Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Category:
Fandoms:
Relationships:
Characters:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Series:
Part 7 of But Now, Mahal Knows, Anything Goes
Stats:
Published:
2022-12-21
Words:
2,876
Chapters:
1/1
Kudos:
38
Hits:
0

The Book Detectives

Summary:

A little interlude before we are forced to tackle the royal courtship/wedding issue.

Notes:

(See the end of the work for notes.)

Work Text:

"Have you ever thought wh..."

He had been pleasantly immersed in a Sindarin translation of a book on dwarven courtship rituals and thus did not notice Nori sneaking into his personal nook in the library and settling on the side table until he opens his mouth. He manages not to hear the rest of the question due to having his hands firmly on his ears.

"No, I haven't. Every time someone comes with a question like that, I end up doing something horrible and embarrassing. This time I will not rise to the bait."

He presses his hands harder when Nori says something. He is not going to listen because he wants to have a nice day doing research for his book and the Courting Habits are throwing new light to some of the mysterious goings-on on their Quest. Ori warned him that the book is a very old one, from the Second Age, salvaged from the libraries of Moria, so it is not quite describing the present-day mores. But apparently the House of Durin doesn't mind being old-fashioned.

His admiration for those librarians, who while escaping orcs and worse, still had the presence of mind to pack valuable books and scrolls and drag them all the way to Erebor, is immense. What is intriguing is why they had taken a Sindarin guide to courtship rituals with them in the first place. Especially as so many valuable books had perished.

After the Guild of Scholars and Librarians had judged him scholarly enough to become a member, based on his little treatise on comparing plant life in the Shire and Erebor, alas those carefree days were far behind, they had invited him to a secret lament.

It is his first secret ritual ever, so he is proud to be included, even if he cannot participate in it in full. At least not quite yet, because it consists of singing, in Dwarvish, names of the books that do not exist anymore. It had been eerie and very sad, and he had almost started to tell dear Thorin about it but realized with a shock that there were Dwarven secrets that belonged to him, and not to his husband. He still doesn’t know what to think about it.

Nori tapped his hand.

"What?" He cupped one hand just a little to hear the answer.

"You don't even have to leave the library, just to think about the matter."

"I was told that I did not have to leave the kitchen the time Bombur wanted to bake me into a pie!"

"For the last time, he did not want to bake you, it was just a pie shell and he thought that it would have been funny if you would have jumped out of the pie while we were celebrating the king's birthday. He has a weird sense of humor."

It had not been funny at all, very few attempts to pervert the dinner are.

"We had been promised a mushroom pie, my husband was waiting for it specifically, and my jumping out of it would have been a betrayal of the worst kind."

"But you would have been tastefully wrapped with mushroom garlands. Thorin would have appreciated that."

He has a strong feeling that Nori is talking about that disgraceful event just to misdirect him somehow.

"They would have been mushed and unhygienic after I had been hiding in the pie, for what, an hour or so. I don’t want to discuss this."

“And yet you started the discussion. All Dwarves have eaten worse things than food stuff warmed by their spouse’s skin. Of course, it means that hair gets stuck in one's teeth, which looks messy"

He hopes sincerely that the courting book would not be making too many references to such practices. Feeding strawberries to one's beloved or sharing a cake were intimate enough for his sensibilities.

"Very well, what did you want to ask from me?" Certainly nothing that doesn’t have the potential of becoming at least a domestic disaster. Nori looks very pleased with himself.

"So, have you ever thought about who wrote the Book? It wasn't dropped into Balin's hands by an eagle flying by, that much is certain."

He has not thought about it, he does not want to think about the Book at all. Indeed, someone has had to put a quill on the paper and compose the dratted thing. He would like to know how they could have faced their family and friends after a day of drafting such stories.

"I guess it was a Man, they are often interested in lewdness and violence."

"But how would they have known about all those people so well? They do obviously know some stories and poems of old, but how did they leap from those scattered facts to such imaginings?"

"You know as well as I do that the gossips don't need more than half a word to build a net of false information and malicious intent."

At least certain inhabitants of Hobbiton had been very well-versed in that skill, but the good folk of Erebor were no innocents either.

"If it were only illicit couplings and inventive violence, I am sure we could blame its existence on the Men, but it is about real emotions and love in strange places too, which kind of shows that it was written by someone, who had some real understanding of the characters, not just an ordinary peddler of lewd stories."

His cheeks must be scarlet verging on purple. He has not blushed so shamefully since he had been a youngster third of his age rushing accidentally to the Thain's bedroom while visiting his mother’s family.

Nori smirks.

"Who would have suspected that the great scholar and an overall decent hobbit, who despises mushroom garlands, read the Book only for the naughty bits? I cannot wait to tell that to Balin and Dís, they will find it very funny."

"Are you trying to blackmail me? And they certainly read it for the naughty bits, too"

"Am I succeeding? And we are not talking about them, we are talking about you."

Objectively, admitting his skimming over the descriptive bits and discussions would only mean little teasing and some supposedly funny remarks about his lewd ways, but he likes to keep the tatters of his dignity, thank you very much. Although Nori might still tell them, even if he did what was asked. For the small possibility that he wouldn't, and because the topic of the author has started to interest him despite all his legitimate misgivings, he folds, once again.

"You win. What do you suggest we should do about establishing the writer of that tosh?"

"First I think we should talk with Ori."

He thinks that he must have misheard, Nori can be foolhardy, but he is not suicidal, which it would be to get the youngest Ri brother mixed up with anything remotely clandestine.

"Dori will kill us if we corrupt his little star."

"Little star my arse, he is an annoying little twerp, but he knows his books. Fortunately, he is also working with some manuscripts in one of the private studies on the floor below, and he always has his lunch around this time."

"And by accident you also happen to have the Book with you, don't you? Balin should find a new hiding place for it and have his locks changed." As if Nori couldn't get in anywhere, he wanted anyway.

He pushes aside his work; everyone knows better than to meddle with it.

The chambers downstairs are for studying those books and scrolls that had not fared well under Smaug's rule and need to be copied with great care and not moved around while it was done. Ori has already put away his pen and magnifying glass and is stretching luxuriously.

"Hello Bilbo, Nori, do you want to have lunch with me? They have the red hot Dorwinion stew today."

He is not as alarmed as he probably should be when Nori locks the door behind them.

"You will be thankful for that far sooner than you imagine now, Bilbo. Ori, we want your expert opinion on a book."

Nori fishes the book out of his pocket, it is starting to look a little worse for wear.

"I told them that they should use sturdier cloth for the covers. Nothing is as good as leather, but this is ridiculous."

He can tell that Nori is trying to cover his surprise, he does not even bother.

"You know this book?" Ori is turning it around in his hands and tut-tutting at smudges and signs of wear on the corners and edges.

"There were some traders from around Lake Rhûn, just putting out feelers, Balin said, eager to establish old trading routes that were ancient history to them. They had some books because they thought we might be interested."

"Yes, yes, but are you familiar with this specific book?"

"No, Balin had it first, and then after paging through it, he asked the book to be given to him as a token of goodwill. I had another one, something they called an Almanack. It had a lot about farming and such stuff, so I gave it to one of the Dale delegations visiting us at that time. They seemed to find it useful. Can we go to lunch now, I have been here since the second bell?"

There is some ruckus in the corridor, and someone is trying all the doors. Nori puts his finger across his lips and slides down the shutters of the lantern. Waiting in the dark brings unpleasant memories of the dragon, and there isn’t darkness deeper or more penetrating than that at the heart of the mountain.

They wait for a long time before Nori raises the shutters again and they blink at the sudden return of light.

"What was that?"

"Lady Dís, I'll explain later. Did they say anything about the book?"

Ori bites his lower lip.

"Come to think about it, the trader was a bit weird, he winked at Balin and said they had had a lot of them made by order. You see they had this thing called movable type they had learned about from some Easterlings. It is really quite fascin..."

"You can tell us about it later. Who had ordered them? It must have been very expensive and taking a very long time, or many copiers."

Who had been subjected to those stories through no fault of their own.

"No, no, that's the thing with the movable type. You cast little letters on blocks and put them on a grooved tray in a mirror image of the words, then you roll ink on them, nice and neat, put a paper on top, push it through a press and you can take as many copies of it as you want, at least until the letters get worn."

"O that’s why the letters were neat, but unevenly inked. Did he say where they had delivered them?"

With the fact that there had been many of them, someone was planning on spreading the Book far and wide, and the purpose must have been to hurt the reputation of Elves. Gandalf had talked about the enemy vanquished at the end of the second age, and perhaps now planning for a return. It must have been some of his minions.

"They told Balin that they had taken them somewhere north of Emyn Muil and delivered them to a troop of travelling men with a funny accent. They had settled the account and that's the last the Rhûnians saw the books or heard of them."

That made his theory of the servants of the enemy less plausible, surely, they would have just killed them and stolen their things.

"Is there anyone living in the North?"

"There are some scattered villages on this side of the mountains, and some Mirkwood Elves hunt and patrol there. There is the Enchanted Forest, too, and its deranged elves, but I don't think they would like to have anything as ugly as this and are probably writing with moon beams on petals."

"But there is the Old Forest Road across the mountains, and there are people living on the western side of them, many kinds of people."

Nori nods sagely; unfortunately, they might be people they know.

"I WANT TO HAVE SOMETHING TO EAT!"

 It appears that Ori is taking more after Dori than he had assumed. He is also a bit hungry, it is already a couple of hours since the elevenses. Nori unlocks the door but when he tries to follow Ori, he is detained.

"Let's wait and see if he gets waylaid."

They wait until Ori's footsteps disappear into the blessed silence of the library.

"What was that?" His sister-in-law had been quite cheerful in the morning, preparing to spend the day in the open court listening to petitions with dear Thorin, who relied on his sister’s knowledge in guild and trade matters.

"There were envoys both from Dale and Mirkwood, and everyone was waiting for bad news, so all except Lady Dís were quite relieved when it turned out that they both wanted to ask her to be a chaperone for their respective kings. She is, after all, a respectable widow and used to the vagaries of royalty."

"I take it that she doesn't consider herself to be a respectable widow?"

"Not in the least. She is going to do it, though. One is not chaperoning two kings a-courting very often. It doesn't prevent her from wanting to spill the blood of everyone else involved. So Balin is hiding in the Chambers of Healing, because Oín won't allow any shouting or fighting there, we are here, and Gloín is the scapegoat because this is mainly his fault."

That is very hypocritical from Nori, but better Gloín than them. Unfortunately, it also means that he can’t have any lunch and they still need to hide in the library. But it leaves time for considering the mystery of the author of the book.

"They have to be somehow connected with the Elves to know all those stories, so it can only be someone living close to the Grey Havens or Rivendell. You lived close to the Havens, are they the kind of place where someone would hear such gossip?"

 He had always thought they must be a melancholic and rather dismal place, but Gandalf had seemed happy to spend time there.

"They do have traders coming and going, building ships requires materials, and the Elves are sailing for days if not weeks before they are wherever they are going to, so food is needed, too. Círdan, who runs the place, is older than some mountains and certain heavenly bodies, so he would definitely have known the people in those stories, but he kind of keeps his own counsel."

He wonders what Nori has been doing in the Elven settlement, stealing, or spying, or just listening to poetry.

"I think Rivendell is a better bet though, they have a library, and have northerners coming and going all the time."

He had enjoyed his visit to Rivendell very much, his mother had been in the Hidden Valley once or twice, and everyone had been very gracious.

A horrible idea started to take form in his mind. "What if it was an Elf or some Elves? They would know of the people and stories and songs. For all we know, they might just be bored and want to have some fun."

Although having all those books made was not just private fun, it was an attempt to spread the word of their less than glorious past.

"I think you are into something there. They certainly have the materials, also in that forbidden language, and time to indulge in such matters."

"Forbidden language? O you mean Quenya. The author uses also Quenyan names, like he had known the people by their original names. Aren't there some very old elves living there? There was that one, the one with golden hair, who knew about the swords, for example. They might be going a bit funny in their old age."

The fact that he doesn't like the theory doesn't make it less possible. How they got the manuscript to Rhûn was a bit of a problem unless....

"Do you think it could be Elrond himself? He appears to be related to everybody, and Gandalf says he has been bored."

They look at each other for a while, but eventually shake their heads. It is a silly idea, and the Elf in question is wise and noble.

"Maybe we should think about it later with a clearer head and less work to do." He really needs to get through the courting rituals by the end of the week.

"You are right, I should go and check whether Gloín is still in one piece, and by the way, don’t tell him about the moving type thing, he will want to have one.”

Nori was already between the nearest bookshelves when he turned back, grinning. “If you are interested in other naughty bits, you should check a dwarf named Narvi, that book will make a lot more sense after that.

 









 

Notes:

You can bet your bottom Dollar or Euro or currency of choice on Elrond having written the Book.