Work Text:
Galadriel was best known for her ability to see things that were, things that are, and things that may be. After stepping onto the boat to sail to the Undying Lands, Galadriel assumed this gift would no longer serve her. Funny how her gift couldn’t stop the mortal failing of making assumptions.
Then again, Bilbo Baggins was best known for defying expectations.
Not as spry as he once was, the elderly Hobbit hobbled with his cane across the deck of the ship. Galadriel tucked the skirt of the dress closer to her body to make a seat for her friend. Bilbo slowly lowered himself to sit next to her and offered her a sweet smile.
Then Bilbo’s smile dimmed, becoming small. It had been years since Bilbo showed a lack of surety so Galadriel patiently waited for Bilbo to gather his thoughts. The Elf knew that Bilbo was a simple and kind soul that had never asked for much during his long life, so she was sure she’d be able to grant any request he had.
Bilbo finally turned to Galadriel before speaking.
“Lady Galadriel, you’re able to see different points of time, correct?”
Galadriel smiled, “Yes, I am.”
Bilbo fiddled with the buttons on his waistcoat.
“Has one ever… been able to not just see different points of time, but also travel there?”
Galadriel’s heart sank.
“It would not be wise, my friend.”
Bilbo’s nose twitched in indignation.
“And why not? There are so many things that could’ve been done differently. So many lives could have been saved-!”
Galadriel placed a gentle hand on top of Bilbo’s knobby knuckles. Bilbo let out a huff and looked expectantly at the Elf. She regarded the waves of the sea lapping at the boards of the ship before lifting her hand to gesture towards the sails.
“Wind blows into the sails to propel a ship forward. Then the ship cuts through the sea. The waves made by the ship ripple and make more waves as a result.”
“Galadriel, I’m not so senile that I don’t remember how boats work.”
An airy chuckle escaped Galadriel’s lips. The normally composed Elf toyed with the ends of her hair.
“I was referring to cause and effect.”
“Reminds me of when I played with dominoes as a boy.”
“Precisely. Despite always referring to yourself as a ‘simple Hobbit’, your actions helped shape the world to the peaceful place it is today.”
“Was there really nothing I could have changed?”
“Will the answer bring you peace?”
Bilbo took a moment to craft his answer.
“Not knowing will haunt me more.”
Galadriel nodded.
“The ring tempted me when I first gazed upon it.”
“You? The Lady Galadriel?!”
“Indeed. No one person could withstand the temptation for long. Especially, not as long as you had.”
“So I had to go on the quest to get the ring.”
“That is correct.”
“Well,” Bilbo huffed. “I would’ve gone anyway.”
Galadriel gazed at the Hobbit through the corners of her eyes. Bilbo tapped on the handle of his cane.
“This isn’t just about that blasted ring, is it?” Bilbo grumbled.
“Unfortunately not. Erebor was an important stronghold. If Smaug had still been living there, he would have been turned to Sauron’s army.”
“I won’t argue that the lizard should’ve died–”
“ Bilbo. ”
“Then what else–?”
“The members of the Fellowship. Because you are not senile, I know you remember who they are.”
“No one would believe me if I told them how cheeky you are… I know the names of those boys. I know five of them well.”
“I happen to be referring to Frodo, Gimli, and Legolas. Do you think Frodo would have been strong enough to travel to Mordor if he had not been raised by ‘Mad Baggins’?”
“How do you know– Nevermind, I know the answer. Frodo had wonderful parents–”
“Gentle parents.”
“Very gentle. Very kind. Excellent Hobbits, in fact.”
“But not adventurous.”
“That’s what made them good Hobbits.”
“Your influence on Thranduil and Glóin cannot be ignored, either.”
“You must be joking.”
“They would never have allowed their sons to join the Fellowship if they had not seen the tenacity of Hobbits firsthand.”
“The bond after the Battle of the Five Armies helped, no doubt.”
“I wonder which Hobbit helped that.”
“ Galadriel. ”
Galadriel smirked. Her posture remained perfect as she leaned towards Bilbo.
“And then, there is the matter of the three kings that came into power.”
“I’ve always hated politics.”
“Bard would never have become king had you not intervened in his life. His lineage was needed to unite Men, Elves, and Dwarves.”
“I’ll give you that one.”
“Aragorn–”
“I’ve met the boy once .”
“Would not have become the king he is without his friends, your boys.”
“Thorin Stonehelm.”
A frown marred Bilbo’s face. The Hobbit took a shaky breath before collecting himself.
“This is cruel , Galadriel.”
Galadriel held Bilbo’s hands in hers.
“I know you miss Thorin Oakenshield. But the Dwarves needed a ruler that had not experienced temptation, one that had not fallen to dragon-sickness.”
Bilbo swallowed the emotion caught in his throat.
“Then… Did we have to fall in love? If everything else was supposed to happen… Did we still have to fall in love?”
Galadriel pursed her lips and her flawless face crinkled around her eyes.
“Frodo would not have survived without the mithril chainmail.”
Galadriel felt wet drops upon the tops of her hands and followed their path to Bilbo’s eyes. She could not blame him for crying, nor could she have prevented it.
“For the sake of everyone alive today, Thorin and I had to fall in love and he had to leave me behind.”
Bilbo fetched a handkerchief from his breast pocket and dabbed at his eyes.
“What was the point of having a love so short?”
Galadriel pulled the Hobbit into a hug.
“Coming from opposite perspectives, you and I both still know that time and love never truly influence the other.”
Galadriel squeezed him tighter.
“It mattered, Bilbo, and just because it did not last does not mean it was not real. I promise you, it was real.”
As foreseen, Bilbo only cried more but Galadriel held him tightly until his tears dried.
Bilbo sniffled, “It’s not fair.”
Galadriel hummed her agreement.
You don’t suppose I’ll ever see him again, do you?”
Galadriel didn’t know how to answer that.
“I am afraid my gifts can offer you no comfort.”
Bilbo slowly nodded, digesting the answer. The Elf felt hollow. Because it wasn’t fair. It wasn’t fair at all but that was how the events unfolded. Against her will, Galadriel felt words slipping from her mouth.
“I know that of all the things that were, the most common occurrence I saw was a brave Hobbit doing everything he was told was impossible.”
Bilbo looked at Galadriel. She saw a familiar twinkle of mischief.
“Impossible and I never seemed to agree with each other.”
“Indeed.” Galadriel smiled.
Bilbo chuckled, “First, I should try to get an audience with the Valar!”
The Hobbit prattled on with his grand plans and Galadriel offered suggestions as they traversed the sea. It helped pass the time and settled Galadriel’s heavy heart. Bilbo had always been a wordsmith and his plans held the same wit and enthusiasm as everything else he ever spoke.
This writer’s vocabulary did not include ‘never’ or ‘impossible’ and Middle Earth was better off for it.
