Work Text:
The question was not meant to hurt him.
That was perhaps why Bilbo answered it.
Much later, Thorin would wonder what might have happened if the question had been asked in council, with formal chairs and guards at the doors and everyone remembering exactly who they were.
Bilbo would probably have smiled.
He would have said something clever about Gandalf being very persuasive.
Perhaps he would have complained about unexpected dwarves eating his pantry bare.
Everyone would have laughed.
And that would have been that.
But it was not asked in council.
It was asked on an evening when everyone was tired enough to be comfortable.
The room had once been some minor receiving chamber in Erebor. Not grand enough for kings, apparently, but too large for a private sitting room. It had therefore become, through no decision anyone could remember making, a place where people gathered.
The fire was lit.
Someone had found cushions.
Bombur had discovered that a table against the eastern wall could hold an astonishing quantity of food.
There were mugs everywhere.
Bilbo approved.
The Mountain was still wounded.
So were they.
The great gates were being repaired. Corridors still bore black marks from dragonfire. Parts of Erebor remained inaccessible, and every day brought another discovery: a collapsed passage, a sealed storeroom, a chamber full of things someone remembered from childhood and could not enter without weeping.
But Erebor lived.
That mattered.
More importantly, its people lived.
All of them.
Thorin's left arm remained strapped tightly against his body, the shoulder and upper arm healing slowly from wounds that Óin still became grim-faced about if anyone asked too many questions.
Bilbo's right leg was stretched upon a stool with two cushions beneath it.
He disliked the cushions.
He disliked the stool.
He disliked the splint even more.
He had expressed these opinions repeatedly.
Óin had expressed his opinion that Master Baggins could either use the stool willingly or be tied to his bed until the leg healed.
Bilbo had decided the stool was tolerable.
Fíli still moved carefully when he thought no one was watching.
Kíli had perfected the art of looking healthy while leaning against furniture.
Dwalin was carrying enough hidden bandaging beneath his clothes to mummify a small pony.
Thorin tired too quickly.
Bilbo tired even faster.
None of them admitted any of it.
They were alive.
For the moment, that was enough.
And somehow their quiet room had expanded beyond the Company.
Dáin was there.
He had spent most of the evening arguing with Glóin over iron shipments, stopped discussing iron shipments when Bilbo threatened to throw bread at both of them, and was now drinking ale beside Balin.
Bard had come to discuss rebuilding agreements between Dale and Erebor and had somehow remained for supper.
Bilbo suspected Bombur.
Tauriel was speaking quietly with Óin about a woodland plant which apparently had different properties depending upon whether it was harvested before or after flowering.
Legolas stood near one of the carved pillars, listening to both conversations without appearing to listen to either.
That was a very Elvish trick.
Bilbo had been trying to learn it.
He had not succeeded.
Thorin had also stopped glaring at Legolas every time Bilbo looked away.
Mostly.
Bilbo considered that progress.
Perhaps even the beginning of friendship.
Or at least the beginning of diplomatic relations which did not involve anyone reaching for a sword.
Gandalf was there too.
Bilbo had forgotten that.
Not truly forgotten.
One did not entirely forget the presence of a wizard.
But Gandalf had arrived late, after Bilbo had already settled beside Thorin, and had taken one of the deeper chairs beyond the main pool of firelight. He was not hiding. There was nothing secretive in his position.
He had simply sat somewhat apart, pipe in hand, listening to Balin and Bard discussing roads.
Then he had fallen silent.
And Bilbo, whose attention was divided between Thorin, tea, and making certain Kíli did not steal the last honey cake, had ceased to consciously notice him.
That mattered.
Later, it mattered very much.
Because someone asked:
"Why did you come?"
Bilbo looked up.
Kíli was watching him.
Bilbo blinked.
"To this room?"
Kíli laughed.
"No."
"To Erebor? I seem to recall being dragged the final few miles by a particularly unreasonable dwarf prince who insisted my leg was broken."
"It was broken."
"It was only slightly broken."
"Óin said—"
"Kíli."
The young dwarf grinned.
"On the Quest."
Bilbo's smile faded.
"Why did you come on the Quest?"
Something changed.
It was very small.
Thorin felt it because he was sitting beside him.
Bilbo did not move.
He did not gasp.
He did not pale.
He merely became still.
Kíli noticed too.
His grin disappeared.
"I don't mean—"
"No."
Bilbo picked up his tea.
It had gone cold.
"Quite all right."
Fíli was watching now.
"So why?" Kíli asked.
Bilbo took a sip anyway.
"Temporary insanity."
Bofur laughed.
"Sounds about right."
"Indigestion," Bilbo added. "Possibly a head injury."
"Before we'd met you?" Glóin asked.
"I had a very eventful morning."
That earned more laughter.
Bilbo smiled.
It almost worked.
Then Fíli said:
"It was something you said after Goblin-town."
Bilbo's fingers tightened around his cup.
The laughter faded.
Fíli frowned, remembering.
"When we thought you'd left."
Bilbo knew exactly what was coming.
He wished, suddenly and desperately, that he did not.
"'You've got no home,'" Fíli quoted slowly. "'It was taken from you.'"
Kíli picked it up.
"'But I will help you take it back if I can.'"
Silence.
Bilbo looked into his tea.
"Good words," Dwalin said.
Bilbo's throat tightened.
"Thank you."
"True words," Balin added.
Bilbo looked at him.
Balin's expression was gentle.
"But not all the words, I think."
There it was.
Bilbo could lie.
He was rather good at lying now.
That was another thing he had learned on the Quest.
He could tell them he had meant exactly what he said.
He could say he had become fond of them.
He could mention the contract.
He could make some joke about Tookish blood and disappear into his rooms before anyone realised he had not actually answered.
He nearly did.
Then Thorin's fingers brushed his wrist.
Not holding.
Not restraining.
Simply there.
Bilbo looked at him.
Thorin's eyes were warm.
Patient.
Trusting.
Bilbo looked away.
"Do you know very much about hobbits?"
There was a pause.
Dáin grunted.
"More than I did six months ago."
"That would not be difficult."
Bofur snorted into his ale.
Bilbo smiled faintly.
"We're small."
Thorin's expression changed.
Bilbo saw it.
"Small, Thorin. Not weak."
"I know."
Immediate.
Absolute.
Bilbo's smile softened.
"I know you do."
That, at least, had changed.
Once, Thorin had looked at him and seen someone soft and foolish and entirely unsuited to the world beyond his garden gate.
Now Thorin knew better.
They all did.
"Hobbits can fight," Bilbo said. "We simply prefer not to."
"A sensible preference," Bard observed.
"Thank you."
Bilbo shifted carefully, adjusting his injured leg.
"We have archers. Hunters. Bounders. Hobbits who know how to use a club or a knife if they must. A hobbit defending his hole or his family can be a remarkably unpleasant opponent."
Dwalin nodded approvingly.
"But we don't have soldiers."
Dáin stopped drinking.
"No standing army?"
"No."
"Militia?"
"Not really."
"Fortifications?"
Bilbo smiled.
"Hedges."
Dáin stared at him.
"Very good hedges."
"Bilbo."
"Some have gates."
Dáin lowered his mug.
Bilbo sighed.
"No walls. No fortresses. No army. No trained force capable of standing against one."
Legolas had turned from the pillar.
Bilbo did not notice.
The Elven prince did.
He understood borders.
He understood the difference between peaceful and undefended.
The Woodland Realm was hidden and guarded, its paths watched, its king defended, its warriors trained over centuries.
Its people might sing beneath trees and feast beneath stars, but blades were never far away.
A realm without an army was not merely peaceful.
It was dependent.
"Then who guards your borders?" Bard asked.
"The Bounders."
"You said they weren't soldiers."
"They aren't."
Bilbo hesitated.
"They keep ordinary trouble out. They watch for strangers. Warn people. Deal with disputes. Sometimes wolves."
Dáin's brows drew together.
"And if ordinary trouble becomes an army?"
Bilbo was silent.
Dáin understood before the answer came.
"Someone else."
Bilbo nodded.
"Someone else."
He rubbed his thumb along the edge of his cup.
"The Rangers."
Legolas's eyes sharpened.
"Dúnedain?"
Bilbo looked at him.
"Yes."
Legolas knew of them.
Not well, perhaps, but enough.
Scattered Men.
Watchers of empty lands.
Descendants of kings who dressed like wanderers and guarded people who often never knew they existed.
"They patrol beyond our borders," Bilbo continued. "They keep many dangers away before we ever see them. Most hobbits don't know how much they do."
"And the Elves?" Tauriel asked.
"Sometimes."
Bilbo glanced towards her.
"Not often openly. But there are Elves who travel near the Shire. And sometimes when danger has been particularly bad..."
He stopped.
There was an old story his mother used to tell.
Not a proper story.
More a fragment.
A Took-story.
Those were different.
Proper hobbit stories had beginnings and endings and respectable morals.
Took-stories had gaps.
Names people refused to explain.
Journeys no one admitted had happened.
"And?" Fíli prompted.
Bilbo blinked.
"And sometimes Elves help."
Legolas watched him.
Bilbo had said it too carefully.
As though repeating something learned.
Balin heard it too.
"When?" he asked.
Bilbo looked uncomfortable.
"Oh, various times."
"Such as?"
Bilbo sighed.
"You dwarves do realise curiosity is supposed to be a hobbit failing?"
"No," said Dwalin.
"Apparently not."
Bilbo settled deeper into his chair.
"The Fell Winter."
Bard straightened.
Even Dáin knew that name.
Bilbo looked into the fire.
"Long before I was born. Terrible winter. Wolves crossed the Brandywine. White Wolves."
His voice softened.
"Hobbits still tell stories about it."
The Fell Winter had become almost unreal in the telling.
Snow higher than doors.
The river frozen.
Food disappearing.
Wolves coming out of the north.
The Horn-call of Buckland sounding through the darkness.
"People died," Bilbo said.
The room quieted.
"Hobbits don't like putting that part in children's stories."
No one interrupted.
"My mother was young before it happened. Not a child, but young."
Bilbo smiled despite himself.
"Belladonna Took."
"Your mother," Thorin said.
"Yes."
Bilbo's expression changed when he spoke of her.
Legolas noticed that too.
Love.
Grief.
Pride.
"Belladonna was..."
Bilbo considered.
"Trouble."
Bofur laughed.
"That explains a great deal."
"Indeed."
Bilbo smiled.
"She was one of the Old Took's daughters. She and her sisters were famous. Or infamous. Depending upon who was speaking."
"Tookish," Kíli said.
"Extremely."
Bilbo's smile lingered.
"Before the Fell Winter, Belladonna went away."
"Where?" Fíli asked.
"She never told me."
That silenced them.
Bilbo shrugged.
"I asked. Many times. She'd say she had gone walking."
Dwalin stared.
"For how long?"
"Several months."
Dwalin's eyebrows rose.
"That is a long walk."
"I pointed that out."
"What did she say?"
"That she had short legs."
Kíli burst out laughing.
Even Thorin smiled.
Bilbo did too.
For a moment Belladonna was alive again.
Bright-eyed.
Laughing.
Refusing to explain the strange clasp she kept in a box or why she knew three words of Sindarin or how she had once recognised a Ranger by name when respectable hobbits supposedly did not even know Rangers had names.
"She came back," Bilbo continued. "There was a dreadful fuss. Her father shouted. Her mother cried. Half Hobbiton and Tuckborough talked about it for years."
His smile faded.
"Then came the Fell Winter."
The room seemed colder.
"The Rangers came."
Bilbo's voice was quieter.
"They helped patrol. They killed wolves. They brought warnings."
Legolas watched him closely.
"And the Elves?"
Bilbo nodded.
"Food."
Tauriel inhaled softly.
"Not enough to feed the whole Shire. Nothing like that. But there are stories of stores appearing where roads should have been impassable. Medicines. Dried fruits. Grain."
"Who brought them?" Bard asked.
Bilbo looked at him.
"Depends which story you believe."
"And Gandalf?" Balin asked.
Bilbo smiled.
"Of course."
Far behind them, in the deeper chair, a pipe went very still.
Bilbo did not see it.
"Gandalf was there."
Bilbo said it as though it were obvious.
"He organised things. Appeared where help was needed. Spoke with the Thain. Spoke with the Rangers. Probably spoke with the Elves."
Legolas glanced past Bilbo.
And saw the wizard.
Gandalf was listening.
His face had become very grave.
Legolas looked back at Bilbo.
A pattern was forming.
He did not yet know what it meant.
Dáin did.
Or thought he did.
He was a lord of his people.
Now, after battle and blood and the near destruction of a royal line, he carried responsibilities he had not expected to carry quite so soon.
He knew what leadership cost.
Food first to children.
Warm halls first to families.
Warriors placed between danger and those who could not fight it.
A king ate last in famine.
A king stood first in battle.
A king paid.
Always.
His eyes narrowed.
"What happened to your mother after?"
Bilbo looked at him.
"After the winter?"
"Aye."
"Nothing."
Dáin frowned.
Bilbo gave a small shrug.
"That was the point."
"The point of what?"
Bilbo was silent.
Thorin turned his head.
"Bilbo?"
Bilbo looked down.
"The stories."
Something in his voice changed.
Not much.
Enough.
"The Took stories."
Balin leaned forward.
"What stories?"
Bilbo sighed.
"You're going to make me explain all of it, aren't you?"
"Yes," said several dwarves.
Bilbo rolled his eyes.
"Very well."
He placed his cup aside.
"The Thain is a Took."
Dáin nodded.
"You've mentioned him."
"He isn't a king."
Thorin inclined his head.
"I know."
"Nor a lord, precisely. Not as you would understand it. Hobbits are..."
"Stubborn?" Dwalin suggested.
"Independent."
"Stubborn."
"Quiet."
"Stubborn."
Bilbo glared at him.
Dwalin grinned.
"Hobbits do not generally enjoy being ruled. The Thain's position is old. Older than most hobbits bother thinking about. There are duties attached to it, although many are ceremonial now."
"And you're related to him," Kíli said.
Bilbo nodded.
"My mother was one of the Old Took's daughters. The current Thain is my cousin."
There was a pause.
Dáin stared at him.
"Your cousin."
"Yes."
"Your ruler—"
"Not ruler."
"—is your cousin."
"Yes."
"And you neglected to mention this?"
Bilbo blinked.
"Why would I mention it?"
Dáin looked towards Thorin.
Thorin sighed.
"Do not begin."
"I'm merely saying that if I'd known the burglar was close kin to the leader of an entire people—"
"He's not a leader in the way you mean," Bilbo protested.
Legolas almost smiled.
Dáin looked unconvinced.
Bilbo waved a hand.
"The point is the Tooks are looked at differently."
His expression became more serious.
"Always have been."
"Because they go adventuring," Fíli said.
"Partly."
Bilbo stared at the fire.
"The Tooks are too wild."
A faint smile.
"Too loud. Too curious. Too likely to climb a hill merely because someone told them there was nothing worth seeing on the other side."
Kíli looked delighted.
"They sound sensible."
"That is because you're a terrible influence."
"Thank you."
"They marry oddly sometimes. Talk to outsiders. Travel."
Bilbo hesitated.
"They leave."
The word mattered.
Legolas heard it.
"So they're distrusted," Tauriel said.
"Yes."
"But one is your Thain."
"Yes."
"And the Shire accepts that?"
Bilbo gave a strange little smile.
"Yes."
Dáin leaned back.
"Why?"
Bilbo did not answer immediately.
Because that was the contradiction, wasn't it?
The thing no one spoke of directly.
The Tooks were improper.
The Tooks were reckless.
The Tooks were mad.
The Tooks were—
Useful.
Bilbo's mouth went dry.
"They distrust us," he said slowly.
"Us?" Thorin repeated.
Bilbo glanced at him.
"My mother was a Took."
"You are a Took."
"Half."
Thorin merely looked at him.
Bilbo surrendered.
"Fine. Yes."
He rubbed his palms together.
"The Shire distrusts the Tooks."
His voice became very soft.
"But it is also grateful for them."
Dáin stopped moving.
Legolas understood something then.
Not everything.
But enough.
He was a prince.
He had been born beneath the weight of expectation.
His life was not entirely his own.
There were things he could not refuse because his people might pay the price of his refusal.
He looked at Bilbo differently.
"What do the Tooks do?" he asked.
Bilbo looked at him.
For some reason, the question from Legolas was harder.
Perhaps because Legolas's face held no amusement.
Only understanding.
Bilbo turned towards Thorin instead.
"Would you do anything for your people?"
Thorin's brow furrowed.
"Yes."
"Anything?"
"Yes."
"Don't answer quickly."
Thorin went still.
Bilbo looked directly into his eyes.
"Anything?"
Thorin understood that this was no longer hypothetical.
His answer came more slowly.
"Yes."
Bilbo turned.
"Fíli?"
The heir straightened.
"Anything."
"Kíli?"
Kíli's humour was gone.
"Yes."
"Dáin?"
Dáin did not hesitate.
"I have."
Bilbo looked at Legolas.
The Elf was already watching him.
Bilbo nearly did not ask.
"Would you?"
Legolas's answer was quiet.
"For my people? Yes."
"Even if you hated it?"
No one spoke.
"Even if it went against your very nature?"
Bilbo's hands were trembling now.
"Even if everything in you rebelled against it?"
His eyes returned to Thorin.
"Even if you were told that the price of keeping Erebor safe was that once in every generation, perhaps, someone of Durin's line must leave the Mountain."
Thorin stared.
"Leave it willingly."
Bilbo swallowed.
"Go somewhere dwarves hate."
He gave a weak laugh.
"Spend a year living as a guest of Elves."
There was a strangled noise from Glóin.
Dáin looked personally offended.
Kíli's eyes widened in horror.
Bilbo very carefully did not look at Legolas or Tauriel.
"This is not about Elves," he said quickly.
Legolas's mouth twitched despite himself.
"Would you?"
Thorin looked at Bilbo for a long time.
"If that were truly the price of my people's safety..."
Bilbo waited.
"...yes."
"Even if they mocked you for going?"
Thorin's expression hardened.
"Yes."
"Even if they distrusted you when you returned?"
"Bilbo—"
"Even if they called you mad?"
Thorin stopped.
Bilbo's eyes were shining.
"Even if they laughed about Oakenshield madness for the next fifty years while sleeping safely beneath the Mountain because you had gone?"
Thorin's face changed.
"Oh."
Bilbo looked away.
Dáin whispered something in Khuzdul.
Legolas closed his eyes briefly.
Because he understood now.
A prince could recognise another kind of sacrifice.
Even when the person making it did not possess a crown.
Bilbo's voice was very quiet.
"We have no army."
No one moved.
"We have no walls."
His breath trembled.
"When something truly terrible comes, we cannot stop it."
He looked towards the fire.
"So we depend upon others."
The room had become utterly silent.
"The Rangers."
A breath.
"The Elves, sometimes."
Another.
"And Gandalf."
Behind him, unnoticed by Bilbo, Gandalf lowered his pipe.
The wizard's face had gone pale.
"Too often," Bilbo said, "when aid comes, Gandalf is there."
Gandalf did not move.
"There are old stories."
Bilbo's voice had taken on the cadence of memory now.
"Belladonna goes wandering before the Fell Winter. Gandalf is seen in the Shire. The Rangers come. The Elves bring supplies."
He swallowed.
"My great-uncle Hildifons Took went away and never returned."
Bilbo looked down.
"No one knows where."
Kíli's face had gone white.
"Years later there were troubles on the borders. Rangers came south in greater numbers. Gandalf was seen at the Great Smials."
Bilbo rubbed his hands together.
"Isumbras's younger brother—another Took—travelled for nearly two years. When he came back, he never spoke about where he'd been."
Bilbo's voice had become distant.
"The following winter, when sickness came through the Eastfarthing, medicines arrived from outside the Shire before our own stores ran out."
Balin looked towards Gandalf.
Bilbo did not.
Gandalf looked stricken.
Were the stories even connected?
Some might have been.
Others might not.
That was the horror.
It did not matter.
People had connected them.
A coincidence repeated became a pattern.
A pattern told to children became tradition.
Tradition became truth.
Gandalf remembered Belladonna.
Laughing Belladonna.
Fearless Belladonna.
Belladonna had never told him.
Not once.
Had she believed?
Had she looked at him on some bright Shire morning and thought *it is my turn*?
His hand tightened around his pipe.
Bilbo continued.
"There are others."
His voice was barely audible.
"Not always Tooks. But usually someone Tookish enough for everyone to say afterwards that of course it had been them."
"Bilbo," Balin whispered.
Bilbo looked up.
Balin's eyes were wet.
That frightened him.
"What?"
"Why?"
Bilbo frowned.
"Why what?"
"Why would they go?"
Bilbo stared at him.
The answer was so obvious.
So deeply embedded that he had never considered how it sounded outside the Shire.
"Because someone has to."
Thorin made a sound.
Very small.
Bilbo looked at him.
"What?"
Thorin's eyes were horrified.
Bilbo did not understand why.
Not yet.
"The Shire has no army," Bilbo repeated patiently. "We cannot pay Rangers. We cannot command Elves. We cannot demand that a wizard come whenever wolves or Orcs or worse things wander too close."
"You think you pay Gandalf," Bard said.
Bilbo stiffened.
"No."
But it was too quick.
Bard's face tightened.
Bilbo looked away.
"Not pay."
"What, then?" Legolas asked gently.
Bilbo's eyes closed.
"A debt."
Behind him, Gandalf stopped breathing.
Bilbo did not know he was there.
"A bargain?" Dáin asked.
"No."
Bilbo shook his head.
"No one ever called it that."
That was important.
There had never been a contract.
No promise.
No wizard standing before the Thain demanding a Took.
It was subtler than that.
More terrible because of it.
"It is simply..."
Bilbo struggled.
"...understood."
"By whom?"
"Everyone."
"Does the Thain choose someone?" Dáin asked.
Bilbo recoiled.
"No!"
The force of it startled them.
"No. Never."
"Then how—"
"Gandalf chooses."
Silence.
Far behind him, Gandalf shut his eyes.
Bilbo continued.
"When Gandalf takes an interest in someone..."
His voice faltered.
"...when he invites someone on an adventure..."
Bilbo could hear his mother's voice.
"Sometimes, my little lad, safety has a price."
He remembered asking what sort of price.
She had stroked his curls.
"One a Took should be willing to pay."
Thorin went rigid.
Bilbo looked at him.
"We protest."
No one moved.
"We always protest."
A faint, broken smile.
"We say adventures are nasty, disturbing, uncomfortable things that make you late for dinner."
Kíli made a small sound.
Bilbo looked at him.
"We close our doors."
His eyes filled.
"We hide."
"Bilbo..."
"We hope it isn't us."
Thorin's good hand reached for him.
Bilbo let him take it.
"We say whoever goes is mad."
His voice cracked.
"We gossip about them."
A tear escaped.
"We shake our heads and say there was always something queer about that family."
Another tear.
"And underneath..."
Bilbo could barely speak.
"...we are grateful."
No one in the room moved.
"Because someone went."
Thorin's grip tightened.
"Someone paid."
Bilbo looked at him.
"And Gandalf will keep coming."
Behind them came the tiny sound of wood striking stone.
Gandalf's pipe had slipped from his hand.
Bilbo froze.
No.
For one heartbeat he did not move.
Then another.
Very slowly, Bilbo turned his head.
He saw the chair beyond the firelight.
The grey robes.
The fallen pipe.
Gandalf.
Bilbo's face emptied.
Thorin felt his hand turn ice-cold.
"No."
Gandalf's lips parted.
Bilbo recoiled.
"No."
"Bilbo—"
"You weren't—"
His breathing changed.
"You weren't here."
Gandalf stared at him.
Bilbo looked wildly around.
"When did he come in?"
No one answered.
"When?"
"He was here before we began," Balin said softly.
Bilbo went white.
"No."
Thorin moved closer.
"Bilbo."
"No."
The word was a whisper.
Everything changed.
The room.
The conversation.
The stories.
Bilbo had not been explaining history anymore.
He had confessed.
In front of Gandalf.
"Oh, no."
"Bilbo," Gandalf said.
Bilbo flinched violently.
Gandalf stopped.
And that, more than anything, horrified the wizard.
Bilbo Baggins had faced Goblins.
Wargs.
Spiders.
A dragon.
Battle.
He had stood before Thorin at his worst and refused to bend.
And now Gandalf speaking his name frightened him.
"I didn't mean..."
Bilbo's voice shook.
"I shouldn't have said..."
"Bilbo."
Thorin's voice.
Safe.
Bilbo looked at him.
"I've ruined it."
"What?"
"I've ruined it."
Gandalf rose.
Bilbo's terror sharpened.
"No!"
Everyone froze.
"Don't."
Gandalf stopped instantly.
Bilbo was trembling.
"You cannot change anything."
Understanding began to dawn on Thorin.
Not the old belief.
The new fear.
"Bilbo," Gandalf said carefully, "I need to tell you—"
"No."
Bilbo tried to stand.
Thorin caught at him.
"Bilbo, your leg."
"I have to—"
"Sit down."
"I have to make him understand."
"He understands."
"No, he doesn't!"
Bilbo pulled free.
His injured foot touched the floor.
Pain exploded up his leg.
It buckled.
Thorin lunged.
His injured arm betrayed him.
Dwalin moved.
Too late.
Bilbo struck the floor.
"Bilbo!"
Óin surged to his feet.
"You blasted fool!"
Bilbo barely heard him.
Thorin was trying to get down beside him one-handed.
"Don't move."
"Thorin—"
"Don't move!"
But Bilbo was already dragging himself upright.
Not standing.
Kneeling.
On the floor.
Before Gandalf.
Every dwarf in the room went still.
Dáin's face changed.
He was a leader.
He knew submission when he saw it.
So did Legolas.
A prince knew supplication.
This was not Bilbo speaking to a friend.
This was a subject begging someone he believed had power over the survival of his people.
Legolas felt suddenly sick.
"Please."
Gandalf's face crumpled.
"Bilbo, no."
"Please."
"Get up."
"Don't punish them."
Gandalf stared.
Bilbo was crying.
Pleading.
"Don't stop coming."
"Bilbo—"
"Please!"
His voice broke.
Thorin was beside him now.
He had gone down too quickly.
Pain tore across his face as his injured arm shifted.
Bilbo did not notice.
"Don't stop the Rangers."
Gandalf's eyes filled.
"I don't command—"
"Don't tell them not to come."
"I would never—"
"Don't stop the Elves."
Legolas inhaled sharply.
"Bilbo," Tauriel whispered.
Bilbo looked only at Gandalf.
"I shouldn't have told."
His breath hitched.
"I shouldn't have said anything."
"You have done nothing wrong."
"I have."
"No."
"I've condemned them."
Gandalf looked appalled.
"No."
"Please."
Bilbo bowed forward.
Thorin caught him.
"No."
Thorin's voice was rough.
"Bilbo, look at me."
Bilbo couldn't.
"Bilbo."
Thorin put his good hand against Bilbo's cheek.
Bilbo was shaking.
"If he doesn't go..."
Bilbo could barely form the words.
"If Gandalf doesn't go back..."
"I will."
Bilbo stared at him.
Thorin's face was white with pain and fury.
"I will send soldiers."
Bilbo stopped breathing.
"If danger comes to the Shire, Erebor will answer."
"Thorin..."
"I swear it."
Dáin stood.
"As will the Iron Hills."
Bilbo turned his head.
Dáin's expression was grim.
"You have no army?"
Bilbo shook his head.
"Then if you need one, send word."
"Dáin..."
"I mean it."
Bard stepped forward.
"Dale too."
Bilbo stared at them.
Legolas looked at Tauriel.
Then towards Gandalf.
He thought of his father.
Of ancient grievances.
Of guarded borders.
Of the strange, quiet folk west of the mountains who apparently lived behind hedges and trusted strangers to stand between them and darkness.
"I cannot speak for my father without counsel," Legolas said carefully.
Bilbo's face fell.
Legolas continued.
"But I can speak for myself."
Bilbo looked at him.
"If word reached me that the Shire stood in danger and no aid had come, I would."
Tauriel stepped beside him.
"As would I."
Bilbo made a broken sound.
Thorin pulled him closer.
"There," Thorin whispered. "Do you hear them?"
"But—"
"You are not their price."
Bilbo shut his eyes.
Thorin pressed his forehead against Bilbo's curls.
"You were never their price."
Gandalf finally moved.
Slowly.
Carefully.
He knelt.
Not close enough to touch Bilbo.
He would not risk Bilbo flinching again.
"Bilbo."
Bilbo opened his eyes.
Gandalf looked older.
Not the ageless oldness of a wizard.
Simply tired.
Heartbroken.
"I never knew."
Bilbo swallowed.
"I know."
"No."
Gandalf shook his head.
"I don't believe you do."
Bilbo stared.
"I never chose Belladonna."
Bilbo went still.
"I never asked her to leave the Shire."
"But you knew her."
"Yes."
"She went on adventures."
"Yes."
"And you—"
"Because she wanted to."
Bilbo blinked.
Gandalf smiled sadly.
"Your mother was quite capable of finding trouble without my assistance."
Despite everything, a tiny laugh escaped Bilbo.
Gandalf's eyes softened.
"The Fell Winter came because winters come. The Rangers defended the Shire because they had chosen to guard those lands. Aid came because people were suffering."
"The Elves?"
"Helped because they chose to."
Bilbo looked towards Legolas and Tauriel.
Legolas nodded.
"Aid freely given is not a debt."
Bilbo looked down.
"But afterwards..."
"Your people made a pattern."
Gandalf's voice was gentle.
"Perhaps because patterns are easier than uncertainty."
Bilbo frowned.
Gandalf continued.
"It is frightening to accept that terrible things sometimes happen without reason. That rescue may come without payment. That safety can depend upon the kindness of people you cannot control."
Bilbo stared at him.
"So they made a rule."
Balin spoke quietly.
"A rule means the world makes sense."
Gandalf nodded.
Bilbo's eyes filled again.
"I thought..."
"I know."
"When you came to Bag End..."
Gandalf closed his eyes.
Bilbo looked at Thorin.
Then at his Company.
"I hoped I'd escaped it."
Thorin went utterly still.
Bilbo laughed once.
A miserable sound.
"I thought perhaps I was too Baggins."
He wiped his face.
"Too respectable."
Kíli looked as though someone had stabbed him.
"My relation to the Thain isn't especially close by hobbit standards. Cousins proliferate rather alarmingly in the Shire."
No one laughed.
Bilbo looked down.
"I thought Gandalf might choose someone else."
Thorin's fingers tightened.
"Then I saw him."
Bilbo looked at Gandalf.
"That morning."
Gandalf said nothing.
"And I knew."
Bilbo's voice was very small.
"I'd been remembered."
Thorin bowed his head.
Fíli turned away.
Kíli's eyes filled.
Dwalin swore under his breath.
Gandalf looked devastated.
"You ran after us because you thought you had no choice," Thorin whispered.
Bilbo looked at him.
"At first."
Those two words mattered.
Thorin raised his eyes.
"At first," Bilbo repeated.
He reached up and touched Thorin's face.
"I didn't know you then."
Thorin leaned into his palm.
"I didn't know any of you."
His gaze travelled around the room.
"I thought you were loud."
"We are," Bofur said.
"Rude."
"Aye."
"Destructive."
Glóin muttered something.
"You ate everything in my pantry."
Bombur looked unapologetic.
Bilbo smiled through tears.
"And then..."
He looked at Fíli.
Kíli.
Balin.
Dwalin.
Bombur and Bofur and all the others.
"...you became mine."
No one laughed now.
"My friends."
His voice softened.
"My Company."
Then he looked at Thorin.
Everything in his face changed.
"And more."
Thorin's eyes shone.
No mark declared them.
No ancient magic had placed a sign upon their skin.
No prophecy had bound a hobbit to a dwarf-king.
They had done something far more frightening.
They had chosen each other.
Slowly.
Badly, sometimes.
Stubbornly.
Through arguments and mistakes and terror and forgiveness.
They had chosen.
Bilbo's thumb brushed Thorin's cheek.
"So yes."
His voice trembled.
"I came because I thought it was my duty."
He smiled.
"But I stayed because it wasn't."
Thorin closed his eyes.
Bilbo rested their foreheads together.
"I've had fun."
Kíli gave a watery snort.
"Some fun," Bilbo amended.
"Very little fun," Dwalin said.
"More than you admit."
"I was chased by Goblins."
"So was I."
"Spiders."
"Yes."
"A dragon."
Bilbo considered.
"Admittedly, that part was somewhat unpleasant."
Bofur laughed.
The room breathed again.
Bilbo smiled.
"I've had terrible days."
His expression softened.
"Wonderful ones."
He looked at Balin.
"I've learned."
At Fíli and Kíli.
"Taught a little."
At Dwalin.
"Been shouted at."
"You needed it."
"Frequently, apparently."
Then Thorin.
"Loved."
Thorin's face softened completely.
Bilbo smiled.
"And generally had an adventure."
For a little while there was silence.
Then Bard asked gently:
"Is that why you won't return?"
Bilbo's smile faded.
He knew what Bard meant.
The Shire.
Home.
Bag End.
His books.
His garden.
The green door.
Bilbo looked down.
"Partly."
Thorin did not speak.
He never pressured Bilbo about the Shire.
That was one of the reasons Bilbo loved him.
"I still love it."
His voice was soft.
"I expect I always will."
He thought of spring rain.
Fresh earth.
The Water.
Summer evenings.
The Party Tree.
"I miss it."
Thorin's hand found his.
"But I don't think I belong there anymore."
Bilbo swallowed.
"I would go back and everyone would know."
"Know what?" Tauriel asked.
"That I'd gone."
Bilbo smiled sadly.
"That is enough."
His gaze drifted towards the fire.
"They'd stare."
His fingers tightened around Thorin's.
"Whisper."
His mouth twisted.
"Be terribly polite."
Dáin frowned.
"That sounds preferable to hostility."
Bilbo laughed.
"You've never experienced hostile hobbit politeness."
"Should I fear it?"
"Deeply."
That earned a few smiles.
Bilbo's faded.
"Children would be told not to become like me."
Thorin's jaw tightened.
"People would invite me to tea because not inviting me would be rude, then spend the entire afternoon making certain I understood precisely how unfortunate they considered my choices."
He shook his head.
"I couldn't."
His voice broke slightly.
"Not after this."
He looked around.
"Not after knowing what it is to have comrades."
Dwalin looked away.
"To be trusted."
Balin smiled.
"To be useful."
Fíli's eyes shone.
"To be wanted."
Thorin lifted Bilbo's hand and pressed his lips against his knuckles.
Bilbo looked at him.
"And I'm changed."
There it was.
The simplest truth.
"I've killed."
His voice was quiet.
"I've lied. Stolen. Fought. Slept on stone. Gone hungry."
A faint smile.
"Argued with kings."
Dáin snorted.
"Threatened a dragon."
Bard shook his head.
"That was foolish."
"Extremely."
Bilbo looked at Thorin.
"Fallen in love."
Thorin's expression warmed.
"I cannot put all of that away and become the Bilbo Baggins who worries that the spoons aren't polished."
A pause.
"I don't want to."
Thorin kissed his fingers again.
Bilbo looked at Gandalf.
Fear flickered.
Not as violently as before.
But it remained.
"Nothing has to change."
Gandalf's face tightened.
"Bilbo—"
"Please."
"Something must."
Bilbo went pale.
Gandalf lifted a hand.
"Not the protection."
Bilbo stopped.
"Never that."
Gandalf's voice was firm.
"The Rangers will not abandon the Shire because you spoke."
Bilbo breathed.
"Nor will I."
Another breath.
"And I will speak with those who should know the truth."
Bilbo tensed.
"Carefully," Gandalf added.
Bilbo stared at him.
"No storming into Michel Delving?"
A tiny smile appeared beneath Gandalf's beard.
"No."
"No turning the Thain into anything?"
"Bilbo."
"I feel it is a reasonable precaution."
Dáin laughed.
Even Legolas smiled.
Bilbo sagged against Thorin.
Then he frowned.
"It won't change quickly."
"No," Gandalf said.
Bilbo stared into the fire.
"It's old."
"Yes."
"My mother believed it."
Gandalf's expression saddened.
"I fear she may have."
"And her mother probably did."
"Perhaps."
Bilbo thought about generations of Tooks.
Wild Tooks.
Mad Tooks.
Adventurous Tooks.
Children growing up knowing that if Gandalf ever looked at them a certain way, they were supposed to go.
He shivered.
"It could take years."
Gandalf nodded.
"Yes."
"Generations."
"Perhaps."
Bilbo leaned his head against Thorin.
For some reason, that did not frighten him as much as it should have.
He had learned something about long roads.
They were travelled one step at a time.
A belief built over generations might have to be unbuilt the same way.
Quietly.
Patiently.
One child at a time learning that adventure could be chosen.
One Took at a time learning that *no* was permitted.
One Baggins at a time discovering that leaving did not make them responsible for everyone they left behind.
Bilbo breathed out.
"All right."
Gandalf looked at him.
"All right?"
"Yes."
Bilbo's eyes were tired.
"We begin there."
Thorin stroked his curls.
"We?"
Bilbo looked up at him.
"Well, I'm certainly not letting Gandalf explain hobbits to hobbits without supervision."
Gandalf looked offended.
"I have known hobbits for longer than you have been alive."
"And yet somehow you still arrive at lunchtime without warning."
"Bilbo—"
"Uncivilised."
Kíli laughed.
Fíli joined him.
Then Bofur.
The room loosened around them.
And that was when Óin's voice cut through everything.
"Have you all finished?"
Silence.
Bilbo blinked.
Óin stood with his arms folded.
He looked furious.
"Óin?"
"Excellent."
The healer marched forward.
"Now that we've finished uncovering generations of cultural trauma, rewriting the diplomatic obligations of three kingdoms, making oaths of military assistance, and discussing Master Baggins's romantic future..."
Bilbo's eyes widened.
"...perhaps someone would like to explain why my patient is on the blasted floor?"
Bilbo looked down.
He was, indeed, still mostly on the floor.
Thorin was beside him.
So was Gandalf.
Dwalin coughed.
"Well—"
"No."
Óin pointed at him.
Dwalin shut his mouth.
Legolas watched with fascination.
Óin rounded on Thorin.
"And you!"
Thorin actually leaned back.
Bilbo had never seen anyone make Thorin Oakenshield look quite so much like a guilty child.
"You have one functioning arm!"
"My arm functions."
"It does not!"
"It functions somewhat."
"It is strapped to your chest!"
Thorin frowned.
"Temporarily."
Óin made a noise of profound suffering.
"And you decided the sensible thing to do was throw yourself onto the floor after a falling hobbit?"
"I did not throw myself."
"You lunged."
"He fell."
"Because he stood on a broken leg!"
Everyone looked at Bilbo.
Bilbo drew himself up.
"It is healing."
Óin turned.
Bilbo immediately regretted speaking.
"Master Baggins."
"Yes?"
"What part of *do not put weight on that leg* was unclear?"
Bilbo considered.
"Most of it was fairly straightforward."
Kíli covered his mouth.
Fíli looked at the ceiling.
Óin's eyes narrowed.
"And yet?"
"There were mitigating circumstances."
"You were begging a wizard."
"Yes."
"On your knees."
Bilbo winced.
"Technically one knee."
Thorin made the mistake of laughing.
Óin spun back towards him.
"And His Majesty finds this amusing!"
Thorin stopped.
"No."
"You are both impossible."
"We've been told," Bilbo murmured.
"I heard that."
Bilbo looked innocent.
Óin pointed towards Bilbo's chair.
"Up."
Bilbo looked at Thorin.
Thorin looked at Dwalin.
Dwalin sighed.
Between Dwalin and Fíli, Bilbo was lifted without placing weight upon his injured leg and deposited firmly into the chair.
Óin immediately knelt to examine the splint.
Bilbo hissed.
Thorin's expression changed.
"Is it worse?"
"Oh, now you ask."
"Óin."
"No, I do not believe he has broken it again."
Bilbo brightened.
"See?"
Óin glared.
Bilbo stopped brightening.
"But he has almost certainly set the healing back."
Bilbo wilted.
"How much?"
"I'll tell you tomorrow."
"Why tomorrow?"
"Because if I tell you tonight, you'll negotiate."
Bilbo looked offended.
"I do not negotiate medical treatment."
Every dwarf in the Company stared at him.
Bilbo looked around.
"Oh, really."
Thorin was helped upright next.
Óin examined his arm.
Thorin attempted to insist it was fine.
Óin informed him that kings were not anatomically different from everyone else and therefore did not get to decide whether torn flesh and cracked bone were inconvenient enough to acknowledge.
Dáin laughed so hard he nearly spilled his ale.
Óin threatened to examine him next.
Dáin stopped laughing.
Bilbo settled back into his chair.
His leg hurt.
His eyes burned.
His head ached.
He felt scraped hollow.
But Thorin was beside him again.
Alive.
Warm.
Chosen.
Around them were dwarves.
Men.
Elves.
A wizard.
People who, an hour ago, had belonged to different realms with old grudges and older suspicions.
Now Dáin was muttering about routes west.
Bard was asking Balin how messages might travel fastest.
Legolas was quietly questioning Gandalf about the Rangers.
Tauriel had resumed her place near Óin, though she was now helping the healer bully Thorin into remaining still.
Bilbo watched them.
His chest tightened.
The Shire had spent generations believing someone had to pay for help.
Perhaps that belief had begun because small people living in a dangerous world could not imagine that powerful strangers might protect them simply because it was right.
Perhaps gratitude had become obligation.
Obligation had become expectation.
Expectation had become sacrifice.
And sacrifice, repeated long enough, had become culture.
Bilbo could not undo that tonight.
Gandalf could not undo it tomorrow.
Perhaps the Thain could not undo it in Bilbo's lifetime.
But Bilbo looked around the room.
At Dáin, who had offered soldiers.
At Bard, who had offered Dale.
At Legolas and Tauriel, who had offered themselves.
At Gandalf, who looked as though he intended to spend the next hundred years personally correcting the misunderstanding if necessary.
And at Thorin.
Thorin noticed him looking.
"What?"
Bilbo smiled.
"Nothing."
Thorin raised an eyebrow.
Bilbo reached for his hand.
Thorin gave it immediately.
That was the difference.
Once, Bilbo had run from Bag End because he thought a debt had been called due.
He had believed that being chosen meant being obligated.
That adventure was something demanded.
That safety had a price.
He knew better now.
He had fulfilled what he once believed was his duty.
He had crossed mountains.
Walked through darkness.
Faced a dragon.
Helped reclaim a kingdom.
And somewhere along the road, without noticing exactly when it happened, duty had ceased to matter.
He had laughed.
Grieved.
Learned.
Taught.
Fought.
Forgiven.
Been forgiven.
He had found friends.
He had found a Company.
He had found Thorin.
Bilbo squeezed his hand.
Thorin squeezed back.
No prophecy.
No mark.
No debt.
Only choice.
Bilbo looked into the fire and thought of Belladonna.
He wondered what she would say if she could see him now.
Perhaps she would laugh.
Perhaps she would tell him she had always known.
Perhaps she would be furious that nobody had ever told her she could have said no.
Bilbo hoped that wherever she was, she knew now.
An adventure freely chosen was not a payment.
Aid freely given was not a debt.
And love freely offered required no price at all.
"Bilbo."
He looked up.
Óin was glaring at him.
"What?"
"Bed."
Bilbo stared.
"It's barely evening."
"Bed."
"I am not tired."
Thorin looked at him.
Bilbo glared.
"Don't you dare."
Thorin smiled.
Bilbo pointed at him.
"You are supposed to be on my side."
"I am."
"Then tell him."
Thorin turned to Óin.
"How soon?"
"Now."
Thorin nodded.
"Bed."
Bilbo looked betrayed.
Dáin laughed.
Kíli started laughing too.
Within moments half the room had joined them.
Bilbo folded his arms.
"This," he announced, "is precisely why hobbits distrust adventures."
Thorin leaned over and kissed his temple.
Bilbo tried very hard to remain offended.
He failed.
And for the first time in his life, when the room laughed at something Tookish in him, Bilbo laughed with them.
