Actions

Work Header

Even Monarchies Have Their Endings

Summary:

“It is simply the nature of all kings to kill, plunder, and hoard wealth— in the same way it is the nature of dragons,” Bilbo said.

 

Bilbo Baggins has lived all his life in The Shire, where leaders are democratically elected. He has never met a king before. Royal families have always been nothing more than characters in stories from far away.

But after meeting several haughty warlike kings on the Quest for Erebor, Bilbo finally realizes why the Shire has no monarchy — it is a ridiculous horrible form of government and no one with any hobbit-sense would ever agree to it.

Following the Battle of the Five Armies, Bilbo explains representational democracy to King Thorin Oakenshield. Overwhelmed by the hobbit’s wisdom, Thorin impulsively converts Erebor into a democratic republic and retires from public life.

But what will happen when Bilbo and Thorin’s actions set off a wave of anti-monarchical democratic revolutions across Middle Earth? Will they ever be allowed to live in peace?

(A book/movie tragicomedy about the struggles of searching for an ending where “they all live happily ever after to the end of their days.” Don't take this too seriously XD.)

Notes:

On one hand, LOTR takes place in an imaginary fairy-tale-world where it's possible for monarchy to be good. It's just that on the other hand, applying the logic of anti-monarchical revolutions to Middle Earth is very funny. ....Don't take this too seriously XD.

A book/Movie fusion based on this Tumblr post: https://www.tumblr.com/overthinkinglotr/730106846622384128?source=share

The things I'm taking from the movies: Thorin is more kindly and more serious; Bilbo and Thorin had a close (if sometimes tense) friendship on the Quest, and sincerely care for each other. My Bilbo is very Ian-Holm-inspired.

The things I'm taking from the book: Thorin is more haughty and goofy. Bilbo has more Fussy Old Man energy. Bard is a bit more warlike.

If you've ever read my webcomic adaptation of The Hobbit, it's like that. (Retelling the Hobbit, which you can find here: https://archiveofourown.org/works/22839055/chapters/54585289 ).

But yeah, this fic is what happens when you've spent over ten years in both the Lord of the Rings AND Les Mis fandoms (remember how the Hobbit and Les Mis movies both came out in 2012?) and are now trying to reconcile that contradiction.

Long live the Republic!

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Work Text:

“I had always loved kings,” Bilbo said, “or I had always loved the idea of kings, marching their great armies on the edges of stories from far away. Monarchy really did seem magical to me before all of this. I had always thought of kingship as the sort of grand tradition we could never have in a plain place like Hobbiton, a great thing that would never fit in such a small country, a power that belonged to the heroes who were far too important to stop at the Green Dragon. And then—“

“And then?” Thorin asked.

“And then I met real kings!” Bilbo said fussily. “That breaks all the illusions, doesn’t it?”

He passed Thorin a cup of tea. Thorin raised himself up in bed and accepted it with a weak smile.

The two of them were in a small barren stone room that resembled a cell. It was once a bedroom, and now that they had won the Lonely Mountain it was going to become a bedroom again— eventually. For now it was stark and grey. It was not cozy, like a bedroom should be.

The courtiers of the Iron Hills had offered to decorate it, but Thorin had refused. “I have grown sick of gold,” he had said, “it offends my sight.” And so the room had remained as it was.

The only furniture was an old bed, a rickety bedside table, and a wooden stool. Thorin was in the bed; the Arkenstone was on the rickety bedside table; Bilbo was on the stool, sipping tea.

A month had passed since the Battle of the Five Armies. Thorin had been gravely injured, and it had seemed he was on the point of death. Fortunately, Bilbo was in his own way as stiff-necked as Thorin. The hobbit had demanded an audience with the Elf-King and urged him to put aside his petty grudge with Durin’s folk long enough to render some assistance. The Elf-King, who was accustomed to the fury of orcs but unprepared for the fury of a hobbit, was frightened into sending one of his best healers to Thorin’s tent. With the help of that elven magic, Thorin and his family had survived the battle.

Thorin had insisted that his Company should spend all their time tending to Fili and Kili, pompously reassuring them that he could manage his own recovery alone. Most of the Company was too stubborn to obey and found a way to spend time with all of them.

But the hobbit spent the most time alone with Thorin. The other members of the Company longed for them to reconcile, and giving Thorin time to apologize to the burglar in private had seemed the most reasonable decision.

And so Thorin had spent the past few weeks apologizing; Bilbo had spent the past few weeks managing those apologies until he grew tired of them; now they talked often, about everything and nothing. They met in the mornings for breakfast, the afternoons for lunch, the late afternoons for tea time, and the evenings for supper and desserts. Now that Thorin had the strength to walk, they sometimes slowly walked through the halls of Erebor, tiredly trading stories.

Today Bilbo and Thorin were discussing something drearier than the Battle of the Five Armies— they were discussing their futures.

Thorin had offered Bilbo a place of honor in Erebor, as a Dwarf-Friend and friend to the King. Bilbo had refused, insisting he must get back to the Shire.

From there, they had begun to discuss Thorin’s return to the throne, and then kingship as a concept.

“I am sorry I have disappointed you,” Thorin said with half-hearted haughtiness, staring into his tea. He was haggard and pale. His beard was thinner, his hands trembled, and a new scar ran down his face.

The flame within him had died. His former long-winded arrogance had been burned out of him. He spoke only with the ashes of importance.

“Disappointed!” Bilbo said. “No, no, that is not what I meant at all.”

“I am sorry,” Thorin sighed, “That I am not the grand king from your stories.”

“Thank you, but I am not looking for an apology!” Bilbo said, taking a sip of tea. “Really, you have given me quite enough of them. I hardly know what to do with all your apologies.”

“You deserved to meet a better king,” Thorin said miserably.

Bilbo laughed with a quiet bitterness.

“A better king!” Bilbo said, and made a strange gesture with his glass of tea. “There’s an idea! You might as well say— ‘Mister Bilbo Baggins, I wish you had met a better dragon.’”

“Oh?” Thorin looked at him, and scratched his beard thoughtfully.

“See, perhaps it’s because I am from the Shire, where folk are more reasonable —- but I do not think there are better kings. That is what I have been trying to say to you. Indeed I have come to think that all kings are terrible.”

“I am deeply sorry, then,” Thorin said morosely. “I know I have not made a very splendid figure as King under the Mountain. You are right to think so lowly of royalty, after how poorly I treated you—“

“Stop, stop!”

Thorin stopped.

“I thought you had learned, Mister Oakenshield, Mister Son-of-Thrain-Son-of-Thror,” Bilbo said, jabbing one finger in his direction, “that not everything in Middle Earth is always about you. You’re only just a little fellow in a wide world, after all.”

“But I have been a wretched king,” Thorin said, dejected.

“If that’s what worries you, then you are hardly the only ‘wretched king’ I’ve met on this journey, you know, and not even the ‘most wretched’ of them,” Bilbo said. “There was that horrid Goblin-King, and that greedy Elf-King, and that warlike Bard of Laketown, and that stiff-necked Dain, and— well, even Mister Smaug the Golden called himself the King Under the Mountain! You are not the only king who has been bothering me lately.”

Bilbo grumbled and took an angry sip of tea.

“Certainly there must be the possibility of a good king, though,” Thorin said.

“Dear me! No; I don’t think so at all,” Bilbo said.

“There must be,” Thorin repeated with exhausted haughtiness. He leaned against his pillows, and stared at his reflection in his tea as if he no longer recognized himself. “I may have failed, yes, I admit that I have been foolish, and warlike, and a laughingstock, and a wretch, and that I have disgraced my line; I admit that I have lost the path of wisdom and the path of a just king and may never find it again. But certainly there is a way for a king to rule wisely and well.”

“I don’t think there is— now listen.”

“I am listening.”

“I think a good fellow can be a king— or that he can be a good fellow, before he is a king. But I do not think that kings can be good. It is a wretched miserable job, and it makes you do wretched miserable things.”

He sipped his tea viciously.

“It is simply the nature of kings to kill, plunder, and hoard wealth— in the same way it is the nature of dragons,” Bilbo said. “The crown touches your head, and then your only duty is to slaughter people for treasure!”

Thorin glanced at the Arkenstone, which was glimmering on the nearby table.

“Look at that Bard. He was a good man, if a little grim. Got along well with him,” Bilbo said, gesturing with his tea cup as if he was gossiping about his neighbors in the Shire, “But then he becomes king, and suddenly he wants to start a war for gold! And what is worse, he is excited for it! Boasting about how his people will slaughter dwarves! It’s like something got into his head. The moment you become king, you start wars and slaughter people over treasure, no matter how good you were beforehand — it is some dark kingly instinct that possesses you. Every king becomes like Smaug, no matter how good they begin. I confess I do not understand it.”

Thorin continued looking at the Arkenstone, and then shut his eyes.

“I do not understand either,” he said quietly. “But I think that now, somewhere in my heart, I may agree.”

“The crown corrupts people like a, like ….,” Bilbo suddenly reached into his pocket and fidgeted with some object. He knitted his brows, playing with the object thoughtfully. “It corrupts them like— oh, I hardly know. The crown corrupts them like it’s some sort of evil cursed piece of jewelry.”

He remained lost in thought for a moment, still fiddling with the object in his pocket.

“Thorin!” He said suddenly. “You are not drinking the tea I gave you. It is very good. If you do not want it I will give it to Gandalf.”

“Oh! I am deeply sorry,” Thorin said, and took a sip.

“How is it?”

“It is very good,” Thorin said. “You must teach me how to make it.”

“I will!”

“Thank you.”

“You’re welcome!”

“And I think the trouble may be,” Thorin said, lifting his head with an air of self-important self-sacrifice, “that kingship is simply too great a burden. It is a load that breaks all who carry it.”

“Oh I suppose that’s true! Goodness knows it’s been hard to watch kingship fling you around like a doll and cause you senseless misery.”

“Hm!” Thorin said.

“But I think it’s the lack of limitations that makes it truly terrible, really,” Bilbo said. “A king can do whatever they please, to whomever they please, and no one can stop them. They’re not beholden to anybody and the only way to get rid of them is to kill them. That’s why things involving kings always become dark, nasty businesses!”

“It is hard,” Thorin said drearily. “It is hard work.”

“Certainly!” Bilbo agreed.

“It is too much power, too much responsibility…too much importance.”

“I don’t doubt it!”

“And I am sorry I have made you detest me so,” Thorin said.

“I do not detest you,” Bilbo said, “I have simply grown to detest kingship, as an idea.”

“Yet I am a king,” Thorin said bitterly.

“And I do not like you, as a king,” Bilbo admitted. “As a king, you would throw me over the ramparts for the sake of a jewel. But that is not because you are bad; it is because royalty is bad. It is not about one evil dwarf; it is about— it is about a power that corrupts all who touch it.”

Bilbo paused and thought for a moment, fiddling with the object in his pocket.

Then he raised his head, as if he’d just thought of a new verse for a poem he was writing, and said solemnly:

“Monarchy makes dragons out of everybody.”

Then he took another sip of tea. Thorin watched him with a sort of bewilderment.

“Will you not stand by me, once I have returned to my duties as king?”

“I am afraid I will not,” Bilbo said apologetically. “You will always be my dear friend, but forgive me, I have dealt far too much with the dratted ‘duties of kings.’”

“You believe I will become monstrous again, once I return to the throne?” Thorin said.

“To become a king is to become a monster,” Bilbo said. “If you return to the throne, there is no helping it.”

“You could be my advisor,” Thorin offered, his eyes glittering. “Your courage and wisdom could rein in my foolishness, as it has before.”

“Neither of us can ‘rein each other in’— we are both far too stubborn for that!” Bilbo said.

“We are not too stubborn,” Thorin said.

“We are,” Bilbo insisted.

“I believe we could manage,” Thorin said.

“I believe we could not,” Bilbo said.

“We could learn to manage.”

“We could never!”

“You cannot be so certain of this.”

“I am perfectly certain.”

“So you do not trust me,” Thorin said.

“I cannot trust any king, at all,” Bilbo said. “Someone with so much power— goodness, that is far too much trust to put in anybody. How dreadful!”

“So you are afraid of me.”

“I am not afraid of you. I am afraid of anybody who can have me executed for disagreeing with them,” Bilbo said.

“I swear,” Thorin said, with a tragic light in his eyes, “that I will never again use my power to hurt you.”

“But you could! And you understand that being able to is enough to break us apart. Knowing that you could have me thrown over the ramparts on a whim— oh my! That is enough to make me fear you, knowing that you could even if you wouldn’t. I could never speak freely like this again.”

Thorin grew morose. Bilbo fidgeted with his cup of tea, and placed it down on the table.

“I am sorry if I am offending you,” Bilbo said. “Know that If any other king offered to let me be their advisor, I should say the same thing in response. Even if some kind old fellow like Balin, or some wise wizard like Gandalf, suddenly became king— I should say “no thank you!’ I just do not think this royalty business can ever end well.”

Thorin sipped piteously at his tea.

“And yet you are returning to The Shire,” Thorin said with bitterness, “are the kings there so special? They must be grand and beautiful kings indeed, to be the exception to your rule; the Shire must truly be a great realm, where the kings are noble beyond imagining—”

“The Shire has no king,” Bilbo said.

Thorin coughed and nearly choked on his tea.

“No king!” He said, staring at Bilbo in stupefied amazement. “So you are leaderless?”

“No, we are reasonable. We are plain quiet folk and we have no use for kings,” Bilbo said. “I would have told you all about it, if you had ever asked— but forgive me, you often gave me the impression that you did not care to learn how the Shire did things, because you thought us too silly and Unimportant!”

“I wish to learn now,” Thorin said.

“I know, and I thank you! You have made quite a change in yourself!” Bilbo said, and cleared his throat. “So it is like this: after the fall of the Northern Kingdom long ago, we started ruling ourselves. We’ve got a plain hobbit-system called ‘democracy.’”

“Democracy!” Thorin said, “I have only heard whispers of that kind of government.”

“Yes, it seems exceedingly rare in Middle Earth these days. In any case, a ‘democracy’ means that we vote for our leaders. Every hobbit gets to cast a ballot for their preferred candidate and the winner rules over the Shire. And then, there are other positions like the treasurer and so forth, and we vote to fill those as well. Hardly a perfect system, by any means— oh, recounting all the terrors and scandals of hobbit politics will take years— but it’s certainly a better one than monarchy.”

“Oh,” Thorin said. A strange light seemed to be kindling within him. “I have only heard about such systems of governments in old stories, and legends, and tales from far-off— rumors in birdsong on the wind. I did not know that any remained upon this earth.”

“Well!” Bilbo said. “We are certainly remaining. We are good at that, if nothing else.”

“You are good at many other things,” Thorin said gravely, staring into Bilbo’s eyes. “There is more of good in you than you know.”

Bilbo flushed and spluttered out something polite.

“It would be very hard now, to be king without you,” Thorin continued drearily. “I have grown quite used to you. I like looking to you, and speaking to you, and knowing you will do what I cannot. I think that I trust your judgment more than I trust my own.”

“Thank you— but I am sorry,” Bilbo said, evading his eyes. “Kingship is your ‘adventure’ and not mine. You may visit me in Hobbiton if you ever retire, I suppose.”

Thorin fell into a deep and tragic meditation that was full of despair.

“So you will hate me again, once I am king,” he said.

Bilbo frowned. He fidgeted with his hands, and with the buttons on his coat. He thought deeply about what the proper thing to say in this situation was, and went round and round his head looking for it for a very long time.

At last he simply put his hand on Thorin’s bed.

“I may not like you as a king,” Bilbo said gently, “but I want you to know I really am very fond of you as a dwarf.”

Thorin laughed weakly.

“Oh, it is not a joke! Bother everything! You shouldn’t make fun when I am being serious. I really am very fond of you, Mister Oakenshield— despite everything!”

“Not a joke after all? Then I suppose I am also very fond of you, Master Burglar— despite everything,” Thorin said with the ghost of a smile, bowing his head gently.

“It’s the royalty business that’s ruining things,” Bilbo said. “It never mattered on the quest— spiders did not care who was a king or not. You were just some absurd pompous creature, and I was also just some absurd pompous creature, and when we butted heads we were both equals in our own queer way.”

Bilbo sighed and rubbed his temples.

“I miss that, you know. It was quite bothersome and bewildering at times, insufferable even, but— well! Looking back on it now, I can say it was also a bit of fun. It will be a good thing to put in my book.”

“Ah,” Thorin said, “so you will still include me in your book?”

“Certainly!”

Thorin bowed his head in meditation.

“You do not need to put me in your book, if you do not wish to. You can leave me out entirely, or mention me in passing as a haughty annoyance you have dealt with, as a nuisance you have overcome; you can speak of me as a great obstacle you have beaten, a monster you have defeated-“

Thorin went on like this for quite some time. It seemed that he was feeling just well enough to get his long-windededness back; this was a good sign, if an annoying one. After a particularly long sentence, he took a sip of tea. Bilbo frowned at him.

“I have realized,” Thorin said finally, “that I am really not too important to your story…. Or indeed, not too important to you at all.”

Bilbo did not like the self-deprecation he heard in Thorin’s voice. He also did not like the passive-aggression.

“You will be in my book! You need to be!” Bilbo said.

“Oh?”

“Firstly, because you are important to me. And secondly, because I think children will like you,” Bilbo continued.

“Children?”

“Yes, they will love how long-winded you are. They will find it funny. They will say ‘that silly Thorin, he is a fun character— you should add more of his talk. I like it when he’s rude to poor Bilbo. He makes me laugh.”

Thorin did not look offended. Instead he looked as if he were considering this very thoughtfully.

“Oh!” Thorin said, sincerely, “I suppose you are right, as usual; it is necessary to bring me into your book, and to make fun of me, if it makes children happy— is it not an important duty, to bring joy to children?”

“It is!” Bilbo said.

“It is,” Thorin said thoughtfully, “it is enormously Important?”

“Very enormously!”

“Then I should be glad to be given such an important role in your book. Make fun of me all you please.”

Thorin raised his tea to his lips, and then faltered for a moment.

“But what shall you say about me at the end of the book?” he asked. “Will you tell the children: ‘oh and then he became a King, which is to say he became a monster, and I hated him again?’”

Bilbo opened his mouth to respond, shut it, and fidgeted uncomfortably. Then he rubbed his forehead, and sighed.

“I haven’t decided on the ending yet,” he said. “I’ve thought of a good one, which goes: ‘and then they all lived happily ever after until the end of their days.’ But I don’t know how to get to it.”

“I understand how that is,” Thorin sighed.

“I know,” Bilbo said. “I know you do. I suppose you know better than anyone!”

They were silent for a few long moments. Bilbo frowned, and buried his head in his hands. Then he sighed again, more miserably this time.

“I thought, after the dragon was slain— that would be ‘happily ever after.’ Then, I thought I could buy off war with the Arkenstone— and that could be ‘happily ever after.’ Then I thought, after the battle—- but it seems it keeps slipping away from me! I have it in my hands, and then it wriggles away! Every ending is another beginning! Bother everything.”

He buried his head even deeper in his hands, and his voice grew more agitated.

“Lately my life has been — oh, it’s been like a draft of a story you can’t quite finish writing. You know, it’s the draft that sits in your head all day and night begging you to find the right words, when there don’t appear to be any ‘right words’ at all. Everything you write is wrong. Every ‘ending’ you write is hollow. And so you are trapped all alone with that wretched unfinished prose and those confounded blank pages, unable to work but unable to rest, unable to do anything at all, isolated and shut in, searching for something you cannot remember, wanting to finish writing but knowing it’s beyond you. And you've got to finish or you will never be at peace! But you begin to doubt you ever can. So you look at those empty pages, at all the horrible blankness that stretches ever on and on, and you are suddenly weary in a way that you have never felt before. You wonder if this is what it means to be old. And you are suddenly tempted to let that emptiness spread its fingers into all the corners of your heart until it has entirely hollowed you out— Oh, now I am talking nonsense! I will save this for my poetry, but it needs revising…!”

As the hobbit spoke, Thorin gazed at him thoughtfully, in the midst of some horrible inner debate. It looked as if the pillars within the dwarf-king’s soul were slowly crumbling away. He gently placed his tea down on the table and meditated; he stared at Bilbo, and at the Arkenstone; finally he stared at the blank empty walls of his bedroom.

Then he raised his head, and an expression of grim resolution appeared on his face.

“I shall help you create your happy ending, Master Burglar!” Thorin said in an enormously Important voice.

Then he suddenly seized Bilbo’s hand. His eyes blazed bright like fire beneath a thicket, and he smiled with a grim determination Bilbo had not seen since the early days of their journey.

“How will this do, to begin: ‘From this day forth, Thorin Oakenshield is no longer a King,’” he said magnificently, “Erebor is now a democracy.”

Bilbo started in surprise, and flushed.

“Oh my! Really?” Bilbo stammered.

“Indeed! That would be a bold way for your book to end, would it not?”

“Oh, well— I suppose—“

“Then in my last act as King, I shall declare my kingdom a ‘democratic republic.’”

“Good gracious!”

“And the throne shall belong to no one.”

“To no one!”

“Royalty shall be abolished among my people, and they shall never suffer under the whims of monarchs again.”

“Dear me!”

“And then, we shall convene in the great halls, in the ancient tunnels of Erebor, and we shall hold an election for our first— what do you call your leader, in the Shire?”

“We call one of them the mayor,” Bilbo said.

“We shall hold an election for our first mayor!”

“Oh my!”

“And the bells shall ring in gladness as a new age of Durin’s Folk begins, a grand age, where we shall see our days renewed.”

“This is all very kind and lovely of you!” Bilbo said, now very flustered. He awkwardly patted Thorin’s large dwarven hand with the air of someone who had just been given an unexpected marriage proposal.

“Thank you,” Thorin said.

“But well, this is still all very sudden!” Bilbo said, still deeply bewuthered. “It is good! I do believe it is good. It is very good, it is incredibly good, better than I dared hope, I think— but come, perhaps we should plan it over more? It does not seem like the sort of thing a dwarf should rush into.”

“We can plan it over!” Thorin said magisterially. “Oh, there will be time to plan, and to plan over.”

“Indeed! You have got to learn how a democratic government works, and the logistics, and so forth,” Bilbo said.

“Certainly! It shall not be too difficult for me,” Thorin boasted.

“And then, we probably ought to be careful about the Implications. Who knows what effects this may have on other countries! Perhaps other people may try to get rid of their kings.”

“Good!”

“It is good, but I should like to avoid having another war on my conscience,” Bilbo said testily. “I prefer for things to happen peacefully. I know most kings generally do not agree with me on this, however, and they prefer instead to slaughter anyone who disagrees with them. But it is a dangerous thing-- to go poking at sleeping dragons or contented monarchies.”

“I think other kings may follow my example,” Thorin said magnificently. “What greater legacy for a king, than to rid the world of kingship?”

“What greater legacy indeed!” Bilbo said. “Yes. Yes you’re right. Yes, I worry too much. There will be no need for war. It will be good, in the end.”

“And perhaps,” Thorin added, “this will finally give us our happy endings.”

“Perhaps,” Bilbo said with a laugh. “But we are talking of making an entire change in a system of government! Such things are difficult. A monarchy does not fall in a day.”

“We will do what we can,” Thorin said.

“I suppose!” Bilbo said. “But—“

“But we are only two very little fellows in a wide world, after all,” Thorin said.

“Yes-- and thank goodness,” Bilbo said, taking one last sip of his tea.

Notes:

Thank you so much for reading! <3 ;_;;;;;;

If you like my wonky Bagginshield writing in this, check out my webcomic adaptation of The Hobbit at "Retelling The Hobbit" on A03: https://archiveofourown.org/works/22839055/chapters/54585289.

You can find me on Tumblr at @secretmellowblog (my main blog), @secretmellowart (my art blog), @overthinkinglotr (my lord of the rings blog) and @retellingthehobbit (my webcomic adaptation of the Hobbit.)

I'm also in the "Acorns and Oak Leaves" and "Fellowship of the Fics" discord servers!