Work Text:
Bilbo had never intended to become friends with Klûk, the occasionally horrifying not-dwarf beloved of Gror, son of Fror. In truth, he would have chosen to forget Klûk, though their (admittedly not very pleasant) first meeting had rendered such forgetfulness impossible. That meeting has only come about as a result of the hobbit's inordinate Tookish curiosity. Thorin had taken him to the Hall of Mirrors and... well... there had been that giant mirror, and he just wanted to know, and... things got a bit out of hand. At any rate, finding out Klûk's true nature had shocked everyone present in the Halls of Durin-in-Erebor when Gror had convinced his unique partner to demonstrate his true (horrifying) form. Once the initial shock had worn off, Bilbo had shaken his head to the sound of Thorin's gentle ribbing about curiosity killing the hobbit, and that should have been that. And it would have been, except for one thing. Curiosity wasn't the only thing Bilbo had in abundance.
The first issue was that the first meeting with Prince Gror had not only revealed the subject of the oversized mirror. Said meeting had also made it clear to Bilbo that the miner did not seem to be what any dwarf (or hobbit) would call a wonderful spouse. The hobbit's lips pursed whenever he thought of the way that the miner had treated Klûk as more of a pet than a proper partner. Despite the obvious fact that the... whatever Klûk was... had seemed long accustomed to the miner's peccadilloes, Bilbo had Views on such things, and felt that nobody deserved to be treated in such a way. When he said as much to Thorin, he felt justified when his own husband made it clear that he shared the hobbit's opinions on the matter. Even so, opinions were common as crabgrass and about as valuable, as the Old Took had been fond of saying. It was very likely nothing would have happened if Bilbo hadn't liked to explore the Halls of Mahal when Thorin was busy. He was careful to always take at least one companion with him - strange dwarves had been known to be upset (or at least unnerved) by the sight of non-dwarves in the Halls (dwarves not being known for their love of other races, even unfamiliar ones). But there was just so much to see!
Quite a while after the initial meeting, he and Ori were exploring deep in the halls of what the hobbit thought should be the First Age Ironfists. The two were tracking rumors of a library when the hobbit saw a familiar fish-belly pale form sitting by... himself? itself?... on a bench and staring into space. Before Ori could say a word, Bilbo had stopped to speak.
"Hello again... Klûk, wasn't it? Lovely to see you," the hobbit said, smiling. Something about the set of the broad shoulders spoke of dejection, but the oil-black eyes that rose to his showed no recognizable emotion.
"I greet," came the rolling basso profundo response, head nodding in the vaguely serpentine motion Bilbo remembered. "Yes, Klûk I am. I memory? No... I remember..." the voice stopped, bunched jet-black hair sliding of its own volition across the shoulders of Klûk's tunic. "Baggins. Not-Eldest, but Ring carrier." Sharp teeth that belonged on a cave fish or goblin smiled oddly in a purplish mouth just a hair too wide to look normal. "Met in new Durin halls. About mirror."
"Indeed, indeed, Bilbo Baggins, at your service," Bilbo said, ignoring Ori's glaring, panic-stricken eyes while stepping forward. "I am surprised to see you here. What brings you to the Ironfist halls? Is your husband about?" Reaching out his hand, he dragged Ori forward. "And this is Ori, son of Vuori, I don't recall if you were properly introduced last time." Ori gave a credible bow, though his eyes still showed a ring of white around the irises and his hands were tense and clenched.
"I greet, I greet," Klûk rumbled with a second nod. "Gror meet with dwarfs here, want mine below... always want mine," the not-dwarf sighed. Bilbo had no idea whether Klûk's body language was the same as a normal dwarf's, but that looked like boredom to him. "Dig, dig, dig. I come sit. Nobody miss Klûk." Bilbo didn't want to feel bad but at this sentence, even spoken in the inflectionless deep voice, he felt his heart crack just a little. Glancing over at Ori, he saw an identical expression on the scribe's face. Well, he thought. Well then.
"Well, permit us to keep you company, then, if you would like. We were looking for the library, but we certainly can sit and visit for a bit." Bilbo's hobbitish social instincts were in full charge now, even as his mind cried out what on earth will we speak about? "What have you been doing since we spoke in the Halls of Durin-in-Erebor?" The ensuing conversation was stilted, not least from Klûk's odd and enigmatic way of speaking and somewhat limited vocabulary, but it went surprisingly smoothly considering the rocky start. Ori eventually overcame the worst of his nerves and began to contribute; when Klûk asked what a library was, Bilbo thought poor Ori would explode. That was good for fifteen minutes of (somewhat one-sided) talk on its own, and when Gror appeared from his mysterious meeting after an hour or so Bilbo invited Klûk (and Gror, keeping his sigh internal) to visit any time. What was said as a casual social comment was clearly taken seriously, as Klûk showed up less than a week later when Gror was busy with some other errand. It seemed despite Gror's claims to the contrary, the miner was not removed from the Durin obligations among his kin - his schedule was alternating bands of mining and visiting among the nobles of Khazad-Dûm, and when doing the latter, Klûk was not anyone's favorite guest.
After a few hesitant conversations, Bilbo finally asked the rather awkward question about the creature's preferred gender. He was unsure of how to refer to Klûk and didn't want to give offense, but was told upon asking that the whole concept of male and female was irrelevant to the Eldest (how Klûk referred to the not-race of beings who dwelled in what Klûk called 'the roots of the world'). It was, in fact, the first laugh Bilbo had heard Klûk give, an odd coughing sound. "Call whatever," he was told with another of those enigmatic too-wide, too-sharp smiles. "Klûk is all and none, like all Eldest. No parents or children we, Eldest just are." Bilbo finally settled on referring to his new friend as male for ease of reference, since Gror seemed to have done so; Klûk made it quite clear that he was utterly indifferent, since language itself was strange enough without worrying about referents.
Gror might not mind, but not everyone was so sanguine. Thorin was less than pleased with the burgeoning friendship, clearly still thinking of the horror that was Klûk's true form. Despite the hobbit's increasingly pointed admonishments, Bilbo's husband cast suspicious glances at the other whenever he appeared. Even so, Thorin had long since learned that Bilbo did as he pleased; after a dramatic bout of grumbling and worrying, he was finally forced to sigh and accept things. Bilbo would never have admitted it to his husband, but he had always been a bit bored (not terribly, but a bit) when Thorin would vanish into his forge for what seemed like days on end; now he had another companion to call on while he waited to see for whatever wonder his husband had just created. For their part most of the others in the Halls of Durin-in-Erebor still shuddered when the pale form glided in, jet-black hair glistening in the torchlight, but Bilbo found him decent enough company. After the initial encounter, Ori was similarly open-minded, though he still periodically made jokes about 'getting his warhammer' when Klûk was being particularly obscure (or obstreperous - the Eldest's ability to maintain a blank face was unmatched, for obvious reasons). Kili and Fili were wary but seemed fascinated in spite of themselves; ironically enough, as best Bilbo could tell, Klûk was confused by them on the few occasions when they tagged along, and wasn't that a funny thing?
During their conversations, Bilbo and Ori took it upon themselves to begin teaching the Eldest more words and helping him with his grammar, wondering the whole while that Gror had never bothered in the thousands of years they had been together. For his part, Gror seemed startled at first that others wanted to be friends with his One; it was obvious that he was so used to the dwarves shunning the (admittedly a bit unnerving) Klûk that he seemed taken aback when the hobbit One of his distant kinsman was undisturbed by Klûk's oddness. After the initial confusion, however, he simply shrugged, sending his One along to the Halls of Durin-in-Erebor whenever he thought of it.
For his own part, Gror became less unpleasant in Bilbo's eyes through the hobbit's association with Klûk. Upon deeper inspection, the miner didn't seem to be malicious, he was just... profoundly socially unaware. Bilbo had to admit that Gror really had found the perfect One, because according to Klûk the life of an Eldest was eating stone and wandering tunnels in near-constant solitude; there was no concept of boredom. An Eldest could sit, unmoving, for weeks or months on end - so he said, anyway, telling the occasional curious story from the deep places of the world in which he had lived before meeting Gror. From Klûk's perspective, Gror's inability to socialize was a benefit, or at least not a flaw. The Eldest never got lonely, never missed conversation - in truth, even after so long among dwarves, Klûk readily confessed that he found much of the society and social behaviors of the other race incomprehensible. Even Gror's rather antisocial tendencies to cause trouble were taken in stride by the Eldest, apparently seeming no more nor less odd than the feasts and boasting of Gror's Longbeard kin. Because of this, Bilbo sometimes wondered if Klûk found the additional company offered by the hobbit and friends annoying or oppressive, but he was always told "no" when he asked. The complete lack of expression and affect made the Eldest harder to read than anyone the hobbit had ever met, so he had to assume that the reply was offered in good faith.
The turning point of Klûk's acceptance from most of Bilbo's circle came during a visit to the Waterlight Bridge. Bilbo, Ori, Frerin, Fili and Kili had originally taken Klûk to visit the Halls of Music, but the sound of violins was harsh and offensive to him and he wanted to leave. Rather than have him leave alone they all accompanied him and took the path across the great bridge with its rainbows cast by elaborate lamps. Ori and his new shadow Frerin were accompanying Bilbo and the gliding, impassive form of the Eldest and the two youngest Durins were tagging along behind. Kili, in his usual madcap way, was rhapsodizing about the sight. "It's so tall, we can't even see down below, but imagine, Uncle!" he shouted at Bilbo over the roar of the falls, "If you dived off of this bridge, it would be amazing! You could soar like a bird!" Klûk seemed a bit distracted, though not by the shimmering rainbows; instead he was peering at the bridge's railing as though seeing something invisible, fishbelly pale hands fully outstretched and widespread fingers pressed against the stone.
"Aye, and end up as bird droppings," Frerin said with a smirk. Kili scoffed loudly, turning without paying much attention to Klûk.
"Frerin, you're worse than Thorin!" These were of course fighting words, and a scuffle broke out directly even though Kili's laughter was clearly audible. "You're always so pessimistic!" Kili yelled, throwing his hands up dramatically and making Ori dodge, distracting Frerin. Klûk nodded vaguely, cocking his head as though listening to something. "I think it would be incredible! I wish there was a way I could see the bottom, I bet it's amazing! I wonder if there's a pool down there? There has to be! I wonder..." Without a word, Klûk's body rippled, exploding outward into his true form as the others dodged back in surprise. This was rather shocking, as (after that first reveal) Klûk had seemed reticent about taking his original form around dwarves, doubtless as a result of his experiences with Gror during the miner's life in Khazad-Dûm. A black tentacle almost too swift to be seen wrapped around Kili's waist and hoisted him into the air.
"We go," came the Eldest's rumbled, laconic comment, and then the others watched in horror as the enormous, seething pile of oily blackness flung itself over the railing, a screaming Kili clutched in one tentacle held above it, and plummeted into the darkness below. They all screamed in shock; Ori ran to the edge, peering frantically into the mist while Bilbo stood there, stunned, wondering how he could have been so wrong about the creature he had thought until that moment that he was befriending. Fili was still shouting tearful threats into the flashing rainbows minutes later when a new sound could be heard... excited cheering. Almost faster than anyone could see, a shadowy, writhing mass slid onto one end of the bridge, having apparently scaled the vertical cliff while carrying a sopping wet and very thrilled Kili, dark hair plastered down to his skull. The young dwarf was set carefully down on the bridge as though nothing had happened. After a few moments of shock while everyone recalibrated their understanding of what had just taken place, Kili jumped up and down unsteadily but joyfully, drenched clothes and hair throwing droplets in all directions.
"Fili, Fili, you have to go! It's the best thing ever! Klûk, please please take him, please!" Kili pleaded in a positively manic voice. Fili gaped for a moment, clearly taken aback by Kili's abrupt reappearance. Finally he gave a hesitant nod and was immediately clutched in a shiny obsidian tentacle and held overhead to make the same trip. By the end of the day, they had all done it at least once (Bilbo with the most hesitance but, he reasoned, they were already dead, so...) The hobbit had to admit, it was exhilarating... in an utterly terrifying 'I'm about to die all over again' sort of way. The fall seemed to take forever, followed by a plunge into icy water; before one had a chance to realize how cold it was, the trip back to the bridge had commenced and the person was left dangling in space to watch the cataracts of falling water race by like tumbling diamonds. By the end of the excursion, Kili had made the trip so many times Bilbo began to worry that he would annoy Klûk with the asking, and Fili and Frerin were close behind. The final trip over the side saw Fili, Ori and Frerin held in the air as Klûk slid ponderously over the railings, and Bilbo hoped they would be alright - it seemed a bit much to ask of anyone. When they were back on the bridge he announced the end of the trip to cries of dissent, but he didn't think he imagined Klûk's nod of thanks. When they finally returned to the halls where they lived, dripping wet and thrilled, the sounds of joyous laughter and amusement were far louder than their squelching footsteps. Curious or disgusted looks from passing dwarves were completely ignored. From the point forward Bilbo's two nephews and Frerin were all keen to accompany the trio on their jaunts around the Halls in a search for what the young dwarves referred to as "undiscovered fun".
There was a lingering imbalance, though, and Bilbo didn't like it. Being a hobbit, he was determined to discover Klûk's tastes in food. Being a hobbit, he was likewise shocked and horrified by the reply when he asked. "Eldest eat anything," was the bored reply. "Stone and mushrooms below; here, whatever is offered. It is all the same." Despite being pleased for his friend with the increasing fluency of his replies, the hobbit was outraged.
"All the same!" he spluttered. "You can't mean that! Do you mean to tell me that there is no difference to you between ginger and vinegar, sugar and fish paste? Why they're as separate as chalk and cheese!" Klûk's expression of mild confusion was like a shout to the hobbit, given the habitual flat affect of the Eldest's usual expressionless face. "You... seriously? Nothing?" At another grimace of incomprehension, Bilbo huffed in offense. "Well, we will just have to see about that!"
This began the most thorough campaign any of Bilbo's friends had ever seen. Thorin (after being shouted at one time too many) decided to leave the kitchen strictly alone, though he was for the most part happy to eat anything he was presented. Bilbo was on a mission. He baked cookies and cakes, pies and casseroles, cooked roasts and mixed salads and generally produced enough food for a Shire festival, each of which was taken at some point to Klûk who would taste it and then look at the hobbit with an expression of puzzlement - though he quickly began to look a bit tentative to do so, since it became increasingly apparent how his lack of reaction drove the hobbit spare. Given the connection with the Shire by way of Mahal's mirror portals, Bilbo had quick access to all of the herbs and spices with which he was accustomed to cook; nothing produced a result beyond indifference. He began ranging father afield, asking dwarves of other clans for seasonings (some of his experiments finally led a bemused Thorin to ask "Why are you cooking like a Blacklock?" - that was not a good day for anyone). In truth, the hobbit was reaching the limits of his patience - and his options. Even so, he refused to believe that anyone, no matter their physical form, didn't have a preferred food.
In the end, it was an accident that resolved the increasingly tense (on one side, at any rate) stand-off. Bilbo had been meaning to add a pinch of a new spice he had traded for with some dwarves from the far reaches of the Orocarni; the soft red powder was so spicy that the hobbit had washed his hands carefully and the air still smelled eye-wateringly strong in the kitchen; when he set the spice bread he had made in the oven, it didn't take long for the smell to make it clear that he had used far, far too much. He was about to throw the overly spiced loaf away when Klûk came to find him. The Eldest sniffed, got a very strange expression, and asked "What is this?" When Bilbo handed over the bread, holding his breath to prevent coughing from the overwhelmingly pungent spice, Klûk took a bite and his entire body rippled alarmingly. The hobbit had never seen any reaction at all no matter what was served, so this was the equivalent of a fainting spell. "This is... I... like this." The Eldest muttered quietly, and the hobbit beamed. Finally! The world was right at last; he had something he could cook to show his appreciation of his friend, and the hobbit's universe was once again in balance.
Even if it did involve wearing a handkerchief tied over his nose to cook it.
