Chapter 1: So Many Stories of Where I've Been
Chapter Text
He should have suspected something when he arrived to find the dining hall, boisterous more than ever these days with the upcoming Yule celebrations, completely deserted save for his family, gathered in front of their typical spots on the royal dais. He should have heeded their carefully neutral expressions as a chair was pulled out for him and as dinner was served without ceremony. He should have realized that his father said barely a word throughout the meal, only speaking after calling the group to order with a solemnly raised hand, followed by a pronouncement that seemed to be fresh news only to Thorin’s ears.
“I don’t understand…” he began, then shifted in this seat. He looked around the table, at the faces of his dearest family and friends who now looked upon him with something akin to concern. It made him uncomfortable. “You’re sending me away?”
“Yes,” Frerin answered immediately with a smirk, earning a clicked tongue from their mother and a weary sigh from Thrain.
“We’re not trying to get rid of you, if that’s what you’re implying,” Dis said over Frerin’s protests. “Think of it as an extended holiday.”
Thorin took a careful swig of ale, considering what his father had said just before. “And you all believe that a holiday, away from the mountain, is what will best prepare me to assume the throne next year? Not being present and at Father’s side to ease the transition?”
“You’re the last person that needs any formal preparation, my son.” His mother laid a gentle hand on his arm. “As your father mentioned, you’ve been dedicated to this mountain, day in and day out.”
“A little too dedicated, to be sure,” Dis put in, waving away Fris’ tutting about being interrupted. “All you do is official business. You’re the first dwarf through the entrance hall every morning and the last of us to enter their chambers each night. Dwalin’s seen the guards’ reports”—she nodded to their cousin, seated with his arms crossed next to a weary-looking Balin—“so I suggest you don’t deny it. I haven’t seen you enjoy a minute of leisure, not since, well…”
Thorin felt the entire family grimace. The ill and fatal turn that Thror took following his recovery from that damned goldsickness would always hang heavy on their hearts. He blinked away the memory of his grandfather’s last descent from the throne. “The kingdom needs me. If I am to become King in a year’s time, every minute I spend in this mountain must be a minute learning how to best serve our people.”
“You are to become King of Erebor, not Erebor itself,” Thrain said, his words boldly cutting across the table. He leaned in. “You cannot wear the crown if you have lost sight of who you are without it.”
His words were met with silence from the family. Thorin felt frozen, his heartbeat thundering in his chest at the suggestion that he lacked any sense of self-awareness.
Balin let out a loud sigh. “Your Majesty, if I may?” At Thror’s nod, Balin met Thorin’s gaze steadily. “This is not the first time a succession like this has occurred. There are two instances of the King’s willing abdication during his lifetime.” He tapped a thin stack of paper on the table. “In both successions, there are records that the Crown Prince formally receives the abdication before the kingdom on Durin’s Day, and he is crowned after about a month of transitional preparation.”
Thorin’s frowned, anticipating what Balin would say next.
“A month, Thorin. Not a bloody year.” Their seneschal sat back in his chair. “Ever since your father announced to the council that he plans to abdicate, we have had no concern of your readiness to be King. We could announce His Majesty’s abdication tomorrow and you could be crowned forthwith, as it were.” Balin gave a small smile. “But, dear cousin, we would be doing you a disservice.”
“We’d be doing Father a disservice by delaying his rest!” Thorin cried.
“Peace, son,” Thrain said sternly. “This idea has nothing but my full support. As I said, Erebor needs a king who understands not just the mountain’s place in the world, but his own.” The King smirked. “If you’re protesting out of concern for your dear father, know that I’d be offended by your lack of trust.”
Thorin lowered his gaze, sensing he was outnumbered. “I do trust you, Father,” he said, looking back up at his family, “and I trust that if this is the will of the family, it must be for the best.” He squared his shoulders. “I’ll do it, then.”
—
Later, after everyone had retired to their own chambers, Thorin fiddled with a pipe in Dis’s study, glaring at his siblings. “I trust Father, but it appears anti-thetical to send me away if he is planning to abdicate in order to rest from the duties of the throne.”
“You don’t think I said the same thing?” Frerin muttered around his own pipe.
“Hush, both of you,” Dis sniped. “This was Father’s idea. Remember how he used to tell us of his travels as a youngster? He thinks you’ve been deprived of a chance to see the world. Besides,” she gestured between herself and Frerin with a grin, “he’ll still have us to help him.”
“Terrorize him, more like,” Thorin said, feeling a grin grace his own face. “I’m guessing it was your suggestion to exclude Fili and Kili from dinner so as not to detract from your arguments?”
“On the contrary,” Dis said, rolling her eyes. “They loved it. They wanted to go with you.”
“Oh?”
“Relax, you won’t be playing babysitter.”
Frerin blew out a smoke ring. “Even I considered tagging along, but we’ve agreed that maintaining the secrecy of your identity would be more difficult with more Durins in your party.”
“Let alone those Durins,” Dis snorted. “We can’t have foreign lands thinking you’ve been sent out as a spy.”
“Or an exile.”
Thorin sighed, finally lighting his pipe. Absently, he did wonder at the last time he had a sit-down like this with his siblings.
He couldn’t recall it.
“I’ll miss you both,” he said, then ducked as a cushion came flying at his head.
“Don’t get sappy, idiot.” Dis waved her pipe dismissively. “Just do us a favour and don’t go finding someone you like better than us.”
“Or falling in love,” Frerin said, laughing when the cushion careened his way. “Oi! I’m only saying, you’re going to have a right old time explaining yourself. And if you bring them home without telling the truth, we’d all be horrible actors.”
Thorin rolled his eyes. “The last thing on my mind is romance.” He blew out some smoke, revelling in that near-forgotten feeling of warmth his chest. “So, where do you two suggest I go first?”
—
Thorin grunted as another cloaked man shouldered him while walking past, causing him to narrowly miss stepping into a deep puddle at the side of the road. He turned to bark at the man for minding his space, but the figure was gone. Not for the first time since arriving at this town, he found himself yearning for some minimum level of politeness west of the Misty Mountains. He refused to regret leaving Rivendell with such haste.
With a scowl, he re-adjusted his pack and continued further into town. The man at the gate had named several public houses where he could stay, and Thorin knew he needed a night of rest to determine his next course of action. He had learned the hard way that arriving in a region without any substantial plan was a surefire way to accidentally get caught up in a minor battle, rooming next to the village idiot, or—worse of all, so far—forging arrowheads for elves.
He let out a heavy sigh of relief when a sign bearing one of the pub names appeared, swinging in the damp spring wind as he turned a corner. The main floor of The Prancing Pony was comfortably full, and Thorin felt his heart skip a beat when he noticed a table of dwarves in the corner. He’d seen the odd dwarf or two along the road since leaving Erebor, but none in such large company.
The chances that one of them knew who he was were too high.
Before he could turn around to find another pub, one of them made sudden eye contact. “Oi! Lookit what we have here!” the dwarf called out loudly.
Thorin stared for a second. He felt several of the pubgoers turning their eyes his way. He steeled himself and, ignoring the call, stepped towards the barkeep. “Do you have a free room for the night?” he asked.
“‘Fraid not,” the man answered with a sorry smile. “Though that group over there grabbed a few with multiple beds.” He filled up a mug with a frothy ale, pushing it to Thorin. “Won’t hurt to make nice.”
And so Thorin found himself at the head of a table clearly built for menfolk, his legs swinging pathetically, with several pairs of dwarven eyes staring at him, eager for an answer to their last question. He cleared his throat. “Yes, I left Erebor in the winter once the heaviest of the snow cleared and it was safe to journey outward.”
Cries of awe erupted from the dwarves. “Erebor! You don’t say!” The dwarf who first called him out grabbed the top his oddly-shaped hat in disbelief. “My brother migrated there with his family last season!”
Thorin would have almost certainly met them, then, as they greeted all new arrivals to the mountain at each day’s dinner. “Have you heard from them at all?”
Another dwarf replied in harsh Khuzdul. Thorin tried not to stare at the axe head protruding sharply from his brow. “Almost every month. He’s in the kitchens, and he’s been trying to work his way up and prepare a meal for the King one day!”
“I’m sure he is a fine cook. I can’t recall a single bad meal from Erebor’s kitchens when the public is invited to a royal feast.”
The dwarf with the strange hat widened his eyes. “You’ve supped on Bombur’s cooking!”
This earned some groans from the other dwarves, who soon turned to other conversation. Thorin chuckled, taking a swig of his drink. “I take it you speak of him frequently?”
“We just miss him, is all. But we have to close business affairs in the Blue Mountains before we can join him.”
“The Blue Mountains?” Thorin repeated. “Ered Luin?”
“Correct-o,” Weird Hat replied. “We head out on the morrow, but we’ll be stopping in The Shire for a couple weeks to see if we can’t make some coin beforehand. You’re welcome to join if you’re looking for work, too. I see those forge burns on your hands, I can bet you’re more than a half-decent smithy.”
A question must have been apparent on Thorin’s face, as Weird Hat laughed. “Don’t get your tailfeathers in a twist, Ereborian. The hobbits are harmless.” He leaned in conspiratorially. “And they brew a wicked ale.”
—
The candlelight at Thorin’s side table flickered as a breeze blew into the room through the cracked window. Around him, the dwarves slept on, snoring loudly.
Thorin dipped his quill into a fresh pot, taking care not to spill any ink on the bedsheets, propped up as he was by thin pillows. Beside him, Dis’s last letter lay unfurled, and he glanced at it with fondness before beginning his response:
Dis,
Thank you for continuing to reassure me that Erebor does not look to be on the brink of collapse in my absence. I am glad to hear that Father’s visit to Dale went well and that King Bard is in support of our succession plan. I trust that he will keep the plan in confidence until the formal abdication.
I care not to write more of Rivendell than what I had sent previously. I should add, however, that Lord Elrond assured me that the elves would not dare to spread word of my identity in the region. I trust that he will remain true to his word. I hope this does not put a damper on Frerin’s plan to start a war on Elvendom following my story of the incident with his twin sons and the cheese knife.
I have arrived in Bree, though I will departing tomorrow. I met a group of travelling dwarves who are heading for Ered Luin, and I will join their small caravan. Oddly, a pair of cousins have kinfolk in the mountain—should my travels with them go well, see to it that a “Bombur” finds an opportunity among the royal kitchenstaff.
I await further news. Give the boys my love.
Thorin
P.S. Can you ask Balin to find any information Erebor may have on hobbits?
—
The sound of distant barking tickled the edges of Thorin’s senses, pulling him from a second night of easy slumber. The smell of burning coals wafted gently above him, signalling that someone was already awake and heating the forge. He blinked himself awake and stretched groggily on his sleeping mat, rolling to pull aside his makeshift curtain that separated him from the other dwarves dozing in the smithy’s back room. He shook his head at the way Bifur was batting at the air madly in sleep and took it as his cue to duck around for the chamber pot.
The dwarves had arrived in The Shire, this idyllic land of rolling farms and startlingly green hills populated by a race of creatures who Thorin was shocked to find smaller than even Mahal’s children, just two days ago. They set up the smithy in the late morning, and by the time the sun had signalled high noon, a messy line of the jovial hobbits had formed, each eagerly awaiting their turn to request something from the new visitors.
Apparently, dwarven crafts were something of a marvel among hobbits.
When he emerged, a low murmur of voices could be heard coming from the smithy entrance. Thorin marvelled at these hobbits’ eagerness, to come so early and request what was likely a new gardening or kitchen tool—from yesterday’s customers, he had learned the names and designs of enough such objects to last a lifetime.
He doubted he’d be forging a proper weapon in the couple weeks the dwarves planned to stay in The Shire.
He slipped outside of the back room and made his way to the front entrance, where Bofur was perched on top of a table and whittling at a piece of wood. “I’m afraid I still don’t quite get you, Master Hobbit,” Bofur was saying.
“I don’t see what’s so difficult to understand,” the hobbit in front of him said. Thorin recognised the tone in his voice—it was the same one of exasperated patience that Balin used to use on him and his siblings when they were younger. “It’s a simple baking tool, surely you’ve something similar in your halls and mountains for cutting cookies and dough just so… Oh! Hello there! Perhaps you’d be able to help me?”
It took Thorin an embarrassingly long time to realise that the hobbit was addressing him. Bofur snorted into the dead space, but Thorin was clearly still half asleep.
This hobbit looked like his kinfolk, yes, but he was also so much different. The curls on his head caught the morning sunlight just so, his face was handsomely lined, and his eyes twinkled with a sincerity that was the probably the driving force behind his arriving at the smith so early.
His eyes were also fixing Thorin with a look that suggested he thought Thorin particularly dull.
“Er,” Thorin began, drawing another snort from Bofur. The dwarf shook his head and hopped off the table.
“This one here worked in the kingdoms of Men before,” Bofur said, waggling his eyebrows at the hobbit before leaving to head for a workstation. “Probably knows what you’re on about.”
The hobbit raised an eyebrow, the look assessing Thorin’s stupidity dissipating slightly. “Oh?”
Thorin cleared his throat, trying to stay professional and ignore how the hobbit’s eyes were a striking hazel that reflected the light of the lit forge behind them. “What is it that you need?”
The hobbit made an odd gesture with his hands, like he was trying to mime out a small ball. “A cookie cutter. Or, rather, a dough cutter. In the shape of a star! I need it to make my mother’s famous recipe of mincemeat pies which, yes, I recognise we are months past Yule, but I promised my dear Frodo that we would make the pies and he does so greatly need some cheering up these days.”
Thorin blinked, digesting the barrage of words. It didn’t help that spots of pink had risen in the hobbit’s cheeks as he got more excited. “A dough cutter in the shape of a star?”
“Yes!” The hobbit clapped his hands. “I know my old ones are packed deep away in storage somewhere, and when Hamfast told me that your smithy had opened again, I did figure it would be much quicker to have new ones made than to go delving into my abyss of a mess. And it would be a lovely gift for young Frodo!”
Ah. Frodo was probably a son, meaning this hobbit probably had a wife. Thorin straightened, letting his breath steady out again. “We could certainly have these… cookie cutters made in short order. Let me grab some parchment so we can work out a sketch.”
“Oh, marvellous, just marvellous!” the hobbit said, breaking into a grin that had Thorin sighing internally at the lost potential. He stuck out his hand for the warmest handshake Thorin had felt in days. “And your name, Master Dwarf?”
“Thorin, at your service.”
The hobbit held his hand for a beat before drawing back. He’d likely met a dwarf or so before, but Thorin let out a loose breath when it didn’t seem like he would inquire further about a family name. “Thorin,” the hobbit repeated, the grin still on his face. “Bilbo Baggins. A pleasure.”
—
Thorin frowned at the gate in front of him and cursed his refusal of written directions from Bofur. Some mad instinct had him offering to hand-deliver the hobbit—Bilbo’s—cookie cutters the day after they had been ordered, and Bofur had only snorted when Thorin asked for directions to Bilbo’s house—or smial, as he had been corrected.
Now, Thorin could only guess at whether the fence was oak or ash, placed at the bottom of the hill as this was or next to a cornfield as others were. He fiddled with the package in his hands, the cookie cutters inside clinking.
“Hullo! Are you here for the pies?”
Thorin turned as a small voice piped up just near his knee. A hobbit child stared at him with big blue eyes, his face smeared with some sort of berry juice.
“Now, now, Frodo, remember your manners with guests.”
Well. It seemed to Thorin that his memory was quite fine after all.
“Thorin, it is lovely to see you again!” Bilbo chirped, coming up the opposite end of the path with a basket in hand. He grabbed Thorin’s hand in another warm handshake. “And my dear nephew here did get it right, despite the lack of any niceties. I’m assuming you’ve got my cookie cutters in that bag there.” Bilbo’s eyes twinkled again. “Are you here for the pies?”
Thorin felt a grin begin to split his face. Nephew. He tucked his follow-up questions away and held out the package for Bilbo. “I’m here to deliver your order, as agreed,” he said, waving away the small pouch that Bilbo began to proffer. “No need for that yet. Just drop by the smithy after you’ve used them and found them to your liking.”
Bilbo raised an eyebrow. He tapped his nephew on the shoulder. “Frodo, why don’t you head on inside and start tidying the kitchen.” Bilbo straightened, a determined look on his face. “I do intend on paying you today, Thorin, so if you find yourself free tonight you are more than welcome to see your crafts in action.”
“Tonight?” Thorin repeated, drawing a little giggle from Frodo before the child scurried through the gate.
“Tonight,” Bilbo said, following his nephew into his property. “Though, if you do choose to come back, just remember to follow the path left around the oak tree.”
Thorin blushed. “You… saw me circle back earlier?”
“Twice, actually.” Bilbo grinned. “Tonight, then?”
Thorin tried to tell himself it was for the good of ascertaining the quality of his craftsmanship that he answered with an deep nod, “Tonight.”
—
The odd circular door that appeared commonplace for hobbit smials was still tall enough that Thorin didn’t need to duck as he entered, letting Bilbo grab his cloak with an enthusiastic smile. “Frodo was a bit concerned that you wouldn’t show,” he whispered. “He’s been talking about how he wants to teach you the recipe all day!”
Thorin could hear a child’s absent humming drifting through the rooms, mingling with the scent of cinnamon and sugared apples. A warmth settled over him that had his heart beating a little faster, reminding him that this was the first time he had stepped into a proper home since leaving Erebor.
The fact that it was the home of a rather handsome hobbit whom he had only met the day prior was not lost on him.
“Come! The kitchen’s just this way,” Bilbo said. Thorin followed him through a sitting room with a cozy fireplace and a dining area with a long wooden table, feeling that sense of ease continue to wash over him with every detail of a lived-in space, from the opened books scattered across tables to the blankets draped over each cushioned chair.
The ease subsided slightly, however, as they entered the kitchen and Thorin beheld what could only be described as a mountain of dough on the table in front of little Frodo, whose eyes were wide with excitement. “Is that… all for the pies?” he asked, only partly in jest.
Bilbo chuckled. “That’s the plan! We figured it’s only fitting so that we can test out our new cookie cutters. Thoroughly.”
Frodo grinned at him, eyes wide with excitement. “We have to make lots of pies, Mister Thorin!”
With a quick glance at Bilbo, Thorin leaned forward conspiratorially. “Don’t tell me it’s so that you can eat them all?”
“No!” Frodo laughed. “Uncle said we’d only be able to make Yule pies if we give them out to Sam and Mister Hamfast and all the other neighbours, too, so he wouldn’t have to roll me out of bed every morning!”
Thorin smiled, nodding sagely in a manner that had him flashing back to when he used to listen to Fili and Kili’s innocent attempts at rationalizing their mess of the day as young dwarflings. “Your uncle speaks a lot of sense.”
“And he’s already found a cheerleader, it seems!” Bilbo squeezed Thorin’s arm. “We ought to keep you around, Thorin!”
“I suppose you do,” Thorin said, returning Bilbo’s smile easily. The hobbit hadn’t let go of his arm yet.
“Well, come on then!” Frodo piped up, causing Thorin to blink back out of the middle distance. He’d wager Bilbo was doing the same. “You roll out the rest of the dough, Uncle Bilbo will do the filling, and I’ll cut out stars for the tops!”
Thorin watched as Frodo gleefully reached behind the dough mountain to pull out one of the freshly-made cookie cutters, sinking it into a rolled sheet of dough. Frodo gasped in delight, holding out the new star in his hands. “It’s perfect!”
A rolling pin was handed to him, and Thorin looked up to find Bilbo meeting his gaze once again. “A marvel of dwarven craftmanship,” Bilbo said lowly, and Thorin chuckled despite himself. “While Frodo’s got that covered, let me show you how to roll out the dough properly.”
—
It became a habit after that night. Thorin would rise in the morning, either the first or second dwarf to wake in the smithy, before filling up his diary for the day with the earliest hobbits to queue for their orders. He would complete his tasks, setting out the newly forged items out for the next day’s pickup, then head out of the smithy while the sun was beginning her last descent.
Mahal bless the fact that the other dwarves did not comment about it.
He would arrive at Bilbo’s smial at dusk, just in time for a dinner that Thorin always insisted on helping to prepare, but from which Bilbo always shooed him away with a cheeky grin.
After a week, Frodo started asking Thorin to read a story, which is how Thorin found himself sitting in a cozy armchair day after day, a little hobbit perched in his lap with a book, directly across Bilbo’s soft gaze and cheeks, his face tinged a lovely pink with warmth from the hearth.
And when Frodo went to sleep, Bilbo and Thorin would sit outside in the cool spring air, sharing a smoke. Bilbo would try to offer the bag of coins in exchange for the cookie cutters before Thorin would politely refuse, bidding the hobbit a farewell and heading back to his camp.
On the eve of Thorin’s departure, Frodo dozed off before Thorin could say a proper goodbye. It was probably better that way.
“He’ll miss you, you know,” Bilbo said that night, as they shared one last smoke together. Thorin tried to ignore the pull in his heart when he thought about it.
“And I, him,” he said neutrally, staring out into the night.
“It was a great thing you did, with the cookie cutters,” Bilbo said after a moment of silence. “You know that day, when I ran to your smithy for the order? The night before was the anniversary of his parents’ death, and the one thing I knew would cheer him up was some jolly good baking. Yule or no Yule, my mother’s pie recipe can bring joy to the hearts of any.” Bilbo huffed good-naturedly. “I do wish you’d accept my payment before you leave.”
“It is a gift, as I’ve said before,” Thorin said. He considered Bilbo’s words, wondering if it was worth it to continue sharing anything at this eleventh hour. “I see how much you care for Frodo, as if he were your own. I… I have my own charges, the sons of my sister. Their father died when they were young, and I’ve raised them as my own two boys.”
A gentle hand landed on his forearm. Thorin turned and—when had Bilbo gotten so close?
“You haven’t spoken much of your family,” Bilbo said quietly, the pipe his hands lowering to his lap.
Thorin exhaled slowly, realizing that despite this last night in the Shire, there was no way he could lie to Bilbo. “They remain in Erebor,” he replied. “I won’t be returning until the Autumn season, in time for our Durin’s Day celebrations.”
“Autumn,” Bilbo repeated, almost absently, and—there.
Thorin saw it. A glimmer of hope reflected back at him in Bilbo’s eyes, leaving Thorin with the possibility that he might not be the only one hearing his own heartbeat right now.
“Pity, then, that you have to leave for the Blue Mountains tomorrow,” Bilbo continued, voice barely above a whisper. “With all that time you have before heading home, I should have liked to get to know you further.”
Thorin tapped his pipe, thinking of home. Yes, it was the grandest mountain in the east, filled with glimmering stone walls and the passionate cries of his dwarven kin. Yet, in the few months since he set foot from Erebor, that place had felt farther and farther away, with the sense of home only becoming ever present the more time he spent with a rather wondrous hobbit, his nephew, and their own version of a fire-warmed dwelling built beneath solid earth and stone.
He blew out one last smoke ring before steeling himself and resting his own hand atop Bilbo’s. “Try it again,” he said.
Bilbo’s eyes widened, ever so slightly. “Try what?”
Thorin squeezed the hand of that wondrous hobbit. “Asking me to stay.”
Chapter 2: The Words That Don't Come Out
Chapter Text
Thorin groaned against the weight of the long workbench as he pushed it into the middle of the smithy. Where it had stood as simple storage mere days ago, it would prove more useful closer to the forge. Besides, no other dwarf was around to protest his redecoration.
Bench moved, he began to set out his tools for the day, noting that the long list of orders due by nightfall was still comprised mostly of gardening tools and kitchen items. To his amusement, a hastily scrawled order had been added at the bottom: New set of knives for Hamfast. We’ll surprise him at dinner tomorrow. -B
Thorin chuckled. Bilbo had accompanied him to the forge that morning, and as he had gone about lighting the fires for the day, he remembered the hobbit shuffling about his diary with a deceptively casual interest.
“You could have just asked me about the knives,” Thorin said when he returned to the smial that night, striding into the kitchen. “Why the secrecy?”
Bilbo, sitting at the table and chopping up lettuce—Thorin had never eaten so many vegetables as within the past few weeks—raised a playful eyebrow. “I thought it would be a nice surprise. You’re always complaining about how many saucepans or trowels you have to make.”
Thorin went to the sink to rinse his hands. Bilbo never mentioned it, but the smell of the forge was less than welcome at Bag End. “Knives, though?”
“Closest thing I could think of to that beast.” Bilbo nodded towards the front room, where Thorin’s broadsword could be seen resting against a bench. “I apologise that kitchen knives are perhaps a petty substitute, skill-wise, but I assure you that Hamfast will appreciate them nonetheless!”
Thorin shook his head with a chuckle, moving closer to the hobbit. “It is a kind gesture, for Hamfast and I both.” He stopped in front of Bilbo and rested a hand atop his curls, considering if it were wise to bring up Orcrist. “Remind me to tell you the story of an Elven blade, gifted to the King of Erebor, that used to be a marvel for us smithies.”
He smiled as Bilbo leant into his touch. “I’ll remind you if you grab that payment on the table. I’ve added in extra for the knives.”
Thorin snorted, though he continued to stroke Bilbo’s head gently. “Only if you stop force-feeding me salads.”
—
They had been silly to think that Frodo was none the wiser. Thorin should have known that the boy suspected something, kinfolk to one of the most brilliant creatures in The Shire he was.
Three months to the day that Thorin received Bilbo’s orders of cookie cutters, he woke to the spring sun filtering through the windows and the sound of little feet pattering down the hallway. Too late did the latter register for him to wake his bedpartner and think of a reason for his presence there, and Frodo burst into the room and leapt onto the bed. “It’s the first day of summer!” the little hobbit cried.
To his credit, Bilbo recovered a lot quicker than Thorin. He sat up, gathering his nephew in his arms and dragging him down into the blankets. “Good morning to you as well, little rascal! Have you forgotten how to knock?”
Frodo yelped and giggled profusely. “I’m sorry, Uncle Bilbo! But you said we have a lot of work for the solstice festival tonight!”
“Right you are, my lad,” Bilbo said. He threw Thorin a look. “What do you say, Thorin? Fancy taking a day off from the forge to help us with the cakes I’ve promised for the Thain?”
Thorin had barely blinked since Frodo’s unceremonious arrival, but Bilbo clearly did not have a problem with Frodo’s accidental discovery.
Nor, it seemed, did the young hobbit. “Yeah! Stay with us today, Uncle Thorin!” said Frodo.
Bilbo beamed. Thorin suspected his own face was little different.
That night, stuffed with strawberry cake and summer ales, Thorin moved his belongings from the guest bedroom to Bilbo’s room. They all fell asleep there, with Frodo tucked into the small space between them, and Bilbo’s hand clasped firmly in his own.
–
Thorin,
Damn the niceties. Perhaps I should be calling you Stranger instead? I’m no member of the Mathematicians Guild, but I can surely count that it has been nearly ten weeks since your last letter. I would assume you are dead but for the fact that the ravens faithfully bring me a lock of your hair each time they return. And no, I will not apologise if they happen to pluck it less than mercifully.
If I am wrong and you’re actually dead—which you’d better not be—then you would be right to believe that Father will send the armies of Erebor to break down upon whatever foul land has finally bested you.
That, or perhaps Frerin is right. He’s been betting that you’re distracted from sending us regular replies because you’ve fallen in love. If that is the case, I should hope you’ve gone about courting them properly as a potential future Royal Consort and they are prepared to return to Erebor with you.
Of course, this is all assuming they have been keeping your little secret as well.
I have half a mind to ask Dwalin to find you, but that would defeat the purpose of this all. I would hope you are being responsible, even discovering something to learn. Mahal knows that there is goodness beyond this mountain, and I know you can find it.
But damn it. Write back, please.
Dis
P.S. Fili and Kili tell me they’ve written a song for your return. Don’t give them a reason to make it worse than it already is.
—
“Tell me about your family.”
Thorin blinked his eyes open, pulled back from the beginnings of a nap while stretched out on the blanket atop thick summer grass. Sleep beckoned after a long afternoon of harvesting tomatoes, but he couldn’t begrudge Bilbo the interest. “What do you want to know?”
The hobbit in his arms shifted. “You’ve told me you have two nephews. And a sister. Beyond that I know nothing.”
Thorin watched the clouds drifting lazily in the sky. Not for the first time, he wondered at how to tread this line, remaining genuine to Bilbo while avoiding anything too revealing. He doubted that Ereborian royalty was common knowledge in The Shire, but one could never be too careful.
Then again, he must have been silent a moment too long. “If it’s a sore subject, we need not touch it,” said Bilbo.
“It’s not that,” Thorin replied. “I’ve… I’ve been away from home for quite some time now. I haven’t seen my family since the last weeks of winter.”
“You must miss them terribly.”
A vision of Kili spilling wine on the visiting Lord Radmor, followed by one of Frerin swiping grapes one by one from Balin’s plate, crossed his mind. “You could say that,” Thorin chuckled, wondering at the sudden image he had of Bilbo scolding them. “They get up to plenty of trouble without me there.”
“Oh, so you’re the party pooper, then?”
Thorin poked Bilbo in the side, drawing out a laugh. “My father is always working, even as he ages, and my mother is busy in society. They…own a smithing business, and I’ll be taking it over once my father is ready to pass it on. My sister and brother do assist, but they would never take on the full responsibility of it all. The… the business has been in the family for generations, so it was never a question for us to follow in my father’s footsteps. We’ve built our lives around it.”
“And your nephews?”
“Menaces, the both of them.” This drew another light chuckle from Bilbo. Thorin took a deep breath, feeling like he could push it, just a bit. “Their names are Fili and Kili. Fili is the eldest, and he works by my side to learn the trade, for he will take over after me. He’s the more dignified of the two.”
“But still a menace.”
“Still a menace,” Thorin laughed. “Their mother—my sister, her name is Dis. And my brother’s name is Frerin. He’s the prankster, always used to get us into trouble as children, and he continues to be a bit naughty with our… customers, and with the other smiths and artisans. Dis is the good one. I always say that it’s a pity she wasn’t born first.”
“Could she not take over the family business if she is second-born?”
“Er.” Thorin inhaled sharply. “It’s… tradition in dwarven culture for the eldest to assume ownership.”
Bilbo hummed quietly. “Odd, but who am I to judge? You’re helping me prepare for a tomato competition tomorrow!”
“I fear I am not doing my family justice. They’re… more passionate in person.”
“I’m sure they are wonderful,” Bilbo said, propping himself up on an arm to look Thorin in his eyes. “I should like to meet them some day.”
He drew Bilbo in closer. “I have no doubt they would love you.”
“You think so?”
Thorin looked at the hobbit, gazing down with the summer sun behind him, lighting his head in a manner that had Thorin imagining a thin Consort crown. “What’s not to love?”
—
The sound of hearty laughter drifting down the path up to Bag End greeted Thorin after a long day at the forge. He couldn’t recall Bilbo mentioning any visitors that evening, but the hobbit was always full of surprises.
It still shocked him to enter the dining room and see Frodo pouring water for one of the last beings he ever expected to see in The Shire, let alone Bilbo’s own smial. “Gandalf?”
The wizard thanked Frodo, cocking his head at Thorin and causing a million questions to flit through—how did he know Bilbo? Was he sent here by the King? Was something happening in Erebor that required such a summons and a wizard to hasten his arrival?
Mahal’s beard, did he tell Bilbo who Thorin was?!
At that moment, Bilbo walked in with a tray loaded with food. Thorin braced himself, but the hobbit only grinned widely. “Thorin! You’re just in time for dinner! This is my friend Gandalf, who’ll be joining us tonight.”
“We’ve met,” the wizard said neutrally. He still fixed Thorin with a gaze that was at once reassuring and critical. “I’ve worked with Thorin and his father in Erebor on multiple occasions.”
“Oh! I didn’t realise you dabbled in blacksmithing as well. That must have been quite a boon for Thorin’s family business,” Bilbo babbled on, beginning to lay out the chicken and potatoes while Frodo climbed into Thorin’s lap for a hug.
Gandalf raised his eyebrows ever so slightly at the little hobbit’s actions. “Family business,” he muttered, “indeed.”
—
Speaking about Thorin’s father’s affairs was suitable enough of a pretense to provide Thorin and Gandalf the opportunity for a private conversation after dinner, with Bilbo dropping Thorin a light kiss on his shoulder before running to tuck Frodo into bed.
Standing next to the fireplace, Gandalf cut an imposing figure, the sleeves of his long robe casting dark shadows as he crossed his arms and fixed Thorin with a glare. “Not once did it cross my mind that a casual visit to my old friend Belladonna Baggins’ son would place me in the company of Thorin, Son of Thrain, Crown Prince of Erebor,” Gandalf said gravely, voice low so that only Thorin would hear. “Masquerading as a blacksmith, no less. And,” the wizard’s frown deepened, “sharing the company of one who does not know the truth. I must ask: for what purpose is this entire charade in motion?”
Thorin sat back in his armchair. Gandalf had avoided addressing him directly all throughout dinner, but he knew the full state of affairs was more than apparent to the wizard.
Now, Thorin tried to hold himself with all the dignity he tried to exude when standing next to his father on the throne. “I’ll spare the details, but it was my father’s wish for me to travel Middle Earth without the weight of the crown on my shoulders before I am to be King.”
Gandalf pursed his lips. “He means to go through with it, then. To abdicate.”
Of course the wizard had caught word of the plan somehow. “Your confidence remains deeply appreciated by the dwarves of Erebor.”
“Peace, Thorin,” Gandalf scoffed. “I care not to be a gossip-monger, especially not when you are quite fit to rule that mountain and maintain peace among those lands.” Gandalf deflated slightly, dropping his arms and sitting in the opposite armchair. “I don’t doubt your need to spread your wings before settling into the kingship, but Bilbo is a dear friend of mine. I will not see him hurt.”
Thorin closed his eyes briefly, the thought of hurting Bilbo even the slightest bit pulling his heart into his throat. “I do intend to tell him the truth. I’ll have to return to Erebor for Durin’s Day, when Father intends to announce his abdication. Bilbo will know long before then.”
“And what of after, Thorin? Have you thought about what that will mean for someone who is so clearly in love with you?”
His heart remained stuck in his throat.
“I trust you are proceeding with all the caution of a reasonable dwarf,” Gandalf said, “which is to say, none at all.”
“There is still plenty of time before I return for Durin’s Day.” Thorin glared at the wizard. “Now is not the right—”
“The right time has long passed, so save me the stubbornness.” Gandalf sighed, and his reprimanding gaze turned to one of near pity. “Be careful, Thorin.”
—
Thorin stood at the tailor’s counter, his fingers nervously tapping against the wood. The matronly hobbit had told him to take his time assessing it as she went to help another customer, but Thorin could see no issue with the quality.
The coat was perfect. Every part of it had come together just as he imagined—the deep burgundy fabric in a thickness suitable for the coming autumn, the subtle gold threaded through the seams, the buttons he had forged specially for Bilbo’s favourite tree at Bag End sewn in. He knew Bilbo would love it, just as he felt he knew Bilbo.
The same could not be said in reverse.
“What’s wrong, Uncle Thorin?”
They had given up on correcting Frodo long ago, but that reminder did little to settle Thorin’s nerves. “I just…” Thorin began. He sighed, looking at the way Frodo sat by the window, innocently swinging his legs and looking for all the world like he had no idea Thorin was having a crisis of conscience in the middle of picking up his uncle’s birthday gift. “I just don’t know how I’ll be able to keep this a secret until your uncle’s birthday.”
“Well, you’re keeping my gift a secret pretty well,” Frodo chirped.
That did cause Thorin to chuckle, thinking of the new stationary Bilbo had ordered and the little writing desk Thorin had built, both of which lay hidden at the Gamgee’s place.
“I promise I won’t tell!” Frodo continued. “But why are you worried you will?”
Thorin’s smile faltered. He reached out to stroke the fabric of the jacket again, already hearing how Bilbo would marvel at its sturdy refinement. “I wouldn’t say I am worried,” he sighed. “I just… do not like keeping a secret from him.”
Frodo tilted his head, considering. He rose from his chair to come and grab Thorin’s hand, offering the sort of innocent reassurance that only a child to give. “Uncle Bilbo wouldn’t care,” he said confidently. “He loves you, Uncle Thorin. And you love him, right?”
Thorin blinked. “Of course I do.”
“Then he definitely wouldn’t care. He’d forgive you!”
“I hope so,” Thorin replied. He glanced at the jacket again, thinking of the fine figure Bilbo would cut in it. Bilbo’s birthday was in a week’s time, which meant that the time for making his way back to Erebor was fast approaching, if he were to make it back for Durin’s Day.
“Can we go get chocolate now?”
Thorin let out a long breath. He signalled the tailor to wrap up the jacket and bent down to swing Frodo into his arms. “So long as you don’t get a stain on your Uncle Bilbo’s new jacket,” he teased, causing Frodo to giggle.
The happiness of two hobbits who made a home for him came first, before any thoughts of preparing to depart for Erebor and addressing things with Bilbo.
He still had plenty of time.
—
It appeared as if half of The Shire turned out for Bilbo’s birthday party, with the other half slowly trickling in as the evening wore on, if the continuous wave of arriving guests that Thorin greeted was anything to go by.
The sun had long since dipped below the horizon, but the lights strung along the Party Tree and across the various tents and makeshift lampposts illuminated the field with a warm glow. Bilbo’s party was in full swing, and—so far—everything had gone off without a hitch. It had been Thorin’s idea, wanting to organise a proper celebration for Bilbo after he had so selflessly been dedicating his life to raising Frodo over the past year. Hamfast and his family had been an enormous help, and together they had arranged the whole event, managing every detail from the amount of fruits to serve with the cheese plates, to the rotation of musicians playing in the band.
Bilbo did step in at one point, being the wonderful hobbit he was. “It’s not that I don’t trust you, my love,” he had said, “but Shire politics are lost on outsiders. This guest list is atrocious!”
Thorin had let Bilbo in on the planning from then on. Social niceties were always Dis and Frerin’s specialty, not his.
Now, he took a brief moment of respite near the drink tent, leaning against a barrel and letting his gaze drift across the party. In the far corner, he could see Frodo playing with the other children in some haphazard game of catch that involved a small gourd and an empty basket. He chuckled, scanning the field for Bilbo and finding the hobbit perched on a stool next to the musicians, singing along with the folksy tune they had struck up.
All this, being in The Shire, setting up the forge, meeting the hobbits—it was supposed to be temporary. Thorin was never supposed to fall in love with one of them, with Bilbo. Bilbo, who was warm, open, so utterly genuine in his silly cynicism buoyed by unwavering principles of dedication and loyalty to those he loved.
Clapping to the beat of the music, Bilbo looked happy, relaxed in a way that Thorin could never imagine him being in a place such as Erebor. Gandalf’s words, coupled with the letters that Dis continued to send him even despite his inability to pen a rational reply, pressed down on him like thick fog and prevented him from fully being able to enjoy tonight.
Thorin took a deep sip of the harvest berry ale he had become so accustomed to drinking in The Shire, letting the rich flavour coat his tongue and the slight buzz dull the nerves that told him his departure was imminent.
He should have realised that the buzz may have been to blame for ignoring the slight commotion behind him as he turned to grab a refill.
“Thorin? Is that you?”
His stomach sank. It couldn’t possibly be—
“Mahal’s beard, it is! What the hell is going on?”
Thorin grabbed his refilled mug and turned, as slow as his racing heart would allow, to face his brother. Behind Frerin, Dwalin rose up like a mountain, towering over the quizzical hobbits. “What are you doing here?” he asked, voice dropping gruffly. Thorin chanced a quick look back to the band, but Bilbo was still singing cheerily, none the wiser to the new guests just yet. “How did you find me?”
Frerin scoffed, walking closer to grab a mug of ale from a wide-eyed hobbit lass with a wink and handing another one to Dwalin. “Have you been so long gone as to forget the wisdom of our Ereborian ravens? Or the proficiency of my own tracking skills?”
“And also,” Dwalin muttered, “the Grey Wizard paid us a visit and told us where you’ve been hiding.”
Thorin closed his eyes for a beat. Of course Gandalf couldn’t sit so idly by.
“Fun party, this,” Frerin was saying, taking a hearty swig of the ale. “We’re on strict orders from the Council, though. Find you, then return home immediately.”
“What?” Thorin rounded on his brother, a heat rising up in him that nothing to do with the homemade Shire brew. “I have—I have plans to make my way home soon. In time for Father’s announcement.”
“Any plans went out the window once you stopped replying to Dis’ correspondence,” Dwalin said, almost disapprovingly.
“Mmm. Last Council meeting I attended went on for hours as they tried to figure out what to do about you,” Frerin chided. “Even I was getting involved, imagine!”
“I don’t understand.” Thorin shook his head, pulling his kin in closer to prevent their conversation from being overheard. “Why are you here to bring me back, now of all times?”
Frerin raised his eyebrows. “Now? Thorin, we expected news of your return journey weeks ago. Now, you were already supposed to be making your way home.”
“Consider this a bonus escort,” Dwalin chuckled, though Thorin could not share in his mirth.
“Now. No, I cannot, I—” Thorin tightened his grip on his brother’s arm. “I still have things to explain… Dis was right, though I never answered her, there is a hobbit here at this party, his party—”
“You have fallen in love?” Frerin cried, and that definitely drew the attention of several hobbits.
“Yes, I just… I haven’t told him, obviously—”
“Obviously? Thorin, what haven’t you told—”
“Thorin? Who are these?”
Thorin froze as Bilbo’s voice cut into their group and the hobbit stepped forward, cheeks flushed and the widest grin on his face. “Bilbo, don’t mind them—”
“Nonsense! If I am to hold one dwarf at my party in such high regard, surely I can do the same for others.” And then Bilbo turned to Thorin’s kin, eyes bright and hand outstretched. “Bilbo Baggins, thank you for coming to my party! I can only imagine you are quite dear to Thorin here, since he happened to conceal the surprise of your attendance from me.”
“It was a surprise for him, as well,” Dwalin said under his breath, before dropping into a slight bow. “Dwalin, Son of Fundin, at your service.”
Frerin grabbed Bilbo’s hand, smirking cheekily before bowing just the same. “Frerin, Son of Thrain. Apologies on behalf of my brother, he’s infamous in Erebor for spiralling into great brooding sessions that succeed in achieving nothing.”
Bilbo chuckled. He grabbed Thorin’s arm and held on tightly. “A brother! You must be Frerin, then. I’ve heard plenty about you!”
Frerin shot Thorin a look. “Is that so? Did he tell you I’d make the better king if it didn’t mean losing all my hair in the process?”
“Frerin.” Thorin, stunned mute until then, glared at his brother.
Not now, not like this.
“Peace, brother, you know I jest. That crown goes better with your dark locks, anyways.” Frerin looked at Bilbo innocently. “Has Thorin spoken to you about coming to Erebor?”
“What?” Bilbo asked, at the same time that Thorin growled, “That’s enough, Frerin.”
Dwalin clicked his teeth, groaning loudly and turning towards the ale cart.
Frerin rolled his eyes and waved his mug about with a flourish. “Leave it to this idiot dwarf to make me so unpopular. Our father has requested Thorin’s speedy return after he’s refused to answer our dear sister’s letters. We are to start heading back tomorrow.” He looked Thorin in the eyes steadily. “The Crown Prince would be wise to follow our King’s wishes once again.”
The air seemed to chill despite the warmth of the autumn breeze. Frerin’s words cut through the fog that had been stifling Thorin’s heart like a blade.
“Er, I—I beg your pardon.” Bilbo’s voice cracked as he turned to look at Thorin, eyes widened in confusion. “King? Crown Prince?”
Thorin felt the moment that Bilbo’s hold on his arm loosened, and he felt the moment that Bilbo began leaning away from him. “Bilbo,” he tried, and he hated the way he almost choked on his beloved’s name, “I can explain—”
“Ach, this is torture!” Dwalin cried from the inside the tent. “That there is Thorin, Son of Thrain, Son of Thror, Crown Prince of Erebor, and he is to be King Under the Mountain before the new year.” Dwalin stepped closer, frustration bristling from him in waves. “We are escorting him back to Erebor. Tomorrow.”
Thorin’s heart sank. Bilbo stood still, jaw dropped slightly and staring between the dwarves as if waiting for some kind of explanation, but Thorin was too frozen to offer one.
“I… I don’t understand,” Bilbo finally whispered, voice barely above a whisper. “Thorin, you… you’re a prince? And you’re… leaving?”
Thorin opened his mouth to speak, to apologise, to explain himself, to say something, but before he could, Bilbo turned on his heel, pushing away from Thorin’s side and sprinting away through the crowd of hobbits.
“Bilbo!” Thorin called. He shot his brother and cousin a look, though he lacked any real anger towards them.
He did this.
“Bilbo, wait!” Thorin cried out again, heart pounding as he sprinted, caring not for the shouts of his kin, of bewildered hobbits that he brushed past, single-mindedly chasing after the only being he had ever fallen in love with.
—
The smial door was wide open when Thorin arrived, breathless but powering forward on adrenaline. “Bilbo?” he called, and he turned sharply when the sound of a wracked sob came from the direction of Bilbo’s bedroom. Thorin gulped, pressure crushing his chest as he made his way over.
At the threshold, he paused. Bilbo stood in the middle of the room, clutching his shoulders and looking so… small. The pressure in Thorin squeezed tighter, but he managed to choke out, “Bilbo.”
Bilbo turned, and his face broke Thorin’s heart. Tracks of tears stained his reddened cheeks and his eyes, usually so full of love and warmth, burned now with a fury that cut deeper than any sword. “You lied to me,” Bilbo spat, his voice rough with anger. “All this time. I… I loved you, and you lied to me.”
Thorin took a step forward, focusing on Bilbo’s trembling figure through tears of his own that had violently sprung up. “I didn’t want you to find out like this,” he said, and his hand instinctively reached for the hobbit. “Just let me explain—”
He gasped as Bilbo batted his hand away with a groan. “What is there to explain, Thorin?” Bilbo hissed, his name sounding like a curse. “All along, it’s been a lie. All these months! This must be some cruel joke to you, pretending to be some lowly blacksmith looking for someone to warm his bed”—Thorin winced, dropping his gaze—“and letting me think you were going to stay? Letting me think there was actually a life, a future here in this home where you would live with me and Frodo? Oh, Eru, Frodo—”
And Bilbo started shaking as the force of his sobs ran through him again.
Thorin’s hands balled into fists, fighting against every instinct he had to grab Bilbo, hold him close, and never let go. “Bilbo, you are my home. My home is more than Erebor, and I’ve long since learned that my heart cannot be forever tied to that mountain. I… I’ve been trying to tell you for weeks, but I just…”
“Just what?” Bilbo asked quietly.
Thorin sighed. “It was too late. I just didn’t want to hurt you.”
Bilbo laughed sharply, a second cut to Thorin’s heart with a blade of his own making. “So much for that,” he said, then he sniffled again.
“Bilbo—”
“You can gather your things here in the morning.” Bilbo’s voice was cold, and it shook with the effort of speaking against more tears. “I have to go back and get Frodo, figure out a way to explain to him that he has lost another loved one.”
Thorin took a step back, nearly tripping over the threshold. “Bilbo, I…” He let out a long breath, the tears flowing freely now and dripping onto Bilbo’s wool rug. “I’m sorry.”
Bilbo looked up, and for a brief second, something flashed across his eyes, flickering past the anger and redness to twinkle like the stars each night they shared a smoke outside in the garden.
The brightness was gone almost instantly. Bilbo straightened slightly, moving forward with some renewed vigour and brushing past Thorin, stomping towards the front room. Thorin followed at his heels, heart hammering.
Bilbo paused at the bench by the front door, rummaging around for a moment before grabbing something and flinging it to Thorin’s feet.
It was a pouch of coins, laying there, mocking him.
“Your payment,” Bilbo said, his frown marring his kind features. He looked Thorin in the eyes. “Thank you for your craftsmanship.”
Thorin’s heart broke with each word. He couldn’t stand it, couldn’t bear the thought that Bilbo was hurting, that he had caused it. “Try it again, my love,” he said quietly.
“Try what?”
Thorin bent down to grab the pouch, holding it out to Bilbo with a shaking hand. “Asking me to stay.”
Bilbo let out a shaky breath. He stepped forward as if to take Thorin’s hand, then seemed to decide against it. He shut his eyes, turning away and opening the smial door. He raised his chin, looking Thorin directly in the eyes before gazing out into the empty night and replying in a voice like steel: “Safe travels, Your Highness.”
Chapter 3: These Stories Don’t Mean Anything
Notes:
There are always two sides to a story.
Chapter Text
“I can’t find anymore ornaments! I think we got them all!”
Bilbo secured the knot he was tying, shutting the box that housed the tree skirt and glancing up. “You sure about that, lad?”
“I’m positive!” Frodo circled the tree once more, crawling on his hands and knees. He popped up with a satisfied grin. “Every last decoration is gone.”
“So they are,” Bilbo nodded. He moved to ruffle Frodo’s hair, just as a loud knock sounded at the door. “And just in time, too! Would you mind getting the door?”
With an excited yelp, Frodo ran to the door and was soon dragging a ruffled-looking Samwise into the sitting room by the hand. “Can we play outside now?”
“Are you sure you’re prepared for an adventure out there?” Bilbo returned, raising a conspiratorial eyebrow at Samwise’s parents, who had followed their young son in, appearing quite flushed and windswept themselves. The last thing Bilbo needed was for Frodo to catch a chill after rolling around in the snow all day.
Bell Gamgee came quite chivalrously to Frodo’s rescue, squeezing Bilbo’s arm with a smile. “I’ll make sure his hat and coat stay on,” she said as she began to shoo the young hobbits back towards the entrance. “You two be careful with the needles there. And don’t forget to sweep, Bilbo!”
Hamfast chuckled as his wife bustled the children back out into the cold, armed with proper winter attire and a large container of warm tea. From the window, Bilbo watched Frodo skip down the path leading away from Bag End, turning to throw a haphazard wave in the direction of the smial before following Sam into the field.
Bilbo sighed. “Well, then. Shall we?”
One tedious hour later, the elegant pine tree that had stood in their living room all season was sheared of its branches, laid on its side in the yard around the back of Bilbo’s property. Hamfast was crouched by the steadily growing pile of firewood, taking a breather after having had the first go with the axe, while Bilbo was having his own turn, grunting with each determined stroke.
“Frodo seems to be in good spirits,” Hamfast muttered, taking a sip out of a flask he pulled from under his coat.
Bilbo paused, wiping his brow and shaking his feet to rid them of some snow. “He’s had good and bad days,” he said in response.
Hamfast nodded understandingly. “It’s the first Yule without…”
“Yes,” Bilbo answered, reeling back for another swing, “without his parents.”
“Mmm.”
The sound of the axe hitting the tree again, and again, and again filled the air. Bilbo hardly registered the fact that he had nearly chopped through half of the trunk before Hamfast cleared his throat loudly. “Save some for the rest of us, will ya.”
Bilbo blinked. “Right, er,” he rolled his shoulders back, turning the axe to pass its handle to his friend, “sorry about that.”
Hamfast let out a loud sigh. “Bell and I agree, you’re doing a wonderful job with Frodo. It’ll take time for the boy to adjust, but he couldn’t have a better guardian than you.” He grabbed the axe, clasping Bilbo’s shoulder with the other hand. “When was the last time you did something fun for yourself, for a change?”
“What is that supposed to mean?” Bilbo laughed. In one smooth motion, he patted the hand on his shoulder before shrugging it off and swiping the flask in Hamfast’s coat pocket. “As you both well know, I have my books, my long walks through the forest, my garden, and one very precocious nephew. I would say I am quite busy with enough things to want to pursue something simply for the pleasure of it.”
“I don’t doubt that, but it’s been a long year for you, Bilbo,” said Hamfast, shrugging, and Bilbo probably took a larger sip from that flask than he meant to, for he could have only been imagining the look of sympathy in his friend’s eyes. “I just wish that this time next year, you’re spending the end of the season doing something better than chopping up your Yule tree.”
Bilbo huffed, taking another swig. “That’s a lot of hope to place on the turn of a year, my friend.”
—
Bilbo hadn’t been lying when he said that Frodo had his good days and bad days. Today was one of his bad days.
He didn’t want to regret taking Frodo to the market that day, cooped up inside as they had been with the earliest of spring rains emptying over The Shire for the past couple days. What he did regret was stopping to give Lobelia Sackville-Baggins the time of day when she barked a snide “Good afternoon!” at them as they left the deli.
“Pity, that one,” she had said, nose upturned and looking at Frodo as if he were a runt. “He deserves a real family, not to be shackled up in a place that makes him so lonely.”
“He has a real family,” Bilbo ground out through gritted teeth. “And Bag End is all the more cheerful for our homemaking, leagues beyond whatever I imagine you would have done with it should my father not have denounced your husband in his will for being a bully and a cheat.”
Bilbo could handle Lobelia, but her casual cruelty was the most unwelcome thing for a young lad running a simple errand with his uncle, and it was all Bilbo could do not to throw his basket down in frustration after she had finally left.
Crouching down to Frodo’s level, Bilbo tried to find his eyes under his ducked head. “Frodo? I’m sorry about that. You know you shouldn’t mind folk like her, who are generally unhappy and only wish ill on others.”
Frodo sniffled, and Bilbo cursed Lobelia in his head, thrice over. “Would you like to go back home?” he asked.
His nephew only shrugged.
Bilbo let out a long breath, thinking and reaching back into his memory for the last time he had seen the widest grin split across Frodo’s face. “I’ll tell you what. Why don’t we see if we can gather the right ingredients for some mincemeat pies?”
That drew Frodo’s head up, and Bilbo silently cheered despite the way Frodo’s big blue eyes still shone with unshed tears. “Isn’t that a Yule dessert?”
Bilbo smiled, pulling out a handkerchief and wiping at his nephew’s face. “Who says we can’t bring a little bit of that joyous spirit to any other time of the year?” He straightened up, holding his hand for Frodo to grab as he turned them back towards Bag End. “The first thing we must do, to be sure, is make sure I have the right cookie cutters handy. On principle, my lad, your grandmother’s pies must each be topped with a properly-shaped star…”
—
Bilbo wiped his hands of crumbs, absently reaching for a third pie as he stood at the kitchen window, watching the broad-shouldered figure retreat down the hill towards town. The pie dough was a bit fluffier than Bilbo would have normally made it, but he wouldn’t have changed a thing.
For his first time baking, Thorin had done rather well.
The dwarf reached the bottom of the hill, pausing at the large oak tree. Turn right, Bilbo tried to project to him, sucking in a breath when Thorin took a couple steps in the wrong direction before stopping and heading the opposite way.
Bilbo shook his head with a chuckle, turning back to the rather gargantuan pile of pies they had managed to prepare that evening. He divided the pile in half, setting one half in the middle of the kitchen table for Frodo to pick at over the next few days, while the other half went into a large basket for the Gamgees. Treats sorted, the only things left to put away were the new cookie cutters, just finished drying from after he rinsed them earlier.
He held one up against the lamplight. Dwarven crafts were really something to behold—Bilbo remembered his mother chiding him as a tween, after he had run home yelling about the scary-looking folk who had set up a new business in town one spring day. “You’d do well not to judge strangers simply because you don’t know them,” Belladonna had said.
“I don’t trust them,” Bilbo had complained. “Their fires are big and they have all these big weapons hanging outside their stall.”
“Dwarves are excellent crafters.” Belladonna had then pulled out a small knife from somewhere in her skirts, which Bilbo now chuckled to think of. “There’s more to them than meets the eye.”
Well. That much was for certain.
Bilbo tried and failed to push away the memory of Thorin reaching over to tickle Frodo after the boy had flung a dusting of flour in his face, Frodo laughing while Thorin swung him up and over the kitchen bench before plopping him back down, poking at his nose.
“Gracious, Baggins,” he muttered to himself, “get it together.”
“Get what together?”
Bilbo startled, so lost in thought as he was. “Oh my dear boy, what are you doing up? I thought you were sleeping already.”
Frodo quirked his lips, coming further into the kitchen and returning the lazy embrace that Bilbo offered. “I’m not tired,” his nephew said. “Can I have another pie?”
“Frodo! It’s much too late for a snack.”
“But there are crumbs on your robe! You just had one!”
Bilbo glanced down at his front, noting that the boy was, obviously, correct. “You’re much too clever for your own good,” he chuckled, gesturing toward the pile on the table. “Alright. Just one.”
Frodo grinned, reaching for a pie and—ah. There was that happiness Bilbo had been after.
“Will he come back?” Frodo asked around a large bite of pie.
Bilbo felt his eyebrows rise. “I’m… I’m not sure. Did you have fun tonight?”
Frodo nodded vigorously. “Can we ask if Thorin will come to dinner tomorrow?”
“Oh!” Bilbo exclaimed, though he felt his heart skip a little. “I don’t know, Frodo, they do seem quite busy down at the smithy—”
“Well, could we go there tomorrow? And say hi?”
Bilbo blinked at his nephew. The last thing he had expected was for Frodo to take such a liking to a near-stranger, let alone a dwarf so handsome as Thorin. “I don’t see why not, lad,” he replied, telling himself it was for the sake of Frodo’s happiness that he agreed to this. “Now come, let’s get to bed. We’ll have to be up early to get ahead of the others at the smithy tomorrow.”
Besides, he still needed to make sure that the handsome dwarf was paid.
—
The tomatoes this year were among the best that Bilbo had seen. He cheered aloud as one larger than his fist was uncovered near the bottom of a particularly flourishing plant. Surely, this would take the prize at the market competition tomorrow!
He stood, taking the tomato and holding it up against the morning sunlight, turning it around to assess its firmness, its colour, to look to any possible imperfections that the judges may find—
“Started the harvest without us?” a deep voice called from the front gate.
Bilbo smiled, carefully placing the tomato in his basket and skipping down to greet Thorin, only to yelp as the dwarf hugged him so fiercely that he was lifted from the ground and swung around in a circle. “Thorin!” Bilbo cried. “The tomatoes!”
He felt Thorin’s laugh rippling against his chest as the dwarf set him back down gently. “Your priorities never fail to astound me,” Thorin said, bending down to plant a kiss on Bilbo’s forehead.
It wasn’t the early summer heat that had Bilbo’s face flushing then. “I have not lost the Top Tomato prize in over seven years,” he said, holding out the basket for Thorin to see. “I don’t intend on breaking that streak.”
“Nor should you,” Thorin replied, poking at Bilbo’s harvest so far and nodding gravely. “I shall smite down whoever thinks to challenge you for the title.”
Bilbo laughed, shoving at the dwarf. “You’re hopeless,” he said.
“Careful, you’ll make me regret taking the day off from the forge.”
“I don’t think that’s likely,” Bilbo said proudly. “You’ll find nary a raw vegetable in today’s lunch.”
Thorin’s eyes unashamedly lit up, and the dwarf scooped him up again in a great hug. “For that,” Thorin grinned, “I’ll harvest the entire garden for you.”
“Well, that’s no fun for me, and now that will make me regret having you here all day.”
Thorin laughed again. “Mad hobbit,” he murmured, bending down for a kiss that Bilbo was only too eager to meet him for.
Just as their lips met, a loud CAW sounded from the distance. Bilbo felt Thorin tense up, drawing away with a barely suppressed groan. “Don’t feel bad,” Bilbo said, patting Thorin on the chest, trying to reassure him there was genuinely nothing wrong. “They just miss you.”
“My family has too many things to do to be missing me,” Thorin said under his breath.
They looked to the direction of the bird’s cry, watching as a raven came swooping across the meadow towards the other side of the hill. “Will you…?” Bilbo asked.
Thorin pulled away, following the path of the raven. “Excuse me, love,” he said as he hurried around to the back, out of view.
Bilbo sighed. He wondered at the relationship Thorin must have with his family—he spoke so highly of them at times, bringing up a silly prank from one of his nephews or mentioning the kindness of his mother. The letters that came with Ereborian ravens, however, always seemed to bring a sense of unease to Thorin, and he would retreat to the study for a long while, emerging looking less than settled.
Bilbo knew better than to ask after his private affairs, but he couldn’t help but wonder at the source of such discomfort. He probably would get the beginnings of an answer if he prodded at it today and—
No, he shouldn’t. He trusted Thorin.
If there was something wrong back home, the dwarf he loved would tell him.
—
A rather melodious chorus of birdsong pulled Bilbo out of sleep. He slowly untangled himself from the heavy limbs that were draped over him, heeding the fact that Thorin was a terribly light sleeper.
Indeed, just as Bilbo slid off the bed, Thorin blinked awake. “Bilbo?”
“Shh,” Bilbo murmured, dropping a kiss on Thorin’s hand. “Go back to sleep. I’m just going to check on Gandalf in case he leaves early.”
An annoyed expression crossed Thorin’s face, and Bilbo couldn’t help but laugh. Evidently, whatever conversation he had last night with the wizard must have been characteristically frustrating. “Send him my regards,” Thorin said, before shifting again and shutting his eyes.
Bilbo followed the birdsong out the front door, where he found Gandalf sitting on the bench in front of nearly a dozen twittering birds. The wizard was whistling along with the creatures, and he only nodded at Bilbo in greeting as he went to sit beside him. After a moment, the song ceased, and Gandalf inclined his head toward the birds, who scattered into flight.
Bilbo had known his friend long enough to guess that the creatures were being sent off on some hairbrained errand. “Friends of yours?” he asked, only half-joking.
“That remains to be seen,” came Gandalf’s quizzical reply. “I need a message sent out for others to prepare for my arrival.”
Bilbo watched the birds disappear over the horizon. “You’re leaving today, then?”
“I will do my best to call upon you for Yule.” Gandalf pulled out his pipe, lighting it with only raised eyebrow. “I should hope you’ll be a much more enlightened hobbit than you are now.”
“What on earth is that supposed to mean?” Bilbo frowned.
The wizard blew out a smoke ring. “Your mother was one of the most steadfast hobbits I knew,” he said in reply. “Of the values I knew she maintained, one was a ferocious trust in herself.” He turned to fix Bilbo with an unreadable look. “I trust that you will make the right decisions, when the time comes. Not just for the life you’re shaping with Frodo, but for your own heart.”
Bilbo held the wizard’s gaze for a moment before scoffing. “How I shall miss your riddles, my friend,” he chuckled.
Gandalf remained devoid of mirth. “I trust you’ll be careful, Bilbo,” he said simply, before asking an inane question about the seeding cycle of pumpkins with the approaching autumn.
Bilbo shook his head, nevertheless humouring his friend. Gandalf could be a baffling old man, at the best of times, but Bilbo knew that, more often than not, he usually spoke in circles of great schemes that had little to do with the affairs of hobbits.
—
Then again, the baffling old man could also speak some truth.
It didn’t make the heartbreak any less painful.
—
“Uncle Bilbo?”
Bilbo blinked, refocusing his eyes from where they had lapsed into the middle-distance. His hand cramped from where it had been cradling his chin for so long, and he started to massage feeling back into it as Frodo stared up at him from the carpet. “What is it, lad?”
“Er…” Frodo glanced down at the thick book before him that Bilbo had picked up at the market the previous day. A group of dwarves travelling from the Blue Mountains had set up shop in The Shire once again, though a few that weren’t running the smithy had erected a cart full of other crafts.
A timid-looking dwarf had seen Bilbo eyeing a stack of books in Westron. “These are some brief histories of the Kingdom of Erebor, the Lonely Mountain,” the dwarf had said kindly. “My brothers and I will be heading there in time to celebrate Yule.”
Bilbo had managed a small smile. “I know of the Kingdom, though I am less familiar with its histories.” Grimacing, he had added, “And its rulers.”
“Erebor is the greatest dwarf Kingdom in Middle Earth,” the dwarf had replied. “Could I interest you in this introductory text? It, well… it details the founding of the kingdom, sets out how things are organised and run now, and illustrates the lines of royalty.” The dwarf had blushed. “I… transcribed that volume myself. I’m hoping the Librarian’s Guild will accept me into their ranks once we reach the mountain.”
Bilbo told himself it was only because of the sweet dwarf’s humility that he brought the book home, gifting it to Frodo immediately and refusing to open it himself.
“There’s a royal family tree in here,” Frodo was saying now. “Thorin’s in it.”
“Well, of course he is lad,” Bilbo said, trying to keep his voice patient. “He’s a prince.”
“I know, but there’s more to it.” Frodo scrambled to his feet and brought the book closer to Bilbo’s face, showing him the chart that outlined Thorin and his siblings, denoting them each as prince or princess. “Look at the note beside King Thror.”
A dismal curiosity had Bilbo squinting at the words scrawled next to the name of Thorin’s grandfather: Cause of death: Goldsickness.
“Frodo, I’m sorry lad but I haven’t the faintest idea what goldsickness is.”
“Oh!” Frodo flipped to a later page of the book, nodding when he found what he was looking for. “Apparently it is a disease, a sickness of the mind that is caused by proximity to massive hoards of gold. King Thror succumbed to it, going mad, and Erebor was in shambles when the throne passed to his son, King Thrain.” Frodo glanced up. “But there is another note here saying that… Well, instrumental in Erebor’s recovery was the Crown Prince, Thorin.”
“I’m not sure why such a good prince would leave his kingdom for such a long time, then.”
“Maybe he needed a break?” Frodo asked innocently. “From literally rebuilding a kingdom! You’re always saying that all work and no play makes for a cranky hobbit.”
Bilbo closed his eyes briefly. “I’m sure it’s not as simple as that.”
“Did you ask him?”
“He made it quite clear that he needed to leave the day after the party.”
“Did he say he actually wanted to?”
“He’s a prince, Frodo, he was doing his duty.”
“But maybe he wants to still see you!”
“I doubt he’d ever want to see me again.”
Then Bilbo nearly jumped as Frodo groaned aloud, a dramatic noise that Bilbo didn’t think one so young was capable of making. “Why are uncles so dumb?”
Bilbo felt his jaw gape slightly. “Frodo Baggins, that is no way to talk to—”
“Wait!” Frodo interrupted, shoving the book into Bilbo’s arms and scurrying out of the living room madly. “He asked me to hold on to this when we bought it, but I forgot to give it to you after he left!”
“Frodo!” Bilbo cried, shutting the book quickly when Thorin’s name in thick gold lettering started to jump out at him from the open pages. “This is quite enough, I don’t know what you’re trying to imply but…” he trailed off as Frodo returned, the words dying on his tongue.
His nephew was holding up a coat that was nearly as long as him, but even despite the length there was no denying that the coat was custom-made for Bilbo. He stood, coming slowly to take coat from Frodo and admire the workmanship. He didn’t peg Thorin as someone who knew the intricacies of fine clothing, but knowing what he knew now, Thorin almost certainly had the finest tailors in his employ. Of course he wouldn’t settle for less than the best, and this coat was, well, perfect.
Bilbo fingered the gold buttons sewn in, and tears sprung to his eyes when he noted the motif of oak leaves and an acorn along each one.
“Why an oak tree?” Thorin had asked as they strode past the Bag End landmark, hand in hand.
“My mother used to say it symbolises resilience, persistence and determination despite any challenge,” Bilbo had answered.
The design on the buttons winked at him in the firelight.
“He made those in the forge,” Frodo whispered.
Bilbo nodded, holding the jacket close. “I know,” he said quietly. “Frodo, you know this… Even so lovely a gift does not excuse the fact that he lied. Not just to me, but to both of us. And you know it wasn’t a small lie, either.”
“I’m sure he’s sorry, though.” Frodo fiddled with a corner of the jacket. “I’m sure he has a good reason for all of this. Why would he have stayed for so long and avoided all his responsibilities as prince if he didn’t?”
Despite himself, Bilbo chuckled. “You’re too clever for your own good, you know?”
Frodo gave a small smile. “I miss him, Uncle.”
“Oh, Frodo.” Bilbo knelt down, gathering his nephew in his arms so that the jacket half-embraced them both. “I miss him, too. Terribly.”
“So why don’t we do something about it?”
Bilbo pulled back slightly, blinking away his tears to look his nephew in the eyes. Frodo was clever, yes, and young, but perhaps that youth saw more potential in the world than he was given credit for.
Gandalf’s words, spoken to him weeks ago now, echoed now in his head.
Bilbo felt his shoulders straighten as something resolved in his heart. “Do you trust me, Frodo?”
Frodo’s eyes widened. “Of course!” he said matter-of-factly.
“Right, well.” Bilbo let out a long breath, refusing to analyse this further and thinking instead if bringing over a fresh batch of mincemeat pies would endear the timid dwarf-scribe and his brothers to the great favour he was about to ask of them. “What do you say to a little adventure?”
Chapter 4: The Story of Who I Am
Chapter Text
The dwarves before them rose in unison, eyes bright and cheeks red with emotion. “Thank you, Your Majesty,” the mother echoed, before turning to lead her children out of the throne room.
Thorin shifted to his other foot, not wanting to show his tiredness from standing for the past several hours as his father held the day’s audiences. Not a year ago, he could endure these ceremonies without issue, but the lack of sleep he’d endured over the last couple months drained his energy more quickly than ever before.
He took a steady breath. Only one more party left before they could retire for the evening.
“Feenil, Son of Greefil, and his wife Toha, Daughter of Tuma,” Balin read out from the ledger, seated at the bottom of the dais. Thorin never envied his old cousin for that wooden stool more.
“Feenil, Toha, welcome to Erebor. May Mahal bless you both,” his father intoned from the throne. “Have you already found quarters in the mountain?”
“We have, Your Majesty,” the male dwarf returned, “near the forges, for we intend to contribute our work as a blacksmiths.”
“Ah, excellent!” Thror beamed, nodding to Thorin. “Perhaps you’ll run into my son by the fires. He’s become a bit of a fixture there.”
Feenil gaped for a moment before recovering himself. “Er, yes, Your Majesty. And we look forward to sharing your great forges, Your Highness,” the blacksmith added, bowing to Thorin enthusiastically.
Thorin returned it, grimacing only internally.
“It is rather obvious,” Dis said that night as they gathered around the fire in Frerin’s quarters.
If there was one thing that Thorin could take comfort in while back in Erebor, it was this new routine of a nightcap with his siblings. Quiet and leisurely conversations before turning to bed were something he could not lose hold of after months in The Shire, and Dis and Frerin were more than happy to indulge him.
“You’re an idiot to think it wasn’t,” Frerin added. “I’m not sure if I necessarily approve of Father’s method of addressing it, though.”
Thorin snorted. “Coming from Erebor’s least tactful messenger.”
Dis groaned loudly. “We are not,” she hissed, glaring at each of them in turn, “re-litigating this issue again. Frerin, you needn’t have disrupted an innocent hobbit’s birthday merry-making. Thorin, you’re a right bastard for not telling the truth sooner.”
Thorin winced. There was nothing more evident that the disappointing reality spelled out by his sister, and he had shouted himself hoarse for days on the road out of The Shire, arguing with Frerin and Dwalin without any real hope of vindication.
“Well, because of your tendency to lack all subtlety,” Dis continued, “everyone in our family’s employ has noticed how much time you spend in the forge now. Balin has even told me that the Master of the Blacksmith’s Guild is beginning to worry over how to allocate work amongt her members, what with you taking over more than they can keep up with.”
“Leave it to Thorin to turn heartbreak into more productivity than Erebor can handle.”
“Frerin.”
“No.” Thorin leaned back in his seat, massaging his brow in a fruitless attempt to rid himself of the dull pain that had settled in his head since returning to Erebor over two months ago. “He’s right. I’ll speak to the Guild Master tomorrow. I just…” He trailed off, staring into the hearth.
The seat beside him dipped as Dis moved to share the sofa. She rested her head against his shoulder and let out a long breath. “I know,” she said quietly. “It’ll take time. We’re here for you, always will be.”
Frerin let out a grim chuckle. “Unless you tell us you’re not really our brother and are a travelling blacksmith from the Iron Hills.”
Despite the weight in his heart, Thorin still managed to lob a cushion over.
—
“Welcome to Erebor,” Thrain paused slightly, perhaps only enough for Thorin and his siblings to notice, “my friends.” The three brothers in front of them bowed together before turning to shuffle out of the hall.
“Bit odd, don’t you think?” Frerin whispered from Thorin’s side, having accompanied him to the day’s audiences as a show of support. Thorin still suspected it had something to do with avoiding getting roped into coronation logistics. “No stated lineage?”
Thorin cast a glance at their father, whose genteel expression remained neutral, betraying no scorn towards the newly arrived brothers, heading up a caravan from Ered Luin. More dwarves from the caravan stepped forward to introduce themselves, throwing back their thick winter hoods as they did so. “Erebor is home to all dwarves, regardless of their background or profession or family history,” he replied, nodding occasionally as Thrain greeted each Ered Luin dwarf in turn.
“Is that an officlal statement from the King?” Frerin returned quietly.
“I am not yet King,” Thorin said under his breath, trying to keep his focus on the caravan.
“In three days’ time you will be.”
“That has nothing to do with who we welcome to their new home in Erebor.”
Balin cleared his throat sharply, throwing Thorin a disapproving look from where he sat at the lower table. Thorin inclined his head towards their seneschal, hoping the exchange escaped the notice of the new arrivals. He stuck his elbow out ever so slightly to ruffle his brother. “I shall ban you from the throne room,” he muttered.
Frerin glared at him before turning to face forward again. He opened his mouth to say something, but his jaw dropped in sudden shock. “Oh, dear brother,” he said aloud, “I think you’ll be quite preoccupied with other matters to be worrying about me.”
“What?” Thorin frowned, following the direction of Frerin’s gaze and hoping that the surprise on his brother’s face was a simple overreaction.
He was wrong.
“Your Majesty,” read Balin after a his own huff of shock that mirrored Thorin’s own, “Bilbo Baggins of the Shire, and his nephew, Frodo Baggins.”
Thorin stared.
Bilbo?
There was no denying it. Standing just a few feet away from the dais, clutching a wide-eyed Frodo’s hand, was the last being Thorin had ever expected to see again, particularly after the tragedy of their last interaction. In an instant, Thorin’s mind whirled back to the final steps he took outside of Bag End, where he had stood at the beginning of the garden path and turned to look over his shoulder, watching as the smial door closed and Bilbo had disappeared from his life forever.
Or so he had thought.
Murmurs sounded throughout the hall at the appearance of a very obvious non-dwarf, but Bilbo appeared to pay them no heed. He looked resolutely forward, and Thorin saw him tug at Frodo’s hand to drop them both into a bow.
“Your Majesty,” Bilbo said clearly, and Thorin’s heart nearly skipped a beat at hearing that voice again. “Thank you for welcoming us to Erebor. My nephew and I seek shelter from the winter for as long as you’ll have us.” His eyes darted quickly towards Thorin, and Thorin’s heart definitely stopped for a moment then. “I… am not quite certain what I can contribute to the mountain, but I can be quite handy in the kitchen if necessary, as the Prince should be able to confirm.”
“Mahal’s beard,” Frerin breathed out, at the same time that Thorin sucked in a sharp breath.
Their father let out a dry laugh. “Oh, is that so? I take it you must be the hobbit—”
Thorin lunged towards the throne, grabbing Thrain’s forearm. “A recess!” he called out loudly. “To, er, allow the caravan to leave and settle into their quarters in short order.”
Thrain cocked his head ever so slightly and looked to Balin, who nodded with a shrug. “Very well,” he said softly, raising his voice to address the hall, “we will resume in fifteen minutes.” He stood, inclining his head towards Bilbo before rising and descending the stairs to speak to their seneschal. “Master Baggins.”
“Your Majesty,” Bilbo returned with a bow, straightening with a determined set to his shoulders as the force of attention from around the hall was directed to him once more.
“Thorin!” Frerin hissed, at the same time that Thorin all but ran down the steps of the dais towards the hobbit who had not left his mind since the door to Bag End had been closed on him.
Thorin was met halfway by Frodo, running towards him with an excited giggle and leaping into his arms. “Uncle Thorin!” the young hobbit cried, likely raising more questions in the minds of the curious dwarves around them, but Thorin found he couldn’t care less.
“Frodo,” Thorin breathed out, holding him tightly. “What are you doing here?”
“Uncle Bilbo wanted to go on an adventure,” Frodo said simply, scampering down and grasping onto Thorin’s hand, pulling him towards his uncle and taking Bilbo’s hand in his empty one. “We agreed we needed to see you again!”
Thorin paused, finally face-to-face with the hobbit. Bilbo’s expression was unreadable, though his face was flushed, betraying what Thorin knew to be a great effort not to burst forward with emotion. “Thorin,” Bilbo said, and Thorin’s throat tightened at the staleness of the hobbit’s tone. “It is good to see you again.”
“Likewise,” Thorin replied immediately, much too quickly, but he was pleasantly rewarded by a slight quirk to Bilbo’s lips. “I…” he began, trailing off and starting to lose himself in the novelty of beholding Bilbo, standing before the throne of Erebor. “I don’t…”
“Me neither,” Bilbo said, putting on a smile that didn’t quite reach his eyes. “I was told when we arrived that we’ll have our own quarters made up. Is there any chance we’ll be able to speak tonight, after Frodo and I have rested a bit?”
Well. Bilbo certainly wasn’t beating around the bush. Thorin couldn’t blame him.
“Anything,” Thorin answered. “We can talk, and I shall find you tonight. Take whatever rest you need.”
“Tonight, then.” Bilbo began to pull Frodo away so that he was forced to drop Thorin’s hand. The boy gave a fervent wave that Thorin returned with a wink, though the non-smile was still on Bilbo’s face when he nodded back, turning to trail after the remainder of the caravan out of the hall.
Thorin broke to see it. “Tonight,” he echoed, staring after the hobbit he still so fiercely loved until a rough hand pulled him back up next to the throne.
“That,” Frerin muttered, as Balin called the great room to order and Thrain re-entered from the side door, “was painful.”
Thorin had no argument about that.
—
Thorin was breathless by the time he turned the hallway to the guest quarters, which he had been warned were almost fully occupied, what with his upcoming coronation and the ongoing Yule festivities. Erebor did not have any rooms built out specifically for hobbits, Thorin had made a note to start converting some of the dwarven-sized rooms to quarters that more closely resembled those of a smial on his return to Erebor. Lower chairs, larger cooking and dining areas, space for a small pantry—realistically he had never expected any hobbit to travel the great distance and visit Erebor, but the refurnished rooms would be most welcome for dwarves, too.
He should have known that one particular hobbit could act quite unexpectedly.
He approached the room that he had been told was meant for Bilbo and Frodo now, steeling himself for what he anticipated would be a hard conversation. He rapped on the wooden door and let out a shallow breath.
A few seconds later, the door swung open to reveal Bilbo, looking less than pleased. “Thorin,” was his simple greeting. “It’s quite late.”
There were circles under Bilbo’s eyes, which were also puffier than they had been in the throne room this morning. He’d been crying, and the realisation had Thorin reaching forward automatically. “Bilbo—”
Bilbo took a step back, out of Thorin’s reach, and when he caught himself doing so, crossed his arms and pulled the belt of his robe tighter around his waist. He bit his lip. “Frodo’s asleep in the second bedroom,” he said. “He wanted to wait for you, but it’s been a long while since we’ve had some decent rest.”
“That is understandable.” Thorin stood, half-leaning into the room while he waited for the invite, holding Bilbo’s gaze steadily.
The hobbit heaved a great sigh, his eyes crinkling slightly. “Well, don’t just stand there.” He gestured with his head for Thorin to follow, leading him into the room and towards a sitting area where a small hearth housed a warm fire.
It pleased Thorin to see a tea set already being used at the low table between two armchairs, the two cups and pot having been forged on his first day back at Erebor. It was probably Dis who snuck those to Bilbo during the day, having seen Thorin staring at the crafts morosely when she had found him in the forge back then.
“Your sister stopped by,” Bilbo said, confirming his suspicions. The hobbit waved for Thorin to sit as he poured out tea for the both of them. “She’s quite lovely. And you were right, if she had been born first I do believe she would have made an excellent ruler.” Bilbo handed a cup to Thorin, their fingers brushing slightly, though he made no sudden movement to jerk away. “The succession line makes a lot more sense now.”
Thorin dropped his gaze to the tea cup, shame flooding every corner of his chest in a way that he hadn’t felt since his earliest days leaving The Shire. “I take it there is no need for the niceties?” he murmured.
“Not at this hour.” Bilbo settled into the opposite chair, leaning back with a look in his eyes that reminded Thorin of the first assessing glance he had given that day at the forge, back in the spring. “Though, if you must know, the caravan that aided Frodo and me was more than hospitable.”
“How did you even find them?’
Bilbo took a sip of his tea, gazing into the middle distance. “They had set up shop by your old forge.” He tilted his head at Thorin. “If I could ask a favour, the ‘Ri brothers were absolute gems. I would wish them to have every opportunity for success here.”
Thorin nodded. “Yes, Bilbo. I told you. Anything.” And he meant it.
“Thank you.” Bilbo tapped his tea cup, a gesture that Thorin guessed belied his nerves. The hobbit inhaled deeply and then, finally, gave Thorin a small smile that had his eyes crinkling the way Thorin remembered from late nights sharing a smoke outside Bag End. “So. Where to begin?”
Bilbo had one question, followed by another, and another, such that Thorin found himself detailing everything pertinent to his life as a Prince of Erebor over the last couple years.
He spoke of his grandfather’s goldsickness, the horrible disease that had settled in Thror’s mind after successfully defending the mountain against a terrible dragon, but falling victim to the beast’s hoard of gold. He spoke of Thrain’s ascension to the throne, the steady manner with which his father ruled but that drained him more than he anticipated, such that Thorin’s duties as Crown Prince doubled and grew until he was nearly ruling over Erebor in tandem with the King.
He detailed Thrain’s plan to abdicate, and the subsequent plan hatched by the Council and his family to send Thorin away in disguise, so as to learn more about the world outside the mountain and how he fits in it as a ruler of a great dwarven kingdom.
He described his travels in the initial months on the road, how he found work in Gondor and Rohan, even finding some respite in Rivendell for a period of time. He told Bilbo how he had never even heard of The Shire until a chance meeting with some dwarves in the village of Bree, how he had planned to pass through to Ered Luin with the other smiths—
“Until, well.” Thorin chanced a smile at Bilbo. “Until I met you.”
Bilbo, to Thorin’s great delight, returned it.
Thorin explained Dis’ letters, how she was the one who sent the ravens regularly, and how he had stopped sending replies once he began to more deeply settle into life in The Shire.
He explained how the rough timeline of his return before Durin’s Day felt constricting, how the thought of returning to Erebor and his future as King felt incongruous with the happiness he had found while building a home with Bilbo and Frodo.
“You… really felt like it was home for you?” Bilbo interrupted, eyes widening.
Thorin looked Bilbo in the eyes with all the sincerity he could muster. “My family sent me away to learn about my place in the mountain. What I learned during my time with you is that my responsibility is to its people, people I care about, people that are the heart and soul of any land and the reflections of its wonders and beauty.”
He could feel his chest warming in a way that had nothing to do with the gently flickering flames in the hearth. “Bilbo, I cannot turn away from Erebor and the crown that they will place on my head soon, but neither can I ascend the throne without telling you that you have my heart. Always. And it will be the greatest mistake of my life, this terrible lie that I’ve forced you to endure. I do not deserve your forgiveness, but know I would welcome you into Erebor, any day, any time, if only so I could show you the great home you have inspired me to build in this mountain.”
Thorin paused there. The fire crackled quietly in the background, and Bilbo was staring at the flames with watering eyes. Thorin could feel the tracks of his own tears drying on his face, but he refused to wipe them, refused to tear his gaze away from the hobbit and miss out on another moment in his presence if Bilbo were to decide that it was all too much and he had to leave Erebor forthwith.
“Well,” Bilbo said at last, “you certainly haven’t lost your flair for dramatics, have you?”
Despite himself, Thorin barked out a shallow laugh. “Shall I blame you for bringing it out of me?”
Bilbo waved him off, quirking his lips in a way that had Thorin’s heart leaping. “I’ve done plenty of thinking on the road, and I’d like to believe I am a sensible enough hobbit to trust in whatever decisions I make.” He stood then, grabbing their teacups and setting them on the table so that he could place himself directly in front of Thorin.
Bilbo stuck out his hands, palms facing up, and Thorin gladly grasped them in his own, relishing in the touch after so long without it. His heart hammered in his chest as Bilbo looked to be choosing his next words carefully. “I think we are past the point of me telling you that I forgive you, but,” Bilbo said quietly, squeezing Thorin’s hands, “I did just travel all the way here, and I suspect that we’ll need to habit here until the winter thaws, at the earliest. That must tell you something.”
Thorin gazed up at the wondrous hobbit before him who had captivated him from the moment he had asked for a set of star-shaped cookie cutters. “‘At the earliest?’” he grinned.
“I only say that, in case I have reason to stay longer,” Bilbo said back, stepping closer until he could rest his forehead against Thorin’s. “So, try it again.”
“Try what?”
Bilbo chuckled. “Asking me to stay.”
—
“I didn’t realise that Yule was also a tradition among hobbits.”
“Well, it does seem that there is more in common between us than at first glance.”
“Such as?”
“A propensity to eat and celebrate with enough enthusiasm to warrant no sleep, perhaps?” Bilbo tapped his chin in mock thought. “If I remember correctly, you and Dwalin drained a barrel of ale each at my party.”
Frerin shrugged casually. “If I remember correctly, both hosts had left the party unattended.”
“If I remember correctly,” Dwalin put in, “Thorin came back and dragged us away before the cake came out.”
“Oh did you?” Bilbo laughed, shoving Thorin gently. “I knew you were the party pooper.”
It was all Thorin could do not to grab the hobbit and tickle him into shutting up—such playfulness was best reserved for times away from one’s family. “I saw many a hobbit celebration during my time in The Shire,” he said instead, throwing an arm around Bilbo and pulling him closer on the sofa. “One barrel of ale would fell lesser dwarves than Frerin and Dwalin.”
Thrain raised a curious eyebrow, sharing a look with Fris from where they sat on the opposite sofa. “And here we thought you’d be doing more blacksmithing than merry-making on your travels,” the former king chuckled.
“We did sleep like wee pebbles that night,” Dwalin mused, slowly sipping his mug of decidedly Ereborian ale, while Balin shook his head in exasperation beside him.
“Good ale or no, Yule is much the same sort of celebration as it appears here,” Bilbo smiled. “Don’t you think so, Frodo?”
Thorin peered over to where Frodo stood at the foot of the large pine, towering at the side of the main sitting room in the royal family’s wing. The young hobbit was still wearing a sheep’s wool tunic that Fris had knitted for him upon learning that they would stay the winter.
Bilbo, for his own part, still refused on both of their behalfs to wear the boots that Dis had offered them. “If you plan on staying in my brother’s rooms, I won’t have you trouncing about barefoot like a vagabond,” she had said sternly, when Bilbo and Thorin emerged that morning to the family dining area. “Not for my sake, you see, but for your own. Fili and Kili spill their drinks everywhere.”
Of course, the ever-gracious Bilbo had replied perfectly, “If it would endear me to you further, perhaps I shall give them a lesson in hobbit etiquette? My young Frodo probably has as much to learn as they do.”
Dis had only laughed heartily, proceeding to drag Bilbo to every Guildmaster’s meeting she had that day and threatening to install him as Head Guild Advisor.
Thorin knew better than to think Bilbo would not make an excellent one.
Now, Fili and Kili were engrossed with some sort of game involving hollow chestnuts on strings that Bilbo had taught them the morning of Thorin’s coronation. He rather suspected the image of Kili getting his fingers tied in the string and being unable to properly genuflect before his uncle and stumbling towards the dais would be burned in his mind forever.
Perhaps hobbit etiquette lessons would also be something to add to Bilbo’s diary.
“The trees are smaller in The Shire,” Frodo was saying now, interrupting Thorin’s thoughts. He stared up at the tree, trimmed with gems and mountain flowers, sparkling in the firelight. The young hobbit fiddled with a new ornament that Thorin had forged that morning, spinning the silver acorn around its hook absently. “I can’t reach the branch I want to hang this on!”
Fris nudged her husband. “Go help the lad,” she said.
“No, no, I can do it,” Bilbo waved at them, beginning to get up before Thorin stood up swiftly.
“Allow me,” Thorin said, making his way to Frodo and scooping the boy up onto his shoulders easily. “Frodo and I had plenty of practice picking apples in the forests, just like this.”
Frodo giggled, hanging the ornament gracefully and sticking his little fists in the air. “Thank you Uncle Thorin!” he cheered, causing a chorus of delight to sound out from his family.
“Uncle Thorin, eh?” Frerin called out, taking Thorin’s seat next to Bilbo. “I heard this the other day, too. When did that start up?”
Bilbo laughed, catching Thorin’s eye. “He did it on his own! I’m afraid there’s no great story behind it all.”
“No great story?” Thorin smiled back, winking at his beloved hobbit. “I beg to differ.”
