Actions

Work Header

Letters to a Lord

Summary:

After a split between the Dwarven King of Erebor and The Gentle Hobbit of the Shire, Thranduil feels entirely too put out by the horrible mood of Thorin, so what does any good ruler do when their near neighbor is far too grumpy to put up with anymore? He writes a letter to a fellow elf to talk shit. It was just supposed to be a way to vent, but somehow other beloved characters end up in the middle of this feud. Lines are draw and crossed. Espionage... sort of, definitely intrigue and deception. Humor also.

Notes:

This has nothing to do with any cannon; if things are spelled wrong or inaccurate- you're damn right they are, but feel free to let me know anyways, I will fix what I can!

Also, and I cannot say this enough- the whole story is told via letters between Thranduil and Elrond. Its about Bilbo and Thorin's relationship and like 1 year where things were very rocky. The actual story of Thorin and Bilbo's spat is barely addressed. This is just Elrond and Thranduil being sassy old immortals just looking to gossip.

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Work Text:

Dear Elrond,
It has been only 2 weeks since Master Bilbo made his way back through my domain and onto the Misty Mountains. 2 weeks of having to deal with the King of bad moods and worse tact. Please for the care of myself and the longevity of my kingdom, when next you see Master Bilbo pick him up turn him around and force him to march all the way back to Erebor. I fear I will not make it more than the year with the stubbornness of Dwarves constantly dogging my heels and traversing my woods.
Send help, or at least stronger wine,
King Thranduil, King of the Woodland Realm, Purveyor of Finite Patience, Eternally Annoyed.

Dear Thranduil,
I was very curious to get your last missive as I was unaware of the instability of your kingdom and its neighboring allies. Master Baggins has since come to Rivendell and returned to his Shire.
I did attempt to understand the circumstances of his hasty return from Erebor, but upon my first questioning of him, the Hobbit shrank in on himself and began to weep!
I have never felt worse of any action in my whole existence and nothing shall compare to the contriteness I showed upon attempting to comfort the poor creature, of which I was unsuccessful.
I then had no choice but to listen to the full tale of how our mutual acquaintances became enemies. Yes, enemies! For Bilbo swore up and down that never again would he travel farther than falls of Rivendell and I tell you with all sincerity that he nearly meant to cut even me out from his future had I not reminded him that Bree was yet a two days journey shire-ward.
I wrote you only to say that Bilbo as you have named him is Elf-Friend and I will do nothing more to remove myself from his acquaintance not even for a fellow though long distant ally.
Good luck with your dwarf problem, mayhap you and your neighbors could do with more lessons in tact and the sharing of important intelligence.
Cordially,
Elrond, Lord of Rivendell, the Last Homely House East of the Sea, Beholden Now to a Hobbit for Bad Manners

Dear Elrond,
A darkness has fallen over my lands, that even the term Mirkwood fails to describe.
King Thorin in his infinite generosity has taken to finding any excuse to traverse my kingdom to its far west border and back again for the slightest chore. The last three mandatory traversals included: meeting up with a party on their way to Erebor, a two week before they would end their three months journey, a dire meeting with a friend at the far west border and most recently checking the roads for future trade between Erebor and Ered Luin. I have since in the last cycle of the moon, suffered the presence of his great grumpiness thrice in the halls of my kingdom and thusly thrice at my dinner table.
I tell you now should he being another red bearded dwarf to assail my tender ears and antagonize my son, I shall declare war upon my neighbor and bring the whole of the third age to its ends.
How fairs our littlest friend? Does he know the pains he has caused three kings and their Kingdom; know I speak of Dale, Erebor, and my own Greenwoods, and not of Rivendell as you brought any annoyance upon yourself when you refused to turn Bilbo Eastward.
King Thranduil, Elvenking, Seeker of Peace, Lone Alley in the Darkness

Dear Thranduil,
I am sorry to hear of the plight upon your lands. If it is truly as grave as you say perhaps you should call upon a mutual friend and alley, Mithrandir. I hear him to be traveling in search of a worthy cause these days and I am sure he would come to your aid.
As far as our other mutual friend, I will tell you only this he has as of late taken to sojourning into my kingdom and to its edge, though unlike the king of the east he gives no excuse for his determined march across my borders. Up till now Master Baggins had turned back home each time pensive and distraught, but should he try to take a single step beyond my realm I now, based on your last callous missive, vow to aid my friend in his return to Bag End
I find I must remind you of my promise to make up the sorrow I cause Master Baggins on his first return and if keeping him from a Darkness that refuses to see any furthering of a meaningful relationship as “erroneous, superfluous, and unrecognizable by and Dwarf worth his salt" than that will be the pledge I take into the next age; whether that is brought on by you or the Valar itself.
I am glad to hear of such diligence from the Dwarven King of the East. I have heard much rejoicing over the open trade routes between Ered Luin and Erebor. Such devotion speaks to the fitness of Thorin to be king, though one has to wonder why he insists on ruling alone.
I will say I was surprised to see your mention of your son, Legolas, and his annoyance with the Dwarves, and even more surprised to hear you had appointed him the official Erebor Ambassador. One would think loosing your captain to the Dwarves was enough, but a son with such amicable relationships to a neighboring kingdom will surely inspire peace across the land for many years to come.
Good luck with your darkness problem and let me know when I can officially start using Greenwoods new nomer Nightwoods.
Lord Elrond, Friend of Hobbits, Lord of Rivendell, the Last Bastion Against Tyranny and Deceptions.

Dear Elrond,
Thank you for your update on Master Baggins health and wellbeing. I have seen fit to share this news with all of his friends in the East; some of which were more receptive to this news than others.
King Thorin for his part has lessened his trips through the Greenwoods though in my opinion this may be a bit premature as I fear there is still a long winter ahead. Though perhaps this oversight is the same that has led him to dithering back and forth between the road to his kingdom and the Misty Mountains, for as you say had he this same devotion in all his affairs he may find himself more occupied within his kingdom than with affairs beyond it.
I will speak now plainly, as you seem to have opinions of me that are unbiased: A Hobbit is far more a friend to me than any Dwarf could ever be and this is truer for one Master Baggins, retriever of the Arkenstone, Bane of Smaug, and indeed still Elf-Friend. He is also a character of reason, so I must wonder why he continued to be unreasonable about his place among his friends and equals of Erebor. You know I would never deign to call any who spurn their greatest desire, logical, but there is logic in restraint. I will finish this thought with: If Elf-friend is enough to have him calling upon you should Dwarf-friend not be enough for one short trip to the East?
Speaking of the East, the great stubborn goat has taken to focusing on his kingdom and any preparation or celebrations for once lost traditions. Again, to think that something you have not looked for will magically find its way home is folly, and I wish no happiness upon any fool enough to follow this path, but I do wish for peace. Something you spoke at great lengths in your last letter.
King Thranduil, Guardian of Greenwood the Great, at his Wits End

Dear Thranduil,
The Misty Mountains have an Eastern and a Western side. If you choose to only ally yourself with your Kingdom and its prosperity, then you choose the Eastern and all its alliances.
Speaking of alliances, I hear congratulations are in order. Give my well wishes to Legolas and his “red bearded" “antagonist”. I seem to recall your last missive stating no Dwarf could be more friend than Hobbit but what could be more friend than family? In this too you will have to recant your words.
If you are truly asking after steps to peace, surely any King of this age would know to end a war you must start with a truce, a ceasefire, in the least. Such things are often accompanied by olive branches as a show of good faith and a will for grace. This I think you will find to be better intelligence than the whereabouts and wherewithal of Hobbit aquaintances.
Lord Elrond, Bearer of Good Words and Herald of Sound Advice

Elrond
I have sent this missive with my fastest messenger as much has been set in motion and there is still much to be done.
The King of Erebor rides for Rivendell in hopes of seeing a prosperous meeting between East and West.
This departure while quickly decided upon still has many roadblocks between your homely house and the edge of Mirkwood; namely the stubbornness of Dwarves. Luckily for all involved Mithrandir is making the journey accompanied by a small contingent of friends. I pray this will be enough to convince the Stalwart King no-longer-under-his-mountain to reclaim that which he has lost!
I write next only to have you make sure our mutual friend is in residence of Rivendell in the next month. And for the love of the Valar, Elrond, make sure they both apologize! I refuse to go through another winter with the chill of Erebor wafting through the leaves of my trees! I have lost much breath to ‘good will’ and ‘shows of grace’. I have little else to give on this matter.
King Thranduil, King of the Elves of the Wood, and the Eternal Exhausted.
P.S. Thank you for your kind words over the nuptials of my son. While I have lost years off of my life with the reclamation of Erebor I have also gained a son. Let that answer your question as to whether a Dwarf can be more friend than a Hobbit.

Dear Thranduil,
They are all returning to Erebor with full packs and the full inventory of Bag End. The only thing I fear they are missing now is true agreement, which in my mind is the crux of all tragedy that has and will yet befall us.
Upon arriving in Rivendell, a full complement of Elves greeted the Eastern delegation, among us was one Bilbo Baggins of Bag End on a weekend walk spurned by a letter of my own hand asking for his presence. I still do not know how I convinced Master Baggins to arrive so precisely on time (it was under the sway of production for one of Master Baggin's stories, which left all of us in the theatrical mood) nor do I know how I continued the farce of the ‘Surprise Delegation’. Luckily, we all knew our parts well and each held to their character.
The cast included one Wizard in Grey as the amenable Friend to all and reminder of happier times as well as the dark times to come. His perspective as usual gave many great pause to think on their next words carefully before they opened their mouth to say the unchangeable. Next was the Eleven Lord Hobbit-friend and Host of the dance; you may henceforth call me Cat Wrangler and Locker of Opportunistic Doors. Then there were the foreign noble’s family whose entire scheme was to openly commit schemes that everyone was secretly after and yet fail at every turn. The youths did add a light air to the show, which was, at times, the only thing keeping it together. Now the Dwarf king, whose part was easiest to play, yet could not have been more over acted. He arrived, he reacted to none of the beauty of Rivendell, and yet he spent many hours in contemplation of each and every hall until of course he stumbled upon the last of our cast, with whom he would spend the rest of the hours in the day, but never past the dinner hour. Finally Master Baggins, who had the tasks of setting the guidelines we all wished to follow and who from one day to the next changed the rules on when how and who could talk on what where and how. It is a wonder Rivendell yet stands as for the whole of two weeks it was built upon eggshells and straw; waiting merely for a tender breeze to collapse the entirety of my home beneath the tensions of one family.
Each actor said their lines and the play went about to a fortunate end, but I believe Master Baggins is still unconvinced of his standing within Erebor’s hierarchy, which means over the long journey back both sides will continue to convince the other to their side. Thusly, leading us back to the same place we were at the start of this correspondence.
Mithrandir is now wise to our meddling and has stated we should “leave it to him,”- this statement is accompanied by a look consisting of mischief and fire and we both know what happened last time he attempted to meddle in this particular affair.
I leave the rest to the Valar and you oh Seeker of Peace and Lone Alley in the Darkness. May your task be an easier one than mine.
Lord Elrond, Cat Wrangler, Locker of Opportunistic Doors, Newly Appointed Eternally Exhausted

(This missive was sent in duplicate to one Elrond Lord of Rivendell and Host of Friends and one King Thranduil Elvenking, King of the Woodland Realm)
It has been only 2 weeks since Master Bilbo and King Thorin have reconciled and a well met match they are once again. Not only are the two cordial once more, but they remind me of the first journey to Erebor we set out on all those long years ago. Is it not great to see two so united? They have a well practiced routine to their days, which allows them to speak little, but say much. I am hopeful this return to Erebor will see the dawning of a new understanding at the least if not a new union to celebrate.
Mithrandir, Istar, Faithfully Vigilant

Amrâlimê,
I hope in the months since I have journeyed with my kin to Rivendell you have been well. I have not the length of parchment nor the time to tell you how the journey there and back has been, but I will once I return to you and your father’s Kingdom.
If Thranduil looks for news about our return, tell him this: It is going to be a blood bath.
We have our work cut out for us yet, but I trudge ever forward to you.
Please let my family know I am alive and standing, but I fear I will be forever changed by this journey. No Dwarf should ever have to watch his king be outmaneuvered by a Hobbit and yet I awaken every day wondering if today is the day I lose all hope and sanity.
I will conclude as this verges on treason and ruin.
Gimli Son of Glóin, One of Durin’s Folk and Not Thrilled About it

Dear Elrond,
Surely you have also received the missive from the wise Mithrandir, but what you may not have received is word from others in the company looking to darken my woods. My son received word from Gimli some odd nights ago, and the young Dwarf warns of death and ruination, so I fear your last missive was far more insightful than the hopefulness of Gandalf the Grey. I have been warned that I ‘have my work cut out for me’. I will take note of your last missive and make strategies and plots for the arrival of, as far as Legolas quotes it, a “blood bath.”
I have began to turn to my advisors to plot out ways to bring this journey to a swift and happy reconciliation. We are running it as if a War Council, something I know much about, but the topic of victory seems beyond the grasp of myself and my councilors. Perhaps I will take the Title of Faithfully Vigilant from Mithrandir, though I do grow weary of this game.
King Thranduil, Cunning and Wise Strategies, Tested by War, but not the Hearts of Hobbits

Elrond,
I write this in the small hours of the morning to state that the whole of Arda owns the Woodland Realm a debt it may never be able to repay. I will take this weariness into Valinor.
Thranduil, King of the Weary Realm, Belabored and Bebothered
P.S. How you managed to set this catastrophe on wheels upon the road such that it made it to my kingdom intact enough to implode at my doorstep is an act of war and I will take no penance, but your complete surrender along with the totality of your homely house.

To the Great Elven King,
I hope this missive finds you well. I have entrusted it to the hands of my most trusted guardians; an auspicious fellowship made of a group of noble warriors from Rivendell and equally noble gentle hobbits. They come baring gifts of perspective and direction. Add them to your War Council and I assure you they will help lead you and our cause to a merry end. They are to be a show of peace and a bid for your grace. All will be well with their arrival, and all will pass well as your guest will soon take their leave of your realm; this I have foreseen.
Lord Elrond, Your Long Time Friend and Correspondent, Verily Unimpressed by Your Dramatics

Elrond,
You menace. You charlatan. You coward. You are hereby banned from the East of Arda. Should you step a mere foot in the direction of my half of the Middle Earth it will be within my right to smite you where you stand. In my darkest hours I have turned to you for your help and advice as many of our kind deem you to be amongst our greatest leaders, but let this day show that you. Are. A. Coward.
Thranduil Oropheraian King of the Woodldand Realms and Smiter of the Cruel
P.S. I have included an invitation to the binding ceremony for my son and his chosen dwarf The honorable Lord Gimli son of Glóin. We would greatly appreciate your attendance at the gathering to show support for their union as even now friends of their bonding are hard to come by. Much gratitude will be shown for your presence.

My Dear King Thranduil,
My friend all will be peaceful in your woods and soon! As I have not seen neither my own smiting nor your demise in the coming years, I will attend the binding ceremony of your son and the esteemed Lord Gimli Son of Glóin. I will bring along with me a larger host of my own delegates, so please prepare us space amongst your stately Woods.
I plan to also bring hope and happiness with me that it may reign over all those currently in your Realm. Perhaps this grand event will even inspire your close neighbor to cast off formality and secretive Dwarven laws, to follow his heart, which is bound in so many ways save the Dwarven and the Hobbitish ones that is, to bring peace to the East at long last.
Lastly my dear, dear friend, and I cannot state this enough, should you wish to have Rivendell at your every beck and call: know it is done already. Should you wish to subjugate Imladris and its people to the Woodland Realm: know you will have to follow me to the Undying Lands and wrest the loreals from my brow.
Lord Elrond, Peace Bringer, Your Loyal Ally

Dear Elrond,
I write this missive to assuage any worries my previous words may have stirred up. You will find in the scant few days since last I wrote, the full War Council, including the numbers of your fellowship, have not only wrest a means of peace for Erebor from the mists of the impossible, but also enacted such plans to ensure lasting peace for the East. I find I can no longer be angered at you or the cohort you sent to disassemble the tensions of the Ereborian Delegation, for from your last missive came the spark of inspiration. I am not so prideful as to not thank you for your foresight and clever words, but I do wonder if you had seen the designs of this end long ago and allowed such pain to befall me in hopes of a “due time”. Regardless of your motives your actions were thusly: provided the means to the end of my suffering. For this all is forgiven between us.
I will elaborate further of the goings-on of my Realm, not because I think you unawares of the outcomes of the Meeting at the Greenwood- I once again fail to believe you had no visions or foresight in regards to the lovelorn guests of my home, but because the events of the last day are impossible to fully believe and I wish to convince myself of their truth.
Firstly, your delegation arrived a whirlwind of chaos and menace to be oil on a tinder fire. My first hopes were that the incendiary meetings would naturally burn themselves out. Council meetings were not safe from the explosive nature of the debate; even the noble nephews of the King Under the Mountain found themselves on either side of the divide. (Their standing may interest you as the soon to be King sided with the ideals of the current King Thorin, whereas the romantic youth found he sided with the younger more romantic Hobbit Heart of King Thorin.) These tempestuous meetings all meet under cover of darkness and secrecy, so as to not draw the eyes of the King Under the Mountain and his not-consort.
Elrond, when I tell you that the solution to this great divide was so simple and easy, I know for certain that you must have known it from the onset, known it before even I who posed the loophole to the Council, because it came on the heels of your words!
‘Perhaps this grand event will even inspire your close neighbor to cast off formality and secretive Dwarven laws, to follow his heart, which is bound in so many ways save the Dwarven and the Hobbitish ones that is,’
By the Valar! You practically gifted me the solution and the credit conjuring it, but I appreciate the fact that I could add it together and present it as my own: this mind you is the only reason our two realms will not see war. Your peace offering has sufficed and we shall meet soon again as friends.
So, as you plainly pointed out the couple was not considered married in the ways of Dwarves nor Hobbits, which was the point of pain for all across Arda, but especially for one Hobbit, who could not convince king that this distinction would matter to only them and not the great stability of Erebor and Esgaroth. Yes, it was your distinctive wording that lead me to question why you noted these as separate things? Because as you well and truly knew this whole time, these two cultures have different understandings of marriages
I did not need reminding that the traditional dwarven ceremony is one of ritual, worship to and before Aulë, with the final steps being the forging of craft, for Legolas and Gimli’s ceremony has been all planned to the smallest details by myself, but I did make mention of this to the War Council to test the reactions of the Hobbits. Stunned was one way to describe the fellows, appalled was another. The small, yet surprisingly loud Misses Lobelia exclaimed almost before I had finished speaking that the makings of a Hobbit wedding were far more personal and intimate to the chagrin of every dwarf present who found themselves offended by her quick rebuke of their sacred and secretive rites.
It was Bilbo’s cousin Mister Otto, I must name them as more than just their association to our friend as all Hobbits present in my kingdom are related in a way that is both enjoyable and eerie, who explained that a Hobbit wedding was a promise. There are words of love exchanged by both parties then promises are made both extraordinary and inane and finally a seed is planted by both as a symbol of growth and a dedication of effort and promise to see the seed grow, all of which sounds like what would be pleasing and important to our Dear Bilbo. The Hobbits also explained that while the Westeron words of wedding and marriage are interchangeable all Hobbits prefer the term “Promise Planting”.
From there Bilbo’s family planned the Promise Planting with the help of the Elven members of the War Council, while the Dwarves were left with the task of convincing King Thorin that to make up for not acquiescing to a binding ceremony with the Gentle Hobbit of Erebor he could at least provide Bilbo with a Promise Planting… And thusly the two were wed, though please for the sake of all of Arda do not tell the King of Erebor he is by Hobbit standards married to his husband, for by the Kings own words, Erebor and its Dwarves could never accept it.
There will be much to celebrate when next you visit.
King Thranduil, Ruler of the Greenwood, Proprietor of Happily Ever After, Wedding Planner for Ereborian Dwarves.

Dear Thranduil,
Kili and Fili talked… They told me all about the “War Council”.
Fuck you
Strong letter to follow
Thorin Oakinshield

Notes:

I hope this was as amusing to others as it was for me to write. Literally just a crack fic, I think.

Let me know what you think.