Actions

Work Header

Bilbo and the Black Rider

Summary:

One chilly Halloween night, Bilbo Baggins tells the story of the black rider and his pumpkin head to four little faunts tucked tight in bed.

One chilly Halloween night, Thorin Oakenshield rides through the Shire, in search of the hobbit who thinks him dead.

Is the black rider real? Four little faunts are about to find out. And Bilbo will draw his own conclusions.

Notes:

And now for something soft and silly.

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Work Text:

It was the night of October 31st, All Hallows Eve, and while the cold wind howled through the fields and marshes of the Shire, scattering leaves in its wake, warm lights shown cheerfully from the windows of Bag End, where four little hobbit children lay cozily in bed with the covers pulled up to their chins, eyes wide and listening intently as Bilbo Baggins spun them a bedtime tale.

“The black rider rode up to the little hobbit,” Bilbo said, using his hands to mimic the clop of a horses’ hooves, “and he reached up to the pumpkin on his shoulders, and pulled it off his neck! The pumpkin had not been hiding the rider’s head at all! The rider had no head, and it had only been a pumpkin all along!”

All four of the faunts gasped and wiggled under the covers, throwing half-frightened, half-delighted glances at each other. Bilbo waited for them to quiet down again before he continued.

“To this day, they say the black rider travels the dark Shire roads on All Hallows Eve, looking for young hobbits who’ve stayed out too late past their bedtimes so he can scoop them up and carry them away!” He leapt to his feet and tickled their bellies then, causing them to squeal and flail, blankets flying as their little feet kicked.

“All right, faunts, storytime’s over. Time for bed!” he called above their giggles, moving to the lamps to begin putting them out. The boys jostled each other as they wiggled back into their places and got comfortable.

“Is the black rider real, Mr Bilbo?” lisped little Sam, and Bilbo saw him glance worriedly at the darkness outside the window before his worried face turned to gaze up at him.

Bilbo crouched next to the bed and tousled his hair. “Do you think he’s real?” he asked instead of answering, trying not to smile.

Sam looked from Frodo on one side to Pippin on his other, trading nervous looks among them, but didn’t answer.

“Well I can promise you one thing, lads,” Bilbo said as he stood again and began to tuck them in. “You are perfectly safe here, so long as you stay in your bed.” He gave them all a knowing glance, shaking a finger at them to make his point.

At least one little faunt was not cowed by Bilbo’s gentle warning. “I’m not scared of the black rider!” Merry crowed, beginning to slide from the bed. “I’m going to go watch for him!”

Bilbo scooped the little boy up before his hairy feet even touched the floor.

“No you don’t, Merry,” he told him, setting him back on the mattress with a bounce. “Bedtime is no time for bravado—“

With a bang, the window flew open, cutting Bilbo off as a great gust of wind blew fiercely in. All five of them jumped, and the little ones screamed, scrambling to the opposite side of the bed and leaping from it to scurry beneath it and hide, their little toes sticking out from under the bed skirt.

“It’s the black rider!” Pippin’s shrill, panicked voice yelled. “He’s coming in!” The other children screamed, hysterical.

“Calm down, calm down! It’s just the wind blowing the window open. It must not have been latched properly,” Bilbo told them, hurrying to shut it again and double checking that the latch was thrown correctly this time. “Come on, out from there!” he said when it was done and he turned back to the bed. ”Don’t make me get down on these old knees to pull you out.”

Slowly the little boys emerged, looking warily around as they clutched at each other. “Come on now, back into bed,” Bilbo told them, helping each climb back up onto the mattress. He tucked them in again, then glanced them all over. Each boy looked up at him with that particular expression faunts were well-skilled at, that was especially made to melt even the stoniest of hearts.

“It was just a story, boys. Nothing’s going to hurt you in here,” Bilbo told them soothingly. The children continued to blink up at him. Frodo’s eyes looked especially watery in the lamplight. Bilbo sighed wearily.

“Alright, will you feel better if I let you sleep in my bed tonight?” he asked. Four cheers rang out, and the boys leapt from the bed again, their feet pattering on the floor as they ran for Bilbo’s room. “Two of you will have to sleep wrong-way-round!” He called after them. “There’s not enough room for all of us!”

He followed them to his own bedroom and after only a brief scrabble for who would get to sleep with their heads at the foot of the bed instead of the ‘proper’ way, he saw them settled again.

“Now, I’m going to go heat up some milk for all of us in the kitchen. And after we’ve drunk it, we’re all going to sleep. Agreed?” He nodded as four little curly heads bobbed up and down. “Good. Stay here, and I’ll be back in a moment.”

-

Thorin Oakenshield had been riding in circles. He was well-versed in the maps of Eriador and as such knew that the Shire was not so very big, but confound it if he could find his way from Stock on the eastern edge of the Shire to Hobbiton in the middle. He was certain he’d passed that crooked old tree before, but perhaps he was wrong? There seemed to be many crooked old trees in the Shire - or at least, they all looked old and crooked in the dark.

Sighing, he turned his pony down another path. Perhaps this would lead him out of his circles. It didn’t help that his mount, a tired black mare that had been the only steed available when he needed to swap in Bree, was mostly night-blind. She tripped frequently in the wagon ruts and wandered off the road more than once.

He saw lights in a window up ahead and wondered how upset the hobbits there would be if he knocked on their door and asked for directions at this hour. Remembering Bilbo, he would frankly be surprised if they didn’t slam the door in his face. It seemed he would have no other option on this windy night, however; he could see that the road he was on ended abruptly just past this hobbit hole. He might as well try to ask before he turned around again and headed back the way he had come.

As he neared the gate, his pony stumbled again, nearly going down entirely. Thorin was bounced in the saddle until he lost his balance, tipping right off the side of her and tumbling into a pile of the crudely-carved pumpkin faces that hobbits often set out this time of year to scare away bad spirits. He landed hard in a sprawl, elbows and knees and everything else smashing into the pumpkins, knocking his head hard in the process.

It was a moment before he blinked his eyes open dazedly, but he wasn’t greeted by the moonlight when he did. He could see only inky black, and a spike of fear went through him for a terrifying second as he thought he had been struck blind, before he realized his head was stuck fast inside a pumpkin.

He staggered to his feet, hands stretching out, trying to feel for things around him and trying not to trip over bits of broken pumpkin. He heard the pony beside him whinny fitfully and rear. He stumbled, flinching away from the pony’s prancing feet, his hands thrown out, and he felt them connect with a door. He fumbled for the knob, intent on getting help, until he found it and wrenched the door open.

-

Bilbo waited at the stove for the milk to warm, grumbling to himself. “This is your own fault, Bilbo Baggins, telling them that story. You’ve made your bed, and now you must lie in it and hope you don’t get kicked all night.”

Suddenly, the kitchen door flew open. A broad, dark figure stood in it, silhouetted by the moonlight outside, and with mounting horror, Bilbo saw that the figure had a pumpkin atop its neck. Fear shot through him as he stumbled back, absolutely convinced in that moment that the story he had told the boys had come true, and the black rider had come to catch him and carry him away, ridiculous as that was.

The black rider reached up toward the pumpkin, and Bilbo acted on instinct, certain that if he saw the figure take off its head, he would faint dead away, and then the poor boys would be helpless. In a flash, he dashed forward, grabbed the heavy pot off the stove, dumping milk everywhere as he lifted it, and with a mighty swing, brought the pot down as hard as he could on the black rider’s orange head.

With a loud clang as the pot struck, the pumpkin cracked right down the middle, a piece sliding off on either side to fall to the floor. Underneath was a real head after all, but not a hobbit’s—a dwarf’s. The dwarf looked at him with a puzzled brow for only a moment, before his eyes rolled back in his head and he fell back out the kitchen door, knocked clean out.

Bilbo gaped. Because that had been no random dwarf he’d just clocked with his best pot. Thorin Oakenshield was at his doorstep. Thorin Oakenshield was out cold on his doorstep. Bilbo had just assaulted Thorin Oakenshield on his doorstep! Which was preposterous, because for the past five years of his life, Bilbo had believed Thorin Oakenshield to be dead.

“The black rider!!” came Merry’s shout from behind him, and Bilbo whirled around, eyes wide, to see all four boys in the doorway to the hall, faces white and fingers pointing at Thorin.

“Uncle Bilbo’s killed him!” shouted Frodo, and all four sets of eyes turned to look up at Bilbo in amazement and admiration.

“No!” Bilbo said, his voice high and panicked. “No I haven’t! I can’t have killed him; he was already dead!” There was a terrible knot in his stomach all of the sudden. He wasn’t at all sure that seeing his long-dead almost-lover was any better than seeing the black rider.

He scrambled for the body, leaping over Thorin’s feet to slip through the doorway and drop to his knees at Thorin’s head. A big red lump was quickly forming at his hairline, and Bilbo winced, hands fluttering over his face, not knowing what to do. He finally settled on slapping Thorin’s cheek gently, and after a moment, Thorin’s eyes fluttered open.

Beautiful blue eyes that Bilbo had been so sure he would never see again blinked up at him. “You’re not dead!” Bilbo gasped out stupidly.

Thorin groaned. “Then why do I feel dead?” He croaked, wincing as he lifted a hand to the knot on his head.

“Oh, I’m sorry!” Bilbo wailed, mortified, trying to bat Thorin’s hand away from the injury. “You just surprised me, throwing the door open like that, and I—I thought—well you looked just like—“

“The black rider,” came a reverent whisper, and Bilbo saw that the boys had crept closer to Thorin’s feet for a better look.

Bilbo turned back to Thorin. “How are you here? I thought you were dead!”

Thorin pushed himself up onto his elbows gingerly. “No. I was injured in the battle, but I recovered. But by then you were gone.” He looked up at Bilbo with widening eyes, as though it was only just sinking in who he was speaking to. Somehow, completely by accident, he’d stumbled right into the one hobbit he’d been looking for. He lifted his hand to hover beside Bilbo’s face reverently, as though he was almost afraid to touch him lest it all be a dream and Bilbo’s likeness should fade away. “Bilbo…” he whispered softly, wonderingly.

“Why didn’t you send word to me?” Bilbo asked, ashamed to feel tears prick the corners of his eyes, but he felt completely caught off his guard. Bilbo caught Thorin’s hand in his own and pressed it to his cheek, anchoring himself to Thorin’s touch. “It—it’s been five years,” he said, his voice miserable even to his own ears.

“I thought you knew,” Thorin answered in a rush. “I would’ve followed you right away if I had any idea that you thought me dead. All this time…I just thought…” He stopped himself, drawing in a deep breath. “Gandalf came to the mountain in the spring, and it was then I learned you had no idea of my fate. I set out the very same day to find you.”

Bilbo let out a noise that was half-sob, half-laugh, his eyes flitting over Thorin’s face. It really was him. The crow’s feet at the corners of his eyes had deepened, and his beard was longer, and there was a little more silver in his hair, but it was undeniably Thorin laying in the dirt outside his door.

“Oh!” Bilbo gasped, his Baggins side catching up to him. He pushed himself up to stand, reaching down to help Thorin stumble unsteadily up next to him. They stared at each other for a long moment, standing too close, hands still clasped from where Bilbo had pulled him to his feet.

“You’re really not dead,” Bilbo said softly, his voice awed.

“I’m not dead,” Thorin confirmed, gazing back intently.

They met each other in the middle, pressing together in a desperate kiss, Thorin’s arms immediately sliding around Bilbo’s waist as Bilbo’s went to the dwarf’s shoulders. It was needy, and desperate, and Bilbo wanted to drown in it.

“The black rider’s trying to steal Bilbo’s head! GET HIM!” came a shout, and suddenly they were surrounded as four little hobbits leapt at Thorin, beating his legs with their fists and stomping on his boots with their hairy little feet.

Bilbo and Thorin broke apart abruptly, suddenly brought back to the present. Thorin blinked at the faunts and then back at the hobbit in his arms. “Bilbo,” he said, eyes wide. “Who are all these children?”

An absurd giggle bubbled up in Bilbo, and all he could do was rest his forehead against Thorin’s chest and laugh.

-

Bilbo explained about the faunts as they sat in the kitchen, doctoring the lump on Thorin’s head. “Their parents have all gone down to the Great Smials for the harvesting,” he told Thorin as he checked the injury. “Frodo is a cousin of mine, actually, but the four of them are a bit of a set, so it’s easier just to take them all when they need watching.” He carefully dabbed a cool, damp cloth against the lump.

The four children in question stood on the other side of the table, peeking behind the chair backs as they watched Thorin suspiciously. “Are you sure you aren’t the black rider?” Sam lisped doubtfully.

“I don’t think so,” Thorin told him. “Who is he?”

Their eyes went wide. Merry stepped forward bravely to explain. “He’s a headless spirit who rides up and down the roads on All Hallows Eve! He has a pumpkin for a head, just like you!”

Thorin glanced back at Bilbo then, a knowing smile creeping over his face. “Is that what you thought, too?” he asked teasingly, crowding a little too close to Bilbo. “That I was the black rider come to get you?”

Bilbo shot him a frown. “Well you were a pretty convincing one, strutting in here with that pumpkin stuck on your head,” he grumbled. “But he had a real head under the pumpkin, didn’t he boys? So he couldn’t be the black rider.”

It took a little more convincing for the boys to accept that Thorin really was a harmless dwarf, but eventually Bilbo shooed them once more to bed (their own, this time, for he had suddenly received a much better offer for bed company than four fidgety faunts), and Thorin stepped back outside to catch his wandering pony and tie her out for the evening.

Job done, he headed back to the kitchen door, but stumbled again over the pile of broken pumpkin pieces. Only one Jack-o-lantern was still intact, and Thorin lifted it from the remains of its friends and gave it a once over. He set it on the fence post beside him and gave it a friendly pat before heading back inside to Bilbo.

From the shadows of a crooked old tree stepped a rider, dressed all in black and riding a black steed. He led the horse up to the fence post and picked up the smiling Jack-o-lantern, lifting it to perch atop his neck where a head should have been. His black mount snorted, steaming in the cold air, and then he set off down the dark road again.

Notes:

Kudos and comments are always appreciated! Happy Halloween! 🎃

You can find me on tumblr at an-odd-ducky.tumblr.com or on my hobbit-specific sideblog, an-odd-hobbit.tumblr.com