Work Text:
Lake Town was a dull place, with damp and mould clinging to most homes, the board walks creaking under the weight of men and threatening to splinter and break at any given moment. But inside Bard’s home, there was a certain level of comfort that Bilbo couldn’t describe.
It wasn’t the comfort of the Shire, with its rolling green hills and constant flora aroma, and it certainly wasn’t Bag-End, with its crackling fire and sturdy wooden beams. No, this comfort seemed to come from the little things, perhaps the barrels that were stocked around, holding books and dirtied clothes in them, or the nets hung over the ceiling, sturdy enough to hold up lanterns that would be hung up on a nighttime when food was being prepared. Perhaps, what made Bard’s home so comforting, was the people who inhabited it.
”So, each of you have a specific craft that help on the quest?” Bard asked curiously, Balin nodding his head with a small smile.
”Yes laddie, though some Dwarrow were taken on the quest for their skills in battle too.” He explained, gesturing to a few members, such as Fíli and Glóin. Bard nodded his head at his explanation, brows furrowing ever so slightly.
”And, you are a thief correct? Specialise in sneaking around and finding things.” The Bowman pointed to Nori, who nodded his head with a hint of pride as Dori rolled his eyes in exasperation. “Right, and master Baggins, you were brought on the quest to steal the Arkenstone from Smaug?” He asked Bilbo, who perked up at being addressed to, before nodding his head. “Right. . But, why bring an inexperienced thief to steal from a dragon, when you already have an experienced member of your kin?” Bard asked the company- aside from Kíli who was having his wound checked over by Óin.
Bilbo felt his brows furrow, a thought he hadn’t ever considered this entire time: why bring him? Nori was fair more skilled than he was, and he was closer to the company on a whole, so he already had their trust and respect.
”Bard has a point.” The Hobbit spoke up, straightening his back from where he was sat. “Why bring me to steal from Smaug when Nori is more capable?” He asked the company, noticing how Óin paused in his movements, sharing an awkward glance with Kíli. Bilbo huffed, looking around the company, and noticing how they all seemed stiff and awkward, especially Thorin, who adamantly avoided looking at Bilbo.
A moment of awkward silence passed over the company, until Bard’s brows became less furrowed, slowly raising his head. “Oh, I see. .” He murmured, glancing hesitantly at Bilbo, who stared back at him, silently willing him for an answer, sharply raising one eyebrow when the man fumbled for a moment before sighing. “Master Nori is their kin, Master Baggins, it would. . . It would be easier to send someone who isn’t kin into Smaug’s lair.” He explained, pointedly ignoring Thorin’s glare when he referred to Erebor’s treasury as ‘Smaug’s Lair’.
The two stared at one another for a moment, until Bilbo’s eyes widened slightly in recognition, his eyes darting to the Dwarrow in the room as they stared at the floorboards awkwardly.
Bilbo slowly stood up from where he was sat, his mug of water abandoned on the windowsill as his mind went through all the events leading up to Lake Town.
The incident with the trolls, what Bilbo originally thought to have been a test of his strength and courage- were they actually testing to see how long he would last against Smaug?
The goblin caves, when Bofur had called him a ‘member of the company’ was he only saying that to try and persuade Bilbo to stay so they could sacrifice him?
The Elves, and Beorn, were they actually worried he would want to stay with them and leave their quest, or were they worried he would walk away and escape being dragon bait?
His eyes landed on Thorin, the two staring at one another for an unprecedented amount of time. Had the glances they shared with one another, the soft smiles at night times, the hug on the Carrock, had all those precious moments been a ruse to manipulate him into staying?
Blue eyes snapped away from green, and Bilbo steeled himself as he nodded his head. That silly little fluttering he got in his heart whenever he was around Thorin was now replaced with a heavy feeling that seemingly drained him of his energy.
”Look, laddie, I won’t be the first to try and deny it, but there wasn’t much consideration for your well-being when we first met.” Balin spoke up, snapping Bilbo’s gaze away from Thorin. “But that changed, we saw you as more than some silly Hobbit who knew nothing about the outside world, we saw you as a member of our company, some of us going as far as seeing you as family.” The elder Dwarf explained, his voice edging on desperation as Bilbo stared at him for a moment longer.
”You need not lie, none of you need to.” He replied, gesturing to the company. “I’ll continue this bloody quest- but only because of the contract I signed- but I will not look at you, or speak to you as friends or family.” He pointed at them as a collective, ignoring the look of hurt that fell over Ori’s face, and the way Thorin’s brows furrowed as his eyes widened in that same way they do when he felt helpless.
“Bilbo-“ Bofur spoke up, brushing Bombur’s hand off of his shoulder.
“-I will not hear it, master Bofur.” The Hobbit cut him off, his heart beating erratically in his chest. “You were so willing to sacrifice me to save your own, that you didn’t consider my kin, the family I have, when you chose to use me as some pack mule for a dragon!” He sliced his hand through the air harshly, sucking in a deep breath in a feeble attempt to compose himself.
Bard glanced between him and the group, noting the look of utter heartbreak on the Dwarven king’s face as he stared unyieldingly at the Hobbit before him.
”Perhaps. .” The Bowman thought to himself as the Hobbit stormed out from his house, Thorin calling out for him as he followed. “Things might’ve gone slightly better in another world.”
