Actions

Work Header

Defying Death (or at least the ones in charge)

Summary:

Bilbo has finally died, and now Lord Mandos wants to shove him away to Lady Yavanna’s Green Gardens. Well, that won't do. After all, Thorin won't be in Yavanna's gardens, and Bilbo won't stay where Thorin isn't.

He’s a burglar, and if he can smuggle his dwarves out from under Thranduil’s nose, he can smuggle himself into Mahal’s Halls under the Valar’s noses to, right?

Chapter Text

Bilbo sat down on the ground and sighed. He refused to be moved from where he was sat, but most importantly, he refused to be moved on.

“It is time to leave, little halfling. To go forth and move on,” Lord Mandas said in a soft tone. Some souls needed a little more coaxing than others, after all.

Bilbo Baggins was NOT one of those souls. He didn’t need hustling along; he didn’t need coaxing or cajoling. What he needed was an answer to his perfectly reasonable question. And directions. Directions would be super helpful at this point.

“No thank you, Lord Mandos, I don’t think so,” Bilbo replied with a little sniffle of his nose as he haughtily tilted his chin. Emulating Lobelia Sackville-Baggins. That woman had one of the best glares ever seen in The Shire, and Bilbo borrowed it.

“I will gladly leave if you just point me in the right direction,” he continued.

“The right direction is there, little halfling.” Lord Mandos said, pointing towards the archway behind him.

Bilbo looked at it, looked at Mandas and scooted further away from the archway. “Whilst I’m positive that is the right way for some hobbits, My Lord, it most definitely isn’t the right way for THIS hobbit.”

Lord Mandos looked at the strange hobbit before him. Never in all of their existence had he ever had any trouble with a hobbit. They were happy to go forward. Glad to go to their forever Shire. Happy to see their friends and family again. They were just happy in general.

But not this one. This one had a nasty little scowl, and somehow, the little creature even had an elven dagger on his hip like a sword.

Mandos was extremely confused. Hobbits did not carry weapons, especially to the afterlife. That wasn’t how their minds worked. So why was this one so odd?

“Little hobbit…” He began. He never got to finish his sentence, though, as the little creature jumped up to stand before him, his hands on his hips.

“You don’t hear me saying Big Lord, or gigantic, huge, humongous or a goodness awful height do you, not to mention the atrocious use of the word halfling? You’re a Valar; you should know better. So why are you calling me little hobbit? I’m not some wayward faunt refusing to go to bed. This is my afterlife, and I will choose where I spend it. Thank you very much, good Sir!” Bilbo shouted up at the Valar.

Honestly, Bilbo huffed to himself. All Big folk were the same as far as he was concerned.

Mandos looked at the hobbit in astonishment. He had never been spoken to like that before, especially by a mortal. A mortal. The hobbit should be happy he was even listening to his absurd pleas instead of throwing him through the archway, enormous feet first.

“Why won’t you go through the archway to Yavanna’s Gardens?” Mandos asked, gritting his teeth.

Bilbo wasn’t fairing much better in holding his own temper back. “Because I don’t want to, ‘’ he spat out at the Valar. “Just because you’re bigger than me doesn’t mean that you can boss me around, you know?” Bilbo shouted up at him.

“I’m the Valar of the dead, and you’re dead, so yes, I can.” Mandos seethed out at the hobbit.

“Well, I didn’t pick you to be the Valar of the dead. You would think I’d get a choice over who I converse with in the afterlife, wouldn’t you?” Bilbo humphed, pulling his waistcoat hem down in agitation.

“And who, exactly, do you wish to speak to, hobbit?”

“Oh, can I speak to someone else?” Bilbo asked excitedly. His eyes lit up in anticipation.

“I haven’t decided. I just asked who you wish to speak to.” Mandos said, watching as a little of the excitement left Bilbo’s face. He didn’t like that, but what could he do if the Valar he wanted to talk to didn’t come?

Bilbo sighed. “Could I please speak to Yavanna or Mahal? Or both?” he asked quietly.

“Mahal? That isn’t the Westron name for Lord Aule.” Mandos said, surprised.

“And yet it is his name, the name that is said with the ringing of the forges and the crafting of a legacy. Just because you all don’t use his real name doesn’t mean those who know better shouldn’t do better.”

“And you have experience with this?” Mandas asked, looking down curiously.

Bilbo, however, thought he was being mocked. “My Lord, the first thing you did was call me a halfling. I may be short, but I assure you I am not half of anything. Whether mind, body, or soul, I am one whole hobbit. So yes, unintentional offences are still offences. I hope you remember that,” Bilbo huffed out. Putting his hands in his pockets and bobbing his head.

What he wouldn’t give for a good smoke right about now, he thought to himself. No sooner had the thought popped into his mind that a little armchair and table with a pipe and pipeweed on it sprang up near one of the benches along the wall. “Would you look at that?” Bilbo said in wonder as he ambled over to it.

Mandos followed him. Struck silent at what had just occurred in his realm. This had never happened before. Admittedly, he didn’t have people stay longer than a few minutes and this hobbit had been here much longer than that already. Even so, who would be tampering with his realm and his responsibilities?

“Come now, come now. Calm down, my dear Lord Mandos.” Bilbo said calmly. “Rustle yourself up another armchair and come have a pipe with me. It will do that frown on your face the world of good,” Bilbo laughed happily.

Mandos just looked around, perplexed. He needed backup. This had never happened before, not since the making of the song, and he was in over his head. He excused himself for a moment and called for aid. Something he had never needed to do before.

Mandos sat down next to the hobbit and watched the hobbit curiously. “Why, may I ask, do you refuse to move on?” he asked.

“I didn’t refuse, My Lord. I just refused to move in that direction. I have to tread a different path.”

“There is no other path for one of your kind. Hobbits go to Yavanna’s Gardens. It is how it is. How it has always been.” Mandos replied softly. Surprised at the determined expression that suddenly flashed on the smaller being’s face. Mandos was shocked at how such a small creature could have so much determination and conviction inside of them.

“Just because it has always been one way doesn’t mean it can’t be another,” Bilbo replied resolutely. “As you made it clear, I have to pick one place to settle, which is stupid, by the way. I won’t pick Yavanna’s Gardens. There will be no rest for me there,” Bilbo finished with a sigh.

“Stupid?” Mandos stood in his incredulity. “The way we have woven the tapestry is not stupid,” he continued, outraged.

Bilbo just looked at Valar having a temper tantrum, unimpressed. He took another long puff of his pipe and muttered, “You could have fooled me,” around the stem he said as he ignored Mandos’ blustering.

If the Valar wouldn’t help, then Bilbo would stay put, right in this hall until the world was remade. He wondered if he could wish for a nice cup of tea. And lo-and-behold, as soon as he thought it, one appeared next to him. Causing him to make a little joyful noise. A good cup of tea was just what one needed when dealing with annoying folk.

Mandos moved away from Bilbo, glaring at him, and sat on his overly large throne, frowning. Bilbo thought he was trying to be intimidating, but what exactly could he do to Bilbo? He was already dead; if Mandos could smite his spirit, he would have done so already, Bilbo was sure.

Bilbo decided he was just being silly because things weren’t going his way and Bilbo wasn’t making his job easy. Well, Bilbo wasn’t having any of that. He had dealt with trolls, giant spiders, an egotistical dragon and 3 kings, and that was just on his first journey. He had been on many more before settling down to raise his boy. If this Valar thought he had anything on baby hobbits and temper tantrums, then he was a fool. Then again, Bilbo hummed to himself in thought as he looked around at the ostentatious decorations. He was close friends with two of the Maia (as different as Gandalf and Radagast were), and as soon as Gandalf had stepped foot in the Undying lands he had turned into a bright white peacock. Flexing his magic and such. Frodo had thought it was brilliant, but Bilbo had just felt grumpy at the display and all the ones after. Each was more absurd than the last.

He was tired, much more tired than he would ever let on to his boy or to his friends. Gandalf and Elrond had put on dinners, shows, and recitals, and Bilbo’s heart had lifted. Not for himself but for his boy. His dear, sweet Frodo, who had taken a burden that should never have been his. One that Bilbo had been too weak and stupid to understand. He had been the reason his child had to face that terrible place, be stabbed by that terrible blade and in the end, leave his beloved Shire and Sam behind.

Bilbo felt the tears forming in his eyes. He wondered if this was his punishment. If this was the retribution of the Valar for him being so weak, so weak that he had almost attacked Frodo over it.

He had finally understood in that moment, more than ever before, how Thorin had felt. How he had gone from a stoic but fair King to a raging monster looking out from familiar blue eyes.

If he hadn’t already forgiven Thorin as soon as he was safe all those years ago, then that moment would have cemented it. He, who had barely had to fight it, had felt the pull, the call. With his desperation for a home and safety, Thorin must have been raging a war inside himself. A war he eventually won. With the price of victory being himself and his boys.

Bilbo quickly wiped the tears from his cheeks, not wanting Mados to see, lest he try to kick him through the hobbity arch again. Bilbo didn’t want to go through that arch. He wanted to step through the one in the corner, the one that had geometric designs and dwarven weapons carved in it.

Bilbo knew Thorin was through there, and he was going to get to him, even if it took him until the world was remade.