Work Text:
Ereinion Gil-galad was technically the current head of the Valar Project, though there were whispers of a higher, secretive council that were the real leaders of all the different hero systems across the globe. Elrond didn't care if Manwë himself stepped out of the annals of history and into the lone conference room left intact in their headquarters at Tirion. Elrond was going to make sure everything was done to get Erestor back and woe betide anyone who got in his way.
“The Formenos Project was destroyed an Age ago!” Someone was yelling at the back of the room. It might have been Fingon, one of the oldest heroes in the Valar Project. Fingon was also, Elrond remembered, rumored to have been sweet on one of those heroes, one Maedhros Fëanorson. But there had been bad blood between Fingon's father Fingolfin who had run the Valar Project then, and Fëanor Finwëson, though what exactly that problem had been, no one knew.
“Why did Sauron call out Caranthir?” Gil-galad was the one to ask, this time to Elrond.
Elrond frowned, staring down at the table. “I do not know.”
“But Sauron seemed to think that Caranthir would come for Erestor,” Gil-galad pressed. “Why?”
“I don't know.”
“Elrond.”
“Erestor is an orphan,” Elrond looked up at Gil-galad. “He grew up in Mithlond and went to school there. That's where we met. His last name is Brothers, given to him by the caretakers at the orphanage. I have no idea why this Sauron would think that Caranthir – if he's even still alive – would come for Erestor. It makes no sense.”
“But are we sure this Brothers is a real – hey!”
Elrond looked over in time to see some no-named lackey cowering away from a glowering Glorfindel. Ecthelion was a tall shadow at his side.
“Erestor has passed every background check that the Valar Project has ever put together,” Bilbo was the one to speak into that silence. “Special Agent Oakenshield has implemented rigorous bi-annual spot checks for the last five years. No one in our facilities has been spared them. If there was anything dangerous or suspect in Erestor's present or past I am fully confident Special Agent Oakenshield would have found it.”
Elrond noted the way Thorin all but puffed up with pride at Bilbo's pride. Elrond also knew that Bilbo himself had hated those bi-annual spot checks and the utterly paranoid battery of background checks Thorin had implemented ever since the nano-bot terror of Smaug the Golden had almost taken down the Valar Project six years before. It had been Bilbo himself who had saved them all from that calamity and was also the reason why Bilbo had to be taken off regular hero duty and was now in charge of the research departments.
“What do we know about the Formenos Project's destruction?” Gil-galad directed his gaze to the researchers in the room but Elrond was the one to answer him.
“The Formenos Project was attacked by Ungoliant,” Elrond saw the heroes in the room all exchange glances. Ungoliant the most powerful villain of all time, one still feared to present day. No one knew if she still lived though some speculated that she had consumed herself in her insatiable desires, but no one knew for sure. “What we know is that Ungoliant attacked the main base of the Formenos Project with Morgoth and together they created such destruction that to this day no one has been able to verify if any of the buildings even remain.”
“Morgoth,” Lúthien was the one to mutter the villain's name with a grimace. Her own husband Beren had been killed by him during a rescue attempt gone wrong by the two of them. Elrond had read that particular file – redacted as it was – and had some suspicions of his own on what just had happened in Morgoth's lair all those years ago.
“But the first Valar heroes killed Morgoth,” Elanor – Nori – Brandyfoot, one of Bilbo's many cousins, leaned forward to look down the table at everyone.
“They locked him away beyond the Door of Night seal, but that was after Morgoth and Ungoliant had laid waste to the Formenos Project,” Elrond said. “But the damage was done.” He glanced over to Fingon, who had his arms wrapped about his middle and was staring down at the table. “There have been several attempts to do recon at the base but all our sensors and drones have disappeared. It is speculated that Ungoliant created a kind of singularity in the region, though why that singularity hasn't consumed all of Arda I do not know. No one knows for sure why all of our instruments disappear when we attempt to survey the remains.”
“So it's possible that this Caranthir still exists,” Gil-galad said.
Elrond gave a small shrug. “Perhaps, but does it really matter?” He ignored the stir from the rest of the room and met Gil-galad stare for stare. “Erestor is in Mordor. We know he's in Mordor. I think all this nonsense about Caranthir is a ruse. A red herring for us to chase after when instead we should be concentrating on getting Erestor back as soon as possible.”
“Why?'
Elrond drew in a slow breath. “Because Erestor is one of the most senior researchers in the Valar Project, aside from myself. He knows the strengths and weaknesses of all our teams. That's why I think Sauron took him. Not for this Caranthir or anyone else in the Formenos Project. But because Erestor is the key to knowing all of our systems.”
“Dwalin,” Thorin spoke before anyone else could. “Initiate the Trollshaws Protocol.”
“What is –”
“It is a full password reset,” Bilbo spoke over the rising questions in the room. “And you're right, Elrond. Erestor is one of our best researchers. He had just come back from the Imladris Library with files on Sauron and the Nazgûl.”
“Suspicious timing,” Thorin said with a glance at Bilbo.
“I agree,” Bilbo nodded. “So there is probably something in those files Sauron doesn't want us to look at too closely. It could be that it was pure chance that Erestor was taken. It could have been anyone in that elevator would have been taken and all of this Caranthir nonsense is just a ruse, like Elrond said. Sauron has demonstrated severe lack of judgment in the past when it comes to things that he has obsessed over,” they all winced at the words. Well did they know that. The Galadriel Incident was something none of them wanted to think about.
“But Oakenshield just changed the passwords, so does it matter if this Brothers blabs to Sauron? He's a liability at this point. Sauron has to know the general stats on our heroes, it's not like they're a secret,” someone said from the back of the room. “Risking our heroes on someone who is probably dead the minute they open their mouth seems like a waste of resources.”
Elrond bristled but Bilbo held up a hand before he could say anything. “Erestor is a gifted member of the Valar Project. Would you have us discard you in the same way?”
“What? No! It's just –”
“It's just that you have been coveting Erestor's position for a decade, Penlod,” Bilbo spoke over the elf's sputtering. “Don't think I haven't noticed it.”
“But I –”
“We do not leave our people behind,” Glorfindel spoke over the rising voices in the room. All eyes turned to him. “I – we – will not leave Erestor to Sauron's dubious mercies. We will be getting him back.” Several of the heroes about him nodded in agreement.
“That's good to hear,” a voice Elrond did not recognize came from the door. The crowd parted to reveal an elf dressed in all black, his dark hair pulled back into a severe tail, dark brows drawn together in a scowl. He looked, Elrond noted in the back of his mind, much like Erestor did in his worst tempers.
Gil-galad stood, hands planted on the table. “Who are you and how did you get in here?”
“Haven't you heard?” The elf tilted his head to one side. He did not smile. “Sauron called me out. I am Caranthir, son of Fëanor, of the Formenos Project.” He ignored the way Fingon lurched to his feet, staring at him. “And I am here for my son.”
