Actions

Work Header

The Dragon's Keep

Summary:

Bilbo attempts to burgle Erebor, but finds himself a captive of the dragon instead. Will Thorin rescue him in time, or will Smaug corrupt his heart?

Chapter Text

Bilbo Baggins had a problem.

Well, several problems.

Well...several problems buffeted up by a network of far more sub-problems, nitpicks, and general annoyances. This was a state he had lived in even at Bag End, where trouble came in many flavors: from the shade of mud tracked over his rug by an unwelcome guest to the dingy flan of those horrid beetles that always fled indoors during the winter. Leaving the Shire, rather than uncomplicating things, had merely displaced them. It was hard to be fussy about the unsatisfactory state of one’s clothes when being pursued by terrifying nether-beasts right out of a childhood nightmare.

But the problem to end all problems, the one that worried him like an errant tooth, was with him from when the party woke at dawn to when they made camp at night. All the more daunting for how inescapable it was, for he was duty-bound to follow it.

Well, “duty” was perhaps too noble of a word. “Obligation,” perhaps. “Contracted” did not seem adequate to cover the sheer scope of all he had been asked (told) to do. Nor did it encompass the confusing fact that he had actually come to somewhat enjoy himself.

And there was the problem again. Because he had conflicted feelings and conflicted feelings only served to magnify the problem until it outweighed all the other problems. So Bilbo sat teething on the knot of it, grimacing at the empty air, until Bofur passed him with a nudge.

“Mind you chew your porridge,” he said mildly.

Bilbo came back to himself, spoon discreetly set back into a bowl of half-eaten mush (although any civilized soul looking at it might remark it looked fully eaten and spit back up) and averted his gaze from the boulder just south of their camp. The rock, besides vaguely resembling a melted frog, held little of interest besides this feature; it was near enough to where Thorin sat brooding over the map that Bilbo could spy on him undetected. And that was what he felt like, a filthy little spy, a burglar, stealing glances when his target’s back was turned (metaphorically speaking; Thorin was currently turned to profile, sunlight picking out the noble planes of his face.)

This was the problem. He was the problem. 

Bilbo had always known himself to be...of a certain sort. Since the day Primrose Grubb had made to kiss him and he’d run shrieking for the hedgerows, they had all laughed and told him he would grow to be a lonely old codger. He resented their words more as he grew up to find them true. Marriage held no allure for him. Relationships were untidy things, and in a place where everyone had known everyone else from birth there was no such thing as a casual romance. They had no care for hobbits like him existing, because such things did not exist in their limited world. A marrow would sooner be pulled from the earth bright purple and shrieking than a—

“—Master Baggins, a word.” Thorin indicated he should come near with a flick of his chin.

Bilbo sighed and set down his porridge. “A simple ‘could you come over please ’ would suffice.”

This was the real problem. Not just that he had fallen for an outsider—a dwarf —but that he was held so very beneath contempt in return. Bilbo was constantly caught between irritation at how he was treated as an annoyance and how he just wanted Thorin to like him, so very badly. There was something about the way the dwarf smiled on those rare occasions when he relaxed, the way he’d held Bilbo in that hug—and what will I have to do for another, Thorin? Save your life again?

Bilbo was careful not to stand too close to the dwarf, holding himself so that their arms would not even brush by accident. This entire quest had become a balancing game of not appearing too eager in Thorin’s presence.

Thorin looked up at him, and Bilbo felt a stab of shame. His gaze pierced even when it did not intend to; Bilbo constantly felt caught out by a schoolmaster when around him.

“Once we make passage across the lake, we will need to scout up to the entrance. How fare you at cliffs?”

Bilbo squinted at the map. “No better or worse than any Hobbit. Couldn’t we go round—”

“Would you have us wait on the step, ring the bell so that the dragon may feast?” Thorin’s tone made emphasis that yes, Bilbo was an idiot for thinking so obviously like a hobbit, Bilbo did not even need to look to see his face. “We are on a mission of stealth, Master Baggins, which I was informed was your specialty.”

“Give the wee laddie some slack, he’s not seen the full majesty of the lonely mountain in his time.” Balin looked over, dropping a reassuring wink. Ah, one Dwarf who could be trusted to see reason.

“Grand peak,” mourned Dori, “great bones of iron and coal. Not like those glorified hillocks you get up north.”

Dwalin crossed his arms, his bulk moving like oiled clockwork. “Aye, you could run a seam thick as pie through the earth, it would nae piddle out after a few chops but bite deep as a river.”

The restriction in Bilbo’s chest eased somewhat as dwarven nostalgia overwhelmed his public display of ignorance. He turned to find Thorin giving him an inscrutable look.

“What?” he dabbed at each cheek. “Have I got something on my face?”

Kili laughed, pinching a full measure of flesh from the side of his face. “Only a hobbit would care whether or not he’s smudged from the road. Your mum’s not here to scold you for getting your britches scuffed.”

“My mother’s dead,” Bilbo muttered, and then slightly louder: “it’s not the dirt so much I mind, it’s the smell. I’m surprised this company even needs to march, your trousers probably stand under their own power by now.”

The dwarves exchanged a distinctly dwarvish look, one only capable of coming from a race used to generations all working and sweating together in a dark, cramped place.

“If you gents don’t mind, I'm going to have a wash before we press further,” Bilbo said, taking up his pack and deliberately not looking at Thorin, “and maybe that way when the lake folk lay eyes on us they won’t run away screaming.”

 

At this bend the forest river ran at a fortitude-shrinking temperature, save for the depths where it ran even colder. After several disastrous attempts at bathing (and several impolite words that would make a corsair blush) Bilbo retreated, spluttering, to the shore. He pulled clothes over his damp, shivering body with numbed hands as quickly as he could, letting out several more colorful words as he stubbed his toe.

“I would think it would be easier to just live with the smell.”

Bilbo froze, his limbs seizing up as his mind did. The problem he had sought to leave behind, even for a little while, had followed him.

Thorin stood on a rock above him, setting down his kit piece by piece, eyes thankfully intent to the task. Bilbo stumbled through dressing himself the rest of the way, turning his head to hide the blush.

“You know, the water in this river is fed by snowmelt this time of year.”

Bilbo sighed, shoulders sagging. “Am I to be ridiculed for simple hygiene now?” he looked up to where Thorin held the trace of a smile on his face. “Do you know what I mourn? More than the exhaustion or the pests or the ravening goblin hoards? A nice, hot bath. Best thing ever invented. Instant curative for whatever ails you. I wonder if you lot would be as stubborn as you are if you took them regularly.”

Was that the ghost of a chuckle he heard? Thorin bent down to fiddle with something. “Dwarves have known baths, little hobbit, we just don’t regard them as a necessity as you do. Besides, tubs and hot, running water are scarce in a mine.”

“Ah yes, and you do as you advised me to, ‘ just live with the smell ’?” 

“Of course not.” Thorin unbuckled his outer tunic and slipped it off his shoulders. “The notion that we are a crude, unwashed people is quite incorrect. We oil ourselves.”

Bilbo stopped halfway through squeezing water from his ringlets. “Sorry?”

“We use a cleansing oil on our bodies, and scrape the grime away. It’s actually quite luxurious, in its own fashion.”

Bilbo’s heart began racing, because now he was confronted with the mental image of a certain dwarf applying oil and oh —there went Thorin slipping off his shirt, when he spoke of cleansing oils and the like he meant to do so now. Bilbo made himself seem very busy to avoid looking up, because if he did his gaze would wander trapped up the peaks and valleys of the dwarf’s body like an ant in a maze.

“I hope you don’t mind,” Thorin said casually, “we Dwarves prefer to do these things away from each other.” He spread a handful of oil over his broad chest. The antiseptic smell of cedar and citrus came wafting to Bilbo’s nose, mixing dangerously with the very male scent of Thorin. “You made a good point. If we intend to seek passage from a boatman, it would do to make ourselves slightly more presentable, such as it is.” He ran a dull iron blade over his oiled flesh, dark rivulets trickling down his muscles.

“Can you, erm, really get clean that way?” Bilbo could not prevent his voice from jumping higher in his throat as he asked. He could no longer make a show of not looking. “As clean as you would if you had water to, um, wash everything away?”

“Just about.” Thorin began working oil into his forearms. “In some ways, moreso. Our hair is better tamed by oils. Not everyone has those thin little curls as you do.” he wound his thick hair into a knot atop his head.

Unconsciously, Bilbo reached up to touch his own hair. He couldn’t decide whether to feel insulted or complimented.

“The oils themselves serve a purpose: they help to repel pests, stop infections. Does that lather of yours do the same?”

Bilbo quickly pocketed the sliver of lavender soap he had been rationing up until now, self-conscious.

“No, it just...it smells nice,” he mumbled. He wasn’t imagining it, Thorin was smirking. Fantastic, if he wasn’t a pest, he was a joke. It was exactly like the Shire only he had no Bag End to retreat to, no quiet place to rest his feet away from prying eyes. Bilbo buckled his pack and cleared his throat.

“Well,” he said tightly, “I'm just finishing up now, I'll leave you to it.”

“Very well. We’ll be pressing on after this. We must make Erebor by Durin’s day. If we fail, it will not be by my doing.”

Again, the subtle dig that Bilbo was not enough. Soft hands and a soft head, more suited for a drawing room than drawing a sword. Bilbo hitched up his pack and squared his shoulders. 

“Right,’ he muttered, swiftly exiting without a look at the dwarf.

Chapter 2

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

They lingered by the dock at the edge of the lake, reasoning that sooner or later there would be a trade vessel ready to barter passage. They killed time as best they could. Some cleaned the cooking tools with handfuls of sand, some whittled, while those with younger blood practiced at war.

“Here!” KiIi's sword flashed and batted a piece of driftwood back to his brother, who parried it away. 

“I’m sorry, what am I meant to be doing?” Bilbo tossed a bit of wood in the air and made an unsuccessful slice at it, missing it entirely.

“Treat it lightly, it’s not a cooking-knife little Hobbit,” Fili teased, doing an effortless-looking backhanded maneuver with his.

“Look my reflexes aren’t what yours are,” Bilbo said impatiently, “you could meet me halfway and toss us a bit.” He flinched as Kili suddenly belted a block at his knee. Both brothers burst into laughter.

“Enough of that.” There was the weight of Thorin’s presence at his back, and Bilbo froze. “A company is only as strong as its weakest member. You would do well to remember a day when you were not so fit yourselves.”

The brothers looked down and murmured vaguely apologetic noises. 

Thorin paused. “Besides, they are right, you’re putting too much heft into it.”

Bilbo tried not to blush. “Oh very helpful, thank you.”

Like the body of a serpent Thorin's hand threaded along his own, covering the grip on his sword. 

“Move your fingers,” Thorin murmured. 

Bilbo tried very vainly not to show 1/10th of the emotion he was feeling at the moment. “W-what?”

“Your grasp on your sword is inefficient. Where you grip can massively affect your swing. Now—” he nodded at Fili, “you must flick it out with a rolling motion, understand?”

Bilbo nodded, blood thumping in his ears. With Thorin’s guide he struck out—and knocked the block into the river. He gave a triumphant little shout...before realizing he was being watched. Indeed, the entire company had halted their activities to look. Now they gave him the condescending smiles of parents watching a child swing a mallet at a croquet ball. Bilbo coughed and looked down. 

“Erm, that’s enough for today I think.”

Bilbo tugged his arm from Thorin’s grip, which showed surprising resistance. Everyone was still looking at him. Damn it all, his cheeks felt hot.

“I imagine when you go back home you’ll have your pick of the fillies.” Bofur tucked a pipe stem into the corner of his cheeky grin. “The lasses love a man who can handle himself in a fight.”

“Even if I was inclined to go stabbing my way around the Shire, I have no intentions of marriage.”

“Someone more exotic then. Say from two miles down the road.” Fili caught up a rock with a flick of his toe and bounced it from knee to knee.

“No,” Bilbo put a hand to his brow, fending off a migraine. “No marriage, not now, not ever. I'm not...the marrying type.”

“Ah,” Bofur nodded sagely. “So it’s like that then.”

‘L-like what? What do you mean?” Panic fluttered in Bilbo’s chest. 

Balin spat out a collection of syllables that sounded like he had a bone in his throat. “When two dwarves have faced battle and blood together, sometimes they are wholly unsuited to domestic life. They make a pact to dwell together until one or the other dies.”

Panic was replaced by the beating wings of hope. Bilbo caught himself turning to look at Thorin and stopped. 

“Y-you mean two fellows can live together and nobody...nobody says anything? You haven’t great aunts and the like barging the doors down to introduce you to someone’s maiden daughter?”

“What would be the point?” Dori asked, “they’re not fit for anyone’s company but their own, why force such a thing?”

“And who would say anything to a warrior’s face?” Dwalin gouged a chip off a hickory branch with a very wicked-looking knife. “Or behind his back? They have been in battle, they have earned the right to privacy.”

Bilbo blinked. “...I think I could get used to that.”

Bofur blew a smoke ring. “Aye, who would you dwell with then? Another to spend time arranging doilies?”

The dwarves tittered at his expense.

Thankfully Bilbo was spared further embarrassment when the silhouette of a boat swayed into view through the fog.

Balin quickly arranged himself at the front, all smiles. “Ahoy there!”

 

The barge slid through dark waters, just barely missing crumbling pillars and jutting stone shoal at turns. 

“I have a feeling there was something much greater here, once,” Bilbo said, keeping still as he could, “not just of architecture but a general sort of grandness. The lake seems quite tame compared to where we came from.”

“Dale was a great trading hub,” Bard intoned, “as salt flows from every land to the sea, so trade from every kingdom of men flowed here. Before it was razed to the ground that is.”

“Aye, nearly a match for the kingdom under the mountain,” Balin said. Surely he meant it as a compliment but Bilbo, who knew how to read a room, winced.

“The vault of a bunch of gold-mongers? Hardly. The dwarves of Erebor cared to uplift no-one but themselves. They were ultimately the ones who called the calamity down from the heavens, that gluttonous wyrm who laid waste to both kingdoms.”

Bilbo could hear a creak beside him as Thorin tensed, but said nothing.

Bard turned a suspicious eye to them. “You say you are but humble merchants?”

“Aye, we had a run of bad luck and lost all our goods,” Bofur smiled gormlessly, “we hope to meet up with a contingency from the Iron Hills to replenish.”

Bofur alone among the dwarves could spin such fancy with a straight face, knowing that not even he believed it.

Bard turned, unsatisfied, back to his barging. Bilbo hunched his shoulders.

“You might do better not to agitate our transport, he may just decide to chuck us over the side,” he hissed.

“You would have us hunch like beaten dogs when common folk insult us?” Thorin murmured, glaring.

“No, I'd expect you to keep a low profile, though everything I've seen up until now tells me it’s folly.” Bilbo glared around the company, drawing himself up tall as he could. “You are not yet back on the throne, you are still at the mercy of other races and yes, a little humility would probably grease the wheels as well as coin.” 

Some of the dwarves had the good graces to look ashamed, but there again—Thorin giving him that inscrutable look. This time Bilbo returned it, gathering his brow quizzically. 

“Ho there, the shore.” Bard went to moor at the ragged ruin of a dock, which creaked dangerously beneath their feet. “Not so much cause to visit these parts anymore, I can’t offer you anything better.”

“We thank you kindly anyway, lad.” Balin made a show of pouring their collective coin into his hand, the very last of their tender. “may favourable winds fill your sails for taking pity on such a raggedy lot.”

Bard regarded them for a long time, studying them so fiercely Bilbo expected him at any second to let on that he knew.

Instead he said, “you spoke of the ruins of Erebor?”

Bilbo could practically hear Thorin’s hackles raise.

“Yes, laddie?”

“I would avoid any nostalgic sight-seeing while in the area. Unsavory things sleep there. The only way to escape harm is to stay beneath notice.”

“We’ll keep it in mind, lad.” Balin smiled and waved jovially as the boatman pushed off, back to lake-town.

Dwalin came up to stand beside him. “Should have let me toss him overboard.”

“We don’t know these waters, we woulndae make the other side without him.”

“Would have saved us a bit.”

“We’re about to rediscover the fallen vaults of Erebor, quibbling over a few coins is idiotic.” Now that they’d set down on the far shore, Thorin practically vibrated with energy. “We must make the lookout by nightfall. The wizard is due to meet us soon.”

New life had flown into the dwarves, they caught up their bundles and laughed and chattered to one another as they set off through the rugged hills. Bilbo practically had to skip to keep up. Their enthusiasm was quite contagious and he smiled even as he panted with exhaustion. When they finally made it to the great vista overlooking the settlement, he gasped with what little breath he had. To hear them tell of such things was one thing, but to see it was quite another. There on the hillside lay Dale, still grand even in ruin. Beyond it lay the keep of Erebor, the guarding stone Dwarf sullenly overlooking the valley. The old excitement he had felt when his mother told him tales on her knee had caught hold of him again. Here now, truly, he felt like an adventurer.

“See there, burglar,” Ori said, throwing an arm over his shoulders, “there is the seat of dwarven power. Even now, she shines as a jewel.”

Thorin smiled, and Bilbo’s heart gave a little tripping step. Years fell away from his face when he smiled, and Bilbo could see the prince he had once been. 

“We will make camp here,” he said, “small fires. Do not attract undue attention.’

“We wait for gandalf?” Gloin asked.

“We wait as long as reason allows, and then we make the summit, with or without him.” The gold of Thorin’s smile retreated, revealing steel. “Durin’s day is almost upon us. It will not wait, nor should we.”

 

Bilbo made himself quite a nuisance (as was his wont) at dinnertime, supervising Bombur's attempt to turn road rations into a palatable meal.

“Damn the sorrel—haven’t you got any thyme? A stew like this needs an herby note, like a wisp of smoke threading through it.”

“Blast ye lad, have ye not learned from last night’s pottage? The salt pork needs a piquancy to cut through it, ere it turns into dog’s leavings.”

“All the boiling in the world couldn’t take the salt from it, it’s saltier than the entire sea. The trick is to use the salt as a jumping off point, I—” Bilbo got a thoughtful look on his face. “I think I saw some laurel branches a ways away, laurel smoke would be a welcome touch.”

“Go, and may your errand take all night,” Bombur grumbled.

Bilbo hurried off, hoping to snag some green branches or, heaven forbid, a dense knot that could be used over successive nights. Any change to the food was welcome. He was so far off the world he knew that he could not even forage for edible wild plants, something green to cut the beige and brown of their preserves. He pined for butter, soft cheese, and other Shire delicacies as he scrabbled as best he could in the half-dark.

“Mind how you go.”

Bilbo gave a start, hand covering his heart. “Do you really have to keep doing that?”

Thorin sat, pipe steaming, barely hiding his amusement. “For one who came recommended to us by stealth, you seem to have difficulty perceiving a man sitting quietly in his thoughts.”

“Well my mind’s not on sneaking at the moment, it's on foraging, so forgive me if I'm not given over to stealth.” His irritation at the surprise helped to override the nervousness at once again being left alone with the Dwarf leader. He turned to go before he could do something else to embarrass himself—

“No.”

Bilbo lowered his foot.

“Stay awhile. Sit with me.”

Bilbo looked at him, eyebrows raised. “...are you sure?”

Thorin gestured. “Am I noted for my stinging spines?”

No, it’s the venom from your barbed tongue I hoped to avoid , Bilbo thought, but he approached all the same, sitting gingerly at the edge of the rock. Thorin seemed to be in unusual good cheer, he puffed away on his pipe and blew wispy smoke-wyrms at the mountain.

“I wish that you could have seen Erebor in its heyday,” he said wistfully, “no dingy mine, a great hall threaded with light all the way through. Banners hung at every vault, gleaming—my forebears discovered the method to draw wire fine as thread, so we had cloth stitched through with precious metals. Gems set into every junction. Every form of stone the earth could bear, we had it. Great metalworks, mechanisms older than my grandfather that ran like new. And the people—if you could have seen our people.” Thorin’s voice clouded and his eyes shone as he looked at the mountain, drowning in the past, “a happier folk you could not find. Everyone had a purpose, every man had a place where he felt useful. Even the lowest furnace-stoker felt like a lord of his own life. We dwarves...we were free.”

Bilbo swallowed around a sudden lump in his throat. He imagined Thorin slaving away at a humble village forge, bending horseshoes for common folk who called him “short-arse” and paid him in copper. It felt like nothing he could ever say could make up for that. Bilbo had never known so great a loss as any of them. He’d lost his parents, one after the other, to be sure but he’d still had home, he’d still had Bag End—

Bilbo cleared his throat. Thorin looked at him, all traces of sorrow skillfully hidden.

“I-in my home, my Hobbit hole,” he begane lamely, “there is—oh it has to be right around the end of summer, there’s a time when the setting sun shines through, just lances through the whole house. All the walls and windows are lit up with this golden light, a light so thick you feel like you could slice it and butter bread with it. All my humble wallpapers and wainscotting and even the floor is pure gold. The air is exactly the right temperature, and you can smell the meadowsweet they’re mowing to put by for the winter. And you stand in it and feel at the center of the entire world—I've never experienced anything like it in all my time away from home. I feel...kingly,” he finished. He gulped and looked down. Ah, what a transparent attempt to make himself seem like less of a...Hobbit.

A laugh, dry and without malice, came from the dwarf.

“Afternoon sunlight?” Thorin peered down at him, his face open and warm. It wasn’t exactly a smile, but Bilbo took nourishment from the sight all the same. “I have felt like a pauper in many places, but to feel kingly in such a humble home…” he sighed. “I envy you. If more people valued home above gold, the world would be a merrier place.”

Bilbo looked at him in mild shock. “Really? You’re not going to mock me for my simple tastes?”

“I have no need to. Your people live as they want, they have learned to be content with a few fields and a milch cow or two. Barring an invading army—”

“What invading army? Who would invade the Shire, we’ve nothing to steal.”

Thorin smiled wryly. “Ah. And there it is. To live beneath notice, that is your lot.”

Bilbo felt unexpectedly irked by this, as if he was being patted on the head. “That means nothing to the measure of a man’s character. Just because I live simply does not mean I couldn’t use my power to vanish in mid-air.”

Thorin chuckled at him. “You have no such power.”

“I could do. You’d never know.”

Both men laughed, tension between them broken.

“If you have any reserves of the kind, you may want to bring them out tomorrow,” Thorin said more somberly. “The beast will use any advantage. He is cunning in his cruelty.”

Bilbo nodded, looking back up at the face of Erebor. In the dark, it looked like the maw of something far greater, older, hungrier than he.

“Tomorrow,” he echoed.

Notes:

I know I'm taking a bit to get to the actual meat of the story, but consider this: if it were the movie I would have had a 10-chapter preamble about how I went to get my writing snacks before sitting down, finding that I was out, driving to the store, finding they were out of ranch but they were fully stocked in the barbeque flavor I don't like as much, then dipping back to when I first had the idea for this fic while out on a walk and how I stepped in dog poop because I wasn't paying attention to where I was going—

Anyway, be glad this isn't the extended edition, is all I'm saying.

Chapter 3

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

They crawled like ants up a likeness of Thorin’s forebears. Bilbo had to keep squeezing his eyes shut and edging along the cliff wall, Kili's hand hooked into his belt loops to steady him. He threw himself on the ground when they came again to flat earth and kissed it.

Dwalin nudged him with a toe. “Up, lad. This is no time to be taking a nap.”

Now that he was at the threshold, Thorin paced like a caged beast. The wizard had failed to make their rendez-vous, and time was pressing in on them.

“The keyhole has to be here somewhere. Help me.” 

As one they patted, pressed, kicked the cliff wall, which remained unyielding. Bilbo hung back, mouthing words to himself as he studied the map. Thorin looked up from a kick to find the Hobbit standing alone. Contempt etched his face.

“Does our burglar think himself exempt from hard work?” he all but snarled.

Bilbo held up a finger. “There’s got to be something—there’s always a riddle or a trick door or—”

“I did not engage you for your pedantry, master burglar, so unless you intend to talk a hole in the mountain—”

Bilbo made an irritated noise. “There’s no keyhole, is there? This is Durin’s day and there’s the rock face before us, something must be wrong. Perhaps we misread it.”

“How very convenient.” Thorin’s eyes narrowed. “Finding the prospect of burgling too daunting?”

“What, no, I…” Bilbo tried a more reasonable tone. “I just think that we’re missing something here, maybe we should have waited a bit longer for Gandalf.”

“You are frightened. Here on the threshold, you cringe in fear. A life of soft beds has prepared you for nothing but idleness.”

Bilbo blinked rapidly. Damn him. It wouldn’t sting so badly if it hadn’t come so soon after he’d felt they’d connected somehow...even a little.

“I think,” he said, managing to keep his voice from quavering, “that if you lot used your heads more often, we would have been in by now.”

Thorin’s face darkened and he began walking at Bilbo, buffeted on either side by appeasing dwarves. Bilbo backed up, mindful of the cliffside.

“Lads.”

They all turned as one. Balin indicated the cliff face, now illuminated by the rays of the rising moon. The keyhole stared back at them.

 

“He speaks harshly, lad, but he’s been under strain for so long,” Balin walked Bilbo deeper into the mountain, putting a comforting hand on his shoulder. “He’s seen his family fight and fall for this place, he’s been living in exile, you understand?”

“Right,” Bilbo said flatly. “I’ll just go down and scout around, see if I can’t avoid being roasted alive.”

“You needn’t make it sound like that, lad. We’re not sending you down to your death.”

“No, just certain death.” Bilbo sighed. “If and when I find the arkenstone, I'll return. And then what?”

‘What do ye mean?”

“Is there a contingency plan? Have any of you studied up on how to kill a dragon?”

Balin gave him a look. 

“Did none of you expect to get this far?”

“Did you?”

Bilbo was speechless for a moment. ‘Right then. I’ll be back.”

“Mind how you go.”

Bilbo walked down into the belly of Erebor.

 

After a lifetime of thinking it a mere figure of speech, Bilbo looked upon mountains of treasure.  There really were no words that would have prepared him for the sight. Literal mountains. From peak to peak the gleam of gold, the sparkle of gems. Bilbo gave a rabbitlike twitch of his nose. He felt a strange, clutching ache and gripped the ring in his pocket. He wondered if what he felt was dragon-sickness, if such a thing could be caught like a passing sneeze. Bilbo tittered, clapping a hand to his mouth quickly. He felt giddy and off balance. The whole place was madness, the plan was mad, and he was halfway mad himself. 

Bilbo gingerly picked his way along, mindful that like any other range, these mountains could have avalanches. He picked up every vaguely white or even clear gem he could lay eyes on, grumbling a bit to himself. You’ll know it when you see it. What kind of an instruction was that? Surely a gem was like any other bit of rock—

... oh.

There, on a shining hillside, was a gleam like fevered moonlight. Bilbo knew in his waters this had to be it: the symbol of dwarven kinghood. Part of him, a boyish hope he could not banish, part of him imagined Thorin’s smile upon its return. Perhaps he would get another embrace.

In his shameful excitement, his eagerness, Bilbo forgot stealth. He took great, sledging steps up to the gem, unmindful of how the coins slithered and clacked against one another. It was a struggle up the side of the hill, but then the Arkenstone was in his hands, coins pouring down the hillside but who cared, he held the fabled Arkenstone and all would be right in the world once again, the coins draining in a river around his feet until he could see a red mound above him split in half by a seam and there he stood out in the open clenching a gem like an idiot.

With horrible quickness, the dragon’s eye opened.

Bilbo’s heart caught in his chest, the Arkenstone clattering from his numb hands. He yelped, chasing it down the hillside as it churned and dissolved into a storm of gold. Coins pelted him and threatened to bury him. The Arkenstone disappeared into its churning maw. Bilbo whimpered and ran on, dodging around pillars until he could find a safe place to don his ring. Now there was the strange underwater feeling he had every time he donned the plain gold band, but also...some kind of a pull . As if he were in a large tub, circling the drain.

Most terrible of all, the pull was to the one thing he wanted to avoid at all costs.

There was an inhale of breath, like smoke being sucked up a flue. Bilbo did not dare look, but he could just feel the presence of something so vast above him. 

“Well, thief?” the deep growl of a voice echoed through the various chambers like tame thunder. Bilbo had to clench his knees, lest he collapse. “I smell you…” a suck of air made Bilbo's curls dance. “I hear your breath…” Bilbo clapped a hand on his mouth. “I feel your air…” 

The shadow of a massive head lurched into sight. The Hobbit tensed everything. 

“...Where are you? Step into the light.”

Bilbo’s knees buckled, wanting to obey on instinct. He hugged himself, trying not to panic. There was something in the dragon’s voice, something that commanded and demanded. Did dragons have such magic?

“Don’t be shy. Introduce yourself. Are you man or Dwarf?” Great nostrils expanded, taking in air. “Neither. Such a strange scent. You may live yet, for the curiosity you bring to me. Come, tell me your name.”

Threatening, yet inviting. Bilbo knew deep in his bones that the second he revealed himself that would be it, he would be roasted to ashes, yet some part of him whispered to be seen; some perverse desire to be known by such a creature. 

Smaug lashed out with his tongue, nearly whipping Bilbo on the side of his head. “I suppose it matters not, a corpse answers just as well to one name as another.” He was tasting the air, Bilbo realized in horror, as a snake did. “There is something gold about you. Something... precioussss .”

Bilbo was struck like a bell, his body quavered and vibrated in place. Suddenly the ring was off, and he was visible once more. The dragon beheld him, knife-slit pupils expanding. Bilbo’s breath caught in his chest.

“There you are...thief.”

Bilbo held his hands up. “Greetings, oh...oh Smaug.” he piped thinly. “Chiefest and greatest of...calam—calamities. Earth-scorcher. Kingdom-ender. I bid you hello.”

The great eye blinked, a second translucent membrane slithering over just as the eyelid shut. It stupefied Bilbo into silence for another brutal moment before he remembered himself.

‘I am a...a traveler. A humble pilgrim. I have no wish to steal from you, Smaug, great beast under the mountain. I only wanted to gaze upon your magnificence, and what the old tales say is true.”

Smaug hissed, folding back on himself liquidly. “You have the stink of Dwarf upon you.”

“Dwarf?” Bilbo blinked rapidly. “Oh...oh yes, Dwarf. They afforded me passage, erm, partway. Miserable buggars. Took my last ten coins as a fee and didn’t even make the summit with me.” He laughed hollowly.

The dragon scrutinized him; it was not unlike being under the rays of a magnifying glass. “You...are a poor liar.”

Bilbo tittered, very close to sobbing. “I-I am, as you can see. I am trustworthy for that reason, I think.” His last word ended on a yelp, as Smaug maneuvered his massive head to where the Hobbit stood. Terror pinned him in place as a face the size of a ship pressed into him. He could feel the heat of fire pouring from every orifice in the dragons face.

“Liar. You come to steal treasure. That is all any who travel here come to do.”

“That’s not true,” Bilbo said in a dry whisper. And then, out of pure instinct, he put his hands to the dragon. He could see the massive nostrils flare, the cunning eyes narrow. He found a place halfway between snout and eyeball, and began to itch it.

Smaug tensed at first, glaring fiercely. Bilbo thought at any moment he might rear back and let loose the great spear of fire.

Slowly, the thin membranous lid began to descend once more as Smaug’s eyes rolled upwards.

He was enjoying it , Bilbo realized.

“Oh Smaug the magnificent,” he said in what he hoped was a reverent tone, “I would never come here to harm you. How could I? You are truly greater and stronger than any weapon I could hope to carry. I am small and weak and...not very athletic.”

Smaug blinked, eyes rolling back to the fore. “How very true. You wouldn’t even make a morsel for me.”

“Y-yes, you see? I am but a humble traveler, burdened by my own curiosity.”

“And the Arkenstone?”

Bilbo furrowed his brow in an attempt at innocence. “The...what ark?”

“The stone in your hands. I saw it as I woke. Do not play games with me, I am in ill mood.”

Bilbo licked his lips. “....I saw a gleam like starlight, I thought it to be a trace of you. I-it was quite lovely. I’m sorry for touching it w-without your permission.”

Smaug turned so that now his nostrils were looking straight at him. Any minute now , Bilbo thought, two white-hot jets of flame and I'll be cinders. There won’t even be enough of me to bury.

“You have nice manners...for a thief and a liar.”

“I am no thief,” Bilbo begged, “I only wished to lay eyes on you for once in my piddling little life, I-I thought it sounded exciting, like an adventure.”

Smaug chuckled. “Oh dear. An adventure . And what is your name, bold adventurer?”

“Bilbo,” he replied without thinking, clapping a hand to his mouth too late.

“Bilbo? What an amusing name. It suggests something round...and soft.”

Bilbo frowned. Ah, something the dragon and dwarves had in common. “I am...Bilbo Baggins of the Shire.” The words spilled half-willingly from his mouth. 

“The Shire? What kingdom is that? A kingdom of dumplings?” Smaug wrinkled his snout in cruel amusement.

“No, no, no kingdom. It’s a hamlet. No king just...just us. We barely have a postal service…” Bilbo trailed off, suddenly realizing how little he had settled for at home.

The dragon blinked. “...really.”

“Yes. It’s f-farmers and fishermen and bakers and it’s...it’s dull as brown bread. It's dull as wash-water after you’ve finished the dishes. Being there is like being buried alive, slowly.'' He didn’t mean to confess this much, but he was about to die, wasn’t he? And here was someone who would listen, if only in mockery. “So you see, even if...even if I die here, even if you kill me, it will still be better than never having gone.” he cleared his throat. “So if you must...dispose of me, I consider it an honor.”

Smaug brought his head close once again, that hellish pupil cast over him. Bilbo swallowed and bowed his head, squeezing his eyes shut. 

“...well, we can’t have that, can we?”

Bilbo’s eyes opened.

Smaug regarded him through one crafty eye. “You’ve adventured so long, clearly, you must be tired. Be my guest. Stay awhile.”

“N-no, I can’t,” Bilbo stammered, “I'm expected back.”

Smaug’s pupil’s shrank.

“I-I mean, down at Lake-town, I left my things at the inn. They’ll probably have sold them, the sneaky bast—”

“Let them be sold then, for they can have no greater value than my company,” Smaug hissed, “unless of course, you have someone else waiting for you?”

Fear trickled down Bilbo's spine. “Erm, no. no no, I suppose it’s a silly thing, possessions, I mean, do we really own anything in the grand scheme of things—”

“You weary me, Bilbo Baggins of the dull Shire. I’m in no mood to be bored.” Smaug settled himself, winding like a red river among the piles of treasure. “Come, tell me of your little hamlet. Do a little of that business with your hands. Make use of yourself.”

Acting as if driven by its own intellect, the dragon's tail whipped forward and caught up Bilbo. He found himself propelled to the dragon's face. After splatting like a midge (which the dragon found most amusing) Bilbo picked himself up with what dignity he could muster. He searched by touch until he found a likely spot, and resumed his ministrations. He was rewarded with a deep rumble, not quite a growl or purr, that rattled the plates of the dragon's scales and made his hands tingle.

“In the Shire,” he began, “I live in a Hobbit-hole. It’s nothing like this. It’s a lovely, cosy house with windows and light and it stays cool in the summer and warm in the winter—”

He spoke about the Shire. He spoke about Hobbiton and the Brandywine river. He spoke of the forests and hills. He spoke of butterflies and bees, of cows and sheep and the fat brown hens that laid rich-yolked eggs. He spoke of haying, of dairy, of brewing. What had once been his own closed off little universe spilled out into the air, until he looked up and realized it was quite late. Thin grey light streamed through openings in the upper level. He had talked until daylight. He was hoarse and his eyes burned when he remembered to blink.

Smaug’s eyes opened. “Continue.”

“I can’t. I’ve been on the road all day, I'm foot-weary and parched as a pigeon.” Bilbo realized he’d been leaning on the dragon and stood upright in horror. “I must be getting on, I've taken so much of your time already.” He fought off a yawn.

“But you have not yet scratched the surface of my hospitality.” One clawed hand at the end of a wing swept down, Bilbo found himself tumbled backwards into it. 

“I-I must insist,” he squeaked, “I've got a bed waiting for me at the inn, and if I'm not there in time they’ll give it away!”

He was brought up to the dragon’s chest, as tall and solid as a city wall. He put his palms out to arrest his flight...and found the surface quite warm. Like a cooking stove long after the fire burned down.

“Nonsense. The trek to that haven of fleas is too far in your condition.”

“Please, I'm really not that ti—” a yawn cut through his sentence. The dragon’s hand was actually much nicer than the stone he’d been sleeping on the night before, and he was warmer here than he’d been the whole of his journey. He grew unsteady on his feet.

“Here now, rest with me.” Smaug gave a sadistic chuckle. “Unless of course...you have other reasons for showing yourself out?”

“No,” Bilbo said quickly, giving as real of a smile as he could manage. “I just...hate to impose upon you any more, oh Smaug the mighty.”

“Oh it’s no bother.” Smaug returned the smile, showing row after row of teeth.

“Y-yes, well.” Bilbo licked his lips. “Good night.”

He made a show of laying down, and found himself pressed against the dragon’s side. He had planned to wait for Smaug to drift off and then escape but he found himself cocooned in warmth and quite comfortable for the first time in a long time and the dragon’s chest buzzed with that noise that was almost a purr but something deeper still and Bilbo felt it relax his whole body…

 

Thorin stood from where he’d been sharpening his sword. He paced for a bit, and then took up a tinder box. After failing to make a few sparks, he paced again. Then he stood brooding at the edge of the cliffside. Then he paced.

‘I’m sure he’ll be back,” Balin said.

Thorin looked at him. Balin raised his eyebrows.

“The fool’s probably stubbed his toe and fallen into the depths,” Thorin muttered.

“Our Bilbo?” Bofur shook his head. “No, no, the poor lad’s just probably caught up looking for the Arkenstone. He swore to return it to you, dinna he?”

“Or he’s caught some dragon fire.”

“Oh yes,” Bofur said cheerfully, “that as well.”

“Enough of this!” Thorin stalked to their tiny campfire. “He should have been back by now, something’s gone wrong. He’s made a mistake.”

“We could go in after him,” Kili said, lilting upwards on the last syllable.

“And then what? Risk capture as with the mountain trolls? Or the wretched goblin horde? I will not risk this quest for the life of one burglar!” Thorin kicked the embers with his foot. The others jerked back at the sudden affront.

“Bilbo. His name is Bilbo,” Balin snapped, “and I can see you’re as worried for the wee laddie as we are—”

“I worry for the future of dwarves,” Thorin said, “I worry about the monster that usurped our home—”

“—we’re all quite fond of him too,” Balin spoke over him, stunning him into silence, “it might be good to take a wee peek. Just to see whether he’s alive or nae. Take a few men and see.”

“I will not.” Thorin cast a sullen glance around the camp. “...I will risk none of you. I will go myself.” His nephews rose in protest. “I cannot ask you to chance your lives in service of such a small task. Stay. I will return.”

Dwalin passed him his sword. “If he’s alive, give the little ankle-biter a pranging from all of us.”

Thorin gave him a slight upturn of his eyes, the closest he could get to a smile right now. He turned and entered the hall, holding his breath.

 

To enter Erebor so long after life had fled it was eerie. Here were the halls he had run through as a child, now empty and dark. Never, not in all his days of travel through the lands of men, had he felt so unwelcome. Hopes that Bilbo had gotten stuck cowering at the end of the hall proved false, and so he went deeper. Now here was the wealth of Erebor, piled without care in a great heap on the floor, a wallowing-pit for a scaled pig. Thorin descended silently as he could, hand on his sword’s pommel. He could see the great red mound of the dragon’s body, draped lazily around stolen treasure. Thorin crept forward, teeth gritted. If he could cut through the beast’s hide with a mere sword, he would behead the thing now and be done with it. The hateful sight of it—

Thorin took a step back. It had Bilbo. It had Bilbo in its clutches. Heart hammering, he drew his sword, making a few uncertain motions with it. He had no idea what to do. The Hobbit did not seem injured from this distance, he could see his chest rise and fall. But there he was, clutched like a stuffed toy, to his people’s greatest enemy. 

“ Bilb— ” he stopped himself. The beast’s nostrils pulsated with breath. He could not wake the Hobbit without waking the dragon. He needed a plan. He needed help.

As one, the company stood outside the doorway, faces etched with worry.

“Thorin?”

Thorin stumbled out into the night air. “The dragon's got Bilbo. He’s in danger. We have to rescue him.”

Notes:

I choose to charitably interpret Thorin blowing hot/cold at Bilbo not just as a simple error in writing *coughreshootscough* but as his uncertainty about his feelings. I get the impression of him as a character who has had to suppress his emotions, his wants&needs in service of his people, and has had a lifetime of feeling not good enough to rule. The moments where he does break you can sense the strain of not being able to show any vulnerability, and I really wish they'd given Richard Armitage more moments like that because the man just...kills it. (Why did he have to be set on brood 90% of the time?) Bilbo is the anchor that keeps him in touch with a softer part of himself, moreso than perhaps any other dwarf in the company, because Bilbo does not know him as a fallen king. He's only ever known the man.
That is really the more intriguing link he has to Smaug, not the "grr, we both haz dragon sickness, we're taking our ball and leaving" but the fact that showing vulnerability terrifies the both of them. You can actually hear Smaug's voice break when he mentions black arrows, probably because that was the first time he might have had to confront the fact he could die. And that's just it: vulnerability spells death to both of them. Death of his loved ones for Thorin, and death of the self for Smaug. I really wish this could have been teased out more subtly in the movies, rather than using wacky filler chase sequence #357

Chapter 4

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Bilbo woke slowly. His body seemed reluctant to let go of sleep, especially since it was the best rest he’d gotten in so long. He was perfectly warm and snug and content to remain that way for a while longer. 

“Little thief, it’s time to wake.”

Bilbo sat bolt upright, heart hammering. Yes. Treasure, Erebor, dragon. He’d quite forgot.

“Oh, erm, is that the time?” he laughed nervously.

“How feel you?’ Smaug’s maneating grin loomed large. “Refreshed?”

“Oh, yes, yes, quite well rested, thank you, I think I should be getting on now.” Bilbo rubbed his hands together. 

“What’s your rush? Meeting someone?”

Bilbo swallowed. “N-no, I'm… I just need to be getting on with breakfast, is all. I haven’t eaten since yesterday.”

“Ah yes. I believe I have something for you around here.”

To Bilbo’s horror the dragon turned and began rooting behind him, coming back up with a haunch of mutton still bearing fur. He dropped it on a stone walkway and jetted one thin plume of fire at it. Bilbo felt his desperate grin freeze to his cheeks.

“Ah yes...thank you.”

The dragon looked on in amusement as Bilbo made a great effort to carve meat from the haunch. Of course a single blast of flame wasn’t enough to cook it properly, but he could cut away parts of it that were neither burnt nor raw. The dragon settled into himself like a cat, watching Bilbo eat.

“You’ll be very pleased to know I've decided what to do with you.”

Bilbo swallowed his mouthful, sweating. “...and what are you going to do?”

“I’ve decided to keep you. I certainly can’t have you leaving and telling the world about me. I find you amusing enough to keep you alive at the moment.”

Bilbo choked a little on his food. “You mean a-a pet?”

“A pet?” Smaug’s pupils bloomed. “How terribly droll. Yes, a little pet. I’ll keep you, feed you, let you live so long as you entertain me. Does that sound agreeable?”

Bilbo licked his lips, his mind a blank panic. “Well, it certainly beats the alternative, yes, but—”

“You don’t want to go back to the Shire do you? Back to that dull little town with those dull little people?”

“...I supposed not,” Bilbo said slowly.

“And you don’t want to return to your dwarves?”

Bilbo’s heart skipped a beat.

“Th-those dwarves? I think they’ve pressed on to the Iron Hills by now,” he said breezily.

Smaug’s murderous grin did not shrink. “Well then, I think it’s settled. I’ve fed you, rested you. Is there anything else you need, my little?”

Bilbo blew air out his mouth, thinking. It was a very odd feeling, being a dragon’s guest.

“Oh well, ah, I don’t suppose there’s much chance of a hot bath.” he laughed nervously.

“Of course.”

“...really?”

“I would be a poor host if I could not provide. Here—” he swept Bilbo up on the end of his tail. Bilbo clung for dear life between spikes as the dragon crawled like a salamander through caverns until coming to rest at a half-destroyed building. The stonework buckled and cracked under his weight, a decorative carving fell into the depths beside them. Bilbo never heard it hit the bottom. 

There was a great marble basin, many times the size of a room in his own Hobbit-house, empty of water. Bilbo slithered down from Smaug’s tail and under his watchful eye began poking and prodding around. He found a lever that, when pulled, opened a floodgate and sent water gushing to fill the pool. 

“Ah, yes, that’s absolutely lovely,” he said, “shame it isn’t hot—”

Smaug fired a burst of flame, making the water sizzle. Bilbo jumped back.

“Well...I'll just let that fill a bit more, then. Wait for the temperatures to optimize.”

On the far side of the building was a stone rack. Bilbo went to unfasten his tunic, and then turned and caught Smaug’s gaze.

“Um, do you mind?” he asked.

“Not at all.”

“No, what I mean is: I'd like to be alone for this.”

“Now why would you want that? If I left you alone you might get into trouble, little one.” Smaug’s tone drooled with sarcasm. “We wouldn’t want that would we?”

Bilbo sighed, turning away from him to undress. “No, we certainly wouldn’t.” He grazed the ring in his pocket, ever-mindful of the dragon’s gaze

He took up his precious sliver of soap and tested the water with his toe before shutting it off. He waded out until he could submerge his body, which he did.

Bilbo made a noise halfway between a moan and a sigh. “Perfect.”

“You find it pleasing?”

“I have missed such things in my time on the road.” Bilbo kicked off, floating. He laughed. “What I would have done for such a large tub back home.”

“All the better to cleanse that stench from you.”

“Yes, yes, I’m working on that.”

Out of nowhere, Smaug aimed a blast of flame at the stone rack, incinerating his clothes. Bilbo struggled back to the shallow end of the pool.

“My clothes! My Shire coat, my vest, my—” he hurriedly sifted through the embers, sighing in relief when he felt the solid gold band. It was eerily cool despite the dragon fire.

He turned to Smaug, who gave a look of diabolical innocence.

“They smelled of Dwarf,” he said.

“Yes, well, I could have washed them.” Bilbo held himself as he stood there, dripping. “What am I going to wear now?’

“Have no fear. Here.”

On one hooked claw, Smaug brought forth a purple robe shot through with gold thread. Bilbo felt it, frowning. 

“It’s so thin, though. I had layers and layers of clothes.”

“You should be warm enough, I think, when I'm around.” Smaug settled again, looking down at Bilbo. Bilbo knew exactly what was expected, and steeled himself.

“Thank you, oh Smaug, for the lovely...raiment. It’s quite grand.”

Defeated, Bilbo waded back into the water, where he scrubbed until the soap was gone to nothing. Smaug watched his ablutions with amusement. Bilbo put on the robe without drying himself (there was nothing to dry himself with ) and found it fit loosely. Once in place, the fabric felt slinky and not at all disagreeable. Were he not in a chilly cavern, he might enjoy wearing such a garment. As it was, though, the metal thread stitched through only served to pull in the cold more efficiently. He discreetly slipped the ring onto an inner tie. It stirred against his bare skin, sending a feeling like a finger rubbing on a wet wineglass up and down his spine. A feeling that was not pleasant...but at the same time not unpleasant.

The dragon spoke and Bilbo realized suddenly that it gave him a similar feeling.

“Now that we’ve bid farewell  to the last traces of dwarvish scum, tell me about that thing you carry and keep hidden.” Smaug held out a clawed finger that Bilbo cautiously alighted on.

Bilbo gulped, unconsciously moving to place a hand over it. “It is...a keepsake. From a loved one. It’s not even solid gold, it’s gold-plated. You wouldn’t be interested.”

Smaug displayed his teeth. “Indeed? Yet it calls out. I can feel it.”

“Y-yet compared to your vast treasure, I shouldn't think that...”  Bilbo couldn’t think of anything that would stay his curiosity.

Smaug chuckled. His longue lashed out, winding up and down the front of Bilbo’s robe. “You would keep it from me, wouldn’t you? As you’ve kept it from your traveling companions.”

Bilbo said nothing.

“Then you understand.” Smaug narrowed his eyes slyly. “This is my treasure, little one. My mountain. I will not part with a single coin of it, not even for that pathetic scion Oakenshield.”

This was the first time he’d said the name aloud. Bilbo struggled to keep his face neutral as his heart hammered.

“Oaken...?” he made a clueless face. “I trust your instincts my lord, but I assure you, I hold no such desire in my heart. What’s mine is mine and what’s yours is yours.”

Smaug’s grin widened. “Spoken like a dragon.”

Bilbo jumped at the opportunity to change the subject. “Yes, please, tell me about your kind. I’m dying to know.”

Smaug’s demeanor changed immediately. Bilbo yelped as he found himself dangling a leg-breaking height from the treasure horde from one of Smaug’s claws.

“Well well well, scouting for weaknesses, are we?” Smoke wisped from the dragon’s maw. 

“No no,” Bilbo shouted, desperately gripping a scale. “I only wish to know more about your magnificent kind. The legends tell us nearly nothing!”

He dangled for another moment that felt like an eternity before he slipped, falling with a gasp to be caught on the beast’s sinewy tail.

“And what, pray tell, do your legends say?”

“O-only that you are fierce beasts, invulnerable to harm.” Bilbo clung to the scaly surface with his whole body, willing his heart to slow down. “I want to know…” he racked his brain. “Do you...do you mate in single pairs, or do you nest in colonies like sea birds?”

Smaug’s look lost some fierceness.

“Do you hatch multiple eggs or only one at a time? Do dragon mothers remain with their chicks? Do dragon fathers? Please tell me, I long to learn more.” Bilbo made what he hoped was a reverent face.

Smaug was still for a very long moment. Bilbo worried he had gone too far.

“I do not recall my mother. Or my father. Dragons are hatched capable of fending for themselves, for that is our lot. I was one of seven hatchlings: the nest bore four females, and two males beside myself.” As he spoke his tail sank into itself to form a coil, with Bilbo sat breathing a sigh of relief in the center.

“Oh how lovely,” Bilbo gained the polite tone he used whenever discussing family. “And do they have their own hordes as you do?”

“I ate them.” Smaug’s grin could have swallowed a city. Bilbo felt a cold sweat of fear as he struggled to keep his face from falling to terror.

“Oh, that’s…” he cleared his throat. “I-I myself have heard, sometimes, that a sibling’s quarrell—”

“I ate them to gain strength. The dragon’s first meal is always the lesser hatchlings. I was the first, and so I gorged myself while they were still wet with yolk. It gave me the strength to fly and I left the nest. Tell me, are your people born so armed?”

Bilbo licked his lips. “No. We are born pink and mewling and, well, helpless.”

“And remain so.” Smaug’s answer echoed through the cavern.

Bilbo willed himself to stop shaking. “We are fed on milk, until we develop teeth. It takes around a year for us to gain enough strength to walk. Our teeth come in one at a time, until then we can only eat mush. Takes years for a child to reach the age where he can fend for himself. I suppose that seems terribly funny to you.”

“Indeed.” 

Bilbo paused. “What about mating?” he blushed at the look Smaug gave him. “Does your kind have a courtship? Do you have seasons where you seek after each other’s company? Do you take one partner or many over your life?”

Once again, Smaug turned a gaze like lamplight to him. He took a long time to answer.

“I have not seen another of my kind for centuries. I have never taken a mate, nor have I raised young. I am alone.”

Bilbo felt...strange at that.

“Well, in a way...you could say we are kindred beasts,” he said. “I am alone as well, at Bag End. I haven’t taken a wife, I have no little ones running around. Always seemed like too much of a bother, really. But now that I say that...it wears on you, doesn’t it? Being alone.”

Smaug did not answer.

“You can enjoy your own company as much as you want, but by the end of the day it drives you a little bit mad. You start jumping at shadows, suspecting everyone that walks past your door.”

Smaug blinked heavily. “You make a wearisome point, little one. Talk of my kind bores me.”

Bores you? Bothers you, more like , Bilbo thought. Out loud he said, “what would you have me talk about, then?” 

“Tell me more of your legends. I find them amusing.”

Bilbo gladly talked of giants (dreadful bores, apparently) trolls (gamey and unpleasant) and were-worms (gelatinous and tasted of sick). He was wilting on his feet, tottering from side to side, when Smaug hooked a claw beneath his robe and lifted him.

“You need refreshment. Here, you can sup once more from your morsel.”

“A-actually,” Bilbo said, ‘would it be too much trouble to bring me something else?”

He cringed as the lamplight gaze of the dragon focused on him.

“I only ask because, well...being so soft, my stomach is sensitive. That meat is turning, and I'd hate to get sick on any of your lovely treasure.”

The dragon reared back.

This was it, he’d pushed too far and Smaug would simply eat him now.

“How amusing. And what do you suggest, little one?”

Bilbo racked his brain for an option that wouldn’t send him after farmland. “Erm, how about a nice joint of...venison? Or wild boar, I won’t trouble you too much on options. Just so long as it’s fresh.”

Smaug stared down at him for a long time without speaking. At any moment Bilbo expected him to break out in laughter or shoot fire. 

Finally he said, “I would hate for you to come to harm while I'm gone, my little. So I shall put you out of harm’s way.”

Bilbo felt the world around him retreat as he was taken up, squeaking in protest. Smaug dangled him above a thin, smooth pillar and let him drop the last few feet. The air huffed out of bilbo as he caught himself on his hands and knees, thankfully avoiding a broken ankle. He peeked a bit over the side and quickly backed away from the sheer drop. He scooted to sit dead center, hugging his knees. Smaug watched this play out with a smirk.

“Mind you do not fall. I have no healing tools here and would be forced to alleviate your suffering, ah...another way.”

Bilbo nodded jerkily. “Right, right, understood. I bless you and thank you oh Smaug the uh, erm, thoughtful.”

Smaug flowed like a red river through and out the treasure hold. Bilbo remained in place, grasping his knees, whimpering. Oh what a fine mess this was. Even supposing he managed to get down without breaking something (he wouldn’t) he had lost all bearing on where the Arkenstone lay in the treasure. And suppose Smaug returned early and found him gone? He thought of the gush of fire overtaking him, turning the metal threads of his robe white-hot—

Bilbo screwed his eyes shut and pressed his face to his knees. His vertigo made it seem like the pillar swayed in the wind, though he knew it to be solid. 

“...ilbo? Bilbo!”

Bilbo peered over the side, holding his breath. There were the dwarves, led by Thorin, dashing along one of the stone bridges that criss-crossed the long drop of the cavern. He lay on his belly so his head showed while the rest of him lay securely back.

“Here!” he hissed.

Thorin saw him first, stopping short his run.

“Bilbo, lad, you worried us! What’re you doing up there?” Bofur squinted.

“You have to leave, right away,” Bilbo said. “He’s coming back. I don’t know how long he’ll be.”

“The Arkenstone,” Thorin pressed. 

Bilbo felt a little hitch in his chest. Oh I'm fine too, thank you very much. “I...he’s hidden it. I think he knows I'm after it. He hasn’t killed me yet, but I don’t know how long that will last. He left to find food for us. You all need to get out of here before he comes back.” 

“Not without you, lad.”

“We can construct a ladder!”

“Raid the armory!”

Bilbo shook his head, pushing out with his hands as if physically shoving their suggestions down. “And how do you kill a dragon, then? Do you know of any weaknesses?”

The dwarves fell silent. 

“This is what I mean. You had an-an-an army last time, and still could not fell him. I will not allow you to get yourselves killed. Not for me.” He swallowed around a lump in his throat. “I will find the Arkenstone. I will bring it to you. But you have to have faith in me, and trust me when I say you need to wait.”

Thorin looked up at him; that ever-piercing, ever-inscrutable gaze that lanced through him. If Smaug’s gaze burned with the fire inside him, then the dwarf’s gaze was the ice of his eyes.

“Do as he says,” he muttered.

The other dwarves protested. 

“The dragon takes sick pleasure in suffering, he would hunt us down the second he knew we were here. Our burglar serves to distract him, let us use the time constructively instead of wallowing in despair.”

Bilbo pressed his lips together.

Reluctantly, with backward glances, the dwarves wound their way back up the bridge. Thorin was the last to go, still gazing up at Bilbo with that distant stare.

“Master Baggins,” he said finally, turning to follow the others.

Bilbo waited until silence fell in the cavern before he rolled over to lay on his back. The sound he produced behind the hand clamped to his mouth was too small to be called crying, but still it echoed in the cavern.

Notes:

Just to get this out of the way: no there will not be any freaky dragon sex. Sorry to dissapoint some of you, but that is not the direction I was intending on taking with this.

Chapter 5

Notes:

TW: child skeleton

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

Smaug returned with his hurricane wingbeat, flurrying gold coins as if they were snowflakes. He had an elk stag dangling from one leg in his mouth like a cat with a field mouse.

He dropped it before the stone pillar with a splat. “I’ve returned, my little. See what a treat I bring for you?”

‘Thank you, o Smaug the generous,” Bilbo said listlessly. He sat curled into himself in the exact middle of the pillar.

Smaug paused, his nostrils dilating. Bilbo’s heart hammered.

“I-I was wondering,” he said, his voice breaking, “if I could...poke about a bit? You know, find a kitchen anywhere. The meat you bring me is indeed...fresh, but we Hobbits like our spices. The Dwarf palate may be a touch unsophisticated but I'm sure they at least have salt.’

Smaug angled his head, eyeing Bilbo. 

“Salt?” he said.

“Salt. Pepper. Any kitchen has those.”

“I wouldn’t know.”

Bilbo had a sudden epiphany.

“Tell you what,” he said, standing, “I could roast this whole thing for you, you know, cook it over slow fire with a bit of seasoning. I bet you’ve never had that.”

Silence fell. For a moment he wondered if his gambit hadn’t failed, the dragon surely saw through him. 

But Smaug then huffed a laugh.

“Such a little mind, with such little ideas. Seasoned meat? Well you go on then, Bilbo of the silver tongue.” 

He was nicked up at the scruff by an enormous claw, this time set to rest upon a shoulder joint. He got a distinct bird’s-eye view of Erebor as Smaug scaled the walls vertically, until he slammed his eyes shut and clenched his whole body. It was only when they came to rest that he dared open them again.

There was a vast kitchen built to serve the entire hall, a square block with the corners cut away. It was a marvel to him how dissimilar Erebor was to other cities, more like a gigantic burrow with various rooms and sub-rooms without a single solid wall between them. More evidence of the dwarves being so supremely used to their own company. He realized how different they really were, dwarves and Hobbits, for they could be packed cheek to jowl in their hamlet but at the end of the day each Hobbit resided in their own little burrow.

Bilbo trotted to the drawers where the utensils inevitably lay and kicked something with his foot, it was only when it was sent skittering that he realized it was a skull, it was a skull and it was smaller than his own, he musn’t scream, he musn’t—

Bilbo closed his eyes and took a deep breath, crossing the rest of the kitchen blindly. He fumbled and felt for the drawers, opening it so that the next thing he saw was a clean, orderly procession of knives and forks and spoons along with more esoteric cutlery. He busied himself skinning the beast, trying not to think of Smaug doing the same to his prey. Now he was left with a bloody carcass quite a bit bigger than him, and a spit that could have served him as a lance. Smaug assisted him in lacing the stag onto the spit and lighting the cooking fuel (strange brown lumps he’d found, hopefully peat.)

In jars hewn of stone Bilbo found salt and fossilized peppercorns, along with herbs that had disintegrated into dust. He busied himself rubbing salt into the elk’s flesh, keeping his vision focused on a small square of space at a time. If he kept his mind on a little bit at a time, he could avoid bubbling over into hysteria.

Smaug rested on his haunches, watching Bilbo with amusement.

“Slow fire? You little folk do invent the most droll idioms. All fire eats at the same speed. You’ve just contented yourselves with using only a pittance of its full power.”

“Well I'm not trying to destroy the meat, am I? I’m trying to cook it through.” Bilbo felt a wave of relief as the elk began to sizzle. “Here, have a whiff of that, will you? That’s not disagreeable, is it?”

Smaug’s nostrils flexed. “It is not,” he allowed.

“There, you see? And it only gets better as it goes.” Bilbo set the great clockwork mechanism into motion, and the stag began turning itself. The gamey musk of wild venison was worlds better than the smell of scorched hair from yesterday’s meal.

Smaug watched him work, firelight catching his eyes and making them gleam in the dark.

“And what of your visitors, little Hobbit?”

Bilbo nearly dropped the spoon he was holding. “Visitors? N-no, great Smaug, I’ve been—”

“Don’t lie to me, my little. It’s pathetic. I can hear it in your speech.” Smaug inhaled, making Bilbo’s robe ripple toward him. “Smell it, even. You truly are the world’s most abysmal liar.”

Bilbo swallowed, steeling himself.

“Yes,” he said slowly, feeling the ant-creep up his spine that the dragon’s speech awoke in him. “Yes, they...they came to see me. The ones that abandoned me. They asked me to accompany them to the Iron Hills. They wanted to take of your wealth, great Smaug, but I told them you would miss the lack of one gold thimble, and you would catch up to them long before they managed to spend it. I sent them away.”

Smaug chuckled. “And Oakenshield?”

Bilbo’s pulse jumped. “One of them might have been so named. They’re so thuddingly dull with their names, aren’t they? Gladhelm and Ironskull and Rock-biter, terribly silly business.”

“So you say you do not know Oakenshield then?” Smaug’s voice was dangerous. Bilbo made the mistake of turning around. The dragon had crept forward until his head invaded the little space, the eye with that devilish pupil turned full force on him.

Bilbo made himself very still.

“No,” he lied.

“Then why does your heart tremble at the mention of his name?”

All the saliva in Bilbo’s mouth dried, and he could not form words in response. He had known, he had always known.

Smaug chuckled, pressing one scimitar-claw forward to twiddle the front of Bilbo’s robe. “Do not worry, little one. I had guessed the purpose of your visit ages ago. The coward Oakenshield would not face me head-on, none of them will.”

“That’s not true,” Bilbo burst out, flinching back immediately.

His outburst did not anger Smaug, instead it fed his amusement.

“And he sent you in here to..what? Even if he stole the Arkenstone, wielding it would not bring him victory. He could lead a thousand armies, he will never overthrow me. I am king under the mountain now. He is but a cowardly, avaricious Dwarf.”

Bilbo blinked rapidly. “That’s not true,” he whispered, more to himself.

Smaug laughed. “What did he promise you? A share of the treasure? As if it were his to give. You are being used, my little. You were only ever a means to an end.”

A sick feeling stole over Bilbo. “No.”

“The coward Oakenshield has weighed the value of your life and found it worth nothing—”

“No, no, no,” Bilbo screwed his eyes shut and shook his head, pressing hands to his temples. The dragon’s word wound inside him, coming to rest like a brand. “That’s not true, you’re lying!”

“I have no need for lies when the truth is so much more devastating. Tell me the truth now, if you dare, did you truly enjoy your quest here?”

Bilbo sucked in a breath, tears pricking his eyes. “...no. It’s been horrible. I’ve been chased by any manner of monsters and attacked and-and-and sat on, I've slept on rocks and gotten grit in every meal I've had, and all I've gotten for it is looks of contempt for how soft I am, and now I'm facing down the most fearsome beast I've ever seen in my life.” It was like lancing a wound, spurt after spurt of foulness drained from him. “I’m a Hobbit. I’m made for living simply. They-they came into my house without asking and ate my larder bare and bullied me into this.” He started to sob, couldn’t help himself. “I’m going to die and I don’t even really know why, it’s not fair.” He sank down, mopping his eyes with the sleeve of his robe.

“Gooooooood, little Hobbit. Doesn’t confession ease the soul?” Smaug lit out with his tongue, pushing it out serpent-like until he could sweep the flat of it up Bilbo’s face. He retracted it with a smirk. “I would agree with you. Salt does add to a meal.”

Bilbo held himself until the sobs subsided and then stood, burying himself in the task once more. The elk roasted, fat dripping and smoking on the iron floor of the cooking area, until he was sure he’d quite faint from hunger. He had no idea whether it cooked through all the way or not, he simply carved off a joint for himself and backed away, nodding at the elk.

“There,” he said, “I hope—”

Smaug snapped up the elk like a frog with a fly. He took some of the iron spit with it as well, though he gave no indication that it gave him any difficulty. Bilbo just stood there, mouth hanging open.

Smaug smacked his chops. “Interesting. Not terrible, certainly, but not worth the wait. Such an inefficient manner of subsistence.” 

Bilbo laughed hollowly, sliding to the floor with a serving platter balanced on his lap. “You’ll get no arguments out of me. If there’s one word that could describe me, it’s ‘inefficient.’ Never the shortest route between two points.” He carved the meat into ragged slices. “Can't even do the job I was contracted for. I’m the wrong shape for this environment.” He put some meat into his mouth. It was tough and gamey and oversalted, but he ate it all and gnawed from the bone.

Smaug cast an almost proud eye over him. “Good. I shall bring you to sup down here. I’ll let you sprinkle your little herbs and cook with your slow fire. It will be my treat to you. Does that sound agreeable?” he laid the blunt side of his claw atop Bilbo’s head, moving it in a circular motion.

Bilbo smiled miserably. “Of course. How could I say no?” 

He climbed into Smaug’s outstretched hand.

“You should abandon thoughts of the dwarves coming to rescue you. With them you would face certain death.”

Bilbo looked at him. “And here?”

Smaug gave him a glowing smile.

As he raised Bilbo to his shoulder, the Hobbit saw a shadow between wing and breast, the exact shape of a missing scale.

He caught a breath.

 

Thorin sat on an overturned pack, looking into the embers of the fire, seeing nothing.

“No word from Dáin?” he asked.

“None.”

The fire made shadows dance in the hollows beneath his eyes. “And what of the other Dwarf lords?”

“They will not come, Thorin, until proof of kingship is yours,” Balin said gently. “You should try and eat something. No good thinking on an empty stomach.”

Thorin did not react.

“The lad’s made his bed.” Dwalin oof ’d lightly as he took a seat beside their leader. “He’s always been a tricky one, him. I wouldnae worry about it. If any of our number could survive the beast, it’s him.”

“It doesn’t even make sense,” Ori said, “why would the beast keep him?”

“To hurt me,” Thorin said.

The other dwarves fell silent.

Thorin looked in the fire, lost in his thoughts. “The dragon is a thief. He takes. He holds. He covets what is not his, and flaunts his theft. I told you he takes a sick pleasure from his cruelty. He knows Bilbo is one of our number. So long as he thinks it brings me pain, he will continue to hold him.”

“And then?”

Thorin did not answer. The embers popped, sending sparks drifting into the night.

Balin tamped down the bowl of his pipe. “Here, consider this: if any one of us had gone down there, we’d be dead by now. The lad is not only alive, he’s gotten the bloody thing to feed him. He’s got a way, hasn’t he, of creeping under your skin?”

Thorin did not react.

“Perhaps he’s grown a wee bit fond of the lad, just as we have. Maybe the stay of execution isn’t just to hurt ye, it's because the beast is so charmed by him.”

The end of Thorin’s mouth flicked up. “Charm. Perhaps Bilbo has complained about the quality of his meals and won the beast's heart.”

A whisper of a chuckle arose from the other dwarves.

“I’d chance that he’s shown the poor thing his bunions and won sympathy,’ Kili said, and then in a higher voice; “good lord, this one’s the size of my big toe .”

The laugh this time was slightly louder.

“Aye, he’s probably up there moaning about how we cheated in mumblety-peg,” Bofur chimed in, “you should have seen the size of the knife, nearly cut my finger off ,” The corners of his smile turned down, his speaking got slower. “He cou...he could barely hold a filleting knife, we had to give him the little paring blade, remember? Like a child, almost.” He choked a bit. “Blessed little lad. Never stopped complaining, but he never stopped trying either.”

Fili chuckled, eyes bright. “I always thought he’d be the first to make honorary Dwarf through formal complaint. I can just see the letter now: dear sirs under the mountain.” He snorted liquidly.

Thorin looked into the fire, but not at it.

“You speak of him in past tense,” he said. “Do not bury the man before his time.”

He got up and stalked away from the fire.

The other dwarves, by turns, unrolled their packs and went to sleep. Dwalin was the lone hold out, but even he eventually gave in, nodding off while sitting upright. Thorin sat alone looking out over the cliffside. Long after the fire had died down, he got up and strapped on his sword. Then, with a last look at the company, he descended the steps to Erebor.

Notes:

I think the role I have to compare Thorin to, more than any other role Richard Armitage has played, is John Thornton from North&South. They hit a lot of the same beats: fear of not being enough to support his people, his taboo affection for an outsider, his pride constantly getting in the way, etc. And then there is the moment where he is Soft around his love interest, like when he listens to Bilbo's plans for the acorn and it nearly snaps him out of the dragon sickness. Again, if Armitage could have gotten more heavy acting moments instead of a wheelbarrow ride on a river of the fakest fake molten metal I've ever seen (really, what even is convection heat?) that would have made the movies for me.

Chapter Text

“...far beyond the edge of this place is a sea,” Smaug said, “but it is a sea unlike the one you say you know. Strange things swim in the depths. I have seen a great fish that fountains water from its back at times.”

Bilbo lay snug in the crook of one wing, pressed against his side. “Have you ever eaten one? How did it taste?”

Smaug grimaced. “Terrible.”

Bilbo laughed. “My father told me the sea ends in a sharp edge, and ships could sail off of it.”

“Your father was a victim of his own ignorance. The sea circumscribes this land. In the far reaches there are curtains of light in the night-time, they shimmer in any number of colors and flicker in the wind.”

Bilbo smiled. “It sounds quite beautiful. The most colorful thing I've ever seen is a sunset.”

“This is no mere sunset. It is like starlight that has become lost on its way.” Smaug regarded Bilbo. “I can take you there someday, if you wish.”

Bilbo looked up in surprise. “Really? You would do that for me?”

“You have lived such a limited existence, little Hobbit, I consider it an act of charity to expand your horizons.” Smaug settled his head on a mound of treasure. “Someday. Provided you can behave.”

Bilbo turned and laid his cheek against Smaug’s chest. He knew when sleep came to the dragon, because here came that rumbling buzz that was not quite a purr and not quite a roar, but sleep would not come to him. He still felt sick from everything he had seen and heard. Interacting with the dragon, he reflected, carried with it a strange duality. Almost as strange as the poor creature who had originally possessed his ring. The beast could be so charming that one could, for a moment, forget they were speaking with a merciless predator the size of a sailing ship. Even now he found himself doubting every interaction between them, unable to stop himself analyzing every word or inflection, searching for a single crumb of humanity.

And why? What happened if he found one? Did he think he could broker peace between the dwarves and a beast who had killed a substantial number of their relatives?

Or were his motives more selfish, he thought, thumb rubbing along the curve of the ring he clutched to his body.

He could slip it on at any time, he knew. Vanish. Leave the beast wallowing in his gold pile, Arkenstone be damned. But he was warm and fed and cared for...and something about the beast felt like home. 

He loved the ring so much it made him sick, sometimes. He’d first felt it in Mirkwood after mercilessly stabbing that spider-thing to death, the horrible clench that made him want to do anything, everything to hold onto it. He could never breathe a word of it to the dwarves, not even Gandalf, because he knew they would not understand how it felt. 

But the dragon knew. Oh, how he knew.

Far off, something fell.

Bilbo tensed. When he did not hear any more, he tried to write it off as a simple gold shift. But then, oh no, he could hear boots, could those bloody dwarves never learn stealth?

Holding his breath, Bilbo began to wriggle, a little at a time, until he slid from Smaug’s grasp. He stole down the hillside as carefully as he could, trying not to cause any more avalanches.

Away from Smaug was deathly cold, the stone under his feet was ice and the metal thread of the robe branded his skin with chill. Shivering, he picked his way up the stone steps in the direction the sound had come from.

 

Thorin stole down the hall, eyes out for any little movement. As the Hobbit scuttled around a corner the Dwarf slowed, staring. Of all he expected to find, he did not for one moment think he would see Bilbo kitted out in Dis’ old robe. He stopped short, looking the Hobbit up and down.

Bilbo slowed, looking at himself.

“...what?”

Thorin shook himself. “Nothing. Suits you.”

“Yeah, well, he burnt my clothes,” Bilbo said testily.

Thorin frowned to hide his burgeoning smile. “And he gives you such a pretty frock in return? How generous.”

Bilbo put his hands on his hips, which had the unintended effect of reminding Thorin of his late mother. “Oh thank you very much. You know I didn’t choose to wear this.”

“No, it was given to you. You have a very rich benefactor.”

Bilbo crossed his arms, which looked even more like his mother. “Thorin, do you actually believe I am enjoying myself here?”

Thorin regarded him sharply. “You do not seem to be in any amount of distress.”

“Thorin.”

“You’re not even injured.”

“Thorin.” 

“One might even say you were thriving under dragon rule—”

“Thorin I stepped on a child’s skull today,” Bilbo said.

Thorin fell silent.

“I was just walking and it squirted out from under my foot like a carelessly spat melon seed. I am living in a tomb, Thorin, a tomb of your people.” Bilbo threw his hands wide, indicating the cavern. “You say I should have seen it in its heyday? I agree. All I've got is a bunch of remnants of the pasts and...ghosts. This is the unfriendliest place I've ever been, and I've been in a goblin town.”

Thorin’s face relaxed until it was almost a smile. “...so have I.”

Bilbo laughed bitterly. “There, then. So we have it.” He looked at Thorin, the sweetness of his face falling to sorrow. “I am looking, Thorin. I am .”

“That isn’t why I've come.”

Bilbo paused, a number of emotions flitting across his face. “R-really? Then why—”

“I wanted to warn you. The beast knows you belong to our company.”

Bilbo swallowed. “...I know.”

Thorin furrowed his brow. “And he’s done nothing to you?”

Physically? No. Mentally, emotionally, psychologically? Oh if words left bruises… “He...seems amused by me. He thinks you find me expendable.” Bilbo put a humorless little chuckle into the last few words, hoping that Thorin would deny it, swear that he was the most important member of the party.

Instead Thorin said, “that’s good.”

“Oh, fantastic.”

“That means he holds you beneath ransom. Trust me, if he felt you had enough of a bond with us, he would pull you apart right in front of our faces, just to hear the scream.”

Bilbo wobbled a little, blinking. “Well that’s a pleasant image.”

Thorin paced closer, until they stood almost nose-to-nose. “I did not come here to bring you cheer.”

“Oh, father forbid you do that, I’m having the time of my life here,” Bilbo hissed.

 “I came to warn you against getting comfortable. Which is obviously too late.” Thorin gestured to Bilbo’s attire. “The dragon cares only for the gold, Bilbo, and he will do anything to protect it.”

“Oh now who does that remind me of?” Bilbo remarked crabbily.

Thorin took one step closer. Now he could feel the hobbit was shivering in his robe. His first instinct would have been to don his overcoat and drape it around Bilbo, but such a gesture would mean death for him when the dragon found it. The Hobbit had a terrible habit of endangering himself, such a vexing creature.

“My first duty is to my people,” he murmured, so fiercely the Hobbit shrank back a bit, “the gold is their legacy. Their future. Do not accuse me of dragonlike gluttony for wanting back what is rightfully ours.”

Bilbo wilted a bit. “Look, Thorin, no one wants to see you restored to the throne more than me—”

Thorin bristled. “Why should I believe you, when you have so delayed our goal? Why should a non-Dwarf care about my kingship?”

“Why should—” Bilbo bit his lip, jerking his shoulders. “You are the most—” he stopped, and took a breath. “I am here because of you . I only left my burrow and my nice things and my quiet life because of you. Because I...care for you. You are prickly and stubborn and it’s like keeping a hedgehog sometimes, honestly, but I want you to have a home. You are one of the best men I have ever known.” His voice shook. “And if this coward can help you in any way, he will. Even if it means snuggling with a dragon.”

Thorin was quiet. “You are no coward, Bilbo Baggins,” he said at last.

Bilbo smiled. “Well, tell that to the saga-writers when they—” He was cut off by a hug.

Thorin embraced him, tucking his head into the crook of his neck. Oh , this was well worth the wait. Bilbo held his breath for a moment before melting into it, breathing in Thorin’s scent. Dwarfs had a smell, he thought, and he liked it. It smelled like cedar and sweat and smoke and good honest work, it was a wholesome smell. It smelled of life.

Thorin released him (too soon) and looked him up and down.

“So long as the worm thinks your presence here is an injury to me, you are safe,” he said. “Do everything you can to stay alive. Fawn over him until you learn his weaknesses. He must have a soft place somewhere.”

Unbidden, Bilbo thought of the dragon’s offer to take him to see the dancing lights.

“Of course,” he said. “Until then, please tell me you’ll do all to stay out of sight.”

“Easy enough. The clumsy brute has but one manner of exit from here, he practically announces his departure with a herald every time he leaves.”

Bilbo stayed his arm with a hand. “That’s not what I mean. You can’t come visiting me so often, he can smell you.” 

Thorin seemed affronted at the notion.

Bilbo slid his hand up and down his arm, enjoying the feel of another’s flesh after days of cold stone and dragon scale. “Never mind. I'm surprised dragons can smell anything over the stench of brimstone.”

He thought of a shadow between wing and breast, a gap just on the edge of perception.

“Thorin,” he said falteringly.

The dwarf looked at him. “Yes?”

Bilbo’s resolve failed him. He gave a chummy pat on the arm.

“Mind how you go.”

The corners of Thorin’s mouth perked up a bit. “And you, master Baggins.”

Bilbo watched him go, a great longing pealing through him. He wanted to catch Thorin’s arm, and beg him to take him out of this place to the safety of the dwarves. He wanted to sleep in the middle of a knot of bodies again, he wanted to eat mush and sing rude songs as he marched. He wanted to be teased about his height and his soft hands and his tendency to sneeze. He wanted to be amongst people again.

Instead he watched Thorin retreat until darkness swallowed him up. Then he turned and padded silently back, up and over mounds of treasure to where Smaug lay, wriggled between the great clawed hand and side and stuck his icy Hobbit feet against the hot surface of the dragon’s skin. Sleep did not find him for a long time.

Chapter 7

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Bilbo woke and stretched, rolling over to be cupped in the palm of the dragon’s hand. It was that crucial time of day when the need to cling to the dangling threads of sleep fought against the fullness of one’ bladder. Sleep held its ground for several minutes before pain won out and the morning’s functions called to be fulfilled. He slithered from Smaug’s grasp once more (the dragon lay still in sleep) and made his way to a particular stone bridge, where he made his toilet over the side. He hoped it was to end up in a forgotten cavern somewhere, rather than some unfortunate dwarf’s drawing-room. That would raise some uncomfortable questions when they retook Erebor. He finished his business and turned—

To find Smaug had silently woken and was spying on him through slit lids.

Bilbo jumped, putting hands to his heart. “You mustn’t do that, I've had no end of frights lately.”

Smaug began stretching, unwinding lengths of himself fluidly. “My apologies. I hope your late guest did not keep you too long?”

Bilbo flushed. “Guest? I am your guest, Smaug the most hospitable.” He laughed a little too sharply.

“Then who has made those roses bloom in your cheeks?”

Bilbo stammered into silence.

“Your posturing is strange to me. Do you think he will take to you mate? Make you his consort?”

Bilbo flushed even deeper. His fingers flew to his ring, a nervous tic he had developed. Smaug regarded his actions with amusement.

“Thorin does not know about your keepsake, does he? He does not know how it feels, this grasping love. He cannot.” Smaug flicked his interior eyelid. “But...we do, do we not?”

Bilbo could feel the words winding into his head again and fought off panic. “I d-don’t know what you’re—”

“This need, this burning need.” Smaug’s mouth began to smoulder. “I only ever feel at rest when I am here, on this bed of gold. Should someone take your ring—”

“No!” Bilbo shouted, instinctively hunching into himself.

Smaug retreated, point proven. “Do you think he would accept you, if he knew?”

Bilbo cast his eye down, finger circling the ring. “I don’t...I don’t want to find out.”

“And what if he came down here and became like us?” Smaug opened one hand, and to Bilbo’s horror he saw the gleam of the arkenstone within it. “Became greedy? Jealous? I am almost tempted to let you take it, if only to watch Oakenshield suffer, watch it destroy his heart—”

“No,” Bilbo whimpered. He put his face in his hands.

“No?” Smaug held the gem before him. “You do not want it, my little? Call it your share of the treasure.”

“No.” Bilbo cowered away from it.

“Such a shame. It would make a pretty bauble for your neck.” Smaug dropped it with a dry chuckle.

Bilbo kicked himself. He had just refused the arkenstone, the reason he was stuck in this gilded prison in the first place. But even tossing aside the fact that the offering was a very obvious trap, he knew on some level that Smaug was right. There was a sickness on this place, and its heart was that stone. He had a horrible vision of Thorin becoming corrupted like his forebears, becoming cruel, greedy, violent…

He wouldn’t let that happen. He’d die before it happened.

“What about this then?” 

A small jingle as something landed at his feet. Bilbo picked it up and found it a chain of intricate delicacy, a gold helix worked in links as fine as a hair. He looked up, barely daring to breathe.

“I don’t understand...you’re giving this to me?”

“A gift, my little. For your...trinket. So that it may always be close to you.”

He didn’t know how to feel about it. He turned from Smaug’s gaze to fiddle with the clasp, slipping his ring on discreetly before draping it around his neck. Now the ring sat against his flushed skin, almost pulsing. Bilbo shivered at the feeling.

“Thank you,” he said, turning back to Smaug, “that is very generous of you.”

“It is but a trifle. See how I spoil you, my pet. I am enjoying this.” Smaug used the end of one sharp claw to ruffle the hem of Bilbo’s robe. “Perhaps I should give you more adornments. Bedeck you in gold, so you match my treasure.”

Bilbo felt oddly embarrassed. “It’s quite all right. The gifts I have are enough.”

“So modest!” Smaug sardonically tilted his head. “You ask so little...but you’ve taken everything, haven’t you?” he reached his claw to snag at the newly-hung chain around Bilbo’s neck, making the Hobbit wince. “You feel no guilt accepting my gifts, and then lying to me?”

Bilbo swallowed. “I...I mean no offence, Smaug. You have been generous beyond reason. I am but a small man, soft and subject to the whims of my heart.”

“Indeed. And Oakenshield knows this fact very well. See how he imprints upon you his scent? (Bilbo took a step back, paling.) He had to have known I would detect even the slightest trace of him. I wouldn’t wonder if it was intentional,” the dragon purred, “is he tiring of you, my little?”

Bilbo shook slightly. It was like that horrid gaze was piercing through him, right down into his heart. Every fear he’d ever felt bubbled to the surface to be skimmed off like scum. “I-it may be,” he managed, “but it will not happen again.” He bowed his head, the weight of the ring at his neck dragging him down.

Smaug whiffed at him, snout wrinkling at the traces of dwarvish scent. “You should bathe again. Come, let us depart.”

This time with some rooting Bilbo found a chunk of calcified soap that gave off faint whiffs of tallow. He walked into the water, robe on, then ducked out of it.

“You wash clothing,” he told Smaug’s disappointed expression, “otherwise it’s just wasteful.”

He hung the robe to drip-dry and then focused on himself. 

He lathered his hair, humming to himself: “Oh you can search far and wide, you can drink the whole town dry...ba-ba-ba...the one we deedly-dee... by the flagon .” he dunked his head under the water, remaining submerged for a moment as he looked up at the reflective surface. Under here there was no dragon. If only he could stay longer than a breath. He surfaced with a whoosh, scattering soap foam.

The ring remained on the chain around his neck as he bathed, he did not dare take it off. More than that, he didn’t want to take it off. It made him feel almost sick...but in a way that felt good. Like when you were in the dregs of a fever and all you did was eat and sleep. 

Sleep. Bilbo realized he had not dreamt once since arriving here. The thought of it gave him pause.

“Smaug,” he asked, “do you dream? I mean, have you ever dreamt?”

Smaug was watching him, head pillowed on one wing. “What is a dream?”

“You don’t—” Bilbo quickly hid his shock, worried it would offend the dragon. “When people sleep, sometimes they...they make pictures in their heads. Scenes play out before them.”

Smaug narrowed his eyes.

“Sometimes it is a memory of days gone by. Usually it is just absurd nonsense that runs on its own logic. On very rare occasions it is a portend.”

“And you say you have them every night?” Smaug asked.

“Nearly. For instance the last time I dreamt my cousin Drogo needed to grow a carrot in one of my ears as part of a plan to convince—”

“No wonder you all run around half-mad,” Smaug said in disdain, “with your heads full of nonsense and never-weres.”

“So you tell me you have never dreamt?”

“My mind is always alert, ready to rouse my body at the first hint of danger.”

Bilbo frowned. “That sounds terribly un-restful.”

“So you see the need for my bed of gold, little one. Only here can I feel at ease.”

“I guess the dream is really more the realm of the creative lot.” Bilbo furrowed his brow thoughtfully. “...have you lot ever made anything?”

Smaug eyed him. “Such as?”

“Well, anything, really. A sonnet, perhaps. A daisy chain. Even a meal. Do you think you could cook a meal, should you so choose?”

Smaug seemed discomfited. Bilbo realized his ego had slammed up against a place where his might was not sufficient, perhaps for the first time ever. 

“Why should I need to? I have everything I need to survive,” Smaug sounded confused. 

“But making things isn’t just about surviving, it’s about…” Bilbo rolled his gaze up, thinking, “well, celebrating, for one. Remembering. Mourning. After you’ve eaten and slept and...done your business, what else is left?”

“Yes, what else is left?” Smaug pressed. “You talk in riddles, little one. Why should I have to?”

“Well, you wouldn’t have to.” Bilbo swirled bathwater as he contemplated. “But should you want to...you could write a song about yourself. In celebrations of your great deeds.”

Smaug’s eyes narrowed in suspicion. “And you? Did you make that little song I heard you sing earlier?”

“That? Oh no, it’s an old drinking song.” Bilbo hummed a bit of melody. “You can drink your fancy ales, you can drink them by the flagon, but the only brew for the brave and true comes from the green dr —” he choked off the phrase, looking down.

“The green what?”

“Oh nothing, I can never remember the rest of that song,” Bilbo lied.

“Where does that song hail from?”

“Somewhere in Bywater, I don’t know,” Bilbo said dismissively, soaping areas he had already washed. 

“What is the title?”

“What?”

“What is the title of the song?”

The soap slid from Bilbo’s grasp. He watched it drift gently to the floor of the basin. 

“The Green Dragon inn,” he sighed.

Smaug blinked. “They named a house of ale after my kind?” he hissed.

“A very nice one,” Bilbo said, hands raised in defense. “All the houses and inns are named like that. They think it gives a place prestige.”

“I should fly there and raze it to the ground.”

“Don’t,” Bilbo pleaded. 

“I see no reason why I shouldn’t. There was a time when dragons ruled the sky. We were respected and feared. We sent men fleeing into the shelters of the night,” Smaug growled. He stirred the basin with his claw. Unbidden, Bilbo thought of Smaug firing a single jet of flame and cooking him like soup.

“It’s a shame,” he said, cringing as he jolted Smaug out of his reverie. “Such a time has ended. The legendary age. I have always loved the tales of giants and wizards and—”

“Dragons,” Smaug said testily. 

“Y-yes.” Bilbo swallowed. That is why I'm here. The age of men is a terribly boring time to live.”

Smaug flattened the scales on his head. “So long as I live, little one, it is the age of Smaug.”

“Of course,” Bilbo soothed, quickly fetching his robe, “you are one of the last remaining figures of distinction. I left the only home I've ever known to come to you, Smaug. Does that count for anything?”

Smaug regarded him as he stepped into his great claw. “Tell me of your little hovel. Do you have a bed of gold to rest upon?” he said mockingly.

“A gold bed? Well no, but—” Bilbo licked his lips. “At the right time of year, you know, when they’re mowing the meadowsweet to put by for winter, the setting sun lights up my whole burrow, filling everything with gold light. My wallpapers and wainscoting, everything gets turned to gold—”

“But it’s not real gold, is it,” Smaug said, lifting Bilbo up to eye level, “it’s just a light that fades after a few hours.”

“I suppose,” Bilbo said in a small voice.

“Why you should miss a dirt hole in the ground is anyone’s guess,” Smaug muttered, scaling the walls back to their hold. “A place of dirt and sticks, no real distinction at all.”

“It was mine,” Bilbo said miserably. The dragon did not seem to hear. He slithered a trail through his golden bed, just barely keeping Bilbo aloft. He submerged his head in a hill of golden coins and writhed until he’d quite buried himself. Bilbo just managed to leap off and weather the storm in a great golden basin that had probably served as a platter cover once upon a time. The dragon was upset. He’d hit a soft spot without even meaning to…

Soft spot.

When Smaug reemerged, Bilbo tried to discreetly scan the hide where he had seen the shadow the other day. Yes there, just beside the breast, a gap between scales where skin showed pink as a plucked chicken. 

“So it is true,” he breathed, “the black arrow found its mark.”

“What?” Smaug’s head snapped down to look at him. Bilbo suppressed the sudden rush of fear.

“I was just thinking...do you shed? Like a lizard.”

Smaug narrowed his eyes suspiciously. “You do ask the oddest questions sometimes.” He presented his hand, and Bilbo climbed in.

“Well do you? I don’t think I see a single inch of you that isn’t battle-scarred.”

“I was born with the exact number of scales I have today,'' Smaug growled. “I remain indestructible. Even those tub-trading lakemen, those sniveling cowards with their longbows and black arrows couldn’t dent me!” His voice mottled, choked off. Bilbo realized he was uncomfortable talking about it. That was promising.

“I just ask because usually having an itch to scratch usually means you’ve got dead skin to get off. Like your diminutive cousins, the lizards. Or cats.”

“Cats?” Smaug whiffed suspiciously.

“Small brown furry things. Live in barns, chase rats.”

“Ah, smaller creatures.” Smaug settled his head back on the treasure. “They end up charred all the same, I've never bothered to pick them apart.”

“Well, you remind me of them, in a way. They too enjoy being scratched at length.” Bilbo lounged back, legs dangling to either side of the dragon’s finger. “Imagine if you were the size of a cat. I’d keep you on the stove, feed you snips of meat as I cooked. You could light the cooking fire.” He giggled a little at the absurd image.

Smaug was silent for a while. “...you’d feed me?”

The silly smile dropped off Bilbo's face as he snapped back to the moment. “Well...yes. Ah. Yes I would. If that were the case.”

“But I can hunt for myself.”

“Doesn’t matter. It’s courtesy. You feed me don’t you? Technically speaking, I could feed myself.”

“Not well.”

“But I could. Yet you feed me, provide for me. It’s companionship.”

Smaug’s eyes narrowed as if he were trying to read in a language he did not know. “No one has ever fed me, not even my own mother.”

“So no one’s ever cared for you? Not even when you were sick?”

“Dragons do not get sick.”

“So you’ve never....” Bilbo settled back again. “Well, caring for people, companionship...it’s the doing of what is not necessary for yourself for the comfort of another.”

Smaug looked disquieted. “I have done all this for my amusement. It is only by accident that it benefit you.”

A chill raised Bilbo's hairs, and he reminded himself that no matter how reasonable he seemed, a predator was a predator.

“Never mind all that,” he said, “tell me, have you ever heard any stories?”

Smaug squinted. “You mean did my dragon mother tell me stories as a hatchling?” he asked mockingly. “No. I never met her, so her talents for story-telling are unmarked.”

Bilbo rubbed his hands together. “Well, you are in for a treat.”

He told Smaug the fairy stories he had learned at his mother’s knee, about kings and princes and all manner of enchantment. Finally he came to the tale of the heartless giant.

“Now you must be joking,” Smaug said, “a giant cannot live without a heart. Anyone knows this.”

“Well he has a heart. He just keeps it by magic far away from him so no one can hurt him.”

“I see, and does this little prince who came to serve him find it and mend his ways?” Smaug said dismissively.

Bilbo’s face fell. “N-no, actually. The boy ransoms the heart for the release of his kin, who take the heart and squash it.”

“Really?” An unwholesome light came into Smaug’s eyes. “How droll.”

“It’s quite tragic, really. The prince would have given the heart back to the giant, and perhaps he would have mended his ways.”

“Probably not. Giants are stupid things. Can barely find their own mouths.” Smaug itched a scale. “Here. do your little trick again.”

Bilbo found the itch and worked at it with his hands.

“Just suppose,” he said slowly, “for curiosity's sake, I asked you to give the dwarves the Arkenstone. If I said they just wanted that one thing, and then they would leave you alone forever, would you do it?”

Smaug opened one eye. “I wouldn’t believe you.”

“But if you did?”

“I wouldn’t.”

“But if you did, just supposing, believe me. Would you?”

Smaug yawned. It was like looking into a valley of knives. “Not even then. It’s a matter of principle.”

“What principle? Technically this was all theirs to begin with. They dug it up, smelted it, and shaped it so.”

“Yes, and I won it by right of conquest,” Smaug said testily, “you small folk have the most wearying ideas of ownership. If they could have stopped me from taking it, it would have remained theirs.”

Bilbo gave a weak smile. “Just thought I'd ask.”

“Did you?” Smaug ruffled his scales. “Just a simple little exercise in theory? Would you have me turn my weaknesses over as well?”

“Just a thought.”

“A thought.”

“That maybe this could be resolved peacefully.”

Smaug laughed, opening his jaws wide. “And do you think me capable?”

Bilbo sighed. “No. I see that I could sooner divert the course of a river than change your nature, o Smaug.”

“I see. Then you will stop this silly business of asking after my mercy?”

“Of course.” Bilbo scratched, digging deep with his nails. Smaug hissed in pleasure, sinking into himself like a cat.

Notes:

"The Heartless Giant" does not draw from Tolkien, it draws from fairy tales, specifically the version on Jim Henson's the Storyteller. That provided one of the germs for this idea, the search for humanity in a creature who seems to have none. It's wonderfully sad, highly recommend.

Chapter 8

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Fili approached Thorin gingerly. “We’ve got a problem.”

Thorin indicated their packs. “The rations, I know. We can dispatch a party to lake-town to barter more, though who will take what little we have left in trade—”

“We have another problem,” Kili said. As one they turned to look behind them. A man on horseback was covering the ground between Dale and Erebor. Even at this distance they could recognize the lean shape of their ferryman.

“Bloody hell, what does the fool think he’s up to?” Thorin muttered. He turned and called out. “To me! We must meet him halfway.”

A contingency of dwarves were waiting halfway down the cliff as Bard reigned in his horse. The nag danced a bit over the stony ground.

“Greetings, merchant dwarves,” Bard called out. “But I forget my manners. We were never properly introduced. I am Bard of lake-town, and you are no mere merchants.”

Thorin beheld him with icy calm. “And what are we then?”

“Suicidal. Stupid. You’re camping on the step of the dragon’s nest, and I'm sure you've heard about the treasure within.” Bard set a calming hand on the horse’s neck. “I am here to tell you to turn back. It’s folly, no one has managed to steal a single coin from the beast’s maw.”

“Tis no coin we’re after,” Dwalin growled, “but the whole bloody lot. We will kill the beast and share in the spoils.”

Bard looked as if he’d seen a ghost. “You cannot. You will set the beast on Lake-town and the death toll will begin again.”

Balin stepped forward, hands out. “Now, laddie—”

“You think you are equipped to face him?” Bard snarled, “my forebear shot two black arrows from a wind-lance and barely nicked the beast. What possible hope do you think you could have?”

Realization dawned on Thorin’s face.“You say you have a Dwarvish wind-lance? What of the arrows?”

Bard eyed them suspiciously. “It matters not. If I had a hundred arrows, I could not kill it.”

“You’re modest in your own measure,” Balin said, smiling down at him, “if you are the son of the son of the man who almost killed him, we have to talk.”

Bard remained stoic. “There is nothing further to discuss. I am warning you—”

“And if we fail, what then? What could you threaten us with that is worse than dragonfire?” Thorin asked.

Silence was his answer.

“One of our number is in there with the beast,” Thorin said haltingly, “somehow he has survived this many days. If anyone could search out a weakness, it would be him.”

“I have terrible news: if he’s in there with the dragon he’s probably dead.”

“He’s not.”

“And even if he isn’t, can you be sure he could accomplish such a task?”

“I have the utmost faith in him,” Thorin said, stepping to the end of the ledge, “he is capable and up for the task. Could I say the same of you?”

Bard regarded them, looking from face to face to face grimly. There was no hope in his eyes.

“I’m going back to my home,” he said, “I am going to secure my family and move them to safe ground. I have long ago ceased caring about my own life, but theirs are infinitely more precious.”

“Then we understand each other,” Thorin said. Bard gave him an odd look.

As the horse galloped away, Thorin turned to the others. “We must go back into Erebor. Now. We need to retrieve Bilbo.”

“Do ye think he’s found the dragon’s weakness yet?”

“We must chance it. That fool will raise the alarm in Lake-town, it’s only a matter of time before it draws the beast's attention outward, and eventually to us.

Balin looked at him, eyes upturned in an almost smile. “You’re thinking with your heart, lad. This is no strategic mission. ‘Tis a rescue.”

Thorin stopped, he felt the eyes of the company upon him.

“Do any of you take issue with that?” he asked fiercely.

“Me? No, not at all.”

“Furthest thing from my mind really.”

“I’dve been in there days ago, if you’d let me.”

Thorin felt a swell of pride as the men fell to preparation, strapping on swords and axes and what little battle armor they possessed. Dwalin clapped a hand like a tree root on his shoulder. Of all Dwarves he would have thought Dwalin the most contentious, reluctant to waste any of their lives on one Hobbit.

“Let’s fetch the wee laddie, and give the beast a smile for Durin’s folk.” Dwalin slid a thumb across his neck. 

Thorin had to suppress a smile. “Let’s go.”

 

Bilbo lay ensconced in the massive hammock of one wing, one hand curled under his head, the other gripping his ring. He did not know what made him open his eyes, only that when he did Thorin was waiting before him on one of the stone walkways

Bilbo shook his head as little as he dared and mouthed ‘no’.

Thorin beckoned him.

Fear lancing through his chest, Bilbo slowly edged his way off the dragon wing, flinching at every little stir. As he placed both feet on the stone, Thorin grabbed his arms and pulled him into another embrace.

“We’re leaving,” he breathed. 

Bilbo’s heart hammered. “But I haven’t told you—”

“The Arkenstone does not matter now,” Thorin said, once again infuriatingly close to the truth without actually touching it. “We must get you to safety, then we can worry about killing the beast.”

“Oh dear, such ambition! One can only hope your reach does not exceed your grasp.”

Bilbo froze, not daring to look behind himself. He could feel the voice through his bones, even in Thorin’s protective embrace. 

“So we meet at last, worm under the mountain. I am Thorin, son of Thrain, son of Thror. I am going to end your reign here.” Thorin angled himself so that Bilbo was no longer before him but curled protectively into his side.

Rigid with terror, Bilbo looked down the stone path to where the other Dwarves hunkered just out of sight. Very carefully, with the hand that was not visible to the dragon, he drew a circle on his breast in the same area as the missing scale. Most of them  made confused faces, but at the very least Balin  seemed to understand and nodded. Biblo pointed back the way they came. A few dwarves, Dwalin especially, stood fast. Biblo pointed again, and then pointed to Thorin’s back before laying his hand on it. Anger, fear, regret swam through their faces. But at long last they turned back the way they’d come.

“How very fierce. And tell me, Dwarf, son of Dwarves, how do you intend to start your reign? Would you perhaps require this?”

Bilbo’s mouth dried in terror as he turned, knowing before he did that yes—

Smaug held the Arkenstone. He pinched it between claws like a grain of salt and peered through it. Thorin’s guard fell and he approached by a few steps, held at bay by Bilbo. 

“He had…” Thorin turned to him, pained. “You knew?”

Bilbo did not want to meet his gaze, but made himself. “I did. He dangled it cruelly before me. Listen—”

“Yes, listen to the little Hobbit,” Smaug mocked, “how he does talk at length, he flatters and flirts with acumen. Tell me, was he complementary to you too?”

Bilbo could not stand the look Thorin gave him. His fingers found the gold chain around his neck and felt dirty.

“It matters not. What is a mortal life in the great span of a dragon? I have outlived mountains, little one.” Light built in Smaug’s chest. “I shall see the sun fall dark, and the age of men wither into dust.”

Bilbo tried to think of where the Dwarves would be by now. Hopefully scaling the cliffside. But then there was the long run to the lake, the boat ride to town...

Thorin drew himself tall. “Beast. You shall not live to see the end of this day.”

“Funny.” Smoke was leaking from Smaug’s nostrils. “I was about to say the same to you.”

“Smaug,” Bilbo said suddenly, “son of nothing. Father of nothing. Lover of nothing.”

Smaug’s wicked gaze slid over to him. But Bilbo found he had no fear left in his body and stepped forward.

“Coward,” he hissed.

Smaug’s scales flattened, the light in him banked.

“Coward,” Bilbo said, taking another step. “Usurper. Thief. You can create nothing, you can love nothing, you cannot change, you cannot grow, you will never be more—”

Smaug hissed, steaming into laughter. “Finally, my little lizard sheds his skin. Tell me, do you think you have found my secret heart? Will you ransom me into behaving?”

“I would crush it myself,” Bilbo said, “if such a thing existed. But you have never had one, only a hole where it should be.” This sent a ripple through the dragon’s body. “No one is going to mourn you, Smaug. There will be no ballads sung about you, and you will not be thought about for a single moment after your death.”

Smaug bristled. “I am eternal, I am—”

“Going to die, like any other being. You are soft inside, Smaug, chiefest of calamities, and that frightens you, doesn’t it?” Bilbo’s voice rang against a thousand gold surfaces like a mass of carillons, it roared back at the dragon with a metallic edge. “You must sleep on your golden bed because you fear to sleep anywhere else. It eats at you that a town of fishermen were enough to mark you. Tell me, when the black arrows found you, did you weep to feel pain for the first time?”

Smaug’s pupils were thin lines. “Impudent little wretch.”

“Kill me if you want,” Bilbo said, “I would prefer oblivion to one more second in your company.”

Thorin grabbed his shoulders and wrenched him back, wrestling with him.

Smaug watched them, a crafty look stole over his face.

“Oh dear,” he said, “you truly are bonded, aren't you? I will do you a favor and spare him, then. No sense in wasting a perfectly good king. Not that he will ever enjoy his coronation.”

Biblo realized what would happen a second too late to cry out. The dragon opened his maw. The Arkenstone hung glittering in space for a moment, gleaming for all the world like a real star, before falling down into the gluttonous depths of his throat.

Thorin gasped as if stabbed. Bilbo felt his stomach drop. 

“No no oh no,” he cried, hand out as if he could grab the stone out himself.

Smaug regarded them smugly. “That was rather filling. Yes, I am in a much better mood, having supped. I think I shall eliminate your little friends first, just so I can watch the hope die in your eyes. How far do you think they’ve gotten by now?”

He’d known. He’d known all along.

Thorin shook. The sensation of it cut Bilbo’s heart. The man who had been so steady and strong through all of this was wilting in his arms.

“No,” he said pleadingly. 

Smaug raised his wings. Bilbo had but a second to tackle Thorin before the hurricane of gold overtook them, and then he was gone.

Thorin attempted to get up and slid weakly down. “We...we have to stop him, we have to tell them.”

“They are halfway to Lake-town by now, perhaps further.” Bilbo tried dragging him up and failed. “Thorin, please—”

Thorin grabbed fistfuls of Bilbo's robe. “Why did you not tell me? It was right there the whole time!” He was halfway between tears and rage.

“Thorin…” Bilbo felt so weary. He untwined Thorin’s clenching grasp from his robe and locked their fingers.. “I wanted to give it to you...many times, I…”

Thorin shook him slightly. “It’s all gone,” he said, his voice breaking, “it’s all lost. I haven’t saved them, I've led them to a more elaborate death, a thousand times more painful than the first.”

“And they followed you, remember that.” Bilbo wrapped arms around him. Oh mercy, the embrace was just as good going in the other direction. “Even if they had known the exact date and time of their death, they would have followed you.”

. ..the runners caught up to a lone rider on a horse, who broke into a gallop...

Thorin held him, teetering as if he could no longer hold himself up. “I was a fool.”

Bilbo smiled. “You are a fool. You do not see your successes, only your failures. I’ve learned to accept that.”

Thorin looked at him. His gaze was piercing, but it no longer cut like it once had. “Tell me why you kept this from me.”

“Because I knew if I told you, you would come in swords drawn and charging. You’d have been roasted alive. And—” Bilbo choked a bit. “I am selfish. I am a greedy, selfish person, Thorin, and I wanted to give you the Arkenstone myself. I wanted to see your face light up and oh, I wanted to see you happy, and know that it was I who—”

Thorin pulled him into a tight embrace. 

...a lone archer took up station at a dwarvish wind-lance...

“I have been happy,” he whispered. “I have hidden it, for fear it would be taken away like everything else precious to me.”

Oh the sweet man, the sweet, stubborn, sentimental man. Bilbo felt tears swarm his eyes, from both happiness and sorrow.

...Smaug rolled elaborately in the sky…

“I am sorry, for leading you into such perils,” Thorin murmured against his hair.

Bilbo choked back a sob. “I am glad to have shared in your perils, Thorin. Each and every one of them….because I…”

...Smaug hovered in the air, gullet lighting up like a furnace…

“Because I…”

 ...the wind-lance creaked into motion, still operating after years of wind and rain and neglect because it was built with skill by Dwarves who had lived for their work. The black arrow spiraled deadly through the air…

Biblo pressed his face into Thorin’s chest. He could not speak it aloud, not here. He had let Thorin down, he had no call to air his feelings out. 

...the arrow found its mark. Smaug registered a look of surprise before he fell, sinking like a hot iron into a quenching bucket. The lake flashed into steam. The wave his body created swamped the town and unsettled the boats where the screaming citizens floated.

Thorin looked up. “The roaring, it’s...it’s stopped.”

Bilbo opened his eyes. “Did they make it?”

As one they rose, and walked to the parapet. Lake-town glowed in the dark, but there was no light in the sky, nothing spewing fire in the night. Bilbo shivered a little at the cold. Thorin threw an arm around him and held him close, his warmth was not a thousandth of the dragon’s but it was all the more radiant.

They could see from the embers of the town that boats retreated to the shore. Some lake dwellers had escaped, though how many and who was anyone’s guess.

“The Arkenstone,” Thorin said. 

Bilbo put a hand to his back. “In the gullet of the beast, however many fathoms that lies.”

Thorin’s eyes were hooded. “It was the mark of kingship.”

Bilbo sighed. “I am sorry I could not give it to you….but part of me is glad I could not.”

Thorin looked at him sharply.

“There is a sickness on this gold. I feel it.” For a moment the ring throbbed, and Bilbo caught his breath. “That stone was its heart. You’ve felt it, haven’t you? Walking into that great hall. It’s what drew...him.”

“I will have to fight now for what should be mine by right.”

“I would see you fight a thousand battles, rather than let you become like that.” Bilbo looked at him. He gathered Thorin's hands in his own and held them as if he did not intend their return.  “What marks you as king is not a single stone, it is your heart.”

Thorin took a sharp breath. Whatever he was going to say next was interrupted by a shout from below.

“Wa-hey, Thorin? Bilbo! We’re back!”

“The beastie is in the lake!”

“Dropped like a sack of hammers from the sky!”

“Yes, Bard did it!”

“Bard the bowman!”

As one they looked down, Thorin waved at his relatives. Bilbo swallowed his disappointment and greeted the others.

Notes:

Note: Alfrid Lickspittle died on the way back to his home planet. *Itchy and Scratchy theme plays*

Chapter 9

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

In the days that followed Bilbo took to wandering aimlessly, completing any little task the others set him to. He had no real purpose now, you see. As the dwarves busied themselves cleaning up and searching for tools and taking up arms, he drifted like a dandelion seed through halls and rooms. He’d been given clean clothes(after some good-natured ribbing by the others) and free run of the place. And why shouldn’t he? There was nothing left to burgle.

“The bargeman is back. He means to speak to someone in charge,” Balin said.

“Where’s Thorin?”

“Nowhere in evidence.”

“I’ll see to it,” Bilbo said, hopping over Bifur as he rolled a carpet. “Give me something to do.”

Erebor was as large as any human city he’d ever been in, perhaps larger, for he could not fathom its depths. But there were only a few key areas he knew Thorin would flee to, and the first he tried was the royal family’s quarters.

“I should have known you’d find me,” Thorin said, back to the door. The room he stood in was hewn mostly of stone, but as cold as the rest of Erebor was, this was warm. Yellowed marble and warm amber furnishings seemed to sprout from the walls and floors. Blueprints for fantastic machinery and architecture flocked the walls. Thick pelt rugs that carpeted the floor. Bilbo stepped onto one and made an approving noise at how the fur felt between his toes.

“The others are looking for you.”

“Let them manage themselves for a moment. I’m weary.”

“There’s a contingency from Lake-town. I think they’re in need of assistance. It would be wise to broker a relationship with your neighbors, Thorin.” 

He remained with his back to Bilbo. Bilbo looked around the room; taking in the pennants, the maps on the walls, the basket with various tools and a toy wooden sword spilling out.

“What room is this?”

Thorin looked at him, face guarded. “Mine.”

Bilbo couldn’t help a teasing note from creeping into his voice. “Truly? Well, now I can get a view of what your adolescence must have been.” 

“Happy.” Thorin sighed, turning. “Ignorant. My legacy seemed secure as the rock beneath our feet.”

“Your legacy is still strong as it ever was. Stronger, even, because you have snatched it from the jaws of a beast.” Bilbo cleared his throat. “And if any take issue with it...they can jolly well take it up with me.”

For the first time a hint of merriment crept into Thorin’s face. “A formidable opponent, indeed. By that logic, you’d have just as much claim to the throne as I do. You truly felled the beast.”

Bilbo swallowed, the room suddenly gaining a chill. “Don’t say that.”

Thorin turned away again, a sigh passing from his parted lips. “How does one begin again, after slogging through hellfire? Such a wearying task I have set ahead of me, I feel I could sleep for a thousand years and yet...” he swiped a hand across his cheekbone. “...I have hardly slept an hour at a time since we took the city. I keep waiting for the other half of the trap to snap down on us.”

“Given your history I can hardly blame you.” Bilbo wandered, taking up a string toy and dangling it errantly from one finger. He noticed Thorin looking at him and dropped it, blushing.

“Now that the beast lies beneath the lake, and the sign of kingship lies within that beast, my claim on the throne is shaken.”

“You’re not still on about that, are you?”

Thorin bristled. 

“The Arkenstone is just that: a stone.”

“It is the king’s jewel.”

“And a crown is just a ring of beaten metal. Ask any of those other dwarf lords whether they faced down a dragon and lived, will you?” Bilbo caught at his arm. “Thorin—”

Thorin jerked away. “Do not speak to me with such familiarity.”

Bilbo swallowed, throat constricting. “Why shouldn’t I? We’ve spent the last thirteen months eating, sleeping, and traveling together.” He raised himself up a bit. “Are you not the Thorin who put his feet up at my fire and ate the last of my currant jam on toast?”

“Do not speak to me as if I were some lowly dwarf,” Thorin spat out, retreating, “do not speak to me as if I were still Thorin…” his voice broke, “...Oakenshield.” he turned and dashed his forearm over a table, bearing half-finished devices and blueprints to the ground. “I am your KING!”

Bilbo looked at him tenderly. He pulled at Thorin’s arm until they faced each other once more, though the dwarf’s eyes were diverted to the floor. Bilbo touched his face gently with his fingertips. He had to swallow back tears before he spoke.

“I did not follow a king,” he said, “I followed a man. A man who entered my home without knocking and ate all my food and fretted at me for falling behind every step of the way. I said you are the best man I've ever known, and I meant every word of it. I faced a dragon for you, and I would face down every would-be pretender to the throne for you.”

The kiss surprised even him, for his body leapt forward before his thoughts could catch up, and when they arrived they found his heart had been in this place all along.

Thorin parted with a shocked look. “I’m—”

Bilbo’s heart sank into the floor. “Sorry, I'm sorry, I don’t know what I was thinking. Um, erm, I can leave you alone now, if-if that’s what you—”

Thorin grabbed him and returned the kiss, a thousand times fiercer and yet somehow gentler than anything else in existence. Bilbo let himself be kissed, reveling in this new helplessness.

He smiled hazily as if drunk when they parted lips.

“There’s men from Lake-town outside,” he said, “I think they want to talk to you.”

 

Thorin strode to the mouth of the stone bridge before Erebor’s keep, holding himself tall and kingly. Bard had arrived once again on horseback. Behind him smoke rose from the ruins of Dale. Bilbo could see the scurry of people like ants.

“Thorin Oakenshield, son of Thrain, I greet you,” Bard said. He seemed taller, in a way. He held himself differently, and the guarded hostility from his earlier speech was gone. “From my people to yours.”

“I see you have survived the dragon’s fire.”

“Some have.” Bard looked back at the city. “Some have not. I have been pressed into service as their leader.”

“Congratulations are in order.”

“And to you.” 

Thorin nodded guardedly.

“I will not mince words: my people have seen heavy loss. I come to you for aid.”

Thorin stiffened a bit. Bilbo went to stand beside him. At the sight of him Thorin seemed to unclench.

“You shall have it,” he said, “may this be the start of another moment of unity between my people and yours.”

Bard’s mouth smiled, but his eyes still spoke of sorrow. “Had you asked me but a week ago whether a passel of dwarves could have helped to abolish the biggest terror this land has ever known, I would have called you mad. Touched.” 

“Had you asked me but a year before whether I had designs on this place, I would have called you a fool.” Thorin cleared his throat. “My cousin from the Iron Hills had sent word he’s approaching.”

Bard looked concerned. “Does he mean battle?”

“One hopes not.” Thorin nodded tightly. “I will dispatch aid to your people. I…” he cleared his throat again. “I hope you will see fit to inhabit what was once Dale again. It seems a waste of such a grand city to sit empty.”

Bard really smiled this time. “I hope to. Thank you, king under the mountain. I hope the next time we meet is under more felicitous circumstances.”

Bilbo almost spoke, but paused as his eye was drawn upwards. There was a moving bar on the hills, as if a golden centipede were descending.

“Elves,” Dwalin snarled. 

The dwarves took up defensive positions, as if their number could stand against a company of elf warriors. Though that might not be the long chance he thought it was, Bilbo reflected on all he’d seen. Bard’s horse danced to the side. He had come alone, and not prepared for battle. Of course it’s not like a bunch of burned and tired fishermen could stand against…

Bilbo squinted. “Is that a great elk?”

Thranduil rode up, looking as majestic as one could look atop a beast with antlers too large for its body. His golden army marched before him like clockwork toys, moving with an eerie unison. They stopped before the castle keep silently, which was many times more frightening than if they had come in shields clashing. Thranduil bowed nobly from atop his steed.

“Why does the leader of Mirkwood come prepared for battle?” Thorin asked stonily.

Thranduil smiled. “Why do the dwarves of Erebor sit out defenseless in the open? Has your victory against one threat blinded you to all other danger?”

Thorin’s brows met in the middle of his forehead like a stormcloud. The elf king had a way of getting under his skin.

“Speak your peace, elf. I have no patience for words today.”

Thranduil nodded. “Very well. You have something of mine in that treasure hold of yours. Gems of white starlight. I would see them returned.”

“Aye, and a share of the gold as well,” Gloin asked sarcastically.

“If it would help you rid it of the dragon sickness,” Thranduil said lightly.

Thorin made to step forward, but Bilbo put a hand on his forearm. He could feel the Dwarf shift, inclining himself more towards Bilbo.

“You say these gems are of value to you,” Thorin said, “what are they to you, really? I have seen finer settings, certainly.”

Thranduil tensed, eyes traveling over the company one by one.

“...they were my wife’s,” he said at last, “I had tried and failed to retrieve them when the beast was alive. I ask again for fairness, Thorin. I ask for what is owed me.”

Bilbo’s grip tightened.

“Very well,” Thorin said, turning away. “I will dispatch an envoy to return them to you on the steps of Dale.”

Thranduil smiled. “And in return—”

“Nothing,” Thorin said sharply. “I ask nothing. You stay in your trees. Don’t bother us. We will do the same.”

The elf had the gall to look affronted, but then shrugged it off.

“As you will,” he said, “but you cannot stop me from trading with the human city.”

“Nor can I stop them,” Thorin said, “but that is their business. Our business has long concluded.”

To Thranduil's retreating back, Bilbo piped, “there is one thing you might do. Clean up the Mirkwood a bit, it was bloody havoc traveling through last time.”

Thranduil turned. “It appears I have not met one of your number. What manner of Dwarf are you?”

“Not a Dwarf, I'm a Hobbit, and where I'm from people do well to maintain their paths and gardens.”

Thraduil smiled, but his eyes were cold. The soldiers turned as one to look at him. Bilbo could feel the company behind him tense.

“And who are you to make such demands?”

“No demands, just friendly advice. You are ruler over the Mirkwood, are you not?”

“Do you see another here to make that claim?”

“And yet you never saw me,” Bilbo looked at the soldiers. “ You never saw me. It’s a wonder you can detect anything through that mess of webs and horrid creatures.

Thranduil seemed taken aback.

“...I suppose,” he said at length, “we have been lax in our civic duties. But mark me, diminutive one, I consider this a boon. You owe me gratitude.”

“Yes,” Bilbo said, “thirteen  barrel’s worth.”

The dwarves tittered, hiding their mirth as soon as the elf king glanced at them.

“I hate to break up the proceedings,” Bard said, “but another company approaches.”

Raising a dust cloud as they tramped over the hills to the north, the Dwarvish army marched down upon the valley where Erebor’s keep lay.

Bilbo squinted. “Is that...is that a pig he rides?”

“Warthog,” Bofur said cheerily.

“Can none of you find a normal steed?” Bilbo asked indignantly, as Thorin strode out to meet them.

“Hail Dáin, son of Náin.” Thorin held his arms wide.

“Cousin! I heard you had finally slain the wee beastie! What a bonnie day is this!” Dáin dismounted his steed and moved to meet Thorin, arms similarly upraised. As one, they locked arms and exchanged a collision of foreheads.

“Well met, lad.” Dáin dabbed at one watering eye. “I couldnae believe it when they told me you meant to take back the mountain with such a small company.” His eye caught Bilbo. “Hello, and who is this bonnie lass? You dinnae tell me you’d found a wife already.”

Bilbo crossed his arms and made a very displeased face.

“Dáin, this is Bilbo Baggins, our master burglar.” Thorin spoke in a controlled tone, as if fighting off laughter. A snort sounded behind him and Bilbo silenced it with a fierce look. “He is a hobbit from the Shire.”

Dáin gave another look. “My apologies lad, with your soft features I assumed...I kenna tell your people apart on a good day.”

“Well your women grow beards,’ Bilbo muttered.

“What’s that?”

Bilbo cleared his throat. “We’re so glad you're here, it will be good to have a loyal army in attendance. You see—”

“Cousin,” Thorin broke in, speaking so that he would not be overheard. “Before his death, the dragon swallowed the Arkenstone. It is with him in the lake.”

Dáin sucked in a breath. “By Durin’s beard, that is a problem. That stone was the mark of kingship.”

“Yes, and will you tell the other dwarf lords that if they want to take the throne from him they can jolly well face down their own dragon?” Bilbo said testily.

The Dwarves fell silent, staring at the Hobbit.

Dáin chuckled. “That wee one, I like him. You’ve got fire, lad.”

“I’ve had enough fire, thank you,” Bilbo shifted uncomfortably. “I’d like a little peace now, is all.”

“Well, I can lend you my support, but the recognition of your rule falls to the people.”

“That is enough,” Thorin said, “when they hear I have restored our homeland, they will—”

The hellish blast of a war-horn cut him off. Over the western ridge came an army of orcs, warg riders, and trolls.

“Okay now this is just getting comical,” Bilbo said as the other dwarves moved to stand in front of him. Bard nocked an arrow. 

The war-horns fell silent as the army came across not a small company of dwarves as they expected, but an army of many different folk armed to the teeth. After a standstill of several awkward minutes the Mordorian army began shuffling awkwardly backwards.

Fire lit in Dáin’s eyes. “After them.”

Notes:

I know this chapter ended up being a bit lighter than the others, I figured it was getting kind of heavy so it would be nice to have a break.

Chapter 10

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

After the skirmish against the gobin forces (during which Gandalf arrived, once again late to the excitement) things settled in their own way. Bard rode back to Dale, Thranduil rode back to Mirkwood, and Dáin’s people camped out before Erebor. Some old greybeards wept like children as they touched the stones. With all the reverence they showed as they approached the place, you would have thought it was a temple.

Thorin was now tasked with doling out the treasure, which Bilbo could see he did with a heavy heart. He remained on hand to watch for dragon sickness. Beside him was Balin, who did the same. Into a gilt box, Thorin put the necklace of white gems, dispatching it by runner to Dale. Each of the company of thirteen was now bid to come and claim their share. Bilbo dismissed himself, making the feeble excuse that he would make the choice after the others had taken their fill. In truth he did not feel like he deserved any of it. What had he really done for the quest but delay the inevitable, give Smaug the chance to steal the Arkenstone? He exiled himself to Thorin’s old room, thinking it would give him peace from the others.

There was a knock at the door frame; the door itself sat irretrievably crooked on its hinges.

“What...is that?”

Thorin smiled, having unfurled the shirt before his chest so Bilbo could see it was not solid material but a fine mesh.

“Mithril. It will stop any blade. The first of many gifts, I hope.”

Heat rose in Bilbo’s cheeks. “I...I don’t know if I can accept it, it looks so…” expensive, polished, intimate . “...big.”

“You may wear it as a dress so long as it protects you.” Thorin held it up. Bilbo, surrendering to reason, bowed his head and allowed the slinky material to flow over him. It was cold, but there was a cleanness to the cold.

Thorin turned him to look at a polished bronze mirror that had been leaned against the wall. “Suits you, I think.”

Bilbo brushed his hands over it. He couldn’t help but smile a bit. 

“Oh, but what is this?” A ringing filled Bilbo’s ears as Thorin caught hold of the chain around his neck. He began pulling—

“No!” Bilbo blurted out, dancing away. “...no need to help me off with that. Smaug...gave it to me, so I suppose that means I technically stole it. I’m a burglar but I like to think I'm an honest one. Give me but a moment and I'll have it back.”

Thorin smiled puzzledly. “No need. Keep whatever trinkets you like, your share is yours. I have to wonder why he would gift you anything, seeing how greedy he was.”

The thought of mentioning the ring gave Bilbo nausea. “W-well, it wasn’t really like he was giving me anything. I was a thing to him, and he was decorating me with another of his things.”

“Ah.” Thorin cast a thoughtful glance down at the mithril shirt.

Bilbo spoke, because he too could see the parallels and could not stand the thought of them being anything alike. “Th-thank you. For the shirt, I mean. Smaug could never give me anything useful.” He turned back to the mirror, brushing and preening.

“Do you feel for the dragon?” Thorin asked.

Bilbo’s shoulders fell. He had been dreading this line of questioning.

“I feel...pity for him,” he said carefully, “for even in his intellect he truly was a beast. He could be generous in his own way, but only for the fleeting amusement it brought him. He couldn’t dream, did you know that? Even dogs can dream, but he couldn’t.”

Thorin was quiet for a moment. “They say the first dragon was created by Morgoth. It is no wonder a creature created for such an evil end had no real life.”

Biblo sighed, frustrated. “But that’s why I found him pitiable, you see? He could not grow, he could not change. I found myself almost hoping that...that he would. That I had reached him.”

“That you had found a soft spot?” a smile ghosted Thorin’s lips. “You had. You are adept at it.”

‘He flatters and flirts with acumen,’ Smaug hissed.

Bilbo swallowed. “Well, I like to think it’s more than that—”

“It is. You bring out the better nature in those around you. You hold onto this ridiculous notion of civility that you insist must apply everywhere and…” Thorin sighed. “...sometimes you are right.”

Bilbo put his hand on Thorin’s heart. On the place the missing scale had been on Smaug.

“Perhaps I'm not all good,” he said haltingly. “Perhaps we were more alike than you know.” he felt the sickness of the ring stir against him. Once again Thorin smiled the patronizing smile of the dwarves. 

“We are all like the dragon, in our turn. In my darker moments, I was tempted to clutch everything to my chest.”

“Yes, well, that’s more understandable. You’d lost so much. I—``Bilbo could not speak, his throat choked the truth off before it could air. He could tell no one of the ring.

Thorin kissed his brow. “I know, master Baggins. Was it pity first stirred your heart for me?”

Biblo grit his teeth. “Annoyance.”

“Really?” Thorin seemed amused.

“You came into my house barking orders, eating my food. I was all set not to come on the quest, you remember, and then the next morning…” he trailed off.

“What, you had a crisis of conscience?” Thorin joked.

“...the next morning I couldn’t stop thinking about you,'' Bilbo whispered. “Your song echoed in my bones. I knew I wasn’t going to be able to stop thinking about you for a long time. Suddenly the thought of never seeing you again…” he cleared his throat. “I suppose that sounds silly. I’m sure you had no such moment with me that night.”

“Indeed. I thought the wizard had finally taken leave of his senses. (Bilbo deflated somewhat) I was utterly shocked when you joined us. I suppose…” he looked thoughtful. “I suppose it wasn’t any one moment. You chipped away at me bit by bit, until you were always in my thoughts. I was constantly frustrated for your safety. Do you know Balin and Bofur had to talk me out of sending you back halfway?”

Bilbo looked at him, incensed. “Well now I do!”

“I nearly left you with Beorn because...because I was not worth it, do you see? The dwarves who swore their loyalty were kith and kin—”

“And you have kin that stayed at home,” Bilbo said, “they stayed because they do not see in you what we see in you and if I hear you devalue yourself again—”

Thorin kissed him then, to shut him up. Bilbo took it and was thankful for an end to the conversation.

“You will see Erebor restored,” Thorin murmured against his lips, “I promised you that, didn’t I? You will see my people once again thrive, and they will welcome you as I do.”

Bilbo swallowed. “That sounds like a bit of an uphill tread.”

Thorin took his hands up, holding them as if they were precious jewels. “You have the protection of the king behind you.”

 

Day by day, more dwarves streamed into Erebor. Some wept, for they had not seen home in many years, and it had remained home in their hearts. Some had never seen it before and wept for the potentiality it held, for there was no city grander in design.

And day by day...Bilbo felt he belonged less. The company did not fracture but was drifting apart by circumstance. Balin and Dwalin took up their places as advisor and war chief, respectively. Fili and Kili were named princes of Erebor. Everyone of the original company found a station in the kingdom, just as Thorin had said. 

Everyone except Bilbo. 

The more dwarves arrived to fill Erebor, the more alone he was. Every man who greeted the dwarves of the company was immediately a cousin, or a brother, blood ties or not. But Bilbo was always just a hobbit, and there was only one of him.

And day by day...day by day Bilbo could feel the horrid clutch on him grow stronger. He felt ill as Thorin doled out the treasure, for perhaps the last of Smaug’s dragon-sickness had transferred to him. He had been wrong in saying that no one would think of the beast after his death. Smaug had made his grave in Bilbo’s mind, his words had dug the hole. He began having nightmares of Thorin idly reaching out to touch him, brushing the ring by accident...and meeting his end as Bilbo strangled him. His waking hours were no less stressful, he jumped at every shadow. It didn’t help that he always seemed to be in the way of whatever dwarf was closest to him. Oh, if only he were back at Bag End! There were a thousand places he could keep the ring close but not on him. His mother's jewelry box. That awful tin where he kept buttons. The secret drawer in his mantel clock. Here he had to wear it constantly, paranoid at the slightest touch.

The dwarven nobles who had come calling to the city had been surprised at the king taking a companion from another race, but they had appeared appeased when Thorin defended him. But more of them came every day, and as they amassed in numbers the talk became stronger. Bilbo knew the longer he stayed there, the harder it would be on Thorin.

And so one day he found himself with bags packed, a small pony at his side (with a small box of treasure, modest yet still enough to buy the Shire many times over) Gandalf astride a white nag.

“You sure you mean to leave this way? Slip away like a thief in the night?” the wizard puffed on his pipe.

“It must be. I’ve never been one for long goodbyes…” Bilbo sniffed, blinking rapidly. “Could you tell them farewell for me?”

Gandalf gestured with his pipe. “Why don’t you tell them yourself?”

Bilbo turned to find twelve of the original company streaming over the bridge.

“Bilbo lad, where’re you going?” Bofur was the first to reach him and pull him into a rib-creaking embrace. “You can’t leave now, things are just beginning to pick up!”

Bilbo's eyes watered. He fought to keep his voice steady. “I must. Leaves are falling all around, it’s time I was on my way. But still, I'm much obliged to you gentlemen for such a pleasant stay.”

“Pleasant, he says,” Dwalin sounded hoarser than usual. “That’s what the lad calls hard-won peace. This is thanks to you, you ken?” he seized Bilbo’s shoulder in a crushing grip.

Bilbo smiled, wincing. “Yes, but...it is your peace. I have helped restore you to your homes...and now I must repair to mine.”

Balin alone smiled understandingly. “I see it, lad. But you’ll not be taking leave without—”

The thick wooden door behind them flung open. Thorin paced rapidly up to them, fast even under the weight of the king’s robe and crown.

“They told me—” he choked. “I did not believe them. Stay.”

Bilbo had to look away, lest the tears begin uncontrollably. “I wish I could, I really do. But I am a Baggins, of Bag End. And while I find you lads to be the best company I've ever had…” his voice broke. “...I do not belong here.”

“Tell me who has spoken against you and I'll have him out,” Thorin said.

Bilbo smiled miserably. “But that’s just it then. You can’t think like that when you’re king. I am a weak spot, so long as I stay here. You will be thinking of the kingdom second, when you must put it first.”

Thorin said hollowly; “I have put my people first my entire life, must I never have one thing for myself?”

Bilbo approached him, laying a hand over his heart. “You can. I am yours, wherever I go. That is why I leave, to protect your heart. It stays safe with me.”

Thorin took a shuddering breath. “...you will be all the way back in your Shire.”

“Yes, that’s the idea.”

“A king cannot go visiting anytime he pleases.”

“No, a king cannot,” Bilbo said, “but a simple dwarf could. He could slip unnoticed past Bree and into the shire, for the unenlightened folk could not tell one dwarf from another.”

Thorin swallowed. “That...is indeed something to think about.”

Bilbo looked at the company. Not a dry eye between them. “I really must go. The Sackville-Bagginses will have auctioned off my house.” He laughed so that he would not cry. “You are all welcome, any time. Tea is at four. Don’t bother knocking.” 

The dwarves laughed, and they swept him up for a last round of embraces and handshakes. For they were a warm people, Bilbo reflected, and a fine people, and if he had not been born a hobbit he would have been proud to call them his.

Thorin waited until he was saddled on his pony before pulling Bilbo over to kiss him. “Amrâlimê.”

Bilbo flushed. “I...don’t know what that means.”

Thorin smiled. “I think you do.”

Bilbo wanted very much not to look back, for he knew it would hurt. But the whole of the valley, until he rode over the hills out of sight, he turned and looked back at Erebor. And each time the company was still there, waving goodbye.

 

“...and what happened then?” the sprightly ten-year-old bounced in his seat.

“What happened when?” Bilbo rapped his forehead with the mail he’d just fetched. “Don’t bounce so, the springs in that are older than these hills.”

“Did you find any adventure on your way back?”

Bilbo  settled himself. “My dear Frodo, the return journey is always faster than the first. All the adventure has been used up the first round.”

“And did the dwarves come?”

Bilbo smiled a little to himself. “Oh...here and there. Never all at once like they had. I don’t think my plumbing could withstand another party like that, anyway.”

“Will I ever see one?”

Bilbo tapped him on the nose. “That, my lad, remains to be seen. You know what today is, don’t you?”

Frodo made a face. “Thursday?”

“Durin’s day. A very important day for them. And every year I put out some of the good port, and that cheese they seemed to like, just in case.”

Frodo bounced again. “I’m too excited to sleep, I wish they’d get here already.”

“That is up to chance. They have their own kingdoms now, their own quests—”

There was the faint sound of the latch undoing, and the creak of a door swinging open. A sudden, sharp breeze made the candle flames dance.

Bilbo turned around with a smile.

Notes:

Yes I quoted Zeppelin. deal with it.

and that is the end of my plot bunny, folks. I hope you enjoyed it and will join me on my next trashfire of an idea.