Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Category:
Fandoms:
Relationships:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Series:
Part 1 of koomiline's RPF
Stats:
Published:
2026-05-13
Words:
2,299
Chapters:
1/1
Kudos:
8
Hits:
0

On RPF

Summary:

An unnecessarily huge disclaimer about RPF.

Work Text:

Over the years, I've gone back and forth several times regarding my stance on RPF. I thought I should take the opportunity afforded by this new account of mine — starting afresh in 2026, after an eight-years run and a two-years break — to come up with a proper disclaimer that would be too long for an author's note, and not specific enough for a given fandom. The second part of this publication (for lack of a better term) will focus on the detailed story of my own relationship to RPF, if, you know, you're into that kind of thing.

Anyway, here's my credo:

  • RPF is not real. It is, by definition, fiction. In no way would I ever consider myself to hold a particular truth regarding the love and sex life of a real person.

  • RPF is not actually about real people. It is about their public persona, which, I'll admit, can overlap almost completely with someone's actual personality. However, RPF is entirely based on what a person consents to share with the public. Any information acquired through stalking or coercion should not, in my opinion, fuel a RPF story.

  • I do not consider RPF ethical. I'm not saying it's a serious offense, but if I have to think about it in terms of morality, then no, it's not a very good thing to be doing. However, it's not the worst either. I can deal with doing a sort-of-bad thing once in a while, as long as I'm clear on which lines I will not cross.

  • RPF is only human. It's no excuse, as every single thing that we do is only human. But it's also a reason not to demonize it too much. People must have been speculating about other people's relationships since basically forever. It's fun.

  • I always try to lessen the possible harm RPF could do. I'm aware that, theoretically speaking, someone being exposed to RPF of themselves might suffer psychological consequences. That's why I put several limits on my practice of it: I never talk about it where relevant people might see it (e. g. commenting on someone's YouTube video, even if it has a billion views, is off-limits), I refrain from describing their private body parts (though I may mention them), and, if I must publish a story, I confine it to Ao3's restricted access.

  • RPF must only be about famous people. It would be completely creepy otherwise. Hard no. See my point about public personas.

  • RPF is about romance. Other topics, such as real-life grief and trauma, or imagined but heavy ones such as disease, death and prostitution (to name a few I've encountered!) are better left alone. There might be ways to tread carefully, but I would generally consider it risky.


Now for my story:

RPF was not introduced to me as such. I learned to ship it organically, so to speak, when I was in the trenches of the Supernatural fandom circa 2015. It began (as many things do) on tumblr, when, armed with some shaky English skills and a nine seasons summer binge, I seamlessly drifted from Destiel to "cockles" without realizing anything was amiss. No critical distance in my teenage brain, no moral conundrum about speculating on the love lives of two actors — not when Jensen Ackles and Misha Collins seemed almost in on the (gay) joke.

In the end, it was on Ao3 itself that I first encountered those three letters, RPF. I probably found it on a prolific Destiel author's profile, and to this day I still remember the titles of my two favorite (and first) cockles reads: Striking the denim matchbox, and Between a wall and a hard place.

I can't remember if I ever took it seriously. I must have, at some point: never mind that they had wives and children, Misha's ex had written a book on threesomes so it must have meant something, right? To me, a secret-but-not-so-secret love affair was just a pleasant idea to consider, and I figured, if those men actually did have sex, it would have been because they were in love. Sex as a recreative act between friends and acquaintances was completely out of my purview then, and so love itself became the foundation of RPF to me.

Pure romance.

Where I couldn't imagine romance, RPF held no appeal to me. My high school bestie tried to get me into Dylan O'Brien and Thomas Brodie-Sangster's ship based only on one behind the scenes video of The Maze Runner where they pretended to kiss. I'll admit it was a nice view, but it was also performative. Two theater kids doing what theater kids do, right in front of a camera – not concealed enough to be genuine.

I realize now that the secret relationship trope was the defining factor in all my RPF ships. Celebrity in and of itself gives a wonderful framing to any secret romance: what fans are never meant to know, what can't exist in broad daylight, can be imagined over and over again, without reality — or canon — ever getting in the way of the fantasy. It doesn't have to be real, and it certainly doesn't have to be confessed; instead, the more it is denied by the interested parties and everyone around them, the more it seems to be hiding in plain sight.

It's no wonder I fell hard for BTS RPF after that. What celebrity is more constrained, and therefore mysterious, than an idol?

Before delving into that, though, I'd like to talk about the RPF ship I did not ship: Phan. Oh, I was in the phandom — more than that, I was convinced they were together, from the bottom of my teenage lesbian heart. I knew about the video edits, the theories, the analyses, the old posts and the fanfics, because it would have been hard not to. Yet, sure as I was of seeing a real relationship unfold over the course of dozens of silly YouTube videos, I never could get into the ship as fiction. If I had been right (and I was), it would have meant that what had transpired through Dan's (and Phil's, but mostly Dan's) firm rebuttals was a vulnerability and sincerity of feeling that they were not able to hide, and that could be easily exploited against them.

(One day, as I was watching one of Dan's videos on the living room couch, my brother sat next to me, took one look at Dan, heard his way of speaking, and said dismissively: "Gay."

The way I "defended" Dan against this accusation (?) has lots do with my own inability to come out to my family, but at the same time it was out of a genuine desire to respect Dan's statements about himself at the time.)

I'm not trying to say that this was a well thought-out, morally superior stance. Judging the definitive morality or lack thereof of RPF is not why I'm here. Rather, this apparent contradiction enlightens me regarding what makes a RPF ship work for me: it must not cause harm to the people being shipped. A worldwide superstar or an American actor, in my eyes, is less likely to be harmed by my fictitious fantasies about him than some British guy filming funny videos from his actual bedroom. Celebrity status only gives you plausible deniability until someone digs up some Tweets you made in 2009 before you knew you'd make it big.

Which brings me to idols, and their unreality.

When I first encountered BTS, I was 17. To my European eyes, they embodied something I had never seen before, a type of masculinity that seemed nonthreatening, a softness of character that immediately put me at ease and made me seek out more of their videos, interviews and the like. I won't roll out my entire ARMY origin story here, as it is beside the point — suffice to say, wanting always more only led me back to fanfiction. And so, like thousands of people on this website, I continued loving them — what I thought of as "them" — through stories that amounted to shared fantasies. Now ten years a fan most of the appeal has peeled off BTS RPF like shed skin from a snake. As they ceased group activities for military service, I grew, and so did they; now both idol and fan have begun anew.

What was left behind was a type of persona that espoused both K-pop's ideals and my own tastes and expectations where RPF was concerned. As they are now directing their efforts towards breaking out of that mold and shaping a different kind of persona for themselves — more open perhaps, or with more overlap with their true selves —, what made them such good candidates for RPF has taken a seat back: restrictive circumstances and the necessity of secrecy, youth, shared living space, and the purported sexlessness of idols. I'm not saying there wouldn't be any scandals were a BTS member to come out, or announce a relationship. The backlash would be terrible. However, it doesn't seem as improbable now that they are artists in their thirties as it did before, when they occupied the unreal and falsely innocent world of idols.

In conclusion, appreciating a celebrity is not enough for RPF to be born. There are aggravating factors.

Intensely homosocial (or suspiciously homoerotic) behavior is another one. That's par for the course in the world of artists and performers, and yet it got me hook, line and sinker. However, I couldn't help but notice that for ships that cross the line between an exciting what-if and an actual possibility, my interest has waned. (That's the case with Jimin and Jungkook, for instance. Why would I feel any kind of thrill about coming up with secret romance plots myself when there's hickey-giving, ass-slapping and ear-licking going on on camera, for all the world to see? In this particular case, I can't help but think they should be left to their own devices. Whatever those are.)

The balance between too fake to be real and too real to be fake is a delicate one, and that's the exact sweet spot where RPF happens for me. Fanservice of the unsubtle kind is both uninteresting and vaguely insulting, and, on the other end of that spectrum, any hint of "oh shit they might actually be together" is enough to make want to back off.

BJYX (which, ironically, makes a claim for reality in its very name) is a good example of a ship that fell neatly between the two. It caught me by surprise, as I went from enjoying the actual love story of The Untamed to watching behind-the-scenes video to being caught once again in the rabbit hole of the secret romance trope. Confined to a place and a time (the duration of the drama's making and promotion), with enough filmed material to sustain imagination, between two people that appeared to be fated in some way (aren't there heterosexual actors and actresses out there, who have found love while playing it? Isn't this the proof something like that could actually happen?), and yet are systemically prevented from ever making that love public (not only by the star system but also by their government). Were they actual gay men, it would be a terrible situation. Enjoying RPF in peace requires me to believe that they are not.

No ship has captured my interest ever since. Being a fan cannot be forced, being a shipper even less. As no story or artist captivates me at the moment, the RPF candidates are nonexistent. And yet, it seems that I've not entirely given up on the idea of it. For lack of people to ship, I am now writing about RPF itself, perhaps in honor of the joy it used to bring me, the escapist fantasy it provided during a time of my life that I increasingly find to be dark, the more I move away from it. As I starved for love and happiness, fiction as a whole was a getaway to a world where people could find love as if by nature's design. It was fun, it was hopeful. Not perfect, and not healthy; sometimes even seriously damaging — the kind of horrors I've encountered in the BTS fandom tag is part of what made me stop and think, and come up with rules for myself, to try and turn the implicit into explicit (no pun intended), and bring to light issues that, in my humble opinion, are worth talking about.

There's still much that I haven't broached about this topic. For instance, the divide between RPF that strictly follows what real facts fan knows of, and takes place in "the real world", and AU fics of all kinds, which are plenty. This abundance may say something about the element of play inherent to RPF — Barbie, though always the same doll, has lived as many lives are there are children that held her.

I've also chosen against differentiating between RPF about actors whose characters are shipped (and who are subject to what I'd call pseudo character bleed, wherein fans impute to actors the intensity of feeling associated with the fictional ship) and RPF about creators of any kind, or sportsmen, whose idealized self becomes the object of both desire and identification without the mediation of a fictional world.

But I've spoken long enough, and any further discussion might require more than mere opinion — it might require research (if only to find relevant examples of fics). And I'm feeling a bit too lazy at the moment.

If anyone has bothered to read this at all, thank you! Feel free to leave a comment with your opinion, even though I might not answer, especially if you try to change my mind. I've made it up quite well, after all.

Series this work belongs to: