Actions

Work Header

Sins of the past

Summary:

The world has been remade but for some there is no second chance.

Notes:

This is something that has been floating in my head. There is no happy ending here.

Work Text:

Aragorn wakes up with a gasp. He remembers! He remembers his life as Estel/Strider/Aragorn. He remembers finding out he was the King of Gondor, he remembers leading Frodo to Rivendell, and he remembers the war. He remembers dying, but what he remembers most are those blue eyes, which always had a shadow of sadness in them.

He looks around. He is in his bedroom. His other memories surface, and he has been living in his apartment for the past eight years. He is a self-defence teacher for children and also a weapons consultant for a movie company. He wonders why he remembers now. And not when he was a teen. He looks at his calendar, he is glad it is Sunday, he needs time to sort through his memories.

–

Bilbo is making himself some tea; only ten minutes until he closes his café. Bag End is his pride and joy; he has been operating the café for the past fifty years, taking over after his father’s death. He smiles at Lisa, she always comes in an hour before closing and sits at the window and enjoys a cup of jasmine tea with blueberry scones. He hears the bell above the door and looks to his left. He almost drops his cup. He puts it down and goes to the counter, “May I help you?”

“Peppermint tea and a raspberry scone, please.”

Bilbo prepares the tea, “That would be five dollars, please. Take a seat, I will bring it to you.” He watches the man take a seat, turns around and pours some hot water into a cup. He brings the scone and tea to the man, “Enjoy.”

Aragorn takes a bite of the scone, and it is delicious. He knows that Bilbo recognised him; he could see it in his eyes. When he went home to visit his foster father, he realised that Elrond did not remember, nor did the twins or Arwen. And he is glad she did not remember; if she did, she most likely would have wanted to resume their relationship. He is glad he did not have to tell her no. He is glad she is firmly his sister this time and is already married with children.

Lisa has left, Bilbo locks the door and joins Aragorn, “When did you remember?”

“Two weeks ago. I have been looking for someone else who does, and when I saw your flyer, I came here.” He sips some tea. Bilbo looks old, his hair is grey, his skin is wrinkled, and his eyes are those of someone who lived two lifetimes. “How long has it been for you?”

Bilbo lets out a humorless laugh, “I remembered on my thirty-third birthday, that was over forty years ago.” He remembers that morning well. He was visiting his mother, and she was worried about him when he woke up screaming. He told her that he had a nightmare, at first he thought it really was, but then he saw his handkerchief on his nightstand, singed in the same place as in his nightmare. He looked at his hand, and there was a scar. He always thought he was born with it, but he remembered that he got it when he practised with Sting, and he realised all was real. That Arda had been remade, and he was remembering his old life.

“Are there others who remember? Elrond doesn’t, nor do his children.”

“There were, are. Balin remembered, but he passed away over a decade ago. Gimli does too; he has been traveling the world, and he visits from time to time. Frodo doesn’t, not yet at least. Gandalf also remembers, he is a professor at Harvard, if you can believe it. He told me that most of us won’t remember. Some only remember to pass on a message to someone else who remembers. To be honest, I wish I hadn’t. It is a burden and a curse.”

Aragorn can see the bitterness and sadness in Bilbo’s eyes, “What happened?”

Bilbo gets up and brings over a bottle of whiskey, “I am going to need this.” He puts a healthy amount in his cup, “When I remembered, the first thing I did was find someone else who also did, like you. Balin was a regular customer; he came in here every week hoping I would remember. And then one week I did. I immediately asked him about Thorin,” he takes a sip, “You see, I was in love with Thorin, but I never told him or anyone, nor acted on it. Years later, Dwalin told me that Thorin was in love with me, too and that it was my voice in his head that snapped him out of the gold sickness. Thorin was going to ask for my forgiveness, then court me once the war was over. You see, I was his One, his soulmate. But Thorin died, I did forgive him before his death, you know. When I was with him in his last moments, a part of me died too. I went back to the Shire with a heavy heart, always missing him and cursing myself for not making a move, no matter how nervous I was. I keep thinking that if I had done this or that, maybe Thorin and the lads would have survived that day. Anyway, Thorin was the one I wanted to find in this new world, to give us a shot at being a couple. But,” he takes another bigger sip, “But Balin told me that Thorin died fourteen years prior.”

He gives Aragorn a tearful smile, “Thorin felt so guilty for getting his nephews killed and for trying to kill his One. He felt guilty for being weak and falling to the gold sickness. He hated himself for taking Dís’ sons away from her. He hated himself for ignoring that I was his One until it was too late. The guilt ate away at him, and only a few months after he remembered, he killed himself. He did leave me a letter in case I remember.” He reads the letter once a month; it is the only thing he has left of Thorin. He wipes away a tear, “I asked about the others, Balin told me that they all have their own lives and don't remember. I saw Fíli and Kíli a few times, and they liked my scones. They died in a car accident about twenty years ago, when a drunk driver hit them. The driver was Bolg.” He shakes his head and sniffles, “I was devastated, the man that I was in love with was long dead, and I have to carry both memories of his death. I have to live daily with the fact that my soulmate died long before I got a chance to be with him. To this day, I love him. And there are days when the regret is so strong, I can barely move.”

“I am so sorry to hear that,” he feels dread settle in his stomach, “What about Legolas?”

Bilbo takes another sip, he is silent for a few moments, “He died of leukemia when he was six years old. He did remember, I visited him in the hospital, he told me there was no point in talking about things that cannot be undone,” he puts his cup down, “Legolas, he just gave up and didn’t fight his illness, he didn’t want any treatment. He was fading away before our eyes and there was nothing we could do,” he takes out his handkerchief and wipes away his tears, “Thranduil, he remembered too, left after Legolas’ funeral, no one has seen or heard from him since.”

Aragorn is gripping his teacup; Legolas is dead. Dead, he is dead. “How long ago did he die?”

“Twenty-five years ago.” Bilbo feels like he is looking into a mirror; Aragorn has the same look in his eyes as he does.

Aragorn feels like he’s been punched in the gut, he breaks the teacup, he doesn’t realise he cut himself, he just feels numb. He looks at his bloody hand, then at the cup, “Sorry. I will pay for it.”

Bilbo gets up and gets a medical kit. He cleans Aragorn’s wound, “You are lucky, you don’t need stitches, and don’t worry about the china. It can easily be replaced.” He puts a bandage on the cut, “You were in love with Legoas, weren’t you?” He sees the same regret in Aragorn’s eyes that has been reflected in his own eyes.

Aragorn nods, “From the moment I met him.” He looks down, “I chose duty over love. I didn’t follow my heart. I loved Arwen, but I was never in love with her. I did what I thought was best for my house and line.” He accepts the shot of whiskey Bilbo hands him, “Do you know what happened to Legolas after my death?”

“He and Gimli sailed to the Undying Lands. Gandalf told me that Legolas found no solace there and faded away.” He cleans up the shattered cup, “Galadriel says, us remembering years after the others are dead is our punishment for our sins in our old life. That we don’t get a happy ending, no second chance to fix things.”

Aragorn feels numb. This really feels like a punishment, “Where is Legolas buried? I want to visit his grave.”

“There is no grave, he was cremated, and his ashes were scattered over the sea.” He hears a knock on the door, and he looks up and sees Gandalf. He gets up and opens the door, “This is not a coincidence, is it?”

“It is not,” he follows Bilbo, and they both sit down. Gandalf looks at Aragorn, “Good afternoon. You are the last one who will remember his old life. By the look of things, Bilbo told you that Legolas is dead?” He sees Aragorn nod, “Legolas had no hope. He did not want to suffer another heartbreak; he was convinced you would choose Arwen again and ignore your heart. He was told that you would remember too, eventually, but did not want to be hurt again. He did not want to yearn for you and watch you be happy with someone else. Eru gave him a choice: fight his leukaemia or not. Legolas chose not to. Bilbo already knows that Thorin felt he did not deserve a second chance, that he could not forgive himself, so Thorin chose death too.”

Gandalf can see that Aragorn is angry, “I am sorry, but Galadriel is right, this is your punishment. Bilbo failed to show me the ring he found; the fate of the ring was never meant for Frodo. Bilbo was supposed to be the one to destroy it. If he had shown me, I would have recognised it, and we would have destroyed it, and Sauron would not have had decades more to sow his malice. You, Aragorn, you ignored your heart; there is no worse offence in the eyes of Eru.” He shows Aragorn a book, “This was written by the Blue Wizards, they stayed in Middle-earth until it was remade. Your descendants are responsible for a lot of evil.”

“I read that book. So it is based on facts?” Bilbo asks as he pours Gandalf a cup of tea.

“Yes. They recorded everything,” he looks at Aragorn, “Legolas was your soulmate, but I think you figured that out.” Gandalf cleans his glasses, “You two were not the only ones who missed their chances with their soulmates in the old life. After Melkor and Sauron soulmates became rare,” he looks at Bilbo, “Your parent’s were soulmates. Usually if a soulmate pair has a child, that child has a soulmate,” he looks at Aragorn, “Your parents were too.”

“Were Legolas’ parents too?” He hates himself so much; why did he not follow his heart? If Arwen had left with her people, he would have pursued Legolas. But Arwen stayed for him, and instead of being honest with her, he settled.

“No, Thranduil never loved Legolas’ mother. He only married her because he needed a Queen and heir at the time,” he looks at Bilbo, “Bard and Thranduil were soulmates, but actions have consequences, that is why most of you never were with your other half. Thranduil only found out after Bard’s death. He never told anyone, not even Legolas. I only know because I was tasked with finding you all.”

“Are they together?” Bilbo thought there was a spark between Thran and Bard back then.

“No, Thranduil died in a house fire seven years after Legolas’ death, and Bard doesn’t remember.” He won’t tell them about the other pairs that missed each other in both lives; they are suffering enough, no need to burden them any further.

Aragorn runs a hand over his face; all his hopes and dreams have been shattered. “What happens now?” He just wants to go home and get drunk.

“You live your life, and you have to carry the burden of knowledge and remembrance,” Gandalf looks at Aragorn, “Read the book, contact me if you have any answers.” He gets up and leaves.

Bilbo sighs, “It is not a pleasant read. I am sorry.”

Aragorn takes the book, “Thank you for telling me what you know. Do you mind if I come by again?”

“Not all at. It will be good to talk to a familiar face,” he will need to contact Gimli and tell him Aragorn remembers.

Aragorn bids his goodbye and leaves. He returns home and heats some leftovers. He sits down and starts to read.

-

Gandalf is in his office when Aragorn comes in, “Good to see you again, sit down please. I take it you read the book?”

Aragorn hands him the book back, “I did. Is all of this really true?”

“I am afraid so. Your line brought about a darkness never seen before, and Eru was forced to remake the world. Your children and their children were never supposed to be born. You knowingly ignored your feelings for Legolas, and this was the result of that. I had hoped you would come to your senses on your own. I was also forbidden from interfering. When Galadriel told you there was a choice before you, she also meant choosing Legolas over Arwen. She foresaw what would happen if you married her granddaughter. But what is done is done. You made your choice.”

“I will never see him again, will I? Not even in the afterlife?”

“No.” He hands him a small box, “I found this when I looked through Thranduil’s things. It belonged to Legolas. You should have it.”

Aragorn takes the box and opens it, inside is the greenleaf broach Legolas used to wear. He knows it belonged to Legolas’ mother, he swallows hard, “Thank you.” He stays for another half hour just talking.

-

Gimli walks over to Aragorn, “Ya look like shit.” It is true, Aragorn looks tired and unkempt.

“Good to see you, Gimli. How have you been?”

“Good, just came back from a work trip to Cape Verde. Bilbo told me, so I will cut right to the chase. Legolas was slowly fading; he joined the quest, hoping that he would die and be relieved of the agony of a broken heart. You never noticed, but I did. The more time passed, the less lively he was. He stayed away from Gondor, only coming to see you when he really had to because the hurt was too much for him. Nothing soothed him, and as soon as we arrived in Valinor, it was like he could pretend to be fine, and it only took a few months for him to fade. I always thought it was one-sided until I visited you. You did not see me, but you were clutching his cloak, and you had your face buried in it. That was shortly before you died.”

“I stole his cloak, even centuries later, it still carried his scent. It gave me comfort. I am sorry for putting Legolas through it. I was a coward.”

“Yes, you were,” he gets up, “Have to get home to the wife and kids. See you around.”

-

Aragorn is attending Bilbo’s funeral; it’s been twelve years since he walked into Bilbo’s coffee shop. They met twice a month for tea and to talk about their past lives. Bilbo told him about Legolas and what happened during the Battle of Five Armies. Aragorn told him about their quest and the things Frodo did not tell them. But talking about the past was hard; both were filled with so many regrets. He looks at Gimli, whom he has only seen a handful of times. Gimli is busy with his job and family. He is looking around; many people have shown up. Bilbo was loved in the community. He will miss his friend.

-

Gandalf is spreading Aragorn’s ashes; the man died last week at the age of eighty-seven. Aragorn confided in him years ago that he was fed up with his family trying to push him into marrying and continuing his line by setting him up on dates. They did not accept his choice of remaining alone, and he eventually just cut all ties with them. Aragorn turned into a bitter and cynical man in his old age, burdened by regret. He wishes he could see Aragorn at rest, but there is no rest for him.

Gandalf turns around, “My work here is done.”

“It is. Your task was to bear witness and impart information. You can rest now.”

Gandalf walks into Tom Bombadil’s house, he lies down on the bed, ready for his rest.

Series this work belongs to: