Work Text:
THE STONE PRINCE.
No one paid Hobbits any attention for generally they weren’t of any importance. Most were simple farmers, back in the Shire, producing delicious food, or they were cooks or brewers of excellent ale. But many lost their homes to the goblin and orc invasions that occurred during the Fell Winter and in the immediate aftermath so now some hundreds now lived in ‘the Lone Farthing’ a series of small settlements between Dale and Mirkwood, protected by the Men and Dwarves alike. And because the land wasn’t as productive as that Yavanna had created for them, most had to find other employment. Many worked in menial jobs in Dale, for the Man Kingdom was prosperous and many would pay for Hobbit tailoring or sweetmeats or just nimble and cheerful Hobbit servants. But a few had to seek further afield for work and ended up in the service of the dwarves in the Kingdom of Erebor. And one such Hobbit servant was Bilbo Baggins.
Every day before dawn, he would leave his comfortable little smial and walk the miles towards the road to the Great Gates of Erebor, catching the transport carts from the outskirts of Dale to the threshold of the great Kingdom and then lining up at the magnificent gates to be admitted as an authorised worker. Every day, he went to the Housekeeping Master and he would assign Bilbo whatever work he deemed needed a Hobbit to do. Much of the time, he was able to help in the kitchen; if he was especially lucky, he was posted in the Library but sometimes, when the cooks needed no help, he was assigned cleaning and general tidying. And because he was a Hobbit who kept his own home spotless, he always turned to his work with a willing heart.
In fact, Master Dori was a very kind, though fastidious dwarf and Bilbo was always willing to listen to his despairing tirades about his middle brother, Nori, who seemed to be terrible rogue and always seemed to be being chased by the Captain of the Guard, Dwalin son of Fundin. Bilbo had seen Dwalin a few times-a tall powerful dwarf with knuckle dusters, tattoos on his bald crown and two massive axes slung across his back. Certainly, the Hobbit wouldn’t want to cross him and tended to scuttle out of the way whenever he or his guards strode through the walkways of the Kingdom. Dori’s youngest brother, Ori, was a junior librarian and scribe and he was the closest that Bilbo had to a friend among the dwarves of Erebor. When he was assigned to help Ori-and in his own time, what little there was of it-he was in his element. Unusual for a Hobbit, Bilbo loved books, especially those telling of history and poetry and far off lands. Of course, not being a dwarf, he was not allowed to ready any dwarvish history or lore-that was forbidden for all outsiders, even if it was not written in the secret dwarvish language of Khuzdûl-but he was allowed to read the histories of the Elves and Men and if they mentioned something about the dwarves, well then Bilbo would take what crumbs he could get.
The fact he read Sindarin and some Quenya was a point in his favour but despite Ori’s best efforts, no one ever considered his skills important enough to utilise and appoint him formally to the Library. So he remained on the cleaning roster and worked hard, though any chance to utilise the skills his parents had taught him and his love of history was gratefully welcomed. For Bilbo was alone the Lone Farthing, his mother’s family mostly back in the Shire and all of his father’s Baggins kin, save one greedy cousin and his odious wife. Otho and Lobelia Sackville-Baggins wasted no opportunity to let Bilbo know what a disgrace he was to the Baggins name, living as a poor housekeeping worker in Erebor rather than supporting the farming efforts that their people were famous for and letting down the Hobbit way of life. And he really had to bite his tongue to stop himself snarling at their hypocrisy, living in a nice stone house in Dale with barely a garden or window box worth the effort. They were auditors for the agriculture office of Dale, allowing them to snoop into everyone’s business and cause as much trouble as they wished while making far more money than they deserved. And despite being worried about ‘Hobbit sensibilities’ and ‘the family’ name, they had been conspicuous by their absence when his parents had died.
He blinked, dragging his attention back to Master Dori. The dwarf was pacing and looking unhappy.
“I really wouldn’t do it but Draghira and Brekt have both called in sick-they say coughs but I happen to know they were celebrating Azanulbizar Day down in the Taverns all yesterday evening. So I need someone good, quick and reliable.” Bilbo blinked. It was the first overt praise he had received from any dwarf for his work and he found himself curiously self-conscious.
“Thank you,” he mumbled. Dori managed a small smile.
“Naught but the truth, Bilbo,” he said honestly.”So I am going to give you a very sensitive duty. There is a corridor, round the back of the Royal Quarters that can only be accessed through the opal-crusted door behind the statue of King Dain I. You know the one?”
“The angry-looking dwarf statue on the ninth level beside the gallery overlooking the Throne Room?” Bilbo checked. Dori snorted.
“I believe you are correct,” he said. “Can you clean the corridor and then head along to help Ori catalogue some new scrolls of Elvish Poems?” Bilbo nodded cheerfully.
“Of course,” he said. “Should I avoid being seen?” Dori paused and then shook his head.
“Just keep your head down and do a good job, lad,” he said with a sigh. “I know you won’t let me down…”
So Bilbo found himself and his little cleaning cart trundling up the long ramps all the way up to the ninth level-far above where he was usually allowed. Along the way, he had to dodge grumpy heavily-armoured dwarves who all glared at him as if he were committing some appalling crime by simply being on such elevated environs. He always ducked his head and mumbled appropriate apologies even when he had to dodge them almost running into him, not caring that he almost plunged over the edge of a walkway on more than one occasion. Biting his tongue against an ill-advised retort, Bilbo hastened his way upwards until he finally reached the level of the Royal Wing, smiling harmlessly to the guards stationed at the entrance to the Royal Corridor as he pressed on and finally reached his destination.
Quietly, he looked at the door, half-concealed behind a massive and imposing statue of a dwarven King who appeared in a very ill-humour, his face twisted in a yell of fury and his hands grasping the haft of an axe. Bilbo shuddered, for the look was very unpleasant-and not dissimilar to ones he had seen directed specifically at him for the crime of being a Hobbit in the great dwarf Kingdom of Erebor. Yet Erebor needed workers and the former residents of the devastated Shire had needed a new home and jobs. Many worked in Dale, a few on the borders of Mirkwood and far fewer in Esgaroth, for Hobbits and water didn’t really mix. But Bilbo was one of very few who had been accepted in the service of the dwarves. Thinking back, he wondered why-though he knew the wizard Gandalf the Grey had put in a good word for him, for he had been a friend of Bilbo’s late Mother, Belladonna, and had expressed great sorrow and guilt that he had not been there in her hour of need.
Bilbo just made the best of things. It was all he could do, after all and the alternative was to become bitter and mean like Lobelia and Otho-and that was not to be contemplated. So he pressed the specific places on the door that Dori had carefully explained to him and the panel silently swung inwards, revealing the corridor that almost no one knew existed. Made of the same deep green stone of Erebor as everywhere else, the faint seams of gold gleamed in the light of the crystals in the ornate holders. He glanced at them-someone had to have charged them, for they needed to be refuelled every couple of weeks…and yet the floor was dusty with only a few scuffs in the middle. Sighing, he took out his bucket and mop and began to clean the place properly.
Consumed by his task and daydreaming about the last Elvish Lay he had read in the Library-a rather beautiful version of the Tale of Beren and Luthien-he had not noticed the statue until he had almost bumped into it, half-concealed behind a dog-leg in the corridor. That told the Hobbit that this was a natural passageway, for the dwarves were excellent craftsmen and their tunnels were always straight as an arrow's flight, smooth and perfectly finished, even for insignificant places like the third root cellar under the kitchens. So he paused and blinked, staring at the shape in grey stone and almost treading on the little tired bunch of flowers that were placed sadly by his feet.
And the statue was a he-there would be no debate about that. He seemed to be tall for a dwarf, topping Bilbo by a head and powerfully built. Undeniably handsome, his features were striking but his expression seemed to be a cross between shocked and sad, eyes wide and staring beyond where he could see. The person was dressed in good quality clothes-the folds of the tunic and the detail of the short-sleeved mail he wore over his shirt under the tunic were exceptional, as were the fine carvings on the stone beads of his braids. Bilbo could almost see every hair in the statue’s long hair and the short beard that was incongruous with his obvious status. And then he remembered that Ori had mentioned that some of the Azanulbizar veterans kept their beards short in mourning for the terrible loss of life in the carnage of the battle. Could this dwarf have been a veteran, could he have fought for the promise of liberating Moria, only to be broken by the armies of orcs that had poured from the deeps, massacring the brave dwarves? Certainly, the hand that was outstretched was large and strong, definitely good enough to wield a sword or axe to slay the enemy.
Then he noticed that the statue was dusty as well and a shiver of sadness ran through him. Silly and inconsequential as he was, Bilbo knew that this dwarf was clearly someone important for such a magnificent statue to have been made. And so he certainly didn’t deserve to be forgotten. Determinedly he gathered his duster and carefully and respectfully made sure the statue was spotless before returning to his mopping. There was something familiar about the statue-perhaps he had seen someone who looked like the dwarf once-and despite feeling foolish, he spoke.
“I'll bring you some fresh flowers when I get off duty,” he said and looked into the handsome face. “No one deserves to be forgotten.”
The promise was easier said than done and after he had finally mopped the corridor and returned, one of the kitchen workers had come down sick, so Bilbo had been shuffled into the bakery section, helping to make savoury rolls for the main meal. Bombur, the Head Chef, was a generous and kind dwarf and he valued his Hobbit helpers. Hugely rotund and almost a Hobbit in his love of food, he had flaming red hair and a huge looped braid of moustache that rested down over his ample middle like a rope. Allowing Bilbo to make his rolls without supervision was another vote of confidence that had the Hobbit feeling much happier than he had for some months. And when Dinner was done, he was released early to allow the dwarven kitchen workers to finish washing up, since his official shift was supposed to have finished a couple of hours earlier.
But as he walked through the gates, he turned right and made his way up the flanks of the mountain in the twilight gloom and started casting around. Like any Hobbit, he was well versed in the flowers of the old Shire and the new selection in the region of the Lone Farthing and the area around Erebor. Bungo would have been mortified if his son didn’t know his flowers so Bilbo scrambled up the steep path until he found the right kind of conditions amid shattered rocks and rockfalls and cast around. And there, tucked out of the wind, were the little clump of deep green leaves and, nestled out of the wind, a spray of white star-shaped flowers about as broad as his thumb across. Deftly, he plucked them and then cast around once more.
It only took him about ten minutes more to have a decent bunch that he used a thin vine to secure. The cold was settling around the mountain and he was starting to shiver as he struggled down and presented himself at the door. The guard looked sceptical but Bilbo had enough feistiness in his heart to deal with grumpy and cold dwarves.
“I was asked to fetch these for Master Dori,” he said in response to a hostile question.
“Leave him, Huri,” the other guard growled. “It’s that Halfling, Bilbo. He comes every morning, always on time. Let him through.”
Cheeks flaming, Bilbo scooted in and carefully made his way up to the Royal Floor, then slipped into the now sparkling corridor. The lamps offered a steady, warm light and he walked along, conscious of the sounds of his breath in the muted silence. It was strange to think that beyond the wall to his right, the Royal Family lived in (probable) extreme luxury while here, an insignificant Hobbit brought flowers for a forgotten statue. Finally, he found himself facing the stone figure once more, marvelling all over at the perfection of the sculpture. And how could someone not be awed at the astonishing craftsmanship in the likeness? Yet, no one had thought this astonishing work of this hero worthy even of a plinth, let alone caring for it or visiting…
Quietly, Bilbo picked up the desiccated bunch that had clearly sat there for far too long and placed the fresh blooms at the feet of the statue. He hoped the cool in the corridor would allow them to last at least a little, for the dried out bouquet had made him feel rather sad. He bowed his head for a few moments and then turned away, the dried out flowers in his hand.
He had almost made the door when the sound of a footstep had him jumping. Eyes wide, he looked around for somewhere to hide but there was nowhere-and then a voice called out and he froze.
“What are you doing here?”
The voice was deep and rich, the note of command unmistakeable. Unable to resist, Bilbo turned and then he almost gaped.
For facing him was the same dwarf who had been the subject of the statue. The likeness was uncanny and Bilbo was shocked to see that his hair was a deep brown that verged on black, the beads gleaming silver against the long dark mane that was shot with a few strands of silver and were exactly the same as those in the stone. His eyes were a piercing blue and his features, regular and definite, were even more handsome in person. And he had an undeniable charisma, an aura of power. So Bilbo bowed, realising that he had to be a member of the Royal Family.
“What are you doing here, Halfling?” the dwarf repeated. Bilbo’s head snapped up and despite being overwhelmed by meeting the dwarven Prince, he felt a surge of anger.
“Excuse me, your Highness, but I’m Half of nothing,” he said, wondering where he got the nerve to speak to a Dwarf Prince like this. “I am a Hobbit.” There was an awkward pause and the dwarf took a deep breath as he glared at the Hobbit. Bilbo was not as round as most Hobbits, his pleasant face careworn and tired. His burnished brown curls were lank and his clothes-standard Hobbit cut-off pants, shirt, waistcoat and jacket-were grubby.
“Then Master Hobbit, I repeat myself a third time. What are you doing here?” the dwarf Prince demanded. Bilbo sighed and gestured with the dried flowers in his hand.
“I was assigned to clean this corridor today,” he said quietly. “And I saw a statue-of you, actually-just round the corner. It was dusty and the place looked rather abandoned. There were these dead flowers at its feet and I thought it was disrespectful to leave them. So I went and collected fresh flowers and put them in their place.”
The dwarf cast a glance over his shoulder and then nodded.
“Why so late?” he asked with a frown.
“I only got off work half an hour ago and I promised I would do it,” Bilbo said, wishing it didn’t sound so stupid to him. “So I gathered some flowers in the gloom and brought them back while I remembered. They’re Mountain Tears.”
“Thatratûr’abdul," the dwarf said. A small smile lifted the corners of his mouth. “They were always my mother’s favourite.” Bilbo nodded.
“Anyway, I must be going. I am sorry to have disturbed your Highness..." Bilbo gabbled, still staring at the floor and missing the look of alarm in the dwarf’s eyes.
“Wait!” the dwarf said, urgency in his tone. Bilbo looked up.
“Yes, Your Highness?” he asked softly. The Prince sighed.
“May I have your name, Master Hobbit?” he requested, the tone humbler than any he had yet used.
“I-I am really sorry,” Bilbo gabbled.”Please-I need the work. I promise never to come back and…”
“You are not in trouble, Master Hobbit-the opposite, in fact,” the Prince assured him, a gentler look in his eyes. “I just wished to ensure your…diligence was given due credit.” Calming his breathing, Bilbo nodded.
“Bilbo Baggins-at your service,” he said and bowed low. There was a pause and then the Prince inclined his head and managed a small bow of his own.
“Thorin Oakenshield, at yours,” he replied. “Please-I hope I have not frightened you, Master Baggins? Forgive my harsh words, for I was not expecting to see one of your people in this place. You must be trusted to have been given such a duty.” Bilbo ducked his head.
“Master Dori said I was trusted enough for this duty,” he mumbled. Thorin gave a small smile.
“Dori is a good judge,” he admitted. “None of my own people would think to replace flowers at the foot of a statue.” Bilbo looked up.
“I am a Hobbit,” he repeated. “We honour those who fell or sacrificed or were lost with flowers. It is how we were made.”
“Hmm. My own people would simply carve a magnificent statue of the hero and then admire and honour it.” His tone was reflective.
“Or put it away and ignore it,” Bilbo found himself saying, not missing the wince on the Prince’s face. “Flowers and plants make memory alive and vital.”
The Prince stared at him, hearing the edge to his voice. Who did you lose? he thought. Why does it affect me so much? He rested his hand flat over his chest unconsciously. Why does it hurt to hear that pain in your voice? He looked at the smaller being, reading exhaustion and loneliness in the strangely-familiar face.
“Master Hobbit, I would like to see you again but this place is the only way I can escape my duties the Royal Quarters,” he said, praying for forgiveness for the lie.
“I-I don’t want to cause you any trouble…" the Hobbit said, looking up at the taller being. But the dwarf was not going to be denied.
“Come any evening after work and I will be waiting,” he said, his deep voice soft. “I am often here. It would be welcome to have some company.”
“And there are no others who can come?” Bilbo asked. But the Prince shook his head and a look of unbearable sadness filled his eyes.
“You are my only hope, Master Hobbit,” he said softly. “Will you do this for me?” He twitched a smile. “You did offer your service…”
“As did you,” Bilbo pointed out and then sighed. “Very well. But I warn you-I am hardly likely to be of interest to a Prince and a veteran…”
“Yet the fact you know that fact intrigues me,” Thorin told him. Bilbo gave a small smile.
“The beard,” he said. The Prince gave a rueful smile of his own.
“Many call us excessively pious but in that battle, I lost cousins and friends and my brother. My grandfather was beheaded before my eyes and I was powerless stop it. The air was acrid with the stench of blood and charred flesh as we burned the dead, for there was not enough stone to try to bury them decently. I mourn my brother every day of my life. The disfigurement of a short beard is a small price to pay to remember him.”
“I am sorry,” Bilbo apologised, feeling curl of sympathy. “It is hard to lose someone so close.” Thorin walked forward, his eyes dark with understanding and sympathy.
“Who did you lose?” he asked in a low voice. Bilbo looked up into the concerned face and swallowed.
“My parents,” he admitted.”Now, if you will excuse me-I really have to go!” Then he sketched a bow and almost ran from the corridor, sprinting to ensure he was able to leave before the gates were secured for the night. He would be lucky to catch the last cart back to the Shire but he felt the overwhelming need to sleep in his own bed, surrounded by the memories of his parents. If he was late, he could always take a room in the servants’ quarters-the dwarves were very generous to their employees if they kept you late-but now more than ever, he wanted to go home. The last thing he wanted was to sleep in a stone room deep under the mountain when he felt so sad and homesick. Despite his fondness for some of the dwarves, Bilbo was still a Hobbit, a creature of air and light and earth. And it was only when he emerged into the cold night air and began the brisk walk back to his home and the welcome sight of the fast cart back to Dale, his collar turned up against the autumnal chill, that he wondered where the Prince had come from. His keen ears had heard no door open or steps coming closer-the dwarf had almost appeared from thin air.
But then he put his head down and quickened his pace to scramble aboard before they left. He needed his rest and he had another long day ahead of him.
-o0o-
It was a week before he was able to return, sneaking time that should be his lunch break to scuttle up to the Royal level and replace the flowers with a fresh bunch. The corridor remained clean though he knew he would need to return soon and he cast around for the Prince, but saw nothing. With a sigh, he walked towards the position of the statue-and then stopped as Prince Thorin rounded the corner, his eyes clearing as he saw the Hobbit. Bilbo could have sworn he gave a sigh of relief.
“I feared you wouldn’t return,” he said gruffly, though there was a small smile on his lips. Bilbo froze, his eyes widening.
“Oh, I am so sorry,” he said hastily. “I have been really busy-there have been so many staff off sick and Master Dori needed me elsewhere and…"
“Peace, Master Bilbo-I mean no criticism,” the Prince said, his deep voice warm. “I feared I had scared you off.” The Hobbit looked up at the dwarf Prince and sighed.
“I am not sure that I am of any interest to you, your Highness,” he admitted. But Thorin leaned against the wall, his clothes very similar the previous ones. Bilbo wondered if he had several of each and then felt the Prince walk closer. Heat radiated off his sturdy body, his eyes dark and intense.
“Master Hobbit-you are of interest to me for many reasons, not least of which is because you are not a dwarf,” the Prince admitted wryly. “I recall when your people first moved east of the Misty Mountains and settled the lands around Dale. I am ashamed to confess that my people were uninterested in our new neighbours, save in how we could exploit you for our further advancement.” The Hobbit looked up and pushed aside the hurt he felt at the blunt and honest words. Dwarves really didn’t have much filter or diplomacy.
“None of us expected to be welcomed like long-lost cousins but all Hobbits love food, family and growing things,” he admitted. “We are Children of Yavanna, after all. For our ways to be suppressed and for only those who are farming for food to be allowed any land to grow things on was cruel and wrong. It severed our connection with the land and deprived us of necessary food. Many are hungry and the foods you insist we grow are not the best for my people. Roots are not enough.” Thorin stared at him and for a moment, the Hobbit wondered if he was in trouble. Then he felt his shoulders sag. Of course he was in trouble, speaking so frankly with a Prince and criticising his people when Bilbo, in truth, barely knew the dwarf. Yet Thorin tilted his head and looked uncomfortable.
“I see we have wronged you more than I suspected,” the Prince said, folding his hands behind his back, the pose both regal and controlled. Bilbo regretted the furrow in Thorin’s brow that the Hobbit had put there with his words. “And you? How have we wronged you?” Bilbo backed away.
“You haven’t per se,” he admitted. Thorin narrowed his eyes.
“Yet you work hard in a job that should be performed by a stronger dwarf rather than a Hobbit,” he commented. “Your people are exceptional cooks. Was there no space in the kitchens?”
“Do you believe I am not capable of the work?” Bilbo asked, his tone tart. Thorin pinched the bridge of his nose.
“I believe you are capable of whatever you put your mind to,” he managed. “But you strike me more as a cook, a scholar. How come you work here and not in a Hobbit business in the Lone Farthing?”
“I have no family except some unpleasant cousins and my parents are dead,” Bilbo snapped, feeling put upon when he was doing the dwarf a favour in visiting him. “Now if all you wanted me for was to criticise my abilities, then I will bid you good day…”
“WAIT!” Thorin called and then his voice dropped. “Please. I truly meant no harm…but you are the first being I have seen for so long who isn’t one of my close kin. I-I just wanted to understand you better, to know you better.” He gave a small self-deprecating smile. “Dwalin used to note I couldn’t hold a conversation without it sounding like an interrogation! I-I am not noted for my subtlety but I know that I have offended you.” He sighed. “Please don’t leave me so soon. I haven’t met anyone for so long it…” His voice dropped. “I fear I will go mad sometimes from the isolation. Please-I will answer whatever questions you have, if you feel it is needed even the score.” There was a look on his handsome face that appeared as if he was walking to his execution but Bilbo sighed.
“I wouldn’t know what to ask a Prince,” he admitted as Thorin remained tense.
“What would ask a new acquaintance in the Shire?” he asked. “What would you say to a friend?” The Hobbit’s gaze snapped up to the dwarf Prince’s face and wondered what the subplot was. The Royal Family was necessarily distant but they fulfilled a full calendar of engagements and participated fully in the running of the Kingdom. As far as he could tell, they were very popular, though he hadn’t paid much attention to their recent engagements. For the Prince to imply he was all but a prisoner was very concerning-and confusing that he was reaching out to a Hobbit who had no power to do anything. Surely he had more resources than that?
It was even more confusing that this Prince, who had been rude and hostile the first time he had set eyes on Bilbo was now seeming to be trying to be treated as a friend. Surely it had to be some kind of cruel trick, a jape that he would play for a while then scoff at the naive and stupid Hobbit and dismiss him from his presence, after scorning the personal information he would have wheedled out of Bilbo. But Hobbit manners would not allow Bilbo to refuse the proffered connection and he sighed. His parents would expect him to behave properly, no matter what butterflies fluttered within his stomach.
“Well, I would ask you about your family and friends, what you like and dislike, favourite foods, pastimes…” he began and Thorin exhaled.
“And for me?" he asked, his gruff voice not extinguishing the little note of hope in his words. Bilbo nodded.
“Do you have any family?" he asked and then gave huff of laughter. "I mean, that is an embarrassingly stupid question and…”
“My father seems gruff but he is very proud of us,” he admitted. “He misses my mother, Queen Fris, horribly, but she returned to the stone too soon. He and I think she died of grief after Azanulbizar when I brought back to news of my brother’s death. He was always the golden Prince, the outgoing son…the favourite. I was not her favourite, though I was firstborn. I never mistook my place in her affections, though I loved her. I heard the rumours that sometimes she wept that I should have died instead of beloved Frerin.” He exhaled slowly and the brief, sharp pain in his eyes was obvious. “I knew they had to be true for she could not look on me without something akin to betrayal in her eyes for the remainder of her days. My younger sister, Dis, always told me never to listen to them, but I have enough guilt for not being able to save him that I could never follow her advice.”
Without even thinking, Bilbo rested a hand on Thorin’s arm. More surprisingly, the dwarf did not shake his touch off.
“I am so sorry,” he said genuinely. “I remember when my parents died, I always wished that I could fight and help protect them…but they made sure I was safe at their own expense…and of course,I am only a Hobbit.”
“What happened?” the Prince asked, his eyes curious.
“Orc attack,” Bilbo sighed. “They ripped through Hobbitthorpe because the patrol was slow to respond or pick them up. Seven Hobbits were killed but only one family lost more than one member-mine. Both my parents were slain because neither could leave the other behind and hide. The patrol were matter of fact and claimed they hadn’t suffered but I wanted to scream at them that they should have been there. That neither of them should’ve died when we were lured to the Lone Farthing with the promises of dwarvish protection that failed when it was most needed.”
Thorin stiffened and reeled back a pace. His face was stricken and he looked almost unbelieving, shaking his head.
"It could not be,” he murmured. “You’re the Hobbit they failed-and they made you a drudge?” His voice rose. “I am…I was…in charge of the local defence and when I was informed that the patrol was not on their route and that Half…Hobbits…died, I demanded that the affected families were treated like nobility. I was assured that compensation had been paid and everyone had been assured a secure living and their needs seen to.”
Bilbo frowned, finding himself staring at the Prince and trying to cling to the hard kernel of anger that he had nursed within his heart these years. There was always a resentment that he had lost so much and others who had lost less seemed to have been gifted plenty of things to make them secure and safe by the dwarves. In fact he had decided that he had been completely forgotten…unless…
“Oh, they wouldn’t have…" he breathed, his face flushing with anger. Thorin frowned.
“Who wouldn’t have what?” the Prince requested, his eyes concerned.
“You remember those appalling cousins I mentioned?” Bilbo breathed, his fists clenched. “They moved up in the world after I lost Mum and Dad. They moved into a new house in Dale and their business got a huge boost. I guess they claimed to be the nearest relatives of the Bagginses and stole what was intended for me…” Thorin blinked.
"Mahal," he murmured. “I had not credited your people with such dwarvish levels of greed…” Bilbo gave a small, bitter chuckle.
“Every race and every family had the odd one,” he murmured. Thorin shook his head.
“Even my cousin Dain would not be so obvious,” he muttered, then realised that Bilbo was staring. “Dain is Lord of the Iron Hills. His grandfather and mine were brothers-and rivals. They always had to go one better than the other-who was richer, stronger, better at arms, had killed more orcs. The pair united to attack Khazad-Dûm but even then, there was the rivalry to gain entry to the Eastern Gate first. Nain ignored the battle plans and led his battalion ahead, crashing against an emerging throng. Azog cut him almost in half and cast him aside like nothing for he was seeking Thror. When the battle was done, Gror’s son and brother were gone. He died of grief when his son, Dain, reported the outcome. And since, he has been eyeing Erebor. With my…condition, he sees himself as the only natural heir.”
“And is he?” Bilbo asked, watching the emotions flicker across Thorin’s face. The dwarf was regal and controlled but his eyes were expressive and his emotions were there-if you could read them. And somehow, despite meeting this Prince but once previously, Bilbo Baggins of Hobbitthorpe in the Lone Farthing could read him like a book.
“I have no spouse or offspring but my sister, Dis, has two sons," Thorin revealed. “And while they are young and playful, they carry the same right to rule as any child of mine would. They are my heirs. But still he eyes the throne. And with my possible removal, he sees his chance…”
“Are you unwell?” Bilbo asked him plainly, guessing that it was just his luck-to befriend a Prince only for him to up and die a few days after getting to know him. “Can I help?”
There was a pause and the Prince looked uncomfortable.
“I cannot reveal any details," he sighed and then looked up. “And I know that I promised to answer any questions but I am sworn to secrecy in this. My father, the King, has placed a command of secrecy upon all the Kingdom that nothing may be spoken of with outsiders.” Bilbo glared and then nodded. Blasted dwarvish secrecy at its worst.
“Can I help?” he repeated. Thorin sagged.
“You are helping by being here,” he said. “This is a lonely vigil…” The Hobbit folded his arms.
"I can’t say I think much of your family if they leave you alone for so long,” he complained. But he was met with a warm smile by the Prince.
“Fili and Kili are young and would be bored here,” he sighed. “I was never the ‘fun’ Uncle-that fell to my brother. The others have duties-more now that I am indisposed. I understand. But sometimes, being forced into solitude and silence teaches you lessons that cannot be learned in a busy life.” Bilbo watched him, entranced.
“Do you want something to eat?” he asked and then mentally kicked himself. “I mean, I happen to know that Bombur is making the most divine cheese and chutney scones and I am sure I could persuade him to part with plateful…” In a second, Thorin was pulling a heavy iron ring from his left hand, a dull green stone set in the thick band.
“Show this to Bombur,” he said and nodded. “He will provide whatever you request.”
“Can’t I just say that it’s for you?” Thorin huffed a bitter laugh and shook his head.
“That would be against my father’s edict,” he said slowly. “Say the request is from uzbad-dashat‘aban.” Bilbo nodded.
“Will you still be here?” he asked and the Prince nodded.
“I will be waiting,” he confirmed as he watched the Hobbit slid through the door. He could already feel the cold spiking up his limbs as it closed and he stumbled as the blackness took him.
-o0o-
"Ori-if I was to ask about Prince Thorin, what could you tell me?” Bilbo was helping in the Library again, flicking through the Elvish poetry that Ori was cataloguing. The young dwarf looked at him with his amber eyes, his russet pudding-bowl hair only lightly braided. Ori was a keen knitter-unusual among dwarves-and he was wearing multiple knitted clothes over his standard tunic and leather trousers.
“He’s the oldest son of King Thrain, a hero of Azanulbizar and a great warrior,” he said. “Captain Dwalin is his best friend.”
“And…”
“And there is nothing else I can say because you aren’t a dwarf,” Ori admitted, looking unhappy. “You know how it is…”
“I heard a rumour that he was unwell,” Bilbo pressed.
“Bilbo…”
“If someone met him, how would he talk to a Prince who is a secret?” Bilbo asked him tartly. “Has recommitted some heinous crime? Betrayed the Crown? Is he disfigured?” Now the younger dwarf was shaking his head urgently.
“Please, Bilbo,” he said in an agony of conflict. “Look, I could get into terrible trouble-but Prince Thorin is heroic and brave and decent. He is admired by all but there is a Curse upon him.The King needs to break the curse by midwinter day, the Solstice, or he will never be freed.”
They worked quietly for a long while after that, with Bilbo considering carefully. He knew that the King, that Erebor could afford the best advice and he was certain they would find a way to break the curse, whatever it was. Yet it seemed really unfair to have Thorin essentially locked away while he waited for the curse to be broken. Thorin had seemed embarrassed about his ‘condition’ but he had not seemed dangerous-and there was the strongest sensation that he was such an honourable dwarf that he would warn off anyone who was in peril from him.
“Have you met him?” Ori’s question was out of the blue and the Hobbit blinked, blindsided. Then he nodded.
“While I was cleaning,” he said, deciding the stick to a half-truth. “He spoke with me. At first he was rather grumpy but then…he just chatted…like a friend…I think he’s rather lonely. And when you get past the grumpiness and the whole being Royal facade which he does very well, he’s an Uncle who loves his nephews and a rather interesting historian of Erebor.”
Ori blinked and then stared at him.
“Are you sure it wasn’t someone pretending…” he began but Bilbo shook his head.
“He asked me to get food in the name of ‘uzbad-dashat’aban’ which I don’t know how to say properly let alone what it means,” Bilbo told him honestly then fumbled in his pocket, ignoring Ori’s wince at his mangling of the words. “And he gave me this to show to Bombur…” He opened his hand to show the Prince’s iron ring. Ori slapped his hand over the ring and looked alarmed.
“Put that away!” he hissed. “Where did you get that?” Bilbo frowned.
“I told you…” he began as Ori sagged and put his head in his hands.
“Just assuming I believe you,” he said, raising a hand to prevent the irritated Hobbit from snapping a reply, “I cannot ask you any questions or tell you anything useful.”
“But why?” Bilbo was bewildered.
“King’s edict,” Ori said and sighed again. “Look, I can’t help but if you see…him again, remember that if things go ill, on the stroke of midnight on the solstice, he will be lost.” The Hobbit stared at him.
“What can I do?” he asked. Shuffling his papers, Ori picked at a loose stitch on his knitted fingerless gloves and sighed.
“Be yourself,” he advised. “Being yourself is clearly what he needs. And if he speaks to you as a friend, then he knows it. Give him a chance. All those who know him well speak of one who is a loyal and dedicated friend.” Bilbo reached for the next scroll and nodded.
“It’s nice to be treated like a real person,” he admitted. But as he gathered an armful to reshelve in the ‘Weed Eater’ section, Ori watched him.
“My friend, you are probably the most important person in Erebor,” he murmured. “You just don’t understand why.”
-o0o-
The next time Bilbo went to see Thorin, he took a picnic he had scrounged using the Prince’s ring. Bombur gave a silent nod and had turned a very blind eye to the little Hobbit pillaging his pantry to ensure that the isolated Prince got a good meal. He had also allowed Bilbo to do a little light baking alongside the work he was doing for the Head Chef so that he had fresh home-baked goods to treat his friend to. Thorin was waiting as he walked into the secret passageway, a look of hope and relief his eyes.
“Master Bilbo,” he greeted, bowing his head but the Hobbit smiled.
“Your Highness, it is simply Bilbo,” he corrected the dwarf. “We have shared stories of our family losses, broken bread…well, scone…together and this is our third meeting. You have insulted me, I have scolded you and you are still pleased to see me. In my book, that makes friends.” The look of astonishment and gratitude in Thorin’s face made Bilbo’s bold words feel justified. He was after all, a proper Hobbit, despite his appalling relatives, but in this, he was feeling adventurous and rather Tookish, like his mother’s rather wild birth family. And he was shocked that the Prince willingly sat down on the blanket he had brought and savoured the food he had brought.There were meat pies, cheese and bread, baked potatoes wrapped in waxed paper, apple and cinnamon tarts that Bilbo had made and flasks of ale that they shared. And through it, they chatted as old friends, with Bilbo filling the Prince in on the events of the week as Thorin had begged for news. It was touchingly clear that Thorin was grateful for any details and asked questions to clarify his understanding. Sometimes Bilbo could answer but more often, he could not. Yet the Prince never seemed impatient at his ignorance at the lack of detail he was offered: instead, he asked for the Hobbit's impressions, valuing the other being's perspective on the affairs of the Mountain. And it was clear that he appreciated the external eye on the dealings of his people, no matter how incomplete his knowledge.
Shocked, the Prince found himself valuing the time spent with the Hobbit above anything he could recall. He missed his family, of course, though visits had been clearly few and far between and he would be lying if he did not feel grief at their way of dealing with his affliction. There was a twilight when he was cursed, a vague consciousness that meant he was aware that people were visiting, aware of what they said and what they did to him, but not of the altered state of his being nor of the passage of time. Somehow, the curse provided him with the means to contemplate his fate, the awareness to feel the pain of his condition and the isolation to perhaps drive him mad…if it had not been for Bilbo.
And somehow, Mahal had known what he needed, known that Thorin son of Thrain son of Thror, called Oakenshield and ‘the Hero of Azanulbizar’ needed a time to learn that pride and prejudice and anger and coldness was no defence against the anger of a Valar or the curse of his line. And that knowledge and humility and compassion were more important than harking back to the woes of five thousand years earlier and an insult that one of the Line of Durin had given to a powerful Elf-Lord or maybe Maiar. He knew when Bilbo approached, felt the warmth blossom in the centre of his chest and the dawn of hope that the arrival of the Hobbit brought. But he couldn’t bring himself to reveal his curse, didn’t want the pity and horror to twist Bilbo’s kindly face and lay him under any form of obligation. Finding himself greedy for genuine affection, Thorin determined that he would nurture their friendship honestly and only ask more of the Hobbit if he was sure his own feelings were requited.
He stood, offering his hand to the Hobbit.
“Come with me,” he said, his voice sounding gruff and commanding to his own ear. He consciously modulated his tone. “Please. I wish to show you my favourite place in Erebor…as a thanks for such a generous meal.” Bilbo looked up, tidying things back into the picnic basket he had managed to bring.
“I thought you weren’t able to leave here?” he asked, his eyes wide and a little furrow on his brow. Thorin lifted his chin, erecting his ‘regal’ facade and tilted his head.
“I shouldn’t leave but with you…for you…it is worth the hazard,” the Prince said and gave a small smile. “Stay close…please…” And he offered his hand again. This time, Bilbo took it and allowed the Prince as they approached the door. Silently, Thorin opened the door a crack and listened. then he glanced at the Hobbit. “Do you hear anything?”
“Just the breathing of the guard forty paces to our left by the gates to the Royal Quarters,” Bilbo told him and gave a small smirk. “Hobbit hearing is very sensitive.” Thorin’s gaze lingered on the leaf-shaped ears, startlingly similar to those of Elves and yet not offensive when belonging to the Hobbit. He consciously stamped down on the prejudiced thoughts.
Nodding, Thorin hauled him across the walkway and into a little alcove that turned out to be a stairwell that vanished upwards in the green rock walls of the mountain. Curious, Bilbo looked around as he followed, his leather feet almost noiseless as he followed the tall dwarf Prince up the carven steps. Though he was not entirely comfortable in small enclosed spaces within the mountain, there was a large rather Tookish part of him that was curious. After all, though Thorin had shared tales of his family and his history as a warrior, it had always been as if the Prince had been holding back of himself, telling stories of his exploits but nothing of the dwarf under the deeds. His obvious sadness at the way his mother had favoured his brother over him was the closest Bilbo had got to seeing Thorin’s heart.
Not that Bilbo was thinking anything appropriate. No-of course not…because there was no point anyway. Thorin was a Prince, the Crown Prince, the Heir to the throne of the richest kingdom on Arda while Bilbo was an orphaned Hobbit with almost no family who would acknowledge him and who was just a simple menial in the mountain. And though Thorin was handsome and charismatic and brave, he was always a little reserved and gruff when Bilbo asked him what he thought or felt about some of the events he had participated in. Thorin was a Prince and though they were friends, they were from different worlds, let along different races. But every time he saw the Prince, his day was brighter and he felt less alone. And that wasn’t disrespecting or discounting his other friends-Ori, Dori, Bombur, even the grumpy guard, Hurtur, at the gates-it was just different.
They seemed to climb forever but it must just have been ten minutes or so. Bilbo felt as if his feet were falling off and he had needed to stop a couple of times to catch his breath-but the Prince had waited, matching his pace to the Hobbit’s. Until finally, Bilbo could feel the cool caress of fresh air, so alien that it had him halting and pausing to take a deep breath. And then they emerged onto a large flat area open to the air on one side, overhung by a natural rocky canopy and with a series of open chambers to the right where multiple dark-plumaged birds perched, chattering.
“This is the Raven’s Eyrie, where the Ravens of Erebor sleep in bad weather and stay when they are on duty for delivering messages for the Kingdom,” Thorin explained. “Most live in Ravenhill but there are always some willing to carry messages and those stay here for the term of their duty. Their families live in Ravenhill but they are always welcome here in the worst of weather, where the warmth of the mountain keeps them safe and where meat is provided for our allies.”
Bilbo blinked, aware of the acrid, pungent edge to the air when he sniffed that direction. A part of him desperately wanted to get a bucket and mop and clean the place out, preferably with lavender soap to dissipate the stench…But then his gaze was caught by the spectacular vista that spread beneath him, the whole of the environs of Erebor visible. There was Dale, the great city of men, its gaily-coloured flags flying in the bitter breeze. Further off was Esgaroth, whiffs of the damp scent of the lake carried on the wind. Far to the west was the dark shadow of Mirkwood, the home of the Elves. And between Dale and Mirkwood was the rolling land of the Lone Farthing, the fields and nurseries and barns now swathed in snow as the winter tightened its grip. The little lines of smoke from the chimneys in the Hobbit settlements were blown sideways but marked the hidden homes and Bilbo felt a pang of homesickness for his original home in Bag End, the long-lost smial his father had built his mother as a courting gift, back in the Shire.
And then a sudden wave of vertigo washed over him, his head spinning at the realisation of how high up he truly was. Almost the whole mountain was below him, hundreds of feet of drop mere inches from his toes. And the wind seemed much stronger up here, ice running through him and seeming to call him towards the edge. Somehow the floor seemed to be uneven and tilting as he blinked and stared at the horrific chasm…
Then warm hands closed on his shoulders and he found his body pulled a little further back from the edge. He found himself pressed against the warm solidity of Thorin’s body, his grip grounding and reassuring. Bilbo could feel the steady motion of his breaths as the Prince stood behind him. There was the silky caress against his cheek of a lock of Thorin’s long hair, caught on the wind.
“This is my favourite place in Erebor,” the dwarf said, his tone gruff and measured. “I came up here as the first place when I had returned from Azanulbizar, when my heart was filled with hatred and pain and grief. No one could reach me amid the horrific losses we had lost, yet I sought solace here, alone with my grief. I hardened my heart and armoured myself against any kindly feeling towards the other races. I was mired in grief and prejudice and anger and I was not the dwarf I should have been. But still I kept coming, kept staring at this view until my affliction took me. And finally, alone with my thoughts and the memories of the beauty and silence of this place, I realised the truth.” Bilbo exhaled, feeling the tension in the dwarf’s body.
“And what was that?” he asked.
“From this height, we are all the same. Elves and Dwarrow, Men and Half…Hobbits,” the Prince sighed. “We are all tiny and insignificant. The land remains, the world remains, no matter what we do. Our deeds live in tales that will one day be forgotten. Our cities will fall to ruin and new ones arise in different places. But still I clung to my grief and my pain until I suffered the curse of it. And then I realised the true message that this view told me. That we all live together on Arda under Eru and the Valar. Our lives are little and brief and what time we have should not be wasted with bitterness and pain. And we all live together, our lands and homes shoulder to shoulder in a world that is cold and uncaring. More binds us than divides us and I should recall this, not the anger at lack of help in any one battle.”
Bilbo closed his eyes and felt the cold breeze his face. He should feel cold but heat was leeching from Thorin into his body-and now he thought about it, he always felt a warmth in his chest whenever he was with the Prince.
“I tried to feel anger at the dwarves who failed to protect us when they had sworn to do so,” Bilbo found himself saying. “I tried to feel betrayed by the Elves who assured us that lives by their eaves would be as safe as if we were in the Shire itself. I tried to feel bitterness at the Men who exploited our skills for meagre rewards but did not come when we were in desperate need. But none of those help me. I am a Hobbit with few family-and fewer I can trust and call upon. So I have to trade with Men and work for the dwarves and forget that I am a creature of earth, of the Green Lady Yavanna who made us for the Shire. Because orcs destroyed my home and my part of the Shire and our safety was gone, never to be returned. If I am bitter and angry, I am no better than Otho and Lobelia and I will be forever unhappy. So I give my best, I make friends, I look for beauty and kindness in wherever I find myself and in every place, I find it. And here, at the top of a Mountain, with a Prince, I get to see the most magical sight, a view no Hobbit has ever seen. And I have you to thank for this gift.”
He turned to the dwarf, staring up into the clear blue gaze and smiled.
“Thank you,” he said. But the Prince bowed forward, his lips curved in a smile and his hands still resting on Bilbo’s shoulders as he gently rested his forehead against the Hobbit’s. Bilbo scarcely dared breathe, feeling the soft caress of the Prince’s breath on his skin. Thorin closed his eyes and his voice was soft but genuine and warm.
“No, Bilbo-I should thank you. You have given me far more than you realise. I am barely worthy of your friendship…but I treasure it above gold and mithril.” Bilbo didn’t move, aware of his closeness to the Prince, the curious intimacy of the gesture.
“I am nothing special,” he demurred…but Thorin gave a little chuckle.
“Bilbo-of all the people within Erebor, I am up here with you,” the Prince pointed out and finally pulled back. “I chose to share this place-and my thoughts-with you. If that doesn’t make you special, I have no clue what special is.” He gave a small smile, the intensity of his gaze transfixing the Hobbit. “You treat me like a real person. And that is most precious to me.”
-o0o-
So Bilbo visited the Prince more frequently, because he shared the feeling that there was a connection. And somehow, the trip to the Ravens’ Eyrie had broken the floodgates. Thorin shared stories of his youth, smiling as he recounted pranks he and his siblings had played, times spent with his family and his worries over the gold-sickness his grandfather had started to suffer before his death. In return, Bilbo told Thorin about his childhood in the Shire, of peace and plenty and warmth and family-and of the Fell Winter where orcs had crossed the Brandywine and slaughtered and burnt where they had gone. Of the razing of Hobbiton and Bywater, of the deaths of many Hobbits and the defiling of many of their lands. And of the belated arrival of Rangers and the Elves of Rivendell and the Lords of Ered Luin. Of how a deal was made to protect the Shire in return for their agricultural skills and how a portion of the homeless and shocked Hobbits had been moved to the Lone Farthing.
“I was only a young Hobbitling, in my teens and when the river was crossed, we heard the warning horns call,” Bilbo recounted. “We had warning, something some poor souls never got. So we grabbed what was precious and valuable and what we most needed, two packs each, and then we set off, use the back tracks to get to Tuckborough and shield with Mum’s family, the Thains of the Shire. And there were so many people crammed in there that it was locked and guarded and though they sniffed around, they were warned off by the Shiriffs.”
“A wise precaution,” Thorin said, nodding. Bilbo had baked fresh cheese bread and lemon tarts and the pair had gone up to the Eyrie once more, wrapped warmly against the view. Bilbo stared into the landscape, today swathed by low cloud and rain.
“Most of Hobbiton was razed to the ground and dozens were killed,” Bilbo said tightly. “Our neighbour, Holman Gamgee and his family were lucky to hide. Bag End-our home-was fired. Many other homes were as well and they poisoned the soil. Nothing would grow. Half the Shire was uninhabitable. There was no choice: we had to leave. It was that or starving.”
“I recall my Grandfather hearing about the tragedy-it wasn’t long before Azanulbizar,” Thorin said, staring into the mist. “He scorned your folks, calling you weak and soft, that you sought only food and ale and sitting by the fire. He said…that we should not waste our efforts on those so weak and worthless because we were Khuzd, fashioned by Mahal himself, spared by Eru and allowed to wake after the Firstborn but before Men. That we created and built while you…did nothing of consequence.”
Bilbo stared at him.
“I see,” he said hollowly. But Thorin shook his head.
“No,” he said, his hand gently resting on Bilbo’s. “Because he was entirely wrong. You are not dwarves-but you were created by a Valar, the spouse of our own creator. And if we scorn her works, we can only anger Mahal who loves Yavanna. And you have shown me and told me of the bravery of your people-not loud and self-aggrandising and raucous but quiet and determined and steady. You relocated across half a content-Mahal, I would never want to have to attempt such a thing. You lost your home and you gathered together, planned and made the best of what was offered. And I know, because I was in on discussions, that you were not as well-served as you should be. But you delivered everything that you promised, always cheerful and personable. I know that Lord Bard of Dale and even the ElvenKing-supercilous bastard that he is-recognise how hard you have worked to squeeze harvests from this land. We were wrong. We judged you by the standards of dwarves-but you are not dwarves. You are Hobbits.”
“I’m glad you noticed,” Bilbo murmured. The Prince inspected him with a small smile.
“No dwarf would spend this time with me,” Thorin admitted. “My shame would scare them away. Or they would treat me like their Commander and I would get less than a word from them.” He stared at the mist again. “You do not know how much I appreciate your kindness and generosity.”
“You know, you are rather good company yourself, your Highness,” Bilbo admitted, inching closer to the warm shape. “There are few enough people I can trust or who are interested in a mere Hobbit.”
“Then they are the fools, for not valuing such an intelligent, generous and compassionate being,” Thorin declared.
“Even though you insulted me to start with?” Bilbo checked. Thorin huffed a defeated sigh.
“My own stupidity always works against me,” he admitted. “I can only beg your forgiveness and ask that you can believe that even a dwarf can change his opinions…”
“I already have,” Bilbo said “Forgiven you, that is. I doubt you actually knew any Hobbits before you met me. And we tend to be seen by all the other races and small and weak and insular. But Hobbits are stubborn and determined and will always do their best to help.” He looked at the dwarf. “And you are a good friend. You have listened to me when I have moaned about my lot, about my horrible relatives and how lonely I feel among my own people. And the best part of my day-the absolute best part-is when I walk through that door and see you waiting there. And I am sorry-it must be such a let down to have a Hobbit coming to visit, not one of your own folk…but you are someone I feel I can tell anything.” The dwarf Prince dipped his head, his hair shielding his face from view.
“My brother would be laughing from the grave,” he said bleakly. “He alway joked that I was the worst communicator and listener he knew.” Bilbo gave a snort.
“There are far worse listeners out there, I can tell you!” he said honestly. “You are a surprisingly good listener when you put your mind to it. You just have to try to look as if you aren’t being skewered while listening and you’ll be fine.” Thorin looked at him, his brow dipping in a scowl as Bilbo collapsed, laughing. “I'm sorry, I’m sorry…” he gasped. “You do look annoyed when you start listening-I think it’s just the way you look when you are concentrating. I don’t mean any offence…” Thorin shook his head.
“I was taught to appear serious and stern…but I could imagine that doesn’t look terribly interested to a Hobbit,” he confessed. “I will endeavour to do better.”
“And you look as if you are about to face a battle single-handed without a weapon,” Bilbo told him. “Thorin-you only have to listen if you want to.”
“But I do,” the Prince said defeatedly. “I want to know everything about you because you are my friend. And I wish to learn all about the being who had given me so much hope amid the darkness that surrounds me.” Bilbo gently pressed a hand onto his arm, feeling the tension beneath his touch.
“Thorin-I will always be here for you,” he said. “I just wish that you could tell me what ails you so I can help.”
“You always help,” the Prince admitted, offering a smile. “Having one person who will spend time with me, one who will listen to my words without judging me, that is worth more than all the gold in Erebor.” Bilbo smiled.
“Then I will keep helping and keep visiting my friend as long as he wants me to.”
-o0o-
Outside, the days shortened until the Solstice, known to the Hobbits as Yule, the end of the year, grew close. The world outside the mountain was deep with snow and Bilbo had moved into servants’s quarters in Erebor during the freeze. He had asked his neighbours to watch his home, promising he would return when the snows eased and he could travel to his work once more but the benefit was that he had more time to spend with Thorin…and with his other friends. Ori and Dori had insisted he dine with them and Bombur had introduced him to his brother, a miner named Bofur who was sociable and friendly. Their cousin Bifur, a veteran of Azanulbizar with an axe buried in his head, also attended meals. He was quiet and only spoke in ancient Khuzdûl but Bilbo could see the pain in his eyes and spoke quietly and respectfully to the dwarf, knowing the pain of the battle from his long talks with Thorin.
So even though he was a long way from his parents’ memory and his home, Bilbo did not feel alone…but he was shocked when he arrived in the corridor one day and Thorin was not there.
Casting around, he could see scuffs on the floor and realised that the statue had been taken as well, scraped along as it was manhandled through the doors any away. And something in Bilbo felt grief and a sense of loss at seeing the MountainStars crushed under iron-shod feet as the dwarves had taken the statue away. And though he waited for a couple of hours, there was no sign of the Prince…not that he had expected there to be. The feeling of warmth and familiarity that had always washed through him when he entered the corridor was gone, dissipated like the mist on a breeze.
So Bilbo went in search of Ori, who knew the most as a Scribe and Librarian and who was most likely to tell Bilbo what he needed to know. And the young dwarf was shocked at the breathless Hobbit who arrived in the Library, looking wild and distressed.
“He’s gone,” Bilbo panted. Ori cast around.
“Who?” he asked carefully. Bilbo shook his head.
“Thorin,” he gasped. Ori froze.
“The Prince?” he asked carefully, looking around nervously.
“Yes,” Bilbo confirmed, nodding. “The Prince. I have been meeting him most days and he’s always there…but today, he isn’t. And they have moved the statue…” Ori buried his face in his hands.
“Mahal, grant your servant wisdom to do thy will,” he muttered, closing his eyes. “Guide me to the true path.”
The Hobbit stared at him as if he had gone mad.
“What have I said?" he asked, suspicious. “Was I not supposed to meet him? He wanted me to and he was always pleased to see me and…”
“Bilbo-no one was supposed to see the Prince because no one could,” the Librarian said urgently. “The Prince is cursed-a curse that becomes permanent if he is not wed by midnight on the Solstice. He was concealed…but it seems the Royal Family are having one last attempt at saving him-when, it seems, their own edicts and short-sightedness have stopped them from helping the Crown Prince.”
“Ori-you are talking in riddles and if you say one more time that this is because of some Royal Edict that you can’t tell me, I swear I will beat you to death with Gunther the Bald’s History of Dwarrow-Elvish conflicts of the Red Mountains!” Bilbo threatened. Ori burst out laughing for he was considerably stronger than the Hobbit and Bilbo couldn’t even lift Gunther the Bald’s massive tome. In fact, it had its own pulley in the ‘Extremely Boring History’ section of the Library.
“Bilbo-I cannot tell you anything,” the dwarf said, but grabbed the Hobbit’s hand. “However, I can show you what you need to know…” Then he hauled Bilbo out of the side entrance of the Library and along a seldom-used passageway that finally took them to a concealed balcony above the the Throne Room. “For the love of Mahal, keep quiet,” Ori hissed. “They cannot know we are here…”
Heedless, Bilbo leaned over the railing and almost gasped at the sight that lay below. The King was obvious with the scars over his left eye and the heavy crown on his furrowed brow. His long greying hair was braided with enough beads to make his station obvious and a magnificent cloak and robes swathed his stocky form. At his right hand stood a dwarrowdam who looked eerily like Thorin, though the deep burgundy gown that swathed her solid form and her curves made her gender obvious. The gown was intricate with gold and silver detailing and there were gems sewn into the hem and cuffs. Her hair was braided with many beads and her long beard was as intricately wound and decorated as Thorin’s was short and plain. Beside her stood two younger dwarves one with dark gold hair and a braided moustache and the other with dark hair bereft of braids and rather sorry scruff for a beard. They had to be the Princess Dis and her sons Fili and Kili. On the King’s other side stood the familiar balding shape of Dwalin with his armour, knuckledusters and axes and his older brother Balin, the long white beard, red tunic and breeches and frightening intelligent gaze known to all. Beyond then was a solid shape in rich dark robes with magnificent flaming hair and beard-Gloin, the Master of Coin and a distant cousin of the Crown.
The statue was placed before them, looking towards the door of the Throne Room. But there was no sign of Thorin.
“Where is the Crown Prince?” Bilbo asked, snapping his head round to look at Ori. “What is happening?”
“He’s here,” Ori said in an emotionless voice.
“No, he isn’t,” Bilbo said. “There’s only the statue…” And then he frowned and peered at the statue. Subtly different to the position he had been in when Bilbo first saw him, the statue’s left hand was tightly clenched and his right hand was open, half-stretched out to the person he was looking at with a look of fierce hope and longing on his petrified face. “Oh no…”
“That is the Prince,” Ori confirmed.”The entire Kingdom knows of the curse.”
“You mean everyone…absolutely everyone…knows about this except me?” Bilbo asked sharply.
"It was the King’s Edict that none the other races could know,” Ori protested in a desperate hiss. “The Curse is said to affect those with pride and madness in their blood. To teach those who would make a bad King a lesson. And it can only be broken by the One of the cursed.”
“One?”
“The other half of a dwarf’s soul is called his One,” Ori said urgently. “Mahal made them to complete us, compliment our weaknesses, bolster our strengths… It is His greatest gift. A dwarf only loves once and to find your One, to love your One…it is all we could possibly hope for…”
“But why’s he still stone?” Bilbo asked, gesturing to the petrified shape.
“You have to be close enough to him to break the curse and turn him back to flesh,” Ori said, frowning. “We must be out of range.” He gestured at a crowd of richly-dressed dwarves who were surging forward through the door of the Throne Room, held back by the guards and allowed forward one by one. “The King is hoping one of these will be the one to break the curse…” And then Ori looked at Bilbo. “Ohhh…”
“What will they do?” the Hobbit asked.
“Watch. And for the love of Mahal, keep quiet!”
So Bilbo did and saw Thorin approached by one after another dwarf. Each one stood confidently in front of the statue, each wearing an identical cocky expression that assumed they would be successful. When the statue remained of stone, each one tried to entice him to respond. With some, it was merely touching him-stroking his face, touching his hair, patting him on the chest or shoulder-gestures that were over-familiar or far too personal for a stranger towards a dwarf, let alone a dwarf Prince. But others went much further, caressing the statue well below the equator, fondling his face or neck or kissing or licking his face. Bilbo felt physically sick, hoping against hope that Thorin was not aware of the indignities he was suffering or the fact that people were watching.
“I can’t watch this any more,” the Hobbit snapped. “Is there another way into there?”Ori started and looked guilty.
“That door leads down to the Throne Room-but they would see you immediately!” he protested as Bilbo sprinted off, with the young dwarf in pursuit. All the Hobbit could think of was that Thorin was there, being humiliated in front of a Court that did not need to do so to save him. So he ran round, down the arrow flight of stairs and through the little archway-just as a rather portly and very ugly red-haired dwarf smooched Thorin in a thoroughly indecent way, his hands lingering far too low for any civilised company. And as Bilbo emerged through the door, Thorin’s eyes flashed to blue and the grey stone of his face faded to the pale colour of his skin, stone giving way to flesh and armour and long dark hair with a long thin braid stretching from each temple. And instantaneously, he jerked back.
There was cheering and the King rose to his feet.
“At last,” he sighed. “Finally, we have found…”
“No!” Thorin interrupted, his tone a mixture of disgust and anger. He was pushing the unpleasant suitor away while urgently wiping his lips with his hand. “There is no warmth in my heart from his proximity, Highness. He is not the One.”
“Of course he is!” Thrain said, his face filled with relief. “You are here, alive once more rather than lifeless stone. So that means…”
“He is nearby…" Thorin interrupted, walking past the other dwarf and scanning the room. And his face filled with relief when his eyes fell upon the shape that had just emerged from the stairwell. “Bilbo…” The Hobbit took a couple of steps forward before a meaty arm wrapped around him and Dwalin lifted him bodily from the floor. “NO!”
“Thorin…” the Hobbit called, struggling. Dwalin frowned and then glanced at his Prince and closest friend.
“You know him?” he breathed.
“Since Autumn,” Bilbo answered honestly. “We’ve been meeting every other day…and I didn't know about the Curse. I only knew he was ill.”
“But how didn’t you…” the Guard muttered and then glanced over at the King.
“I’m not a dwarf and apparently the King’s Edict meant that no one who wasn’t one of your people could know,” Bilbo hissed. “So no one would tell me. Even when I had met him. I mean, I must have sort of suspected because I never saw him and the statue but even so…”
“This is insane,” Dwalin grunted, holding the Hobbit back. Thorin was advancing steadily, his eyes fixed on the smaller shape.
“Let him go!” he commanded, his voice deep and harder than any Bilbo had yet heard.
“Inùdoy…Thorin…you cannot persist with this madness!” the King said, his voice growing angry. “We all saw it. When Lord Irigul kissed you, the Curse lifted…”
“When Bilbo entered the Throne Room, the Curse lifted,” Thorin argued. “That…Stiffbeard…assaulting my person was an unlucky coincidence.”
“You cannot have a One who is not a dwarf!” Thrain shouted. “It has never happened!”
“It has now-because Bilbo is my One!” Thorin roared back. “He has lifted the Curse. He stumbled across my abandoned form and felt pity for me, all alone and forsaken with only the dead flowers placed there when I was first moved. So he returned to bring me fresh flowers, to honour my deeds and he showed me…kindness. And when he visited me, I felt it-the warmth of life running though me once more. I found myself a creature of flesh once again, felt the weight of my body, the aches of being still so long and then I saw him.”
He blinked and glanced at the Hobbit once more. “I saw him, a creature not of our race and like a fool who believed everything he had been taught without thinking, I insulted him. Instead of quivering before a dwarf prince, he defended himself and his race with the heart and spirit of the bravest warrior. And as he turned away, I felt the cold knife drive into my heart once more and I knew then what Mahal had designed for me. I knew the lesson I must learn and the One I must earn the friendship of. So I begged his forgiveness and I…I begged him to stay. I put aside pride because the truth was…I was alone. Of all the thousands in this Mountain, he alone had cared that I was here. He came when no others did. And he stayed, talking with me like a real person, not a…statue. And when he left, I felt bereft and desolate, imagining that I had lost my only chance. Yet he returned again and again, visiting me and treating me as any dwarf, not knowing that I could only be a dwarf in his presence. He spent the time with me that no one else did-even though he was a Hobbit and felt he was not worthy of my time! When the truth is that I was not worthy of his! But though we were of different races and upbringings, the kindness and loyalty in his heart made him continue to visit a lonely and desolate Prince who had no other people!”
Then he turned. “Where were you? I was aware of what was happening even when I was as stone. I heard you talking, heard you giving up on ever freeing me rather than continuing to scour the whole of Arda for the one being who could release me. I heard you deciding to hide me away in the back corridor, away from sight and mind and the shame my condition brought upon the Line of Durin. I heard the ploy that you would declare that I had died in battle many leagues from Erebor and that my body was lost…and then you would unveil my statue…me…as my own memorial. And I was praying to Mahal that my awareness would be gone by then, for it would be punishment worthy of the worst traitor, to be aware but frozen as a statue forever.”
Balin looked disturbed at the accurate report of his words. Then the Prince looked at his family.
“You all gave up when I would have fought to the last second for you,” he accused them bitterly. “You left me there and never visited again. There was one withered bunch of Thatratûr’abdul by my feet when I heard Bilbo approach. And I felt the warmth blossom in my chest and the cold in my limbs dissipate as he came close and it all ended when he walked away from me. He brought me flowers every week. And he brought himself, brought life and hope when you left me to rot.”
And then he opened his right hand to reveal a fresh flower, picked just a couple of days before. There were gasps and the Princess looked distraught.
“I demand you honour my claim!” the ugly red-haired dwarf, Lord Irigul, snarled. “I broke the Curse! I get to marry the Prince!”
“Then we shall prove it!” Thorin snapped, his voice commanding the space. “Withdraw to the doors of the Throne Room, Lord Irigul! If you are indeed my One, I will turn back to stone. If not, then you will have to acknowledge that Bilbo holds that honour-as my heart already knows.”
Balin nodded.
“That would prove it, Majesty,” he told the King. Thrain walked back to his throne, an angry scowl on his face.
“It’s a waste of time but it will, at least, end this senseless argument,” he growled and sat down like a sulky child. He waved a hand. “So be it!”
Fuming, Irigul spun on his heel and stomped across the long bridge to the door of the Throne Room. Casting the Crown Prince look of pure venom, he stamped through the doors and slammed them.
Every eye turned onto Thorin, but the Prince remained himself, breathing hard and cradling the flower in his palm. He turned look at Bilbo.
“Bring Irigul back and then we will send the Hobbit away,” Balin commanded the guard. “To demonstrate the final proof…”
Irigul stamped back and was furious to see the Prince still looking at him, his expression cold and triumphant. Then Thorin turned to Bilbo, watching Dwalin release him. The Hobbit ran forward and stopped in front of the Prince.
“I am rather cross you didn’t tell me the truth,” he said sternly, staring into Thorin’s face. Then he looked around. “But I understand more now. And I am sorry that things were worse than you said. You should have trusted me.”
“I know,” Thorin said and took the Hobbit’s hand, placing the flower in his palm. “I must ask you to trust me again, with little cause. For my father to acknowledge you, we have to prove beyond all doubt that you are the only one who can free me from this curse. So I have to ask you to walk to the Throne Room door and show that it is only the proximity to you that brings me back to life.”
“But…” Then Bilbo looked up. “Does it hurt?” he asked. The tiny gap before Thorin spoke was answer enough.
“It is worth it to finally be able to be with you, to be a dwarf once more,” Thorin told him and smiled. “And please…don’t look. I don’t want you to see.” He looked at his friend. “Dwalin…”
“He’ll be safe as in the Shire,” the Guard promised and waved to the guards to escort the Hobbit over the bridge. But as he almost reached the door when he heard gasps and he turned-to see Thorin still, his arms and legs already reverted to pale stone but his face and eyes still all too real. He saw Bilbo see him and his lips parted as he tried to speak but in that moment, the change completed and he was a statue once more. The Hobbit slapped his hands over his mouth.
“Thorin…” he gasped.
“Mahal, it’s true,” the King said in shock.
“Adad, it is proven-and it is Mahal’s will that my brother is brought back to us by this Hobbit!” Dis said. Balin sighed.
“There is absolutely no precedent in the Archives,” he commented. “But it seems our Crown Prince will be marrying a Hobbit…”
“NO!” Irigul roared. Furious, humiliated and frustrated, he raced forward, his axe swinging-at the defenceless statue. One swing glanced across Thorin’s face with a horrid crack but as the axe swung round, it sliced straight through his left wrist-and then buried into the left side of his chest with a very final crunch.
As the dwarf was tugging at his axe, determined to destroy the statue and the Prince once and for all, Dwalin raced forward, tearing the enraged and murderous Lord away and throwing him sideways. He stumbled, losing his footing as he hit the edge of the narrow walkway and tumbling into the bottomless depths under the Throne Room. His final screamed dopplered into nothingness as a horrified silence filled the room.
“THORIN!” Bilbo yelled and turned to get back to the Prince. But the Captain of the Guard raced forward, yelling.
“NO! Stay where you are!” he roared. “You come any nearer and he may turn back into flesh. And if he does, he’ll bleed out. His only chance is to remain as a statue and see if we can fix him.”
"Fetch Oin. NOW!” The King's voice echoed through the Throne Room. Dis was already at the statue's side with her sons a step behind. Dwalin had wrapped his arms around the Hobbit and was dragging him back, his dark eyes narrowed with concentration.
“You go to him and you kill him!” the warrior repeated. “Mahal knows I love him like a brother and I would see him happy, no matter how strange the will of the Valar. But I will not let you kill him through your concern for him when we need the time to fix him up.”
“Fix him?” Bilbo yelled. “He’s been mortally wounded…”
“And he’s a statue,” Dwalin told him, restraining him. “The Curse is sparing his life, for it buys him time. And if he is aware, I pray that does not extend to pain. But even if it does, he will not die of his injuries now. He is in Erebor. We have some of the finest artisans and craftsmen on Arda-including stonemasons. They will be able to fix him as good as new, restoring the statue to all of its former glory-so when he can turn back, he will be healed…” Bilbo stared at the mangled statue and thought about Thorin, trapped within. And he could feel the echo of the warmth still in his heart and knew that he could not condemn the Prince to die before his eyes just to satisfy his own urges to rush to help him. The best Bilbo could do was stay away.
“Are you sure?”
Balin walked forward and nodded.
“See him safely away, brother,” he said quietly. “I will arranged the craftsmen. We have little time and we will have to use every possible scrap of rock that originally formed the statue to repair it if we are to restore him to how he was.” He looked over at the Hobbit, who was shaking. Ori appeared behind Bilbo, looking shocked. “Trust us, Master Hobbit. We will send for you as soon as he is ready. We will not lose him again-now you have brought him back to is.”
But as he was led away by Dwalin and flanked by Ori, all Bilbo could do was glance back at his fallen friend and pray to Yavanna that the dwarves were as good as they claimed.
-o0o-
The weather had broken so it was with surprise that the inhabitants of Hobbitthorpe found Bilbo Baggins being escorted back to his home on pony back by two dwarvish guards. They patted him on the shoulder and then rode away, leaving him by the door of his home.
But when he tried to open it, it was locked. He frowned and tried his key again-and finally hammered on the door until it was finally wrenched open-by a mean-looking Lobelia.
“What are you doing here?” she asked him nastily.
“I could ask you the same question!” he retorted. “What are you doing in my house?”
“Well, you abandoned it so we moved in over the winter to claim it,” Lobelia sneered at him.
“We both know it wasn’t abandoned,” Bilbo replied angrily. “I told Holman Gamgee that I was working up at the Mountain and would be there until the roads opened. Did you even wait a week before you lied to the Thain and stole my home?”
“I resent the implication…” she began to bluster but Bilbo folded his arms. He had endured a very trying time and was still wrestling with a myriad of emotions, most of them composed of fear, worry and desperation. And to return to find himself made homeless by his greedy grasping cousins… He folded his arms.
“Then let’s speak to the Thain and see, shall we?” Bilbo asked her snarkily. “And in the meantime, we can also ask him what happened to the compensation for the deaths of my parents that the dwarves apparently paid to the relatives of the deceased-and of which I never saw a penny. I wonder who took that? Any suggestions-Lobelia?” She went puce and started to splutter but Bilbo had turned away and was already stomping down the slope towards New Tuckborough, the home of the Thain of the Lone Farthing, the Tooks-his kin. Maybe Lobelia had forgotten but Bilbo hadn’t…and the current Thain was his cousin Adalgrim.
It was time for the upright and decently Hobbitish Bilbo Baggins to be a Took once more. And if he couldn’t fight for his friend…who was (secretly in Bilbo’s foolish and treacherous heart) maybe more…then he would fight for his home and his rights.
-o0o-
Balin son of Fundin was a worried dwarf. The Kingdom was in chaos and even those who hadn't been there (i.e. most of the Kingdom) had heard everything that had happened in exquisite detail. Rumours abounded and the Adviser to the King knew that he would have to work exceptionally hard to keep a lid on things. The Lords were in uproar-they were always in an uproar, to be honest, though this seemed even more serious and uproarous than usual. Uproar was their default setting, along with extremely loud and stubborn, though that really just described them as dwarves, but it all added to Balin’s metaphorical and very real headaches.
The King was the biggest problem but he was also the easiest to handle. Thrain was a son of the Line of Durin, meaning he was stubborn, proud and very cognisant of his heritage and duties. But it also meant he was very proud of and fond of his eldest son, emotion he was exceptionally bad at displaying. And the words that the miraculously alive Thorin had roared at his father had the uncomfortable merit of being true. Thrain had dealt with the Curse on his son by trying a bit and when that didn't work, he had not thought beyond his own race and had given up. The statue-his own son-had been hidden in an unused corridor and the family had been informally forbidden from seeing him, leaving Thorin out of sight and hopefully out of mind.
Balin was not such a fool and he had reached out to Lord Elrond in Rivendell and Lady Galadriel in Lothlorien, as well as to Saruman the White, the wizard generally acknowledged as one of the most learned beings on Arda. But none of them had much to offer save condolences. Saruman had supplied a few tidbits of intelligence but there had been no cure, no easy way to free the Prince. Only Gandalf the Grey, the wandering wizard known to the dwarves as Tharkûn, had seemed optimistic.
“Thorin was a proud and judgemental dwarf and the Curse was designed to teach such dwarves a valuable lesson,” he said. “There are others in the Mountain who may offer hope. But you must not allow your insularity to prevent those who may help even knowing what it is they can do.”
The words had been true but not helpful, since Thrain would not be shifted. Yet the sight of his son, arguing so fiercely in favour of the Hobbit-creatures that Thorin had been scathing of in the past for their weakness and interest in undwarvish things such as growing things and simple pleasures-had shaken him. And the fact that Thorin had turned back to stone when the little creature had walked away sealed the deal. No matter what Thrain may wish, what precedent and history and even the loud proclamations of the StoneSeers may say, Bilbo Baggins was Thorin’s One. There could be no more graphic demonstration and that had shaken them all to the core.
And then the attack, the horror of seeing their Prince, a strong and vital dwarf, a warrior and leader, laid low by a fat and vengeful dwarf thwarted in his venal ambitions. Helpless as stone, Thorin had been dealt what in essence were mortal wounds and even the stonemasons had been shocked. Balin had them collect every last crumb of the beige-grey material of the statue and use it in the repair, against the arguments of the stonemasons who all had their own ideas what to do. For about the hundred thousandth time, Balin cursed dwarves hard-headed stubbornness and argumentativeness. The intelligence of Saruman the White had been clear: if any damage, the original materials must be used or incorporated into what was used for it would all be in vain. So they had mixed mortar with the pulverised shards carved from the statue and used it to patch the frozen Prince back together.
Balin walked round the cold shape, lain on a stone pallet and lashed down like a thing. He could recall the words that Thorin had spoken with a chill of horror.
I was aware of what was happening even when I was as stone.
And he had repeated conversations almost verbatim, for what else had he to concentrate on but the words that had dismissed and condemned the Prince to oblivion? So Balin walked to the side of the supine statue, staring down at the frozen face and he winced. They had managed to stick his hand back on, the seam of mortar a little uneven. But the cut across the right side of his face had sliced into his eye and the repair was not as good as the Adviser would have liked. The mortar had been pushed into place and smoothed crudely, leaving a scar that mutilated the familiar features of the Prince. Everyone knew the Line of Durin was not famed for their looks but Thorin would lose the eye and the scar was ugly, not even gained in honourable battle but instead a cowardly attack. Then he glanced at the patch on the abdomen, the mortar mixed with the shards that had been carved out, the cracks filled and surface smoothed with much more care. But it was an ugly wound and in a flesh body, it would be a cruel and painful scar.
“I am sorry,” Balin said, his voice measured. He knew he should feel embarrassed at talking to a statue but he was now painfully aware that somewhere in there was the mind of the Prince he had helped raise, the Prince he had educated and guided and tried to care for. Thrain was a distant father and Thror had been stark staring mad with Gold Sickness, treating his elder grandson with harshness that Thorin had endured with the stoicism expected but which must have hurt a young dwarf desperate for the approval of his grandfather. When the King had taken all his heirs to Azanulbizar, Thrain, Thorin and Frerin had all paid in different ways: Frerin had died, Thrain had been wounded and suffered psychological trauma ever since and Thorin-brave, lauded and never allowed to forget-had castigated himself every single day for not saving his grandfather and his brother. Of all of them, Balin always felt that Thorin had the hardest burden to bear-it was just that some wounds were much harder to see.
“I let them forget. It was easier because they had given up hope. And I should have forced the issue, made them parade every inhabitant to Erebor past you…not just the nobles and those who hoped to use you for their own enrichment.” He sighed. “But a Hobbit, Thorin? Even I wouldn’t have imagined that. Yet it is clear he cares for you and you…well, you’ve given him your heart. The young prince I knew would never have hesitated so I am certain you will have plunged in. And I know you will never have declared your intent to him so I will have to.”
He paced back and forth. “I have no idea what state you will be in when we wake you. You may curse us for bringing you back but I believe…that you wouldn’t want to leave him without saying what lies in your heart. So we will get him back and we will see. I do not know if Hobbits have Ones but I do not think he will be scared by your wounds, my Prince. Just do not let your own fear push him away when you need him most.” He looked up. “It is the Solstice, Thorin. We have to wake you today or we will never have the chance.” Then he turned to the door and stalked into the corridor, looking at his brother stationed on guard.
“We need to find the Hobbit,” he said.
-o0o-
The wind had risen and snow was being blown all over the land as two dwarves galloped past Dale and on to the Lone Farthing. The short midwinter day was already past its noon as they arrived at Bilbo’s little home-to find it locked. Undeterred, Dwalin leapt down and hammered his fist on the green door, glaring at the closed portal as if it had personally offended him.
“He’s not there,” an unfamiliar voice said. Dwalin turned to see a short and very round Hobbit leaning on the gatepost, a wide-brimmed straw hat hanging onto his head as if by magic. His features were homely and eyes kindly as he shuffled his feet, wrapped in sturdy well-used outdoor clothes. “Master Bilbo. Those thieving Sackville-Baggins persuaded the Thain to declare the home abandoned so they moved in…”
“WHAT?” Ori jumped from his pony and walked forward, his eyes intent and face scrunched in an unfamiliar frown. “You knew he was working up at the Mountain in the bad weather-he did it last year as well. My brothers and I have been keeping an eye on him.”
“Aye, well, I’m only a Gamgee and that Lobelia is a vicious one where getting his bony paws on someone else’s property!” the Hobbit said, offering his hand. “Holman. My son Hamfast is back in the Shire. He’s a fine farmer but Gamgees have always done for the Bagginess-not those thieving Sackville-Bagginses!”
“Master Holman-where may Bilbo be now?” Ori asked, his eyes fixed on the Hobbit’s face. “We need him urgently. He has been helping the Crown Prince with a special project and he is needed urgently at the Mountain. Today.” The Hobbit scrunched his face up as he thought.
“He’ll be at New Tuckborough, speaking to the Thain to get his home back,” Holman admitted. “And to right an old wrong.” He gestured. “Down the Lane, left at the Inn then straight on for two miles. You can’t miss the Thain’s Smials-it’s the largest home in New Tuckborough. I am sure Mister Bilbo will appreciate your support.”
“Come on,” Dwalin grunted. “We need to go!” Ori nodded thanks and then mounted up, cantering off after the Guard.
The Lone Farthing? Brother have you gone mad? We need him here, not thirty miles away! There is so little time to play with. What if anything happens to him…?
I knew we needed him out of the Mountain and we couldn't risk him being too close to Thorin in case he undid the Curse too soon…
But sending him away? Now have no time. Whatever it takes, brother-you get him back and back today. Or we will never have the chance to speak to Thorin again…
Ori glanced over at the Captain of the Guard and wondered how it was that he, a lowly Librarian and very junior Scribe was here on this mission. Sure, he was Bilbo’s friend and had explained everything to Lord Balin once Bilbo had been rapidly shuffled out but that hardly qualified him for secret missions to neighbouring lands in the company of the King’s Guard. Though he did have to admit that if Dwalin turned up on most Hobbits’ doorsteps, they would run away while almost everyone seemed to think Ori harmless. Though Bilbo was a very uncommon Hobbit…but Balin had felt that Ori’s presence would reassure the Hobbit that he was not in any trouble.
In fact, Ori had never really been out of the Mountain and had almost no experience of riding so the process he was engaged in was extremely uncomfortable and he was sure he would be unable to walk in the morning. But maybe, if he helped his friend save the Crown Prince, it would be worth it… But he was never so grateful as when he saw the sign saying ‘New Tuckborough’ and the humps of typical Hobbit homes rising ahead of them. Dwalin was grim and worried, his face grave but there was no mistaking that he was stealing small glances at the young scribe, leaving Ori wondering what he was doing wrong. It was true that Dwalin was striking in appearance and he had been nothing but polite to his young companion but Ori was rather awestruck, to be honest. The Captain was a cousin of the King and Crown Prince, raised with Thorin and Frerin and famed in battle while Ori…well, his mother has never given the name of his father-or that of his middle brother, Nori either-so they were always the subjects of not-so-discreet muttering and sideways looks. Maybe that was it, maybe Dwalin was recalling the stories and looking at Ori as if he was a ram with two heads…
“This must be it,” Dwalin announced, pulling his pony to a halt by a rather large and neatly kept double door that was painted a bright red. A neat sign read “Great Smials’ which Dwalin thoughtfully tethered his pony to before offering Ori his hand. “You look a bit stiff,” he noted, helping the scribe down. “Sorry to bring you on this day but we have to get the Hobbit back to Erebor before midnight or Thorin will remain as stone forever. And you are his friend. I know Thorin’s heart-and he's already given it to the Hobbit, the great romantic lump. But does your friend feel the same?”
Ori grimaced as he took a stiff step. He might not be able to sit down for a few days when they finally got home. “I think so,” he said. “He was distraught when he found the statue was missing and insisted on getting into the Throne Room to find the Prince. And despite my warnings, he had to get closer, had to save his friend from being pawed and degraded by those dwarves…” He pulled a face. But Dwalin heaved a sigh of relief.
“At least we’ve got something to work with,” he exhaled. “The Prince is so rock-headed he would rather die than force one he loved into a marriage unless it was mutual.”
“Marriage?” Ori stared at him. Dwalin nodded.
“Aye,” he said and walked towards the door. “If they are not wed by midnight, Thorin will be as stone forever.” Ori scurried forward.
“Don’t mention that until he is back in Erebor,” he advised the Guard. “Bilbo is a kind and generous Hobbit but he doesn’t think he’s worthy of a Prince and if you tell him that, he’ll run rather than tie someone as magnificent as Thorin to a lowly Hobbit.”
“Magnificent? Mahal, his head would never fit through any doorway if he heard that,” Dwalin chuckled and hammered on the door. A rather surprised-looking blonde Hobbit lass opened the door, red ribbons in her hair and clearly wearing her best clothing for the festival. “We need to see Bilbo Baggins, lass. We’re on a mission for the Crown Prince of Erebor.”
“It’s a matter of life and death,” Ori added, looking his most innocent. He was a head shorter than Dwalin, not actually armed and his homely knitted scarf and gloves were much more in keeping with Hobbitish fashion.
“He’s talking to Da,” the young Hobbit said, ushering them in and firmly closing the door against the icy wind. “You came from the Mountain today? The weather’s freezing!” Ori nodded, carefully wiping his boots on the mat. He was aware from Bilbo how house-proud all Hobbits were. He gestured pointedly at Dwalin until the Guard complied with ill grace.
“And we’ll be going back as soon as we find Bilbo,” he confirmed. “I wasn’t joking, Miss. Bilbo is needed.” She frowned and then nodded.
“I think cousin Bilbo desperately needs to hear that,” she admitted, her hazel eyes twinkling. “I’m Floribunda Took, daughter of Thain Adalgrim Took. And my Da and Bilbo are this way…” She gestured down a wide passageway that was high enough even to easily admit a Man, let alone dwarves and was wide enough for four dwarves to walk abreast with plenty of room. The walls were plastered and whitewashed and smooth light wood-ash and pine-accented the doorways and made elegantly carved shelves with woodland and floral motifs. Nik-naks were everywhere along with a few portraits of relatives and a large mural that clearly showed the Shire itself. But Ori was drawn to the sounds of raised voices, one of which he knew very well. Floribunda tipped them a wink then opened the door, to admit them to a large parlour, where a dark-haired Hobbit in a very festive red and gold waistcoat, cream shirt and deep brown cut-off Hobbit pants was looking pained as Bilbo harangued him. To the other side stood a dark-haired Hobbitess wearing a garish red, blue and orange gown that had at least twice too many flounces and frills and who looked as if she had swallowed a couple of lemons. At her side was a portly male Hobbit with similar brownish hair to Bilbo but a mean cast around the eyes and an over-brocaded waistcoat.
“…only gone three days before you handed over my home to these grasping Orcs!” Bilbo snarled, his eyes narrowed with anger. “Holman knew I would be up in Erebor until the storms settled-I did it last year and I presume that was where these avaricious goblins got the idea to say I had abandoned my home. For Yavanna’s sake-back home in the Shire, you could go on a walking holiday for three weeks and folks would come over and water your plants, not try to steal your entire life!”
“And we are not in the Shire,” the female sneered, her voice as shrill as Ori imagined it would be.
“No-this is the New Shire, where unHobbitish things seem to be the way of things-like stealing, lying and betrayal of family!” Bilbo snapped.
“Harsh words,” the seated Hobbit-Thain Adalgrim Took-said thoughtfully. There was an intelligence in his eyes. “I was unaware that Holman Gamgee vouched for your whereabouts.”
“It hardly matters!” the female Hobbit cut in. “It should have been ours anyway…”
“LOBELIA!” The Thain’s voice would have cut metal. “You lied to me when you petitioned to me to get Bilbo’s home deeded to you. You said he had been missing for months and that no one knew where he was.”
“He’s so seldom there that it hardly counts…” Lobelia sneered.
“And why is that?” Bilbo asked her directly, spinning and glaring at her. Ori was impressed. Bilbo was thinner than he should be from such an active life working in Erebor and more missed meals than he should have endured. He looked tired but he was scrubbed up and looked neatly dressed, though his clothes were clearly not his Sunday best. “I can tell you why. Because I was left when my parents died with almost nothing. Yet I recently learned that when the raid happened, the dwarves felt so bad that they had failed in the protection they had promised that they paid generous compensation for every life they failed to save. And as the only Hobbit who lost two relatives, I should have been left comfortable, enabling me to maintain my parents’ garden and cling to their memory and maybe do those things I truly desired. But instead, I knew nothing of this money and didn’t receive a penny. And unable to get a job on the farms-or in any of my family’s businesses-I was left with no option but to work in Erebor.”
He makes it sound as a punishment, Ori thought and then he sighed. Why would a Hobbit, a creature of light and earth and growing things choose the inside of a mountain if there was any other option? But he was always so cheerful and positive. He never complained…but maybe he knew there was no point. Bilbo always tries to make the best of things…but maybe, sometimes things seem so bad you just can’t keep up the act any more. Like when you see the last person you have loved turned into stone and broken…
“You should have moved there!” Lobelia spat. “Otho and I could have used your home as a base in Hobbitthorpe for the weekends while we lived in Dale for business during the week…”
“And how did you come by the money to buy a home in Dale and set up your businesses, Lobelia?” Bilbo asked her directly. “From the money that should have been paid to compensate me for the loss of my parents. Money that would have made life easier. And how did Otho, Bungo’s cousin, have a greater claim that Bungo’s only son? And you had no claim on Belladonna at all! She was my mother and Adalgrim’s aunt-but she was nothing to you!”
“Yes-how did that happen?” Adalgrim murmured and glanced over to the corner where his son, Paladin, was colouring with his uncle, Adalgrim’s cousin Flambard. “Flam-could you help Paladin get the Green Ledger from the office please?” And he winked at the little faunt who was grinning gappily. Flambard-who looked like a darker-haired version of Adalgrim-swept the little boy up and then trundled out of the room chatting quietly with the child. Then Adalgrim turned to face the newcomers in the doorway. “As this is a holiday, my surgery isn’t open. But I suspect that two dwarves-one of the Captain of the Guard, if I am not mistaken-would not travel in such weather unless there was a very pressing reason. How may I help you, Master Dwarves?”
“Well-met, Thain Took,” Dwalin said gruffly. “We are here for Master Baggins. He is needed back in Erebor-the Crown Prince desperately requires his help.”
“With what?” Lobelia scoffed. “You make it sound like Bilbo is something important. But he’s really nothing-no parents, no siblings, no Baggins family and generally ignored by the Tooks as well!” Adalgrim looked ashamed by her words as Bilbo glared at her. “So if his own people value him so little, what could he possibly offer to dwarves? Unless...” Her brows pulled down and she gave a coldly triumphant expression. “I knew it! The reason why Bilbo was sleeping in Erebor was because…"
There was the sharp metallic zing of metal on metal and suddenly Lobelia found the twin edges of Grasper and Keeper, Dwalin’s famous battle-axes, biting coldly into her neck.
“Another word, she-orc, and we’ll see how well you speak with no head,” Dwalin growled, his eyes dark with rage. “You insult my people and Master Baggins. Master Baggins who is the Chosen One of the Crown Prince, who is his friend and support and heart. Prince Thorin is gravely ill and it has been Master Baggins’s support that has kept him going. He was sent away when the Prince took turn for the worse because we feared for his safety but now, the Prince needs him. I am his oldest friend, his Shield-Brother and I will give my life to protect Thorin son of Thrain son of Thror-and the Hobbit his heart has chosen.”
There was an absolute silence as everyone stared at the dwarf and the terrified shape of Lobelia. Adalgrim swung his head round to look at his cousin incredulously. But Bilbo sighed and waved his hand.
“Much as it would probably increase the general level of happiness for everyone in the Lone Farthing and in my life in particular, I can’t let you kill Lobelia, Captain,” he said firmly. “Kindly withdraw your axes. I think she understands that her evil-minded slander was as ill thought-out as her other plans to steal my home and wealth. And will end with the same abject failure.”
“Bilbo-she has done you so many wrongs-and you still want to protect her?” Ori asked. “I know from your words how you dislike the work in Erebor and she forced you to do that. She’s taken you home, refused to support you when you needed her, stolen your silver spoons, bad-mouthed your parents and lied to pocket the money Erebor gave to support those who lost relatives in the orc raid.” Bilbo looked up and gave a wan smile.
“I am a Hobbit-and we don’t solve our problems with cold steel,” he said sadly. “Usually it's with a sharp word, some juicy gossip and exclusion from social events.” Then he exhaled as Dwalin reluctantly pulled his axes back. “But though I resented having to go to Erebor, being forced to work inside, I have gained so much from being there. I have you and Dori and Bombur and Bifur and Bofur as friends. I get to help in the Library and have seen some truly ancient and beautiful Elvish texts. And I met Thorin, who I never would have if I had remained in the Shire. Sometimes, the darkest of roads takes you to the most beautiful destination. And I will regret none of it.”
“Lobelia might,” Flambard announced from the door. He was balancing the ledger in one hand and holding Paladin in the other, the little faunt pointing out the entry they had found. "It says ‘compensation for Bungo and Belladonna Baggins claimed by the Head of the Baggins Family, Otho Sackville-Baggins.’ Which I believe was Bilbo’s point.”
All eyes turned to the portly Otho and he began to stammer and bluster.
“Yes, well, y’see, it was all a terrible time, Nasty, nasty business. And young Bilbo, so young and naive, totally unsuited to be given so much so I decided as it were to be the older and wiser head and take the money into safe-keeping. As it were.”
“I was of age,” Bilbo told him sharply. “And I am the Head of the Baggins Family. You are a Sackville-Baggins, not a Baggins, lest you forget, Otho. You stole the money designed to help me deal with the loss of my parents by not having to worry about bills and used it to enrich yourselves. How long was this safekeeping meant to be, Otho? Until the day the world is remade?”
“The Kingdom of Erebor would be extremely disappointed to hear that gold handed over to help those so cruelly wounded by the orc raid had been stolen with the complicity of the authorities,” Ori found himself saying, sounding as stern as Balin did at his most grave. Dwalin raised an eyebrow and then nodded.
“Aye, I think the King would be most upset,” he added. Adalgrim nodded slowly and then stared at the couple who both looked furious that their schemes were uncovered.
“While I can only apologise for the laxness of my officers, I cannot make an apology for those who plotted to steal and defraud your people,” he said. “They must answer for their own crimes. The compensation was administered by your people, Master Dwarf, so any error in allocation would be on your shoulders. I merely keep a copy of the final judgement for our records.” He nodded and Flambard turned the book round to show the angular dwarvish writing and the Seal of Erebor. “I rule that Bag End is the property of Bilbo Baggins and remains his until left by Will to a person of his choice. It will be restored to him intact and with every possession in place-including every single silver spoon, Lobelia!” She hissed in anger. “You and Otho will repay every single penny of the gold you defrauded the dwarves of and it shall be given to its rightful owner-Bilbo.”
“But…but…we’ll have to sell our house and move!” Otho protested. “We’ll lose respect and social status…”
“You should be in jail!” Dwalin yelled. Both the Hobbits cringed and even Bilbo winced.
“I suspect publicising their actions will be punishment enough, since no one will trust them to offer any credit or trust them with any secrets,” he said. “And moving to a much more modest home will be a good experience for Lobelia.”
“It should have been you that the orcs killed!” she spat. “You perverted little goblin! You’re a disgrace as a Hobbit and…”
“And that is the cue to leave,” Bilbo said sharply. “Adalgrim-can I trust you and Holman Gamgee to see that my home is restored and safe until I return? I have an appointment with a Prince-with people who actually care about me and my welfare.” Adalgrim rose and clasped Bilbo’s hands.
“For what it’s worth, I am sorry,” he said. “It was my father, your Uncle Hildegrim, who was Thain then and we both know he wasn’t a details person. As long as he got a good meal and a nap, he was happy. I didn’t realise you were struggling. You should have called me.”
“And say what?” Bilbo sighed. “I was desperate and grieving and the Tooks were pretty much absent. You can’t say that you expected Lobelia and Otho to support me?” Adalgrim chuckled.
“No one in their right mind would,” he admitted. “When Dad went to Yavanna’s fields in the Spring, I was lost and I finally know what you felt. I’m sorry.” Bilbo nodded.
“I have to go,” he said. “I’ll be in touch. I think young Paladin there has the makings of a fine Thain in the future…”Adalgrim glanced at his only son, who was smearing chocolate cake on the leather binding of the ledger.
“He’s got the right attitude towards paperwork,” he chuckled as Bilbo nodded then walked out with the dwarves. Ori handed him a fur-lined cloak.
“It’s really cold out there and we need to ride,” he said. Bilbo laughed at his grimace as he wrapped himself up. But he still shivered as they walked out into the afternoon. The light was already starting to grey and a few tiny flakes of snow were fluttering around in swirls on the strong arctic wind.
“I take it that you and horses aren’t friends,” he smiled. Ori stiffly remounted then nodded. Dwalin boosted the Hobbit onto his own pony then mounted behind him.
“He’ll develop a good seat with practice,” he said and nodded. “But you will ride with me for safety. I wouldn’t put two novices together in this weather-especially when we have so little time.”Bilbo stiffened.
“Is Thorin…?” he asked, his tone wary.
“He’s repaired,” the Guard said, wheeling his pony round and kicking the beast to a canter. “Well, Balin thinks well enough though I’m not impressed. But the Curse says he has to be woken before midnight on the Solstice or he’s gone. So piss poor repair or not, we have to take the chance.”
“What do you mean?” Bilbo asked. Dwalin leaned over him, shielding him from the wind and staring ahead.
“You’ll see,” he said.
-o0o-
Oin son of Groin, Chief Healer of Erebor, was very worried. He couldn’t pretend that he knew what to do with magical wounds or how to treat a wounded Prince who was cursed to become stone. He had seen the patches the stonemasons had made to the statue…and he was less than impressed at the quality of the workmanship. Didn't they realise their work would become real when the Halfling returned? And a shoddy patch would become an ugly and painful scar that could cause the Prince disability and pain for the rest of his life. If it was so poor, would the organs that would be in that position even work properly? Would they wake the Prince only for him to die?
He paced around the room. He had pain draughts, poultices, ointments and inhalations all ready to treat whatever condition Thorin was in when he woke…but if he woke with wounds that were so imperfectly mended that he could not survive, then Oin the Healer would have to watch the Crown Prince expire on his watch.
Balin stuck his head in the door. The Chief Adviser was a measured and clever dwarf, a good cousin who was a great Chess player and pleasant companion. Oin’s hearing had been damaged and though he used an ear-trumpet, he did miss some of the ambient conversation. But he could lip read and was very talented at interpreting body language. And Balin was tense.
“They’ve been sighted on he approach road,” he reported. “Be ready.” Oin nodded and mentally reviewed his equipment and pharmacological options, glancing down at the Prince. Quietly, he removed the ropes that lashed the statue to the stone bed and draped a warm blanket and then a fur over the statue and slid a pillow under the unyielding rock of the head.
“I am not sure what will happen, my Prince,” he murmured as he looked down onto the repaired face. “But I will be with you all the way. You do not have to be brave. Let me know what hurts and what ails you and I will do all in my power to alleviate your suffering.”
And then he stood back. There was noise outside and then the King walked in, flanked by the Princess and the two young princes.
“They have arrived,” Thrain announced, stationing himself opposite the bed. “The Halfling is with them.” He cast his eye over the stone shape. “Hmm. We’ll just have to see…”
“Adad! He can hear!” The Princess was known to be fierce and brave but there was a distinct waver in her voice that suggested that the Royal Family had come prepared to witness the death of their cursed son. And silently, Oin swore that he would not permit that to happen. He had looked at the portents and they had not shown grief or death…but there had been pain, followed by joy. And Oin had to hope that he had interpreted the signs correctly. The King grunted and fiddled with the edge of his magnificent fur-lined robes.
“Then listen to me, Inùdoy-when your One arrives, you will wake. And I will accept the One that Lord Mahal chose for you because He knows far more than I. And I would even accept an Elf if it meant that you returned to us. I am proud of you, my only surviving Inùdoy-and always will be.”
Balin walked in a nodded.
"It is time," he said and stepped back from the door. Dwalin entered then glanced back and nodded. And then, finally, Bilbo walked in.
There was a wordless gasp from the bed as Thorin began his transformation back. His eyes were wide and fearful-though, as Oin and Balin had suspected, the ugly raw scar over the right brow and cheek snaked over a whitened, blinded eye. The flush of colour ran over his face and hair, down his neck and through to the centre of his chest, washing out in an unstoppable wave over the ugly red scar that covered half of his chest and the upper left of his abdomen. His arms and legs were last, thrashing, though the left hand barely moved, fingers twitching rather than spasming. And then Thorin gave an incoherent bellow of pain and another, even more gut-wrenching.
“Thorin!” Oin shouted, instantly at his side. He grabbed at the thrashing right arm. “Speak to me, my Prince!”
“Bil-bo…” the Prince gasped, eyes staring wildly. Then the Hobbit realised that his friend could not see him, standing in the doorway to his right. He surged forward, scooting round the bed and grasping the dwarf’s arm, just below the ugly thick red scar that circled the Prince’s wrist.
“It’s alright, Thorin-I am here,” he said urgently. Wildly, the dwarf turned his head towards him and a fraction of the fear left his remaining blue eye.
“Safe?” he asked in a rasping voice. There was so much pain in that tone that Bilbo almost wanted to weep and it felt like a stab in the chest.
“Dwalin looked after me,” he assured the Prince. “You have a good friend there.” Thorin groaned and managed the slightest nod.
“The best…" he breathed. “Safe?”
“I am safe and you are here, safe,” Bilbo repeated, looking up to meet Balin’s worried glance. The Prince seemed to be in far more pain than he should be and it seemed that their worst case scenario was coming to pass.
“Oin?” he mouthed. The healer pushed past Bilbo and used his ear-trumpet to listen to the Crown Prince’s chest.
“The lung is collapsed and is filling with blood,” he murmured, resting a hand over the horrific scar. “The work was not good enough.”
“Yes, it was,” Thorin breathed, his lips pale and eyes wild. “Because I woke and I have time with my One.”
“Thorin-I want you to have years and years-all the years to the end of my life,” Bilbo replied softly.
“And yet…the Valar are cruel,” the Prince murmured. “I find you and then fall to a cowardly attack that kills me when I cannot even move. But I know now that you are my One.”
“I know what that means now,” Bilbo said quietly. “Hobbits have soul-mates though it is more a generic voluntary term than a physical thing.”
“A dwarf loves once-and I am…honoured that you are the love Mahal chose for me,” the Prince said. “I have been blind so I am blinded. I scorned your weakness so I am weakened beyond endurance. I scoffed that your people carry no weapons so I lose a hand so I can no longer fight. The Curse has repaid me for my arrogance, my unkindness to your people.”
“Thorin-can’t this Curse cure you?” Bilbo asked him softly. “If there is magic, why can it not heal you when you have learned your lesson? Haven’t I broken the curse now?”
“No, laddie," Balin said gravely as Thorin struggled for breath. “The only way to break the Curse would be to complete the partnership and marry him.”
“But I release you from that duty,” Thorin gasped, his face pallid and beaded with sweat. “You should not have to marry a dying dwarf, blind and weak and crippled. I am not the dwarf you met.” Bilbo’s grip on his arm tightened and he rested a hand on Thorin’s chest. The fierce heat was gone, the fading warmth of a dying fire the only sensation of heat there. But the warmth in his own chest remained.
“And I am glad of it,” Bilbo said primly. “The dwarf I met was rude and judgemental and unpleasant. He was not really someone I wanted to spend time with. But then…he showed me something, showed me that somewhere in the admittedly-handsome body, there was a spark of humility and realisation that some things-decency, kindness, compassion-are universal. And as that dwarf emerged…him, I fell in love with.”
Thorin managed a small huff of laughter, a smile curving his white lips. Shakily he raised his right hand to rest against Bilbo’s cheek.
“My Bilbo,” he murmured. “It is worth seeing you one last time.”
“Nonsense,” Bilbo told him firmly. “I didn't come here to watch you die. I came here to save you. To save the dwarf I love. Now how do you dwarves get married? And please don’t say it’s on a long forty-day quest and a series of challenges and multi-hour services which quite frankly we don’t have time for!” Then he leaned forward and rested his forehead briefly against Thorin’s, knowing how much the gesture meant to the dwarf. “I just want you safe. And alive.”
“It’s a simple service, carried out by an officer authorised by the King to do so,” Dis announced.
“Or by the King himself,” Thrain said. He looked at the Hobbit and nodded. “Say after me…”
“Wait…” Thorin murmured. “Two things. First…I will not wed on this bed like an invalid. I will stand on my feet like a Prince of the Line of Durin-even if it is…the last thing I do.”
“Probably will be, stubborn idiot,” Oin grumbled. “Dwalin…”
“Bilbo,” Thorin gasped as he was pulled up to a sitting position. His tunic and armour were ragged around the horrible wound, the wound oozing blood that was staining the deep Durin blue rent undershirt. He blinked and looked on the verge of passing out but rallied. “Bilbo-before you wed me, there is one…thing you must know. One last truth I have concealed.”
“Thorin…” the Hobbit said, staring into the ashen face. The Prince closed his eyes.
“The patrol that failed, that did not protect your home…was mine,” he said in a heavy voice. “I was leading the patrol that day. I was late. There is no excuse because my actions cost you your parents. The dereliction of duty was mine. And at the time, I was scathing that so many died in such a small raid. Halflings were weak and unable to fight and soft. I was…beyond cruel, beyond deserving of any forgiveness. I had hardened my heart against all since the Battle…since my failure and grief…but when I heard that they had left families-and one orphaned son, I felt shame. I had forgotten what I had learned. My prejudices against those who were not Khuzd allowed me to forget you were people as we are. That you love and have families and grieve as we all do. So I sent compensation to help ease the burden-which never reached you. And I was too ashamed to come in person and beg your forgiveness. So I earned this Curse with my pride and prejudice. And you are the person most harmed by my actions. You should not waste your kindness on me.”
Bilbo stared at him and dropped his arm, taking a deep breath. He could hear one of the Princes whisper something along the lines of ‘Uncle’s screwed!’
But Thorin looked into Bilbo’s eyes and ploughed bravely on, unburdening his heart and accepting his fate.
“So go back to your home, your people. Sit in a cosy armchair and study the history you love. You will always be welcome in our Library and your friend Ori will always help you find whatever tomes you seek. I ask my family to ensure that you are given the gold you need to ensure you have comfort and no need to swab corridors or peel potatoes to pay for your food and fuel. You will sit in your garden and grow flowers and plants and honour the ways of your people. And forget the Prince who cost you so much…"
“You utterly impossible rock-headed, idiotic…seriously, did someone drop you in your head when you were a baby?” Bilbo growled. “Are you trying to die? Because you seem to have some terrible death wish!”
“Got it in one,” a voice said from behind Bilbo that was definitely one of the Princes-Kili, if Thorin’s tales were to be believed.
“My parents died because orcs attacked our settlement, having got past Human and Elf and Dwarf patrols,” Bilbo told him bluntly. “My parents tried to fight but against orcs, they stood no chance. Holman Gamgee told me that Mum killed a couple and Dad impaled one with his garden fork but there were just too many. Holman was wounded but survived and his wife Rosa was safe. I was locked in the chutney cupboard by Mum and Dad to protect me and by the time I got out, your patrol had arrived. And I saw you there, leading the counter-attack. I knew you were there and a commander-it was only when I met you, when the nightmares resurfaced that I made the connection. So I know you were involved-but I never blamed you. I learned to let go of bitterness and assigned blame to those who actually own it-the orcs who attacked Hobbitthorpe.”
Every eye landed on him.
“I have spent months feeling that a Prince like you didn’t deserve such a lowly and unimportant and uninteresting Hobbit as me as a friend,” he said, staring at the listing Prince. “And it seems, you have decided that you do not deserve happiness-or even life-for things that happened in the past and that were not your fault. You can be blamed for your pride and rude words and underestimating an entire race-and I rather think you have earned and already paid a horrible penalty for that. But to want to die because you couldn’t save everyone the orcs attacked? That is just madness, Thorin.” He walked forward and pulled the dwarf towards him, resting his forehead against the Prince’s, his hands buried in the Prince’s thick hair. He was breathing hard in his anger but the contact calmed him. Tentatively, Thorin rested his right hand on the back of Bilbo’s neck, holding him close.
“You don’t deserve a crippled dwarf as your husband,” Thorin murmured, the shame in his voice painful to hear. And Bilbo could understand, for he had spoken to Thorin for so many hours and knew how proud the Prince was of his martial prowess, the self-worth he derived from being able to lead his troops as a true Son of Durin should. His injuries would make that well nigh impossible-but there was nothing that Bilbo could say to make that wound any better. All he could share was what was in his heart.
“I forgive you,” Bilbo said. “Now you have to forgive yourself. And I want my One as my husband. No one else. Can you do that?”
“I don’t deserve…”
“Probably not,” Bilbo told him as he pulled back. Thorin’s eyes widened, the uneven stare unnerving. “But sometimes we get less than we deserve-and sometimes more. I am definitely less than you deserve…as you somehow and insanely seem to think that you are less than I deserve. What rot! But no matter-I think we agree that we are meant to be together. So stand and say the words, Prince Thorin son of Thrain son of Thror, called Oakenshield and probably soon to be called Numbskull of all Numbskulls!”
Thorin blinked at the commanding tone and then nodded, his teeth gritted against pain as he stumbled to his feet, supported by Dwalin. He faced the Hobbit and took his hands in his own, the left barely moving to twitch his fingers rather than gripping the smaller being’s hand. He averted his eyes from the ugly thick scar around his wrist and looked up, staring into Bilbo’s bright eyes.
“If this is the last act of my life, I die content,” he said. Bilbo sighed.
“If it is the last act of your life, I will be very disappointed,” he said firmly then looked up at the King. “Your Majesty?”
It was a simple service, the vows said in clear Khuzdûl that Bilbo had to repeat phonetically after the King. But Thrain was patient and even though he and everyone else winced at his pronunciation, he nodded when the vows were said.
“Then before Mahal and by my authority from Durin the Deathless, the father of our race and my direct ancestor, I pronounce you married. May your Union be blessed with love and health and happiness for the long years of your lives.”
Thorin’s head sagged, his lips almost colourless and his skin a waxy white. He already looked like a corpse.
“Not so…very long…” he gasped. But he leaned close, his hands closing on Bilbo’s head and pulling him gently close. “One kiss, my Sanâzyung, to take with me to Mahal’s Halls.” He paused only to ensure he could see acquiescence in the eyes of his beloved before he leaned in and Bilbo rose on his tiptoes to meet him.
But as their lips met, incredible, all encompassing warmth washed all through Bilbo and surged through Thorin’s cooling shape. The Hobbit felt his husband gasp against his lips, the grip tightening and the left hand moving as it had not when he had gently grasped Bilbo. Thorin was shivering and Bilbo felt the connection with his husband warm further in his chest, a sense of rightness and peace filling him. And then, with a shiver and a flash of light that he must have imagined, the all-encompassing warmth was gone, though the little spark in his chest remained.
Thorin straightened up, two blue eyes staring back from an unscarred face. His colour was back, lips curved in a smile that was more shock and amazement than anything else. Bilbo looked up then his head snapped down and a hand pressed against Thorin’s chest. And his palm met smooth, unscarred skin, the warmth leeching into his hand. Thorin’s heart beat under his hand, the chest moving as he breathed.
“You’re healed,” Bilbo breathed. “You’re alive!”
The deep gong of the midnight bell echoed through the mountain.
“Solstice is over,” Balin announced. “And the Prince is…a dwarf again. The Curse is broken.”
There were cheers from the young Princes and suddenly Bilbo was swung away as Thrain-the King of Erebor!-hugged him fiercely.
“Thank you for bringing my son back to me,” he whispered. “I was as prejudiced as he-your compassion has cured us both. Thank you.” The Hobbit looked up and gave a sigh.
“You’re welcome,” he said and smiled. “Earlier today, I was hurt because I was having to fight my family to regain my home and what I owned after it had been stolen by them. And now, I have gained another family, one that I guess will be a little less keen to steal my silver spoons.” The King burst out laughing and looked over to Thorin, who was being embraced by Dwalin and Balin.
“I approve of this One,” the King announced. “Balin-when you have finished there, get the cooks up and organise a feast. We must celebrate! My son has returned-and he’s got a brand new husband!”
“You were right-Sigin’Adad did drop Uncle on his head when he was a baby,” the fair-haired Prince-Fili-said, slinging an arm around Bilbo’s shoulders.
“And Dwalin has hit him over the head enough times while training to cause brain damage,” Kili added. “Hmm-you’re not sure, are you?”
“About you two-no, I’m very sure,” Bilbo told them with a small smile. “Thorin has told me enough tales of your pranks to know to keep a very close eye on you!”
“Aww, it’s not fair that Uncle Thorin has already turned our Hobbit Uncle Bilbo against us,” Kili whined. The Hobbit chuckled.
“If you don’t prank me, I am certain we can be friends,” he said. “And I bake…”
“Muffins?”
“Honey cakes?”
“Apple tarts?”
“Bleurgh," said Fili who hated the smell of apples. “Blackberry tarts!”
“Pies!”
“You have made friends for life,” Princess Dis said, pulling her sons away from the Hobbit. “A way to a dwarf’s heart is definitely through his stomach.” Then she paused. “Thank you,” she added formally. “I have lost one brother and I feared I would lose the other. Be kind to my brother, Master Baggins. I know he takes too much guilt and responsibility upon himself but it is who he is. One day, he will rule this Kingdom and you will be his rock, the strength to lift him up and support him even on the hardest of days. So for that, for all you have done and all you will do, I am always in your service.”
Blinking back tears, Bilbo surged forward and hugged her.
“There is no need for service, only friendship,” he said thickly. Her arms wrapped around him in one of those furnace-warm Durin hugs that he realised he loved.
“Then know this, my Hobbit brother,” she murmured. “I will be your friend until the bitter end, until the last breath of my life leaves my body and then in the world hereafter. My sons-careless and mischievous though they are-swear the same. You will never lack family again, Bilbo-for we are yours. Forever.” then she pulled back and bowed. Huffing a shocked breath, he barely even registered the bear hug from Dwalin-with a murmured promise of service and protection-and Balin, who mumbled the same. And then, finally, Thorin’s arms closed around him once more.
“Are you safe?’ the Crown Prince asked gently. Bilbo nodded.
“Just overwhelmed," he admitted. “This morning, I awoke in New Tuckborough, in a spare room at my cousin’s home waiting to petition him for the return of my home. I was homeless and everything I had was stolen by my kin. The Tooks had been little or no use and I was feeling horribly alone. And I realised it was because I feared that I would never see you again, never speak to you or laugh with you or hear your voice once more. And I felt as if my life was over. I had lost my parents and that was awful…but to lose you, the person my heart chose…that was not something I think I could have borne. So when you started talking about dying and leaving me, I knew that whatever happened, you needed to know that you were loved and wanted. I needed you to fight for me because I would fight for you.”
Thorin stared down fondly into the determined face.
“You don’t know how easy it would have been to give in to the blackness and the pain that seemed to be tearing my chest open,” Thorin murmured, nuzzling the Hobbit’s hair. “Hmm-I will need to put a marriage braid in.” Bilbo chuckled.
“My hair is impossible,” he warned the dwarf.
“I am determined,” Thorin announced. “And utterly impossible, rock-headed and idiotic, if memory serves me correctly.”
“It does,” Bilbo said with a wry smile.
“I think I need a moment with my husband,” the Prince announced, turning to glance at his family and bowing his head to the King. “If you would permit me…” Thrain waved his hand.
“It will take us a little while to whip up a feast,” he announced. “Join us in the Royal Dining Room when you are ready.” Thorin gave a small bow, then grabbed the fur off the bed and dragged the Hobbit from the room. Bilbo looked up, a little surprised at the Prince’s sudden fervour.
“Um…Thorin…are you sure…” he began as the dwarf turned to hug him again.
“Âzyungel, there will be time for such sports later,” Thorin murmured, a smile on his voice. "I just wanted a few minutes of solitude…with you.” Bilbo nodded and followed him, all the way up the long flight of stairs, not worrying when Thorin paused, stopping to finger the unmarked skin through the rents in his clothing and shake his head. And nor did he worry when the Prince sprinted up the last twenty steps or so and sped out of sight, trudging up the last few stairs with heavy calves and his breath huffing out in little clouds-to find the Prince standing right by the brink of the view over the lands around Erebor-certainly further away that the ‘range’ required for him to remain human. It was the proof he had needed to seek for himself that the Curse was finally gone.
Shivering, Bilbo wrapped the fur around his shoulders and walked forward to stand by the dwarf. Automatically, Thorin wrapped an arm around the Hobbit and pulled him close, the warmth from his body leeching into the shivering Bilbo. Before them the land was swathed in white, though the sky had cleared from earlier and the brilliant panoply of stars twinkled in the cloudless sky. Before them the city of Dale was marked by a few watchfires by the gates, the warm light contrasting with the cold light of the stars. Beyond, the humps of the Lone Farthing were almost lost amid the gentle carpet of snow, only the vertical lines of smoke rising from the chimneys marking the homes of the migrant Hobbits. Beyond, the smudge of Mirkwood seemed even darker and gleaming beyond, from such an elevated position, it was possible to just glimpse the gleaming snow-capped peaks of the Misty Mountains.
“It’s my favourite place as well,” Bilbo murmured, feeling Thorin’s arm close tighter around him. “You can see half the world from here and know that no matter what, everyone faces the same problems. Everyone is cold and snowed in and staring out into starlight on this Yule night. And no matter what name you call the constellations, they are the same shining down on us all.”
“How are you still so generous?” Thorin asked him. “Just today, you were homeless because your own family stole your home. Your people have been exploited by every other race and yet you remain so positive.” Bilbo chuckled as Thorin turned him to face him.
“I am a Hobbit, a child of Yavanna,” he said honestly. “We were made to appreciate Her bounty, to be happy and content with home, family and friendship. We are not warlike or vengeful or made to bear grudges. So we are generous and kind and share what we have with any who need it.” Thorin exhaled, wrapping his arms more firmly around Bilbo’s body.
“I still love this view,” he said gruffly. “Especially this part.” Bilbo leaned against the dwarf and heard Thorin’s heart beating solidly as the dwarf rested his bearded chin on the top of the Hobbit’s head. “I think I understand now. We are all part of this world, all neighbours. My own people are insular and jealous of our culture and that attitude leads us to be proud of our own culture and sceptical and dismissive of others. Yet you have shown me that the proudest and most arrogant of dwarves can be brought low by the will of the Valar and saved by those he disregarded. That the smallest person can change the course of history. That I was a fool and utterly impossible and idiotic and rock-headed. And that I feel you here in my heart. A heart that belongs to you forever.”
“I should have added sappy and romantic,” Bilbo murmured. “My heart is yours, my no-longer-cursed Prince. And I will be with you forever. And whenever you need me, I will be here.” Thorin kissed him again and then grasped a little hank of hair, deftly weaving in a braid that he secured with one of his own beads. Carefully, he took Bilbo through making a rather wonky version in his own mane, securing it safely with one of the accessory clasps from his braid of the House of Durin.
“Now we are official,” the Prince murmured, pride filling his eyes.
“So that is it?” Bilbo asked as his husband led the Hobbit towards the stairs once more. Thorin nodded.
“Not quite. You do realise that you will be one of the most powerful and important people in Erebor?” he murmured as they began to descend once more. “No more being ignored or jostled aside. And no more cleaning the floors…”
“Thank Eru,” Bilbo replied and then looked up. “I can still go to the Library and help Ori, can’t I?” The Prince chuckled.
“Whatever you want, Âzyungel,” he said. “You’ll have to learn about ruling Erebor but you must be able to pursue your own interests as well…”
“I’m assuming Âzyungel isn’t an insult,” Bilbo said as they turned the corner and started down another level.
“Love of all loves,” Thorin said with a small smirk.
“Dramatic,” Bilbo said and then stopped. “But I have to thank you too. You have given me a home, family, love…when I was alone and sad and didn’t even realise. I may have cured you-but you cured me too.”
And then the smiling dwarf Prince took his Hobbit husband’s hand and Thorin led Bilbo down back to his new family and the belated Solstice/Yule Feast that would celebrate the new year and new life they were starting together.
The End.
