Actions

Work Header

How Would You Have Me?

Summary:

A continuation of Thorin and Bilbo's conversation after Thorin gives Bilbo the mithril shirt. Bilbo takes the opportunity to try to talk sense into Thorin, seeing as how he is fairly confident his feelings could be returned. It almost works, until it doesn't.

Notes:

I was rewatching The Battle of Five Armies for the first time in years and this just sort of happened. Did I break out of an almost year long ao3 writing block / hiatus out of no where? Yes. Is bagginshield what did it? Apparently?? I did not see it coming, I really didn't.

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Work Text:

Bilbo takes in the silver steel he wears. The mithril weighs next to nothing, it allows him to move freely. He wonders briefly if Thorin had really found this in the hall of treasures, or if he had fashioned it himself. For how well it fits, Bilbo fears it is the latter. He could put his coat back on and forget he was wearing it, if only the gesture hadn’t already carved itself so deeply into his heart. 

If only. 

“I look ridiculous,” Bilbo insists, “I’m not a warrior, I’m a hobbit.” 

Thorin looks at him, almost fondly, almost Thorin. Almost. 

“It is a gift,” Thorin replies, “a token of our friendship.” 

Bilbo smiles weakly. 

“True friends are hard to come by.” Thorin speaks low, so only Bilbo can hear. The compliment hurts, compliment though it may be. 

I am no true friend. Bilbo thinks, but he is sure giving Thorin the gem in his coat would end so badly, especially now. I betrayed this gift before it was even given. His regret drowns a moment later in ice cold fear as Thorin takes his shoulder and roughly pushes him out of sight of the rest of their party. 

“I’ve been blind,” Thorin says quietly, “I am betrayed.” 

Bilbo can barely bring himself to meet Thorin’s manic gaze. 

“Thorin, what?” Bilbo starts. “Betrayed–?” 

“The Arkenstone,” Thorin whispers roughly. “One of them has taken it.” 

Bilbo breathes a momentary sigh of relief, and hopes Thorin doesn’t notice he is practically shaking. He’s parlayed with a dragon, yet it is Thorin Oakenshield who frightens him now? He stretches his hands before clenching them into fists at his side. 

“Thorin,” Bilbo speaks, louder than Thorin but still calm, “the quest is fulfilled. You’ve won the mountain, you’ve brought your family home. We’re all here, safe. Am I–” Bilbo pauses. “Are they not enough? Is that not enough?” 

“Te be betrayed, by my own kin–”

“No,” Bilbo shakes his head. “You’ve made a promise, you gave your word. You would help the people of Laketown. It is all of our responsibility, what happened to them. Is a bit of gold truly worth more than your honor? As king? And my honor? I gave my word, and I vouched for yours.” 

“For that I am grateful,” Thorin says, and once again just a hint of fondness permeated his words, his gaze. It’s gone as quickly as it came. “But the treasure in this mountain does not belong to the people of Laketown.” 

“You’re right,” Bilbo nods, “it doesn’t. It belongs to you, to your kin. And it is yours to give.”

Bilbo takes a step back and Thorin takes one forward, menacing, but he keeps talking. 

“You cannot rebuild a kingdom by hoarding gold beneath it. You need strong communities around you, you need trade. Erebor will be what it once was if you would just–” 

Bilbo freezes as his heel scrapes the edge of the stone behind him. He glances back quickly to find his retreat has ended on a part of the wall that must have been destroyed when Smaug had gone crashing through the front gate. Yet Thorin doesn’t stop, his expression cold. 

Bilbo shuts his eyes tightly. “Thorin, please.” 

The air around them freezes. When Bilbo cracks one eye open, Thorin is looming over him. With nothing but open air behind him, and quickly fading hope that Thorin will see any sort of reason about that fact, Bilbo reaches out to grasp onto the edge of Thorin’s armor. His knuckles pale from how tightly he holds on to it, not wanting to anger the king under the mountain any further, but also not wanting to fall from the battlements to his death. 

Thorin blinks, a line appearing between his brows, his head tilts as if in confusion.

“Are you frightened of me?” He asks. 

Bilbo takes a deep, shaky breath. “No,” he says, and hears his voice waver. 

~

It is a fleeting spark of clarity in the haze of his mind. A result of the fresh air on a clear night and the moonlight shimmering through the mithril shirt Bilbo wears. 

Thorin blinks, he feels his armor shift where Bilbo is clinging to it, and his hand closes around Bilbo’s wrist, lifting gently until Bilbo lets go. He raises Bilbo’s hand until it rests against his face. Bilbo’s wide eyed gaze is frozen on his own, but his hand opens further, cupping Thorin’s cheek gently. 

“Thorin?”

It’s the bewitching, golden brown of Bilbo’s hair, the shimmer of the mithril, the firelight behind them versus the moonlight above them reflecting in Bilbo’s eyes, confusing the color, bringing out the blues and flecks of green simultaneously. It’s the slight glow around them both, the warmth of home. 

For one calm, satisfying moment, Thorin has his treasure in his arms. He leans forward until their foreheads rest against one another. Bilbo’s other hand rises to tangle in Thorin’s hair. 

“Thorin,” Bilbo breathes out his name. 

“Hm?” 

“You’re not alone.”

“No?”

“No,” Bilbo says.

~

“You’re not alone.”

“No?”

“No,” Bilbo says, “look at me.”

Thorin does, and this time it is more than just a moment that the endeared look lingers. He is looking at Bilbo like he did on the cliffs after the eagles had rescued them. Looking at him the way he did when he had lunged to the bars of his cell in the Woodland Realm when Bilbo unlocked it, like he’d done when Bilbo talked of planting a tree in his garden back in the Shire. Thorin gazed at him like he was the treasure, and Bilbo glowed with it. 

It gave too much hope, in the end. Too much confidence that Thorin was returning to himself. Too much trust that Bilbo could reason with him. 

“You’ve done what you’ve set out to do,” Bilbo starts, “and you will never be alone, you have family here who are loyal to you, I swear. And you have, well, me. If you will have me, that is. But you must listen. There is more than enough gold here to rebuild Erebor and Dale and Laketown. Twice over, if not more. You are trusted and respected and loved, as the king. You do not need the Arkenstone for that.”

Thorin steps away so abruptly Bilbo almost loses his balance, but in gathering him in his arms, Thorin has pulled him far enough away from the edge that he is not in danger of falling. It hurts more that he’s miscalculated, again. He’s pushed Thorin further away than ever. He’d thought Thorin was coming back to himself, he’d hoped–

“I am alone after all.” 

“Alone?” Bilbo feels a restless panic build in his stomach, “Thorin, you’re– you’re not. I promise.” 

“I am,” Thorin says, all manner of softness gone. And that look, that look has taken over his handsome face again. “This gold… is ours, and ours alone.” He breathes heavily, as though this, this dragon sickness, has taken hold of him again. Bilbo is so haunted by his next words he can almost hear the one who’d said them first. “I will not part… with a single coin,” Thorin hisses. “Not one piece of it.” 

The members of their party pass between them, Thorin having backed so far away he is now on the other side of the narrow hall. Bilbo can only stare back at him, searching for a hint of the dwarf he’d met in Bag End. 

The last of the dwarves pass, and they are alone. They hold each other’s gaze.

Thorin steps forward slowly as he speaks.

“I would have you,” he says, a hint of himself in his voice, “crowned, by my side, the heirloom of my people shining above us.”

Something like frustration sparks, and the knowledge that there had been mutual affection they'd never mentioned before they arrived here gives Bilbo more courage than he’d had a moment ago. 

“You dwarves are so damn… stubborn,” Bilbo snaps, now that he is confident they are out of earshot of everyone. Thorin stands in front of him again, having crossed the hall. He narrows his eyes at Bilbo’s outburst. 

“You would have me only with a mountain of gold beneath us and a cursed stone above our heads?” 

Thorin doesn’t answer.

“I would have you back at my front door, with nothing but the loyalty of your kin and a map you cannot read,” Bilbo insists. “I would have you with everything you had when we first met.”

“I had– nothing ,” Thorin growls. 

“You had honor. You had your family, and you still do, and now you have your home. Thorin, you are not yourself, you must see that.” 

“Master Baggins, do not–”

“But you wouldn’t, would you?” 

Thorin glowers at him. “I wouldn’t what?” 

“You wouldn’t have me, without everything else. You would have me and that stone, or nothing? You couldn’t just have me?”

“To ask you to join me on a throne without the birthright of my people? I wouldn’t do you such a dishonor.”

“Oh, it's just for me? Well, in that case,” Bilbo shrugs. “I don’t want it. There, problem solved?” 

Thorin’s silence says everything Bilbo already knew, and it hurts. It hurts so much, even though he knows Thorin is truly not himself. He knows that, he tries to convince himself. The question he’d stopped himself from asking earlier pushes its way to the forefront of his mind again: am I not enough?  

“Well, I– I understand,” Bilbo says, he looks away from Thorin, stares at the ground as he mumbles to himself, “I’m glad I didn’t ask.” 

Thorin lets him pass, and Bilbo pushes down the disappointment that he does not try to stop him. What is a simple hobbit, a hired burglar, compared to such a beautiful jewel? To the king under the mountain? Nothing, apparently. 

He picks his coat up off the floor, shrugging it on and disappearing down the stairs. He makes it to the bottom of the stairs and stops, kicking a few coins and watching them tumble over each other. He crosses his arms, cursing the stubbornness of his idiot dwarf, and wondering when he’d started thinking of Thorin as his. Something shifts under his coat when he moves, and he looks down to see the mithril shirt Thorin had gifted him, comfortable and light. 

He’d forgotten he was wearing it. 

Notes:

i really didn't know how to end this, it just sort of happened in the span of a couple hours, but i hope it was okay!

I don't know how obvious it was that Thorin was beginning to compare the Arkenstone to Bilbo in his mind, seeing the way Bilbo looked in the moonlight.