Actions

Work Header

The End of an Era

Summary:

What if Thorin actually threw Bilbo off the ramparts?
What if everyone survived the battle?

I'm here to answer those questions and maybe make you cry

TLDR: Thorin kills Bilbo, Thorin grieves, Thorin dies from old age.

Notes:

To my girlfriend: if you're reading this, no *bonk*

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Work Text:

This. This was the moment where everything changed. Thorin held Bilbo over the ramparts, his mind clouded with the gold sickness.

Gandalf watches the horror unfold from a distance, Thorin's glare so cold that even Gandalf freezes in place. The rest of the dwarves look on in horror, seeing that they were right about Thorin falling to the sickness. Ori and Nori begin to cry, Kili and Fili look sick as their Uncles grip tightens and Bilbo's feet leave the ground, dangling in the air.

Bilbos dirty and hairy feet kick at the air, his hands where Thorins was gripped to his coat.

"Thorin put me down! You are sick!"

Thorin sneers down at Bilbo, scoffing in disbelief.

"You are a fool, hobbit. I have never been more clear in my life."

He says as he grips tighter, Bilbo squirming uncomfortably in his tight grasp.

Bilbo just hung useless in the air, unable to free himself from Thorins grip.

Thorin growls down at Bilbo, shaking him by the collar.

"You think you could play me for a fool? Conspire against me?"

The company watches in horror, too frozen in fear to step forward.

Thorin's grip around Bilbo's collar tightens, pulling Bilbo up close to his face.

"You have no place in my company, burglar. And I assure you, you’re not wanted."

He spits the final word, then tosses Bilbo, sending the hobbit off the ramparts, to the sharp rocks below.

As Bilbo falls, the only thing he can think of is 'oh dear... This wasn't supposed to happen' before he hits the ground, a sickening crack echoing through the air.

Thorin and the dwarves look over the ledge with wide eyes, watching as Bilbo's battered body lands, blood pooling beneath it.

The dwarves look to Thorin, disbelief coloring their faces, looking to their king in terror as an uncomfortable silence fills the air. That is, until Gandalf's strangled voice rings out, shattering the silence.

"What have you done." He says, horror filling his usually gruff voice.

Later, after the Battle, when Thorin is no longer in the tight grip of gold sickness, he remembers what he had done. He kneels at the base of the ramparts, the cold and dead body of his One in his arms.

A sob escapes Thorin's throat as the realization of what he had done came crashing down on him. He holds the body of the hobbit close to him, tears falling from his eyes and landing in the hobbits hair.

"I’m sorry… I’m sorry…." He sobbed into the hobbit's hair, the words repeating over and over as if it would bring Bilbo back. If only he hadn’t let the lust for gold cloud his judgment, his hobbit would still be with him.

Bilbos eyes were open but unseeing, dried blood crusted in his hair and at his back. The fall crushed his spine, killing him immediately on impact.

Thorin holds Bilbo’s body to his chest, cradling it as if his hobbit was just sleeping. He closes his eyes, unable to look at the blank eyes staring back at him. Thorin buries his face in Bilbo’s hair, taking in his hobbit’s unique scent. He gently pats Bilbo’s curls, sobbing into them as he holds his One close to his heart, as if he would never be able to let go.

It is the worst crime among dwarves to hurt their One. A dwarf only has a single One, a person who was made from part of their own soul. And Thorin killed his.

Thorin could feel the weight of his sin upon his shoulders. It felt as if the very world was crashing down upon him. The knowledge that the One who he was tied to, the one who was made from his own soul, was now gone. Taken away by his own hands. He cried into Bilbo’s hair, shaking and trembling as he sobbed in grief.

He remembered Bilbo sitting on a bench at Beorns, weaving a flower crown before placing it gently on Thorins head. He remembered Bilbo visiting him in Thranduils dungeons, sneaking him extra scraps of food. He remembered their hug on the Carrock, the moment that made Thorin certain that Bilbo was his One.

The memories flood to the front of Thorin’s mind. The way Bilbo would look at him, as if looking to seek his approval. How the hobbit always listened to his words, following Thorin with a steadfast loyalty. The way Bilbo’s hair would stick up in the back, making Thorin want to reach out and run his fingers through it. The way the hobbit’s laugh was like music to his ears, lighting something within him every time he heard it.

The feeling of Bilbos fingers in his hair, braiding strands together. The feeling of his warm body against Thorins as they both slept. The feeling of Bilbos throat in his hands as he held him over the open air...

Thorin shudders as the last memory passes through his mind. He remembers the feeling of his fingers around Bilbo’s throat, the hobbit’s struggling against his iron grip. A sob escapes his throat once more as he holds Bilbo even tighter to his chest, crying into his hair, begging for forgiveness even though he knew it was too late. The knowledge of the hobbit being gone, even though his body was still there, was like a dagger to his heart.

Thorin’s head snaps up at the sound of footsteps approaching. He tightens his hold on Bilbo’s body out of reflex, turning his body to protect him before realizing who it was. At the sight of Dwalin, Thorin’s eyes widened, tears still streaming down his face as he holds Bilbo protectively to him.

Dwalin steps forward, looking at his king with sadness. He has never seen Thorin look so broken. The king, who always held a look of confidence, was now shattered, holding the lifeless body of the hobbit like a lifeline. Dwalin opens his mouth to speak, voice gruff and soft.

“Thorin…”

At the sound of his name from Dwalin, Thorin’s sobs started back up, shoulders shaking as he tried in vain to speak. He looks down at the broken body in his arms, shaking and trembling as he clings to his hobbit. After a few moments of struggling, Thorin finally looks back up at Dwalin, eyes filled with grief and tears.

“I-I… Dwalin…. It’s my fault… I… I did this…”

Dwalin approached Thorin, kneeling down in front of the king. The look on Thorin’s face was pure anguish and grief, making Dwalin’s heart ache. He gently placed a hand on Thorin’s shoulder, not caring that the king probably didn’t want to be seen in such a state.

“Thorin, it’s not your fault. The sickness…”

Thorin shakes his head, denying Dwalin’s words. He clings to Bilbo’s body, holding him as if his hobbit could disappear at any second. He was still struggling to speak, each word coming through in a broken, shaking voice.

“N-no… No no, it is my fault… I-I killed him, Dwalin… I killed m-my One…”

Dwalin is shocked by the revelation, his eyes wide. He knew how sacred One’s were for dwarves, knowing the pain and anguish you would feel if you lose them. To learn that Thorin’s One was the Hobbit… no wonder Thorin was reacting such a way.

“I-I didn’t know he was…” Dwalin trails off, not knowing what to say. Thorin is his king, who was now holding the lifeless body of his One in his arms. It was a devastating sight to behold.

Thorin let out a heartbroken wail, one that every dwarf knew came from someone who had lost their One.

At the sound of Thorin’s wail, the dwarves go deathly quiet, looking with wide eyes on as their king cries over the small body. All the dwarves knew what that mournful cry meant, a cry only a dwarf who had lost their One could make. It was a sound that would cut straight to the soul, the pain so immense that only someone who lost a One could make it.

The dwarves watched silently, some with tears in their eyes, as Thorin clutched the dead hobbit to his chest, shaking and weeping. Thorin’s pain was something all the dwarves could understand, the grief over losing one’s One something no dwarf could ever overcome. The knowledge that your one person in the world, the person who was made from your soul, was now dead must be like a dagger through the heart for the King.

Thorin was reluctant to get up, not wanting to let go of Bilbo. But he knew that his hobbit deserved a proper burial, and the least he could do was give him that. With great hesitation, Thorin carefully lowers the body to the ground, laying it down gently so as not to injure it further. He slowly stands up, his limbs still trembling, and looks down at the lifeless form of his One.

A few days later Bilbo is buried, and next to the grave Thorin planted the acorn that Bilbo had gotten from Beorns garden.

Thorin stands over Bilbo's grave, tears still flowing from his eyes. The company stood a distance away, each looking just as saddened as their king. It has been days since Bilbo passed, and Thorin has been silent throughout the burial. He stands over the grave, feeling hollow inside as he plants the acorn from Beorn's garden. It seems like a small comfort, but Thorin's heart aches as he pats the soil down around the acorn.

As time went on, the oak tree grew tall, becoming stronger and more beautiful each day. The tree provided shade for the grave of the hobbit, Thorin making sure the spot was always clean and free of weeds. As Thorin advanced in age, he often spent his days sitting under the shade of the oak tree, sometimes talking to Bilbo, hoping his One could hear him from beyond the grave. As Thorin lays on his deathbed, he asks to be buried next to Bilbo, so that he can be reunited with his One at last.

Notes:

I'm not sorry