, and now, sitting in his landlord’s backyard, he cared even less.

 

Hannibal took pleasure in attending to every aspect of Will’s life. So even when Will discovered that the cleaning products in his bathroom had multiplied to the point where there was barely room for his toothpaste, he made no complaint. Their arrangement was simple: Hannibal did as he pleased, and Will did his best to tolerate it. Fortunately, the man had yet to summon the nerve to propose anything that might threaten Will’s life or his free will. They both understood how bloody the consequences of an outright violation of boundaries could be, and after recovering from their fall, neither of their bodies was in any condition to endure another such elaborate resurrection.

 

So they simply kept each other company. Ever since Hannibal had been able to get out of bed and walk on his own, they had been sleeping in separate rooms. Outside of their three meals a day, they rarely saw one another. Hannibal spent most of his time in the study, apparently devising one scheme after another to recover the rare books he had once treasured. He had never shared his frustrations with Will, but Will knew the hospital had confiscated all his books. The wounds might have healed, but the fear remained. So Will had never asked. He simply signed for the deliveries under their assumed names whenever a thoroughly wrapped courier appeared at the door.

 

Mateo Moreno and Andres Moreno. Their perfect human disguises.

 

Will raised his coffee cup and drank the last of the coffee, grounds and all.

 

They might have enjoyed this peaceful domestic interlude, if only Hannibal hadn’t been so insufferably self-assured.

 

The first body had appeared three months earlier. Their house had only one floor. That afternoon, when Hannibal walked into the kitchen carrying an insulated container, Will had been in the backyard tending to the white lilies Hannibal had insisted on planting there. It wasn’t until three hours later, when he tasted the meat, that he realized what his housemate had been out doing that day.

 

“Who is this?” he remembered asking. His voice had been remarkably steady, at least until Hannibal supplied a name that Will barely recognized. Only then did the anger begin to surface. “You killed someone who had absolutely nothing to do with us.” He straightened in his chair and looked directly at the man across from him, making no effort to conceal the bitterness in his voice. “You owe me a reasonable explanation for killing him.”

 

But Hannibal, seated opposite him, merely raised his chin and ignored his anger. “His arrogance earned him the privilege of becoming our dinner.” He even took another piece of meat, bringing it to his mouth with an air of exquisite refinement.

 

“Your arrogance,” Will corrected him. Then he got up and walked out of the dining room without looking back.

 

He had never introduced Hannibal to anyone as his husband or lover. Partly because they weren’t really lovers, partly because the FBI’s official account described them as kidnapper and victim, and partly because, in Will’s mind, they were much closer to being kidnapper and victim than anything else.

 

Did they have feelings for each other? Will found that whenever he considered the question, he was overcome by an urge to laugh. Once, he had actually done so, right there in Hannibal’s kitchen, when Hannibal asked whether his opinion of Iliad had changed. He couldn’t stop laughing. Hannibal, apparently unable to understand what had struck him as so funny, could only watch as Will continued until tears came to his eyes, until the laughter gave way to uncontrollable sobbing. He still remembered the sting of tears running into his nose, the strangled sounds he had made, the breathless helplessness of it, and the way what little remained of his rational mind had struggled to find its footing amid the chaos of his thoughts.

 

He suspected Hannibal had privately made a note of that particular breakdown. Oddly enough, however, he no longer cared what the psychiatrist prescribed.

 

There was so little left for him to care about. Everything he had once cared about had already vanished long before he took Hannibal with him into the Atlantic. And when he opened his eyes again, the only thing left that he could care about was everything that belonged to Hannibal: the man who had pulled him out of the crowd, forced him to confront everything that made him different from the rest of the world, and then allowed him to cast them both towards death. But when Will swallowed that mouthful of meat, he understood that the other man did not care about him as much as he had thought. Served alongside that steaming plate of meat was Hannibal’s cold heart. It was as though Will were still nothing more than an experimental subject in Hannibal’s consulting room, a plaything in his interminable game, an insignificant insect that happened to cross his field of vision as he surveyed the world below him.

 

They had never stood side by side. They hadn’t before, and they never would. Everything Will had was still a gift bestowed upon him by Hannibal.

 

He was exhausted, body and soul, so he left. He should have left long ago: walked out of that house, walked out of a life that contained nothing but Hannibal. From seven years ago until now, this was the first time he had lived without Hannibal, without anything or anyone else by his side. A week had passed, and he was still here. He had neither returned to Hannibal nor added anything else to his life.

 

He wasn’t going to burden himself with anything more. He knew that, and Hannibal knew it, too. Perhaps that was why he hadn’t yet seen Hannibal suddenly appear before him, carrying his landlord’s head. At the same time, however, he had no desire to invite Hannibal back into his life. His world could contain nothing at all. He didn’t need to start coveting something as presumptuous as respect. He could have drifted through the rest of his life like this. Sometimes he told himself that without Hannibal, his life would have been lonely, but that would have been all. And now he was sitting in his landlord’s backyard, surrounded by things that did not belong to him in the slightest. Perhaps that was better. Perhaps this was closer to freedom.

 

After discovering that sincerity could be nothing, loneliness had become easier to swallow.

 

The last traces of sunlight flickered, then finally disappeared at the far edge of his vision. The temperature had dropped considerably since the afternoon. He had no coat in his luggage suitable for this weather, and winter had crept in before he had found the inclination to go shopping. Hannibal’s order of winter clothes should have arrived at the house by now, he suddenly thought, before gathering the dishes in front of him and returning to his room. That was one of the greatest advantages of living with a wanted criminal who would never respect anyone else: he always made sure everything was prepared in advance.

 

Will looked at the crumbs on his plate by the last of the natural light. Well, there was also the food, which was always so perfectly suited to his taste.

 

It was interesting how people naturally assumed that whatever Hannibal served at the dinner table would be some elaborate French or Italian dish, with a name longer than his list of victims. But few people knew that, in fact, his greatest talent lay in ordinary home cooking. And just as he always reminded Will to prepare firewood before the temperature dropped, Will suspected that the Baltic Sea’s merciless winters had left him with something close to an instinctive fear of the cold.

 

But he had never shared that suspicion with Hannibal, just as he had never told Hannibal what he thought about murder and cannibalism. There were so many things between them that ought to have been discussed properly, yet neither of them had ever been the first to bring them up. From the day Will drove away in their only car to this moment, standing beside a river in a state he couldn’t even identify, he had asked himself again and again: if Hannibal had actually asked him back then, would he have gone with him to kill someone, even if the victim had been chosen entirely at random, even if it had been nothing more than an experiment?

 

He knew what his answer would have been. He also knew that Hannibal knew what his answer would be. And yet Hannibal had never asked.

 

Will gave another little snort. Their relationship had always been like this: one of them did as he pleased, and the other did his best to tolerate it. Hannibal was too proud, blindly convinced that their desires were one and the same, and too insecure to face the possibility that Will might refuse him. So he pushed closer, and closer, and closer, until Will finally stormed out of the house and drove towards a place where he could no longer see their little bloodstained home, nor the white lilies he had so carefully tended in the backyard.

 

The notorious Dr. Hannibal Lecter, supposedly so skilled at manipulating the human mind, was no more than a child who would throw a tantrum the moment someone refused him a toy.

 

Will sighed and pulled open the screen door.

 

The house was dark, which surprised him somewhat. At this hour, his landlord would usually have been sitting on the sofa, muttering into his beer as he repeated one of his old stories, or finding some way to hint that Will ought to join the others for an evening out. He should have been home by now. Perhaps he had suddenly decided to arrange a game of charades with someone, Will told himself. But he hadn’t expected to detect something unusual in the air just beyond the door.

 

For a moment, he thought it was Hannibal’s scent. But no. This was someone else.

 

Someone unfamiliar.

 

Will instinctively bent forward, slowly setting the dishes in his hands against the wall. He moved towards the kitchen, one measured step at a time. He knew which floorboards would creak and where the blind spots were from the hallway. Not for any particular reason, but because his former profession and his crime-loving housemate had taught him to remain aware of his escape routes at all times.

 

Probably a burglar, he thought. An amateur, too. He hadn’t even considered checking every room in the house before making his move.

 

When Will reached the space beneath the dining table, the shadow outside suddenly shifted. Then came the sound of rubber soles crossing the creaking porch. The intruder pulled open the screen door and walked straight into the room where Will lay in wait, stopping beside the dining table. Will narrowed his eyes. A white man, in his fifties or sixties, with short golden-brown hair, around six feet tall. A former soldier, perhaps. No firearm. The shape of his right pocket suggested a folding knife. And—

 

Will sniffed the air between them.

 

Too much alcohol.

 

That explained the unsteady movements.

 

This should be easy enough to handle.

 

He could almost laugh at the misfortune awaiting the man in front of him.

 

When the intruder came within reach, Will suddenly extended his left hand, caught the man by the leg, and pulled him sharply towards himself. Before he could hear the man cry out, he heard the impact as he fell against the concrete floor. How satisfying, a voice inside Will remarked, as he used the towel from his shoulder to restrain the intruder’s ankles.

 

The clumsy burglar was shouting in a language that clearly did not belong here, and his instinctive attempt to reach for the knife in his pocket was far less practiced than anything Will had seen among the local fishermen. How beautiful, the voice in his head remarked, as he watched the tears glimmer in the man’s eyes when he twisted his hand out of its socket.

 

Will made no attempt to determine how much of that voice belonged to him and how much belonged to Hannibal. He simply took the folding knife from the man’s pocket and made sure he could no longer put up a fight. Then, while the man continued to shout, Will found the bowl of apples his landlord had left beside the sink. He cut one in half and stuffed a piece into the man’s teeth.

 

“You’d better hope you haven’t done anything to the owner of this house.” Will chewed on the other half of the apple, speaking with an almost leisurely calm. “Because that will determine whether I punish you first or kill you first.”

 

The knife was of decent quality. And although Will hadn’t had the opportunity to deal with wild animals himself in quite some time, he still remembered what little physiology he had learned during his forensic training, along with the far more extensive experience he had picked up from Hannibal during the years he spent studying the Chesapeake Ripper. When he was finished, he used his freshly washed hands to give the man a light pat on the cheek.

 

“And remember to be grateful for the apple he bought.”

 

Only then did he head outside.

 

Fortunately, his landlord was unharmed. The frightened man had practically folded himself into the shape of a piece of cornbread, huddled behind his sofa and trembling. Even after Will draped a blanket over his shoulders, he was unable to speak.

 

“I’ll finish packing before I leave. You can keep the rent.”

 

Will merely patted the man’s skeletal shoulder before closing the door between them and returning to the kitchen.

 

The rest of the cleanup was easier than he had expected. He was not nearly as particular about perfection as Hannibal, and he had enough experience to know how to deal with the aftermath without making a spectacle of it. He packed everything away in the heavy-duty bags his landlord kept on the shelves, then dealt separately with what remained. The whole process took about an hour. He even scrubbed the kitchen afterwards. It was quite clear that his landlord had no idea what the row of cleaning products beside the drainpipes was for.

 

One of the advantages of living with a serial killer.

 

Will glanced at the spotless sink and the bags of supplies on the other side, then shrugged.

 

When he used his landlord’s little timber cart to move the bags out to the front yard, he wasn’t surprised to find the man he had spent the entire week missing standing beside his car.

 

“This weather should be fine for the drive back. It probably won’t spoil. Though, of course, an insulated container would be better.” He gestured towards the black bags in the back of the cart. “And we’ll have to stop for gas first. I haven’t had time to take the car out to fill the tank lately.”

 

It was too dark in the unlit backyard to make out Hannibal’s expression, but Will knew he must have heard the unmistakable note of satisfaction in his voice.

 

“You’re not going to make me explain how I knew this man was the toy you sent me, are you?” He tilted his head, looking at Hannibal with nothing but amusement.

 

“Would you come home with me?”

 

Will hadn’t expected Hannibal’s first words to be such a straightforward concession.

 

He raised an eyebrow. “I’ll forgive you this time, too.”

 

He opened the trunk beside Hannibal and watched as his serial killer obediently put away all the black bags. Then he walked around to the front and opened the driver’s door. “You drive. I need to rest for a while.” He issued the order without looking at the expression of things left unsaid on Hannibal’s face. Instead, he walked around to the other side and dropped himself into the passenger seat.

 

“Have you not been sleeping well these past few days?” Hannibal asked when he took the coat from his own bag, the one that should have been hanging in Will’s wardrobe by now, and carefully draped it over him.

 

Will’s only response was a final little snort before sleep took him. “You know I can still get out of this car and go back to that room. I paid a month’s rent.”

 

Fortunately, Hannibal didn’t say another word for the rest of the drive. Fortunately, it was already completely dark. And fortunately, the coat carried the familiar scent of all those cleaning products Hannibal owned in quantities that bordered on the absurd.

 

For the first time in what felt like countless years, Will slept more deeply than he could remember.