Actions

Work Header

The voice in my head

Summary:

Bilbo returns to Erebor after declining Thorin's proposal

Work Text:

Bilbo swallows hard when he sees the scene before him, “What is this?” Bilbo counts the heads on spikes; seventeen heads are placed before the gates of Erebor. This is what you escaped. I told you coming back was a mistake.

“A message,” Bard puts a hand on Bilbo’s shoulder, “Those are the heads Thorin cut off. Most were the former council. Others are heads of dwarrow dams who dared to court him.”

Bilbo looks up at that, “I don’t understand.” He follows Bard back to Dale.

Bard closes the door, and they sit down. “Thorin uncovered some very old law that states if someone wants to court the King, they have to meet him in a fight. Should the King beat them in the fight, he is within his rights to kill the person who challenged him for his hand in marriage. No one expected him to actually kill anyone, so when he cut off the Lady’s head, everyone was shocked, but they could do nothing about it. It did not deter others from trying, and he killed every single one of them. There was one dam who beat him in a fight, but then she made the mistake of laying a hand on Thorin, and what no one knew was that the fighting part was part of an ancient courting ritual which forbade touching. Thorin cut off the lass’s hand for breaking the contract. Her head and beard were shorn off for dishonoring the King, and she was banished and marked as an unhonorable. There was another dam who beat him, and she made the mistake of leaving the gift in his room. He killed her for entering his rooms unasked, and he also killed the guard who let her in.”

Bilbo is crying, “This is not the Thorin I remember.” He ignores what the voice in his head is telling him.

“No, it is not. Thorin has turned into a cold, cruel and bitter King. He is still friendly with me and even Thranduil, if you can believe it, but to others he is not.”

“What happened to him?”

“You broke his heart and humiliated him in front of his family and friends.”

Bilbo looks up, “Fíli?”

“Aye,” he sits down, “You are uncle’s One and when you rejected his marriage proposal and went back to the Shire, something in him broke.” Fíli is mad at Bilbo, “Why are you back?”

“Because I made a mistake. I never should have left.” Bilbo wipes his nose, “I overheard some dwarves talking that they would make you King if Thorin were to marry me. It is unnatural to marry an outsider, and that Thorin should marry someone to strengthen ties. I could not let Thorin lose what he fought so hard for. I left so he could remain King.” He does not mention the voice in his head which urged him to leave, too.

Fíli lets out a bitter laugh, “You are such a fool. You are his One! For Mahal’s sake, they would have accepted you for that alone, and I can’t believe you listened to some gossip and believed them to be fact.” He takes a deep breath, “Kíli is married to Tauriel, and I am married to Sigrid. No one forbade us from marrying our Ones; Thorin just told us not to get married and live in Erebor, since there is no place for love in Erebor. Kíli and Tauriel have been living in Mirkwood, and I have been living here in Dale. We rarely see Uncle anymore.” He gets up. He needs air. “You should leave before Amad finds out you are here and kills you.”

Bilbo takes a shaky breath, “No, I ran once, I won’t turn my back on Thorin again.” Fool

“You are a fool if you think you can fix this.”

Bard looks at Bilbo, “I agree with him. Thorin will not accept you with open arms. Go back home."

“I have to try.” Leave before you lose your life. He is not worth it. He tried to kill us! Bilbo ignores the voice.

*-*-*

“I should kill you where you stand, but death is too good for you,” Dís is sneering at Bilbo, “Follow me, halfing.” She leads him to the battle grounds, “A dam petitioned to court Thorin, why they still do baffles me. Thorin would rather kill himself than marry someone who is not his One.”

Bilbo is clenching his fists so hard they have turned white. Thorin easily disarmed the lass and cut off her head. Bilbo swallows down bile, this is not what he thought would happen after he left.

Dís leads him to Thorin’s rooms, “I won’t leave you two alone, I do not trust you.”

Bilbo numbly nods. He looks up and sees Thorin, and his heart breaks. Thorin has dark circles under his eyes, his hair is grey, and his face looks sunken in. Gone is the majestic stature he carried; all that is left is a broken dwarf. The guilt hits Bilbo full force; he did this to Thorin. He broke both their hearts because he listened to a stupid voice in his head that told him to leave. When he sees Thorin look at him, he sees just how empty those piercing blue eyes are.

Thorin grunts, “Halfing, why are you darkening my doorsteps?” All the feelings he had for Bilbo once are gone; he is but an empty shell who cares for nothing.

“I am sorry, so sorry. I made a grave mistake when I left. I love you.” He is not foolish enough to believe that his saying those words will magically fix things, “I never should have left. I should have stayed and married you.” There wasn't a day when he did not miss Thorin and regret his choice.

Thorin lets out a hollow laugh, “I do not believe you. No word from you for seven years, and now you are suddenly here, proclaiming your love.” He shakes his head, “Mahal must have made a mistake when he chose you as my One. A One who betrayed me when he gave the Arkenstone to my enemy. Do you have any idea how humiliating that was to me? That is why, in my madness, I wished to kill you. A part of me wishes I had, it would have spared me further humiliation.” He looks at Bilbo, “I did not think halflings to be so cruel as to play with someone’s heart and then crush it.” He shakingly gets up, “I may have forgiven you for everything you did to me, but I will never forget.”

“I want to fix this,” Bilbo takes a step forward, “Please let me fix this. I missed you so much, and I was miserable.” Liar, you were happy to be back in the Shire. No danger to yourself. You were happy with your books and armchair. Bilbo ignores the voice.

“Go back to the Shire burglar, there is no place for you here. You must think me a fool if you believe I would fall for your empty words again.” Thorin turns his back, “You are banished from Erebor. Should you step into my kingdom again, your head will join the others.”

Bilbo is crying, Dís leads him out of the mountain. Bilbo sees the company, they are wearing the same looks of anger, fury, pity and disappointment as the last time he saw them. You never belonged with them. Your place is not at their side. You never should have come here. He wordlessly passes them and makes his long way back home.

*-*-*

Bilbo is sitting on a bench in Rivendell, and Frodo is off to destroy the ring. A ring that he should have destroyed decades ago. He now knows that it was the ring that told him to leave Erebor and Thorin, whispering in his head all those years. Elrond speculates that the Ring knew it would be found out if he had stayed and thus made sure Bilbo left. Bilbo feels like a fool to have been influenced by the One Ring; no one blames him, but he blames himself. He slowly gets up and makes his way to his room. He hopes he can apologize to Thorin one day. He gets into his bed and dreams of better times.

Series this work belongs to: