Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Category:
Fandom:
Relationship:
Characters:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Series:
Part 1 of WhatIf AU Bingo, Part 1 of The Inspector Durin Mysteries
Collections:
What If? AU Bingo
Stats:
Published:
2024-05-26
Completed:
2024-06-29
Words:
3,173
Chapters:
6/6
Kudos:
26
Hits:
0

The Body in the Physic Garden

Summary:

The latest, eagerly awaited, series of The Inspector Durin Mysteries> a weekly radio drama, featuring Inspector Thorin Durin of Scotland Yard and Mr Bilbo Baggins, an expert gardiner.

Notes:

Written for DW's WhatIf AU Bingo card - Law Enforcement square

Chapter 1: The Call to a Body

Chapter Text

[A voice announces: Inspector Durin Mysteries, The Body in the Physic Garden: Episode 1 – The Call to a Body]

A telephone rings.  “Hello, Durin speaking…What?...Yes, I’ll be there in fifteen minutes.”

There follows the sound of the bells of an approaching police car, which brakes and stops, and footsteps are heard as the occupants leave the car.

A man speaks.  “Ah, thank you for coming so quickly, um, um…”

“I’m Inspector Durin and this is Sergeant Dwalin.”

“Do come into the Chelsea Physic Gardens.  I don’t suppose you’ve been before?”

“No.”

“Then let me show you the way.  I assume you want to see the body.  We got a doctor, but he said he wouldn’t do anything until you arrived.”

“I presume he ascertained that the man was dead.”

“I don’t think there was ever any doubt about that.  He was clearly dead when we found him.”

“Right.  And who found the body?”

“Well, I suppose it was me.”

“I’m sorry, I didn’t catch your name.  And did you find the body?”

“Oh, my name is Ralston.  I’m Head of Plant Collections.  The gardener’s boy was with me, but I noticed the legs first.”

“Right, we’ll need to take statements from both of you in due time.”

“Oh dear.”

“Is that a problem?”

“No, it’s just that I won’t know what to say.”

“Don’t worry.  We’ll ask questions and you just need to answer them.”

“Oh, that’s all right then.  Here we are.  If you like to go in.  Do you need me any more?”

“Not for the moment, but please don’t leave the gardens.”

“I’ll be in the office.  I suppose I’d better start telephoning people.”

“We’d prefer it if you don’t make the news known widely for now.  Obviously no-one may come in this morning and if you could limit who you contact to only the essential few for the moment it would be appreciated.”

“Of course, of course.”

Thorin and Dwalin inspect the body, and there is the sound of feet on gravel, before Dwalin says, “I don’t need a doctor to tell me he was killed by a gunshot at close quarters.  Why on earth didn’t he phone for us immediately, rather than getting a doctor out?”

Thorin replies, “Yes, I’m not convinced by him at all.  He seems to be trying too hard to be a muddled individual, but I don’t see how he could become, what is he? Head of Plant Collections, without having certain abilities.”  He sighs.  “I could do with knowing more about this organisation, my instinct tells me this wasn’t a random death.  I wonder…”

“You’re thinking of contacting Mr Baggins, aren’t you?”

“Yes, I could certainly do with his expertise.”

“It’s a good idea, sir.”

[End of episode music.  An announcer’s voice says, ‘Tune in next week for another thrilling instalment’]

Chapter 2: Bilbo Baggins

Chapter Text

[A voice announces: Inspector Durin Mysteries, The Body in the Physic Garden: Episode 2 – Bilbo Baggins]

The sound of a door knocker on a wooden door and the door creaks open.

A man says, “I’m sorry, sir, but we’re not open today.  There is a notice pinned on the door.”

“Yes, I understand, but I’m here to see Inspector Durin.  My name’s Baggins.”

“Oh, well, if you wouldn’t mind waiting a minute, I’ll go and see.”

The door shuts again.  Bilbo Baggins hums to himself.  The door opens.

“Come in, Mr Baggins, the inspector is waiting for you.”

“Thank you, Sergeant,” Bilbo replies.  “It’s nice to see you again.”

“And you, too, sir,” Dwalin says.  “And hopefully you’ll be able to throw some light on this case.”

“I’ll do my best.”

“Mr Baggins, sir,” Dwalin says.  “The fool of a constable on the gate left him outside.  Do you want me to stay?”

“No, it won’t be necessary for the moment,” Thorin says.  “Can you do the formal interview of the gardener’s boy?  I know we’ve got a basic statement from him, but you might be able to find out a bit more from him.  And he’s more likely to talk to you, than to me.”

“Will do, sir.  I thought I might share my bit of fruit cake with him.  It’s a bit crumbly, but I doubt that’ll bother him.”

“Good thinking.”  There is a pause while Dwalin walks away, and then Thorin says, “Bilbo, thank you so much for coming up.”

“I just hope I can be of use to you,” Bilbo says. 

“I’m sure you can.  Do you know this garden at all?”

“I’ve visited two or three times before, but I can’t say I know it well.  I do know a couple of fellows who come here quite frequently, so I could put you in touch if there was anything particular you need to know.”

“Thank you.  And what do you know about Ralston, the Head of Plant Collections?”

“I understand he was abroad for a number of years, overseeing the purchase of plants for various gardens in this country and also, I seem to remember, those in the States.  There was some surprise when he was offered the role here on his return to the country, but he clearly knew about collecting plants so in some ways it seemed appropriate.”

“Right.  And now, do you recognise the person in this sketch?”

“No, not immediately.  I suppose it’s possible I’ve seen him somewhere before, but it’s very hard to say.”

“The sketch isn’t entirely accurate; it was the best which could be produced immediately.  Once the photographs have been developed and printed, I should be able to show you a proper likeness, which might help.”

“I presume the sketch is of the dead man.”

“Yes.  Ralston says he’s never seen him before and the gardener’s lad, who was with Ralston when the body was discovered didn’t recognise him, although that would be unlikely unless he’d been a regular visitor.”

“I’m afraid I’m not being much use to you.”

“I haven’t finished yet.  I want us to take a walk round the gardens and I want to see if you notice anything which looks strange or out of place.  Dwalin’s spoken to both the gardeners, who aren’t aware of anything, except one of the watering cans missing, which may or may not be relevant.”  Thorin pauses.  “Yes, Dwalin, what is it?”

“Here are the photographs of our body.  And I’ve had a message to say there was nothing to identify him in any of the pockets of his clothes.  The doctor thinks he may well have been living abroad until quite recently, which will make it even harder to identify him.”

Thorin sighs.  “In which case, do what you can to get his picture into the late edition of the evening papers.  We need to know who he is.”

[End of episode music.  An announcer’s voice says, ‘Tune in next week for another thrilling instalment’]

Chapter 3: Who is the Body?

Chapter Text

[A voice announces: Inspector Durin Mysteries, The Body in the Physic Garden: Episode 3 – Who is the Body?]

There is the sound of gravel crunching, indicating Sergeant Dwalin is walking away.

Inspector Thorin Durin grumbles, “Why should an unknown individual be shot here of all places?  The Physic Garden is hardly the most obvious location to meet someone.  According to the doctor the man had been dead for about two hours when he was called in, which means it was an early morning meeting.”

“The Garden would be ideal if you didn’t want anyone to see you,” Bilbo Baggins says.

“But it means that both the dead man and his murderer had to know the Garden, it’s not the sort of place anyone else would choose.  And without knowing who he is we really are working in the dark.”

“Can I have another look at the photograph?”

“Yes, of course.  What do you make of it?”

“He does look vaguely familiar.  I’m fairly sure I’ve never met him, but I may have seen his photograph somewhere.”

“You mentioned you knew a couple of people who came here quite often.  Do you think either of them would be able to help?”

“Yes, I’m sure they would if they could.  One of them works at Kew Gardens, I can give you his name, and the other is somewhere near Harrogate at the moment, which I realise isn’t as useful.”

“I can get Constable Nori to go down to Kew as a first step, and if that isn’t successful, we can always get a photograph sent up to the Yorkshire Constabulary.  Let’s go and find Nori.”

There is more gravel crunching and then Thorin says, “Right, Nori, off you go.  And telephone me immediately to let me know if you’ve been successful or not.”

“Yes, sir!” Constable Nori says.

“Good,” Thorin says.  “Ah, Dwalin, all done?”

“Yes, sir.  The photograph will be in the evening papers, no problem.”

“Excellent.  Well, Bilbo’s given us a possible contact, Nori’s going to Kew to check him out.  In the meantime, how did you get on with the gardener’s boy?”

“He’s a good witness.  He confirms everything Ralston told us about finding the body.  One thing though, when I asked him why he’d been with Ralston, he said the man had asked him to go with him for the start of the morning round.  Normally he takes either the head gardener or his deputy, but today the gardener’s boy had been asked.  The boy had wanted to check with one of the main gardeners if it was okay, but had been told not to bother them, and the lad wasn’t going to argue.”

“Now why on earth would he do that?  Unless he knew what he would find and needed someone to witness the fact.”

“And he thought the main gardeners would ask questions,” Dwalin adds.

“Precisely.”

[End of episode music.  An announcer’s voice says, ‘Tune in next week for another thrilling instalment’]

Chapter 4: The Body Identified

Chapter Text

[A voice announces: Inspector Durin Mysteries, The Body in the Physic Garden: Episode 4 – The Body Identified]

The sound of crunching gravel and then Sergeant Dwalin says, “Inspector, Constable Nori is on the phone.  He says he has some information for you.”

“Thank you, Dwalin,” Thorin replies.  “You’d better come with me, Bilbo, I might need your help.”

Further crunching and then, “Nori, what do you have to tell me?”

“Mr Fleming was very helpful.  He’s identified the photograph as being a Reginald Wyatt.  I gave him brief details, didn’t see much point in not telling him, since the news will be in the evening papers.  I hope that was okay?”

“Before or after he identified the photograph?”

“Afterwards.  He gave me the man’s name, then asked why I wanted to know, as anyone would.  He seemed genuinely surprised when I said he’d been found dead, and I didn’t mention how he’d died.  One thing he did say was that Wyatt knew Ralston.”

“What?”

“Yes, mentioned something about them having worked together at some point in the past.”

“Right, I may have to come down and talk to him myself, but for the moment that’s all I want.  Make your way back to the Physic Garden.”

“Yes, sir.”

“We have a name,” Thorin says to Bilbo.  “Reginald Wyatt.”

“Of course,” Bilbo replies.  “I thought I recognised him.  I’ve heard of him, but I think the only photographs I’ve seen of him were maybe from ten, fifteen years ago.  But surely…”

“Yes, your friend Fleming said that Ralston knew Wyatt and that they had worked together at some point.”

“I suppose if it was some years ago, he might not have recognised him.”

“You don’t believe that, and neither do I!”

“No.”

“But before I confront him with this fact, I’d like to know some basic information concerning the work they were both involved in.  I could go down to Kew and ask Fleming, but it would be quicker if you were able to tell me about it.  Can you?”

“Oh, yes.  It caused quite a stir at the time.”

“Sir!” Dwalin’s voice interrupts.  “Ralston’s not in his office, and no-one’s seen him for the last half hour.”

“Find out where he’s gone and check with the constable on the gate whether he let him out.”  Thorin says, and then he adds, “Sorry, Bilbo, can you wait to give me the details?”

“Of course.”

“Dwalin, that was quick.  Don’t tell me, there’s bad news.”

“It turns out there’s a small side gate the gardeners use during the day and Ralston has the key.  The gardener said, when he asked Ralston if he could go out for something this morning, he was told we’d been given the key.”

[End of episode music.  An announcer’s voice says, ‘Tune in next week for another thrilling instalment’]

Chapter 5: In The Greenhouse

Chapter Text

[A voice announces: Inspector Durin Mysteries, The Body in the Physic Garden: Episode 5 – In The Greenhouse]

“I presume no mention was made to you of a side gate?” Inspector Durin asks.

“It seems to have slipped Mr Ralston’s mind,” Sergeant Dwalin replies.

“Along with the key for said gate.”  Thorin sighs.  “Well, there’s nothing we can do about it for the moment.  Dwalin, phone through to the Yard and get them to put out an alert.  If I wasn’t suspicious of the man before, I certainly am now.  So, Bilbo, what can you tell me about Ralston and Wyatt?”

“As I told you Ralston, before he took up the post here, was sourcing plants for various prestigious gardens, both in Europe and in the States.  At one point he was working quite closely with Wyatt, but I believe that of late the relationship had cooled.  And shortly afterwards he returned to the UK.”

“Do you know why the relationship cooled?”

“Various rumours abounded, but nothing which really made sense.  The most plausible had it that Ralston did a few deals in the States where Wyatt’s share in the sales was reduced.”

“Even if that was the case, and supposing Wyatt had come over to confront Ralston, would that be sufficient motive for murder?”

“I suppose if there’d be an argument and Wyatt threatened Ralston, then he might have tried to defend himself.”

“No, that doesn’t make sense.”  Thorin stamps his feet in frustration.  “This was premeditated.  Ralston invited Wyatt here in the early morning, intent on killing him.  But why?  And why in one of the greenhouses?”

“Would it be possible for me to take a look?” Bilbo asks.  “I won’t touch anything, but it might help.”

They walk to the greenhouse.  The door creaks as it’s opened, and Bilbo walks inside.

“You mentioned a missing watering can,” Bilbo says.  “It’s there, propped up on that shelf, dripping slightly.”

Thorin steps towards it.

“No!  Don’t touch it.  Those drips are some form of strong weedkiller.  See the weeds on the ground directly underneath are all shrivelled up, but the others are still green.”

“What on earth?  I presume this was deliberate.”

“Definitely.  And that was why it had to be the gardener’s boy who accompanied Ralston to discover the body.  Either of the main gardeners would have noticed the watering can, just as I did.”

“Could this mean that there’s a plant or plants in here, which have a bearing on the case?”

“It would certainly seem a possibility.  But there I couldn’t help you.  There should be records of course.  And, unless Ralston had sole charge in this greenhouse, one of the gardeners would have some idea or at least would notice if something had been moved.”

“Nori,” Thorin shouts.  “Ask one of the gardeners to come to the greenhouse!”

“Yes, sir.”

There is the sound of approaching footsteps and the gardener says, “What on earth’s happened here?  Who’s moved all the plants?”

[End of episode music.  An announcer’s voice says, ‘Tune in next week for another thrilling instalment’]

Chapter 6: The Clue in the Plants

Chapter Text

[A voice announces: Inspector Durin Mysteries, The Body in the Physic Garden: Episode 6 – The Clue in the Plants]

“I don’t understand,” Sergeant Dwalin says.  “Why would anyone move all the plants around in that greenhouse?”

“I don’t understand either,” Thorin replies.  “Unless it was to hide something or take something without its absence being noticed.  But I’m sure it has to be relevant.  We should know more once Bilbo and the gardener have finished going through the list.”

Once more there is the sound of footsteps on gravel.

“Bilbo, were you successful?” Thorin asks.

“Yes, I think so.  We’ve gone through the whole list and there are four plants missing.  But before I go into that, you need to know that some of the plants on this list are protected species and should never have been brought into this country.”

“I thought these plants were all brought back years ago.”

“Similar ones were, but these are different varieties which have only recently been discovered.  Halliday, the gardener, wasn’t aware how new they were either.  It’s only because I have a particular interest in plant propagation that I knew.”

“Right.  Carry on – are these the ones which are missing?”

“Two of them are, the others are still in the greenhouse.  I’m not sure what the procedure for returning plants is, you’ll probably need to bring one of the experts up from Kew.”

“That, fortunately, is unlikely to be my problem.  You said there were four missing.”

“Yes, the other two, we think, were treated with the weedkiller.  Neither were particularly valuable; Halliday says there are others in the garden.  My guess was that Ralston used them as some sort of demonstration of what he could do.”

“Agree to my terms or else!” Thorin says.  “But why?”

“I imagine Wyatt was threatening to expose Ralston for bringing the plants back illegally.  If that came out, he would be ruined.”

“So Ralston tries to do a deal and when Wyatt refuses to agree, he shoots him.  But he must have known the murder couldn’t be covered up indefinitely.”

“Long enough to give him a chance to escape though,” Dwalin says.  Then, looking at Bilbo, he asks, “What would you do in that situation?”

“I’d head for the continent.  There are collectors out there who are less scrupulous in where their plants come from.  And he’s got two plants with which to establish his credentials.”

“That makes sense,” Thorin says.  “Yes, Nori, what is it?”

“Message from the Yard, sir.  Ralston’s been apprehended trying to board the ferry to France.”

“Did they say whether he had some plants in his boot?”

“They did.  Apparently, he told the constable to treat them very carefully.  They’ve left them in the boot, in case they’re toxic.”

“Are they, Bilbo?”

Bilbo laughs.  “No, they’re not toxic.  But, Nori, you might like to pass the message on that those two plants are worth rather more than the car is.”

“Blimey!  I’ll let them know.”

“Once more, I must thank you, Bilbo, for all your assistance in solving this crime.  Do you have to rush back home, or can I take you out to dinner?”

“Dinner would be delightful!”

[End of episode music.  An announcer’s voice says, ‘We hope you’ve enjoyed our latest Inspector Durin Mystery, ‘The Body in the Physic Garden’]

Series this work belongs to: