Actions

Work Header

Can You Tell Me?

Summary:

Taking the old hobbit’s hand in his, he brushed the silver hair from his eyes. “You would sacrifice yourself... for me? After all I have done?”

“Well yes, you great troll,” old Bilbo sighed, his eyes drooping ever so slightly. “You were the best adventure I ever had.”

Notes:

There's a podfic now! https://archiveofourown.org/works/69630611

Edited on 18th October 2025: this work and all its associated pieces have been unlocked. Please treat then kindly. This is a piece of my soul and I am entrusting it to you. Thank you for reading.

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Work Text:

The ice was cracking under his feet. It wouldn’t fall away completely (being far too thick to worry at this juncture) but Thorin scowled as he paced, circling the Pale Orc with light steps.

Azog had sought him out, finally.

And Thorin was the last one left.

Biting back the moisture that threatened to spill from his tired, red eyes, he ignored the urge to let his gaze flicker to Fíli's prone body lying at the base of the dilapidated tower. He refused to dwell on Kíli's fate. His sister-sons. His to protect.

He had failed.

He had failed and now Dís would have to hear of her sons’ deaths from someone else because there was no conceivable outcome where he won this fight. Yes, Azog would fall to his hand, but Thorin knew he would also perish here on the ice. He had nothing left to live for. The mountain was recovered; Smaug lying dead by the hand of Man, and Thorin had thrown away the lives of those dearest to him in a dash for glory and redemption. His sister-sons were gone, and soon he would join them.

The only thought that gave him pause as Azog raised his blade-arm with a cruel sneer was the fate of his hobbit.

No, not his hobbit. He had lost the right to call him that long ago; madness and greed ripping what could have been away before he’d even had a chance.

Despite his rising nausea at the memory of his actions, Thorin allowed himself one last pleasure. The thought of those auburn curls, an imagined bead hanging loosely from a neat braid. A laugh, more familiar than his own at times, echoing from somewhere just out of sight.

He shook his head, dispelling those cunning green eyes from his mind. It would be the last time he saw them, he knew as much for certain.

Stalking forwards, Thorin’s thoughts fled, one by one, until nothing was left. An empty shell with one purpose. Face blank, eyes grim in determination, he walked to the end.

The first swing of Azog’s weapon was easily dodged – as was the second – but the orc was relentless in his onslaught. The flail punched into the ice, shattering it in great chunks that threatened to destabilize him, but Thorin found his footing.

All too briefly; another pass sent him diving to the side, his leg plunging into the water. The cold was knife-like, forcing a gasp from his lips as he scrambled to stand once more. Another narrow miss turned into a roll as Azog brought the weapon around again and again and again until, finally, his sword met orc-flesh.

Azog barely registered the slash. With a mighty swing, he brought his weapon down, landing where Thorin had stood a mere second before, where it stuck. With a snarl Azog launched forward, but the ice dipped perilously, forcing him to remain locked in stalemate.

Thorin didn’t hear the eagles over the rush of blood pumping through his ears, but the orc’s momentary distraction was all he needed to lift the great weapon, throwing it back at its wielder. One moment of stunned panic passed over his face, and Thorin was stepping back; leaping from the ice as it tipped to cast his nemesis into the frigid waters.

The silence brought his awareness rushing back.

The sound of battle, always a constant droning from below, vanished. His blood still ran hot, the thunderous crashing in his ears bordering on pain, but the fire inside him had banked. It was over.

As if in a trance, Thorin sought out Azog’s corpse as it flowed to the falls. His eyes were wide, pupils dilated, but they began to drift closed the further the river carried him.

The Defiler was dead.

Thorin was alive.

He hated it.

Bitter revulsion spilt up, and despite the numb impasse that painted itself over his features, Thorin found himself suddenly and violently furious. How dare this creature take so much from him. How dare it die so easily, without a drop of his own blood spilt in the effort. How dare Azog, vilest of his name, pass in relative peace under the ice, whilst Thorin remained in purgatory.

His sister-sons were dead. His people thought him mad. Bilbo-

Azog’s eyes shot open, and before Thorin could react, a sickening crunch split the air. A second later, the pain hit, as the orc’s wicked blade cleaved through his foot.

As he doubled over in agony, the only thought in Thorin’ mind was better.

Because it would be, he thought as Azog broke through the ice. Because he could die here. Thorin parried the first strike, but the second sent Orcrist wide and in that moment, he knew he was lost.

Until a firm weight barrelled into his side, throwing him out of the way of the oncoming blow.

He didn’t see his rescuer’s face, but the sight of lank, grey hair and overlarge hobbit feet had Thorin snapping back to awareness just as the blade swung down, piercing his rescuer’s belly.

The hobbit, for that was indeed what he was, barely made a sound. A harsh intake of breath, followed by a grunt as wizened hands locked over the blade.

Azog couldn’t pull free. Thorin’s swing meant he never would.

He dropped Orcrist, falling to his knees to drag the headless corpse off the hobbit in mad haste. It was only when the orc’s body had been pried away that Thorin realized exactly what he was looking at.

An elderly face, screwed up in pain, lay beneath. His eyes were firmly clamped shut as ragged breaths sawed in and out with great difficulty. It was clear the wound would be fatal, even with intervention.

“W-why?”

Why what, Thorin had no idea. Why was an elderly hobbit wandering around a battlefield? Why had he saved him? Why had he stolen the killing blow?

But every trace of questioning faded when the hobbit opened his eyes, for there was never a green as clearly recognizable as the beryl stare of Bilbo Baggins.

“I... I thought I might try things differently this time,” this old, strange Bilbo murmured. “I think I died, you see, and-,” he hissed, blood rising between his lips. “I was given a rather interesting gift.”

Thorin was dumbfounded. Bilbo, his Bilbo (for in that context it seemed acceptable to call him such) was the other side of the ruin. He could hear him calling, shouting his name like a desperate prayer above the noise of battle. But this Bilbo was ancient. His face was tired and well worn, wrinkled skin pale beneath the flecks of blood. If he hadn’t known purely by the haughty expression he wore, it would have been inconceivable that the elderly being dying on the ice was Bilbo.

Taking the old hobbit’s hand in his, he brushed the silver hair from his eyes. “You would sacrifice yourself... for me? After all I have done?”

“Well yes, you great troll,” old Bilbo sighed, his eyes drooping ever so slightly. “You were the best adventure I ever had.”

His Bilbo’s cries were louder now, and Thorin knew it was only a matter of time before he arrived at the scene. Some primal instinct told him not to let the two meet, but he couldn’t hold off the search forever, nor could he quicken his passing.

The old hobbit coughed, and Thorin tightened his grip. He could not stave off death for long.

“Ah, I suppose this is the part where I die again,” he muttered nonsensically. “It wasn’t... too much fun the first time, although this was more than worth it.”

“No,” Thorin blurted out, but he knew it was a lost cause.

Old Bilbo scowled. “Now don’t you go giving me attitude. I raised a nephew, alone I might add. Don’t make me do it a second time. And-,” he choked, more blood burbling to the surface. “Tell me what... mithril... means. The truth will serve you well.”

Thorin’s breath caught in his throat, those hot tears he had resisted finally spilling forth at the admission. This Bilbo knew. However he'd done it, this Bilbo had rewritten fate to bring him a future. One he might share.

“Thank you,” Thorin rasped, gently cupping the hobbit’s face in one shaking palm. “I cannot even begin to-”

“Shhh,” Bilbo’s eyes fluttered shut, his lips lifting in a satisfied little smile that almost broke him. “Live your life, Thorin Oakenshield. Let the past remain there and the future ahead. Journeys are the here and now.”

“Thorin!” The worried shout had him turning his head to spot his Bilbo dashing across the ice, but the moment he spun back it became clear the old hobbit was gone. His wrinkled face was frozen in a slight smirk, eyes shut as the gentle wind fluttered through his grey hair.

“Thorin, finally,” his Bilbo panted, waving a hand vaguely at the tower. “Dwalin, he has Fíli and Kíli. They’re-they’re alive. Some elven poultice and, might I say, some rather impressive bandaging that Oín may be loath to remove just turned up , and Kíli is ranting about Tauriel appearing out of nowhere, and... who is that?”

Thorin was frozen. The information was too much, too fast. Fíli and Kíli alive. His sister-sons were alive . And his Bilbo, beautiful, stubborn Bilbo with an unquenchable furnace blazing away in his eyes was here.

After a moment’s pause, the stiff cogs of his brain made a decision. Slipping the fur coat from his shoulders, he draped it over the old hobbit, pausing only to ease Azog’s blade from his gut. He would not have that filth tied to Bilbo, even in death.

Rising to his feet, Thorin took one last look at the forlorn body under his fur, before turning to take in his very alive (and frankly far more concerned than he had been a minute ago) Bilbo. His hair ruffled and bloody, his fingers coated in much the same.

But his eyes were still beryl-green.

“Thorin, who was that?” he repeated, craning his neck to stare at the withered form next to Azog.

“Someone who thought I was important enough to live,” Thorin croaked, before throwing his arms over Bilbo’s shoulders and bringing him in for a tight hug.

* 

No one knew for certain how Fíli had survived. His wounds were complex; the stab to his chest deep and piercing, touching a lung but conveniently missing most else. The fall had destroyed the bones in one of his legs and a hip, but Oín (and Thranduil as, strangely enough, he remained) were confident he would walk again.

Kíli was well, barring a few scrapes from his and Tauriel’s escape from the tower. She had, as he claimed, known exactly where to find him through pure luck.

Thorin knew otherwise.

The tiny grave atop Ravenhill would not answer his questions, but it did provide him some comfort when the shouting below grew too loud.

He had buried Bilbo in his coat, above stone and below the sky. Thorin supposed he would have preferred that to being entombed in Azsâlul'abad proper, so whilst the others bickered away, he’d slipped out with a shovel and a heavily bandaged foot.

And now he sat beneath the stars at the feet of his greatest love, trying not to cry.

“Nori said I’d find you up here,” a gentle voice murmured.

Thorin didn't look up, but neither did he tense when a slight body sat next to him. He did, however, notice the flowers.

“Heather and rosemary. Protection and remembrance.” Bilbo laid the small sprigs atop the little heap of dirt with a reverence that made his heart clench. “Being as we owe more than one life to his actions.”

Thorin's chuckle was light but sad. “I had a feeling you would know.”

“Well, obviously.” Bilbo tilted his head back to stare up at the night sky. “Mysterious elven medicine appearing in the nick of time. Tauriel asking me if there were more hobbits roaming the mountainside. And to top it off, Thranduil looks like he's been threatened into helping us. With what I have no idea, but he won’t so much as glance in my direction. Somebody wanted the Durins alive at all costs, it seems.”

“And that somebody was a hobbit?” Thorin queried, unsure as to how much to reveal.

Bilbo huffed. “I’m not quite that stupid, King Under the Mountain. That was indeed a hobbit, and a very old one at that. So, I'll ask you one more time: who was he?”

Thorin bit his lip hard enough to taste rust. “I answered you earlier. Someone who thought I was important enough to live.”

Bilbo scoffed and went to move, but Thorin stopped him by sliding his hand over the top of his outstretched fingers. The quiet intake of breath was all he needed to continue.

“I knew him once. In another life, I suppose. He saved me, time and time again. Even when it was myself I needed saving from.”

Bilbo stiffened, but he didn't pull away. “Did you love him?” he all but whispered.

Thorin nodded. “I did. Although I did not know how he felt about me. Our time together was... troubled.”

“Understandable,” Bilbo murmured, although his voice was slightly strained. “I suppose this was during your time in exile.”

“Yes, but that was not what made it difficult. I... judged him. Harshly.”

The snort was unexpected, though not unwelcome. “Yes, because you're the perfect judge of character. A shining beacon of appraisal.”

“I have been known to be,” Thorin grumbled, but there was no heat behind the words. “It was not until he saved my life the first time that I realized just how wrong I was.”

“This all sounds rather familiar,” Bilbo joked, but Thorin did not laugh. Instead, he turned to gaze into Bilbo’s eyes.

“It should.”

He saw the moment realization dawned on the hobbit’s face; a jarring, stuttering thing that slowly slackened his features until Bilbo was left gaping.

“That’s-”

“Yes.”

“And I-”

“Yes.”

“And you-”

“I do not lie, Bilbo Baggins, although sometimes I wish the truth was kinder.”

“A-ah.” His face had turned a sickly pale, pupils glassy and blown wide in shock. “I suppose it’s too late to ask if you’ve something stronger than ale on your person?” At Thorin’s negative, he sank back, flopping into the grass with a light ‘whoosh’.

“I am lying on top of my own grave,” he managed.

Thorin did not know what to say about that, so he remained silent.

“I am lying on top of my own grave, and you... you were meant to die today.”

“It is admittedly a lot to take in.”

“Do you really think so?” Bilbo spat. He breathed deep, gathering himself before continuing in a milder tone. “Yavanna give me strength, this is unheard of.”

“You said...” Thorin trailed off, mulling over the words that had been adhered inside his mind since they were first spoken. “The other Bilbo said he had died and been given a gift. That he wanted to try things differently this time.”

“I suppose he did, being as you’re still very much alive,” Bilbo muttered, casting a hand over his eyes. “Did he say much more, or do I really not want to know?”

Thorin weighed up his options. On the one hand, he could say nothing. At best, it would give Bilbo a reprieve from the influx of information he’d been given, if only for a day or so. On the other, he... he had to know.

“He told me to tell you what the mithril meant.”

One green eye peeked out from behind Bilbo’s hand. This was obviously a topic of great interest to the hobbit and Thorin felt his pulse quicken.

“What did it mean?”

“Patience,” Thorin murmured, shooting him a small smile when Bilbo’s obvious irritation shone through. “I would apologize first, for my words and deeds at the gate. I was too rash, and you have suffered deeply as a result. If you wish to never speak to me again, I will abide.”

Bilbo propped himself up on an elbow. “The sickness... it’s gone now?” Thorin nodded and the hobbit exhaled. “Then your apology is accepted. Now don’t go looking at me like that,” he protested, swatting Thorin’s hand lightly when his face turned dark. “It was not you. And besides, if I hadn't already forgiven you, I'd have never left the safety of Dale to warn you of Azog.”

Feeling something within himself settle, Thorin relaxed a little. “Then I am in your debt, Master Baggins. To think you had already put aside your feelings on the matter is... more than I had anticipated. Or hoped for.”

“Yes, yes, that's all well and good, but what about the mithril?”

Thorin couldn't help but grin at that. “Impertinent.”

“Impatient.”

He couldn’t really argue with that. “The mithril was... ill-thought out.” Seeing Bilbo’s confused face, he continued. “In my sickness, I sought ways to keep all that was precious to me safe. In doing so, I may have proposed to you.”

Bilbo nodded. “And?”

There wasn’t really an ‘and’. Thorin’s face collapsed into shock, his mouth opening with an audible click as he tried to gather his words. Bilbo raised a brow at the sight.

“I travelled with thirteen dwarrow for the better part of a year. I understand what a gift of that significance means, Thorin,” Bilbo intoned dryly.

“But you accepted!”

“And why wouldn’t I have?” The hobbit pushed himself to fully sit now, facing Thorin with an almost incredulous expression. “You were sick; impossible to reason with, grumpy and generally a very difficult dwarf to get along with. Who was I to antagonize you further?”

Thorin spluttered. “But you still accepted. You still knowingly accepted.”

“I suppose I did,” Bilbo mused. “It wasn’t a terrible loss to be engaged to you, but oh, I expect you’ll be wanting the mithril back now, won’t you?”

The very notion was abhorrent. “What?”

“Well, now that you’ve come to and realized a hobbit consort is a terrible idea.” Despite the wry tone, Bilbo’s eyes were flat. They were dead; the shine all but extinguished to the tiniest ember. “I don’t blame you, really. I’d eat you out of house and h-”

“Bilbo, I think you have forgotten something important.” Thorin cut him off, unwilling to listen to another word. The flatness didn’t leave the hobbit’s face, but he inclined his head, a polite smile obscuring whatever real emotion hid there.

“By all means remind me, your majesty.”

Gesturing to the grave that Bilbo had seemingly forgotten existed, Thorin smiled ever so lightly. “I loved him, but I did not ever find out how he felt about me. Can you tell me?”

“Oh,” Bilbo whispered.

And then there were hands in his hair, fingers tangled in his braids, a sweet mouth upon his and Thorin could think no longer.

Sometime later, when the sun rose above the horizon and the sky turned orange, he became aware of three things.

The first was that old Bilbo had been right. The mithril had indeed served him well.

The second was that, despite his best efforts otherwise, he was well and truly alive, and that Dís was going to kill him for endangering her sons. Probably before resurrecting him and killing him again for not telling her he was engaged.

And the third was that Thorin Oakenshield, King Under the Mountain, had not failed. In fact, he had triumphed in the face of adversity, and it was all thanks to one (or two, depending on who you ask) very determined hobbit(s).

Notes:

So this was the result of no sleep, no nicotine, no alcohol and a raging chronic illness. I make no apologies.
Brought to you by Lesbianism.

*They went back to the mountain before fucking, I promise it was not on Bilbo's grave*

Series this work belongs to: