Work Text:
"Who are you?" I asked, as the swirling black cloud suddenly took shape.
"I am your shadow," it replied.
"What is my shadow doing in my dream?" I asked.
"To show you something."
I turned around and, within that blindingly white room, I beheld a mirror.
"What is it you want to show me, shadow?"
"I am showing you who you are."
"With this mirror?"
I waited, but the shadow did not answer. It remained motionless directly before me.
A total darkness. Impenetrable, yet intangible.
"Why do you want to show me something?" I tried addressing the shadow once more.
"Because you must see yourself."
"What will it bring me?"
"Suffering."
I swallowed hard and turned toward the mirror.
The glass was clear. Not a single corner was clouded or dull. Beyond the green meadows and warm holes, such mirrors did not exist.
"What should I look for?"
My reflection was clear and distinct, and yet I felt no suffering.
"Me," the shadow answered, veiling the reflection with its darkness.
"You are made only of blackness. What am I supposed to see?"
"Why are you looking with your eyes, foolish Hobbit?"
Its counter-question threw me off balance.
I hesitated and took a small step back. Away from the mirror and away from the shadow.
It frightened me.
"With what should I look, if not with my eyes, oh honorable shadow?"
My voice trembled.
"With your heart," the shadow countered, sinking to the floor. Its harsh contours blurred, dissolving into a shallow darkness that drifted around me in calm circles.
Once more, my gaze wandered to the mirror.
"Nothing has changed, shadow."
I still saw the very same Hobbit. And my heart did not have much to say about it. After all, it was just a mirror.
It showed no more and no less than my outward appearance.
"You are right," the shadow's voice boomed at my feet.
"This mirror will never show anything else either. Well done, clever Hobbit."
I started as the shadow took shape again right beside me.
Its featureless face turned toward me, and despite my fear, I understood that I had to see with my heart.
"You are a part of me, aren't you?"
"Of course. I am your shadow."
"And yet you have never been here until now. Why?"
"Because I lacked the strength."
"Can my own shadow lie to me?"
"No."
"Can I lie to my shadow?"
"Yes."
Cautiously, I stepped closer to the shadow. Though it stood a little distance away from me, I suddenly felt that it spoke the truth. It was a part of me. It could not lie to me. But I could lie to it.
"I am not afraid of you."
"And I am not afraid of you, my Hobbit."
As my hand touched the darkness, it felt strangely familiar.
There was fear, hatred, worry, anger, and doubt.
I felt longing, sorrow, insecurity, discontent, and frustration.
"This is you?"
"Yes," the shadow said, sounding neither joyful nor sad.
I pulled my hand back, and hearing the shadow laugh, I realized I had placed it over my own heart.
"This is me?"
"Of course. After all, I belong to you."
Thoughtfully, I looked at the shadow, of which I was no longer afraid. It was made of unpleasant things, but all these things were natural, and a part of me.
"Where is the rest of me?"
"What rest?"
"I am not afraid of you, shadow. Tell me!"
The shadow laughed again, and I realized I did not like that sound.
"Within me is only darkness, you foolish Hobbit."
"Do not lie to me!"
"As you have already established, I am incapable of doing so," the shadow countered. And it was right. It could not lie to me.
"Where is it then?" I asked, feeling how desperate my voice sounded.
"Everything that makes you who you are, my Hobbit, is here."
I looked around, yet there was nothing in this eternal void except the shadow and the mirror. The mirror showed me my exterior. Without judgment, without praise or criticism. The shadow consisted of misery and suffering.
"This is me?"
"Yes."
My shadow spoke the truth. For it would not lie to me.
It could not.
And yet, I did not want to believe it. For that would be terrible. Then the sum of my parts would be something I did not wish to be.
"Why do you shrink from me, my Hobbit? What frightens you so?"
"I am not afraid of you, shadow."
My shoulder bumped against the mirror.
It slipped aside a little, but it did not fall. Likely, it was unable to.
The shadow grew larger the further I backed away from it. And it laughed. I hated that laugh.
"That is a great pity, my Hobbit."
"What is a pity? What are you speaking of?"
"Do you truly wish to know? You know I am not capable of deceit."
"Of course! Speak!"
"It is a pity that you are afraid of me."
~*~
Startled, Bilbo bolted up from his sleeping bag and cursed as his head struck something unexpectedly hard.
"What in the—"
"Oh, I'm sorry. You were sleeping so fitfully, I just wanted to check if everything was alright."
"Fili?"
The high canopy of Mirkwood let no moonlight through. It was difficult to find one's bearings in this everlasting darkness. By now, he recognized most of the dwarves by their voices alone.
"Are the others still asleep?"
"It is the dead of night, Master Bilbo. They will be asleep for quite a while yet."
"And you are on watch?"
Bilbo felt around for the shadowy outline of the young dwarf until his fingers caught his sleeve.
"Yes, until dawn. Though you can't see a thing in this damned darkness anyway," he cursed, letting himself drop to the ground beside Bilbo's sleeping bag with a dull thud.
The Hobbit could not blame him for his frustration.
Mirkwood lived up to its name.
All the night revealed to them were the glowing eyes of scuttling creatures.
"If all goes well, we shall leave this cursed patch of land soon."
Fili nodded and squeezed Bilbo’s hand, which now rested in the crook of his arm.
In the eternal darkness, the company had drawn closer together.
A little physical contact provided the illusion of not being entirely blind.
Exhausted, Bilbo let himself lean against the young dwarf's broad shoulder.
He was terribly tired, but what good was sleep?
Nothing but twisted dreams.
He felt the sweat trickling down his forehead. In the cool night air, the moisture left an icy trail.
"Have you ever heard of a shadow, Fili?"
That dream had been intensely realistic. Surreal, yet somehow tangible. And terrible.
Full of suffering.
That was exactly what the shadow had foretold. Suffering.
"A shadow? Everything is dark here, Master Bilbo."
"I am not speaking of the shadow your eyes can see."
"Then I am afraid I do not know what you mean, Master Bilbo."
No, he had never heard of it.
"Stop that 'Master Bilbo'. It sounds ridiculous. Just 'Bilbo'. Alright?"
"Very well."
In the canopy high above them, he could make out isolated pinpricks of bright light.
Somewhere beyond them, the moon had to be.
And the stars.
Somewhere up there was the sky in all its nightly splendor.
It was comforting to see a little light.
It was disquieting that he could now feel the presence of that other shadow within his heart. For no matter how pitch-black the night was, the darkness of the other shadow ran deeper.
Precisely because it could not be seen.
Precisely because it seemed so distant.
Precisely because he was capable of lying to it openly.
In the dark, that shadow gained its power. The corruption of Mirkwood, with all its enchanted magic, made the shadow strong.
Bilbo’s gaze drifted over the sleeping dwarves. They all seemed restless. For they were all in this enchanted place.
And they all felt the suffering within them.
He couldn’t see this suffering with his eyes, but what were eyes anyway? They were blind to such things. They were the first thing anyone closed when the pain arose.
Yet he would never be able to close his heart.
With comforting intent, he squeezed Fili’s hand, which lay warm in his own.
One could not banish the shadow when it was a part of you.
But one could cause it to grow smaller.
~*~
It is not easy to accept one’s own shadow.
Of course, he was afraid.
Of course, he wanted to deny that he was all of those things.
But he was unable to.
The shadow had spoken the truth. And to fight against the truth was futile.
The truth would always catch up to you.
Eventually.
Likely at the exact moment when you could least afford it.
Therefore, Bilbo came to terms with it. For this last shred of power he did possess over his shadow.
Yes, he was afraid.
And yes, he felt insecurity, sorrow, hatred, and discontent.
That, and so much more. But he could live with it.
These were parts of him. What would be the use of denying them?
"Does this madness never come to an end?" Dwalin’s voice sounded foreign.
Muffled and somehow drained of strength.
It did not suit the great warrior.
"Soon. Soon we shall have made it. Soon we shall see Erebor."
He was leading them through the forest alongside Thorin.
The two of them were constantly scanning for the Elven-path.
Disputing whether those moss-covered stones did indeed still form a path, or if they had already been led astray.
"How do you know that, Thorin? Everything looks the same here!"
"Because I know it. This is the way forward!"
Bilbo walked only a few paces behind them.
Ahead of him was Balin, but he had not uttered a word for hours.
The old dwarf looked as though he might collapse at any moment under the weight of his pack.
"Water. I am thirsty. Why do we have no water left?" Behind him was Dori.
Dori, who had already complained of the discomforts of this journey when it rained.
Bilbo turned around, but he beheld nothing but his own greenish-brown eyes. Another deception of this enchanted forest.
He knew this, but somehow that knowledge did not make it any better.
There was no comfort in being aware of one's own descent into madness.
"This is not the way! This way!" Dwalin talked a great deal. More than usual.
Apparently, this was his way of not losing his mind entirely in this forsaken place.
A sound escaped Thorin’s throat that resembled deep frustration. Frustration was a familiar feeling to them all.
Frustration, thirst, and hunger. Weariness.
Bilbo thought of his shadow.
He knew it was far more than that.
The shadow was gaining strength in this forest.
The shadow that made him feel all the terrible things in life. Never before had Bilbo been more aware of this darkness within himself.
Fili didn’t recognize the shadow.
Had the others dreamed of their shadows?
Did they also know how wretched the individual pieces were that made them up?
Darkness and a banal reflection of themselves?
Or was he the only one?
Did only he understand their suffering in all its facets?
Or was he the one who was already so mad that he dreamed of ominous shadows and vast, empty rooms?
~*~
He was not alone.
They all felt it. Even if they surely could not have put it into words.
Bilbo had been assigned the first watch for the night.
Another night and Mirkwood still stretched out before them, and no end was in sight.
Perhaps they would not live to see the end of this madness.
Restlessly, his gaze swept over his sleeping companions.
Though he had not cared much for the dwarves at first, he had by now grown fond of this company. He tried to remember the day they had ransacked his larder.
That day when they had quite literally tumbled through his front door without permission, tearing him away from his comfortable life.
Oh, how grateful he was to them for it.
He started as a warm hand suddenly pressed against his shoulder. He had not noticed that someone else was awake.
"Kili?"
"No."
Thorin.
The two of them shared a similarly strong, somehow gentle grip. Kili had often jolted him from his thoughts in this manner.
Thorin had never done so before.
"Can you not sleep either?"
"I have the first watch. You assigned me yourself only a few hours ago."
Gladly would Bilbo have dispelled the darkness a little, if only to see the face of his companion. Thorin had always been a particularly taciturn dwarf. Yet his face sometimes betrayed his thoughts.
At least if one knew him well enough.
And by Yavanna—Bilbo knew him quite well by now. A fact he would never have deemed possible not so long ago.
"May I sit with you?"
"Oh, um—... of course."
Hastily, Bilbo slid aside a little so that Thorin could sit beside him.
He had established his lookout on a fallen tree stump, slightly away from the camp. It was hard and uncomfortable, and should he fall asleep, he would instantly tumble backward.
This was intentional, for it was the only way he could endure his watch.
Bilbo remembered the other night when Fili had settled down beside him in a very similar fashion.
It had comforted him then to hold the dwarf's hand and to lean against his shoulder.
Thorin, however, did not touch him, and Bilbo would never dream of leaning against him uninvited.
There was no closeness in this darkness. But there was security. A security that allowed Bilbo to close his eyes for a brief moment and breathe.
"You don’t need to worry, Thorin. Hobbits are not known for being active at night, but I can manage. Truly, I—"
"I cannot sleep."
"Oh, that—..."
Yes, what was he supposed to say to that? That he was sorry?
That he could sympathize with him.
For a brief moment, Bilbo hesitated.
After all, it would be too forward. Thorin might notice. He might suddenly know what was going on inside Bilbo.
But that was foolish.
That could not be.
And so he hesitated no longer, but carefully placed his hand into the crook of the dwarf's arm.
For a little closeness in this darkness.
Thorin did not pull away.
Did their strong leader possess a shadow as well? The thought was so surreal.
It was somehow disturbing, frightening, enlightening, and hopeful.
For what else was Bilbo to cling to, if not the hope that someone else was not so terribly afraid?
"Have you ever heard of a shadow?"
Perhaps it would be easier if Thorin understood what he felt. The dwarf was older and more experienced in life than Fili.
Perhaps he, too, had already dreamed of his shadow.
"A shadow? This forest consists of a single darkness. Not even the deepest pits in the darkest mountains hold such despair within their gloom."
"I am not speaking of the shadow we can see, but of—..." Of the shadow in our hearts.
But would Thorin understand that?
"I do not understand you."
No.
"I wish you did."
Suddenly, Bilbo was certain that their leader possessed such a shadow in his heart as well. And it frightened him far more than his own shadow.
Yavanna herself would likely be unable to tell him why that was.
"Explain it to me."
Bilbo gasped as another hand rested over his own.
He could feel his heart hammering against his throat, and suddenly he was no longer certain at all if he could hide the turmoil within.
There were too many things. Too many fears. Too many worries. Too many hopes. Too many shadows and uncertainties.
Thorin must never find out what he felt.
"I think I should not explain it to you."
"Do you believe me too foolish to comprehend it?"
He did not wish to anger him. He truly did not.
"No, no. I—... It would not help you. It would do you no good. It was foolish of me to bring it up."
They fell silent again.
It was something they did often by now. But normally, Thorin’s large hand did not rest upon his own. And normally, in these moments, he was not plagued by uncertainty as to whether the other was angered.
Yet the darkness of the night and the gloom within his heart prevented him from seeing what the other was feeling.
~*~
To accept one’s own darkness was difficult.
But to tolerate the shadow within a loved one was something entirely different.
One could measure one's own shadow.
Bilbo knew that he could bear this burden. He knew that, somehow, everything was still alright. That he had things under control.
But what of Thorin’s shadow?
How vast was the darkness within someone who had witnessed such far more terrible things?
Bilbo knew his story. And he felt no pity.
Thorin had no need for pity.
But would it hurt to bring a little light into his darkness?
Did the dwarf, outwardly so strong, perhaps even require precisely that? A helping hand that asked no questions and was simply there at the right moment?
They had already endured a long march that day. The faint sunlight barely allowed them to keep from losing one another in the thicket.
But it was exhausting to fight through the many tangled vines hanging from the trees. Far too often he had overlooked a stubborn branch, and by now, his face and hands were covered in scratches and scrapes.
Today, he walked near the front.
Dwalin was further back, helping the others carry the sleeping Bombur through the undergrowth.
Bilbo did not envy him that task.
"Bilbo? Are you still there?"
"Of course. Here. Right behind you."
Thorin’s searching gaze drifted over him. Deep shadows hung beneath his blue eyes. They spoke of weariness and exhaustion.
"Can you see me? Thorin?"
"No."
Bilbo nearly fell into their leader as Kili bumped against his back. When had they stopped?
"I am here."
He found Thorin’s hand and gave it a brief squeeze. Yet when he went to withdraw, he was held fast.
"That is good. Very good. Stay here. Right here. Do you understand?"
A rough thumb brushed over his fingers, and really, what did it matter if Thorin eventually realized what was going on inside him?
What was a little truth against the madness that reigned around them? Nothing!
"When are we moving on?"
"Is there something there?"
"Have we been here before?"
"We make camp," Thorin announced, letting his pack drop to the ground. After that, he took Bilbo’s hand once more.
"Tho—..."
"And you stay here. Understood?"
"Yes."
~*~
The forest grew bleaker. The trees grew ever denser.
The thirst grew sharper. Overpowering.
And Thorin did not let go of Bilbo’s hand.
Would that suffice to keep him from his shadows?
~*~
"These webs everywhere. It's disgusting."
"I know, brother. I care little for it either."
Soon Balin and Dwalin would be asleep as well.
Bilbo would remain awake. For Thorin sat beside him.
Close.
Far too close, in truth, for him to miss the loud hammering of the small Hobbit-heart.
But perhaps he did not miss it at all.
Exhausted, Bilbo let himself lean against the familiar shoulder and tried to forget his thirst, while a strong arm wrapped around his shoulder.
"Shall we ever come out of here alive?" It was the first time he had put his doubts into words to Thorin.
He had not meant to say it. He had wanted to be strong. So that the shadow within Thorin would not grow any larger.
"Of course. Someone like you does not die in such a place."
He had not seen Thorin smile in a long time. And this smile was genuine.
"Someone like me?"
Soon it would be dark. Utterly dark. The nights of Mirkwood were long and relentless.
"You are kind. And brave. You have a good heart. Such a person does not die in such terrible a place."
Bilbo did not know how he had earned such a high opinion from Thorin.
The words were few, yet Thorin spoke but rarely. Therefore, what he had said meant a great deal.
Important. Meaningful.
It felt like a lie.
'I am none of those things,' he wanted to say.
But he kept silent.
He could still see the smile on those familiar lips. And for that, he would keep his silence. For it was so much more important to weaken the other's fears and doubts than to utter his own.
"Thank you. It is nice of you to hold such a high opinion of me. And I dearly hope you are right. I do not wish to die here."
It was the first night they sat together for so long that, eventually, he fell asleep with his head in Thorin’s lap.
~*~
"So we meet again, my Hobbit."
"Why am I here?"
"Because we are always here."
Everything was exactly as Bilbo remembered it.
"Have you grown smaller, shadow?"
"No."
"But you look smaller."
Bilbo turned toward the mirror. In the darkness of Mirkwood, he had not seen his own face for far too long.
But the mirror, too, had grown smaller, and he had to bend down to see his own countenance.
"The mirror is smaller as well? Why is that, shadow?"
"The mirror has not grown smaller, my Hobbit."
"Stop speaking in riddles! I have had enough of those in my life!"
The shadow laughed. And though Bilbo had feared that laugh before, it was suddenly meaningless.
"You have grown larger, my Hobbit."
"Lar—... I beg your pardon?"
He startled as the shadow collapsed in on itself and suddenly wrapped around him. Once more, he felt all the things he feared so deeply.
But the dread did not come.
"What has changed, shadow?"
"You have grown larger, my Hobbit."
"How?"
"Because you chose to be."
The shadow became too clingy, and suddenly he knew that he could grasp it. He reached into the blackness and pulled it away from himself, setting it down beside him once more.
He would not have dared to do that then. Why, then, today?
"What has caused us to stand before each other so differently today, my shadow?" he asked, hoping that this time he had chosen his words wisely.
"You decided upon it. Nothing more."
"I decided upon it. I have-..."
The shadow laughed, but Bilbo already had his answer. He no longer needed to speak with his shadow. He could turn his back on it. For he had resolved to be strong. He was more than fear, hatred, and doubt.
He was kind and brave.
"I am stronger than you, shadow."
"Yes, you are."
The once vast shadow curled into a small ball and suddenly seemed far less tangible. Somehow formless. Powerless.
And as Bilbo looked around in the great infinity, he suddenly realized that there was something else. For when he had first been stranded in this situation, he had seen only the shadow and his optical reflection.
He had entirely ignored that there was something else in this room.
And that was himself.
How could he have overlooked that?
In truth, it was so obvious it was laughable.
Had he truly believed that he consisted only of bad things? What nonsense! That could never have worked.
In this dream, too, his hand found its way back to his heart. Not the place, where the shadow had it’s heart but his very own.
Yes, there was much more to this Hobbit.
And there was much more to everyone else he had doubted.
For no matter how great the shadow may be, every man remains the master of his own fate.
"I can be happy at any time, can I not?"
"Of course."
"I only have to wish it."
"Yes."
"And believe in it."
"Yes."
"It sounds very simple, does it not?"
"It is."
There is an end to these woods, Bilbo thought.
And we will find it soon.
