Actions

Work Header

winter song

Summary:

Sometimes, even when you love someone with your whole soul, there isn't a happy ending. Sometimes soulmates cannot be together.

--

 

They say that things just cannot grow
Beneath the winter snow,
Or so I have been told.

 

They say we're buried far,
Just like a distant star
I simply cannot hold.

Notes:

(See the end of the work for notes.)

Work Text:

Were he less preoccupied with the restoration of Erebor, scrambling to make the mountain fit for survival through the winter, Thorin might have noticed something before it was too late. As it was, the beginning of the distance between himself and Bilbo remained unbeknownst to the king. There were far too many tasks to be completed before the first snow fell; treaties that had to be straightened out, supply routes secured, merchants and crafters reinstated within the mountain. His relationship with Bilbo was not strained but much of Thorin’s time was occupied and he only saw the hobbit when he retired for the night. 

As such, the night that things came to an end, he was not prepared. Thorin had been thinking of bringing up courtship to Bilbo that night, as they ate dinner together. It was not something that hadn’t been discussed, but they’d both agreed to wait until Erebor was stable enough that Thorin could focus his attentions elsewhere. As things were coming together, he was hoping that time might be coming very shortly. 

“I cannot stay in Erebor,” Bilbo said, setting his fork down. Thorin paused, his eyes flicking up to look at the hobbit. 

“Did someone say something to you?” Thorin dropped his knife, hot anger opening up in his chest. “Who? I will–”

“You will do what?” Bilbo raised a brow, crossing his arms over his chest. “Thorin, I don’t want you to use your status as king to bully people around. Besides, no one said anything to me about not belonging here. But we both know that I don’t.”

“Bilbo–”

“This isn’t my home, Thorin,” Bilbo said softly, his eyes dropping to the table. “I received a letter from a cousin of mine. I have to return home.”

When Bilbo met his eyes again, there was a firm resignation in them. Thorin knew, very suddenly, that this was a decision Bilbo had already made, and that it was not a spur of the moment thought. He wondered how long Bilbo had been ruminating on telling him. When had he received the letter? And what did it say that meant Bilbo had to return to the Shire?

He couldn’t call it Bilbo’s home. Bilbo’s home was supposed to be Erebor, with him. 

“I love you, Thorin,” Bilbo said, and Thorin tried to ignore the melancholy in Bilbo’s voice. “I do. But I don’t belong here. And you do. I couldn’t ask you to come back with me.”

“What is it that this letter said? If there is an issue you have to sort out, you can go and then come back, there will always be a place for–”

“My cousins drowned,” Bilbo said, standing from his seat at the table. “They have a son and he’s too young to be on his own. My other cousins all have far too many children to take on another faunt. The custody of the lad is falling to me.”

A child changed so much in Thorin’s mind, but all he could think was that they could take care of a child in Erebor. The child would have a good home here. 

Why didn’t Bilbo see that?

“We could-”

“Don’t,” Bilbo said sharply. Thorin didn’t miss the strain in his voice or the shine of unshed tears in his eyes. “Don’t, Thorin. I’ve made my decisions. I… I cannot stay here. It wouldn’t be good for me. I cannot thrive within a mountain. I need the sunlight and I need the rolling hills of the Shire. That’s… that’s where I belong,” he breathed out, a soft half-laugh half-sob. “We accomplished what we set out to do, Thorin. I vowed to get your home back, so I.. I have to go.”

“You don’t have to,” Thorin said bitterly. “You will always have a place at my side, Bilbo.”

“I know,” Bilbo looked up at him, then sighed softly. “I know that.”

“When will you leave?”

“I’ve set up plans with Gandalf. He’ll be here in a fortnight and then we’ll head back to the Shire,” Bilbo seemed to hesitate as he spoke then reached for Thorin’s hand. When the dwarf did not pull away, he intertwined their fingers. “You have me until then. And it is not as if I will disappear off the face of Arda. You will write to me, won’t you?”

“Of course,” Thorin met Bilbo’s eyes. “I’d move this mountain for you if I could, but if all I can do is write letters to you then.. I will write a letter every day.”

Bilbo laughed wetly, burying his face in Thorin’s chest. Thorin wrapped his arms around the hobbit, holding him close, and wishing that this would be enough. He’d never force Bilbo to stay, but there would always be a selfish part of him that wanted to lock him up, even if he’d never act on that. 

Instead, Thorin scooped Bilbo up and carried him to bed. If nothing else, they had two weeks until Bilbo left. And Thorin would try to make the best of that time with him. 

During the quest, two weeks would have felt like a lifetime, but when they had nothing else to do but build up a kingdom and mountain, two weeks was nothing. It flew by before Thorin could process that it had gone. But then Bilbo was talking about packing and asking what they should do with the furniture in his rooms, talking to Bombur about recipes, and Dwalin was trying to arrange a dwarven escort for the hobbit. 

“I really don’t need an entourage of dwarves,” Bilbo said, tucking his bag over his shoulder as he regarded the company. They were standing at the gate of Erebor and Thorin was a few feet back, not able to quite make those last few steps to the gate. If he did, then he was saying goodbye, and it was real. “Really. I’ve got a wizard with me.”

Dwalin snorted, casting a glare at Gandalf, who merely smiled in amusement at them. 

“Besides, we aren’t being chased by orcs this time,” Bilbo added, chuckling. “And we aren’t really on a time-sensitive mission this time. We’ll be able to take a safer route.”

“ Amad has headed out from Ered Luin,” Fili said, stepping forward to grasp Bilbo’s hands. Bilbo smiled up at the prince. “You may cross paths with her. Should you, do let her know that we’re fine.”

“I will,” Bilbo promised, reaching up to pat Fili’s cheek affectionately. Thorin thought he’d have made a fine uncle to the boys. “Though I’m not going to sugar coat anything if she asks for more information.”

Then he pulled Fili into a hug and Kili quickly joined, the pair picking Bilbo up off his feet for a brief second before they set him down. 

The hobbit worked through his goodbyes and Thorin watched from the shadows. Bilbo exchanged teary words with Bofur, Bombur, and he had some kind of exchange with Bifur that had the dwarf hugging him tightly. His goodbyes to Dori, Ori, and Nori were of a similar nature, though it ended with Bilbo chuckling shakily at something Nori said. He promised Gloin and Oin that he’d greet Gimil and update the lad on his father and uncle’s status in Erebor. When Dwalin lifted Bilbo off the ground in a tight hug and Balin squeezed his shoulder after, Thorin turned his head. 

He didn’t want to say goodbye. 

If he said goodbye, then he would be admitting to never seeing Bilbo again. 

“Thorin,” Bilbo’s voice came soft, with a touch to his forearm. Thorin turned his head back, taking in the sight of the hobbit, reddened eyes and nose, his smile loose and not quite reaching his eyes. Neither said anything and then Bilbo cleared his throat. “Goodbye.”

“Goodbye, master burglar,” Thorin said quietly. “Go back to your books…”

“Oh stop that,” Bilbo said, his voice hysterical as he pulled Thorin down into a kiss before the dwarf could pull away. It was far too short and probably too long in front of their friends, but Thorin would have clung to Bilbo forever. The hobbit broke the kiss, taking a step away. “I shall write to you the next time we are somewhere that isn't on the side of the road.”

“Very well,” Thorin murmured, dropping his gaze to their feet. “I will write to you before then but I suppose you will not read my letter until you reach Bag End.”

“Likely not,” Bilbo agreed, clapping his hands together and turning to Gandalf. “Shall we?”

Gandalf looked between them, his gaze lingering on Thorin before he turned to Bilbo with a warm smile. “Aye, let us depart before the sun does.” 

Thorin watched the horizon until he no longer saw the shapes of the wizard and hobbit. Whether he lingered until the sun had truly set was his business. 

 

*

 

When Gandalf had left Bilbo on the edge of the Shire they had arrived a week prior to what Bilbo had predicted they might. His feet were tired and he wanted nothing more than to find the nearest inn and collapse into a feather-soft bed. Buckland was not too far, though, and it wasn’t sunset yet. He could make it to his cousin’s burrows before nightfall and that was likely for the best. 

The sooner he gathered Frodo, the sooner he could be home in Bag End and not have to deal with his cousins again for some time. 

And he’d have to restock his pantry not for one but for two, and one of those being a growing fauntling. 

Bilbo ran a hand through his hair with a sigh, his heart thumping when his fingers caught against the cool metal of the bead in his hair. He pushed the feeling away and began his trek down the paths of the East Farthing, towards Buckland and Frodo. 

By the time he arrived, he was dearly hoping that Rory would at least offer him a meal. He didn’t quite expect the decorations and ongoing work that seemed to be happening at Brand Hall. Bilbo came to a halt, frowning as he looked around curiously. 

“Bilbo! Bilbo Baggins, is that you?” Rory’s voice came from the garden bench and the hobbit jumped off, hurrying down the path until he came face to face with Bilbo. “By the Green Lady! It is. Goodness me, come inside. We weren’t expecting you yet.”

“Ah, yes, thank you, Rory,” Bilbo smiled, following his cousin inside Brandy Hall. “May I ask what the decorations are for?”

“Oh, well… actually, I suppose you must be out of sorts!” Rory chuckled, shaking his head. “Imagine, a hobbit forgetting his own birthday!”

“What?” Bilbo huffed and looked around Brandy Hall. 

Indeed, now that he had the light of the hall to look in, he could see the decorations were of the birthday celebration type. Bilbo had never been particularly that close to Rory, though, and he sincerely doubted his cousin was throwing him birthday parties while he was away. 

“Did you forget that young Frodo shares your birthday?” Rory asked, an awkward smile on his face. “I suppose you must have. Well, if you haven’t been keeping track of the days, it’s tomorrow. We thought you wouldn’t be here until after, so… well, we were going to have him celebrate it here.”

“That won’t be necessary,” Bilbo said, smiling faintly. “I’ll be taking him home to Bag End tonight.”

“Oh,” Rory looked surprised but then he gave a quick nod. “Of course, of course, probably for the best… well, as you asked Paladin and I made sure that Bag End was maintained and kept out of Lobelia’s paws.”

“Thank you,” Bilbo sighed, pinching his nose. “Where is Frodo?”

“Oh, this way, yes,” Rory directed him to a room out of the way. He lingered for a moment and when Bilbo lifted a brow, he cleared his throat and left in a hurry. 

Bilbo turned to the door and knocked gently, pausing and listening. No sound came and Bilbo waited for a few minutes before he gently opened the door. He knew that Frodo was likely struggling and did not want to have anything to do with Rory, but he hoped that his presence might change things a bit. Bilbo had always been close to Drogo and Primula, and he’d met Frodo a few times before. 

“Frodo?”

The faunt was curled up on his bed, staring out the window in the room. His shoulders twitched and then he sat up, staring at Bilbo in surprise. Bilbo stood in the doorway, smiling sadly as he took in the sight of the faunt. Frodo’s eyes were wide as he registered Bilbo in the door and then he was tumbling to his feet, running to Bilbo and wrapping his arms around his waist. 

Bilbo held back the noise at the back of his throat, closing his eyes for a moment before he kneeled down in front of Frodo. The faunt looked at him, tears in his eyes. 

“Well,” Bilbo said softly, tucking hair behind Frodo’s ear. “It seems you and I are both alone now. What do you think we should do about that?”

“Are you taking me home?” He asked quietly. 

“Yes. We’re going to Bag End tonight. Would you like that?”

Frodo nodded into his stomach and Bilbo carded his fingers gently through the faunt’s dark hair. It was hard to ignore the dark hair and bright blue eyes, but Bilbo did his best. No need to think about that right now, it was something he’d probably dwell on late in the night when Frodo was tucked into a bed in Bag End. 

They left Buckland shortly after, with a pack of food that Menegilda prepared for Frodo. The trek to Hobbiton was not a short one, and Bilbo had to carry Frodo for most of it, but they made it back to Bag End that night. The door creaked when Bilbo pushed it open and he made a mental note to himself to have its hinges checked sometime that week. There were likely dozens of things he’d have to check on in Bag End, but for now, he focused on getting Frodo to the room next to his. The faunt couldn’t keep his eyes open and Bilbo tucked him, smoothing his hair away from his forehead before he left the room. 

Alone, he sank to the floor against the wall outside of the door to Frodo’s room and buried his face in his hands. It was as if all the weight he’d been pushing off was making itself known again. He had a child to care for now. He had left Thorin in Erebor. 

Bilbo wiped at his eyes, breathing in shakily before he stood back up. 

He didn’t have time to wallow or mourn. 

Tomorrow, he’d get the letters from his mail. Tomorrow, he’d read a letter from Thorin and write him back. 

His hands hesitated before he stuffed them into his pockets. He felt the brush of something cool in his pocket. Bilbo closed his eyes for a moment before he drew out the acorn and held it in his palm. Then Bilbo sank back down to the floor, propping his chin on his knees as he looked at the acorn resting in his palm. 

So much hope had rested in the tiny seed. 

Perhaps he’d plant it tomorrow. 

 

* 

 

My dearest, 

These halls feel empty without you. Each time I return to my rooms, I think that you will be there waiting for me. Each time I turn a corner in Erebor, I think that you will be there. I know that you are not and will not be there, but my heart yearns that I might catch yet one more glimpse of you. Balin has told me to take time to myself, but I do not think that it would help. Time to myself would only allow me to think more on you and then I may do something foolish. Something that I know you would not approve of. Work, at least, keeps my thoughts from turning there too often. But do not mistake me: I think often of doing something very foolish indeed. 

But I will not. As you said, the Shire is not mine to call home.

I pray that Frodo is faring well. You must tell me more about him in your letters when you arrive home. I would like to hear about him. If it is not too much of a burden, I’d like it very much if you would write about him often. I wish to know what you will allow me about your life. 

I have not been able to sleep much since you left. Oin told me if I do not sleep soon then he will be making me a tonic. Pray that these restless nights end soon. You and I both know how foul those tonics are. 

I love you. Never doubt that, no matter how much time goes on. I will always love you, Bilbo Baggins. 

I await your letters with bated breath. 

Ever yours, 

Thorin Oakenshield, King of Durin’s Folk 

Notes:

I don't really write angst. but this idea popped into my head and I wanted to get it out so I could focus on writing my fics which tend to be much fluffier and have happy endings!

As a little tidbit I think that Frodo was never told about Bilbo's true relationship with Thorin. He would have found all the letters from Thorin after Bilbo left the Shire in FOTR. I guess you could figure out a happy ending for them but my intentions are not for that in this one.