Work Text:
The storm outside the Baggins’ Estate raged on with the same intensity as it had hours ago, the lightning briefly outshining the dim candles of the mansion as it flashed through the windows.
Bilbo was curled into his favorite armchair, an open book resting on his knees. He hadn’t paid attention to the title when he picked it up, and he hadn’t retained one word from the pages he’d been mindlessly flipping through for hours.
He’d been much too consumed with looking across the room.
On the opposite wall, a man was sitting at a desk, carefully marking the notes for a new piece he would practice on his harp later that night. The music would haunt the halls of the mansion for hours, seeming to taunt Bilbo.
The man had dark hair, the same shade as his husband’s. His eyes were as shockingly bright. He even responded to the same name.
Thorin.
That… thing , however. That was not his husband, there was no room for doubt in his mind.
In the present, the fake leaned back until there was a crack. Bilbo’s skin crawled at the sound.
He knew it wasn’t his husband the moment the creature walked into the sitting room those few nights ago. It’s heavy leather boots were covered in the slimy, weedy mud that could only come from a lake. ‘ His ’ tunic and pants were waterlogged, but carried the heavy smell of musty earth that no storm could recreate. The strangest thing, however, was the thing’s skin. It was clean; not a speck of muck in sight. If his beard and hair was dryer, one could have glanced through a window, and assumed he had just come from the drawing room, rather than…
He’d walked his way over to Bilbo, leaving muddy prints and water drips behind him, and bowed his head apologetically.
“My treasure,” he’d started, arms folded behind his back. “I am immensely sorry for the words I said to you, and moreover, for raising my voice. It is most unbecoming of a husband, and I deeply apologize. I hope you can find it in your heart to forgive a foolish man.”
And that was all he'd said. He’d walked out after that. Bilbo had been shocked still, and had halfway convinced himself it was a dream. But the muddy prints and stench remained.
Bilbo realized, right then.
He had just spoken to something Other, and it sought after his immortal soul.
Later, much, much later, he'd crept into their room to find the imposter’s sullied clothes in their hamper. They laid on top of the outfit Bilbo had worn out on their late-afternoon excursion, and the combined force of lakemudfilth had his stomach curdling. He felt lightheaded as he lowered the hamper’s lid shut, quiet as a mouse, and glances at the creature wearing husband's face.
He slept fitfully in the study that night, curled up tight underneath his desk, a heavy paperweight gripped between two cold, shaking hands.
The Baggins' had never seen the need for a large staff, only hiring a few helpers here and there and perhaps a local gardener in the springtime, but when Thorin had first step foot into the manner those handful of months ago, he’d immediately written to have some of his previous help moved to the estate.
“My dear, they’re practically my family’, Thorin had claimed, “you wouldn’t separate family, would you?”
In the rosy haze of honeymoon-love, and perhaps more importantly, in the blue haze of recent grief, Bilbo had agreed. With his parents sudden deaths (one right after the other, poor dears), the more people to fill the void of their departure the better. Besides, he’d naively told himself at the time, with his husband to bring his two nephews to live with them, it would be good for the boys to have familiar faces.
Now, all it meant was that there was no one to put between himself and the other; Thorin had laid off the staff the moment his letter had been sent off for delivery.
In the before-times, Bilbo and his husband could go days without running into each other; their record sat at one week and six hours. Now, though, it seemed his husband seemed to gravitate towards wherever he was.
They didn’t talk every time they ran into each other. Most encounters involved Bilbo walking by Thorin in a corridor, meeting the sharp, white smile with one of his own… although his was more off-eggshell and shaky.
It seemed to Bilbo that Thorin was trying to tell him something; ‘I’m here. I never left. I’m here and I’m watching you.’
He swore he could see Thorin out of the corner of his eye. Sometimes, he'd be alone in the library, or his study, or gazing out a window, and he'd see something move, just in the outer edges his peripheral vision; a shuffling figure, something peeking around corners, and sometimes he swore he could hear breathing just behind him.
But when he looked head on?
He was alone.
Bilbo half expected some sort of confrontation, but Thorin appeared to have gained a maturity that would have taken most men years to achieve seemingly overnight. There were no more screaming matches, or razor sharp comments, or the sort of maniacal rants about apparent enemies of the estate that had Bilbo sleeping rough for nights after. Now, in their place, were respectable conversations about how to run the estate and investments that should be made, and more idle chatter than their entire length of marriage combined.
Bilbo’s head was constantly spinning with fear. He knew he should be punished, but this was downright cruel and unusual. He'd lived a good life up to this point; shouldn't that have gained him some form of karma?
But, perhaps, karma only worked its magic for those who could still be helped.
And he knew he was a lost cause.
It came to a head a full week later, at dinner.
They were eating Bilbo’s favorite- apparently Thorin had dug around and found Bungo Baggins' cookbooks and requested Bilbo try his hand at making something.
“I’d love to try something from your childhood,” Thorin had said while he shoved the book into Bilbo’s hands.
Before, Bilbo imagined his husband would have scoffed at the simple meal; now, all he could focus on was the sounds of food being gleefully consumed. Wet smacks of lips; the rough grind of teeth; the unavoidable sound of a throat constricting with each swallow.
Bilbo stared at his own plate. He had only managed a few bites, and even those were a battle with his own body. His throat seemed to close up every time he tried to force the food down, sticking to the back of his tongue. It almost blocked his airway. It was a strange feeling; he knew air was there, somewhere, but is body wouldn't take it in. Maybe this is what-
“Where is he, then?” Thorin interrupted his spiral abruptly, his voice precise. The sound of his voice sunk into the dead space of the room; it took Bilbo a moment to recognize that Thorin had actually spoken and it wasn't a figment of his imagination.
“Pardon?” Bilbo choked out, a bit of food catching in the back of his throat. “I’m not sure… I’m not quite sure what you’re talking about.”
Thorin laughed. It was deep and low; Bilbo swore it was burrowing itself into the depths of his mind, begging to be torn apart and analyzed over and over and over. Was there always that little airy hitch in the middle, or that stony rumble as it trailed off? Had he heard the real Thorin's laugh enough to properly discern between the two?
He finally turned from his plate to meet his husband’s eyes, and felt ice spread through his chest.
He knew.
Bilbo met those eyes and just knew without a shadow of doubt that Thorin knew that he knew. There was a sparkle in them; amused, almost, like the look a cat gives a trapped mouse. He didn’t let his distress show outwardly, but a drip of ice made its way down his spine. It contrasted nicely against the hot bile rising in his throat.
"I'm sorry, my dear." Bilbo stood up quickly, and his knees knocked into the table hard enough to rattle the candles sitting in the middle of the table. "I do not feel well. I think I need to lay down."
It wasn't quite a lie. he did feel as if his stomach as about to invert itself. He stumbled across the room on colt-weak legs and jerked away frantically when Thorin tried to grasp at his wrist as he passed.
"Let me help you to bed," Thorin said, brow furrowed and eyes filled with worry. Why was it still pretending? They both knew what it was. What he was.
"No, no, I can make it myself just as well, stay and finish dinner." Bilbo tried to walk calmly and with purpose, but he heard Thorin's chair scrape against the floorboards and all of the sudden he's running full speed towards the manor's entrance, instincts taking over. He reached it seconds before he heard Thorin calling for him, and he threw the front door open just as the pursuing man runs around the corner; he left the door open as he dashed off into the night.
He couldn't quite make out which direction he was running, but the darkness that was clawing at him from all sides like the beasts of his nightmares kept his legs moving faster than his mind could keep up with.
All he knew is he needed to move. He ran and ran and ran -
-and he almost ran straight into the lake. Unfortunately he was only left standing on the edge, the wet, icy mud finally seeping through his shoes and freezing him to the core. That damned lake. That damned lake, with its damned dock to the right of him. He glanced at the unholy ground and the blood rushes from his face.
A small rowboat, not large enough to carry a company but perfect for a duo, was left abandoned next to the dilapidated structure, pulled up to the bank gracelessly.
He smelt the basket before he spotted it tipped over under the seat of the boat. The stench of rot and decay penetrated the air like a candle in a darkened room.
His head throbbed. It seemed even blind, he was driven to the lake; his heart knew what he needed to do.
...He hadn’t known the rain would come so soon, he hadn’t . The sky had been overcast, sure, but he’d only wanted to enjoy the clean air for just a moment, just a minute, just a second longer. He and Thorin hadn’t exchanged a single word the whole trip, and though Thorin wasn't exactly thrilled to be rowing them around the lake, he hadn’t complained once. They’d simply shared in a silence that seemed to push the grey sky out of his mind, the bright sun of hope peaking through the silvered edges of the clouds. The blessed silence that seemed to finally calm his eternally frazzled nerves…
Then he'd felt a raindrop on his nose.
Thorin had been well past furious about getting caught in the storm, so enraged that when they'd managed to pull themselves up onto the dock, he’d begin to scream.
Oh, how he screamed .
Thorin had screamed and screamed and screamed- and Bilbo had just stood there, frozen.
Thorin had been pacing back and forth, every so often making a short lunge towards Bilbo but reining himself back at the last second; Thorin was moved closer, and closer, and just as Bilbo began to wonder what would happen when he finally reached him, Thorin slammed his heavy boot down onto the old, worn dock…
…and suddenly, Bilbo had been all alone, the last words Thorin spoke echoing across the lake, loud enough to be heard crystal clear over the pouring rain.
The air in his throat caught.
The memories washed over him and that same fear froze his bones once again as he heard the dull thump of boots getting closer.
He felt beads of sweat beginning to form on his brow. He tried move, to force his legs to run, he would not be a sacrifice, he would not he a victim-!
But no one chooses to be a victim, and Bilbo Baggins did not move, and the footsteps were getting louder.
All Bilbo could do was feel every approaching step in his chest, a kick to the ribs and a squeeze of his panicked heart with every slap against wet grass and snap of twigs, until finally a hand landed on his shoulder, forcefully turning him around.
Turning him from the lake.
“Get away from me!” He screeched, suddenly invigorated with an energy that seemed almost manic. His arms suddenly thawed and he was scratching at the imposter’s face. But Thorin only furrowed his brow and caught his wrists in an iron grip.
“Bilbo, you’re not well, we need to-“
“No!” Bilbo broke through the restraint and threw himself back, now landing ankle deep in lake muck. “I know what you are- I know what you want!”
Thorin didn’t look surprised at his accusation. He only raised his hands in a placating manner and knelt down onto the ground.
“Bilbo,” he started. “My love, my treasure… ”
Bilbo only laughed wetly- when had he been begun to cry?
“He called me that too, you know? But I know… I know-!” He couldn’t continue, the words refusing to pass his lips, instead clogging his throat and burning his eyes.
He sobbed. He collapsed and cried with air he didn’t have and wished he was dead.
“Bilbo,” the voice was strained, and Bilbo closed his eyes so he couldn’t see his damnation staring back at him.
“Please,” he sobbed, fists beating on his thighs. “Leave me alone.”
“Can you not trust your husband?” Thorin was begging- he’s never begged, why was he begging- as he now gripped Bilbo’s arms in his unforgivingly gentle hands.
Bilbo shook his head and tried to wiggle out of the hold but it only tightened in response, and he was pulled to a solid chest. It was warm and comforting in ways it never should have been, never was, and it scared him terribly.
“Yes you can!” There was no room for argument by the tone of Thorin’s voice, but Bilbo knew there was always space to disagree.
Bilbo sobbed roughly, his throat burning as it struggled to hold back the stomach acid threatening to paint the front of his shirt.
He should feel guilty. He should be throwing himself from the tallest tower of the estate for what he did. He should be completely and irreversibly devastated .
But he wasn’t.
He wasn’t , and that was the worst thing of them all.
It was strange. His feelings were mixed together in one big tumble of emotion, yet he could pinpoint that fact as clearly as he could do arithmetic. He didn’t feel a tad bit bad. He would have done it a hundred times over if he had to.
Was that what the gods wanted? To show him the life he could have had, only to have him throw it to the same fate as his old one?
Thorin brought their foreheads together, and the tears ran thicker than ever.
“Where is he, treasure?” the raven-haired tempter whispered. Bilbo opened his eyes and their gazes met. Bilbo felt like a butterfly pinned in a case. The admittance of inhumanity should have terrorized him, the proof that his paranoia had merit, but all Bilbo felt was a strange mix of frenzied fear and all-encompassing exhaustion.
His husbands eyes were still blue, he realized, and the inconsequential nature of it sent him spiraling.
Blue.
A shockingly familiar, and yet now an unnaturally bright, blue.
Bilbo tried to take a deep breath, but he only managed to shake his head once again before choking, his panic picking his heart and lungs apart into a million bits.
“I can’t,” he choked, the words coming out confused and thick and tired on his swollen tongue. He closed his eyes in an act of defiance. “I won’t.”
“Yes, yes you can, you must,” Thorin urged. He took Bilbo’s face into his hands and the heat of the thumbs on the curve of his cheeks only added to the nauseating warmth swirling in the pit of his stomach.
What was the point in hiding it anymore? He was already hell-bound. What was the hurt in telling the devil his sins?
He cracked his eyes open a bit and looked into blue, blue, blue .
Bilbo pointed towards deeper into the lake with a single shaky finger.
“There.”
He’d heard the struggle.
The ugly, sickening struggle.
Drowning is much quieter than the stories made it seem. There was very little splashing, almost no kicking, and not a single scream for help. The choking, cut-short breath of a sinking man being dragged down by layers and layers and layers of rich material was all that reached his ears.
He heard that crackling gasp, each bubble of precious air popping on the surface on the pond.
He could have helped; jumped into the freezing depths and tried to release his husband from his waterlogged chains.
In the end, what had he done?
He’d stood there. He stood there, letting the rain further soak him, starring at the space his tormentor had once made up. As he stared at the rippling water, he imagined he could see two blue eyes straining up at him, begging for forgiveness.
He hadn’t moved from that dock for a long, long time.
But, eventually, he’d pulled the boat up to the shore with shaky hands, not bothering to tie it down before dragging himself back to the mansion.
He’d ignored the mud he’d dragged in, somehow managing to get himself to the washroom without collapsing. He’d stuffed his clothes into the very bottom of the hamper, and sunk himself neck deep into a hot bath. He’d spent hours staring into dead space, numb and mute, brain full of an overwhelming static that drowned out any thought that tried to form.
He knew he’d have to face it eventually.
He knew, sooner rather than later, a bloated, discolored body would appear face-down the lake, nails and lips tinged blue with betrayal.
He knew that.
However, he found that, deep down in his blackened heart, he just didn’t give one single damn .
Bilbo Baggins-Oakenshield and Thorin Baggins-Oakensheild lived together in the Baggins Estate, and they had a very nice daily routine, now.
Every morning, they woke up together, legs and hands tangled, and Bilbo helped braid Thorin’s hair- which was healthier and thicker than it had been. At least, until their trip to the lake.
“Perhaps all that mud was good for it,” Thorin said once, a twinkle in his eye, and Bilbo had laughed for the first time in what felt like an age.
Then, Thorin and Bilbo picked out outfits for each other, and they’d go about their duties. They’d meet while they walked from here to there and back, and they’d eat meals with each other while discussing this and that, and sometimes go to the markets and shops to pick up bits and bobs, as they didn’t have a staff who could do it for them, yet.
Finally, at night, Bilbo would pick a book out, and Thorin would make sure to tie the curtains next to their bed closed extra tight; the window overlooked the estates lake. Then he too would retire, sometimes bringing papers to look over, and other times laying his head on Bilbo's lap and let the man read to him until they both fell asleep.
All in all, they acted as a newly married couple should act; happy and in love and relaxed. And they acted this way because they were happy and in love and relaxed, even if they technically weren’t newly married.
One day, Bilbo had the sense, or perhaps boldness was a better word for it, to ask his beloved,
“What are you?” He reached across the book sprawled in his lap to cup Thorin’s cheek, and had looked deep into the icy eyes that had a hold on his soul. “What have you become?”
Thorin paused in his writing, and seemed to consider Bilbo thoroughly as he spoke.
“I’ve not become anything, treasure. I am as I was the day I came into the world. The other… the rest does not matter. It is in the past, and the past is over with,” the bigger man said vaguely, returning to his papers that sat sprawled on the bed-sheets.
Bilbo paused, thinking over his words before speaking again.
“I’m glad you came.” He turned his head to stare at the candle beside the bed, tracing the fire as it danced the shadows away. The words were choked out, like they’d been struck out by a blunt object. “Its rotten of me, to be fully honest, but it makes me… so, so much happier than it should that you are here instead of…”
Again, there was a break in the shuffle of papers, and he jumped as a thick arm wrapped around his waist. Thorin pulled him close to his side, and rested his head on top of Bilbo’s. A broad hand rubbed comfortingly at his back and, for some reason he couldn’t place, Bilbo had the urge to cry.
He did not, in fact, cry, but the urge sat behind his eyes in a near painful pressure.
“Nothing about you could ever be rotten, my dear. It was him.”
“Are you sure about that?” Bilbo shot back with a touch of appropriately cynical laughter.
Thorin didn’t share his mirth. He pulled back until their eyes could meet, mouth set in a grimace that looked painful, an expression that was too familiar for comfort.
“Did he not hurt you? Did he not make your every day a living hell?” With every question, the larger man shook his shoulders lightly, but it felt like the force of a mountain was rocking his bones. “Did you not hate him?”
“He could have changed,” Bilbo spit out. In that brief moment, a rage he’d never felt over came him, but he only had the venom of a saline solution to dip his words in. Almost instantly, the fire of anger blew out and he was left empty.
“Oh, my treasure, it’s not a question of if he could,” Thorin said, eyes hooded and sweet, “it’s a question of whether or not he would .”
Bilbo felt like he’d been slapped, but by who or what he couldn’t tell. He shook his head mutely, and paid no attention to the hot slide of tears running down his cheeks. The drops ran over his trembling lips, salty and sticky. The air was suddenly too thin and all encompassing, everywhere and nowhere at all.
Thorin was breathing easy. His eyes were sparkling, his lips quirking up. He leaned in close into Bilbo’s space, an almost childish energy overtaking him.
“Do you know why I chose him?” He said it like he was sharing a secret, which Bilbo figured he was. He shook his head, and was rewarded by a chuckle. Those blue eyes were still sickly sweet.
“He was a sickness . Nothing but a pollution, something that exists only for eradication.” Thorin’s dark language didn’t match his tone. It was overbearing, with so much love packed into each word it made Bilbo’s heart jackrabbit against his ribs. The man brought his other hand up to Bilbo’s chin and tilted his head up, and the small man couldn’t help but smile as he saw the adoration in Thorin’s demeanor. The taller pressed their foreheads together, declaring, “He was lower than the scum that is scrapped off of our boots. I was simply doing the world a favor.”
It was quiet for a long while after that. Bilbo let himself be rocked like a child being comforted after a nightmare, complete with Thorin humming a long forgotten lullaby in his ear. The tune was warbling and deep, like nothing Bilbo had ever heard, and later he’d wonder how a human could even accomplish those sounds. In the moment, the sound was more felt than heard, and he was grateful for it.
Bilbo felt odd. He felt like a toy that had been left behind in the rain, heavy and lost and so, so confused. An unfamiliar, invisible hand was suddenly gripping his jaw in an unrelenting grip, forcing his lips to move around the words his brain couldn’t find the will to say.
“Is he dead?”
A laugh. It wasn’t a mean laugh, but it wasn’t exactly kind, either.
“That depends; how would you define death?” Thorin’s eyes were gleaming, a strange spark contrasting the ink-black words sliding off his tongue. He kisses Bilbo’s forehead, and then his nose, and finally the corner of his lip. “Now, get some sleep. The rest arrive tomorrow.”
Bilbo lay limply in Thorin’s arms, and realized his husband was right. The Durin staff was supposed to arrive in the morning, along with Thorin’s nephews. It had taken months to get affairs settled, and while the first few dragged on like years, it seemed like this last one had flown over his head. He took a momentary pause, digesting everything.
He could ask what Thorin meant by “the rest” .
He could ask Thorin what he defined death as.
He could ask Thorin many, many things.
But, he didn’t. Bilbo looked into those bright, bright blue eyes, and nodded, just a tad, before snuggling close. He felt Thorin smile into his hair, and decided there were some things that were best left alone.
