Work Text:
It was a dark and stormy night. This in itself was quite unusual for the Shire. Generally rain fell there like honey on morning toast: generous and plentiful, but over in a snap and almost never unwanted. Storms were a thing that happened in Bree, and other places further off.
After all of his adventures, Bilbo Baggins had more experience with them than most of his neighbors. Subsequently, he did not sit out under an awning with a chair to watch the flashing lightning as many hobbits did, but instead holed up in his study to work. A storm brought memories like a rockslide in the Misty Mountains, with furious intensity and overwhelming, inescapable demands. As if before his very eyes, that scowling, disappointed face filled the whole of his thoughts. He stared at a single sentence, his eyes tracing back and forth, unable to read a word. His hand went to the ring in his pocket, tracing over that soothing gold band again and again.
The sudden knock at the door came as a relief.
Springing from his desk, Bilbo rushed to the front hall, eager to help a guest in out of the rain. When he opened the door, however, he saw nothing. No one. Another vision of a dead friend, but no real person. Bowing his head, he let the door drift closed.
A meaty dwarven hand caught the green wood with a thud.
“Have you no greeting for me at all, Master Baggins?” The voice sounded like Thorin’s. Grave. Important. Too big for the room.
“No.” Backing away, Bilbo mustered what bravery he could and yanked Sting from his umbrella stand.
The creature stopped advancing. “Surely you do not fear me?”
It looked like Thorin. His long black hair was plastered to his face with rainwater, just as it had been after their escape from Mirkwood by way of a rushing river. Between his nose and the curve of his mouth, the profile was almost correct. But his skin was ash pale and his face too stiff. An imperfect copy. Looking him in the eyes was impossible. Bilbo could not bear it.
“It is not fear but caution that raises my blade, wight.” Giving lie to this sentiment was the quaver of Bilbo’s voice, but he tried. “Back! Be gone! Trouble me not, specter.”
“Bilbo.” The wraith stepped forward, into Bag End, and the hobbit had no heart to defend his threshold. He dropped his sword and bowed his head, permitting the entry.
“A cup of tea perhaps.”
Huffing a little laugh, the wraith swept off his hood and cloak, hanging it on one of the many pegs by the door. “Please.”
Putting the kettle on the stove, setting saucers then cups upon the tray, and pouring cold milk into his grandmother’s silver creamer calmed Bilbo immeasurably. Glittering blue eyes watched from a corner of the kitchen, following him into the sitting room. Thorin accepted a cup and saucer with a small smile, even a few polite noises, but he didn’t drink. He didn’t speak.
“Well then,” said Bilbo, running out of patience. “What brings you to Bag End?”
“Can I not visit an old friend?”
“You are dead.”
“Yes.”
“Then you cannot visit! The dead do not drink tea, Master Oakenshield.”
Thorin looked down at his tea cup. “No. We do not.”
“Well,” repeated Bilbo, feeling it entirely insufficient. “Well, then. I should like an explanation.”
Steam swirled up from Thorin’s cup; his fingers, curled around it, were white as the porcelain. “Some secrets belong only to the dwarves, Master Baggins.”
“Surely you have not come all this way only to say what I may not know.”
“No.” There was a stillness to the dwarf, holding his tea while making no move to drink. “I came to see you.”
This was far too much for the little hobbit, who felt tears stinging his eyes. He did not want to blink. Having met Thorin’s gaze, he could not look away. “Will you stay?”
“I cannot.” The dwarf bowed his head. “Perhaps it was wrong to come.”
Alarmed, Bilbo reached out to grab his wrist, as though Thorin would leave at once. As though Bilbo could stop him if he chose to. Touching that pale skin froze Bilbo’s palm to the point of pain, like thrusting his hand through a sheet of ice. He held on.
Gently, Thorin withdrew his arm. He refreshed Bilbo’s tea from the cozy little pot. Part of Bilbo expected the porcelain to shatter as something so cold gripped the hot handle, but Southfarthing pottery was more resilient than it appeared. It did not break.
“I did not know.” The words were as close to an apology as the dwarf usually managed. “I did not think it would be like this.”
Bilbo tried not to think about a distant Carrock where warmth once enveloped his body so completely. He failed. “What did you think it would be like?”
“Once a year, on this day, a dead dwarf may visit those he left behind.”
“Oh?”
“It is not like this. We—they—the living put out liquor and light braziers to warm the dead. The dead see and hear those left behind, but they—we do not speak. They cannot be seen or heard, save only rarely by the very wise or the wholly innocent, who thereafter are seldom certain of the interaction.”
“You look real enough.”
“Yes. It is strange. There is a gravity to Bag End unlike any I have felt. There is something about this place. About you, Bilbo.”
A tear fell then. The hobbit couldn’t help it. Quickly brushing it away, he wiggled his nose and cleared his throat. “Hardly. I had no idea there was anything particular about tonight other than this unseasonable weather. If you would prefer strong brandy, you have only to say.”
A smile hid in Thorin’s sigh. “I can no more drink the liquor than I can the tea.”
“Then why have you come?! We said our goodbyes, Thorin. I mourned you. I have mourned you for years.”
“I wanted only to see you. I did not think to be seen. I did not think to hurt you.”
“You never do. What good are your intentions? You should be here. Really here. Can you choose to stay?”
“No.”
“How long?”
“Not long. Until sunrise. It took me some time to realize I could manifest here. I thought you would prefer it if I did so at the door instead of in your study.”
“So you did choose.”
Thorin simply looked at Bilbo, placid and unyielding as the grave. He did not meet the hobbit’s arguments with the same fiery temper that so lit him in life. It was for Bilbo to decide if he wanted to spend the time in anger.
“I miss you,” said the hobbit.
“As I do you.”
Bilbo pressed the palms of his hands hard against his eyes. There was nothing else to say. The tea was cold.
“I will not come again,” said Thorin.
“Don’t go.”
“I will not come again.”
His lips were ice: hard, immovable, and painfully cold. Strong arms crushed Bilbo to that frigid chest, leeching all the warmth and life from his smaller frame. Convulsing against the hold like a body wracked with bone-breaking fever, he tilted his chin up for another kiss. He did not pull away, not even when his body could tolerate the chilling touch no more. Not even when all the world went dark.
In the morning, seeing a sky blue hood with a silver tassel still hanging in his entryway, Bilbo Baggins sank to the floor. Pulling it about himself like a blanket, he wept until his eyes were red and his voice was hoarse, just as he had that day on the mountainside.
Some things never leave us.
