Actions

Work Header

A Stack of Letters and No Outgoing Mail

Summary:

Almost three years have passed since Hannibal surrendered outside of Will's farmhouse in Wolftrap. As another year draws to a close, both Will and Hannibal find ways to harness their complicated emotions and express all the things they wish they could say to each other.

Notes:

this fic was solely inspired by this TikTok edit , so thank you to that creator and to Cameron Winter's beautiful song :,)

though this fic is a standalone, i've included some easter eggs from my long-form fic (click here) so check that out for more! (i'm still slowly uploading chapters to it)

this made me sad to write, so let's all be sad together <3

Chapter Text

Will grit his teeth in irritation as he crumpled the lined paper he had covered with clumsy words and broken sentences. He winced as the rough edges of the paper earned him yet another small cut on the pad of his thumb. 

Several pages were now missing from the back of one of Walter’s school notebooks, as Will had torn them out, one by one, hoping that each would be the last. 

He glanced at the analog clock on the wall opposite him, its rusted pendulum creaking—a noise he had learned to block out. After living with Molly and Walter for over two years, there were lots of things Will had learned to block out. He squinted at the time: 3:00 pm. Molly and Walter would be back soon, as well as the end of Will’s hour of quiet contemplation and mental solitude. 

Walter would come in the house, loudly complaining about another humdrum day of school, and Molly would console him by offering to make his favorite chocolate chip cookies—ones that Will would always pretend to be impressed by. 

Because he knew someone else that could make an infinitely better— 

Will balled his hand into a fist and smacked the table in frustration. Almost three years had passed since that awful night outside his farmhouse. After Hannibal had been hauled off by Jack and his team, Will had waited until the flashing lights of the police vehicles disappeared before he reemerged out of his front door to stare at the imprint Hannibal’s kneeling figure had left in the snow.

Now, it was the end of December, marking the conclusion of another year that he had survived. 

Survived. He wasn’t really living—not anymore. 

As he stared at yet another empty page, he wondered why he bothered. The stark whiteness of the paper seemed to mock him, goading him into sharing the shameful admissions he had promised he would keep buried in the dark recesses of his mind. He had tried this countless times before, his attempts always ending with a wave of guilt and regret washing over him—a persistent ache in his chest. 

Will flexed the fingers of his left hand, his ring finger bare. Whenever he sat down in front of a blank page, a half-dried black ballpoint pen in his hand, he felt the need to remove his wedding ring. 

Why? He wasn’t sure. The guilty part of him knew that what he was doing could be considered a betrayal of his wife, but Will couldn’t help himself. 

Where Hannibal was concerned, he never could. 

Will took a deep breath, his pen hesitating over the paper before his shaking hand finally made contact: 

 

Dear Hannibal, 

 

“Dear Hannibal?” Will thought, immediately scratching out the greeting. It was too intimate, and—at the same time—too cold. But hadn’t his relationship with Hannibal always been that way? 

They were a dyad riddled with contradictions—a tangled web of confusion and betrayal, love and loyalty, and… 

He needed to return to the task at hand; otherwise, these thoughts would cause him to drift toward the sideboard and grab his favorite whiskey bottle out of habit. 

The same way his father used to. 

 

Dr. Lecter, 

 

No, that was too forced. Hannibal would know that Will was trying too hard to sound nonchalant. 

Will dragged a hand down his face as he sighed, ripping yet another page from the notebook, nearly tearing this one in half. He wondered if he should even address Hannibal at all. After everything Hannibal put him through, Will certainly didn’t owe him any kind of acknowledgment. 

But, even though he had physically and emotionally damaged Will, Hannibal had also saved him many times. That deserved some kind of recognition: 

 

Hannibal, 

I’m sure you’ve been wondering whether I’d ever contact you. I’ve been wondering the same. 

It’s been almost three years since we last saw each other. How has confinement treated you? 

 

Will scratched the back of his neck, unsure whether this last sentence sounded too disparaging. He had done his best to avoid information about Hannibal’s trial, eventually conditioning Molly to hastily turn off the TV if Hannibal was ever mentioned on the news. 

She knew very little of Will’s entanglement with Hannibal. He had told her just enough to know it was a very sore subject—one that should never be brought up. Which, of course, made Hannibal feel like an ever-present shadow over every room Will entered. Will carried on: 

 

I’m not sure if Alana has told you, but I’m married now. It was a small ceremony—my dogs were most of the guests. She has a boy, and we’re still learning how to get along. 

 

Will set his pen down and picked up his wedding ring, spinning it on the table until it made him dizzy. 

“She.” He couldn’t even bear to say his own wife’s name. It was true that he and Walter were still working on their relationship—or lack thereof. Walter’s father had died several years before Will met Molly, and Will had never tried to take his place in Walter’s life. 

He told himself that it was out of respect for the boy’s late father, but he knew the real reason: He simply didn’t care enough to try to foster a connection between them. 

He blinked, thinking back to all those years ago when he had almost had the opportunity to be a father. “I would be a good father,” he had said—to Hannibal, of all people. 

Hannibal, who had taken away the only other parent-child relationship he could fathom: Abigail Hobbs. Will hadn’t known it at the time, but Abigail was alive. Hannibal had watched Will grieve a child he didn’t even know, when he could have spared Will the heartache by giving him the child he always wished he could have. 

Until he took her away. As he was bleeding out on Hannibal’s kitchen floor, Will had watched Hannibal wrap his arms around Abigail and slit her throat—the same way her father tried to do. 

Hannibal, and Will by extension, had promised to protect Abigail. Both of them had failed, but the blame lay more heavily with one than the other. 

Will glanced at the clock again. Molly and Walter were due to be back soon, and Will hadn’t even filled a quarter of the page. He continued, wondering if there was even a message he was trying to convey: 

 

I know almost nothing about what’s happened to you. I didn’t watch your trial, and I certainly didn’t read Chilton’s book. All I know is that you ended up at the BSHCI. But that’s where you wanted to be, isn’t it? 

I’ve always wondered why you surrendered. Whatever game you thought you were playing, you’ve lost. I meant it when I said I don’t want to find you, or see you, or speak to you again. 

 

Will pulled his pen off the page and leaned back in his chair. Lie, lie, lie. He was wrong—Hannibal had won his twisted game. 

Will did want to find Hannibal. He wanted to look him in the eyes and speak to him again. Even though he had long since recovered from the mental manipulation Hannibal had put him through, the inner voice in Will’s mind still sounded like Hannibal. 

He still heard Hannibal’s accent roll smoothly over certain vowels and hook on certain words. “How does that make you feel?” was a phrase that constantly bounced around Will’s head. 

He had no idea how he felt anymore. He had once told Hannibal that he felt like he was fading, and he felt the same could be said now—but he didn’t have an illness as an excuse this time. 

Will took a shaky breath, wondering why he kept tormenting himself. He had kept these emotions bottled up for nearly three years. Even if Hannibal hadn’t earned the right to hear these words from Will, Will owed it to himself to finally get them off his chest: 

 

I’ve been wanting to write to you for a long time—years now. I must admit that I’m disappointed you haven’t tried to write to me. There are so many things I want to say to you, but I’m not sure you deserve to hear them. 

You’ve hurt me, Hannibal. I haven’t seen you in years, and you’re still hurting me now. What have you done to me that makes me feel your absence so strongly? 

 

Will’s brows furrowed as he read his last sentence. It was a wayward thought that seemed to have slipped out. 

A very honest thought. Too honest for Will’s liking. 

He used his pen to furiously scratch it out, leaving the words illegible beneath the frenzied lines of ink. He tried again: 

 

I resent you for this, but I know you already know that. When you wander through the halls of your memory palace, do you ever find me? Do I haunt you there? 

I hope so. 

 

That sounded spiteful and rude, which Hannibal would hate. It gave Will a vindictive sort of pleasure to imagine Hannibal excitedly reading Will’s letter, only to find that Will wished him to suffer the same mental anguish that he had endured. 

Will frowned as he realized that there was something in his own words that he resented himself for. Perhaps it was because it was still difficult to extract his thoughts from Hannibal’s. “You and I have begun to blur,” he had said as he and Hannibal sat in the quiet Uffizi Gallery, staring at Botticelli’s Primavera. 

 

When my mind stills, and I’m wrapped in quiet darkness or enveloped by a soft breeze, I think of you. I see you behind my eyelids when I sleep at night. Whether I see you as a dream or a nightmare, I’m still not sure. 

 

A muscle tensed in Will’s jaw as he prepared himself for what he was about to write. It was a memory that he simultaneously hated and thanked Hannibal for, as it was a constant reminder of Hannibal’s presence in Will’s life. It made him feel a poignant sense of loneliness—one that was both comforting and tragic. 

 

“‘You can make it all go away.’” I don’t want to forget. A part of me will always hate myself for not leaving with you. 

“‘Put your head back.’” I sometimes wish you had killed me—the absence of you is more painful than any physical wound you’ve inflicted. I see a shape of you in the shadows—my shadow—and I always turn around, expecting to find you there. 

“‘Close your eyes.’” I still have nightmares. Part of me will always see you as evil and cunning, but that makes me feel less alone. The man I was before I met you pales in comparison to the one that’s been left in your wake. 

“‘Wade into the quiet of the stream.’” I hear your voice whisper to me when I’m out fishing, the soft current moving around me. I can never discern what you’re saying to me, and I think it’s better off that way. I don’t want you to reel me back in like a fish on a hook, unable to resist your bait. 

 

Will blinked in confusion as a bead of water fell onto the paper. When he touched a hand to his cheek, he was surprised to find wetness there. Whenever he’d attempted to write a letter to Hannibal before, he had never cried. Then again, he had never gotten this vulnerable. Some of his failed attempts were reveling in Hannibal’s imprisonment, and others merely wished him well. 

This time was different. Will was finally being honest in the way he and Hannibal both deserved. Now that the door was open, he was powerless to control what else came through: 

 

I miss you, Hannibal. I miss smelling your rich cologne as you mock my cheap aftershave. I miss the way you smile when you’ve caught on to someone’s weakness—you always were working some angle. I miss being around someone who understands me—who knows me better than anyone else. 

Do you miss me too? I frequently think about visiting you. Would you want to see me? Would I truly be ready to face you? 

I think the answer to the latter is “no.” If I see you again, I don’t think I’d be able to look away. 

 

Will’s head shot up as he heard a car door slam, announcing Molly and Walter’s arrival. He returned his attention to the paper in front of him, finally scribbling out the thought that had been working away at the steadfast bars in his mind—bars that had finally crumbled to dust: 

 

I wouldn’t be able to look away because I’d want to be in there with you. The only peace I’ve ever found is by your side. I said I can’t think about you anymore, and yet, that’s all I do. I hate feeling this way, Hannibal. 

I’m sorry I’m not brave enough to see you again. Just know that I wish I could. 

 

Will jumped at the usual chorus of his dogs barking at any movement behind the door. Heart hammering, he stared down at his letter. Though there was more emotion behind it than anything he’d felt over the last three years, he still felt like something was missing. Just as Molly and Walter came through the door, he found the final words he was looking for: 

 

Love,

Will 

 

As he folded the letter into a neat square and stuck it in his pocket, he knew he was never going to send it. But, just in case a surge of courage ever struck him, he sealed it inside an envelope anyway.

Chapter 2

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

It was the end of December, marking the start of the third year since he had surrendered. 

Not for the first time, Hannibal was staring at a blank page of expensive parchment stationery paper. Even though he had promised to end her life, he still had to thank Alana for accommodating his “frivolous” requests—as she called them. Though Hannibal knew she was doing it to mock him, he appreciated that he could maintain some sense of dignity. 

The one request that she had denied was his request for a scalpel—for his pencils, of course. It was severely inconvenient to request to have them sharpened by a disgruntled orderly who would sooner clean his toilet than sharpen a pencil to Hannibal’s precise liking. 

But he was willing to go through the trouble today. 

As he took the pencil in his hand, he shifted aside his most recent drawing: Prometheus handing the first torch of fire to mankind. He modeled the sketch of the Titan god after Friedrich Fuger’s painting of the classic Greek myth. In Fuger’s interpretation, the god’s face was wild and regal, with golden hair and bright eyes. 

Hannibal had decided on an altogether different rendition. In his drawing of Prometheus, the god’s face was much softer—still elegant and poised, but also more subdued and sad. 

He had used a face he could draw from memory, one that haunted both his sleeping and waking hours. After almost three years, Hannibal was startled to find that it was becoming harder and harder to remember its finer details. 

He stared at his drawing for several seconds, impressed by how Will fit right into the scene. 

Hannibal shouldn’t have been surprised. He had inserted Will into many of his drawings in recent years, as if repeatedly shaping his features would conjure the real Will in front of him. 

Hannibal often wondered what Will thought of him now. Did Hannibal’s memory follow him like some dark, hovering shadow? Or did Will choose to reflect on the “happier” moments in their relationship—if those moments even existed. 

Knowing Will, the former was probably true. 

Hannibal sighed, straightening the paper in front of him. It was a pleasant cream color, reminding Hannibal of a time when Will had accidentally poured too much milk in his coffee. His nose had scrunched in disgust, setting his oval glasses askew. 

Small flashes of memories were all Hannibal had left of Will to cling to now. 

He finally touched the tip of his pencil to the page, frowning at the dusting of charcoal that immediately scattered across the paper. 

This was why he was insistent on sharpening his own pencils. 

Hannibal had written many letters to Will over the last three years, and they were all neatly arranged in a thin box that he kept under his bed. Of course, it wasn’t really hidden. He was surveilled by cameras day and night, so if Alana wanted to barge into his “cell” and confiscate them, she was well within her right to do so. 

But Hannibal guessed she believed that holding onto these letters was punishment enough for him—keeping his thoughts of Will so close, even though Will couldn’t be farther away. 

The first letter he had written was brief and scattered. Hannibal hadn’t known whether to be angry at Will or to begrudgingly wish him well. He decided on the latter—before he immediately tore the paper in half and tossed it into the trash. 

The tone of the rest of his letters shifted based on his mood—sometimes mocking and arrogant, sometimes vulnerable and kind. When Alana had burst into his cell two years ago to happily announce that Will was now married, Hannibal had angrily snatched a piece of his expensive paper—wrinkling it in the process—and written Will a long, vicious letter to tell him that he would never be able to escape his past—how would his new wife feel if she knew about everything that he and Hannibal had done? 

But then Hannibal had stopped to think that maybe she did know everything about Will’s entanglement with him. It was difficult for Hannibal to comprehend the idea of Will opening up to someone else the way they had with each other, but maybe Hannibal was wrong. 

It seemed that Will had changed. He really meant it when he said he didn’t want to think about Hannibal anymore. 

By the end of that letter, his conclusion was barely legible, as tears peppered the paper, causing the ink to bleed through. 

That was why he only wrote with pencils now. 

 

Dear Will, 

 

All of his letters started this way. He loved the way Will’s name looked in his elegant script, the top of the “W” curving into a dramatic swoop. He realized that, aside from those ridiculous clocks Will had drawn, Hannibal had no idea what his handwriting looked like. If Will were to send him a letter, would it be composed of neat letters in orderly rows, standing like soldiers guarding Will’s words? Or would it be full of messy sentences that Hannibal would have to squint to distinguish? 

Hannibal hated venturing down such trains of thought—it was fruitless. Will wasn’t coming, and—even after almost three years—Hannibal still struggled to accept that. 

He took a deep breath and continued: 

 

It’s the end of another year. As I look toward the future, I fear this next one will feel even longer than the last. What does your future look like, Will? Do you still wish to be a father? I think you would be a good one, as long as you don’t let your past come knocking. 

 

Though Hannibal really did believe that Will would be a good father, a knot formed in the pit of his stomach at the idea of Will sharing a child with someone else. They were supposed to share a child: Abigail Hobbs. 

During his years of solitude, Hannibal had accepted that his reaction to Will’s betrayal was unforgivable. Taking his anger out on a girl who had already suffered the same wound from her own father was despicable, even by his standards. At the time, seeing the look of horror and devastation on Will’s face was satisfying, but Hannibal now reflected on that night with immeasurable guilt and regret. 

Hannibal blinked, doing his best to stave off the swell of emotions that always overcame him when he thought of what he had done to Abigail. 

 

Do you ever think of me? I sometimes feel your keen eyes staring me down, and I always wonder if your mind is reaching out toward mine. You know where to find me, Will. The doors of my memory palace are always open for old friends. 

Is that what we are? Are we considered “old friends” because our friendship has endured over so many years, or because it has gone stale? Neither of us has had many friends to determine which is more true. 

 

Hannibal frowned as he reread his last few statements. His faith in Will hadn’t wavered over the years—he still considered him a friend. Did Will feel the same? Or did Will have new friends who made him forget Hannibal completely? 

 

Are we still friends, Will? I can’t say I’d blame you if your answer is “no.” I must admit that, whenever I think of you now, I realize that I’m slowly forgetting more and more about you. A true friend would never forget his beloved. 

 

His “beloved?” Hannibal thought. Though Hannibal’s feelings for Will had always been complicated, they had heightened after he was institutionalized. 

Hannibal missed him. Even though his compassion for Will extended far beyond friendship, he—for his own sanity—had to force himself to perceive Will as nothing more than a friend. 

 

Have you forgotten me? Part of me hopes you have. You deserve to be free of the burdens of your past—including me. There is nothing to be gained from looking back. I hope your future is more promising than mine. 

But the selfish part of me yearns for you, Will. Even if you think of me with resentment, I’d be comforted by knowing that at least you still think of me. If I’m ever fortunate enough to see you again, I’d be content to face your anger, since it will give me a chance to lay eyes on you once more. 

When we spoke of ideals all those years ago, I wondered if you could hear it in my voice. I tried to tell you, Will. You are my imago—the perfect culmination of everything dark and beautiful, wonderful and untamed. I hope that, one day, you will realize this. 

Maybe you already have. 

 

Hannibal lightly tapped his index finger against the desk, trying to dispel the emotion welling up in his eyes. This letter was somehow more intense than others he had written. Even the one that carried three simple words: I love you. 

Hannibal had thought better of continuing with that one, as Will would surely balk at a comment so direct. Not that it mattered—Hannibal never intended to send the letter. 

But that didn’t keep him from imagining Will’s reaction anyway. 

 

I miss you, Will, even though I still feel you right beside me. Such a strange paradox, isn’t it? Now that I have an endless supply of free time, I’ve taken up drawing again. I just finished a drawing of Prometheus—an ancient Greek Titan. I think you’d like who he was modeled after. 

He showed empathy to mankind, so much so that he was punished for it. Does that sound familiar? You may share in his triumphs, but I share in his punishment. He was chained to a rock, where an eagle feasted on his liver every day. In that way, he and I were both responsible for our own suffering. 

Though I must admit that—for the eagle—he was getting the sweet end of the deal. The liver was always one of my favorites. 

How would you react if I showed you this drawing? Your reaction to my depiction of you as Patroclus was extremely gratifying. Even back then, you knew of my unfortunate compassion for you—whether you were fully aware of it or not. 

 

Hannibal’s hand was shaking now, his finger tapping the desk more persistently.

 

This is the fifteenth letter I’ve written you—the fifteenth one I’ll never send. I store them out of sight, as if I’m pretending I’ve shipped them off to you. 

If I were to write you, would you even dignify me with a response? I must admit that I’m unsure. Then again, I could never entirely predict you. That, above all else, has always been your most alluring quality. 

Is there anything you miss about me, Will? You always looked on my long-winded metaphors with disdain, but I wonder if you miss them now. The world is ever so polite and mundane—maybe it would serve you well to think of me. Let me serve as your reminder that there is a far more grisly side of life, if you only dare to venture out that way again. 

Do you miss me the same way I miss you? It is a special kind of torment to live this way. I often resent you for bringing me so much pain, but I’ve come to realize that you’ve taught me to be human. I saw up close what empathy does to a person. I didn’t realize how close I was going to get. 

When I think of you, I pity you. I pity you for never embracing the life you were always meant for. I pity myself for the disappointment of not being the one to show you how. Nevertheless, I hope you’re happy, Will. 

It’s the least of what you deserve. I’m sorry I couldn’t offer you more. 

 

Hannibal set down his pencil and pushed the letter to the side so he could rest his elbows on the desk and put his head in his hands. 

This letter was different from the rest, and he wasn’t quite sure why. He had felt compelled to share so much vulnerability, as if he were talking directly to Will, offering his heart on a platter. 

What would Will do with it? Would he hold it close and protect it as if it were his own? Or would he toss it aside and take pleasure in destroying the last shred of hope for a reconciliation that Hannibal clung to. 

He jolted in his seat as he realized he never wrote a farewell. He quickly picked up his pencil and scribbled the same signature as the rest of the letters: 

 

Yours, always, 

Hannibal Lecter 

 

He took a small envelope and tucked the letter inside, licking the seal before firmly closing it. He hesitated before slipping it inside the box under his bed. 

Out of all the letters, this was the one he most wanted to send.

Notes:

thanks for reading! if you have any feedback or would simply like to chat, you can reach me on instagram