Work Text:
Coming back to your childhood home hits differently when your parents aren't there anymore. The little cottage with the bright green door in Bagshot Row still has my mom's wind chimes in the porch and dad's weird garden gnomes guarding the flower beds, and honestly most of the furniture, but many things have changed, including, thank every gay deity in existence, the neighbour situation.
I spent almost twenty years away from Wisconsin, first getting my English degree at NYU (because apparently, I needed to go as far away as possible to read thousands of books that discouraged me from trying to be an author, but made me instead decide to make a career out of writing about people pretending to be other people on stage), then building my career as a theatre critic. I might be a walking gay cliche, but I am a fucking good one at that.
Now here I am, back in the house I inherited, writing scathing reviews of experimental Shakespeare productions from my childhood bedroom, because I couldn't, for the life of me, imagine myself sleeping in the master bedroom. It’s not because I'm sentimental about keeping it as some sort of shrine (my parents would have hated that), but because sleeping where they both peacefully passed away in their sleep feels... well, let's just say, my therapist and I are working on it.
Besides, I love my attic bedroom. Being 5'6" as a man has few perks, but my favourite one is that I can navigate sloping ceilings without developing a permanent hump. As much as I loved the Hunchback of Notre-Dame as a kid, I do not want to become him.
The walls are still plastered with the same posters: the entire Star Wars saga (original trilogy prominently featured, because I am a purist, but I am also human and Obikin was one of my first shippings… I mean, who doesn’t like Ewan McGregor with braids?), a massive Middle Earth map above my bed that I used to trace with my fingers before falling asleep, and that slightly faded Aragorn poster that definitely contributed to my sexual awakening. Look, every gay nerd's journey starts somewhere, okay?
Madison is so different from what I remember, or maybe I'm the one who is different. I willingly traded the frantic energy of New York's theatre scene for a job as head editor for "Lakes Arts Quarterly". It’s less prestigious, maybe, but I can actually afford to eat something other than ramen now. Not to mention the housing situation: who would choose to spend thousands renting a NY studio, when they own a 1000 sq ft cottage, completely mortgage free, on the other side of the country? Plus, there's something nice about bumping into old schoolmates at the farmer's market or that coffee shop where I had my first job in junior high.
I have to admit time seems to move slower here, like the city's perpetually stuck on a Sunday afternoon mood. It’s taken me some time to adjust. Not having to commute for hours every day is a blessing, but then, one has to find productive things to do with all the extra time they’ve never had in their hands before. I finally have time to go to the gym, not that I am going as often as I should. Or at all.
Dating, though? That's a whole other language around here. You'd think being in touch with theatre people would make it easier, but apparently, I'm living proof that all the gay stereotypes can cancel each other out. Yes, I'm a theatre critic who likes fantasy and can quote entire episodes of Queer as folk, but somehow I'm still the odd one out in Madison's gay scene. Online dating feels about as appealing as getting a root canal while listening to Eminem, Grindr scares the shit out of me after a very rough encounter back in NY that I escaped from unscathed through the skin of my teeth, and most of the guys I meet through work are... well, let's just say there's only room for one drama queen in my life, and that position is already filled by yours truly.
At thirty-six, I'm starting to think I've aged out of the "adorkable" phase and straight into "eccentric cat gentleman" territory. Except I don't even have a cat. Not yet. Just me, lots of dust bunnies that roam free whenever I open my windows to let the air circulate, and an increasingly concerning interest in my neighbour's wood-chopping technique.
Speaking of which...
Look, I'm not proud of myself, okay? There are definitely more dignified ways to spend my Sunday mornings than perching on my window seat with a supposedly intellectual book I haven't turned a page of in thirty minutes, pretending I'm not completely mesmerised by the show next door. But dignity flew out the window (pun absolutely intended) the day I saw my new neighbour, code-name Broody Lumberjack.
The old neighbor, Mr. Durinsen, was what my mother diplomatically called "eccentric" and what the rest of the neighbourhood called "that smelly hoarder guy." The man collected everything: newspapers from the 1950s, rusty bike parts, empty milk jugs, you name it. His yard looked like a junkyard from that Disney post-apocalyptic movie, barring the cute big-eyed robot. I used to make up stories about treasure buried by a dragon under all that debris to make myself feel better about living next to what was essentially a tetanus factory.
So when I moved back three months ago and saw that the Durinsen property had been transformed into something that could actually pass for a normal house with healthily growing grass in the yard, I was relieved. Then I saw the new owner, and "relieved" turned into "lord have mercy on my gay soul”.
He's the living embodiment of every wet dream I nursed in high school: like the best mixture of Aragorn and Obi Wan, and Jared Leto (before he turned into a rock star slash cult leader), and that horse guy from The Mummy. Dark, thick hair that curls just past his shoulders when it isn't tied back in a messy bun, a beard that's just the right length between scruffy and unkempt, and eyes so deep blue they make me want to compare them to shades of flower petals, even if I can’t tell daisies from buttercups. And they are not just objectively big and beautiful, they are kind of eyes that look straight through you, like they're reading every secret you've ever kept.
And don't get me started with the rest of him. He's got the kind of body that makes you wonder if he moonlights as a fitness model when he isn't tinkering with the vintage Harley in his garage. I've caught glimpses of those abs when he's mowing the lawn in the summer heat, and let me tell you, counting to six has never been so difficult. His legs seem to go on forever in those worn jeans he always wears, and the way he carries himself, confident but not cocky, makes my knees weak.
And so here I am, watching him from behind my curtains like some lovesick teenager, wondering if the universe is playing an elaborate joke by placing this walking fantasy next door, completely out of reach. Because guys like him? They're never gay. They're the ones you pine over in high school, college, and apparently even in your thirties, but they never look your way. At least, not the way you want them to.
Still, a man can dream, right? Even if those dreams involve his ridiculously attractive, probably straight neighbour who seems to have an aversion to wearing shirts while doing yard work. Which apparently he’s a fan of. Seeing the immaculate state of his garden and how he seems to be running out of things to do, I’m half tempted to ask him if he’d fancy coming to do mine. My garden, I mean. There’s an awful amount of fallen leaves right now, and I can’t bring myself to rake them off before the first snow comes.
I swear I never intended to be a creep, spying him from behind closed windows. I tried to be neighbourly, I really did. Spent an entire evening baking an apple pie from scratch . That’s kind of my thing, the whole stress-baking situation. Usually, it's opening night reviews that have me up at 2 AM perfecting my lattice technique, but this time it was new-neighbour anxiety. There's something soothing about measuring ingredients precisely, working the butter into the flour with your fingers until it's just right, watching the filling bubble through the carefully woven crust in the oven. Plus, there were tons of apples from the old but apparently still feisty apple-tree in the backyard, and there’s only that much apple sauce one can eat with their breakfast porridge before feeling like a baby.
My mom hammered good manners in me, which included being on biannual home-cooked gift terms with your neighbours (gingerbread cookies in Christmas, something cooked with the garden produce in the summer), and my dad always said you could tell everything about a person by how they react to homemade pie. So, with those intentions in mind, and nothing else, I carried my pie over to the other side of the fence, still warm, with my best "welcome to the neighbourhood" smile, but Mr. Broody Lumberjack wasn't home. I had to leave it on his porch with a little note: "Welcome! From your next door neighbour: BB." Even threw in a little smiley face, because apparently, I temporarily lost all self-respect.
That pie sat there for two days. The local birds had better taste in pastries than I expected, as they had picked it clean by day two. The pie dish mysteriously appeared on my porch a week later, spotlessly clean. No note. No knock on the door. Just a silent return of property that made me feel like I was in some weird passive-aggressive kitchenware exchange program.
After that stellar failure at normal human interaction, I probably should have given up on any neighbour-related activities. Instead, I've developed what my best friend calls an "anthropological interest" in the daily routines of one Broody Lumberjack Whatever-His-Real-Name-Is (I tried to Google him, okay? I'm not proud of it, but I did. Turns out "hot lumberjack-looking guy in Madison" returns an alarming number of results, none of them helpful). I haven’t gathered the guts to go check his mailbox yet, because he has it just by the door, and what if he sees me spying?
Which brings us to my current surreptitiously spying situation. I mean, what's a gay man supposed to do when the universe plants a six-foot-five mountain of muscle right across the fence, who apparently believes shirts are optional during yard work, even though it’s October and we are in Wisconsin? I'm only human. A very gay, very single, very thirsty human.
Today's performance features a very fascinating firewood-chopping ritual that I have been following with rapture. You'd think someone who looks like they bench-press small cars for fun would have a mechanical log splitter, but no. Broody Lumberjack prefers the old-school approach, and honestly? Bless him for that. Because the way Broody Lumberjack handles that axe should be studied by scientists. All kinds.
First, he bends down – and yes, I'm absolutely taking detailed mental notes of how those jeans stretch across his thighs – positioning a log upright on the chopping block. His hands, god, those huge calloused hands, grip the axe handle firmly. Then comes the main event: he takes a wide stance, positioning his feet just so, shoulder-width apart, creating a stable base. The muscles of his shoulders bunch and flex as he raises the axe overhead, a perfect parabolic arc behind his head, potential energy building, and I swear I can see every individual muscle shifting under that sun-kissed skin. The way his obliques twist slightly with the movement? Poetry. Pure poetry.
The downswing is where I lose whatever is left of my sanity. It's like watching lightning strike. A perfect, graceful arc of contained power. His core tightens (and believe me, I've become something of an expert at spotting when those abs engage), his arms snap down, and then CRACK! The log splits clean in two, pieces falling to either side like they're eager to get out of his way. I’d see myself falling to pieces before him quicker than that.
It's not just brute force, no… though God knows he's got plenty of that. No, it's the way he uses the axe's weight and leverage to his advantage. The handle acts as a lever arm, multiplying the force of his already impressive muscles. He times the release perfectly, letting the weight of the axe head do most of the work. The blade strikes the exact same spot every time, right over the wood's grain line, with an accuracy that would make an engineer weep. The logs split with a satisfying crack that sends both halves flying in opposite directions, like some beautiful demonstration of Newton's Third Law.
Sometimes, if the wood's particularly stubborn, the axe gets stuck. That's when I have to bite my knuckle to keep from making embarrassing noises, because watching him wrestle with a stuck axe is like... imagine the sexiest tug-of-war competition ever, but it's just one gorgeous man versus an uncooperative piece of timber. He'll brace one boot against the log, muscles straining as he yanks the axe free, and I'll be here dying a little inside. La petite morte.
And as apparently the universe really wants to test my restraint, more often than not, he'll pause between logs to catch his breath, and do a little stretch and flex. His chest heaves in a most becoming way, those perfectly sculpted pectoral glistening with a fine sheen of sweat, the dense hair in the middle forming sweat-driven curlicues. His long black hair is doing that thing again, where a few strands escape the messy bun and stick to his neck with sweat. It's unfair how even his sweat is sexy. Meanwhile, I'm here in my ratty Star Wars pajamas at noon, probably looking like something the cat dragged in, threw up, and dragged back out again. I should probably get a cat, if only to make me up my joke game.
I sigh. I bite my lips. I adjust my reading glasses, which I definitely need for "reading" and not for getting a clearer view of those shoulders. Sweet mother of biceps, the way they bunch and flex with each swing of the axe should be illegal. Or at least come with a warning: Caution: May cause spontaneous gay combustion.
Those ice-blue eyes never look my way, thank god. He's always got this brooding expression, like he's contemplating deep philosophical truths while massacring innocent logs. Or maybe he's just constipated. Either way, it adds to the whole mysterious lumberjack aesthetic he's got going on, which is perfectly fine by me.
I should really introduce myself someday. That's what normal neighbors do, right? "Hi, I'm Bilbo, I've been watching you work out in your yard for three months and I've named your abs individually. Coffee sometime?"
Yeah, no. I'll stick to my creepy window seat and my unread books, thank you very much. Besides, guys who look like that are always straight. It's like some cosmic law designed specifically to torture gay men with good taste and bad luck.
Oh sweet Jesus, he's bending over again. You know what? I don't even care if this makes me a voyeur. Some sights deserve to be appreciated, and that ass in those work jeans is basically art. I'm not objectifying: I'm cultivating my aesthetic appreciation.
The crack of another log splitting jerks me out of my reverie. Broody Lumberjack is now wiping his forehead with his forearm, uncovering an unholy amount of moist pit hair, and I almost whimper. How does he make every single movement look like it should be on the cover of "Lumberjack Monthly: The Thirst Trap Edition”?
Maybe one day I'll grow a backbone and actually talk to him.
Maybe he'll turn out to be gay, single, and into slightly neurotic science fiction nerds who spy their neighbors.
Maybe pigs will fly and hell will freeze over.
Until then, I'll be here on my window, with my book, mentally writing sonnets about the way his back muscles ripple when he swings his axe.
It's pathetic, but hey, at least I'm self-deprecating about it.
And if anyone asks?
I'm just studying the physics of wood-chopping.
You know, for survival purposes.
In suburban America.
Completely legitimate.
