Actions

Work Header

If Thranduil Were a Cake, What Kind of Cake Would He Be?

Summary:

This is a very calm, innocent, and technical story about baking cakes without scandals, catastrophes, and AU typical mayhem. Baking is not my forte, so please, take anything I say with a pinch of salt. Specifically, I do not have any idea how large princess cakes can be made, but huge mounds of pastry cream cannot be structurally sound.

Notes:

(See the end of the work for notes.)

Work Text:

"And bang, like that I am in charge of their wedding cake. I don't know much about baking wedding cakes, though I know a lot about eating them. I didn't have one."

He didn’t wait until the wedding was over to talk with Bombur. He has waited until the kitchens had prepared and served the dinner before rushing to his friend’s private office where he experiments with new recipes and contemplates on his culinary triumphs.

"A wedding cake is not a dwarven thing. But you did not say no to the treacle and porter pudding. Three helpings if I remember correctly."

It had been an excellent pudding indeed.

"It is a Hobbit thing, but I am afraid the kind of cake we have for the weddings would not be appropriate. It is rather .... spotty, and I don't think King Thranduil would appreciate something spotty. And you should keep a piece of it for celebrating the firstborn, so there is the fertility aspect, which we hopefully don’t have to take into account."

The cake might be something that the Dwarves would appreciate, though, especially if it was well fed.

"I could bake one for the mid-winter for us, it is not only for weddings. There are nuts and fruits in it, and of course distilled spirits, so it fits the season well."

They would need candied fruit from the south, but they are indeed a most innocent thing to buy, aren't they, and not causing any scandals.

"I think that you should start with thinking what kind of cakes Thranduil and Bard would be, and then combine them. It would help if you knew what they like."

"Bard likes cream puffs, the pink ones, maybe I could just make huge heaps of them and add jam and other stuff to make them more festive."

"Nah, there should be those, of course, but whatever you do with them it will not become a proper centrepiece, you need one at a feast. Taste this.”

He had noticed the delicious scent of mushroom filling but had been too upset about the cake issue to pay much attention to it. He licks the spoon pushed under his nose.

"Excellent, thyme?"

"I thought it needed herbal tones to cut the savouriness a bit. Sage was bad, but this is rather good if I say so myself. I have the shell in the icebox, so we can have some pie and tea before going to bed. But back to the cakes."

Nothing promises a better night's sleep than an excellent mushroom pie, and together with Bombur they will revolutionise spicing them.

"We have something called a princess cake, named after one very haughty daughter of a former Thain. I guess they originally thought it an insult to make a cake with a lot of filling and not much cake. But it is quite lovely with a lot of cake cream and jam, covered with a layer of sugar and almond paste. The paste is dyed pinkish with dried, powdered strawberries. It doesn't have any spots or lumps, so it should find approval."

Looking at it from the Erebor perspective, insult by pastry as practiced in the Shire is rather petty, especially as the cake is a pleasant summer treat and pretty to look at. 

"So, it is mostly cream and yolk filling covered with something a bit denser. Let me do some calculations."  Bombur takes a piece of paper, draws a diagramme, he shudders at the sight, and starts to calculate. 

It takes a while, and some harrumphing. The evening shift is putting away their knives after finishing the preparations for the breakfast in the main kitchen. When Estrid comes to report the situation and to say good night, he shakes his head, and the woman casts a pitying look at him. Bombur is famed for his stubborn dedication to planning where a lesser soul would succumb to trial and error.

"I believe that such a cake would be structurally unsound if made large enough, it would not be able to carry its own weight without collapsing. So it is out of the question, even if it sounds appropriate otherwise."

He is not willing to give up on it quite yet.

"What if we had a special cake stand made? We could have smaller cakes and decorations like garlands added to it, and even the stand itself could have, you know curlicues and stuff. It would make an excellent centrepiece."

And still, in his heart of hearts he believes that the cake should be the main thing, not some metal contraption with or without flowers. Apparently Bombur shares his opinion as he sighs and shakes his head.

"I think a structurally sound cake would be a better choice.”

The cake should not be all about Thranduil either, it should have something of both.

"We have concentrated too much on the Elven king whereas as far as we know, a wedding cake is more a Mannish than an Elvish thing. They strike me as more like syllabub or fool, or even trifle people. But no, they would not do as centrepieces either."

Bombur looks nonplussed, the dwarves, bless their little woollen socks, are definitely pudding people.

"I will explain them later. What kind of cake do you think Bard would be?"

Bombur doesn't hesitate, at all, which is a bit suspicious.

"A yeast cake done with brown sugar, currants and butterscotch frosting. That is what his ancestors favoured; I don't think they have baked them since Smaug came. They take more time, that's why they have creampuffs and biscuits, they can be done quickly. The dragon was attracted to fires, and no one wanted to invite it to destroy their new homes."

He had not thought, or understood it properly, that sometimes the dragon needed to hunt for something to eat, even if it had done so very seldom during its last years. "Does anyone know how to make a yeast cake?"

"They baked them in Erebor, too, so some of the old books of recipes would have it. We can test them. It would be nice to serve him some when he visits us next. It is all Bard, though, so would it go with what you have planned for Thranduil?"

He doubted very much that two different types of batter would make a successful cake.

"I thought a white cake would be the best choice, we can use the yolks for making the cake cream, so nothing goes to waste. A marbled cake is the most sensible solution. White is for Thranduil, and if we colour the other half of the batter with something like blueberries, we have a symbol of their union just like that. Marbled cake is not usually used for a layered cake, so it adds value to it, it is not like the other cakes. I am sure Thranduil will love that aspect of it."

Bombur doesn't look very enthusiastic but rather nauseous. "What colour will it be when baked?

"Kind of purplish grey, not really Bard's colour, but it has a certain rustic tone which contrasts nicely with the smoothness of the Thranduil half."

Bombur turns away, with his back shaking.

"What is wrong, did someone unreliable pick the mushrooms? Do I need to call Oin?"

Bombur shakes his head and after some more dry heaving, he can finally talk. "No, that won't do at all, Dwarves don’t eat anything purple. I cannot even think about that colour in connection with anything to eat without feeling sick. I am sorry."

"There is no need to apologise for something you cannot help. We can just make white cake and carrot cake layers, with cake cream, and there was that jam Lady Hjördis brought the last time they were visiting us, it would add a little zing to it, like King Thranduil tends to do when he gets involved in something."

He is not completely happy with the cake as such, it is a bit too sober but perhaps there is no way to have a cake to fulfil so many ridiculous criteria.

"Cloudberries, yes, a good choice, they are precious, and golden, and thus quite appropriate for a royal wedding. Now I think the filling has cooled down enough, so if you don't mind, I will put the pie in the oven."

He had been a bit worried about the pie not getting baked, so he does not mind at all 

The waiting time should be put into profitable use, and he starts to calculate the ingredients required for a truly huge cake. It is his favourite type of calculation, and it takes him some time to realise that Bombur stands at the door of his office, with a look of someone having a revelation to end all revelations.

The revelation is followed by suspicious glances to all directions and a door locked behind him.

"There is something I need to show you." 

He is used to Bombur's private cabinet containing all kinds of culinary surprises, but none of them has been under a lock and key and presented in such a secretive way.

When the box is open, it contains a block of dull, dark brown stuff with some chips shaved off.

"Taste it."

He sniffs the chip, it has a scent the kind he has never smelled before, sweet, but more complicated than honey, definitely better than sugar and even if the stuff looks dry, it melts in his fingers. It tastes vile.

"Horrible, isn't it, but now taste this."

The lighter brown ball is larger than a hazelnut but smaller than a walnut and very suspicious looking.

"Come on, it won’t bite."

But it bites deep into the seat of his taste, and touch. It melts on his tongue and fills his mouth with the sweet softness of something he has never felt before. It tastes like the languidness after lovemaking, his best childhood memories and the perfect revenge against his enemies all rolled into a ball.

"What is this, where did you get it? No, let me guess, it is from the winking southerner’s emporium."

At that moment, he loves the man like a brother.

"He says that it is from very far south, and thus quite expensive. I have experimented a little with it, just some sweets like these, and drinks. We could try how it works with baked goods. Maybe biscuits or something like that first. He will have the next shipment only at the end of summer"

It is getting late, there is a mushroom pie in the offing, and dear Thorin will be waiting for him.

"What are we waiting for?"

After checking that the main kitchen is free from spying eyes, they establish their baking station there.

"It goes well with all kinds of nuts and berries, well, it goes well with everything I have tried with it, but I believe berries could be used in a wedding cake."

In the end they had nuts, dried blueberries, and pieces of fudge to test with their biscuits. When the first batch of dough is ready, they remember the mushroom pie, a little worse for the too long baking time, but still quite delicious.

At first, they are figuring out the right amount of...

"What do they call this stuff?"

"The people who grow it and invented how to make use of it call it Food of Gods in their own tongue, but it is so new in the north that it does not have a proper name in Westron."

"That is too long, and a bit silly. Let's call it fodgo for the time being and then figure out a better name later."

They figure out the proper amount of fodgo for having a nice colour and lovely, sweet taste. Even the not perfect specimens are still very good, and instead of brewing a pot, they decide to eat them with some milk while discussing whether they should go next into the frostings or whether to proceed directly to cakes. 

"Why are you still here, it's past midnight? Come to bed, amrâlimê."

Thorin is standing at the kitchen door yawning and peering at the mess they have made on the table and on themselves.

"You have to distract him; we should keep this a secret and disclose it on a suitable occasion like the wedding."

Fortunately, there is still the pie, and Thorin loves mushrooms like any Dwarf worth his salt.

"I am sorry, sweetheart, we wanted to try something for the wedding cake, and forgot the time. But we have a mushroom pie, Bombur's improved recipe." He pushes the pie tin towards Thorin with some regret and a fork. "You can eat it straight from the tin. Bombur, some ale for the king!"

His husband looks bewildered but takes the fork and after the first bite tackles the pie like a personal enemy. Bombur has the presence of mind to bring the biggest tankard and fill it to the brim.

With dear Thorin happy and well-provided for, they return to their baking, and decide to try simple square tin cakes, so that they can test some fillings too. There is no cake cream available, and they are too eager to experiment to make any, so they decide to use whipped cream instead.

While the cakes are in the oven, they try everything sweet they find in the kitchen with fodgo. Dipping oatmeal biscuits to melted fodgo with some sugar and cream, excellent, covering nuts and raisins with it, lovely, and even better with a little salt, melted fodgo with milk, melted fodgo with strawberries, something to die for.

His husband is sleeping against the wall, snoring softly, with only a few crumbs left of the pie and his tankard empty. 

"That pie should be on the meal rotation. I volunteer for picking mushrooms if help is needed. He looks quite sweet like that."

Bombur mutters something incomprehensible. The beauty criteria of dwarves are very different from those of the hobbits. But that is their problem. 

"I think we should leave the frosting for another night with desserts. Let's just clean up, eat that last bit of cake and go to bed."

"Not so fast, Bombur. How do I know that you are not planning on poisoning the king with your new-fangled concoctions; he looks far too relaxed.” Nori apparently never sleeps and is now sniffing the air standing by the back door. "The air smells definitely poisonous."

"How about you cook your food for the next couple of weeks? And don't you have a husband to pleasure?"

"Nah, they had a mock orc attack for the new recruits, and he ended up defending Raven Hill all by himself. I lathered him with the liniment and left him to wallow in his shame about the low quality of our lads, no one wants to listen to that. And I made a good call, it seems."

He exchanges a glance with Bombur who grimaces and shrugs.

"You know you could just ask. Perhaps test the fares then and take some for your poor injured husband. Perhaps some biscuits, a piece of cake, and some strawberries dipped in the fodgo, Dwalin likes strawberries, and will stop whining if he has some, won't he?"

Nori looks interested, so a little bit of blackmailing will not go astray.

"Of course, you should not tell anyone about this. We are planning a new kind of cake for the wedding. If you do, you will indeed be doing your own cooking for the rest of the year."

Nori winks. "It is indeed better that I check the fare, and if you want to keep this secret, you should perhaps put them into a box."

They pack away most of the leftovers into a bowl and hand it to the spy chief, who traipses off happily and leaves them with the final piece of cake layered with fodgo cake and strawberries with whipped cream.

It is perfect.

"I think this is the cake we will make for the wedding."

***

Gentle reader, that was his worst mistake ever (or rather so far, as there is still quite a lot of time left to make other mistakes). 

Notes:

If Sauron still could take his fair form, I would suspect that Tenhi the Southern Merchant is indeed a version of Annatar trying to accomplish what the Seven Rings could not do and corrupt the Dwarves with porn, chiffon, and chocolate. At least, they seem to work better than the rings. 

Series this work belongs to: