Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

Actions

Work Header

the truth about the moon

Summary:

The moon in the Shire is the same as the one in Erebor

or

Bilbo Baggins reflects on former regrets and embraces the life he has now.

Notes:

Fun fact! I started writing this fic in November 2020 and then just forgot about it!

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Work Text:

Bilbo Baggins was not a young man. He hadn’t been for a long time. No, long were the days he’d spent galavanting across Middle-Earth near-blindly following a pack of dwarves to reclaim Erebor. A time filled with wargs, orcs, a dragon, and so much bloodshed. Each second of the journey had seemingly rewritten his entire being; gone was the ‘respectable’ hobbit and in return was someone who had seen more than most could ever hope to see; who had seen things most could never conceive in their wildest dreams. Whoever Bilbo was now, he was glad of it. 

The journey had led to friendships that would last a lifetime. Unbreakable bonds between comrades that bordered on familial. Not that all the relationships were familial, of course. Whatever had existed between himself and Thorin Oakenshield was unlike anything he had felt before or had felt since. A true longing and wanting. His heart had found itself full of such warmth and joy. Then Thorin Oakenshield had disappeared and the King Under The Mountain had taken his place. 

Bilbo had long forgiven the actions committed by Thorin in the throes of dragon-sickness - of course he had! He wasn’t cruel enough to hold a grudge over something so far out of the dwarf’s control. But that did not mean things could return to how they had once been. Bilbo had once felt secure and comforted by being by Thorin’s sides. But now… Now each touch reminded him of when the dwarven king had been ready to throw him from the top of Erebor’s gate. The pure and visceral hatred in Thorin’s eyes that replaced any semblance of affection. 

When the Lonely Mountain was retaken and the Company had barely made their way through the Battle of Five Armies alive, Bilbo had been given an offer most could never refuse. An offer from the king himself to remain in Erebor; to remain in luxury for the rest of his life as an honoured figure amongst the dwarves that lived within its walls. To spend the rest of his life amongst the Company. To spend the rest of his life with Thorin. It seemed as if Bilbo were the only one to expect the refusal of the offer but he had done so with a certainty that left no room for debate. 

His former travelling companions still made an effort to visit whenever they could; to keep him up to date on each little thing he’d missed. The first few years were full of questions enquiring about his bachelor status (dwarves were known for many things but subtly was not one of them) but when things remained the same, the questions soon faded away. Particularly when he found himself the sole guardian of young Frodo. Who could spare a moment for romance when they had been given something so precious to raise and protect. 

But out of all his visitors, there was one that never came. After all, how could a King justify travelling across half the world for the simple act of tea with a lowly hobbit. Even if said hobbit was anything but lowly in the eyes of Thorin Oakenshield. Then again, it wasn’t as if Bilbo had ever truly considered returning to Erebor - even on the many occasions he’d tried to plan to do so. At first, he simply hadn’t been ready but now? Now he had to play both mother and father to Frodo, leaving no room for new grand adventures. 

Yet there were still many nights that he found himself pondering just what exactly would have happened if he’d chosen differently. If he’d chosen Erebor over the Shire. 

Nowadays, his first thought was ‘what would have happened to Frodo?’. Would he have been passed from family member to family member as they tried to find somewhere stable for him? Or even worse, would he find himself in the unfortunate care of the Sackville-Bagginses? No, Bilbo wouldn’t wish that on anyone! Least of all someone as kind-spirited as his nephew. Frodo had a spark within him that would be too easily snuffed out under the weight of Lobelia’s inability to care for anyone but herself. A heart that one in competition with one so superficial would have been a hopeless endeavour. 

Even if had considered Erebor after taking in the young hobbit, the idea had quickly been dismissed once more. Halls of stone full of strangers was no place to raise a hobbit child - especially one struggling with grief. What Frodo needed was friends, family, and a guardian there to support him when needed. Bilbo was dutiful in his certainty to play the role of the latter as well as any parent could. Even if it was less conventional than most in the Shire. 

Most in the Shire grew up being told the right and wrong way to act; how to properly present oneself within hobbit society; how to gain the approval of your peers. Mad Baggins was the last person who could ever hope to teach such a lesson. So instead, he told Frodo of adventure. He told his nephew about how much bigger the world was; how far it stretched beyond the Shire and all those small tidbits of varying cultures he’d picked up along the way. Teaching him Sindarin had been a must - Khuzdul would have been too if the dwarven language hadn’t been such a secret. Even Bilbo knew that the few phrases he had picked up on his travels were one to be never spoken casually and ones he would take to his grave. Bsides, there was some delight in how aghast his visiting friends looked when Bilbo first informed them of Frodo’s fascination with elves. 

That wasn’t to say elves were the only idea Frodo clung onto. No, the Grey Wizard himself had become a great source of fascination ever since he was a child. It didn’t help that Gandalf was all too eager to offer stories of his own, filling in the more embarrassing details that Bilbo had carefully omitted. The wizard’s visits were scarcely regular but there would never be a time his presence in Bag End would be turned away. 

Gandalf may have also been one of the last to ask Bilbo about his refusal to return to the Lonely Mountain. The last in the Shire, at least. There would come a time when several very familiar dwarves would try and persuade him to depart Rivendell for Erebor. “You lack being content here, my dear Bilbo.” There was no judgement in his words - just the same level of curiosity he’d grown accustomed to. 

“How could I be?” The ageing hobbit let out a soft laugh. “You pushed me towards an adventure unlike any a hobbit has been on before. How do you go back to… to being mundane after seeing all the ways you could be so much more?” The call to travel was one that never grew silent but Bilbo Baggins would refrain from answering. 

“Then why stay? I daresay there are many more than eager to claim Bag End as their own.” Ha! Wasn’t that the truth and a half! Bilbo still remembered the eagerness with which people had been trying to make off with his possessions when he had been ‘presumed’ dead. There were still several of his finest silver teaspoons missing! No doubt hidden amongst the Sackville-Baggins’ cutlery. “Just as I’d say there are many who would welcome your presence elsewhere.” 

Those words were enough to cause an ache in his chest. “You’ve met why, Gandalf. I can hardly leave Frodo on his own nor can I drag him blindly behind me. He needs stability and he’s happy here. What else could I want?” 

Gandalf didn’t dignify his question with words, simply offering the hobbit a very pointed look as he took a puff from his pipe. “It has been several decades since I last saw Thorin Oakenshield, and call me a creature of habit but I never intend to. We had our moments. Our… something. We both survived and some stories end far more abruptly than others.” There had been a time where nothing could have kept him from the King Under The Mountain but such thoughts hadn’t bothered him in years. 

“Middle Earth isn’t as small as simply the Shire and Erebor. We both know that well.” Though Bilbo had more than a slight suspicion that the wizard knew far better than most still breathing. “Lord Elrond would welcome your company in Rivendell should the offer ever tempt you. Given you were the only member of our party not to be as… rambunctious during our stay, you would find a warm welcome there.” 

“Maybe one day when the Shire finally becomes unbearable but Frodo needs me here so here I will remain.” There was a finality to his words; a certain stubbornness that refused to be challenged. “Besides, I have a fine family here and just as fine friends. The sort most could only ever hope to find.” 

A fond look crossed Gandalf’s face. “Hobbits. You never do cease to surprise me. A fine friend, indeed. A sentiment I can assure you is returned.” 

“Besides, there is one thing I came to realise during our journey.” Gandalf offered a head tilt to encourage him to continue speaking. “The moon never changes. No matter where you are in Middle Earth, it is always the same. The one I look at every night is the same way that shines above Erebor. The one indisputable constant.”

Far over the Misty Mountains, a dwarven king found himself staring out at the night sky with a long (and accepted) unending longing. But he had his sister, his nephews, and the fine Company that had become almost as brotherly as Frerin had once been. Back in the Shire, a hobbit took in the same sight as he indulged the company of a wizard and prepared to tell his own nephew about a fearsome dragon all over again.

Notes:

One day I'll write Bagginshield that isn't bittersweet but today is not that day. Love it? Hate it? Commnts are always appreciated or hmu @ delilah-briarwood on tumblr!