Actions

Work Header

The Cost of Worth

Summary:

Thorin had a much more difficult time convincing his council about Bilbo Baggins's worthiness than he should have.

or

5 times Bilbo acted like a Dwarf and 1 time him being a Hobbit was everything Thorin needed.

Notes:

June
wedding/proposal | saving the world | (accidental) love confession | "you aren't what i expected" | downpour | soulmate au

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Work Text:

Near death experiences had a tendency of providing perspective to those who survived them. Thorin was now incredibly aware of his own mortality and how close he was to losing everything. 

But, by the grace of the Valar, everyone had lived despite their gruesome injuries. Thorin had been able to reunite with his nephews and company. He was able to apologize to everyone he had wronged. 

The King Under the Mountain had been able to kneel before his burglar and ask for forgiveness for his actions during the dragon sickness and more. And, because some great force seemed to love him, Bilbo had granted it. 

Thorin never knew he could be so happy . But his recovery was steady, as his kin were by his side whenever he needed them, and he didn’t sustain any damage to his head so he was able to read missives just fine. The work was grueling but every hiccup or delay felt manageable with Bilbo by his side.

Rebuilding the mountain and Erebor’s previous political alliances had taken a year. The process quickened every month with more Dwarves traveling to the lonely mountain with the promise of employment. The increase in productivity eventually led to Erebor stabilizing enough for Thorin to finally breathe. 

After he breathed, Thorin asked Bilbo to marry him. Breathing seemed even easier after Bilbo smiled and accepted his proposal.  

Bilbo still missed his books, doilies, and armchair. More than that, the hobbit had worries about being a successful member of a monarchy but Thorin was quick to assure Bilbo that he would be taking on all of the responsibilities himself.   

Despite everything going well, Thorin was completely aware of how quickly grains of sand fell down the hourglass. 

For every stolen moment between the two lovers, there were twice as many meetings or emergencies. There were decrees, legislations, treaties, contracts; more documents than any dwarrow would ever have to read in their lifetime. 

But Thorin read each word with careful detail, as was the duty of the crowned king. He led his people across the world to get his homeland, succumbed to dragon sickness, and dragged his people into a war. So much to make up for, so little time.  

All of this progress sadly came at a price. 

The heads of dwarven noble families, whose fathers or grandfathers had been the advisors of Thror, deigned to travel to the mountain after all of the hard work had already been done. All with demands to be made to return Erebor to what it had once been.

Thorin pushed back the meetings as much as he could. He solved problems of infrastructure he knew were likely to come up. He, to his chagrin, spent time dealing with Bard and Thranduil to strengthen the alliance between the three kingdoms. He spent more time than was strictly allowed to kiss his beloved Hobbit before he had to return to work. No matter what he did, the meeting with the noblemen still sat on his neverending itinerary. 

Thorin could avoid death, but he couldn’t avoid the inevitable for forever.

◅◈▻

The inevitable was the five Dwarves that made up the council of nobles. Elbick was from a long line of merchants and it showed from the copious jewels that were braided into his hair, beard, and clothing. 

Uloth was a proud warrior with a facial scar from the first time the dragon attacked. The damage was so severe that the long line from forehead to jaw always pulled the dwarrow’s mouth into a frown. 

Runli had a friendlier disposition but that only had Thorin more concerned. In the Blue Mountains, nothing seemed to happen without Runli knowing about it. The dwarrow had a gleam in his eye as he toyed with the rings on his thick fingers and looked at Thorin as if he was waiting for the king to tell him information he already knew. 

Flin hid behind the presence of the other Dwarves in the room. Thorin noted that the lad seemed to fidget with his three beard braids when he was nervous. Flin had married into the line of nobles and it showed by the way he seemed to defer to them all before even choosing a seat. 

Fisdrumir took priority on Thorin’s list of concerns. The large forehead, straight nose, and distinct sneer were not features one could easily forget. Thorin had known Fisdrumir’s father and his grandfather and even his great grandfather. Each dwarrow in that line was a staunch traditionalist who believed they were the last line of defense in protecting the sanctity of dwarven traditions. Thorin didn’t remember who died and put that family in charge, but he had some words for them when he finally reached Mahal’s halls. 

Thorin walked in with them, but allowed himself to seek out the gazes of Balin, Dwalin,  Ori, and Fíli. Balin and Fíli stood on either side of Thorin, both ready to offer him wisdom from the previous and newer generations. Dwalin stood behind the five Dwarves with his weapons at the ready. His friend took a passing look at each member of the council and rolled his eyes. However, Thorin did catch the white knuckle grip Dwalin had on his hilt, betraying what the Dwarf was really feeling. Thorin’s eyes slid to Ori, who laid out his writing supplies on the table with precise movements. Thorin was pleased that at least one person on his side was confident. 

Thorin held his head high as he lowered himself into the seat at the head of the table. The other Dwarves followed suit except for Dwalin, who stood vigilant at his post. The scrape of the chairs against the floor echoed loudly but no one else seemed bothered by the noise. 

Thorin opened the meeting with, “Thank you all for coming. How are your families?” 

Thorin politely nodded as they spoke and drummed his fingers underneath the table when they took too long to get to the point. 

Eventually, the pleasantries were dropped in favor of actually doing the work they all came to do. Thorin referenced the appropriate documents as he spoke of the progress they made during the rebuilding of not only the mountain itself, but the infrastructure of the kingdom. 

Thorin repeatedly braced himself for the inevitable criticism, but no one spoke until he finished his report. 

Elbick  broke the silence, “Your Majesty, you’ve gone above and beyond what we thought was possible. You’ve met every expectation of a king. ” 

Uloth grunted his agreement to Elbick’s statement. 

Thorin blinked once and exhaled before he replied, “I thank you.” 

Runli smirked, eyes twinkling, “Don’t be so surprised. We heard about your progress long before we entered this meeting.” 

“Knowing you, that doesn’t surprise me at all.” 

Runli let out a chuckle that Flin quietly spoke over. 

“We’re quite impressed with all of the work you’ve done. The agricultural project was an inspired decision.” 

“Thank you, but I cannot take all of the credit,” Thorin explained. “My One came up with the idea.” 

The air grew stifled with discomfort. Thorin scanned the room to find the source of the shift in mood. 

Flin was making a mess of his beard with all of his fidgeting while Elbick looked at him with polite disdain. Runli twisted the rings on his fingers to purposefully avoid Thorin’s gaze. Uloth gave the game away by staring at Fisdrumir. 

“Ah, yes.” Fisdrumir intoned. “The Hobbit.”  

Thorin never claimed to be the wisest, but there was no denying what the issue was. After everything, Thorin knew Bilbo’s worthiness to be unquestionable. So much so that he forgot how truly unusual the situation was. 

“Bilbo Baggins is a hero who was invaluable in the journey to reclaim Erebor and the defeat of Smaug-!” 

“No one doubts his efforts, King Thorin.” Elbick assuaged. 

“There’s just been talk,” Runli continued coyly. “About how you would conceive Dwarven heirs.”

“I have an heir.” Thorin grunted, gesturing to Fíli. The lad took the comment with more grace than Thorin would have at his age and merely raised an eyebrow. 

“Surely, that can’t be the only concern.” Fíli replied, eyes compelling the council of Dwarves to be honest.  

Fisdrumir had enough honor to speak plainly, “Master Baggins is not a Dwarf.”  

“My One may not have been born a Dwarf, but he has plenty of Dwarven qualities.”

It seemed Thorin needed to tell them about Bilbo. He was confident once he did, they would readily change their minds.

♚♚♚♚♚

Gandalf was a fool to believe that a Hobbit, with no prior knowledge of the quest, would join as a burglar simply because he asked. 

Thankfully, Thorin had already anticipated this. He didn’t expect anyone who wasn’t a Dwarf to care. Men and Elves turned their backs on Dwarves before, Halflings would be no different. 

There was no race on Middle Earth with more honor than a Dwarf. Thorin was sure of it. He knew from experience how difficult it was to get only twelve of his kinsman to join his quest. Because of that, Thorin Oakenshield knew Bilbo Baggins would not be coming along. 

Well… he knew that until he heard the distant shouts of a Hobbit talking about signing the contract. 

♔♚♚♚♚

Outsiders often called Dwarves stubborn creatures. Dwarves called themselves determined. 

It wasn’t much of a surprise to the Dwarves when they managed to escape Goblin Town. No one knew caves better or fought harder than Dwarves. This was also why Thorin was sure that Bilbo had not made it out. Or if he had, he would not want to stay with the company after experiencing such a trial. 

This was surely where Bilbo Baggins would leave him.

But then Bilbo appeared out of thin air to prove him wrong and make him feel like an idiot. The Hobbit then vowed to continue on the quest just to help them claim their home. 

Thorin knew at that moment that determination was not a trait exclusive to Dwarves. 

♔♔♚♚♚

Even before twelve Dwarves agreed to the dangerous quest to reclaim their homeland, Thorin knew his kind were loyal. They could have been made that way by Mahal or forged into intensely loyal creatures after others in Middle Earth had wronged them. Either way, Dwarves were loyal. 

So was Bilbo Baggins. 

The Dwarves spent weeks in the Mirkwood dungeons. Thorin listened as one by one the other members of the party gave up hope of escaping. Thorin hadn’t given up hope. He could never give up hope because Bilbo had yet to be captured by the elves. 

Thorin didn’t get to see Bilbo during this time but he heard his voice and the promises his burglar made. Those promises were enough to sustain Thorin until he heard the jangling of keys. 

♔♔♔♚♚

No matter what Elves said, there were no better craftsmen than Dwarves. Dwarves not only played instruments and wrote songs, they also forged metal into beautiful objects. Not just weapons, but jewelry and tools. 

Dwarves had creativity so strong that it gave them purpose. So when no Dwarf could think of an escape out of the Mirkwood dungeons, Thorin thought all hope was lost. 

Until Bilbo brought them all down to a wine cellar and commanded them all to hop into the empty barrels waiting to be tossed in the river. Thorin was growing increasingly talented at drowning out the complaints of his fellow Dwarves to bask in the presence of Bilbo Baggins, the most creative creature outside of Dwarves. Now, he might have even surpassed them. 

Thorin has only one response to the complaints of his company. 

“Do as he says.” 

♔♔♔♔♚

After the Mirkwood elves turned away the first time the dragon attacked, Thorin assumed that no other race would care about Dwarves as much as Dwarves themselves. 

But apparently Bilbo Baggins was put on Middle Earth to just prove him wrong. 

Bilbo put in countless hours tending to the injured after the battle. After that, he put in even more time helping Thorin with diplomatic disputes and event planning. Thorin knew that Bilbo had a kind heart but he never dreamed of meeting someone who would care for his people alongside him. 

But Bilbo did because Bilbo viewed the company as family. And he loved Thorin most of all. 

◅◈▻

The council didn’t see it that way. At least, it certainly didn’t read that way based on the faces of the five members. Thorin’s tongue was dry from the explanations but he didn’t feel comfortable enough to drink. 

Fisdrumir sighed, “I respect you, Thorin. I do. But it’s our job as your council to remind you of your duty.” 

The stern Dwarf reached down into his bag and set a crown on the table. 

Dwalin gripped his ax tighter to not move from his position behind the council members. Balin raised verbal objections to the display. Fíli looked to Thorin, as if waiting for a signal for how to react. 

Thorin could only stare at the object he detested. 

♔♔♔♔♔

It was just a piece of metal. That was the mantra Thorin repeated to himself as Balin held up his new crown. Blacksmiths and jewelers lined up to be the chosen artisan of the new crown months ago after the final repairs to the mountain had been finished. Now, Thorin stood to look at the final product. 

Per Thorin’s insistent requests, the crown was forged without any jewels, it didn’t even have any carvings. But that wasn’t enough to assuage the Dwarf king’s concerns. Thorin could see that it was made of mithril, the only metal fine enough for a king. 

Thorin lifted his eyes to see the expecting looks from the members of his company. He promised them a proper king before the journey even began. Now, the journey gave each member of the company a new scar that marred their bodies and new ghosts to haunt their dreams. Following tradition, wearing the crown was the least he could do for them after all they have sacrificed. 

Haunted blue eyes returned to the crown. Thorin’s breathing grew harsher as he felt a foreign pulse of delight at the wealth of the crown, the symbol of his rule. He lifted his shaking hands– 

“I’ll never understand the appeal of crowns.” 

Thorin lowered steady hands and turned to his intended. Bilbo stood with his arms crossed, a hip jutted to the side, and a tilt to his head. The posture was far too casual for the sanctity of the event and Thorin couldn’t stop the smile pulling at the corners of his lips. 

“I take it no one wears crowns in the Shire.” 

Bilbo waved a hand in the air as if to dispel the sentence from existence. 

“Certainly not! That would be awfully gaudy. Though on occasion, you’ll see someone with a decent sunhat.” 

If any dwarrow had complaints about Bilbo’s irreverent remarks, Thorin couldn’t hear them over the sound of his own laughter being wrung out of his chest. Bilbo’s responding smile made the cleverness in his darling Hobbit’s eyes shine brighter. 

Bilbo stepped forward and slipped his fingers between Thorin’s before whispering. 

“You look so handsome without a crown hiding your brow.” 

Thorin felt himself flush with a heat that no metal could cool, so wearing the crown seemed rather pointless. 

◅◈▻

Thorin lifted his eyes to meet the gazes of the council. They held the weight of expectation that Thorin had placed on himself since the day he woke up after the battle. After years of rage and determination, Thorin felt the fight leave his body. 

“It seems that I cannot convince you that Bilbo Baggins would make a fine ruler.”

Fisdrumir smiled with the confidence of a man promised victory. 

“Indeed. The King of Dwarves must have a dwarrow or dwarrowdam by his side.”

Pushing the crown forward, he continued.

“This crown has meaning.”

Thorin tempted fate and allowed himself to look at the crown. It was a gray ring with a simple design. Nothing had changed about it since he last looked at it and felt the seductive promise of riches and power. And yet… 

“It’s just a piece of metal.” 

Despite the loud protests and flushed faces of the other Dwarves, Thorin knew this to be true. 

The slamming of his hands against the table quieted the others. Thorin stood tall and let the harsh scrape of the chair legs against the floor speak to his displeasure. 

“Metal does not make a king—”

“A king puts the needs of his people first. A king listens to his council!” Fisdrumir  bellowed. 

In spite of the tension in the room, Thorin found himself chuckling at the statement. 

“Then perhaps I should step down as king.” 

The council screamed their outrage, as did Dwalin and Balin, but Thorin ignored them to look at Fíli. The boy, perhaps now finally a man, looked just like his father. Fíli was his sisterson, the only one he would choose as his heir. 

Fíli hid his smile by twirling one of his mustache braids. He looked utterly unsurprised at the turn of events, which was more than Thorin could say. Perhaps that was a sign of the reign the young prince would have. 

The pair traded a look with more weight than physically passing the crown could ever do. Fíli was ready to be king and Thorin was ready to go home. 

Fisdrumir snarled. 

“All of this, for a mere Halfling?”  

Thorin, no longer pinned down by a mask of political politeness, couldn’t stop the tugging at the corners of his mouth. He smiled and nodded.

“Thorin, son of Thrain, you are not what I expected.” 

“Then I’m even luckier than I thought.” 

Attention was drawn away from Thorin when Fíli promptly snatched the crown from the table and placed it upon his golden locks. Thorin gave the new king a bow before leaving the meeting room. 

The yelling grew quieter the further down the hall Thorin walked. He felt so light that he couldn’t muster concern for the heavy footfalls behind him. 

“Shouldn’t you be protecting the new king?”

“He’ll never need me as much as you did,” Dwalin replied. “He’s not as likely to attack a noble for saying something stupid.” 

“I’m glad you agree he’ll make a fine king.”

“Aye, he will. But what will you do?” 

Thorin slowed his gait to a stop. Thorin looked at the familiar halls of his ancestors before speaking.

“I’ll find some books and an armchair. I’ll plant something and watch it grow. I’ll get used to the warmth of the wooden floors of a Hobbit hole and try not to miss the stone. I’ll even put in the effort to see the appeal of a doily.” 

Dwalin huffed out a quick laugh before regarding Thorin with a critical gaze. 

“You’ve changed, Thorin.” 

“Yes. For the better, this time.”

The grains in the hourglass never stopped, but Thorin took his time saying goodbye to his people, to his company, and to his family. He and Bilbo waited until Spring to start their journey and felt no need to rush towards their destination. 

It took several months to reclaim all of the furniture stolen from Bilbo’s home and several years for Bilbo to not be angry about it. Thorin planted the garden with only two in mind. He found an armchair and several books he liked. 

He never understood the appeal of doilies but he planted an oak tree and watched it grow. 

He never again felt the desire for more.

Notes:

This fic was a pain in the ass to write. Why did I try to make a 5+1 fancy?

This couldn't have been done without the support and suggestions from my beta reader Alana. Thank you for always supporting my nonsense!

Series this work belongs to: