Actions

Work Header

Miscalculation

Summary:

Bilbo never would have imagined Thorin would react this way to him giving the Arkenstone away

Work Text:

Thorin is looking at Bilbo. He sees his mouth moving, but he can’t hear what he is saying, not since the halfling told him he gave the Arkenstone, his family heirloom, to his enemies. He takes a step back, “I have been betrayed. My One betrayed me!” He barely gets the words out; they are sending a stab to his heart.

Gasps can be heard, some of the company are looking at Bilbo, he is Thorin’s One? Thranduil curses, Bard is confused, “One? What is a One?” He never heard of that before.

“Soulmate, few dwarves have a One; they say that Mahal split their souls in two, and when you meet your One, you are whole again. If I had known Bilbo was Thorin’s One, I would never have accepted the Arkenstone.”

“Why?”

“Because Bard, being betrayed by your One, is a great shame and dishonor to dwarves. In the old days, when that happened, the betrayer was decapitated.” Thranduil knows that Thorin will never forgive Bilbo for that; in that moment, he pities Thorin Oakenshield.

Thorin takes another step back, “My One consorted with the enemy,” he takes off his crown and hands it to Fíli, “You are now King, I do not deserve to be King,” he turns around and ignores the voices calling him. He walks quickly into the depths of the mountain. His One betrayed him, his one love turned his back on him. He cannot show his face again without facing judgment, pity and ridicule. His One shamed him, dishonored him. His One clearly does not hold him in his heart as Thorin does Bilbo. Mahal must have made a mistake when he chose Bilbo to be his One. Thorin would rather have no One than to be betrayed and suffer a broken heart. He enters his chambers and sits down on the bed; he will not face more humiliation and pity.

-/-

The battle has been won, Bolg and Azog have been defeated, Fíli made sure to give Bard and Thranduil what they are owed and apologized for his uncle’s actions. He enters the throne room, “Any word of Thorin?” No one has seen him in two days, and he is worried about his uncle.

“No laddie,” Balin sighs, “He could have left the mountain, he knows all the secret passages.” His heart is telling him to fear the worst.

Dwalin rubs his chin, “I think I know where he is,” he looks at Ori, “Is there a map of the mines?”

“Yes,” Ori gets up, and Dwalin follows him, “There are several.”

Dwalin looks at them, “Here, there is a secret room that needs a password. Thorin hid there as a child; he told me the hammering brought him peace.” They make their way to the room, Ori finds the door and says the password. Dwalin pushes the door open and falls on his knees. Thorin lies dead on his bed, a dagger sticking out of his heart.

-/-

Bilbo is weeping, Thorin is dead, and he killed himself because Bilbo betrayed him. Bilbo wipes away his tears; he knows his presence is only tolerated and that they want him gone from Erebor. He knows that they all blame him; he blames himself, too. He gave away the Arkenstone to save Thorin, to avoid war, and it was all for nothing. Thorin is dead, and the war still happened. He puts the Arkenstone in Thorin’s hands and leaves. There is no goodbye; he simply leaves Erebor behind him with a broken heart.

-/-

Thranduil is looking at Bilbo, “Tell me, did you know you were Thorin’s One?” This is something he has been wondering about.

“Yes, he told me.” Bilbo is playing with his food; he is not really hungry, “He told me at Beorn’s. He wanted to marry me, make me his consort.” Those were better days before all the bad happened

“What on earth possessed you to give me the Arkenstone? You must have known how cherished Ones are. You knew Thorin had fallen under the gold sickness, and he was not in his right mind. How foolish you were to believe that Thorin would see reason in his madness.” He can’t believe how naive Bilbo was.

Bilbo is struggling for words, “I thought it was a good idea. I never imagined Thorin would end his life. I knew he would be mad, but I never...” He hates himself for taking the Arkenstone and giving it away.

“You know that dwarves are an honorable race. To be dishonored is a great shame. When I heard Thorin call you his One, I knew he would take his own life. Your actions humiliated him, you hurt his pride, and he would have been pitied by everyone, and Thorin hated pit,y even if he had not suffered from madness, he still would have taken his life because that is the kind of dwarf he was. He survived many heartbreaks, but this heartbreak had broken him.”

Bilbo is crying again, “I am sorry.”

“You should be.”

-/-

Bilbo is back in the Shire; he’s been back for two years, and he is miserable. First, he had to prove he was not dead, then he had to hunt down all his belongings. Now he has settled back into his old life, but he is not happy. Before his death, Thorin had declared Bilbo Baggins an enemy of the dwarves and hobbits to be untrustworthy. No dwarves are doing business with hobbits anymore, and word soon has spread that Bilbo was to blame. Half the Shire calls him Mad Baggins for running off and shuns him. Hobbits sneer at him and blame him for losing business, some having had business deals with dwarves in the past. Worse, they all know he is responsible for the death of a King, that he betrayed a King. Very few hobbits want to talk to him, and Lobelia has more than once tried to run him off, trying to rally the Shire behind her, but he will not let her get rid of him; this is his home. He takes a deep breath and suddenly regrets consuming him; it always sneaks up on him. He has had many nightmares about Thorin dying and accusing him of not loving him. But he does love Thorin, and he tried to save him out of love, but he miscalculated.

No one is there to lend him comfort, not even Gandalf had words of comfort to offer him; no, the old wizard only looked at him with pity. Bilbo wishes he had done things differently; he can only hope to see Thorin again and apologise. Until that day, guilt will be his companion.

Series this work belongs to: