Work Text:
“Fuck,” Billy muttered, concentration breaking as he blinked down at the stinging papercut marring the pad of his right thumb. Sneering at himself – unable to believe he was sitting at his desk writing letters like a fucking loser – he tossed aside the page he’d been proof-reading, absentmindedly swiping his tongue over the sliver of blood that had welled up before attempting to shake out the stiffness in his fingers and wrist.
A frustrated glance over at his digital clock revealed he’d been absorbed in his mortifyingly sentimental scribbling for almost two hours, a fact that his tired eyes and aching shoulders were quick to attest. Billy leant back in his chair with an annoyed grunt, lifting his arms over his head and arching his spine until it gave a series of tension relieving cracks. He kept his face tilted mulishly upwards, glaring at the ceiling instead of looking down at the mess of scrunched paper, used or broken pens – he’d snapped one or three in frustration, so fucking what? – and empty envelopes scattered across his desk.
This was such so goddamned stupid. He felt so goddamned stupid. What the hell was he even doing, aside from inviting trouble and humiliation? Billy knew very fucking well how much Maxine liked to snoop. If she found any of the letters he’d started writing she’d throw a huge bitch fit – he shuddered to think of all the yelling and ugly crying his sister would unleash – before snitching to Steve or Hopper or worse, Ms Byers about what she would undoubtedly assume were the beginnings of multiple suicide notes. Hell, if anyone found what he’d been writing they’d assume exactly the same thing, and then he’d be in the shit so deep he’d drown no matter how badly he wanted to keep breathing. His dad would get so apoplectically angry he’d probably break through the psychic roadblocks installed in his head and kill Billy on the spot, punishing his only son for being such a weak, pathetically shameful disappointment. Susan on the other hand probably wouldn’t give a shit, stowing the letters back where she’d found them and going about her day as normal. If she stayed true to form – her strange generosity at Christmas remaining nothing but an outlier – then at least he could count on her apathy.
Steve…Steve would be disappointed in him for supposedly breaking the promise he’d made after their first and only real fight, which was arguably way fucking worse than anything Neil might do to him. Even if he knew the older boy wouldn’t ever see these fucking letters – Billy would never risk allowing Steve to step foot inside 4819 Cherry Lane – just the thought of Steve’s sad doe eyes was enough to make him itch to burn the loose pages spread before him until they were nothing but ash.
The things he’d written… they were too truthful, too vulnerable, too disgustingly pathetic. Committing his most closely guarded thoughts and feelings to paper – giving them a damning physical form that could be seen and read and judged – left him restless with immense discomfort, skin prickling and lungs tight. He wanted to erase them, flashing eyes lowering from the ceiling and finding his lighter where it rested innocuously atop his battered old dresser. It would only take a few seconds, and after that any proof of his own intangible fear would be gone.
So what if he’d had another disturbing as fuck dream? And so what if it had felt similar to his nightmares involving the demo-dog’s tunnels, or Steve having the shit beaten out of him while tied to a metal chair? Psychic abilities or no, Billy wasn’t fucking omniscient. He could be wrong. His dream could mean nothing.
That he’d woken up with a ruthless headache and a fresh bloodstain on his pillowcase – he was getting pretty goddamned fed up with how often he was having to buy new ones – didn’t have to matter if he just ignored it. There was no guarantee his dream wasn’t full of shit, so what the fuck was the point in worrying about it? Billy could burn the letters into nonexistence, go back to sleep, and pretend when the sun came up that the sleepless bruises beneath his eyes weren’t any darker than what had become normal.
The problem with that plan was that for the first time in about a decade he was actually enjoying being alive, so. Considering the fact that his psychic bullshit had affected his nightmares in the past, ignoring a dream wherein his own name was engraved on a headstone was just plain fucking idiotic. And cowardly.
Hence the letters, and their horrifically personal contents.
Eighteen years of hiding the parts of himself that didn’t meet Neil’s exacting standards of masculinity meant it went against every single one of Billy’s deeply ingrained instincts to write them. Still, once his headache had calmed from stabbing agony to a far more tolerable discomfort and his restless aggravation gave way to logic, he’d known he needed to. If his dream was nothing more than a morbid figment of his subconscious then fan-fucking-tastic, he’d wait a few weeks and then rip his own words apart with relish, but if it wasn’t?
Billy couldn’t imagine his death as anything other than quick and violent, the kind of painful, pointless end that didn’t leave any opportunity for last words. That assumption hadn’t changed since he was nine-years-old and seriously considering paddling towards the briefly glimpsed dorsal fin of a shark. For a long time he’d had next to no attachment to his shitty excuse for a life, with nobody who’d care if he disappeared, and nobody he would regret not saying goodbye to.
He had all those things, now. Which was about as galling as it was miraculously comforting. Contemplating his own death had always sent him oscillating between bitterness and apathy, and for that to change now – after moving into a town where bloodthirsty monsters and hell dimensions were real – was…inconvenient, to put it mildly.
It was just his goddamned luck, to have some vague as shit psychic dream about being dead only after he’d stopped wanting to die.
Dragging his hands roughly down his face, Billy exhaled a sharp breath and hunched back over his messy desk. Morning was only a few hours away, and he didn’t want to drag this self-imposed torture out even a minute longer than necessary. He’d already finished with the simplest letters, but just like her snippy personality, Maxine’s was proving to be fucking difficult. Writing down what might turn out to be his final words to his sister was draining in a way he hadn’t been prepared for, tired eyes burning with the repeated – and infuriating – threat of tears as he struggled to shake off the crippling doubt plaguing every flick of his pen.
Billy wanted to leave Maxine with something that would make her less… sad, but he had absolutely no fucking idea what he needed to write in order to accomplish that. Maybe something that would make her angry, instead. The little shit had always seemed more comfortable being pissed than being any variation of miserable, which was a character flaw they shared.
Fucking hell, if Maxine’s letter was giving him this much trouble then trying to compose something for Steve – gentlehearted, steadfast, easily hurt Steve – was going to be a goddamned nightmare.
Silently scolding himself for all of his uselessly whining procrastination, Billy fetched his current draft from where it’d fallen to the floor and picked up his pen, clicking it a few times before forcing himself to resume writing.
Two and a half hours later the sun was beginning to shine through the gaps in his drawn curtains, the cramp in his hand had worked its way up into his shoulder, and his lower lip was raw from how long he’d been gnawing at it. Maxine’s letter was in bits and pieces over about a dozen different pages, sentences and paragraphs he’d deemed acceptable between rambling bullshit he’d scratched into illegibility. Billy would fix it into one properly flowing document later, but for now he was entirely focused on ensuring Steve’s contained everything he wanted it to. Everything it needed to, if it was going to offer his best friend…
Offer him what, exactly? Closure? Truth? Something palpable to remember him by? Something he could read whenever he wanted, knowing every word was meant for him, and only him? Would Steve even want something like that, or would he be weirded out by the inherent – not to mention fucking mortifying, not that Billy would be alive to care – emotional intensity of a final, personalised letter? Knowing Steve he’d probably be honoured to realise Billy had thought to leave him anything at all, though that wouldn’t last long before he was devastated by what it contained, and what that contents signified.
Because as unnatural as it still felt – and would likely always feel – to acknowledge, Billy didn’t doubt for a second that his death would devastate Steve.
Hesitating over how he’d sign off before committing with an impatient click of his tongue and the faint sensation of heat in his cheeks, Billy folded the pages together and shoved them atop the messy stack of drafts to his left. He still needed to rewrite Maxine’s mess of a letter, check the others over for any stupid mistakes – unlike a certain dyslexic he could name, Billy had no excuse for shoddy spelling – and find the mental fortitude needed to write to one last person, but none of that was going to happen right now. His thoughts had started turning sluggish about thirty minutes ago, and while he typically wouldn’t hesitate to ignore the fatigue weighing down his entire body in favour of stubbornly pushing on, what he was writing was delicate and important and he didn’t want to fuck it up.
Rubbing at his eyes, Billy collected his drafts and envelopes before heaving himself out of his chair. As Maxine had so rudely demonstrated a few months ago, his desk drawer was not a good place to hide shit he’d rather not be seen by prying eyes. He moved over to his closet on silent feet, reaching inside and plucking his denim jacket from its hanger. Folding his collection of torn schoolbook pages into an even tighter configuration, Billy shoved everything into one of his jacket pockets, mostly confident that no-one – not even Neil at his most invasively vindictive – would think to check his clothes for any kind of incriminatingly emotional contraband.
Letters hidden well enough for now, he crossed the small distance back to his bed and promptly collapsed into it, curling up on his side and turning off his bedside lamp with an absentminded twitch of his fingers. His mattress was as lumpy as ever and his pillow still smelt like blood even after he flipped it to the clean side, but it felt damn good to be lying down after hours spent slouching over his desk.
Billy already knew he wouldn’t be sleeping – first because he didn’t fucking want to, second because his headache wouldn’t let him, and third because his alarm was due to go off within the hour – but he closed his eyes anyway, barely resisting the urge to turn his face into his pillow and let himself suffocate.
He was so fucking tired.
Tugging at his hair until the sting in his scalp was more prominent than the hollowing pang in his chest – Steve wouldn’t approve, but at least he hadn’t reached for his smokes – Billy turned his lethargic mind towards his dream, which was clear as crystal in his memory.
He replayed it from the beginning, focus as sharp as he could possibly make it as he studied the images playing out behind his closed eyelids. If his fucked-up dream really had been the result of his psychic bullshit – and he couldn’t afford to assume it wasn’t – then Billy was going to take a mental fine-tooth comb and go back over every morbid second of it. He didn’t know what he was looking for, but there had to be something he could use to avoid ending up dead on the Fourth of fucking July. There had to be, because if there wasn’t then what was the point?
Billy wanted to live, and if replaying the cold loneliness of his dream until he had every frame memorised might help him not get his ticket punched to the obnoxious cacophony of fireworks? That’s exactly what he’d fucking do, royally screwed-up sleep schedule be damned.
~
Maxine sat cross legged on the grass, hair pulled into a low plait and the headphones she’d been gifted at Christmas jammed firmly over her ears. Billy couldn’t see his sister’s face from his position standing almost directly behind her, but judging by her terrible posture and general air of melancholy it was easy to deduce she was pouting pretty goddamned hard about something.
Maybe she’d somehow managed to land herself on El’s shit-list again, or maybe she and Lucas had broken up. Also again. If it was the former then Billy was inclined to believe Maxine was probably the one at fault – Maxine’s tendency towards sarcasm and El’s incredibly blunt nature one spark away from blowing up their still somewhat tentative friendship – but if it was the latter? Well, Lucas had been warned about the consequences of hurting his little sister, and Billy knew where the nerd lived.
He wouldn’t actually do anything to the kid, but he knew he wouldn’t need to in order to make Lucas feel like a worthless sack of shit. For whatever bizarre reason the dweeb genuinely respected Billy – enough to seek out his approval before asking Maxine to be his girlfriend, anyway – and earning the disappointment of someone you looked up to could sting just as much as a smack across the face.
“You’re gonna fuck up your spine sitting like that.” Billy drawled, taking the few steps needed in order to place himself within reaching distance of Maxine’s morose form. Her lack of reaction told him she was blasting her music way too loud, and he bent down to tug at her plait with a displeased click of his tongue. He’d warned her time and again that it was dangerous to be so unaware of your surroundings, but of course she never fucking listened.
His fingers passed through her hair as if it were made of nothing but red-tinted mist, a rush of ice-cold numbness shooting through his hand and racing up his arm. The breath stealing sensation sunk into his jack-rabbiting heart and fucking stopped it, chest seizing with shock and dread.
Billy jerked away from Maxine’s ghost with a vehement curse, falling backwards as he stared wide-eyed at her stooped back. Temper flaring in response to his own rampant confusion, he scrambled to stand, unwilling to face whatever the hell was going on while sprawled gracelessly on his ass.
That he was dreaming was patently fucking obvious in hindsight, a single glance at his surroundings revealing everything except Maxine and the circle of grass surrounding her to be blurred beyond recognition. Still, that knowledge did absolutely nothing to soothe the sharp unease tying his stomach into knots.
This didn’t feel like a dream, or even one of his nightmares. It felt…disturbingly real.
When willing himself back awake failed to do anything other than frustrate the shit out of him, Billy slowly approached Maxine’s hollow copy once again, curiosity warring with and then winning over caution. He lowered himself into a tense crouch a few feet away on her right, tilting his head to observe her downturned face.
His sister looked fucking awful, sickeningly pale and even more sickeningly thin, with bloodless lips and red-rimmed ice-blue eyes. Billy’s first instinct was to grab her by the shoulders and demand to know what was wrong – like him, Maxine hated admitting when she anything other than fine – but he fought the urge down before his hands could so much as twitch by his sides. Reaching out now wouldn’t do a damn thing except give him shivers, and he’d rather not see any more proof of Maxine’s intangibility.
It reminded him too much of Bob, and the way he’d faded into mist in that pitch dark emptiness Billy had unknowingly trapped them both inside.
Stuck on what the hell he was supposed to do in this freakishly silent dreamscape if waking up wasn’t an option, Billy pressed his palms to his knees and straightened up, casting another frustrated glance at his blurred surroundings.
The small crowd of black-clad, featureless figures that appeared out of fucking nowhere along the edge of his heavily obscured perception nearly gave him a goddamned heart attack. Placing himself between them and Maxine was second nature, but as time slipped by and none of the shadowy people – if that’s even what they were, their forms blurring into each other until they appeared more like a demonic-looking, multi-headed black mass than individuals – made a single movement or uttered a single sound, Billy slowly unclenched his white-knuckled fists. They were just standing there, watching from an oddly respectful distance.
“What do you want?”
None of the figures deigned to answer, which had Billy spitting some choice insults before resolutely turning away from them. Tension coiled around his militarily straight spine the moment the people – or monsters? – were out of his immediate sight, but he forced himself not to look back. What was there to be scared of, anyway? All this bullshit was nothing but a weird as fuck dream, and like hell was he going to show fear to a bunch of unmoving, mute motherfuckers drenched in black.
Where before the space in front of Maxine had been nothing but a greenish-grey haze, there now sat a plain gravestone. Billy’s eyes darted over its neat inscription, the rapidly growing weakness in his legs forcing him down until he was kneeling beside the ghost of his little sister.
WILLIAM HARGROVE
MAR. 29 1967
JUL. 4 1985
GONE BUT NOT FORGOTTEN
Maybe he was the ghost.
Shit.
The weakness in his lower half spread like an infection throughout the rest of his body, and the only thing keeping it from overwhelming him was a powerful surge of indignation. Because fucking William? Seriously? It might be the name on his birth certificate, but nobody ever actually used it – not even his mom back when she was still around – and if they did? They’d learn pretty goddamned quickly that Billy had plenty of bite to go along with his bark.
Williams had godawful bowl-cuts and big, sad brown eyes. Billy’s had weaponised grins and a kickass car. Like he’d once asked Steve after the asshole dared to call him Bill, did he look like he was seventy fucking years old?
Knowing his dad, he’d had the gravestone inscribed like that on purpose, marking Billy’s final resting place with a name nobody would recognise as his. One last fuck you to his piece of shit son.
Billy tore his wild-eyed stare from the gravestone, studying Maxine’s drawn face with the sudden, terrible understanding that she looked so bereft because he was fucking dead. Her name escaped his lips near soundlessly, punched out of him by the sudden rush of guilt constricting his lungs. Overcome with a ferocious protectiveness that demanded he fucking do something – that her grief was his fault and he needed to fix it – Billy reached a subtly shaking hand out towards her.
Maybe he would have tried to shake Maxine out of her moping, or squeeze her shoulder in a paltry attempt at reassurance, or just pat her on the back because what the fuck were you supposed to do when it was your death being mourned? Whatever he might have done didn’t matter, because just like before his hand passed through his sister’s incorporeal form like she wasn’t even there.
Because she wasn’t there. Because he was dreaming, for fucks sake.
Suddenly so angry he could barely think beyond the feeling, Billy rose up on one knee and swept his arms sharply through the space Maxine’s spectre occupied, steadfastly ignoring the shiver of fear that clogged his throat when she disappeared into whisps of pale smoke. Next he gave his unwanted audience a hateful sneer, all but snarling when their only reaction was to remain watchful – their empty faces didn’t have eyes but he could fucking feel their stares digging into him anyway – and silent. Flipping them off, Billy dismissed them outright and turned his fury towards the headstone. His headstone.
Jesus fucking Christ.
Infuriated all over again at the sight of the impersonal, disgustingly formal William, he reeled a tightly clenched fist back and-
The shrill beep of his alarm jolted Billy out of his restless half-doze, and with an irritated groan he groggily willed it to stop. The crunch of plastic and circuitry had his head whipping up and eyes snapping open, another, more irritated groan scraping past his dry throat when he saw the shattered remains of his alarm clock.
It was the second one he’d accidently destroyed in less than three months.
Occupying his frazzled mind by planning a trip down to Melvald’s for yet another replacement – something practical and simple and fucking normal – Billy levered himself up and threw his legs over the edge of his bed. He sat still for a few prolonged moments, breathing through a mild wave of dizziness before carefully finding his feet. Still very pointedly not thinking about his clusterfuck of a night, Billy exited his bedroom and made a beeline for the kitchen.
Maxine had started waking up early enough to demand a share of the French-toast he’d gotten back into the habit of making, and as much as Billy grumbled about the extra effort, he liked the comfortable mundanity of their Sunday morning breakfasts together. Making and eating French-toast still made him think of his mom – he knew it always would – but even though the memories ached they were still good, and he didn’t try to shy away from them anymore.
Billy wasn’t about to let some fucked-up, potentially prophetic dream ruin his morning before it had even started. There’d be plenty of time to worry about it later, along with the unfinished letters sitting like dark, shameful secrets in his closet.
It was only mid-June, anyway. If the date of death on his shitty headstone really was a warning conjured by some sort of psychic self-preservation instinct, he still had a bit more than a fortnight to figure out how to stay alive.
Easy fucking peasy.
