Work Text:
A quiet sigh escaped him as he finally set his bowl of hot soup down beside himself, only to glance over at the campfire. To where the others sat, talking and laughing. Gandalf. Bifur. Bofur. Fili. Kili. Dori. Nori. Ori. Oin. Glóin. Balin. Dwalin. Bombur. Thorin…
All of them… just not him.
He was inevitably the outsider of this company, an ordinary hobbit among dwarves. Someone who had simply set out into the blue to see all the things he had always longed to see deep inside. New places… Rivendell, Erebor. New peoples… cultures like the elves he had read so much about. And also, the dwarves, whom he had imagined so very differently.
Back when he had been small, still learning, still observing everything with bright eyes, he had always dreamed of all this. Of something completely different from the ever quiet Bag End. Of forests and mountains larger than the ones he had seen in his books. Of an adventure… a fate he would never have found in Bag End. Something he could only find out there in the wide world, darker than anything he had ever known.
It was fascinating.
And yet—why did it feel so different from what he had expected? Why did all of this feel so wrong? So wrong and yet strangely, right?
Why did he feel pity for those dwarves who had lost everything, even though they barely paid him any attention? Who saw him as a burden who couldn’t get anything right…?
It bothered him. It hurt.
What could he do about the fact that he had never fought? Never been a warrior who could wield a blade?
All he wanted was to belong. Not to be a burden… not to weigh others down, but to lift burdens from them.
His mother, Belladonna, had always said it was important to help those who were worse off than oneself.
And wasn’t that exactly the case here? He had a home—Bag End—while these dwarves, who always looked at him so mistrustfully, did not. So, he would help them. He would truly try. Until they finally understood that he was not a burden.
But no matter what the hobbit tried, no matter how hard he worked, he only did things wrong.
During sword training he couldn’t parry without stumbling under the weight of the blade. While gathering firewood he got lost, forcing the others to search for him. And even collecting berries for food he had messed up, accidentally picking the wrong ones—berries that, to his misfortune, caused severe diarrhea.
The only thing left for him was to keep watch over the ponies and warn the others of danger. Even then he wasn’t trusted, for during his shift one of the dwarves was always awake as well.
“I really shouldn’t have come along…” he whispered to himself, staring at the flickering fire that gave him pleasant warmth. Which was good, because the night was icy cold, and his limbs trembled from the fresh wind.
“Tell me, halfling, why are you here?” The sudden question made him look up into the attractive face of the dwarf who confused him the most. Thorin, rightful King under the Mountain, who always looked at him so strangely from those dark eyes.
Quietly, searching inwardly for the right words, the hobbit sighed. “Because it’s the right thing. I mean… maybe I’m no help, maybe even a burden… but one must help those who are worse off.”
He glanced briefly up at the starry sky, hoping it was true and hoping Thorin and the others would finally understand him, finally accept him.
But they did not. Not at all.
“And how exactly do you intend to help us? There is nothing you could possibly do,” the dwarf replied in that mocking tone Bilbo should have been used to by now. A tone that shouldn’t hurt so much.
Lowering his head, he heard the crunching steps on the ground as Thorin walked away.
Oh, and it hurt. It hurt so much.
Why? How could this be the right thing? Should it really feel like this?
If so, why did his heart feel so wounded with every word from the dwarves, with every word from Thorin?
It made no sense… none at all.
And why was he crying? Why couldn’t he stop it?
He was doing his best! He was trying so hard… And all he wanted was a few kind words, or maybe a small, honest smile meant only for him…
Even when he had managed—with Gandalf’s help—to free the dwarves from the three trolls, Thorin gave him only cold, sarcastic words in return.
The others treated him differently now, looked at him differently. He befriended them. Laughed with Fili and Kili. Cooked with Bombur. Talked with Balin about long past days.
So why wasn’t it enough? Why wasn’t he happier?
Why did it have to be Thorin whose attention he longed for so desperately?
…
And as so often in recent days, another almost pitiful sigh escaped him. Noticed immediately by none other than Lord Elrond, the dark haired elf who still fascinated him and about whom he knew so little.
Elrond gave him a strangely knowing look, as if he already knew everything about Bilbo’s life, as if he could see what troubled him with a single glance.
“Lord Elrond…?” “You are truly a fascinating hobbit… so far from your home, so far from everything familiar. Far from all peace and comfort. Leaving all that behind requires great courage,” the elf said, his melodic voice emphasizing every word.
“Courage, you say?… I don’t know if I’m courageous. I constantly think of my cozy home and what I left behind. And Lord Elrond… I’m afraid. I fear what might happen, what might cross our path. I don’t know if this is right, if I’m doing the right thing. Lately I even think it was a bad decision to leave the Shire… to go with the dwarves…”
He revealed thoughts he had carried for so long, thoughts he had never dared to share. Yet here, with Elrond—an elf—it was easier than with the dwarves, who were far less gentle.
“It is not always easy to know what is wrong or right. Whether what one does is truly the right path. Some may know the answer immediately, without searching. Others search their whole lives. Search and search… day in, day out. And without noticing, they forget to live. Forget that it is alright to take a wrong path sometimes. Forget that there is nothing wrong with being afraid,” Elrond said, making Bilbo think even more.
Bilbo let his gaze wander over beautiful Rivendell. The place of the elves he had read so much about and the place he had always wanted to see.
And here he was now, without ever having hoped for it, without believing he would ever stand here. Rivendell, Imladris… Bruchtal.
Perhaps this was what he should do. Perhaps this was his path.
What if he simply stayed here? Here among the elves, who had welcomed him kindly from the start, who had shown interest in him without knowing him, who were not prejudiced, who did not look at him with cold eyes.
He should stay. It would surely be better for the dwarves—who he only caused trouble—if he said goodbye here. If they had one less problem to deal with.
That would be right… wouldn’t it?
But why did his chest ache so unbearably when he thought of saying goodbye to the dwarves… to Thorin?
Why did his heart scream and plead when he imagined staying with the elves?
Why did he feel so miserable at the thought? So much like a burden…?
Another weak sigh escaped him as he looked back at Elrond, who had apparently watched him the entire time with those knowing eyes.
“So, I should just continue? Stay here? … Elrond, which is it?” he asked pleadingly.
But he received no clear answer. Only a mysterious smile that could mean everything or nothing, with which the elf left him alone on the windless balcony.
Well… now he could understand Thorin a little. He knew elves loved riddles, but he had hoped for clear answers. Not more questions.
What should he do? Where should he go?
“Bilbo? What are you doing out here? The others are already at dinner… well, they’re trying at least,” Gandalf said as he stepped onto the balcony.
The wizard to whom he owed all of this. Who had said this journey would do him good…
But was that true? Had this journey—on which so little good had happened—really been good for him?
Before he could sink deeper into his thoughts, a loud growl pulled him back into reality. His stomach, ignored for too long, demanded attention.
Giving it the attention it deserved, he followed Gandalf, ignoring the wizard’s looks. He didn’t need anyone else meddling in his problems.
He would fix everything somehow. Make it feel right again. Stop doubting. Never doubt again.
Yes, he would make everything right… somehow.
..
With his hobbit stomach now somewhat satisfied, he sat with the others—and several elves, including Elrond—at a large table.
Bilbo couldn’t really focus on the conversations around him. He watched each dwarf for a while, wondering whether they would miss him, whether they truly liked him. Whether they liked him as much as he had grown to love them.
“What’s wrong, Mister Beutlings?” “Why so quiet?” Fili and Kili asked almost simultaneously, making a small smile appear on his lips.
“It’s still Baggins… and don’t worry about me, I’m just thinking about a few things,” he replied.
But curious as they were, they asked again. “What things?”
Knowing them well enough by now, he realized he had to say something, or they would never leave him alone.
But what?
Before he could think too long, he opened his mouth and said with a smile: “About a story my mother once told me…”
Instantly he forgot he had only wanted to make something up. The story came to him. The one he had always loved most. The story he had never forgotten, that had accompanied him since childhood, that had made him dream, believe, hope, fight.
“The story even reminds me of you… because you see, in that story there was someone who had lost everything. Someone to whom everything had been taken…”
He lifted his gaze and found himself looking into many attentive eyes.
“And what did he do?” The question came from Thorin, whose dark eyes were not cold this time, but searching.
Unable to look away, Bilbo stared into those eyes as he answered:
“He did what you are doing now… He fought. For himself and for what no longer existed. He kept fighting and never gave up. He walked path after path. Sometimes left, sometimes right. Never stopped. Stumbled, but never stopped. And in the end, he succeeded…”
He paused, finally understanding the story himself, before continuing:
“What he had lost was gone… well, not entirely. It had changed, just as he had changed. In all the years he wandered, fighting, searching for those responsible for his suffering, he had grown old. He had forgotten what he still had, what had not been taken from him. But it no longer mattered. In the end, he realized he already had everything he needed.”
He finished the story quietly.
Thorin stood without a word, then announced loudly that it was time to take care of other matters.
And Thorin was right. There was still an adventure to face. They had to keep moving forward.
And Bilbo decided he would not stay here. He would continue with the dwarves. He too had to keep fighting. Follow his path into the world.
The Shire was not his home… Well, it was his home. But that was over. He was no longer the same hobbit who had lived there.
He wanted to help the dwarves, prove he could be useful. Laugh with them, face dangers with them.
And he wanted to stay with Thorin.
…
“He has been lost since we set out. He should never have come. He does not belong with us.”
He heard those cold, bitter words again and again. They repeated, gave him no rest, drilled into him, hurt him.
He wanted to close his eyes, but it didn’t help. The dark eyes stared at him disapprovingly. Mocked him. Laughed at him.
Bilbo didn’t want to continue. Didn’t want to walk… didn’t want to stand.
Why did it hurt so much? Why was it so unbearably painful?
It should stop… Stop hurting. Stop tormenting him.
But it didn’t.
It throbbed. It hammered in his rising and falling chest. It lived where he didn’t want it to live. It felt—so loud and unrestrained—and he wished he could stop feeling altogether.
He should never have gone with them. Never continued traveling with them.
Why had he kept going? Why had he followed Thorin and the others? Why had he begun to feel?
He should have known better. Done better. Tried harder.
But it was too late.
He had stumbled. And he feared getting up again. Feared continuing.
If life felt this painful, heavy, unbearable… why keep fighting? Why keep going?
He didn’t know.
And yet he didn’t want to give up. He kept fighting.
No matter the pain, no matter if it destroyed him inside, he would help the dwarves reclaim what they had set out for. He would help Thorin. He would give everything.
And he did.
Without hesitation, without regret, he threw himself in front of Thorin when Azog attacked. Protected the dwarf who meant so much to him, who made his heart beat so painfully, who now stared at him in shock as Bilbo slowly sank to the ground with a smile.
It still hurt, and the pain held him tightly. But now it felt different. Not cruel or torturous, but almost unbearably gentle and warm. Almost beautiful.
Bilbo was sure it was over. That his end had come. That he would die.
But then, hesitantly, his eyes opened—only to meet the eyes that had always seemed so unfathomable to him. Eyes that had seemed so cold and yet were so warm. Eyes that no longer looked at him with disapproval. Not with hatred. Not with mistrust.
Before he knew it, he pushed himself from lying to standing, hearing loud, chaotic voices around him. Relieved. Happy. Joyful.
All of them seemed glad he was alive.
All but one.
Thorin’s voice rose loudly as he stood before him:
“Did I not tell you that you were a burden? That you would not survive in the wild? That you would never belong with us?”
…
So nothing had changed… Nothing at all.
At least that’s what he thought—until Thorin pulled him into a firm, warm embrace.
“I have never been so wrong… not in my entire life. I am so sorry. Truly. I don’t know what I would have done if you had died because of me. I could never forgive myself for losing something else that I care about…”
The deeply remorseful tone made Bilbo pull the dwarf closer, gently stroking his back.
“It’s alright… it’s all alright now. I will stay with you, now and for as long as you want…”
Words he had wanted to say for so long.
And when Thorin whispered, “…Then stay forever,” and both of them smiled.
Forever was a long time.
And yet Bilbo knew that this—this and nothing else—was what he wanted.
