Chapter Text
It was not commonly done; soulmates coming from different races that is. Yavanna had been the one to propose the idea to him.
“Think of our love,” She had said to him one night under a canopy of trees. “Our children are extensions of ourselves. It would be our love sent out into the world.”
And he’d agreed, of course. How could he refuse her anything?
That had been the only other time they had each created two halves of the same whole. One dwarrow and one hobbit destined to be one’s. Their love had blossomed under the summer sky and they had loved each other endlessly. They had loved each other like the sun loved the moon and stars. Much in the way that Äule loved his wife.
Two beings joined as one that could not be separated when death called. Where one went, the other followed shortly after. Spending the rest of eternity in each other's arms.
After much time had passed, his wife had asked once again. It did not take much convincing on her part. He was always weak against his wife's wishes.
Under the light of the stars they each made two halves of the same whole and set them out into the world. Each made in their own likenesses so that their love could once again bless middle earth once more.
Fate , however, is a cruel mistress. A fickle thing, really. One that gives and takes and it is not often that it can be swayed.
If he had known -
They are not supposed to interfere in their lives once they’ve been created. They are not to tempt and sway fate this way or that, because in the end it is their lives to live. Their children had always had free will.
But that does not mean it does not fill him with grief when his children are in pain. It does not mean he cannot hear or feel their agony as they hold a loved one close for the last time.
But Äule has learned from the past that it does not do well to show himself in these moments. To let them know he is near. Loved ones did not always take comfort in knowing he was there to guide their hearts into the afterlife. There was almost always a fight with his children. They would shout, scream, and fight. The pain of losing a loved one is too raw. “You must,” they would tell him; for they knew who he was from the moment he revealed himself. “ You must bring them back!”
“I’m sorry,” he would whisper to them. “I cannot change their fate.”
This time-
This time is different .
His wife is crouched by his side, her tears shining like fresh dew on the morning grass. “My child,” she murmurs, reaching out but not touching.
He does not seem surprised that they are there. No, maybe he had expected them to come in the end. Or perhaps he merely saw them for what they were in that moment. Harbingers of death.
The hobbit curls tighter around his lost love as if trying to protect him.
It was a mistake to come here. Äule knows this. Knew this when his wife demanded to cross into their realm. It would not do well for either of them to see their love cut so short.
But his wife had not listened and crossed over anyways, knowing he would follow wherever she went.
His wife reaches out once more and smoothes out errant curls that have fallen in Bilbo's face. A bitten off sob escapes him and he presses the back of his hand to his mouth to try and stifle the noise.
Äule has to steel himself. Has to stop the wounded sound that tries to claw its way out the back of his throat as he watches the scene unfold. For his wife is a burning star, fierce and unyielding. She is a force of nature so strong and heartachingly beautiful that even he bows to her presence.
This little hobbit had been made in her likeness. It only made sense as he watched him across their short journey that he would grow into just that. Time had passed in just a few short moments for him, but perhaps a lifetime to them. He had seen just how quick witted and sharp he could be. He had seen just how brave and fierce this tiny creature could be. Which is why this hurts Äule so.
He does not fight and shout like his children normally do. He does not demand that he be brought back nor does he try to bargain with him. There is no fight in his soul, Äule realizes. Bilbo’s flame had gone out the moment Thorin’s had.
He merely sits there, eyes staring beseechingly at him as he tries to keep the tears at bay.
"Don't take him from me." He whispers. And it aches, aches, aches because Äule never wanted this.
He thinks, distantly, that this is what it would look like if he were to lose Yavana in some way. Small and broken as the other half of his soul was stolen away and it's hard to bear the sudden grief that tries to swallow him.
Yavanna looks at him like she shares his anguish. Their own love torn apart by the twisted hands of fate.
The love they had intended had barely had time to grow. Had just barely begun to root itself into the ground. Yet it grew as a sapling pokes through the desolation of a forest fire. A hope that, if tended, can grow into something beautiful.
"Please," the hobbit’s voice comes out broken, thick with the tears spilling down his cheeks. " Please ," Bilbo makes a dreadful sound like he's the one dying when he looks back down at him. Strokes back the hair that has fallen into his face. Tucks it behind an ear. "I love him."
Yavanna smooths back the curls that fall into his eyes once more, face twisted in sorrow as she watches her child suffer. "Can we not make an exception?" She whispers.
"It could change everything." Äule responds slowly, a sad frown marring his features. "We cannot change fate."
"We are not supposed to change fate." Yavanna rises from the ground and walks over to him and Äule resists the urge to sway into her. She brings her hands up to cup his jaw. "Just this once, my love."
He goes silent, seemingly thinking.
"If we bring him back-" Äule begins carefully, shooting a look at Bilbo to quiet him when he looks ready to pipe up. " And I do mean if - we would have to bring all three of them back. Their fates were intertwined up until this moment."
His wife says nothing, simply rises from where she had been crouched and approaches her husband. Her hands caress his cheeks and she brushes a stray lock out of his eyes. Äule closes his eyes. Leans into the touch before turning his head and laying a kiss upon her palm.
"What would we do if we did not have each other?" She whispers, "their love was born out of ours. Would you separate us if this was our fate?"
He is silent as he gazes into her eyes. Tries to imagine again a life where she was so cruelly taken from him and has to suck in a steadying breath.
“ Madtubirzul *,” He whispers between them before taking her hand and kissing the back of it. His gaze slides to the hobbit.
He wants to do this. Truely, he does. But…
"This could end badly." He says and he knows by the way she looks at him that she's already thought of the possible consequences this could bring.
"But what if it doesn't ?" She says softly, coaxingly. "Fate changes all the time, does it not?"
Äule shuts his eyes and breaths out a resigned sigh. He has always been weak to his wife’s wishes.
