Work Text:
Thorin stopped the pony just before the entrance to the Shire, noticing that the path was much clearer in the daylight.
He closed his eyes, taking a deep breath. The mix of nature, pipe weed and freshly baked bread reminded him of Bilbo, not because this was what he smelled like, but because these simple pleasures made him think of Bilbo. Many domestic comforts reminded him of Bilbo these days, perhaps out of a certain nostalgia for a peaceful and simple life that he never had, or perhaps because Bilbo reminded him to be someone he wouldn’t regret being.
He tapped his pony on the side and carried on his way. Bilbo was expecting him, and he wouldn’t leave him waiting.
Once he made the last turn, he saw that Bilbo was sitting in front of his house, leisurely smoking under the late afternoon sun. As soon as he saw Thorin, he stood up, waving with both arms widely, more signaling than greeting. Thorin would be offended by the implication that he couldn’t find his destiny, but Bilbo’s concern was oddly endearing. He was taken by a sudden urge to leave his pony and run to Bilbo, but he fought the urge as ridiculous. Instead, he raised a hand to acknowledge him, and continued on his way.
Bilbo rushed to the gate before Thorin got there, so when he dismounted they were face to face. Bilbo gave him a large smile, and Thorin took him by the shoulders to touch their foreheads, feeling some of the weight strangling his heart finally be lifted from his chest.
“”I’ve missed you, my friend,” Thorin said, his eyes closed as he enjoyed their contact.
“I’m glad you finally accepted my invitation, it’s been too long,” Bilbo said, not doing anything to move away.
They kept the hug for slightly longer than it would be proper, and when they finally separated it was Bilbo who spoke first.
“You must be starving from the road, come inside, I have been waiting for you for tea.”
Thorin smiled. Bilbo had mentioned many times in his letters that he had yet to experience hobbit hospitality in its entirety, and he suspected that this might involve a lot more meals than he knew how to name. He followed Bilbo inside, already starting to be contaminated by that cheerful but quiet energy that Bilbo seemed to possess. Perhaps Balin was right, and this trip would help him find what he was searching for.
-
It felt strange, being unarmed and without any armor outside of his own bed chambers. Even among friends, his people’s custom was to hold on to their weapons, not as a sign of distrust of their host, but as an indication of a general readiness for battle that was expected even inside their halls.
Thorin didn’t plan on shedding his weapons, despite knowing that the Shire was safer than even the innermost chambers under the mountain, protected by something far more effective than stone walls and imposing gates: disinterest. The people there lived a simple life and didn’t meddle in the affairs of other people, and they had nothing that would interest anyone else to the point of waging war.
However, it was this safety that changed his mind, but Bilbo, by offering him a chest by the door to place his weapons, and proudly exhibiting his embroidered cloths he made for the express purpose of wrapping weapons. It was endearing, in a way that Thorin couldn’t find himself refusing. He was a guest in Bilbo’s home, and he could follow this request, could respect the peace he so admired about the Shire.
Thorin sat at the table and watched as Bilbo retrieved several items from the pantry, having been told in no uncertain terms that Bilbo would rather not have another dwarf digging through his pantry after a long journey, and that hobbit hospitality would be better served by not allowing his guest to be of any help.
Bilbo brought the tea set, a selection of cheese, a loaf of bread, no less than five different kinds of jam, and a pie still warm from the oven, although he couldn’t have known for certain the time of Thorin’s arrival.
“You’ll love this,” Bilbo said, starting to cut the pie as soon as he sat down around the corner from Thorin, “it’s my mother’s famous rhubarb pie recipe, known as far as Bree.”
“Well, now you can say it’s known as far as Erebor, although it isn’t necessary to prepare as big a meal for just the two of us,” Thorin said, accepting the slice. He took a bite, it was crusty on the outside and moist and flavourful in the middle. “It’s delicious, but I don’t want to burden you during this visit.”
“Oh, it’s no trouble, I assumed you might be hungry from the road, and you have always been welcome to stay with me, this visit will bring me nothing but joy. Tell me, how was your journey?”
“Uneventful. I encountered no orcs on the way, although one night I heard the distant calls of wolves.”
Part of the reason was that he no longer was on a mission followed so closely by his enemies, but perhaps traveling alone contributed to keeping his journey bloodless. It was much easier to ride without being noticed, and hide if necessary, when he was by himself.
“I’m glad to hear.” Bilbo glanced down. “I feared for you, traveling by yourself all this way.”
Thorin lifted his chin so that he could look at him.
“Nothing would have prevented me from keeping my promise of meeting you again. I know I could find a safe path here, no matter the challenge.”
Bilbo blushed, and placed a hand over Thorin’s. “I was afraid we would never meet again after I left Erebor. I had this sense of dread, as if I was abandoning something that meant a great deal to me.” Then, it was as if a spell had been broken, Bilbo shook his head, moving slightly away from Thorin’s touch. “What am I saying? You didn’t come all this way to listen to the ramblings of an old hobbit. Tell me about the mountain, how are the rebuilding efforts going?”
Thorin ate another piece of pie to give himself time to think. In truth, he had already shared much of the news in his frequent letters, but he feared Bilbo was dancing around the question he wanted to ask in earnest, why Thorin had finally taken him up on his offer, and why now, when there was seemingly much to be done under the mountain. Neither question he would be willing to answer, not when he barely knew the reason himself.
He left because he could no longer stay, but what he was seeking and what he should do next were still mysteries. For once he was lost, without purpose, having achieved everything he sought out to achieve and still being faced with the rest of his life.
“Erebor will soon be known once again as one of the great kingdoms of the dwarves, our relationship to Dale is flourishing, and we have even started tentative trades with the elves. I still don’t trust them, but Fili has made a case for keeping good relations with our neighbors. He has grown wiser than his years in a short time.”
He was proud of him, Fili would make a good king, the king his people needed, the king they deserved.
“I would love to visit again, but I’m afraid I may have had more than my fair share of adventure for a lifetime. I wouldn’t want my relatives declaring me dead again. Lobelia Sackville-Baggins is so eager to get my silverware that I think she may bury me if I take too long to open the door. You better watch out for her or she’ll take the beads off your beard.”
Thorin smiled. He would never make light of Bilbo’s worries, but mundane problems came as a welcome reprieve from the stresses of their exile and the rebuilding of a kingdom in ruins.
“You’ve mentioned some of this in your letters. I hope your kin hasn’t judged you too harshly for our adventure, and recognize your heroic efforts.”
It was the perfect thing to say, because Bilbo then went on to complain about his neighbors and distant relatives, who labeled him a dangerous rebel who enjoyed seeking trouble and starting fights. It made him think of what he first thought of Bilbo, before discovering his skill and bravery, having seen only a sheltered halfling softened by a life of peaceful comforts. Perhaps the truth of Bilbo’s character lay somewhere in between.
Thorin just listened as Bilbo talked, only occasionally agreeing with him or adding a question, taken by the weight Bilbo gave to these inane problems even after facing a dragon and an army of orcs. Despite all the suffering and great battles, having the greatest achievement he could hope for in his life, Bilbo could still find purpose in the simple life he led before. It was all Thorin could hope to find for himself.
-
As Bilbo refused to accept any help preparing dinner, Thorin took this time to settle in his room and wash from the road. Bilbo’s home was fairly large, especially for a hobbit living alone, but it hadn’t been enough with the addition of thirteen dwarves and a wizard, so now he insisted on giving Thorin better accommodations.
It wasn’t lost on Thorin that the bedding had the colors of the house of Durin. Bilbo also gave him an empty dresser and a chest to unpack his travel bag, much more space than he needed, as well as a way to say that he was welcome to stay for a long visit.
He lit the wood for the bath before unpacking. Although he wasn’t opposed to a cold bath, having grown used to them, he wouldn’t refuse heating when offered. He had packed for an extended trip, and by the time he was done putting away his things, the water was pleasantly warm. With a cloth, he washed away the dirty and dust before soaking in the tub, the warm water relaxing his tired muscles.
-
When Thorin returned, Bilbo had already set the table.
“Are we waiting for more company?” Thorin joked as he sat down.
“No one should leave a hobbit table hungry,” Bilbo said, sitting close to him. “Although this isn’t much, barely more than I would make for myself.”
Thorin looked around the table at the roasted lamb, mashed potatoes, vegetables, soup, pie, sliced flush, beans and salad. He found it hard to believe that Bilbo would have cooked all of this for himself, but he did mention food in his letters quite often, so perhaps that was an important element of hobbit culture.
“I can’t have you cooking for me like this every day of my stay. It would make me a poor guest,” Thorin said.
“I enjoy cooking, and I’m glad to share this with you.”
“I insist on helping. You have shared with me something of your people, and I would like to do the same. Cooking may not be my craft, but I know enough to prepare you a meal.”
He expected Bilbo to protest again, and was already preparing his next argument, but Bilbo surprised him by smiling widely.
“I would never pass on the opportunity to try new dishes. We can go to the market and get anything you might need.”
Bilbo’s glee was intoxicating, and Thorin was glad that he was able to cause this, especially with something as simple as an offer to cook dinner. He had never cooked for someone before, but he couldn’t stay there for several days or even weeks and do nothing to help.
“Of course,” Thorin replied, although he had just planned on seeing what Bilbo had in his pantry and trying to think of something. He was longing to experience a simple life that as a king, even in exile, never belonged to him, and worrying about what to buy for dinner was a perfect example of this type of life.
“I hope you are planning on staying for a while, I would love to show you some of our festivals. And you have to go to at least one birthday, I was invited to one of the big ones next month.”
“I didn’t say for how long I would be always. I could stay for a way, the journey is too long for a short visit.”
“You can stay for as long as you like. Or as long as your duties would permit it.”
It was what Thorin had been dreading, although he never hoped he could avoid the question for too long. He couldn’t find it in him to lie to Bilbo in his house and while he was his guest, but the truth was something he couldn’t yet verbalize. There was nothing that he could say that Bilbo wouldn’t eventually question, especially if his visit extended itself, so perhaps the best option was part of the truth. As much as he could make himself admit to.
“There wasn’t much for me to do in these times of peace. I left Fili in charge so he could learn to rule over a stable kingdom, rather than in a crisis. I will be easier for him this way,” Thorin said, trying to keep the sorrow from his voice.
He never learned how to rule over a peaceful kingdom, never learned to do anything but protect his people and try to keep their unity despite the distance as they scattered in exile. He kept word and his duty, and gave his people everything short of his life to return them to their rightful home. But after the dragon was slayed and the mountain reclaimed, his people still needed more and he didn’t know how to be the king that they deserved.
“Well, we have no kings and we only have times of peace, so perhaps those are the moments a society can run itself,” Bilbo said, breaking Thorin’s train of thought and releasing him from a spiral of doubt.
“I believe we still have much wisdom to learn from your people.”
And that was true. During the time that they traded letters and even before, on their journey, he had come to learn some things about the way of life of the hobbits, and the more he learned, the more he found that there was some sort of great wisdom in their simple way of life. What they valued and what they chose to ignore seemed to afford them a rare level of peace and contentment, as well as plentiful meals and comfortable shelter.
As much as he spent all of his life cherishing Erebor, it was still, whatever else it might be, a fortress first and foremost. The threat of an attack would never be too far away from a rich kingdom. So in a way, he couldn’t help but wonder if the treasures were worth the suffering.
After this, he moved the conversation towards food, hoping that Bilbo hadn’t noticed his exitance, or would at least afford him the courtesy of not inquiring further.
-
As it were, their trip to the market only happened after a couple of days. Once Thorin wrote down a list, having chosen the best examples of dwarven cuisine he wished to introduce to Bilbo, or at least the best ones he could reliably make, Bilbo had decided on the best day to go shopping in order to guarantee the freshest materials.
In the time Thorin was there, he hadn’t yet met many other hobbits, having spent most of the time in Bilbo’s home, or in long walks with him through most empty fields. The abundance of the hobbits’ crops despite their lack of wealth fascinated him, and he enjoyed these quiet moments with Bilbo after spending so long with his attention always needed, always pressing issues to resolve with so many people.
So it was the third day of his visit when Bilbo handed him a large basket, took his arm and guided him towards the market.
“You have to know which stands to go to, and don’t just judge them by what is on display. Almost everyone has better produce hidden away,” Bilbo said on their way there, then proceeded to give him detailed information on every farmer who would be selling at the market.
Thorin listened, and tried to remember at least some of what Bilbo was saying, although it would be impossible to retain everything.
"What should we procure first?" he asked as they arrived, their short walk taking longer due to the leasure pace.
Thorin glanced at the list, partially regretting his choice of dishes, as they would probably spend hours shopping for all items.
Bilbo paused, glancing at both vendors and shoppers, no doubt looking for the people he would rather avoid.
"Potatoes," he said, pulling Thorin along, "we need to get to them before all the small ones are gone."
As they walked, Thorin noticed many people staring at them, or perhaps staring at him. He didn't know if this was caused by seeing someone of a high social class with a stranger, or perhaps simply because their isolationist ways meant they seldom had visitors from other peoples. However, if Bilbo saw anything, he didn't react, so Thorin decided to follow his lead. It wasn't the first time that he felt unwelcome among other people, and it probably wouldn't be the last, but he wouldn't allow that to ruin his time with Bilbo, however long it turned out to be.
-
Cooking for Bilbo, Thorin soon found out, wasn't a possibility as long as he was around, and instead his plans for dinner transformed into cooking with Bilbo.
"Should the mushrooms be cut diagonally?" he asked, taking a few from Thorin's pile and starting to cut them himself.
"It's not necessary as much as for presentation," Thorin replied, having given up on making Bilbo sit back and allow him to cook alone, as Bilbo seemed too enthusiastic about learning new recipes to fulfill their agreement.
"I'm sorry we couldn't find the right ones, I suppose our forests aren't dark enough."
In truth, Thorin had found their variety of produce much greater, and had trouble choosing a replacement among so many different kinds he knew nothing about. He wonder if Bilbo realized through their journey what he had in the Shire.
"I suspect these might make for a better dish, as they are heartier."
"Is that enough time for the garlic in the oven?"
"It should be. Can you take them out?"
Bilbo's arm brushed against his back as the crossed the kitchen towards the oven. In the seamless way they moved together in the kitchen, Thorin saw something close to a domesticity, and wondered when they had grown so accustomed to each other. Was this the result of their few days together now, spent walking around nature and talking about anything and nothing? Or maybe something that had grown from their traded letters, hundreds of pages of conversations that perhaps could be had with no one else? Perhaps even it had been there since some point of their journey, so long and yet concluded so fast.
Bilbo brought the freshly baked garlic and put it over the counter top. "I never heard of this technique, how should we peel them?"
"Allow me to show you," Thorin said, taking Bilbo's hands in his and demonstrating the cut, before showing him how to remove the newly formed cream.
Although his plan had been cooking for Bilbo as a way to thank his hospitality, he found that he would much rather they do this together.
-
After dinner, they settled in front of the fireplace. Not on the sofa but in front of it, closer to the fire on top of the soft carpet. As they shared a glass of wine, Bilbo rested his head on Thorin’s shoulder.
They had spent most of the dinner talking, and now their conversation dwindled, and they were content simply staying in each other’s presence.
“Would you sing to me?” Bilbo asked after a while, his voice tinted with the type of drowsiness that came from resisting sleep.
“I don’t know any songs for the comforts of home,” he said, shifting his arm to wrap it around Bilbo.
Bilbo snuggled closer to him. “It could be anything, I enjoy your voice.”
Thorin moved his thumb soothing up and down Bilbo’s shoulder, and Bilbo reached up to take his hand. Thorin took a deep breath, trying to remember a suitable song, and started to sing. Songs rusty in his memory, from a distant past before the mountain fell, before he knew of pain and loss, when he was still so sure of his destiny and of his place.
He sang until he lost track of time, and by the time he stopped, he noticed that Bilbo had fallen asleep. He considered waking Bilbo so that he might go to bed, but he looked so peaceful that Thorin couldn’t bring himself to do it.
Careful not to wake him, Thorin took Bilbo in his arms, carrying him to bed. He placed a blanket over him, and sparing one last glance to make sure he was settled, went back to his room.
That night, he had trouble sleeping. He felt on the verge of a realization, the songs reminded him that he was able to save their home for everyone but him, and he wondered if there would ever be a place where he could feel at home again.
-
The next time Bilbo went to the market, Thorin declined to accompany him, instead going to procure wood and later chopping the logs for use at the fireplace. He was still cutting the logs when Bilbo came back.
“You should have come along,” Bilbo said, and it took Thorin by surprise, because he hadn’t heard him arrive, “everyone asked me about you.”
Thorin sighed. It wasn’t simply an impression then. “I hope they haven’t bothered you too much on my account.”
“I gave up on shopping halfway through the list. Everyone wanted to know about the ‘tall handsome stranger’,” he said, sounding slightly bothered. “I was asked many times if you were already wed, and if you had any interest in a hobbit spouse.”
Thorin turned to Bilbo, studying the annoyance on his face. “Marriage means a great deal to my kin, and most dwarves will never marry. However, being of a different kin would not be an impediment, although I don’t think I ever heard of a marriage between a dwarf and a hobbit.”
Bilbo blushed. “I’ll put away the groceries.”
As he left, Thorin wondered if he had said something wrong, because he couldn’t understand Bilbo’s reaction.
-
Again, Thorin had trouble sleeping. Increasingly he realized how glad he was to stay there with Bilbo, which only served to further prove that he had no place to return to.
The mountain wasn’t his home, not anymore, and he tried to make it home again, tried to be what was needed of him, but in his heart he knew it was too late. He thought that reclaiming the mountain and bringing back his people, reuniting them once again, would be enough to erase all the pain he suffered there, but he felt Smaug’s presence in every hall and every chamber. A suffocating shadow that strangled him at every quiet moment, but even seeking to be active during the entire day did nothing to prevent the sensation from coming at even the most minute of pauses.
He was meant to travel to relieve some of his stress before it took him to an early grave, and to seek a new purpose, but although he had succeeded in the first, he wasn’t sure he made much progress in the second.
The only thing he knew was that he didn’t want to leave, and yet he couldn’t stay there indefinitely. Could he?
-
They had been walking for a couple hours, hand in hand, enjoying the fresh but still pleasant spring air, when Bilbo pointed at a tree, standing alone on the edge of the hill.
“This is a nice place to rest,” he said, sitting down with his back against the trunk.
Thorin glanced at the homes below, only a short distance away. It was quiet there, only adding to his perception of a peaceful and tranquil life there. He sat down next to Bilbo, their shoulders almost touching.
He refused the pipe Bilbo offered him, and as Bilbo prepared his own, he closed his eyes, enjoying the quiet.
“You had talked about the virtues of this place, but I don’t think I understood until I came here. My heart is light as it hadn’t been since I was but a pebble under the mountain.”
As strange as it was to feel at home so far away from his people, he couldn’t help but feel that life there came to him more naturally than being King ever could. Perhaps he had been away from the mountain for too long, or perhaps his grandfather’s greed had poisoned the crown to him, but he had no desire to return, and didn’t regret his choice to leave.
“It has been better with you here, I’m seen as too much of an adventurer,” he paused, placing a hand between them, “I wish you would stay.” It was painfully earnest, not a polite invitation, but a legitimate yearning.
Thorin sighed. He had avoided telling Bilbo the truth for too long already, but perhaps now he knew enough to know what to say. “I could stay. I am no longer the King Under the Mountain.”
It was the first time he said aloud, or even put it in these terms. He had been at Fili’s coronation, setting the example for his people that this was the king they should follow, but letting go of the crown was easier than abandoning the title. For so long he was a king with no kingdom, and now he didn’t know who he was without that.
“What happened?”
If only he knew, perhaps he could have fixed it before it was too late.
“It wasn’t one thing, but so many little details that made me realize I could never find peace there, and I couldn’t be the King my people needed. I lead them this far, but I can’t…” he paused, unable to continue. Then Bilbo took his hand, squeezing it tight. “They need a King who can look at the mountain and see a prosperous kingdom so they can be led there, not one who can see only ghosts of all that was destroyed, all that was lost.”
He tried the best he could, but something had been broken in him, not exactly in the same way that his grandfather and his father suffered, but still something necessary to rule. If he had insisted, continued to carry the crown despite his reservations, it would likely consume him, until there was nothing left that was good and worthy of being a king. Perhaps he had even carried on for too long already, although the last few weeks told him that he could still heal.
“You passed on the crown to Fili then.” It wasn’t a question, and it wasn’t an accusation. Despite his fears, Bilbo seemed to understand his actions.
He nodded. “It was always my intention, although I didn’t think it would happen this soon. I took him as my heir long ago, when he was still very small, and I was advanced in years enough to believe I wouldn’t find love.” He squeezed Bilbo’s hand back, he had gone this far, he shouldn’t hold anything back now. “Although my mistake was not thinking I could find it outside of my kin. You have proven me wrong.”
Thorin hadn’t realized this when he came to the Shire, although he had sought Bilbo to help him decide what to do once he passed on the crown. Perhaps he should have known that this was what brought him there, that love was what lessened the pain in his heart from a lifetime of loss, and what he was seeking when feeling lost himself.
In truth, he felt at home since coming there not because of anything special about the Shire, although he had grown to appreciate their simple way of life and peaceful ways, but because of Bilbo. He felt at home with Bilbo, wherever they were.
Bilbo leaned in, resting his head on Thorin’s shoulder. “I could say the same happened to me, although I didn’t dare hoping my feelings would be reciprocated.”
Thorin remembered Bilbo’s annoyance at the interest other hobbits demonstrated towards him, finally understanding his reaction. “Then I have been a fool because it took me too long to realize this.”
“Would you stay with me then?”
Thorin kissed him on the top of the head. “Nothing would bring me more joy, if you’ll have me.”
Bilbo turned to face him. “I could wish for nothing more.”
The earnestness of his words warmed Thorin’s heart. Bilbo made him believe that a peaceful life with his loved one was worth more than any kingdom and any riches, that this could truly be all that he needed to be happy. Maybe this was the reason why the greed of the gold sickness couldn’t fully take hold of him, because of that seed of love that showed him that he could have all he needed to be happy and none of that would be found in a treasure room.
Thorin placed a hand on Bilbo’s chin and gave him a chaste kiss. This was his place and this was his choice, after all he did for his people he didn’t need any greater purpose than to live the rest of his days with his love.
