Actions

Work Header

Full Circle

Summary:

The first time Bilbo dies, it happens in a cave deep in the Misty Mountains.

Chapter 1

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

The first time Bilbo dies, it happens in a cave deep in the Misty Mountains. The air is damp and stale, and it adds an unpleasant taste to the salty blood from his split lip. Dizzy and disoriented, Bilbo isn’t as fast as he should be when he draws his sword. The terrible creature, Gollum, pelts him with rocks, muttering to itself about all the ways it will cook Bilbo, its spindly arms possessing deceptive strength for its malnourished body. And while Bilbo cringes and dodges as best he can, he is too slow. His vision swims, and the cave floor buckles under his feet. One of the rocks hits true, colliding with Bilbo’s temple.

The last thought he has is about the curious little ring he put in his pocket.

Bilbo wakes up. He stretches, luxuriating in the feel of soft bedding, and opens his eyes. Sunlight peeks through the round window of his bedroom. He breathes in the scent of bluebells and daisies he remembers picking the day before Gandalf and his grand idea to send him on the mad journey—

Bilbo bolts out of bed, his heart beating like war drums in the Goblin Kingdom. “The quest!”

It must have been a dream, he decides. Yes, yes, just a dream. Nothing more.

Slowly, Bilbo pads through his home, fingers trailing over the walls, book spines on the shelves, the polished surface of the dining table, reassuring himself of reality. He makes a cup of tea and sits in his favourite armchair, warming his hands on the thin ceramic and watching the tea leaves unfold.

When Gandalf shows up and blocks the sun, looming over Bilbo with all his Man height and a pointy hat besides, Bilbo drops his pipe.

He doesn’t want to go on any quests. He goes anyway.

This time, he kills Gollum first. He wanders through the caves for weeks, hopelessly lost. He finds an underground lake and tries to catch fish, but without a rod, it is a fruitless endeavour.

In desperation, he eats the mushrooms growing near a small pond. Their caps are slimy and bitter, but Bilbo stuffs himself on them anyway like they are special seed cakes his mama used to make for his nameday. He spends the next few days puking his guts out and unable so much as to stand up. On hands and knees, he crawls to the pond and drinks, gulping dirty water despite it leaving a gritty residue on his palms. His stomach hurts like Bilbo is being stabbed with every breath he takes. Curling into a ball, he prays to the Valar for it to end. He dreams of sunlight and his full pantry.

Sometimes, Bilbo hears the voices of the Company. Once, Gandalf sits beside him and makes a flower crown, braiding pond lilies with seaweed. When he finishes, the wizard places it on Bilbo’s head. His father appears next. Bungo says nothing, but for the first time in the deep, dark cave, Bilbo smiles. The stretch of skin feels foreign on his face, but he doesn’t stop. He licks damp stone floor to moisten his lips, too weak to raise his hands. His tongue is dry and scratchy and too big for his mouth. A strange sound escapes his throat, and Bilbo realises that he is laughing. He laughs, and laughs, and laughs until he doesn’t while Gandalf and Bungo watch him with kind eyes.

He dies of dehydration several days later.

The third time, Bilbo doesn’t even make it past the trolls. He is so bloody shaken and terrified that he manages to antagonise the entire Company. So much so that when the trolls threaten to rip him apart, the dwarves aren’t in a hurry to comply and put down their weapons. The pain is excruciating but thankfully brief.

The fourth time he doesn’t go at all. When Gandalf comes, he flat out refuses to go on any and all adventures. Bilbo has had enough excitement to last him several lifetimes, thank you kindly. Of course, the bloody wizard ignores his words and scratches his door anyway.

Well, Bilbo thinks, throwing a change of clothes and supplies for a week-long trip into his backpack, they can wait on my porch till the cows come home, for all I care.

He fastens the clasps with jerky movements and stuffs his pipe into a pocket of his breeches, intending to have a smoke on the way. He leaves through the back door, calling out to Hamfast and saying he plans to visit his relatives in Tookborrow.

As soon as he is past the Hill, Bilbo stops and lights his pipe, waits until he is sure that nobody can see him. He turns left and hikes all the way back and into the woods lying Overhill. Good luck finding me there!

A week later, he returns home much calmer and with a sack full of mushrooms. He gives it to the Gamgees, not leaving any for himself. While he still likes them in theory, Bilbo is reasonably sure he won’t be able to eat any mushrooms for a bloody long time.

Old coot Dodinas down at the Bagshot Row complains at the ruckus the dwarves had made when they didn’t find Bilbo, and Lobelia shoots pointed barbs at his lack of hospitality. But life goes on as it always does, and soon, the birth of Bell Proudfeet’s thirteenth grandchild and the preparations for Summer Harvest Festival are the topics hobbits gossip about.

As months go by, Bilbo stops looking at the shadows with suspicion. Resolutely, he puts the dwarves out of his mind.

One autumn evening, after visiting with the Baggins side of his family and enduring the Sackville-Baggins’ cooking, Bilbo goes to bed early. He drinks ginger tea to settle nausea and hopes that a good night’s sleep will help with the deep ache in his stomach. He drifts off to the sound of wind howling in the pipes and rain pelting the earth with oceans worth of water.

Bilbo wakes up clammy and too hot, his legs tangled in the sheets. His room smells of bluebells and daisies. Outside his window, birds are chirping a morning song and summer sun is cheerfully bright in the cloudless sky.

Grabbing his pillow and pressing it against his face, Bilbo screams until he can’t anymore. His throat is raw, and he feels like lying down on the floor and never getting up. Instead, he plods to the kitchen and fixes himself a cuppa. His hands are shaking.

Notes:

This ficlet might or might not grow into something more lengthy at a distant point in time. It probably will. The idea took my brain hostage and threatened to eat it until I wrote this down. If you like the result, please leave a comment.

Chapter 2

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

All morning, Bilbo camps outside, sitting on his bench and smoking. He misses Second Breakfast and forgets about Elevenses. When Gandalf’s silhouette shows at the end of the Bagshot Row, he jumps and runs to the wizard. Gandalf’s eyebrows shoot up, and he smiles at Bilbo’s enthusiastic greeting.

“Come, come,” Bilbo says. His knuckles are white as he tugs the wizard along by the sleeve of his robe. “I have a story to tell.”

Inside his smial, Bilbo directs Gandalf to the only Man-sized chair he owns and hides in the kitchen, puttering with cups and saucers, looking for scones he meant to bake but didn’t. He goes to slice bread and drops the knife — it lands too close to his toes — and stops, suddenly unable to breathe. Gasping, Bilbo folds in on himself, but no matter how hard he tries, his lungs don’t work, refusing to suck in air. Dark spots dance across his vision. Oh, Eru, not again, he thinks and passes out.

Bilbo comes to lying in his bed, and for a moment, he is afraid that it’s early morning all over again, but the light is all wrong and a damp cloth is cooling his forehead. He sighs in relief and meets a troubled gaze of his guest, keeping vigil beside him.

“What happened, my dear Bilbo?” Gandalf asks, and words tumble out of Bilbo’s mouth like grain out of a holey bag.

Gandalf listens with a pensive expression on his lined face. His brows furrow at the mention of the ring, but he remains silent. As the story comes to its end — this very morning — the wizard nods. For several minutes, he is motionless, his eyes distant and clouded, and Bilbo holds his breath. Everything is quiet and still; the midday sun is painting half the floor in golden hues, and if not for the light breeze playing with the curtains, Bilbo would think the room frozen in time. Finally, after what feels like an eternity of waiting, he hears Gandalf’s sigh and looks up.

The wizard says, “It is an odd tale, indeed, my friend. I would like nothing more than to offer you a reassurance” — his voice is soft and grave at the same time, and Bilbo’s heart sinks into his stomach — “but I’ve never heard of anything like this.” A large hand, warm even through the thin blanket, lands on Bilbo’s knee, pats it twice. “I think you should continue with the quest. Perhaps, it is your destiny to complete it. Valar willing, you will find a way out.” Another sigh, and Gandalf offers him a small smile.

“And meanwhile, we will search for a solution in Rivendell.” The corners of his eyes crinkle as Gandalf’s smile widens, turns mischievous. Bilbo can’t help it — his lips twitch up too. “Lord Elrond’s library is one of the best in Middle-earth, and he is an elf of great wisdom…”

Bilbo nods, his head bobbing fast and shallow. “Yes, yes. Of course, you are right, as always.”

Gandalf gets to his feet. “I will return later. Though” — he chuckles — “you already know all about that.” He adds a wink and, as Bilbo climbs out of his bed, picks up the staff he leant on the wall near the corner. It thuds on the floor with every other step the wizard makes, the sound quiet and a little hollow.

“Until later,” Gandalf repeats, turning to wave at Bilbo in the doorway.

“Yes, yes.” Bilbo nods again, his head feeling light and like it’s floating. “I’ll need to make preparations for dinner.”

The company comes later than Bilbo expects but in one large group, Gandalf leading the dwarves together with Thorin. Like all the previous times, the king gives Bilbo a condescending once-over, looking down his prominent nose, and asks about his preferred weapon.

“I’m not good with a sword,” Bilbo says mildly, and all the dwarves have a comment they must voice. He waits till they stop, nails biting the meat of his palms deeper and deeper, leaving rows of crescent indentations. He licks his lips. “But as I understand it, you need a burglar, not a warrior.” He swallows with difficulty; his throat is too dry. “And that I can be.”

After a long, hard look, Thorin finally nods and turns to Gandalf. “You promised food?..”

The company takes it as approval, and the chaos begins.

At first, the journey goes well enough, and Bilbo is cautiously optimistic. He still sneezes at Myrtle, but allergies aren’t something he has any control over. So he pats the pony’s neck and sneaks her apples in apology. He buys rain gear in Bree and advises the Company to do the same. The dwarves mutter among themselves about the weather being fine and ‘what does a halfling know about travelling,’ but Gandalf backs him up. This time, when the rain starts, nobody sleeps in soaked through clothes.

Every time they need to make a stop, Bilbo anticipates it and, riding up to the wizard, points out the best places to camp. After the third time it happens, Balin asks him over their meagre — by Hobbit standards — dinner.

“Do you travel often, then, Master Bilbo?”

Bilbo looks up from his bowl, a spoon half-way to his mouth. He feels wrong-footed, caught off-guard. So far, only Gandalf has talked to him directly, the rest of the Company preferring to send him sidelong glances. “Um…” He blinks, eyelashes flying down twice in short order. “You could say that, yes.”

Balin nods, seemingly satisfied with the answer, and Bilbo hurries to get back to his food, hunching over the bowl to keep it away from the rain. The stew isn’t getting any warmer. Bilbo has been cold for too long to allow even the smallest amount of heat dissipate.

As they move closer and closer to the trolls, he continues with his little predictions. A change in weather, a bountiful spot for fishing when they cross a river or a stream, a herb that Kíli slips into Bombur’s pot as a joke and that would see them all suffering upset stomachs if not for Bilbo’s warning. It’s going on and on, little things that could be explained by themselves but put together create a peculiar picture.

What first was seen as a strange but ultimately harmless quirk of the hobbit now is met with suspicion and furious whispers behind his back. Bilbo doesn’t care for the names they call him.

He warns them about the trolls and in return gets narrow-eyed stares. Gandalf, however, insists on camping farther afield and stays with the group. The dwarves keep watch in threes and twos. The night passes, uneventful, and Gandalf disappears with predawn to come back with the news of the trolls’ defeat at the morning light.

Bilbo tugs at his sleeve, tells him in a hushed tone about the hoard. The dwarves pretend not to listen but, confronted with the unmistakable sight of three stone figures and the elven swords Bilbo described — a definite proof if there is any — they give him a wider berth than usual, the whispers of ‘oracle’ and ‘halfling witch’ gaining ominous weight. A deep frown lines Gandalf’s forehead.

The bushes rustle. As one, the dwarves go for their weapons. Sting hangs on Bilbo’s hip. Its weight is half-familiar and thus all the more uncomfortable. He doesn’t touch its hilt. The ponies snort, dig the ground with impatient hooves, uneasy with the stench wafting out of the trolls’ cave.

The Brown Wizard rushes into the clearance on his sledge, and Bilbo is forgotten.

Riding is faster than travelling on foot, but even their ponies, spurred by the angry howls, can’t outrun the wargs. The elves find them first. Arrows fly over Bilbo’s head and pained whines join the growls of their pursuers. While dwarves dismount and take the fight, he hugs Myrtle for dear life and waits for the battle to end in their favour. If sneers and disdainful looks he later receives are anything to go on, his actions do nothing to endear him to the Company. Bilbo pretends not to care.

In Rivendell, when Bilbo talks with him, Lord Elrond remembers Belladonna fondly. He’s given the same room she used to stay in on her visits and permission to use the library to his heart’s content. Stepping into an airy, light, and spacious bedroom with — he guesses — child-sized furniture, perfect for a hobbit, Bilbo remembers the dwarven camaraderie of his first stay in The Last Homely House East of The Sea. Even if he was excluded from it, kept on the outskirts, his place was beside them. A fist squeezes his heart, and resolutely, he slams the door behind him while members of the Company trudge past.

Bilbo refreshes himself in the bathing chambers. When the rumbling of his stomach gets louder than his thoughts, he knows it’s time for dinner. At his approach, the dwarves — all at once, as if following an unspoken command — move to block any free space on their ends of two long benches so there’s not enough room for a fly. They look the other way. He holds back a sigh and sits next to Gandalf, close to their host. The dwarves ignore him, resuming their grumblings and complaints, but the skin on the back of Bilbo’s neck itches. He knows unfriendly glares when they are directed his way. On his left, Gandalf’s expression darkens. At the head of the table, a slight frown mars Lord Elrond’s smooth, ageless face.

On Gandalf’s urging, the next morning Bilbo seeks out Lord Elrond and tells him about his situation. For a long time, the elf is silent. There’s a faraway look in his unfathomable eyes as he contemplates the tale. Bilbo follows his gaze to the horizon. A clear blue sky meets the tops of the trees as far as his eyes can see. The rushing of water and a susurrus of leaves drifting on the breeze fail to soothe his spirit.

“This magic is unknown to me. I’m sorry,” Lord Elrond says, at last, cutting into the sounds of nature, and Bilbo’s thundering heart stops, skips a beat, and plummets into his stomach.

He wets his lips. It was too much to hope anyway, he thinks as bitter disappointment floods him. He bows to the elf. “Thank you for your time.”

The elf turns to him, rests a hand on the balcony railing, his long, white fingers contrasting with the dark grey of the stone. “I’ve noticed you don’t get along with your companions.”

Bilbo snorts without humour, briefly glancing up. “To put it mildly.”

Lord Elrond hmms. “I’ve heard that hobbits value the comforts of home.” He pauses, and Bilbo’s heart speeds up — a rabbit caught in his chest or a hummingbird trying to get free. “You are very welcome to stay here.”

Bilbo nods, thanks him, murmurs, “I will consider it.”

The days go by. He marks them with meals taken alone in the kitchen and the number of yellowed scrolls and weighty tomes that tower around him in the library. These times, only the whispers of turning pages and the librarian’s light footsteps compete to disturb his concentration.

Longing for a change of scenery, Bilbo joins their host at dinner and discovers that he is the only one staying. The dwarves raided a large kitchen pantry and disappeared without so much as a goodbye a week past, with midsummer’s dawn. Gandalf, according to Lord Elrond, assumed that Bilbo was with them and left the same day to follow. In a way, Bilbo is glad. He has more time to peruse the library.

The leaves turn gold and red, fall to the ground, dry and brittle. The shadows lengthen and darkness comes faster. The clothes Bilbo brought with him hang loose on his thinning frame. Sitting in his usual nook under a narrow arch of a window, he lights the candles earlier and reads until the words blur, dancing like miniature fairies on fading yellow fields. He sighs and rubs his closed eyelids. His stomach rumbles, but he is too tired to move. The books and the scrolls hold no answers.

He falls asleep in silence, the librarian and other patrons long gone, a page creasing under his cheek and dusty, papery smell in his nose.

Bilbo wakes up to the sunlight caressing his face and the aroma of bluebells and daisies in the air.

Notes:

Edited on the verge of passing out. See a mistake? Point at it and claim a well of my gratitude and appreciation!

Chapter 3

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

His sixth repetition, Bilbo doesn’t reach Rivendell. He doesn’t change much from the first try, playing a slightly more willing and prepared host to the Company but otherwise keeping his distance. Every time he looks at the dwarves, he hears their whispers, full of distrust and aimed to hurt, even though their lips are sealed. The echoes of the last iteration keep his mouth shut. Bilbo does buy appropriate gear, however, and is the only one not soaking through when the rain starts. He takes gleeful pleasure in the sight of his waterlogged companions.

He refuses to go anywhere near the trolls.

“Nori is more skilled in this sort of thing,” Bilbo tells the royal heirs, crossing his arms over his chest and digging in his heels. The stench alone is enough to dissuade him from even making an attempt. A memory of unbearable pain makes an unwelcome comeback, and Bilbo shudders. He won’t budge unless they pick him up and throw him at the monsters.

Kíli’s expression and the glint in his eyes say he’s considering doing just that. Bilbo glares at him and sidesteps back into the bushes. On light feet, he runs all the way to the camp to deliver the news.

“Trolls?” Thorin spits out, his face like a thundercloud. “And the damned wizard chose to take a walk just when we need him!”

Dwalin brandishes his axes. “We can take them on.”

“Now, brother,” Balin says, “it might not be the best idea.”

The Company dissolves into an argument, but in the end, as Bilbo expected, Nori is elected for the rescue. He doesn’t disappoint, saving all but three ponies. The trolls, never the smartest creatures of Middle-earth, blame each other for the loss and their confrontation comes to blows. When morning light touches the tree crowns, bringing Gandalf along with it, sunlight freezes them into statues — two sitting on the ground, clutching their injured limbs, and the last sprawled across the clearing. He didn’t regain consciousness after a particularly vigorous hit on the head.

The dwarves cheer and dive into the cave to search for treasures. Gandalf presents Bilbo with Sting. In the commotion of Radagast’s sudden arrival, as warg’s howls fill the air, the ponies bolt, and again, like the first time, the members of the Company have to run for their lives.

Bilbo’s shorter legs carry him as fast as they can, but he barely keeps up with Ori and Nori. Something must have gone wrong: half of the orc’s party ignores the Brown wizard. Glancing over his shoulder, Bilbo almost stumbles at the sight of enormous wolf-like creatures and their riders — too close to outrun.

Nori notices that, too. He pushes his sibling to the nearest tree, muttering, “Come on, come on, up you go,” his fingers spasming on his weapon.

And while Bilbo doesn’t believe it will do any good, he has to try. He climbs after Ori. “The elves will be here soon,” he whispers under his breath.

The wargs’ paws eat the distance before Bilbo can finish his ascent. Out of the corner of his eye, he sees Nori swinging his mace. He hugs the tree trunk, pulling himself up with all his strength.

Sharp pain slashes the back of his right leg as a large jaw closes over it like a steel trap. Bilbo screams. He doesn’t know where Nori’s gone to, where any other member of the Company is. Later, Bilbo will remember Ori pelting the wargs with stones, but now, as his arms slide over the rough bark losing purchase, the stinging in his palms like mosquito bites, all he registers are the cracks in the dry earth the moment before his face smashes against it, a warg pulling him down. Tasting blood, and dust, and bits of shrivelled leaves, he hears pained cries filling the air. An animal whines. Gandalf’s voice booms, but Bilbo can’t make out the words.

He goes for Sting as if that’d be much help. Hot, moist breath stinking of raw meat and decay washes over the side of his face. Another jaw clamps onto his arm, teeth cutting flesh to the bone, and all he knows is agony. He doesn’t scream himself hoarse only because he doesn’t live long enough to do so. Consciousness deserts him when one of the wargs dig into his stomach.

Bilbo wakes up in his out bed, legs kicking off the blanket as he scrambles to sit with his back to the headboard. A trapped sparrow throws itself against the cage of his ribs. His body aches with residual echoes of pain. The sunlight and fragrant smell of flowers do nothing to calm him down. He hugs himself, fingers clutching his shoulders to the point of bruising, and shakes.

“I can do it, I can do it, I can do it,” Bilbo mutters again and again. He needs to get to the Rivendell library.

The knock on his front door thunders hours later, shattering the silence. Bilbo flinches, staring at the doorway leading out of his room as if Gandalf can see him through all this distance and wood besides. Maybe he can. He is a wizard.

Eventually, Bilbo pulls himself out of bed, goes about his day. Gandalf, of course, is long gone, but Bilbo knows with the certainty only he possesses that by nightfall, his home will be invaded. He isn’t wrong.

This go-around, he is an even worse company for the dwarves. Not that it makes any difference. He’s subdued and doesn’t offer much of a conversation when Balin asks him about his experience with travelling. The only thing keeping him going is the thought of research. There are so many books he hasn’t read. Surely, Bilbo thinks, one of them has the answer. Surely.

Near the destroyed farm, he spurs Myrtle into a gallop until she is head-to-head with Gandalf’s horse. He pulls on the reins and clears his throat.

“Hello, Bilbo. A pleasant day, isn’t it?”

Grey clouds, heavy with the threat of rain, blot out the setting sun. The temperature dropped during the night. A piercing wind sneaks its fingers under Bilbo’s collar. He shivers.

“If you say so,” he murmurs, voice full of doubt. He beacons for Gandalf to lean down. With an inquiring look, the wizard complies. “I’ve heard rumours,” Bilbo says, “about people disappearing around these parts.” He chances a glance back and meets the dwarven king’s scowl. “You saw the farm we’ve just passed. What happened, it wasn't like that a month ago.”

A frown settles between Gandalf’s eyebrows. “This is troubling.” He straightens in his saddle and Bilbo shifts in his. “Oh, but do not worry, my friend. Whatever the danger is, I will be there to protect you.” The corners of his mouth turn up with good-natured humour, and Gandalf pats his shoulder. Bilbo forces his lips into an answering smile.

The warmth of the wizard’s hand lingers long after Bilbo has returned to his customary place; the promise, however, feels solid like a soap bubble.

With Gandalf warned of the danger, they easily avoid the trolls, going farther than usual. Of course, some of the dwarves insist on fighting them, Fíli and Kíli most vocally, but Gandalf refuses, and with the support of the older generation, the matter is settled. In the morning, he deals with Tom, Bert, and William himself. Bilbo considers how many different poses he’s seen them take and laughs with what must be the gallows humour.

This time, he makes sure the ponies are properly tied. It doesn't change the outcome. Urging Myrtle to run faster, he leans forward, hugging her neck and hoping to make himself smaller. The pace is brutal. His thighs, unaccustomed to the saddle, flare with pain on every step. Myrtle’s mane surges up, tickles his face, and Bilbo sneezes. His eyes water and his nose is about to leak. When a spear hits her flank, he feels the shudder that shakes her whole body a moment before her front legs buckle.

His pony pins him to the ground, too heavy for Bilbo to crawl from under her; his bones are broken. Warm blood spurts from the wound in Myrtle’s side, mixing with his own. Lying on the scabbard, his sword impossible to reach, all he can do is wait for a quick death, panting and whimpering. A toothy, grey-skinned monster delivers it with a slash of a rusty scimitar across his throat.

With a shout, Bilbo bolts upright. The softness of his mattress is a sharp contrast to the hard ground of the previous moment, but his breath stutters in his chest. His heart beats as if preparing to explode. He tries to stand and crashes to the floor, trapped in his blanket.

Laying there, his mouth full of dust — he needs to clean under the bed more often — and all of his right side aching, his face scrunches into a grimace. Moisture slides across the bridge of his nose, gets into his ear.

“I can’t,” Bilbo moans later. The sun rays have left his bed and moved to the wardrobe. His skin feels tight and salty. “Not anymore. Please, why won’t it end? Just end it already!”

He turns onto his stomach and bangs his fists against the floor until they hurt. He hits it with his forehead, kicks with his knees. And all the while tears fall on the wood, collecting in decades-old scratches.

The day floats past him like fog. If Gandalf comes — of course, he does — Bilbo doesn’t hear his knocking.

Going around the smial, gathering supplies into his mother’s battered backpack, Bilbo’s mind is perfectly blank. He knows what he has to do, what food and how much of it to cook. His hands wash, and slice, and dice, and when the dwarves come, the table in the living room is covered with dishes.

He doesn’t say a needless word aside from greetings and signs the contract without questions.

On the road, Bilbo fluctuates between flinching at every loud noise and lapsing into silence when his attention wanders, staring into the distance with unseeing eyes. The library, his mind insists, the library is where you need to go. He nods, agreeing, and doesn’t see the looks the dwarves give him.

The whispers among the Company that he is loony, not quite there grow louder. He doesn’t care.

When Gandalf stalks off in a huff, leaving the camp for the night, Bilbo doesn’t think at all. Nobody asks him to deliver the food to the royal siblings. He spends the time watching flaming tongues change shapes as they dance in the fire.

The shouts take him by surprise. Bilbo flinches, hugs his knees to his chest, and hunches his shoulders. He doesn’t know that the trolls eat Ori and Nori and Kíli. They maim those who offer the most resistance — Dori, Dwalin, and Thorin. The dwarven king dies by morning, missing a few limbs and a lot of blood.

He will find out later.

For now, Bilbo stays at the campsite, palms pressed to his ears, and hums him mother’s lullaby to tune out the screams.

Notes:

Apologies for the delay. If you see a mistake, please, point it out.

Chapter 4

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

The quest breaks down barely begun. With half the Company dead, Gandalf’s rousing words fall flat. The dwarves, mourning their relatives and friends, refuse to listen and turn around. Bilbo watches them go, feeling numb. He knows they won’t survive the orcs and wargs. It doesn’t matter.

“Well, Bilbo,” Gandalf says, his voice heavy. His shoulders are bent as if the weight of the Misty Mountains dropped on him overnight. “Just you and me. What say you to a trip to Rivendell?”

That was the plan. The library. Bilbo nods and follows the wizard.

* * *

His stay with the elves is pleasant and uneventful. Lord Elrond gives Bilbo unreadable glances as he listens to the wizard’s tale, but Bilbo doesn’t mind. As long as he is allowed to peruse the ancient tomes he came to Rivendell seeking, all else is a secondary matter.

He spends his days reading in a quiet corner, sunlight slanting across the pages through the open window at his back. From time to time, a fresh cup of tea appears at his elbow, a blueberry scone or a lemon tart — his favourite childhood sweet treats — keeping it company. Bilbo meets them with muted surprise. He knows from his previous visit that the librarian here is stringent in his adherence to the rules, and ‘no food around books’ is a significant regulation.

The elves pity him, Bilbo decides, the poor traumatised halfling. Their murmurs, lilting voices filling the hallways like gently babbling brooks of Bindbole Wood, wash over him as Bilbo drifts to and from his room in the early morning or late at night, his thoughts foggy and gaze clouded. It doesn’t occur to him to wonder why he is never left alone. It doesn’t occur to his hosts to wonder if he is starting to grasp their language, either.

As evening shadows come faster and the air grows colder while the sun weakens and fails to warm, the sections of the library with books written in Westron Bilbo hasn’t touched dwindle in number. And then, one autumn day, he crawls into bed in Rivendell, the bedding silky-soft and pillow cloud-like under his cheek, and wakes up in his own bedroom.

The journey starts anew. Again and again, Bilbo goes through the cycle. He greets the Company with relief, reluctance, warmth, and, finally, indifference, not interested in conversations he can repeat verbatim. Besides, they won’t remember him come next attempt, and it will come like the inevitable change of seasons. He has a goal: find a solution, a way out, whatever it may be. Most times, he reaches Rivendell. Sometimes he doesn’t.

He dies and dies and watches the others die — by trolls or wargs or orcs and once of sickness. The trolls smash Ori. An enraged, grief-stricken Dori manages to kill Bert all by himself before Tom falls on him. They eat Bombur, and Bofur and Bifur end up as a collection of limbs. A warg gets to Kíli and rips out his throat before the archer can take a shot. Thorin and Dwalin dice the beast into a thinly sliced fillet. It doesn’t matter, so Bilbo does nothing to interfere. He is a silent bystander, the only solid being wandering the land of shadows. It does not matter, for the dead will rise and find their way to his doorstep one late Astron evening.

When Bilbo survives for long enough, he strides to Rivendell with single-minded purpose. And in the end, as Halimath advances, he slips into his bed — and after many repetitions, it is his bed, his room, and Rivendell is almost home — and… The smells of bluebells and daisies, sunlight across his face. Restart.

Books have no answers, he discovers. He reads them all, Westron and Sindarin and Quenya, and nothing ever mentions a time loop. The fervour of the earlier visits changes to desperation, to depression, to apathy, to determination, to resignation, and settles on being a routine.

After a while — it might be months or years or decades, he doesn't know; he lost the count of the cycles after twenty — Bilbo notices a pattern. When he survives, the time resets itself on Halimath 16. He marks the date, and writes the timeline of the first journey as best he can remember, and finally arrives at a conclusion: the reason it all started is—

“The ring!” Bilbo starts, the sound of his voice unnaturally loud in the hushed library. He glances left and right, but nobody is around. This time, the Company arrived in its whole. “Of course,” he murmurs after a moment, brimming with excitement. Only when he had the ring, that curious little trinket, did he live longer, or so it seems; his memories of the time under the Misty Mountains aren’t the most reliable. Unable to stay still, he breaks into a jig, laughter bubbling like sparkling wine on his tongue. It doesn’t last for long.

“All right,” he says as exhilaration abates, replaced with the cold reality of a daunting task before him, “back to business.” And, heaving a sigh, Bilbo looks at the mountainous bookcases. He does remember seeing a mention of jewellery… Somewhere.

Days pass. The Company departs and so does Gandalf while Bilbo hides. By then, he has avoiding people down to an art form. For all of Afterlithe, he reads and reads, and finally, the only hint he finds — by chance — is hidden in a ballad.

“One ring to rule them all,” Bilbo says, tracing the lines of text with the tip of his finger. He read or maybe heard somewhere that as long as it exists, Sauron will live — a banished, disembodied spirit but a constant promise of a threat.

“This must be it.” Dread coils in Bilbo’s stomach. He had a piece of the Dark Lord — his power or soul — in his grasp. He shudders. He needs to get it and destroy it. Smash it or… melt it. Surely, a dragon’s fire is hot enough for the task.

With this new goal, Bilbo redoubles his efforts. He is a perfect host — again — and dwarves find nothing to complain about. His uplifted mood and helpful attitude sway the members of the Company to extend a hand in friendship. Two days after leaving Bree, Bilbo is joking with Bofur, the royal siblings listening in and joining on occasion. A week into the journey, and he discusses history with Ori and tea blends with Dori and shares his favourite recipes with Bombur.

The trolls are left for Gandalf; they outrun the wargs and orcs — the elves show up in time — and reaching Rivendell, Bilbo is tentatively hopeful. I’ll get the ring and travel all the way to Erebor, and soon it will be over, he thinks on the eve of Mid-year’s Day, sipping a fragrant elven wine, liberally mixed with water. But life, as it often happens, never follows plans.

There are, he discovers, so many ways to kill a hobbit. He falls off a mountainside that turned into a leg of a Stone Giant. Somehow, after so many repetitions, Bilbo forgot about them, an oversight he is unlikely to repeat. For once, Eru shows mercy: his head hits an outcropping long before Bilbo reaches the ground.

He makes it to Goblin-town. His fall into its deepest caves has an unfortunate landing. With a broken spine — he doesn’t feel his body past his neck — Bilbo can do nothing but watch as Gollum creeps closer, brandishing a large rock. When it descends onto his skull, it’s a relief.

Next time, Bilbo clutches a nearby goblin for dear life. The stench of years spent without bathing, bad breath, and foulness that clings to all creations of Morgoth is worth enduring as the goblin cushions his landing. Flesh meets stone with a meaty thud. Bones crack like twigs — snap, snap. Shuddering, Bilbo scrambles off and melts into the shadows. He hides behind a rock formation, its surface glinting in the barest hint of light coming into the cave from above. The smells of fungus, mushrooms, and a tang of fish assault his senses with the strongest déjà vu. His stomach hurts with phantom pangs of hunger. Not now, Bilbo thinks. Not ever again.

He finds the ring. It looks innocuous and friendly. His fingers curl around it as if they have their own will. Cool metal warms in Bilbo’s fist in moments. Use me, it would say if rings could talk. I wish to help. You want me.

Sauron, Bilbo reminds himself, shivering. It must be evil. With an effort, he does not fling it into the murky water of the shallow pond or leave it for Gollum. An odd possessiveness fills him like rain a barrel in a summer storm. There is a whisper on the edge of his perception. If only he could concentrate a little more, he’d catch the meaning… He shoves the ring into a pocket with all the haste due to a scalding kettle.

It must be evil, and it is. I must be cautious.

To find a way out, Bilbo riddles with the creature. Despite its pitiful appearance and obvious insanity, it’s smart, so very smart that Bilbo has to cheat.

“What’s in my pocket?” he asks with daring arrogance. He wins. Of course, the creature cheats as well. It lunges.

Bilbo catches a flash of bulbous, protruding eyes, too large in a gaunt face, and a mouth full of sharp teeth. He stumbles backwards. The ring slips on his index finger — How? Why? I put it in my pocket! — and Gollum’s hands pass him by a wide margin.

The creature stops. “Gone, my precious. Whats should we do?” it bemoans and answers in another tone, its whole demeanour changing, “finds him, yes, yes, we finds him and skins him and eats him, yes, yes, my precious, we wills. Gollum, Gollum.”

Bilbo freezes, barely daring to breathe, his heartbeat Horn-call loud, almost deafening. Muttering to himself, the creature continues its search, but soon its target changes.

“Precious! Gone, stolen, my precious!” The creature’s scream echoes in the cave. “Thief! Nasty, filthy thief! Catchs him! We will catchs him, we will!” And Gollum rushes into an inconspicuous passage.

This is it, Bilbo thinks. Feet slapping the cold, wet stone floor, he runs after the creature. A whiff of fresh air tickles his heated skin. A while and five turns later, weak sunlight brightens the end of the narrow tunnel. Bilbo can almost taste the sweetness of an escape when Gollum stops, pivots around, its spindly arms outstretched toward the walls, and jumps right onto Bilbo.

Bilbo stumbles. Invisible or not, he isn’t incorporeal. The creature bites his neck and with a vicious snarl rips out a chunk of flesh. Hot agony makes Bilbo clutch the wound, releasing his grasp on Gollum’s scrawny forearms. The creature smiles, its mouth — a terrible gash of bloodied, pointed teeth. Its pupils dilate so much, they eat the irises.

“We gots him, precious. We gots the thief, and now he will pay. Gollum, Gollum,” is the last thing Bilbo hears as razor-edged pain blasts into his skull along with a sharpened rock.

Next time, Bilbo dives for the ring as soon as he and his goblin cushion land. It slides onto his finger, and Bilbo senses eagerness not his own. Huddled in the deepest shadow, he waits for Gollum to notice the goblin. The urge to stab the creature in the back is so strong, he finds his hand on the Sting’s hilt… and lets it go like a hot iron’s handle. His other hand is curled in a fist.

This is not me, he thinks. Cold sweat plasters his hair to his forehead. It isn’t right. When did he start with such unhobbity behaviour? His stomach drops. He glares at the ring. No, you don’t. No tricks and no mind games. I’m on to you.

The ring continues its innocent act, but Bilbo knows better now. He promises himself to never listen to the almost-there voices. He leaves the caves with Gollum still alive; complaints about the stringiness of meat and the sounds of chewing follow him out.

Rejoining the Company, Bilbo dares to hope that the worst part of the journey is over. Alas, the orcs catch up with them.

“Not trees again,” he mutters, earning bemused looks from Bofur and Kíli. Of course, Bilbo thinks with a touch of bitterness, it didn’t happen. Not this time. They rode to Rivendell and left the ponies there — the mountain road is too treacherous for the gentle beasts.

Things go downhill. Knowing quite well how high wargs can jump, Bilbo has scaled a pine to its crown. He hasn’t considered that it could be uprooted. He chances a glance into the chasm. Pale moonlight illuminates the distant plain below. The sight makes him dizzy, and vertigo momentarily overcomes him.

Another warg adds its weight to the already overburdened tree. The trunk swings down. Bilbo’s arms give out. He drops into the abyss. The rush of wind, its feel against his skin and sound in his ears are depressingly familiar. His scream echoes off the cliff wall all the way to the ground. It’s not a pleasant death if any of them were.

Waking up, Bilbo bangs his head against the headboard. Eyes tightly shut, he lets a string of vicious swearing escape the confines of his mouth. Glancing at the portrait of his parents, he winces. Bungo’s warm brown eyes radiate disapproval. “Sorry, Father.”

His mother would have understood and, probably, approved.

With a sigh, he wows if this “adventure” is ever over — when, he reminds himself — to never ever not for a million cakes or Aunt’s Isabelle apple crumble pie recipe climb anything higher than a chair.

Notes:

Fun fact: starting this story, I didn't check The Hobbit Timeline and was sure that the quest lasted longer and, well. Ahem. Let's say this is an AU where Durin's Day is in winter.

Bilbo references the Shire Calendar. Mid-year's Day is June 22. The months follow the lunar cycle. Afterlithe is approximately 24th June to 23rd July; Halimath — 23rd August to 21st September.

If you spot a mistake, especially a wrong tense, please, let me know.

Chapter 5

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

The next cycle goes well right until they reach the cliff. Bilbo has no idea how to avoid the falling pine accident. When he hears wargs howl, he wipes his clammy hands on his breeches. There's a patch of dried mud on his left thigh. It stains his palm. With a grimace, Bilbo rubs it off on his jacket. He needs to wash it, anyway.

“Can’t you do something?” he asks Gandalf even as the wizard calls out for the Company to move. “Magic up a barrier?”

Gandalf’s frown deepens. He purses his lips and spares Bilbo a glance. “It doesn’t work like that.” Turning to the dwarves, he shouts, “Up to the trees!” Another glance, and seeing Bilbo’s dithering, the wizard says, “Bilbo, climb!” He hurries to lead by example, his long beard getting in the way and catching on the bark, much to Gandalf’s mounting irritation.

Around Bilbo, the dwarves defy logic and his expectations by jumping and reaching high branches as if propelled by an invisible force, as if their reportedly dense bones are weightless.

The soles of his feet feel the tremor of the earth before he hears a growl. Chiding himself for being distracted, Bilbo turns to the sound. A snarling warg bounds right at him. The warg leaps. Bilbo doesn’t know how, but Sting is in his hands, thrust forward as an only defence against the enraged animal.

Their gazes lock. The blade slides into the warg’s forehead, gliding through the bone like a heated steak knife through butter. Something vital goes out of the warg’s eyes. The momentum forces Bilbo back several steps, even as it drives the dagger deeper. The monster slumps and falls backwards, tugging Sting out of Bilbo’s hands.

Mouth slack and eyes wide, Bilbo stares at the impaled animal. His pulse is thundering in his ears. He feels feverish, hot and cold at the same time. A lone thought bounces around in his otherwise empty mind: It shouldn’t have worked!

“Bilbo, climb!” Gandalf’s shout snaps him out of his shock. He grabs the hilt of the dagger and has to brace a foot on the dead body to pull Sting out.

“They are close!” Thorin says, voice harsh like a week-old bread on a parched tongue.

Bilbo looks around, turning his head so fast that short strands of sweat-soaked hair whip him across the temples. He is the last person on the ground.

A warg pack descends upon him like a tidal wave.

“Damn it!” Bilbo screams, bolting out of bed. He kicks the bed frame, stumbles backwards, and jumps on one foot, clutching the other and cursing through gritted teeth. The ache helps bury the memory of razor-sharp claws and hungry, yawning jaws. It stops the impotent rage. Plopping onto the mattress, Bilbo sighs and says with feeling to the empty room, “I hate wargs.”

* * *

Next time, he dutifully scales the blasted tree to its middle. The scene repeats with minor variations, and then a milky-white orc arrives astride an enormous white warg with which he bears an uncanny resemblance.

Three branches under Bilbo, Thorin says, “Azog.”

The name sounds like an accusation. From what Bilbo can see of the dwarven king, even the fur of his coat bristles with indignation at the unfairness of Thorin’s adversary being alive.

“I should have known,” Bilbo mutters over the Pale Orc’s dramatic exclamations, missing half of them. Not that it matters — he doesn’t understand a word of Black Speech.

With a shout and a downswing of an arm, Azog commands his retinue of smaller orcs — still large compared to a hobbit and very ferocious, mind you — to attack. The wargs rush up at the trees, forcing the Company to scramble and jump from pine to pine like a… well, like wood elves, really. What an insult to the dwarves it would be if I said that aloud, Bilbo thinks. There’s a distinct flavour of hysteria to this thought.

Once more, they end up on the pine growing at the edge of the cliff. Bilbo clutches the trunk for dear life. His cold, sweat-soaked shirt clings to his skin, and Bilbo moves his shoulders in a vain attempt to unstick it. Gandalf sets pine cones on fire and with a mischievous expression on his face distributes them among the Company. A rain of blazing comets lights up the night. An orange lake blooms on the ground, forcing the wargs away. The heat reaches high, warming Bilbo if only just a little.

This will be a bad death, he thinks, watching the flames devour the forest even as the dwarves cheer their short-lived victory. There’s nothing behind them and no way back. As if to drive the point home, their tree decides enough is enough and with an ominous crack extracts half of its root out of the earth. The scaly bark scratches Bilbo’s cheek, but he holds on. Only a trowel could pry him off the trunk.

With a deep moan, the roots give up more ground. Ori cries out, barely clinging to Dori’s boot as they swing above the chasm.

“Mister Gandalf!” Dori shouts, the branch he is dangling from creaks in his hands.

Fire licks the base of the pine. Sparks fly, framing the wizard’s silhouette as he brings his staff around for Dori to hold onto, but… It is too late. Like stone boulders, ’Ri brothers plummet to their death.

Azog’s laugh, low and deep, and full of dark, malicious amusement, overlaps Nori’s scream of denial.

Bilbo swallows. He knows too well the freedom of a flight cut short by a painful landing.

Azog says something, the Black Speech lending his words a well of gravity, and Thorin gets to his feet and walks down the tree trunk. He stalks along the smouldering carpet in a cloud of sparks, following a path through the sea of fire. His sword glows with pale blue light, a falling star trailing in his wake.

It’s all suitably dramatic, Bilbo decides, befitting a king’s confrontation with a sworn enemy.

Thorin breaks into a run. With a mighty roar, he swings his sword. Bilbo hears sharp intakes of breath and holds his own. Azog spurs his warg to jump off a stone ledge and hits the dwarf in the chest with a mace, knocking him down.

That, Bilbo thinks, could have gone better.

Thorin stands up only to face another hit. The warg clamps its jaws around his torso, and Thorin screams. Bilbo shudders, his body aching with an emphatic pain. A branch cracks. Familiar voices shout words in Khuzdul. Another member of the Company plummets into the misty abyss. The warg tosses Thorin’s body aside like a used chew-toy. Something in Bilbo rebels. In a fit of insanity, he finds himself running to the fallen king’s side.

He tackles the orc who is about to cut off Thorin’s head. Quickly, before he loses the advantage, Bilbo stabs the orc, piercing him between the ribs. Panting, he gets up. Blood rushes in his ears; black liquid drips off Sting’s blade. It looks like tar and not quite real in its glow.

Bilbo turns.

Azog smiles. The deep, crisscrossing scars gauged into his cheeks contort, marring an almost pleasant expression, inasmuch as an orc can look pleasant. In the corner of his mind paying attention to such things, Bilbo is distantly surprised that this particular orc managed it at all. The rest of his thinking capacity is overcome with chanting, “Oh, damn, damn, damn!” all thirty seconds left before an enormous mace crashes into the side of his head.

Waking up, he swears to never engage in such foolishness again but does it anyway this very try: without Thorin, the quest will fall apart.

He considers warning the Company or, at least, Gandalf about their pursuers but, in the end, doesn’t see the point. There’s no way to hurry up their departure from Rivendell. He can’t very well just come out with the message written in moon-letters he has no right to know about. Trying to sell it as ‘premonition’ will deplete even Gandalf’s not inconsiderable credit of trust. At the same time, Bilbo can do nothing to avoid their involuntary visit to Goblin-town. He needs the ring —  he must destroy it. He hopes that some small difference will allow the events to play out to a better outcome.

Some things change. Dori catches Gandalf’s staff, but his boot slips out of Ori’s hands. It takes Bifur, Balin and Dwalin to hold crying without restraint Dori back while Nori talks him down from jumping after their youngest sibling.

Others stay the same. As Thorin lies prostrate before Azog, Bilbo finds himself in the same hopeless position: alone against a horde of snarling enemies. He swings his blade with clumsy, untrained hands without finesse or even a hint of technique, his tired muscles aching with the effort. Two orcs jump back, avoiding the enchanted steel, but their leader laughs with honest amusement. The sound ties Bilbo’s guts in knots. Straining his ears, he hears Thorin’s breath, raspy and stilted.

With a bellow of rage and heartbreak, Dori charges into the scene, crashing a warg’s skull with a flail and slashing its rider’s chest open with a sword. Dwalin follows not far behind, his axes a whirlpool of death leaving only corpses in his wake.

Licking his lips with sandpaper-dry tongue, Bilbo stands guard over the dwarven king for another moment. For when he stops toying with his prey, the mace of the Pale Orc is swift and without mercy.

Bilbo wakes with an angry, wordless shout on his lips, his heart lodged in his throat, and hands and feet cold despite the summer heat. Blindly, he finds the pretty green vase with painted grapevines sitting on his nightstand and hurls it at the far wall. Shards sprinkle the floor, exposing the white ceramic innards and the jagged, sharp edges. Bluebells and daisies lie in a puddle, their delicate stems broken on the impact. The fragrant aroma is overpowering and almost sickening in its intensity.

Shoving the blanket off, Bilbo stumbles to the open window and gulps clean, untainted air.

“I shouldn’t be so foolish. I’m not a Took!” he berates himself. Except, of course, he is.

From the portrait, Belladonna gazes with fond amusement. You aren’t fooling anyone, my dandelion, her eyes say. The painting blurs, familiar faces gain life going out of focus. Bilbo blinks the sheen of tears away and drowns in a fierce longing. He would have gone a hundred, thousand, a hundred thousand repeated lives only for a handful of moments with her, alive and vibrant and full of laughter and light and endless courage. Bilbo wants to hug her so much, his hands shake. He bites his lower lip until it bleeds.

He is, indeed, a Took, but also, as Bungo’s voice reminds him with gentle firmness, he is a practical, sensible Baggins. This evening, as soon as Dwalin introduces himself, Bilbo asks the former Guard Captain for sword fighting lessons and isn't surprised when the dwarf just stares at him, stalling in the doorway.

“Bilbo Baggins, your host for the night and, hopefully, a burglar for the duration of the Quest. Come in, the food is ready,” he adds, which prompts the dwarf to finally step into the smial.

“I’m not at all familiar with a sword, but as I understand it— leave your boots here, please,” Bilbo says, gesturing at a rag beside the door. “The journey to the Lonely Mountain is long and perilous, what with the orcs, goblins, and wargs, and all sorts of other unpleasantness we will surely meet along the way.” His speech starts brightly and ends up in a mutter as his gaze clouds. What else will the Valar throw at their path? “Oh! And you can place your axes on the rack by the window. I put it there for this very purpose.”

“All right,” Dwalin says, wide-eyed; his eyebrows have climbed far up his forehead and risk encroaching on his head’s territory. He looks Bilbo up and down, evaluating his stature and lingering on the evident roundness of his middle. “We do have a little time before we reach the Lone-lands.”

“Don’t worry —” a smile stretches Bilbo’s lips, awkward and ill-fitting like an old, stretched-out shirt that has been passed down from older siblings until it reached the youngest child in a typical Shire family of ten “— I’m a fast learner.”

Notes:

*sings* This is the fic that doesn't end, the neverending fic.
I planned to wrap it up in three chapters, under 4-5k words. Now, I don't even know. *sigh*
As usual, please round up mistakes for the firing squad in the comment section. I hope you enjoyed this chapter. Thanks for sticking with me for so long!

Chapter Text

Bilbo doesn’t become a proficient swordsman overnight. Not even over the course of the weeks leading up to the first skirmish with the orcs. He buys a dagger from a blacksmith in Bree, a plain steel plank with a wooden grip made for larger, Man hands. It’s heavier than Sting and not at all attractive, but while Dwalin, Nori, and Fíli disparage its make and quality in a dissonant chorus often and with relish, it suits Bilbo’s purpose.

Dwalin calls him for their first training session the evening after they leave Bree. Leading Bilbo to the side of the camp, he stops with his axes held in deceptively lax fingers.

“I am your enemy. Attack,” he says without emotions. Backlit by the fire, with his face cast into shadows, it’s easy to recall how Dwalin fights, the way his eyes burn with berserker rage while his upper lip curves to reveal white teeth. The image causes Bilbo to shudder.

He isn’t keen on confronting that side of the dwarf. He licks his lips and adjusts his grip on the dagger, holding it in front of his chest at an angle. The blade sways.

“Right. Yes. Attack.” Bilbo lifts the dagger over his shoulder and aims a strike at Dwalin’s midsection.

He isn’t sure what happens next, but a moment later, his wrists sting. Several members of the Company chuckle. As Thorin walks past, he glances at Bilbo and shakes his head, his lips curved into a disdainful sneer.

Cheeks burning with humiliation, Bilbo picks up the dagger.

“Again,” Dwalin says, calm as an underground pond.

Bilbo lunges. Dwalin catches the blade between the axes and sends it flying.

“Ten coppers say he’ll give up before Bombur’s stew is ready,” Fíli murmurs, not caring or, perhaps, not expecting Bilbo to overhear, but the sound of his voice fills the lull in conversations’ and carries across the clearing like the tolling of a bell.

Kíli slaps his brother’s hand, oblivious to the attention their bet is gaining. “You are on.”

“Eyes on the opponent,” Dwalin says. “Try to land a blow.”

Gritting his teeth, Bilbo tries again and ends up on his back, weaponless. The dagger is lying in the dirt before the gathered spectators. His tailbone hurts, his wrists smart; the dwarves are outright laughing. Bilbo’s face grows hotter. This is not what he had in mind asking for help. Snorting, Fíli nudges the dagger with his boot. The blade slides for several feet, raising a dust cloud that settles on Bilbo’s legs.

Bilbo gets up, shifts his weight from foot to foot, rolls his shoulders. He hears a dull sound and an indignant, “Oy!”

“This is no way to treat a weapon,” Thorin snaps.

“I’m sorry, uncle,” Fíli says.

Dwalin watches Bilbo with no visible reaction, his eyes are dark and serious and calm. “Remind me, how long ago did you stop falling on your arse every other second, lads?” he asks, directing the question at the shamefaced youths.

Again, it's Thorin who speaks. “At least, the halfling is willing to learn.”

The laughter stops entirely. Bolstered by the unexpected support, Bilbo refrains from spitting I am not half of anything sitting on his tongue. Biting the inside of his lips, he takes a deep breath. I can do it. Just land a hit. Show them I’m not worthless.

He feints and, quick as a viper, dives under the dwarf’s arm and catches his forearm with the tip of the dagger.

“Good,” Dwalin grunts.

Bilbo stops and stares at the blood welling up in a thin, red line, uncomprehending. He didn’t expect to succeed. A cold, hard weight presses across his throat. His gaze follows the length of a muscled arm covered in coarse black hair to the base of an axe handle resting against his Adam’s apple.

“And you are dead,” Dwalin says. “Do not get distracted.” He steps back, and Bilbo nods.

“You must be sure of your intentions. Don’t hesitate,” Dwalin continues. “You are fast and nimble. Use it to your advantage.”

Bifur rumbles something in Khuzdul. It sounds like a suggestion. Dwalin must agree with him, for he inclines his head and tells Bilbo to sheathe the dagger for now. The lesson moves to footwork.

By the time Dwalin calls a halt, Bilbo is ready to fall asleep standing. He is a fair dancer and had spent many festivals twirling and jumping in specific sequences to merry tunes, but without music and excitement of a party, the repetitive movements, the constant back and forth of fighting stances are monotonous and boring. It taxes him more than any physical exertion ever did. He does commit the steps to memory and plows through on sheer determination. He must learn, and so he will. There’s no choice about it.

The royal siblings find him just as he crawls onto his bedroll not bothering to open it properly.

“Mister Baggins?” Fíli says, for once getting his name right. “May we speak with you?” His voice is quiet and tentative. Next to his brother, Kíli is fiddling with a strip of leather.

Sighing, Bilbo forces his body to sit up. He rests his hands on his knees. “How can I help you?”

“We wanted to apologise for our behaviour. It was unbecoming of us,” Fíli says, looking at him with earnest, remorseful eyes. Kíli echoes his statement.

Eru, they are still children, Bilbo thinks. Barely out of their tweens by hobbit standards. They were young when he went on this quest for the first time. Now, the gap between their ages makes Bilbo feel ancient. “You are forgiven.”

Twin sunny smiles light up their faces. They thank him and, after wishing goodnight, Kíli scampers off.

“What is it?” Bilbo asks when Fíli fails to go away and leave him in peace.

The dwarf fidgets, tugging his moustache braid in agitation, and offers to be his sparring partner.

“All right,” Bilbo says, not needing to think about it. He will accept all the help he is offered.

The following days, they train every evening. Dwalin raises an eyebrow at Fíli’s appearance. The younger dwarf smiles, saying he could use the practice, and stands next to Bilbo. They go over the footwork and move to basic offensive and defensive moves while Bilbo’s toes are squelching in the mud and Fíli is making a passable impression of a drowning rat. As Dwalin puts it, War waits for no one.

A week before they reach the Trollshaws, Nori melts out of the shadows to stop beside Dwalin. At first, he just watches, eyes sharp and curious, reminding Bilbo of a fox. A hint of a smirk lurks around his mouth as he plays with a throwing knife. Then the suggestions start: widen your stance a hand’s width; bend your elbow farther; knee him in the balls, then jab him in the kidney. With a mild sense of regret, Bilbo ignores the last advice but follows the rest.

Dwalin’s jaw twitches every time the thief is first to spot something to correct, and Nori’s eyes twinkle. It is a game, Bilbo realises, that only Nori’s playing.

“It feels a little like one of Amad and Uncle’s arguments. Only with less yelling and nobody has hit a table yet,” Fíli tells him later when he brings Bilbo a bowl of soup and a chunk of hard bread. They practised evasive moves, and Bilbo’s everything is bruised and aching. He has no doubt the taste of dust won’t leave him for a fortnight.

Sighing, Bilbo resigns himself to months of being caught in the middle of a conflict that nobody is willing to acknowledge. It must run deep under the surface, like the roots of buckthorn. In all the repetitions, this is the first time he actually notices it.

“Better not get involved then,” he says. There isn’t anything either of them can do to resolve it, anyway.

All drama aside, Bilbo does improve as a fighter. Which is precisely why he dies in the first real confrontation. He gets overconfident.

Bilbo doesn’t know why some cycles the orcs follow Radagast and others they pursue the Company. If there is a pattern or a reason for it, he hasn’t found it yet. In any case, this time, the orcs catch up with them early.

Snarling and barking, the wargs nip at their ponies’ heels. Ahead of Bilbo, two riderless beasts go for Ori’s mount; the smell of blood gushing from its leg drives the wargs into a frenzy. The orcs holler commands in Black Speech, and with a detached resignation, Bilbo realises the words are becoming familiar. Unsheathing Sting, he spurs Myrtle to run faster.

The dwarves do their best to fend off the attack while in the saddles. A warg goes down with an arrow spouting out of its eye socket and crushes the orc rider under its weigh. An orc slumps forward with a knife sticking out of his chest. To Bilbo’s right, Bifur utters a war cry and fells an orc and a warg underneath him with one slash of his boar spear.

But slowly, the wargs surround them, forcing them to slow down. Ori’s pony, mad with pain and fear, rears up and hits one of the wargs with its front hooves. Two arrows pierce it in the side. The pony screams, white foam bubbles at its mouth, and Ori flies backwards, his arms windmilling, a startled look on his face. He lands awkwardly, twisting his wrist, and lets out a pained yelp, but dwarven bones are strong. They aren’t easy to break.

Without a second thought, Bilbo urges Myrtle to stop and jumps down. He stands over Ori, presenting a flimsy, still soft-bodied protection against the enemies. His pony bolts, drawing several wargs away in pursuit, and Bilbo feels a pang of regret. Even without him weighing her down, Myrtle isn’t fast enough. Not now, Bilbo thinks, I will mourn her later or not at all.

He concentrates on the fight and thrusts Sting at the approaching warg’s head, catching its snout with the tip of the blade. The warg retreats a step, and Bilbo follows, arm poised to slash its neck, but as he does so, he leaves his back exposed. A fierce pain bores between his shoulder blades, then—

Bilbo wakes up. He rubs his face and sighs.

“That will teach me situational awareness,” he says, quoting Dwalin. “All right, no more unnecessary heroics.”

This time, the Company meets the elves before the orcs give up on catching Radagast. Bereft of retribution, later, Bilbo accepts Gandalf’s flaming cones and flings them at the wargs, hitting the mark on every throw. Vindictive pleasure feels like mulled wine, full-bodied and heady.

* * *

It takes five more tries to finally move past the cliff debacle. Four more traumatic deaths, each at the hands of Azog. Sometimes, Bilbo is not sure he is still in his right mind. On darker nights, he knows he isn’t.

He asks for lessons each repetition. His teachers vary. Sometimes, it is Bifur who joins Dwalin, others it’s Nori or Dori. More often than not, Fíli volunteers to be his sparring partner. Bilbo is glad for it — he grows fond of the young dwarf. The aches and pains of getting his body into a fighting form all over again every time are frustrating, but like everything else, he learns to accept them.

Bilbo gets more skilled, and that, along with his tenacity, earns him respect. It’s subtle. Bilbo only notices it because of his past lives, and thus he treasures the Company’s regard all the more. The dwarves are quicker to include him in conversations. They even insist on Bilbo sharing their room in Rivendell, which is, of course, ridiculous — it is the last place they could be in any danger.

The first time it happens, Bilbo agrees, feeling a warm glow of acceptance. Even Thorin doesn’t glare his way quite so much. He soon regrets this decision, however. Watching the Company break beautifully carved furniture for kindling makes him ill. He tries to stop them, but his entreatments about laws of hospitality meet laughter and teasing. The dwarves continue destroying chairs and tables with ever-increasing enthusiasm, and Bilbo throws his hands up. His hobbitish nature rebels against such a slight to their hosts. As he stalks out in search of other accommodations, Bombur skins a fat rabbit Kíli shot in a picturesque copse of deciduous trees. Bilbo can’t help but wonder if they are about to eat someone’s pet.

* * *

On the fifth cycle, Bilbo finally lives long enough to see Gandalf’s escape plan come to fruition. Given enough time, anything will lose potency, and listening to Azog’s speech is no exception.

“Yes, yes,” Bilbo says, looking at the sky and contemplating praying for patience. “You are a big, bad orc, here to kill us all. We get it.” His grouchy tone causes Kíli and Fíli sitting at the nearest branches to smile though fleetingly. The brothers’ eyes are wide, the lines around their mouths are showing the strain.

The kids are scared.

The scene unfolds as it always does and ends with Thorin lying like a broken doll amid the enemies and Bilbo slaying the same orcs and wargs he did before with frightening familiarity. And Eru, how many more times should he kill them all over again before they stay dead? Cut, stab, pivot, slash, dive under a swinging arm and stab an orc between the ribs, jump back, evade, roll under… And so it goes. He is a quick and motivated study.

As no one falls off the tree this time, the dwarves join Bilbo quicker. They storm into the fight, cutting the orcs down with the force of a spring hail flattening wheat crops. Soon, Dwalin scythes the way to his king, distracting the Pale Orc from Bilbo.

No matter how good they are, however, the members of the Company are at a disadvantage. For every dwarf, there are five orcs and almost twice as many wargs. They cannot win without loses. But then, the eagles come.

Piercing cries fill the air and lightning-quick shadows fall onto their enemies to snatch them up and toss them off into the abyss. It all happens so fast, Bilbo can only watch in disbelief.

It can't be so simple.

The tide is turning, but for whatever reason, instead of letting the Company finish the fight, the eagles swoop to pick up the dwarves. A giant yellow foot descents on Bilbo, enclosing him in a bony cage. The ground rushes off, and Bilbo panics. He screams and flails, convinced his heart will burst. It is too much, too fast, too unexpected. The eagle’s claws constrict, and pain lances Bilbo’s stomach.

For him, the hours of the flight stretch into days as Bilbo swims in and out of consciousness. The lighting changes. The sun awakens, tinting clouds pink on the horizon. When the eagles land, Bilbo is only half-aware of Ori giving him water. He tastes copper on his tongue.

“I’m sorry, lad,” Oin says, patting Bilbo’s hand. The dwarf’s skin is papery and cool against his own. “There’s nothing I can do.”

“It is all right,” Bilbo tries to say but is unsure if he is successful. He coughs and smiles with bloody lips. Not long, he thinks. “I’ll just start over.”

And soon, he does.

* * *

“This is getting ridiculous. Now even Manwe’s eagles are against me?!” Bilbo exclaims with disbelief. He isn’t even angry. “That’s it.” He climbs out of bed and looks at the ceiling. “You hear me? I give up. I quit. Find someone else to toy with. This hobbit has earned a vacation.” He nods. “Yes, that’s right. You heard me, whoever you are. I am not playing your game anymore. I’m done.”

He used to enjoy walking holidays lifetimes ago, he distantly remembers. With so much practice, Bilbo gathers supplies for a week-long stroll in under ten minutes. An hour later, he pins a notice saying, “Went on an adventure,” to his door, borrows a fishing rod from Hamfast and heads west to the Water. He always wanted to learn fishing.

Upon returning, Bilbo finds himself at loose ends. Idling about Bag End, filling his hours with books and dishes he often missed on the road leaves him restless, uncomfortable in his own skin. And after prowling the smial for a few days, picking up and putting down his mother’s doilies and his great aunt’s glazed decorative plates, the things that meant so much but now don’t, Bilbo packs his backpack once more. He is craving action.

He spends the rest of the time until reset studying the art of archery with the Bounders. And every time he aims at a target, Bilbo imagines a large feathery face with a sharply curved beak and cunning golden eyes. He never misses.

Chapter 7

Summary:

This chapter is slightly longer than usual. Hope it makes up for the extra, hmm, two months of waiting? No, probably not. Sorry about that, folks!

Chapter Text

Why don't they get rid of Azog? I bet he'll be a nuisance later, Bilbo thinks as the eagles send orcs and wargs flying to their deaths. If they weren’t evil to the core Morgoth’s creations, Bilbo would sympathise.

As eagles turn their attention to the members of the Company, Bilbo’s heartbeat pulses in his temples. His body is rigid with fright, but when his turn comes, he doesn't struggle. The eagle carrying him in its claws joins the flock in a V formation and tosses Bilbo up into the air. And for a terrifying moment, Bilbo is sure he’s going to die. Again. But after a few seconds of free fall, he lands on the back of another bird, safely nesting between its massive wings.

The ground falls farther and farther away until, at last, they are gliding over a sea of clouds, snow-covered mountain peaks breaking its surface like stepping stones. Bilbo’s shirt is sweated through, and the rush of air battering his body threatens to knock him off the bird. It wouldn’t be this bad if only Bilbo had his backpack, but he lost track of it somewhere between jumping from pine trees and the fight with Azog. Next time, he vows, for no matter how hard he tries to stay alive, there always is a next time, I will keep a better hold on it.

Before long, his teeth are chattering. He can’t stop shivering. Only his toes and the tips of his finger are warm, burrowed between stiff feathers. Exhaustion pulls at his limbs like weights. A familiar emptiness of hunger settles in his stomach.

Hours pass. The lighting changes. The scenery doesn’t. Bilbo would fall asleep just to relieve the boredom, but the overabundance of space beneath his eagle keeps Bilbo’s eyes wide open and his breath catching and stuttering in his chest. His muscles are frozen; he can barely move his eyelids. The wind-induced tears turn into an ice crust.

When they land, Bilbo can’t get off the eagle’s back on his own and has to wait for assistance. After checking Thorin’s condition — alive but unconscious — Gandalf helps Bilbo down with a heavy frown making itself at home on his face.

Lightheaded and dizzy with relief, Bilbo falls to his knees, the pain of impact barely registering.

“Oh, thank Eru,” he whispers around the razors scrapping his dry throat. “We made it. Solid ground.” He contemplates kissing the rock, but his lips hurt too much. He pats it instead.

“Are you unwell, Bilbo?” Gandalf asks, crouching beside him.

With some effort, Bilbo raises his head. His throat constricts. He swallows and croaks, “Cold.”

“Oh.” The wizard touches Bilbo’s forehead. His hand is scalding. “I’m sorry for your discomfort. The eagles were our only way out.”

Bilbo closes his eyes. The thawing ice crystals prick his skin. He hears Gandalf whisper in a language he doesn’t understand. The words are silky-soft but threaded with a power that rattles his back teeth. A wave of warmth runs through his body. A rustle of fabric, weary footsteps, then a weighty fabric is piled on him. Without intending to, Bilbo surrenders to the pull of sleep.

When he wakes up, still on the eyot, his limbs ache but no longer feel foreign. The rough stone under his cheek has changed to a scratchy coat that someone bungled him in. The sun is at its zenith, and Thorin is sitting a few feet away, a hand on his ribs.

“Finally, the halfling awakens,” he says, but instead of the usual mild hostility and distrust, his voice is laced with good humour.

Clumsy and awkward, Bilbo gets out of the coat and onto his feet. Thirst makes talking impossible, and after appropriate gestures, Thorin passes him a waterskin. Bilbo sips slowly, experience warning him against going too fast, lest he makes himself sick.

After he finishes, Thorin grips his shoulder and looks him in the eyes with more sincerity than Bilbo has ever seen the dwarf muster. It is a heartening sight.

“I thank you for saving my life, Mr Baggins. I’m in your debt.”

“I couldn’t let you die,” Bilbo murmurs. And then, as an afterthought, he adds, “Simply Bilbo is fine.”

Thorin’s grip tightens minutely. “Come, we must press on. The sun is getting unbearable here.”

With his hand still on Bilbo’s shoulder, Thorin leads him to the edge of the eyot, the rest of the Company following. A single mountain rises over the endless plains far on the horizon. Forests and lakes, hills and more plains lie before them, but seeing their destination, so close and so far away, lightens Bilbo’s spirit.

“Is it?..”

“Erebor,” Gandalf says, and turning, Bilbo finds the wizard standing behind Thorin. “The Lonely Mountain. The last of the greatest kingdoms of dwarves of Middle-earth.”

“Our home.” Thorin’s voice carries the same longing Bilbo reads in the softening of his features.

“A raven!” Oin points at a bird flying overhead.

“This, my dear, is a thrush,” Gandalf says.

“We will take it as a sign,” Thorin says, meeting Bilbo’s gaze. His eyes are soft, and a gentle smile graces his lips. It is an entirely uncharacteristic look for the dwarven king. A look Bilbo has never seen before. It suits him well.

“You are right,” he replies, “I do believe the worst is behind us.”

His legs, still half-asleep and aching, carry him forward. Bilbo takes a step to the edge of the eyot for a better view of the path ahead, Thorin’s hand sliding off his shoulder. Another step and—

“Bilbo!” Thorin shouts, but it is too late.

His foot finds nothing. With a startled yelp, Bilbo tumbles off the Carrock.

Waking up, he swears and hits his forehead with his palm.

“Stupid! That was so stupid! ‘The worst is behind us,’” he mocks in a high-pitched voice and grimaces. “Ugh!”

Rallying his resolve, Bilbo packs his warmest sweater and breeches, and a second coat. If he survives long enough, it will be winter when they reach Erebor. He is surprised the thought has never crossed his mind.

* * *

The flight on the back of an eagle never gets easier. No matter how long he lives, Bilbo won’t be comfortable with a giant beast that has already killed him once standing between him and painful death. He has grown to hate heights with a fierce passion.

Another series of tries later — Bilbo swears to never try to keep his backpack while sitting on an overburdened pine tree — they reach Mirkwood.

What a horrid place, Bilbo thinks as they march along the narrow trail.

Dead leaves and dry moss prickle the soles of his feet as they crumble. All around, twisted and gnarled ancient oaks loom over the Company like ever-tightening dense walls, pressing closer and closer. The thick, moist air smells of decay, and Bilbo has to swallow repeatedly past the sick, oily residue coating his mouth. No birdsong cuts through the unnatural stillness of the forest. The nights are worse: the darkness, when it comes, is impenetrable safe for the eyes that glow from the edges of the road.

Without Gandalf’s reassuring presence, fear sinks deep into their hearts. They huddle together, resting in shifts, hands never straying far from weapons. Nobody ever attacks, but the constant waiting wears them down. After the brief respite under Beorn’s care — and what a scare it was, meeting him in bear form! — it is especially jarring.

They walk and walk and walk in eternal twilight, the journey seemingly without end. No matter how much Bilbo rations, after two weeks, the food Beorn supplied runs out. He listens to Bombur’s bemoaning the lack, to grumblings of the dwarven stomachs, and curls his lips in slight contempt and pity. He, a hobbit, survived — didn’t — worse and for longer.

With hunger gnawing at his belly, his tongue dry and lips cracked, images of frilly cakes and tart dewberries, and juicy lamb meat layered on golden-brown potatoes tease and torment him as soon as his eyelids slide shut, and sometimes when his eyes are open. They dance before him, tantalising, begging to pluck them from the air.

“My head is swimming,” Oin complains, and the mirage vanishes.

The path abruptly ends in a broken bridge. Bilbo stops. His own head is light, his vision funny. Beneath the bridge, a thick layer of fog hides a river.

“We can try to swim it,” Bofur suggests from Bilbo’s right.

You must be joking, Bilbo thinks. The river seems uninviting.

“You heard what Gandalf said,” Thorin rumbles behind him, voice low and hoarse. “The dark magic lays upon this forest. Water of this stream is enchanted.”

“Doesn’t look very enchanting to me,” Bofur says, and Bilbo tries to smile.

“We must find another way across,” Thorin says. The sound of retreating footsteps follows.

But Gandalf said to stay on the path, Bilbo thinks. Shouldn’t we try to cross it here? His thoughts are slow and thick, like honey.

The fog parts. White flakes or maybe seeds float on the black surface of the river among rust, blown, and purple-pink decaying leaves. Bilbo sways.

“Bilbo!” He hears Thorin’s call and turns. The Company has ventured onto the bank. Shaking his head, which does nothing to clear it, Bilbo joins them.

As the lightest person, they choose him to cross the water. Holding onto mossy vines trailing from above, Bilbo tests a twisted, low-hanging branch of the ever-present trees. It swings from side to side, but Bilbo’s steps are sure.

“’s al’right,” he says, his tongue swollen and unwieldy. “’eems stable ’nough.”

He stretches to reach another vine and loses his footing. He falls, flailing and with his stomach jumping into his throat. And catches the branch with his legs at the last second.

“Ev’thing’s fine.” Bilbo sighs, hanging upside down.

Swinging to catch another vine, he grips a branch and holds himself suspended, stretched parallel to the water. His vision blurs, goes in and out of focus, the spinning starts and stops and starts again. He looks at his reflection. Framed with dark seeds, Bilbo-in-the-river winks from four handspans away. Bilbo frowns, but Bilbo-in-the-river doesn’t and suddenly gets closer, closer, close enough—to touch.

* * *

He dreams of singing.

Melodious voices entwine to form a beautiful, haunting song. The words slip his grasp, however. At first, all Bilbo sees is absolute, all-consuming darkness, but as the chorus nears a crescendo, the darkness lifts to show him a view from an eagle’s back. He sees the Shire, the rolling hills and fields, and woods; the waterfalls of Rivendell; a forest of tall, golden trees with homes built high up on fleets; a gleaming city of white stone with graceful spires piercing the sky. He sees sands, a market square full of colourful tents, twisting streets running like veins through a rust-orange city, and large ships with bright sails anchored in a port under black banners.

Bilbo sees many things, flying over the whole world, and everything in it is on fire.

* * *

Surfacing from sleep to chittering and hissing noises and a white, sticky cocoon suffocating him in a clingy embrace, Bilbo thinks, This isn’t right, but his grasp on consciousness slips through his fingers and—

Bilbo wakes up to the sunlight filtered through a white cloth. Sometime in the night, his blanket bound his legs, and a sheet wrapped itself around him like a shroud. He rips it off his face. His heart is beating against his ribcage like it’s tired of its housing. Breathing hard and fast, Bilbo stares at the soft cotton bunched in his tightly clenched fists, blinks, and mops the sweat off his face.

Next time, Bilbo resolves, he will be the one to lead the way.

He is.

Thorin protests, as does the rest of the Company, but Bilbo does not budge.

“I have researched the maps in Rivendell,” he says with all the stubbornness of a Baggins and pigheadedness of a Took his parentage has granted. “I know the way better than any of you.”

Grumbling and cursing, the dwarves agree. He leads them at a good pace, making steady progress until they reach the river. There must be a better way to cross it, of that Bilbo is sure. He is determined to find it even if it kills him, and, strangely, it doesn’t. Relying on his nonexistent luck, Bilbo chooses left and leads the Company along the bank. The river widens. The trees no longer bridge its width but form a gnarly dome high overhead. And then, he spots it.

“Here, see?” Bilbo points at a lighter patch of colour on the other side.

After a bit of squinting, hobbitish eyesight being sharper than dwarvish, Kíli exclaims, “A boat!“

“I told you,” Bilbo says, and triumph suffuses his voice, “that I will find a way, and I did, didn’t I?”

“Aye, laddie, that you did,” “Good job, Bilbo,” “I never doubted you,” sound the joyous confirmations.

Smiling, Bilbo stands aside as Kíli shoot an arrow with a tied rope. Dwalin reels the boat in. They cross in groups of three and four, Bilbo going first with the ’Ri brothers. If the river has currents, he doesn’t notice; their boat moves in a straight line without any course correction. It all goes well, until the last two dwarves, Dwalin and Bombur, are disembarking.

Leaves swish. The dwarves grow tense, fall silent. Kíli draws the bowstring, the sound loud as a crack of a whip.

“Don’t shoot!” Bilbo shouts as a stag with a coat so white it shines in the perpetual gloom appears between the bushes. The warning comes too late.

Kíli’s looses an arrow. Despite only a hundred paces separating him and the animal, the shot goes wide, but the stag startles and charges. The Company rushes out of its path, but as the stag leaps across the river, Bombur staggers and falls out of the boat with a mighty splash.

Time slows down as Bilbo watches black water close over Bombur’s startled face. The dwarves fish him out right away, but he has fallen into the darkest depth of sleep, and nothing wakes him. With a peaceful expression, Bombur slumbers on, his loud snoring twining the rumbling of his stomach.

Perhaps, he dreams of food and drinks aplenty.

The search for the road is fruitless: the forest is too dense. As if by magic, trees block the way every time Bilbo glimpses an opening, and in the end, they choose a dirt path that follows roughly the same direction.

Even though Bilbo insisted on bringing more supplies and starting to ration right away, the last of their food runs out a week later. They wander the woods, alone and lost and hungry for three more days.

“Bilbo,” Thorin says, stopping abruptly.

They walked for hours on end, and Bilbo’s aching legs want to fold under him. He locks his knees and steels himself for the long-awaited condemnation, but all Thorin says is,

“I want you to climb up. See if you can find a road.”

Wordlessly, Bilbo nods and sets his backpack under a tree he’s to scale. The bark is grey and lifeless. He scrapes his wrists and ankles, but Bilbo has a task, and climb he does, no matter how much his head is swimming. Ten paces up, he hums along with eery music coming from afar.

There’s no warning when he reaches the upper branches, no thinning of tree limbs. Just suddenly he breaches the canopy and shuts his eyes against the blinding light.

A breeze tussles his hair. Under his eyelids, the world is warm red-orange, coloured by the afternoon sun. Bilbo breathes the sweet, untainted air. He shakes his head, the heavy haze that has settled over his thoughts lifts for the first time in weeks. A kaleidoscope of butterflies takes flight, and Bilbo smiles, watching their bright blue and oh so lovely wings.

There is no path, but behind the carpet of treetops spreading in every direction, he sees the Lonely Mountain, a lake, and, closer still, a river. Bilbo traces the river’s flow into the Long Lake, and laughter bubbles up his throat and spills like elvish sparkling wine. Perhaps another week or two of constant walking, and they will make it to the foothill of Erebor.

We are so close!

Still smiling, he takes one final breath and starts the gruelling descent, but when he hits the ground, no one is there. The dwarves vanished as if the trees had hugged them with wooden limbs and took them underground.

Tucked between two knobby roots, his backpack waits exactly where Bilbo left it. No trail of footsteps is left for him to follow. There are, however, cobwebs, sticking to the bark in loose, white threads. Stretches of it sprawl between branches like nets, tall and broad enough to wrap a hobbit twice over. Bilbo freezes. A gentle susurration retreats into the trees, the sound fading.

“Oh, blast and botheration,” Bilbo whispers, not daring to raise his voice. “Exactly how large are they?” He doesn’t want to imagine. Gritting his teeth in resolve and budding irritation, he grabs his backpack and runs after the spiders.

As cobwebs thicken, encompassing more trees and linking them together, Bilbo pulls the ring out of his pocket. It slides onto his finger as if of its own will, with a readiness he doesn’t expect. The world greys out, leached of its colours, and cold sinks deep into the marrow of Bilbo’s bones. The hissing cuts off. Instead, he hears words filling him with dread.

“Let’s eat them!” says one voice. “Bleed them dry!” suggests another. “So plump, so juicy! Let me take a bite!” says the third just as the spiders come into view. And Bilbo’s heart plummets into his stomach. Easily as tall as a horse, the spiders spin their webs, wrapping the sluggishly squirming dwarves in gauzy shrouds. Hanging from thick branches, the cocoons rotate until no hint of any person is visible and only general shapes and sizes allow Bilbo to guess the victims.

His heartbeat thunders like drums. Slowly, Bilbo crouches and blindly pats the earth until his fingers close around a scratchy bark. Hefting the stick, he throws it with all his might. The bushes to his right rustle. The spiders stop.

“What was that?” one says.

“Another prey,” another answers.

“Prey,” “Fresh meat,” “More for us,” “Feast! Feast!” picks up the cluster, and many hairy feet skitter away.

Climbing a tree is easier with swatches of cobweb clinging to it, Bilbo finds. The soles of his feet stick to the wide branch that takes him to the dwarves. Leaning forward, he cuts the web strands one by one. Tumbling through the nets spread below cushions the cocoons’ fall into a manageable landing.

The impact still jars the Company into consciousness. Immediately, daggers and swords rip the shrouds from the inside.

“Where’s Bilbo?” Dwalin asks, turning around. A piece of cobweb sticks to the side of his head, and several more decorate his beard.

“Here,” Bilbo shouts, pulling the ring off.

A quiet chitter is his only warning. Whirling around, Bilbo ducks on instinct. Six black, glistening eyes stare him down. The moment stretches into eternity. The voices of the Company peter out, and in that instance, the world holds its breath. Then, mandibles opening with a hiss, the spider lunges at Bilbo.

Startled, Bilbo falls onto his backside. Sting thrusts up, sliding into the underbelly. The spider screeches, globs of viscous saliva flying out of its mouth. And Bilbo pushes his dagger in and up.

Kicking the body off the blade, Bilbo watches it plummet. With a long exhale, he runs a hand over his face. His nose doesn’t bump on metal as his fingers go down. Bilbo opens his eyes. There is nothing on his finger. He pats his pockets. Nothing is inside. His head whips around, his gaze darting all over. Nothing.

“Where is it? Where did it go?” he mutters, slapping the webs in the hope that the ring somehow hid there, and all the while, It’s mine. It’s mine. It’s mine! pounds in his temples in sync with his heartbeat.

A hint of metal on a lower branch is all he needs to jump—throw himself onto it. The ring is heavy in his grasp. Lying on his stomach, his whole body smarting with a sharp ache, Bilbo raises it to his eye-level. The golden glint shifts as if in a wink.

“Found you,” Bilbo murmurs, and something dark, possessive, alien enters his voice as he says, “You are mine.” Mine to hold, to cherish, to possess. The ring warms up. And Bilbo senses triumph.

But wait a moment, a voice of reason peeps. The ring is beautiful and fascinating. This isn’t right. He wants to look at it and hide it and never share its perfection. Not right at all. No other person is worthy to even have a glimpse of it. What’s going on?!

The ring hits the branch with nary a sound, and Bilbo slaps himself, twice on both cheeks. The sting is burning, but his blood turns cold. His mind belongs to him once more.

“Perfect. More tricks. I hate you. You are my burden.” To destroy. His fist closes around the deceptively lifeless metal band, nails and gold biting into his flesh. A mountainous weight settles onto his back, bowing his shoulders.

Below, spider carcasses with legs curled toward their bodies are strewn across the ground like a handful of wilted flowers thrown to the wind. Lilting tones of Sindarin flow from a distance, all the more ethereal against the harsh barks of Khuzdul expletives and earthy Westron exclamations.

An involuntary sigh gushes out of his lungs. Once again, Bilbo lost the dwarves. This time to elves.

He glances up, sure that the Valar are laughing at his expense and curses.

The Company hasn’t got too far if he still hears their voices. With a burdened spirit and a heavier heart, Bilbo slips the ring on. And follows.

Chapter 8

Summary:

Remember that Hobbit fic about time looping Bilbo you read forever ago? Yes? This is an update for that fic.

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

The palace of the Elvenking is wast, cold, and airy, much like the Elvenking himself. In the heart of a labyrinth of caves, he rests on a wooden throne half turned, larger than life and still as a hunting cat. The guards escorting Thorin move away. Silently, they take position on the steps leading to the dais.

As if awakening from a long slumber, the Elvenking rises. Descends. He glides to the side of the platform that forms his throne room and stops, gazing into the distance. Thorin and, unknowingly for the elf, Bilbo — if they so chose to look, and Bilbo does — have a perfect view of his profile: the delicate features of his ageless face are frozen in weary condescension.

A moment passes, then another. Thanking the Valar for Thorin’s laboured breathing, Bilbo tiptoes away from the edge of the platform.

“Some may imagine that a noble quest is at hand. A quest to reclaim a homeland and slay a dragon,” the Elvenking says at last. His voice is disinterested, detached. He guesses Thorin’s plan as if reading lines from a play he saw so many times it got unbearably boring.

Unhurried and graceful, the Elvenking turns, and Bilbo starts and shivers. The insubstantial monochrome of the ring’s ghostly world rips and blurs all outlines, making the burnt ruin of the left side of the elf’s face a grotesque mask. Cold eyes pierce the space beside the throne, and Bilbo freezes, but no, he is quite safe. He doesn’t even leave a shadow. And even were he unconcealed, no one would notice his small form, not while he huddles at the base of the hulking throne. He—quietly—exhales.

Like a bird of prey, the Elvenking circles Thorin until they are but two handspans apart and, looming over the dwarf, proposes a bargain: his help for the return of the elven jewels.

‘Yes! Please, agree! We are but fourteen, and a whole army of elves will be of tremendous use.’

But Thorin’s wounds run deep; his pride runs deeper. He refuses.

Invisible, Bilbo closes his eyes and curses.

Fool. A justified one, but all the same, a fool, he thinks as Thranduil, the wise and fair ruler of the Woodland Realm, sentences Thorin and the Company to an indefinite stay in the prison cells — to rot forever, forgotten by their eternally youthful hosts. And all for the ridiculous offence of ‘trespassing onto the land.’

Or maybe they both are fools, equally stubborn and obtuse, both holding onto grudges with single-minded focus.

With a nebulous promise-threat to revisit the offer of the bargain in a century, the Elvenking waves his hand. The dwarven king’s glare is full of loathing as the guards seize him by the arms and drag him away. He stares at Thranduil until the Elvenking is hidden from sight.

Down and down, by long, narrow bridges and drafty passages they go, and Bilbo follows, will always follow after Thorin. Every time.

His heart thunders as he runs after the long-legged warriors. The world is bleak and quivery, like a mirage. He grits his teeth and always — always — stays in the middle of the path.

In a corridor with empty cells, deep under the hollowed hill, they stop at the farthest one. Thorin growls insults as the guards, who might as well be animated statues, toss him inside and close the door with a clang. The lock clicks.

“Mouthy one, isn’t he?” a light-haired elf says in Sindarin.

“Quiet,” his partner answers in the same language, tightening his lips in displeasure. “Remember the orders.”

As swiftly as they marched here, they leave; the jiggling of the keys hanging from the belt of the light-haired elf mark their passage.

His back plastered to a stone wall, Bilbo counts to three hundred and only then he dares to whisper, “Thorin?”

The dwarven king starts and looks around. “Who’s there?”

Bilbo pulls off the ring. Colours flood his vision; slowly, so slowly it almost hurts, warmth seeps into his limbs. He feels as if he’s been finally awoken after a fitful rest. The relief is immense.

“Just me,” Bilbo says, staggering into Thorin’s line of sight.

“Master Baggins! You can’t imagine how glad I am to see you unharmed!” Thorin grabs the bars, pressing against them. “Where were you? Did these gurnvos’comys find you and let you go? No—” he shakes his head “—those rukhs shirumund caragu wouldn’t. How did you escape?”

Bilbo blinks, thrown off by the use of Khuzdul. Occasionally, the dwarves would speak it in his presence but never directed at Bilbo. Assuming Thorin means the elves, he says, “By the time I dealt with a giant spider, and let me tell you, spiders should never be that size!” His mind supplies the images of black glistering eyes and mandibles the size of his forearm. He shudders and mutters, “It’s unnatural.”

“Then?” Thorin prompts.

Shaking off the memory, Bilbo continues. “The elves had already captured you, so I followed at a distance and sneaked inside the gates.”

“And nobody noticed you?” Thorin’s eyebrows meet in a heavy frown. “There are a lot of things I call the elves, but poor sighted has never been on that list.”

Bilbo glances around and catches Thorin’s gaze. His heartbeat thunders in his ears. His fingers catch and lock but wouldn’t still — his thumbs start tapping an irregular rhythm. He swallows and moves close to the cell. Bilbo murmurs, “I have a way to stay hidden.” He shifts, his gaze jumps at shadows, returns to the dwarven king and settles on the sky-blue of Thorin’s eyes. “It isn’t something I can share, but—”

Thorin lets go of the bars but not Bilbo’s gaze. “Say no more. It is enough that one of us is safe. What of others?”

“I do not know.” Bilbo looks down. He wets his lips. “I followed you. But I will find them.”

A large, calloused hand touches his interlocked fingers and stops the restless fidgeting.

“Bilbo.”

He looks up. The sincerity on Thorin’s face strikes him like an arrow to the heart.

“I have every confidence in you,” Thorin says. It might be wishful thinking, but his severe features seem to soften.

“I will find the others,” Bilbo repeats, his voice burning with passion and a kindling desire to prove his worth. “And I will find a way out. I promise.” It is a promise he can keep. After all, he has nothing to lose and all the time in creation.

“I believe you.” Thorin squeezes his hands, releases them, but stays where he is, his face pressed between the bars. “My jailers will return soon. I doubt that spineless coward will want me without supervision for too long. Go now. You must stay safe and hidden.”

“I will,” Bilbo whispers. He turns and walks away. Stopping on the last stair before Thorin is out of sight, he glances back. Thorin’s eyes are closed, his forehead rests on the bars.

Bilbo slips the ring on. The world plunges into the cold and shades of grey. Bilbo rubs his forearms and, eager to see his task done, takes a deep breath, and steps onto a bridge.

It is days before he finds the rest of the Company. Bilbo isn’t sure how many. Far inside a hill, where the sunlight reaches only the upper levels and someone is always alert in the halls, it is hard to keep track of time.

Bilbo wanders through caves with walls carved to resemble trees, haunts the endless bridges spanning the heart of the city. He sleeps in corners, never daring to remove the ring. His dreams are dark and full of violence, though he can’t remember them upon awaking. Just blood and fire, pain and rumbling laughter.

He finds the kitchens and steals food from the larders. He never takes much — an apple, a wedge of hard cheese, a bread bun. Something easy to overlook, never enough to notice.

On the third day, he discovers a bathing chamber lavishly decorated with flowers and gauzy flowing fabrics. The water smells like a spring garden. He dips the tips of his fingers in a basin, pours a bit on a handkerchief and cleans his face.

Two days later, he stumbles onto a room with a lake. Its water is dark and still. Bilbo tiptoes closer. Stars shine from its depths. Bilbo looks up, just to check, but there is only stone above him. He doesn’t see it in the lake. He doesn’t find his reflection, either. He doesn’t dare touch the water.

Awhile into their stay in the Elven Kingdom, luck smiles upon him. As Bilbo raids the main larder, several guards come into the kitchen. They lift trays loaded with bowls of gruel with ease.

“When will we be rid of those pests, do you think?” one of the cooks asks an elf balancing a tray on each palm.

“Whenever the Lord decrees it,” is the reply.

Tilting his head, Bilbo studying the elf’s features: his hard expression and tight-lipped mouth are familiar. One look at the elf’s companion, and recognition strikes: these are the guards who locked up Thorin.

Swiftly, they collect food and leave. Grabbing a handful of nuts, Bilbo scampers after them.

* * *

“You call it dinner?” Bofur sneers as a bowl lands on the floor of his cell. “My mother fed her pigs better than this!”

“Outrageous!” calls Dori.

“The standards nowadays.” Balin tsks and shakes his head.

Bifur spits something in Khuzdul and rattles the bars. The elves might not understand the words, but his tone surpasses any language barrier.

“Silence,” the light-haired elf hisses in Westron.

The racket only grows.

“Do not encourage them,” his partner says in Sindarin.

The first elf huffs, turning on his heels.

“Can’t wait to get rid of the lot.” His mutter accompanies a resentful glare to rival Thorin at his best. “The Feast of Starlight, and we are stuck on duty.” He turns, and Bilbo spies the keyring tied to his belt.

This time, Bilbo thinks, I won’t let it out of my sight.

Committing the way to memory, Bilbo shadows the elves. It feels like they walk through the whole hill, passing waterfalls and underground gardens, up and down stairs — again and again — until they reach a cellar. The shelves of the wooden racks are filled with casks and bottles. Large barrels are lying around on the floor. A heavy scent of fermented grapes hangs in the air.

“Hurry on, you lot. These barrels should have been sent to Esgaroth hours ago. The bargeman will be waiting for them,” the dark-haired guard says.

With a smile, an elf admires a jug he is carrying. “Say what you like about our ill-tempered king, but he has excellent taste in wine.” He takes a sip from a goblet and smacks his lips. “Come, Elros, try it. It’s marvellous!”

“I have the dwarves in my charge,” the dark-haired guard replies.

“They aren’t going anywhere; they are locked up,” his partner says, hanging the keyring on a hook and grabbing two goblets from a small round table with a deck of cards stacked neatly on the edge. “Stop being such a sour spot.”

Elros hesitates, and Bilbo holds his breath.

“Fine.” The guard sighs. “But just to taste.”

Slowly, Bilbo exhales and settles in to wait. Hiding in a corner, he listens to idle gossip. One jug runs dry, and then another. They open up a barrel. The wine seems endless, as is the elven capacity for it. The claws of hunger scratch at Bilbo’s belly. Soon, the pangs will start. Not daring to take his eyes off the guards, he eats a handful of pine nuts one by one.

He watches as empty barrels are loaded in the centre of the room. Most elves leave, and only the two guards and the butler stay and drink.

As time passes, the elven voices do not change — the elves do not slur or shout. They do, however, sing and laugh more freely. As lovely as the songs are, the growing impatience robs Bilbo of enjoyment.

The elves drink, and sing, and joke, and drink some more. And then, quite suddenly, like three extinguished candles, they fall asleep with faces resting on the table.

Cautiously, Bilbo jumps off a crate and has to take a moment to stretch his tingling legs. Tiptoeing to the hook, he reaches for the keys and curses elven height. A glance around doesn’t yield a suitable stick or a convenient fireplace poker.

Of course not, Bilbo mouths and rolls his eyes. Unsheathing Sting, he hits the keyring. It sways. He tries again. The tip of his tongue peeks between his teeth as Bilbo lifts the metal ring. Slowly, carefully—The keys fall down with a loud clatter. The nameless guard stirs.

Kill him, the not-quite voice not quite whispers. Kill them. It will be easy. They won’t feel a thing.

Bilbo’s breath stutters. He tightens the grip on his sword. It is so easy, he thinks, to slip and fall into the trap of following advises of awful, malevolent forces.

Sting stabs into its sheath.

The keys in hand, Bilbo stalks out of the cellar. The elves quietly snore on.

* * *

He frees Thorin first. The dwarf is lying on a bed — a carved slab of stone protruding out of the wall that somehow conveys elegance and sophistication — when Bilbo creeps up to the door. The keys not so much jingle as click against each other before he muffles the sound, clenching them in a fist.

Thorin’s eyes snap open. He props himself on his elbows. “Bilbo?”

“Yes, yes, it’s me,” Bilbo whispers, exposed but elated to be seen after so long in the world of shadows. With shaking hands, he turns the first key in the lock. It doesn’t work. He tries the next.

“You didn’t return,” Thorin says, and Bilbo hears hints of worry in his even tone.

His fingers fumble the keys, and his tongue stumbles over the details as Bilbo explains his plan. Key number fourteen turns. The lock clicks.

“Hurry,” Bilbo whispers, pulling the door open. He glances back at the corridor.

A sudden pressure on his shoulders startles him so badly, Bilbo is a hairbreadth away from jumping out of his skin. He flinches, whips his head around and gets a faceful of fur. The smell is a little musky, and Bilbo fleetingly wonders what kind of animal donated its pelt for Thorin’s coat.

The pressure increases, pulling him flush against a firm and oh, so deliciously hot chest. Like sitting before a fireplace after a ramble on a late autumn morning. Oh. Thorin is hugging me. Again, he realises, and, desperate for contact, for a connection with another living being, Bilbo returns the embrace. For the first time in what he suspects is years, no matter, however briefly, Bilbo feels safe.

“I never doubted you, Master Baggins,” Thorin murmurs, sending shivers down Bilbo’s back. A fire kindles in his belly.

“Just Bilbo, please. Remember?” He looks up into the eyes the colour of a cloudless sky and realises that no, Thorin doesn’t. Because for him, it never happened. Bilbo hasn’t asked, not this time. The warmth sours; the fire dwindles to a spark, burns to ashes.

“We mustn't delay. The celebration must have started by now.” And Bilbo slips out of Thorin’s grasps and looks away, avoiding the prettiest blue eyes he’s ever seen that now are filled with confusion.

They do move on. Through silent corridors, they sneak into another part of the prison. Scouting ahead, Bilbo checks that no one is on watch, then gestures to Thorin an all-clear.

Shouts of surprise and joy bounce off the walls as the Company greets their leader. Bilbo bites his lips. Bofur, whose cell is first, cheers him on, quite loudly at that. Squinting, Bilbo measures his girth. Concealing Thorin behind him will be as likely as a peach harvest in winter.

Before too long, however, Thorin commands silence. The volume drop to hushed whispers.

A click of the lock, and, pulling the keys off the ring, Bilbo divides them into three parts. Next, Kíli, then Nori join them, and soon, all members of the Company are free. The dwarves hug each other like they have been separated for leagues and years. Bilbo stays out of the way, on the stairs, listening for the light footsteps or melodic tones of elven voices that never come.

With as much stealth as thirteen dwarves can manage, which is surprisingly a lot, they reach the cellar undetected. Thorin directs everyone to hide inside the barrels and like a hawk watches them disappear one by one until he is the last dwarf left. He catches Bilbo’s arm.

“What about you?”

Bilbo stops his frantic pacing. “I’ll, I will be fine.” He nods twice. “Now, get in. Get going.”

And Thorin hesitates for just a moment, his hand a heavy but comforting weight.

“All right,” he says. “I trust you will follow.”

Bilbo swallows, caught in the endless blue. “I will.” He licks his lips. “Always.”

With a last lingering look, Thorin climbs in.

“All right,” Bilbo mutters, wiping his sweaty palms on his breeches. “All right.” And louder, “Hold your breath!”

Bilbo pulls the lever.

The floor inclines. The barrels tumble down.

Bilbo looks around. Too late he realises the flaw in his plan: there’s no empty barrel left for him. The trapdoor is swinging back, and Bilbo hesitates just for a second.

An elf — the butler — snorts and lifts his head. A bleary grumble. And louder but farther — the sounds of alarm. That settles it. Taking a deep breath, Bilbo dives in, falling, falling, falling into the rushing river.

He hits the surface with a hard impact. Ice-cold water scalds his skin and freezes the air in his lungs. He goes under.

No, no, no, tolls the bell in his head as Bilbo struggles to breach the surface. His arms pinwheel the water, but nothing seems to change. In the darkness of the underground cave, blind and helplessly lost, Bilbo panics. A scream trapped in his chest works its way free. Stupidly, Bilbo opens his mouth, but his voice is muted, and only bubbles escape his mouth.

Someone catches the back of his coat, tugs him upwards. Coughing and sputtering, Bilbo blinks the water out of his eyes and clings to the edge of a barrel.

“I’ve got you,” Thorin says, holding him close.

The current carries them forward. The alarm bells — real and imagined — continue to ring.

Bilbo shivers. His teeth are chattering. His fingers spasm on the slippery wood.

“Waterfall!” someone ahead screams.

And suddenly, the river plunges, and Bilbo’s stomach goes along with it. A moment of free-fall. The barrels hit the water and bump into each other, dislodging Bilbo’s grip. He goes under, but someone else — Balin — catches his arms, pulls him out. Bilbo holds on.

The river narrows, tall boulders form its jagged walls, and the currents are only speeding up. The barrels hit the boulders, again, again, and — one wrong turn — it’s not a barrel getting hit. It’s Bilbo.

His back in agony, he grunts and grits his teeth.

The river rushes on, rotates the barrels, and cascades. And Bilbo’s fingers slacken, lose their purchase.

“Another one!” cries Nori.

The fall is longer and, despite the warning, no less unexpected. Bilbo hits the water, tries to swim, but the currents are faster still. He plunges underwater once again. The river goes over rapids, treating him like a dog playing with a rag-doll, throwing him over rocks and into a boulder. He hits it with his head, and pain explodes across his skull. The water fills his mouth, pours into his nostrils—

Bilbo opens his eyes, warm, dry, and safe, and at his home, again.

His breath is quick, his lungs are burning with a remembered need for air.

Drowning, Bilbo decides, is far from the worst way to go. Top five of the best, actually, he thinks and laughs, and laughs until his throat is sore. He feels like sobbing would be more appropriate.

Instead, he laughs some more and keeps his eyes shut — this way, he doesn’t have to acknowledge the moisture on his cheeks. It is just water. Ha-ha-ha. Just. Water.

He spends the summer visiting the Stoors in the Marish. He fishes, practises with a bow, and learns how to swim.

Notes:

Dwarven insults [gurnvos’comys - tree humper; rukhs shirumund caragu - beardless orc dung] are from WattPad.

Chapter 9

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

The autumn comes in full. The Shire celebrates it with the new harvest. On market days, tweens and faunts run through the fields and hide behind tall stacks of cheery pumpkins, their laughter ringing in the air. Wreaths of gold and red leaves adorning every door and small bouquets left by the sides of the roads slowly turn deep brown and soft. The cycle ends.

The next begins.

One day, when Bilbo wakes, it is another summer. He gets out of bed. Musing on the dinner for the Company, he sighs and mourns the pumpkin pie he made but didn't eat the day before. Inevitable like sunrise, the wizard comes. The dwarves follow. They greet Bilbo like they often do when he does make an effort — jovially, with gratitude, with reservation, but without warmth. And Bilbo's heart aches. Familiar strangers. Then Thorin comes, and Bilbo meets distrustful eyes that held such tenderness just months before.

"Is this the halfling?" Thorin asks. Like always, he addresses Gandalf.

Bilbo's breath hitches; a rock is lodged in his breast beside his heart.

"He looks more like a grocer than a burglar," the dwarven king continues to the amusement of the rest. As if an honest occupation is an insult.

Swallowing the hurt, Bilbo invites him in, unerringly polite, and silently berates himself for foolish hopes. They do not know me, he thinks, not yet. But as time passes, he doesn't go out of his way to change it. The cycle goes on, and Bilbo goes through the motion.

They reach Mirkwood. Finding new paths, Bilbo leads the Company around the area with spiderwebs. The journey through the forest lasts longer, and Bilbo feels like they are closer to the edge than they have ever come before. It is not spiders that trip them up. It is the poisonous air.

They walk and walk along a narrow path he found, and as the grey light dims, mist creeps in, unrolling like a tablecloth between the thick tree roots.

"You hear that?" Bofur asks, canting his head to the side. The ears of his hat stick up at funny angles. His eyes are glazed over. "Someone's singing."

"Singing?" Dwalin mutters, frowning and focusing on nothing. "I hear crying."

"No, it's music!" Ori says. "I hear harps!"

The dwarves mutter.

"Let's check!" Bofur suggests. "It sounds like a party."

Bilbo strains his hearing, but there are only whispers.

Words too quiet, impossible to understand are breathed in his ear.

Bofur takes off. His brothers go with him.

"I'm going, too!" And Ori, followed by Dori and Nori, walks away at a fast clip.

Bilbo shakes his head. "Wait. Wait!" Ignoring his protests, the dwarves wander off.

"A party must have food," Kíli murmurs.

"Wait," Bilbo says or maybe wants to say but doesn't. The dwarves do not hear him or do not listen. His limbs encased in ice, he watches as Kíli and Fíli step off the path. Three paces in, they disappear in dense fog. And one by one, the other dwarves rush ahead.

The whispers morph into an indistinctive din of conversations, like listening through a closed door of a busy tavern.

"Come." Thorin jolts him forward with a light push on Bilbo's back as he passes by. Willing his feet to move, Bilbo falls into step.

The fog surrounds them. Thick and clinging, it embraces Bilbo with tendrils that seem sentient. They hold him down, slowing his movements. He imagines that swimming through a river of honey would feel the same.

Bilbo looks ahead, but there's no one.

"Thorin," he pushes the name past numb lips. "Thorin!"

No one answers. The din in his ears rises in volume. "Thorin!"

With tremendous effort, Bilbo wretches his limbs out of the milky-white strands that should not be so solid. He staggers forward, hoping that he chose the right direction. Step after step, he walks, blind to anything but the fog. Abruptly, the fog recedes and spits him out. Bilbo falls into a clearing.

Before him is a pandemonium that he perceives in blinding-bright flashes. Shouts and cries, the twangs of bowstrings and clang of steel, the creaks of breaking wood, the scent of blood and wine assault his senses. Upturned tables, broken plates, trampled dishes, and—Bilbo stumbles, his toes meeting something dense and wet. He looks down. There's an elf with a deep gash in his unmoving chest. The silver lanterns paint the blood a glistening black. Stifling a gasp, Bilbo covers his mouth with a clammy hand. He scrambles backwards, trips and falls. An arrow hisses past. Crouching, Bilbo ducks behind a bench.

Later, Bilbo will surmise what happened: the dwarves blundered onto the elven feast, and the elves reacted poorly. Thinking themselves under attack, they went for their weapons. The dwarves answered in kind. For now, fog fills his head — perhaps, it has migrated there from the forest. There's a buzzing in his ears, a swarm of angry bees. His feet are cold and sticky. He doesn't feel his toes.

Around him, he sees bodies. Bifur pincushioned with many arrows and Óin with just a single one blooming out of his eye. Nori's fighting an elf, but he's wounded — his left arm hangs limply, broken. The indistinctive voices reach a crescendo, roaring at Bilbo. And over the din of battle, the wordless war-cries and curses, a frigid, clear voice drawls,

"Thorin Oakenshield. I should have known."

"Thranduil."

The voices are cut off, mid-word.

And Bilbo's heart restarts. Alive, he thinks. Thorin is alive. That's good.

Unthinking, he puts his hand into his pocket. The ring slips on his finger by itself.

Two shouted commands — from one and then another king. The fighting stops. With rough shoves and pushes, the dwarves are corralled into a circle and stripped of their weapons. Ice spreads through Bilbo's veins. They are but seven. This cycle is a failure.

Stumbling and wavering, Bilbo follows the surviving half of the Company into the elven city. He rests. With sleep, come dreams — disturbing, half-forgotten things that don't refresh him in the slightest.

He finds the dwarves but has no chance to talk: the guards are always watching. They treat the dwarves harsher, too, feed just enough to survive, and if last time the dwarves thought the food unappetising, now it's unpalatable. A paste, nutritious but tasteless, fills their bowls. The dwarves do not seem to care. Mourning their fallen, they barely speak, and when they do, it's in Khuzdul, which Bilbo doesn't understand.

"You shouldn't be here," Thorin says, voice rumbling like gravel thrown on a tombstone. "Go home, Master Baggins. Find the means to travel back to Beorn and wait for the wizard. He might escort you back."

"What happened," Bilbo murmurs quickly, quietly, "it wasn't your fault."

"Wasn't it?" Thorin demands, glaring into the corridor, somewhere over Bilbo's head. "I am their leader."

"Thorin," Bilbo starts.

"No." Thorin shakes his head. His wan, desponded countenance hardens. He looks at Bilbo then, his eyes, though shining in the torchlight, are devoid of life. "Go. You shouldn't have come at all." He turns away and doesn't answer, no matter what Bilbo says. The guards' return forces Bilbo to retreat into shadows.

But Bilbo stays. A quiet presence, he offers what support he can, bringing cheese and bread and — once — wine, which Thorin does not touch.

When the opportunity arises, Bilbo frees the Company from the cells, but their absence is discovered too soon. The elves sound the alarm while the dwarves are climbing into the barrels. Bilbo hurries them up and pulls the lever, jumps after them and—hits his head on something in the river. Nobody catches him. No one pulls him out. Bilbo doesn't resurface.

Next go-round, the Company avoids the spiders and the feast but stumbles on an elven patrol and ends up captured all the same. Since there are no elven casualties, the guards are lax. Armed with a plan, Bilbo is confident this time he will get it right. It even goes well. Until it doesn't.

Perhaps, more than just the butler and the guards partake the Dorwinion wine too much, perhaps, it’s something unrelated. The reason doesn’t matter — their escape starts smoothly. The barrels hit the river with a loud splash-splash-splash, and Bilbo follows after. The water is, as always, freezing. The first contact is scalding, but Bilbo is ready for it. He swims and catches hold of Dwalin's outstretched arm. The dwarf hauls him closer, and awkwardly, Bilbo loops a rope around him — they wouldn't fit together in one barrel.

The river carries them over waterfalls and rapids. There's a guarded gate ahead, and the dwarves crouch while Bilbo holds his breath, plunging underwater. They pass the gate. The elves, looking outside their border, spot the dwarves. One shouts in alarm, but then—an arrow silences him forever.

Like ants, orcs pour out of the woods onto the rocky shores. A large, brutish orc issues guttural commands, and they attack. An elven horn falls silent, its wielder falling in the river. The enemies are quick to overwhelm the elves. Then, they attack the Company, but even weaponless, the dwarves aren't helpless. They beat the orcs with naked fists and wrench the swords from their hands, but it is not enough. The orcs are just too many.

With no one to distract them, orc archers shoot the Company. Like fish in barrels.

Bilbo wakes up. He hits the bed frame with his foot and curses at the pain.

“Not. Again.” The constant starting over is getting unbearably tedious. Once more, he grows tired of the repetitions.

Time goes by, and he is in Mirkwood again. The Company is captured. Again. This time, as Bilbo waits for the Feast of Starlight, he searches for a library and finds it soon enough. Like in Rivendell, it is a vast room with shelves reaching the high ceiling and aisles so long, he cannot see their ends. But there are no windows, no airy balconies look over quiet brooks, and no sunlight.

Weeks go by with Bilbo holed up in hidden nooks. He neglects the Company. Still hoping to avoid the Elvenking's hospitality, Bilbo looks for Mirkwood maps. He finds them for Greenwood instead, and they are old, inaccurate and probably forgotten. Staring at the beautifully drawn lines, the calligraphic script, the lovely illustrations, Bilbo swallows the urge to rip the map apart and set the library on fire. His fingers twitch, crumpling the parchment.

"Blast it!" he whispers and stills, mindful of the noise he made in utter silence. He counts seconds to five hundred. Nobody comes, and Bilbo slowly relaxes.

Debating with himself on what to do, he smoothes out the wrinkled parchment as best he can, which is not very well at all. Sighing, he rolls the map and shoves it in an inner pocket of his coat. Its absence will be less conspicuous than its current state. Besides, he doubts anyone has had a reason to use it since its creation.

He spies on the guards next and tracks them to the barracks. There, a newer map is pinned to a board. Tip-toeing closer, Bilbo studies the landmarks: the broken bridge is crossed out. Yes, that will do.

Patiently waiting for the evening, he watches as the elves come and go, some staying longer. They sharpen their blades or tend their armour. They gossip, play card games, read books. It seems so normal, soothing, even boring, and sitting in a corner, Bilbo almost falls asleep. He shakes himself awake as many elves leave — must be the time for dinner.

Approaching the board, Bilbo copies the corrections to the map in his possession. His hasty scratches and crosses and the blots of ink his pilfered quill leaves everywhere feel sacrilegious. A large blob lands on the heading, completing the ruination of the work of art. Bilbo doesn't care. Perversely, a part of him is glad for it. He stops.

No. Bilbo bites his knuckles as violent shivers rack his body. It is the ring's influence, he knows. Carefully holding the map, so the ink doesn’t smudge, he returns the quill and ink pot and walks away to hide somewhere out of the way. He finds a supply closet. There, among the rags and brooms, Bilbo presses his face to his knees, squeezes his eyes shut, and counts his breaths, dust coating his tongue.

Later, conscious of his unreliable ability to retain possessions, Bilbo memorise the net of trails and roads. And if by the end of it the ink is smeared, thinned with the salty droplets, there's no one to see or question it.

The day of the feast comes, and Bilbo gets the dwarves out. He times their escape just right for the elves to pursue them but not too soon. As the Company nears the gate, the guards alert the elves at the border. The grate is lowered just as the barrels reach it.

Black speech rings out. An arrow finds its target in an elf. Orcs pour out of the forest, and while they occupy the elves, Bilbo climbs to the shore and opens the passage. The barrels bobble downstream. Amidst the chaos, Bilbo jumps into the water and—Thorin catches him.

"All right?" he asks. Wet hair plastered all over his face, Thorin searches Bilbo's eyes.

"Yes." Bilbo licks his lips, blinks away stray droplets. His heartbeat quickens like a rabbit's. "Quite."

They stare at each other as if the battle—briefly—disappeared and only two of them remain. The moment doesn't last.

"Kíli!" Fíli screams and Thorin tears his gaze away from Bilbo.

"Kíli!" — an anguished and disbelieving cry, and Bilbo turns to see Kíli slumped over the rim of his barrel, a throwing knife piercing his neck.

"No," Thorin says. "Not Kíli, Mahal, not him. He can't be dead." Desperately, he struggles to reach his nephew. The current doesn't let him.

An orc runs out through the gap in the foliage just ahead, a ghoulish smile twisting his black lips. He aims. Bilbo has a split-second to push Thorin away. He might as well try moving mountains. As Thorin doesn't budge, Bilbo does the next best thing: he shields him. And wakes up.

"Might as well start over," Bilbo mutters. "What a disaster."

* * *

Time after time, Bilbo tries to lead the dwarves through the forest quickly, but no matter what he does, by spiders, by wandering off, or by an elf patrol, the dwarves always find themselves as captives of the elves. It seems they truly have no way to avoid it. Once, Bilbo leaves the dwarves in the cells.

"I'm sorry," he says, and Thorin waits, tense with anticipation. "The guards are watching the Company too closely. There is no way to lead you out of the dungeons quietly. You'd have to fight them all the way."

Thorin hits the bars with his palms. Impotent fury twisting his features, he rages, cursing their luck, elves, Thranduil and Gandalf—Bilbo retreats.

When he returns, the dwarf has calmed down. He sits on his bed — the stone slab is bare of any bedding — his shoulders slumped in defeat.

"I'm truly sorry, Thorin," Bilbo murmurs. "If only we could avoid this blasted forest..."

"It's not your fault." Thorin doesn't raise his gaze. His clenched fists are lying on his knees. "I should have known. We should have started earlier, go around Mirkwood."

Bilbo bites his lips. "Maybe," he starts and pauses, but speaks again, "Maybe you should accept Thranduil's offer."

Thorin goes rigid. "What offer?"

Slowly, he raises his head. His eyes are wide. His gaze is sharp and penetrating, it pins Bilbo to the spot. He doesn't move while Thorin stalks the scant few steps of distance to the bars.

"How do you know about that?" the dwarf demands. Then something changes: his face closes off, losing all expressions. "Are you his spy?" His voice is flat and lifeless.

"What? No!" Bilbo sputters. "That's preposterous! I've been hiding in the throne room when you two spoke!" The first time.

Thorin observes him with frosty, distant calmness. "Unless you were under Thranduil's skirt, I don't see where you could have hidden."

And no matter what Bilbo says, all his explanations aren't enough to quell the suspicions. With one suggestion, Bilbo lost his trust.

"All right," Bilbo decides. "You don't believe me. That's fine. I will leave you to it, then."

Thorin turns away, crosses his arms over his chest. The message is clear: he won't deal with the 'traitor' any longer.

Bilbo leaves.

"Ungrateful, suspicious, thick-headed dwarf!" he mutters, marching up a bridge. A passing elf stops and whirls around, searching for the source of a disembodied voice. But Bilbo doesn't care. He is invisible, what can she do?

Throw a knife at him as it turns out. As pain shoots through his back, Bilbo stumbles and cries out. Another knife buries itself in his shoulder. The third has no chance to find its target as Bilbo pitches off the bridge head-first. This death is far from pleasant.

"Stupid, careless idiot, that's who I am!" Bilbo exclaims. What a pair they make! He does deserve the stubborn, paranoid dwarf who sees betrayal everywhere. He learns the lesson well, however, and vows not to forget that invisible doesn’t mean invincible.

Bilbo tries again. He draws the map from memory while in Imladris. He now knows which way to go to leave Mirkwood, but as he feared, the elves catch the dwarves. Bilbo hides and follows.

He goes to the dwarves right away. This time, he is their messenger. Whatever news they wish to be conveyed — and there aren't many — he caries to Thorin and returns with his replies. Most of the Company are fine together, but Thorin's isolation is another punishment, a way to break him, and Bilbo will not stand for it.

They talk — significant and unimportant things — and swap the stories one for one. They make a game of it. A clear spring Thorin found in the mountains in exchange for Bilbo's first fishing trip; Belladonna's best thyme pie recipe for Thorin's mother's stew. Fell Winter for the years before Ered Luin. They grow closer. These moments chase away the cold, but it can never last. All heat is stolen with the next touch of the ring, leeched out into the ever-hungry world of never-ending shadows.

Time flies with Bilbo having given up on tracking it. The Feast of Starlight passes by unremarked upon. Bilbo waits. What feels like ages later, Gandalf finally arrives. He comes for Thorin with the elven guards.

"What took you so long, Tharkûn?" Thorin demands, rising to his feet, but then he notices the wizard's cloak is singed, his robe is stained, and his beard unkempt.

"What happened?" Thorin asks with some concern.

"I was delayed during my investigation," Gandalf says. He pauses, debating with himself, but in the end, the wizard frowns, and all he says is, "It's nothing you need to worry about. Not now, anyway. I have arranged your release."

The guards unlock the door. Swiftly, the wizard sweeps out of the dungeon, quick strides announcing his displeasure.

"What day is it?" Thorin asks, matching the wizard's speed with ease despite the difference in heights.

At Gandalf's answer, Thorin halts.

"Durin's Day has passed. We failed."

"Take heart," Gandalf is saying, "there's always next year.” But Bilbo, who has been running after them, invisible to all, collides with Thorin, hard. He bounces back and slightly to the side, and—

"Why is it always bridges?!!" he shouts, sitting on his bed. The sun is shining in his window. He rubs his eyes, unused to it after the semi-darkness of Mirkwood, and sighs, resigned to start over.

Do this, do that, bring such and such, and train. The tedium creeps in. He doesn't want to start from scratch, to build relationships that never last, not while he isn't sure this time will be the final. Polite and competent, Bilbo keeps his distance.

And in the dungeons of the accursed forest, he asks the dwarven king with whom this time he hardly spoke at all, "What will happen if we miss Durin's day?"

Crossing his arms over his chest, Thorin frowns. "We'll fail."

"But surely you can return in a year."

"And what are we to do in the meantime?" Thorin asks, regarding Bilbo like an outsider who he just doesn't understand.

"You can continue on, go to the Iron Hills. Visit your cousin. Perhaps, he will reconsider and aid you," Bilbo suggests, and Thorin snorts, derisive and dismissive all at once,

"Not likely." He does not elaborate. Turning sideways, Thorin stares at the wall, his lips are pressed tightly in displeasure.

With a sigh, Bilbo leaves him be. There is a keyring, after all, in need of stealing.

Notes:

Next chapter, they will get past Mirkwood. Seriously and honestly. Not kidding. PAST MIRKWOOD!! It's already partly written.

Chapter 10

Notes:

My apologies for the delay in updating. Free time is a precious commodity that I rarely have.

Chapter Text

Bilbo gets the dwarves out of the cells with no complications. It takes some effort, but he manages to find and steal their weapons. The elves chase them, and the orcs attack. As before, Bilbo climbs onto the shore to pull the lever. He is quick and careful about it, weaving between fighters who tower over him at twice his height. The grate comes up, and the barrels rush ahead, bumping along. Jumping into the river, Bilbo is prepared for the worst, but Nori is waiting for him. As soon as Bilbo reaches the barrel, Nori lets go of the wall and pulls him in. It is a tight squeeze, but Bilbo lost a lot of his hobbitish plumpness. Pressed back to back with one of his close friends who still regards him as a stranger, Bilbo tries his best not to impede his movements. Once, throwing a knife, Nori elbows him in the back of his head and mutters an apology, but that's the worst of it.

Somehow, they make it past the orcs. With proper weapons, the dwarves kill a good portion of their pursuers before the river flow carries them too far and too fast to follow, and Bilbo hopes the elves will finish the rest, but with his luck, it isn't a realistic expectation. The river reaches a shallow, and paddling to the shore, they climb onto the rocks. Nobody is dead or injured. Bilbo can't quite believe it. He keeps expecting a sudden attack, his nerves on edge. It seems the dwarves feel the same. Soaked to the bone, shivering and tired, they are on high alert.

A pebble crunches under a boot, and instantly, the whole Company bristles with weapons.

"Who are you?" a Man says. Standing on an outcrop with an arrow primed for release, he aims at Ori. Scowling, Dwalin steps before the young dwarf, ready to intercept the arrow with a swing of his axe.

Despite being outnumbered, the Man does not relax the bowstring. He must believe himself an excellent marksman, on par with elves, for such a confident stance. Diplomacy, however, works much better, which Balin hurries to prove.

“Excuse me, but that barge over there,” Balin says, climbing on the outcrop and nearing the Man, sharp eyes taking in all the details. “You wouldn't be for hire?”

“Who's asking?”

“We are just travellers. Simple merchants going to the Iron Hills.”

The Man levels Balin with a long look and finally slackens the bow. Wordlessly, he goes to his barge and starts uploading the barrels. Balin follows.

Bilbo steps out of the scraggly bushes, hiding his throwing knife. Nori catches his eyes. They nod.

The bargeman, meanwhile, points at the pits and scratches and other imperfections the barrels acquired in the fight. "I know where these barrels came from. Nobody enters Lake-town without the Master's say-so," he says, rolling them onto his boat. "And if you are in trouble with the elves, he'll never permit your stay. He won't jeopardise their trade."

"Enough with the niceties," Dwalin growls, coming forward. "How much?"

Narrowing his eyes, the Man names a sum.

"We do not have that many coins," Thorin says, staring the bargeman down, and Bilbo thinks the Man is going to refuse. Balin steps in.

"With us right now,” he says. “However, we have other items for trade.” They haggle and settle on a lower price and a wooden sparrow with flapping wings Bofur made at Beorn’s. The bargeman, whose name is Bard, directs them to sit beside the barrels. The Company huddles together — to gather payment and for warmth. They still fall short.

"Glóin?" Thorin says.

"What? You promised me riches, and what I get? All this Quest of yours has done so far is bleed me dry," the dwarf complains, hugging himself and puffing up his chest like a cockerel spoiling for a fight. But then, the barge clears a passage between two high walls, and one by one, they all look up at the view behind Gloin's back. Bilbo follows suit. In the distance, clear as the mist allows, the Lonely Mountain rises above the water, its snowy peak lost to the clouds.

"Oh," Glóin exhales. "Take it! Take it all!" Blindly, he pulls a coin purse and tosses it onto the deck, his eyes on Erebor. "I do not need it anymore! This" — he points at the mountain, and his hand is trembling — "this is worth it."

It must be, Bilbo thinks. This all can't be for nothing.

They sail in silence. The air grows cold, colder, freezing. Snow starts to fall. A snowflake lands on Bilbo's face, waking him. It is a beautiful, wintry day, and Bilbo would like to enjoy it, but his wet clothes are frozen stiff. His teeth are chattering. Squashed between Thorin and Bombur to warm his sides, his feet tucked under him, Bilbo prays to survive long enough to actually reach Lake-town.

"Quickly, into the barrels," Bard's demanding voice chases the drowsiness away.

"What?" Óin asks, aiming his horn at the bargeman.

Pressing his lips into a tight line, Bard snaps, "Climb into the barrels if you value both our freedoms."

Into the barrels they go. Bilbo squeezes in with Ori. Time passes, minute after minute, and the anticipation that makes a heart beat faster gives way to boredom and tiredness again. Ori radiates enough heat to warm a bathhouse, and Bilbo's eyelids slide shut, sleep taking hold of him despite the uncomfortable position. The barge slows down, then stops. Bilbo's head jerks up. He hears unfamiliar voices. Footsteps. Silence. Then a waterfall of fish pours on their heads.

The dwarves shout in protest, but Bard barks, "Silence or you will alert the guards!" and they subside. The journey goes on, this time with fins and scales cooling Bilbo’s skin. Finally, the barge slows down.

"Halt! Goods inspection," Bilbo hears. A stop.

He strains his ears, but the Men talk at regular volume, their words indistinct hum, and what he understands is this: they've reached Lake-town. Now that the Lonely Mountain is closer than ever, Bilbo expects to die. At any moment, he thinks, a guard will shout in alarm or poke our barrel with a spear. But nothing goes wrong. Their barge comes through the gate and glides into the town.

"Quickly, climb out," Bard urges. "My house is watched. You'll have to come in another way."

They suffer the indignity of the disgustingly unsanitary way into Bard’s house.

What do the people here think, using the same lake as both the well and outhouse?! Bilbo wonders, quietly horrified. How are they still alive? Every faunt in the Shire knows not to dirty the drinking waters. He puts that thought away lest he makes himself sick.

Bard's children — three tweens, by hobbitish reckoning — welcome the Company to their home. The middle one, Sigrid, provides them with blankets, and soon, Bilbo succumbs to sleep beside the fire — his first proper rest without the ring.

He wakes up to Thorin shaking him awake.

"The dawn nears." Thorin's face is two handspans away. The fireplace was banked for the night, and in the embers' light, Thorin's eyes are deep and dark. "The bargeman came through on our agreement — we have a boat. We must go now." His gaze falls, stopping on Bilbo's lips, before he steps away, offering Bilbo a hand up.

Only when Thorin releases his grip and moves on does Bilbo start to breathe. He rubs his face and sighs. His clothes dried while he rested, but his cheeks are too warm to explain with the heat of the fireplace.

The evening before, Bombur helped Sigrid in the kitchen, and so with a bowl of thin but spicy soup and a chunk of grey, sandy bread to slake their hunger, the Company gathers their supplies — worn but sturdy packs filled with food and necessities. Led by Bard, they sneak out, thankfully, using the proper entrance this time. A Men-sized boat is moored behind the house. While large at first glance, it barely fits the Company.

"Thank you," Thorin says, clasping the bargeman's arm as dwarves one by one step into the boat.

"Don't make me regret it," Bard replies. His severe face, prematurely aged by a hard life, settles deeper into a scowl etched into the lines between his brows.

Guiding the boat through the channels amidst chunks of ice, Bombur and Dori row away, leaving Lake-town behind. Lit with rare lanterns, it gleams like an ember floating on the dark surface of the water. Bilbo regrets not seeing it in the day. It is built on stilts, in a lake. That's not something you see every day.

They reach the shore in the weak morning light and chilling mist.

"Erebor." Thorin sighs, looking at the mountain with longing. "We are almost home. Come!"

"Maybe we should take a break," Bofur suggests. "It's a long way up, and the lads are tired."

"No time to waste." Thorin quells any protests with a glare. "Durin's day is upon us."

While they climb up the base of the mountain to reach an overlook, the sun comes out in full and burns off the fog, revealing the scorched ruins of a city lying on the other side of the valley below with stark clarity.

Thorin pauses for a moment only to spare a glance. “Dale. What's left of it." He makes to move past.

“Wait," Bilbo says. “Aren’t we to wait for Gandalf here? He said not to venture farther without him.” He bites his lips. There's no way for Gandalf to reach them in time, not when the wizard always comes to Mirkwood a week late. Still, Bilbo feels caution is important now.

"Do you see him anywhere?" Thorin demands, gesturing at the rocky plains behind and the road ahead. "We don't have time for his wandering ways. Daylight is wasting." There’s a fire in his eyes, a desperate, dangerous sort of conviction. Without a second's delay, he turns to the path and continues on.

Swallowing the unease that manifests as a lump in his throat, Bilbo follows.

At midday, they come to the feet of a gigantic statue carved in the side of the mountain. The dwarf's features — a strong, prominent nose, long hair, proud countenance — bear a striking resemblance to Thorin.

The Company trails to a stop.

“Durin the Deathless,” Bofur says. “Fitting.”

"Look for the path. It must be here, somewhere close,” Thorin says, and the dwarves spread out.

Bilbo doesn’t move. He stares at the statue, studies the details — the armour, helmet, axe. Narrowing his eyes, he tilts his head and—there! Right at the sole of a massive boot what at first seems an ornamental detail becomes the start of a staircase.

"I found it! Right here!" Bilbo shouts, pointing and waving the Company over. Thorin reaches him first.

"You have keen eyes, Master Baggins," he says, a giddy smile on his lips. He clasps Bilbo's shoulder but barely spares him a second's look, his eye's on the mountain.

Bilbo tells himself he isn’t disappointed in the lack of a more personal acknowledgement. He is not. He squashes the part of him that insists a hug would have been nice.

The climb is tedious. At first, the staircases zig-zag. The steps are hard and narrow and cold under Bilbo's feet, but they are smooth and do not poke his soles with sharp edges. The dwarves are of hardier stock, they do not tire easily. The same, however, isn’t true for gentlehobbits. While Bilbo's recent life has seen to increase in his endurance, it isn't unlimited.

They climb and climb, the sun journeying around the sky, and still, they go up and up without rest. Bilbo’s breath comes out in huffs. His tunic and coat both stick to his back. His knees ache. He isn't the only one at the end of his tether, but step by step, they climb, tenacity prevailing over common sense.

The light changes from midday-bright to richer colours of an early evening. The stairs do not end.

But finally, he sees it — the last ladder, beside the statue's shoulder. The platform with the door must rest beside its head. But—one mistake. That's all it takes for Bilbo to start over.

He steps too close to the edge. A loose rock tumbles from beneath his foot, and Bilbo falls backwards, arms spinning, fruitlessly attempting to catch hold of something, anything. He falls, tumbling down the steps like a sack of flour, hitting his back, and arms, and legs, and head, and— Consciousness deserts him after the third turn over.

Half the Shire must hear Bilbo's frustrated scream.

“Are you kidding me?! I can’t believe it!” he shouts upon waking up. “I was this close!” He holds his thumb and forefinger a hair’s width apart to illustrate his point and shakes his hand. He hits the mattress with his palms and screams again, resting his forehead against his knees. He sits like this for one more minute and then stands up.

“This time, I will make it all the way to the damned dragon!” Bilbo swears. His eyes feverish-bright, his lips — a bloodless line.

Like many times before, away he goes on a Quest, and everything repeats with minor variations until they leave Mirkwood behind, once more in barrels: an orc shoots Fíli in the arm. Still, they escape with everyone alive. Once out of the barrels, Óin treats Fíli's wound, washing it as best he can with river water.

"The arrow went straight through, but orcs are known for using poison." Clucking his tongue and frowning, Óin bandages the wound with strips of linen he always keeps in his pockets. He shakes his head. "Nothing else to be done now. Let's hope there's a good market in Lake-town."

The bargeman finds them then and aims at Fíli. The Company closes ranks around him.

"Don't do any sudden movements," Bilbo says, Sting touching the Man's back with just enough pressure to suggest a quick thrust will pierce his kidney. Bard startles, stiffens, and complies. As Balin steps forward, Bilbo retreats. He doesn't notice the admiring nor speculative glances.

Negotiations for the voyage go underway, but Bilbo is prepared. He opens the seams of his coat with quick slashes of a throwing knife and shakes out enough money to double the Company's combined resources.

"Come now," Bilbo says to Bard, meeting the Man's eyes. "Even if the elves have any objections to our presence in Lake-town — which is a big if, might I add — we won't be there long enough to cause any trouble. We'll leave tomorrow, at first light. With any luck, you won't hear of us again."

For several long minutes, Bard regards him with a shrewd look. "I've heard of Halflings. The word is your people don't usually leave your land.” The way he says it invites an explanation.

"I have my reasons,” Bilbo says evenly, and Bard relents.

"All right, we will do it your way."

* * *

Flurries of large, picturesque snowflakes pour over Lake-town, masking the shabbiness of the buildings. The people are another matter. They bear signs of their taxing way of life plain for all to see. With wind-bitten, hollowed cheeks and rough, calloused hands, in patched-up coats and shawls, they claw the means to survive out of the icy waters.

The barge stops at the tollgate, money changes hands, and they are waved through, but a stooped Man in all black spring out of the outpost before they pass.

"Not so fast. Bringing trouble with you, I see?” He glances past Bard with unabashed glee. “The Master has had enough of you disturbing the peace! Now you've done it. Guards, seize him. The Master wants to have a word. And bring these vagabonds along!"

Armed Men encircle them. It is an ambush laid for Bard — the Men are few, and if the dwarves just so choose, they'd overpower them easily. But Thorin shakes his head — no — and the Company subsides. The order to disarm meets stony glowers and growled refusals and is promptly dropped.

"Wait, why are you arresting him?" Bilbo asks, the first to come to Bard’s defence. "He did nothing wrong."

The Man in black, a worm if ever Bilbo saw one, slinks forward. "He's a bargeman with a licence for carrying empty barrels. He doesn't have permission to carry passengers, now does he?"

"There's a licence needed for that now? Since when?" Bard demands.

"Since the Master said so," the Man in black says and smiles, baring all his equine teeth.

Surrounded by guards, in silence, they go to a square with the largest house of Lake-town.

The smarmy attendant — perhaps, adviser — slinks to the Master’s side and whispers in his ear as soon as the corpulent Man steps out. Of said Master of Lake-town, the less said, the better, such an unpleasant Man he is. Next to his subjects, his appearance — his oily gaze, be-ringed fingers, and rich clothing — is like a jig on a funeral.

Thorin steps forward before the Master can assign the blame. "You must forgive the bargeman his transgression. His good nature won over his sense — he couldn't leave distressed travellers to their misfortune."

"And who are you to speak to me in such a manner?" the Master sneers, the corners of his eyes crinkling as he squints at Thorin with suspicion.

Thorin breaths in deep. His head is held high and proud as he announces his name and heritage, and title.

And Bard turns pale, his lips thin into a fine line. He whirls to face the dwarven king.

"I know what you plan. You can't enter that Mountain. You have no right!"

Thorin turns his head and measuredly, calmly says, "I have the only right."

He makes a speech to the expanding crowd, promising recompense and an alliance. The Master’s eyes light up with greed. The way he looks at Thorin reminds Bilbo of Lobelia sizing up his silver teaspoons and his great grandmother’s prized cookbooks.

"Have you forgotten what became of Dale?" Bard asks.

"Ah, Dale,” the Master drawls. "How good of you to remember the city that your ancestor failed to protect!"

"Arrow after arrow he shot at the dragon," the attendant supplies, "and missed, every one of them."

Bard shuts his eyes, expression pained. "Not every one. One loosened a scale," he murmurs, but his head is bowed. He knows that he lost, still—

"Have you forgotten the prophecy?" Bard asks in a voice void of hope. And Bilbo's heartbeat speeds up, dread filling him to the core as, louder, Bard recites,

"The lord of the silver fountains, the King of carven stone, the King beneath the mountain shall come into his own! And the bell shall ring in gladness at the Mountain King's return, but all shall fail in sadness, and the lake will shine and burn."

"Gladness," the Master says, latching onto the word with speed lest the crowd’s mood turns sour. "Gladness, indeed. Unto you, I say, welcome! Welcome to Lake-town, the dwarves of Erebor!"

They follow the Master into a tavern, leaving the prophesied tragedy and its teller behind. The food and drink are in abundance — the Master, it seems, has taken to heart Thorin's promise of shared wealth.

Throughout the evening, Bilbo worries. The dwarves, so set on following their own prophecy, disregarded Bard's words without a second's thought. He, however, can't forget them. They sound in his mind in rare quiet moments, in lulls of conversations and breaks between songs.

He watches the Company eat and drink their fill, ale, and beer, and wine flowing like rivers. The dwarves dance among and with the hardy Lake-town folks, all but a few. The first is Thorin. Silent but seemingly content, the dwarven king sits beside the Master at the grandest table. His chin is resting on his fist, he listens to the Master's words, his mind elsewhere.

And at another table is Fíli, whose skin is pallid and greying, marred with red splotches, and Kíli sitting at his side, trying to coax his brother to take a sip of broth. As soon as the matter of their possible imprisonment was put to rest, Óin treated Fíli's arm with Mannish medicine, but Bilbo is doubtful it helped.

The evening goes on and turns into the night. The candles melt and are replaced. Unable to resist exhaustion, Bilbo hugs his knees and falls asleep where he is, too used to dozing off in corners.

He dreams of fire on the lake — the burning water, melting ice; the sky  reflects it with red-orange flashes. He wakes uneasy and ill-rested. His neck is aching and left leg asleep. Around him are mostly empty tables — the mugs with dregs, the crusts and bones, and one half-eaten pie. And, Bilbo notices, he didn't fall asleep alone. Bofur is snoring on the floor, Bombur is on a bench beside the princes. The rest are missing.

Before he can start searching, Dwalin comes for them.

"You're awake, good." He nods at Bilbo, shakes Kíli's shoulder and almost stomps on Bofur's hand.

"Wake up, you lazy sod! We've gotta get provisions."

"'m up," Bofur mumbles. Dwalin snorts, grabs a mug of water and splashes it onto Bofur's face. The miner bolts upright.

"What did ya do it for?"

Crossing his arms over his chest, Dwalin smiles. "Now you're up. We've gotta go to the market."

"Fíli is burning up," Kíli says, pale and withdrawn beside his feverish brother, whose bandages are bloodstained.

"I'll find Óin," Bilbo says, all aches and discomfort of hard sleep forgotten. He dashes outside along with Dwalin, Bofur not far behind. They do meet Óin reasonably quickly, and he requests they find Kingsfoil.

"Kingsfoil?" a merchant says when asked. "Why would I sell weeds? We feed it to the pigs."

Through narrow streets and wide boulevards, they search for it, but there aren’t many places for plants to grow. All seems hopeless. Perhaps, they’ll need to go to the shore — the road leading to Mirkwood can’t be a barren wasteland. But finally, Bofur calls, "Found it!"

He brandishes a bunch of slightly chewed stems crowned with tiny white flowers. Exchanging lightning-quick grins, there and gone, they hurry back and at the door meet Thorin.

The dwarven king forgoes greetings. "Gather your things. We are leaving.”

"But what about Fíli?" Bilbo ask. Surely, he can't mean—but no, he does.

"He's staying. We can't afford to bring him along."

Bilbo blinks. "But—"

"But nothing,” Thorin cuts him off. “He'd be nothing but a burden." He doesn’t see it, but behind his back, Kíli’s face falls, his shoulders slump and curve forward.

"I'm staying, too. My place is with my patients,” Óin says from, true to word, the chair beside Fíli.

As if borrowing the healer's hearing affliction, Thorin commands, "Come quickly. We mustn't delay any longer,” and shoulders past Bofur.

Inside, Bilbo finds a small pack left for him — someone must have purchased it in the market. He checks on Fíli, but the dwarf is unconscious. His unwrapped wound is seeping dark, almost black blood.

"This isn't good," Bilbo murmurs.

"No, lad, it is not,” Óin says, grounding Kingsfoil. The pestle scrapes the bottom of the mortar. “With luck, he'll pull through." He sighs. "Go. You shouldn't disobey the king's command."

Bilbo glances at white-faced, miserable Kíli, who holds his brother’s hand, and at the tavern, empty but for a Woman cleaning up the tables. "He isn't my king." He hands the pouch with all of his remaining money to the younger prince. "You will need to pay for accommodations."

Reluctantly, with heavy a heart and troubled mind, he leaves.

The townsfolk have come along with Master of Lake-town to bid them farewell. A troupe of musicians heralds the Master's speech.

Bilbo doesn't listen. Instead, he watches Thorin: the grim determination of Mirkwood, the softer side he showed there, all gone, replaced with jittery anticipation. The Master’s speech winds down, and the troupe starts an upbeat melody. The townsfolk cheer, hopeful smiles lighting tired faces. In the crowd, Bard’s condemning eyes watch them from a mirthless face, still and sorrowful like an ice carving. Bilbo bites his tongue.

Dwalin and Dori work the oars, taking their boat away. The cluster of wooden buildings gets smaller with the distance. The clouds part. Awash in reddish sunlight, Lake-town floats amid the splashes of red-orange. Bilbo looks away.

At the base of the Mountain, Bilbo pretends to look for the stairs and is, of course, the one to find it, and up they go. They climb, again without rest, with Thorin in the lead as their relentless leader. Bilbo's legs ache, his throat is parched, he is exhausted, but as the last staircase comes into view, he clings to the mountain. Carefully, slowly, he makes it to the ledge. He made it.

“The door. It must be here," Thorin says, studying a blank expanse of wall. "We have a key. There must be a lock. Nori."

And Nori starts the search. He listens with his ear pressed to the stone while knocking with a spoon. "It's here," he confirms.

The light waning; the dwarves grow agitated.

"It's almost over," Thorin says. "Look again." They all search for the elusive keyhole, but even as the last sun rays shine upon the wall, the lock is not revealed. Nothing. A shocked, disbelieving silence spreads among them.

"I'm sorry, Thorin." Balin pats his shoulder. "We tried."

Thorin hangs his head. He stays still, frozen by the crushing disappointment.

"No." Bilbo shakes his head. "This can't be it. Our journey couldn't have been for nothing. We've come so far, and you are giving up?"

"What's here left to do? We failed. This door has powerful enchantments — there is no way to open it by force." Heavily, as if the weight of Erebor itself is put upon his shoulders, Thorin turns to the stairs. "Let's go. The way down won’t be easier."

As the dwarves start the arduous descent, Bilbo stays behind. He won't give up. He didn't live through all the deaths and perils of countless journeys just for a paltry slab of rock to stop him. No, a million times no. If not the blasted secret door, he’ll find a way to Smaug through the front gate. He saw it from a distance half-destroyed. He will crawl to the blasted dragon if necessary, and he will feed it with the ring. Who knows, perhaps two evils will cancel each other.

Lost in thoughts, he stares at the wall. A shaft of moonlight falls across it and—Bilbo's eyes widen as right before him a patch of stone sinks in, revealing a keyhole.

"Thorin, come back," he says, staring at it lest it disappears. "It's here. The last light of Durin's day is moonlight." He glances over his shoulder. "Where's the key?" A glint of metal on the very edge of the platform catches his gaze.

"Of course," Bilbo mutters. He falls to his knees and approaches it this way. No need to tempt his luck. The key secured in his fist, he scoots back. A deep breath in.

The key turns. A click, a change in pressure, and with the sound of grinding gears, the door pops open. The passage is pitch-black — a yawning maw of an unknown beast with damp, stale breath.

He looks back. No one has returned. Bilbo is alone.

Steeling his resolve, he marches in. He makes his way by feel, hands trailing  along the wall. His fingers find recesses and raised lines — it must be decorated. The smooth, cold floor under his cautious feet is slightly wet. His footsteps echo. He doesn't know how long he walks, but at some point, lighting changes, and Bilbo steps into a dimly lit cavern. He's inside the Erebor, at last.

The treasury is the vastest room he has ever seen. Mountains of coins topped with coloured rocks and jewellery lie as far as the eye can reach. No hint of scales, however. The dragon must be sleeping, and Bilbo needs to find and wake him up. His heartbeat speeds up. This is it, he thinks and jumps, and lands on coins.

Sharp edges prick the soles of his feet. He walks, then climbs. The coins shift and clink — he doesn't care to be careful or silent. A rock gets underfoot, and Bilbo stumbles. He curses as an avalanche of gold shift the unsteady ground. And when the coins stop, the silence doesn't last. The noise is such as if the mountain itself wakes up. Two steams of air send the coins tumbling, revealing giant nostrils. The ground moves and heaves. And Bilbo can only stare as the gold rains down. A frantic thought flies through his mind: How big exactly is this dragon?!

A snout rises first. It alone is as tall as three hobbits standing on each other. Bilbo can't look away. His knees grow weak. The dragon's head is even taller than its snout. The rest of him — enormous, beyond compare.

"Thief," the dragon says, his voice is deep and rumbling.

“I-I,” Bilbo stutters. He licks his lips and swallows, tries again. "I am no thief, oh Smaug the Magnificent."

"Are you not, indeed?" The dragon raises to full height. He sniffs the air. "Then why did you come if not to steal?"

"To witness your perfection. Tales of your beauty and might have reached far, but hearing about you, I knew I needed to see you for myself."

"And do I measure up?" The dragon sounds idly curious.

"Oh, yes, you outdid my expectations, oh Smaug the Stupendous."

"Hm." The dragon tilts his head. "For a lier, you are polite. You stink of dwarves. Where are they? Cowering outside my kingdom, too scared to show themselves?"

"Dwarves?" Bilbo's hand drops into his pocket. "I don't know anything about any dwarves. My journey is mine alone."

The dragon sighs. “Very well, cling to your lies. It doesn't matter. Alone you say? Then you will die alone."

Steam is coming out of the dragon's nose, his chest and throat are glowing like embers, and Bilbo wants to faint. A furnace with wings, Bofur had called him. As Smaug rises on his hind legs, Bilbo dives to the side while putting on the ring. A stream of fire hits the treasures.

"Where are you, would-be thief?" The dragon moves, steps forward. "I smell you." His voice insidious and sly, he says, "Do not be shy, show yourself.” A long exhale. “I smell gold on you."

Swallowing, Bilbo scrambles to hide behind a column. He is not careful enough. Each of his steps leaves coins shifting, tumbling in his wake.

"A-ha, here you are," the dragon says and spits a gust of fire.

Turns out, a dragon can not, in fact, melt the damn ring. It is, in a way, a good thing, for Bilbo is roasted along with it. He wakes up with the dual feeling of disappointment and relief.

"That could have gone better." He sighs and rubs his face, trying to forget the phantom scent of cooking meat that turns his stomach. It's time, Bilbo decides, to ask how to actually get rid of the accursed thing.

Soon, Gandalf visits, and the Quest restarts. There's no roast at the dinner table.

He travels with the Company to Rivendell, and there Bilbo waits for the Company to leave. He stays behind. Two days have passed when he approaches Lord Elrond at the head of the dining table and is invited to join him.

Bilbo climbs onto a chair made for a person of a taller race. His feet don't reach the ground.

“My lord,” he starts when goblets have been emptied and topped trice. The elves partake the wine freely, but Bilbo doesn't. “Say, hypothetically speaking, if you needed to dispose of a magical item.” He pauses, gauging the reaction: a piqued interest, no recognition. “An item of some power.” Still nothing. “Clothed in a simple form. Perhaps—” his tongue darts to wet his lower lip “—a ring?”

Lord Elrond stills. His pupils constrict and then dilate so far, Bilbo fancies he can see in them his reflection.

“A ring.”

“A ring,” Bilbo agrees. He sips his tea, puts the delicate porcelain cup onto the saucer — a quiet clink. “Mind you, this is just a mental exercise, you understand.”

He isn’t worried.

"Say, hypothetically," Lord Elrond starts, "is it a ring no simple means can harm?"

"Just so."

"Then I would urge its finder to caution. There was a ring thought lost, but if it's ever found, the only way to destroy it would be the fires of Orodruin where it was forged.”

“I thank you, my lord, for indulging my curiosity."

"And Bilbo?" Lord Elrond waits for Bilbo to meet his eyes — unfathomable, ageless, troubled. “If that ring were found or is found in the future, I would like its bearer to keep in mind that he can always find help with us. He needs only to ask."

Bilbo nods. "I will remember."

He finishes his tea. The blend is exquisite — light, fruity, and warming — a hug on a summer morning made into a liquid. He'll miss it in the days to come. He puts the empty cup aside and, wishing his host a good night, retires to his room.

The cycle is about to restart.

Chapter 11

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Orodruin, Bilbo knows from his studies of the maps, is nowhere close to Erebor. As the Quest starts, Bilbo considers parting with the Company early, perhaps, at Beorn's. But as time goes on, the excitement of having a solid plan, however hard it is in execution, wins out over his fatigue. He starts to interact with the dwarves freely. He grows fond of them anew, this ragtag Company — the joyful, playful princes, humorous Bofur, inquisitive Ori... Once more, they win over Bilbo's heart. And then, there's Thorin.

Thorin and his ever-present gaze that never leaves him. Bilbo feels it when he cooks dinner with Bombur, trading recipes and offering tips on the best places to forage as they travel. It follows him when Bilbo spars with Dwalin and bests him in combat, slipping under the large dwarf's guard and holding a sword to his throat. It's there when he talks with Dori, discussing tea blends and wines, and when he teaches Shire history to Ori. At times, it seems there's nowhere he can hide where Thorin's attention would not go.

A day away from the Trollshaws, howls rend the air as they are settling for the night.

"Oh, it must be wargs! Orcs' raiding parties are prowling these lands," Kíli says in what he clearly believes is an ominous whisper. "I heard stories..."

"They will creep into camps like our is, on nights like this, carrying filthy and gruesome riders," Fíli picks up the thread.

"The wargs and orcs are not enemies to take lightly." Bilbo glances up from his sword — a dagger in a Man's hands, it is indeed a proper sword for a hobbit. The edge is sharp; Bilbo has seen to that, but nothing worth comparing with his Sting. Soon, he will get his favoured weapon back. He puts away the whetstone, takes up an oiled cloth. "You've never fought in a real battle, have you?"

The princes shake their heads.

"You will, of course. This Quest is dangerous. And when you do, when enemies too numerous to take on chase after you and corner you like rabbits, and you have no way out but to fight against an overwhelming force, say four or five to one—and orcs have wargs, remember? These slavering beasts they beat and disfigure, starve until they are rabid with pain and hunger, and only then they sic them on their prey. Now, imagine that and how you will feel."

The princes pale. Eyes round like brass buttons of a faunt's doll, they stare at Bilbo with their mouths falling open.

"You will be terrified, sure, and not just for your own life. And brave, because you are brave boys, I see it. You will fight. Imagine even that you win. Perhaps, not all of your companions and kin are so lucky, but you are. You live. And now, I want you to imagine, to think of what it takes to kill. What killing takes from you and what surviving does." He stands then, puts his sword away. And all is silent save for the fire, the chirping of the crickets, and the wargs. He nods and steps into the shadows.

"What happened, Bilbo?" Gandalf asks, finding him later. The night has come in full, but the ponies' warmth is enough to stave off the chill, huddled close as they are.

Bilbo feeds Myrtle the last piece of carrot, pats her neck and sneezes. He wipes his nose with his favourite handkerchief — embroidered with Belladonna blooms. And looking up, he meets the wizard's saddened eyes head-on.

"A lot. Too many things to count. In short, life happened, Gandalf. Good night." He walks away, returning to the camp and under Thorin's watchful gaze.

The journey goes on. The trolls they can't entirely avoid, but Bilbo urges the Company to move past them.

"I've heard distressing rumours while in Bree, and this—" he gestures at the burned down house "—this is bad news. A family lived here just last month."

And Thorin nods, demeanour serious and thoughtful. "We must press on. Whoever did it, they might be near. Be on your guard."

They pass the danger, but Bilbo catches Gandalf's sleeve and murmurs, "It's trolls. I overheard the Rangers talking."

"This is troubling," the wizard says. "Let us hope we are far enough." He strokes his beard and hums. "I must investigate another matter. Try not to get eaten in the meantime."

"Where are you going?" Thorin demands, crossing his arms over his chest.

"To look ahead."

"And how soon will you be back?"

"Whenever I will look behind. I'm not a youngling with a curfew. I will return when I decide and not a moment sooner." With that, the wizard strides away, his long legs carrying him swiftly.

"At dawn, Eru willing," Bilbo mutters, and Thorin looks at him with questions in his eyes but sighs and leaves in silence.

The night is quiet, if not restful, and in the morning, Gandalf leads them to the cave with hidden treasures. The younger dwarves marvel at the stone trolls, but wisely, though Bilbo half-expects it, no one comments on how they would have liked to test their strength against such foes.

"Here, I think, is the perfect sword for you," Gandalf says, distracting Bilbo from contemplating Bert's surprised face. The wizard presses the elven dagger into Bilbo's hands, and Bilbo thanks him, hangs the scabbard on his belt.

He puts away his simple sword and hesitates. "Hm."

"Something the matter?" Thorin asks, his sharp regard a constant Bilbo doesn't even notice. That is a lie. He tracks their leader always. Not outright, of course, but from the corners of his eyes. He tells himself he doesn't.

"No, no. Just thought of something new." He puts his Mannish sword into his pack at last, but just for now.

"I've never tried dual wielding, that is all."

The oddest look crosses Thorin's face. Before Bilbo can begin deciphering it, the racket of the rabbit-pulled sledge puts the Company on high alert.

The wizards talk, the warg attacks, the Company jumps on their ponies and spur them into a gallop.

This cycle is of the luckier ones. Even as part of the orcs' party chases the Company instead of the brown wizard, the elves meet them halfway and lend a hand dispatching their enemies.

"Thank you for your assistance," Thorin mutters under Balin's and Gandalf's pointed looks. "We must be off, however."

But Gandalf takes him aside, and after some debate and expressive gesticulation, Thorin announces their next stop with visible reluctance. To Rivendell, they go.

Lord Elrond greets them, and without a second's thought, Bilbo steps forth to talk with him.

"Your mother was Belladonna Took? Was she the one who taught you? I commend you — your Sindarin is perfect," Lord Elrond says, and only then Bilbo notices the silence of the Company, the stares.

"Oh." He clears his throat. "How rude of me. I was just thanking Lord Elrond for his hospitality," he explains for the dwarves, and for their host, he adds, "My parents left a vast collection of books.” He shrugs. “It helped."

That doesn't explain his flawless pronunciation, but nobody questions him on it.

Some minutes later, they are escorted to their accommodations. Thorin insists on staying in one room, and so their elven guide shows the Company to a suitable chamber. The dwarves go inside, but Bilbo doesn't.

"You aren't coming?" Thorin asks, staying just inside the doorway.

"No. Lord Elrond offered my mother's old room. Apparently, they keep it just for hobbits." He chuckles. "I'm looking forward to a proper-sized bed."

Thorin's gaze darts to their escort. The elf is waiting at a respectable distance, allowing them to keep an illusion of privacy. There's no telling how sharp his hearing is; his placid expression never changes.

"Your mother visited the elves?" Thorin asks.

“Oh, yes! She was quite the adventurous sort in her youth, used to travel with Gandalf. No further than Rivendell, mind you, but for a hobbit lass, that is quite far and most scandalous besides." His smile is soft as he remembers his mother's stories heard so long ago. "It would be interesting to hear Lord Elrond's recollections. She passed away, oh, seven winters back?" he explains, preempting the question. "It feels much longer."

"I understand," Thorin says. He squeezes Bilbo's wrist briefly, and Bilbo shivers.

"Yes, well. I'm looking forward to a bath, don't you? It's been a while since I had a proper soak. I'm going to find a hot spring and not leave it till late evening. You should do so as well; it's quite relaxing. They are so lovely here, hot springs and evenings."

As Bilbo speaks, Thorin's eyebrows climb higher and higher, and belatedly, Bilbo realises how his words could be taken and blushes.

"Oh, that's not how I meant it. I mean, you do stink, so you should wash up too and do laundry while you are at it, but it was not an invitation to bath together." He nods, his skin so hot, he must be brighter than a beet soup. "Good day." And he is off, traversing corridors with the ease of familiarity.

Belatedly, Bilbo slows down and waits for the elf accompanying him to take the lead. It wouldn't do to show that he knows his way around here.

"Whatever was that?" Bilbo mutters once left alone and smacks his forehead in absolute embarrassment. "You stink? Who outside their tweens says that aloud?!" He groans, shakes his head. So Thorin thinks he is a loon and rude, at that. It doesn't matter. He has a task, which isn't forging close friendships.

He skips the dining hall in favour of the kitchens. Enquiring about the way beforehand, Bilbo arranges a light meal to eat in his room. And in the morning, he finds the training yard and watches elves practice. After a while, he asks to join and soon enough finds a willing teacher. The elves look upon him fondly — his diminutive stature, pointed ears and fluency in Sindarin are endearing to the Firstborn of Ilúvatar.

"May I look at your swords?" asks his new instructor, a fair-haired elf named Forgam.

Bilbo hands them over.

"This one" — Forgam holds Sting up — "was made in Gondolin, forged by the smiths of the First Age. A fine blade, it will serve you well. This one, however," this time he weighs the Mannish dagger and clucks his tongue. "This could be better."

"It was the best available in Bree," Bilbo murmurs, taking his weapons back. "They don't exactly have a high demand for hobbit appropriate swords there."

A dip of his chin, and the elf gestures to continue training and starts explaining how to disarm an opponent with crossed blades.

Bilbo deems the matter over, but on the next day, he receives a new dagger, lighter and shorter than Sting, with few adornments. It is a streamlined blade shaped like a leaf, perfectly balanced. He will miss it after this cycle ends.

"This will suit you better," Forgam says, nodding at his thanks, and shows him a new manoeuvre. Out of the corner of his eye, Bilbo sees a shade of red exactly matching Nori's hair, but when he finishes the move and turns to check, no one is in that direction.

Days pass. Bilbo doesn't quite avoid the dwarves. He isn't going out of his way to never meet them, but mealtimes are easy when you have an 'in' with the cooks. Bilbo enjoys what simple tasks they let him do, peeling and dicing vegetables to his heart's content. It is as soothing as it is uncomplicated.

It's not to last. Three days later, Thorin tracks him down.

The morning session in the yard ran long and hard but ultimately rewarding. Bilbo's limbs ache with the promise of strong muscles, and he is stretching his back, his thoughts at the hot spring, when Bilbo spots the dwarf leaning on the wall beside his room.

The way Thorin looks him up and down, taking in his rumpled state and sweat-dampened clothes, heats Bilbo's blood quicker than his training.

"You are a hard person to find."

"Hello, Master Oakenshield," Bilbo says, coming to a stop. "Did you need something?"

In contrast to Bilbo, Thorin’s clothes are freshly laundered. His hair and beard are soft and shining. He even smells like softer herbal soaps, to Bilbo's mild surprise — too elven.

"Just checking if the elves did away with you and if we need to avenge your life. I haven't even glimpsed you once since our arrival. I'm glad my worries were unfounded."

"Yes, well." Bilbo flexes his toes. "I've been busy."

Thorin's gaze slides to the weapons hanging off his belt. "I can see that."

They lapse into silence. Despite Thorin's light tone, the conversation and the whole encounter feel so stilted and awkward that Bilbo frowns, thinking about who might have forced Thorin into fetching him. Gandalf? No, he would have come himself. As if on cue, Thorin asks,

"Will you join me in the dining hall, or are you going to be too preoccupied with other tasks to eat?"

"I've been eating."

Thorin waits, and Bilbo huffs.

"All right." When Thorin doesn't make a move, he adds, "Is that all? I'm not going to disappear, and I am in need of a good scrub." Despite his best efforts, Bilbo colours.

A sudden smirk, mischievous and boyish, pulls at Thorin's lips, highlighting the resemblance with his nephews. "I did find the bathing chambers."

Bilbo licks his lips, his heartbeat gaining speed. "I can see that."

"Well." "I shouldn't keep you." They say it at the same time.

"Right." Bilbo nods. "Until later."

"Later," Thorin echoes. "I look forward to it." He leaves as Bilbo enters his room.

"What was that?" Bilbo wonders aloud, staring at the closed door. He shakes himself. "Right. Clean clothes."

At dinner, Thorin saves a seat for him. He is entirely too courteous, asking after Bilbo's preferences. He offers Bilbo plates of cheeses and cold meats and keeps his goblet full even though Bilbo barely partakes the wine, refusing to lose the sharpness of his wits. He doesn't understand what's going on, why Thorin is behaving in such an uncharacteristic manner.

Perhaps, he suspects Bilbo of something and wants to catch him in a lie. Colluding with the elves? It is early enough into the Quest's timeline that such a thought isn't impossible. Bilbo has been absent a lot lately, and with his knowledge of Sindarin... That's it, Bilbo decides. Thorin's simply keeping an eye on me.

He does. As midsummer draws closer, Thorin meets Bilbo every single day—it just so happens—before the evening meal to walk the last few corridors to the dining hall and always asks about Bilbo's day. It's fine, as far as Bilbo is concerned. He doesn't mind the questions. It turns into a routine, and it is then when Thorin breaks it and seeks him out in the afternoon instead.

"Are you going somewhere in particular, Master Baggins?" Thorin says, intercepting Bilbo as he is about to leave the wide boulevard in favour of a narrow side path.

"Into the gardens," Bilbo says and wonders, why is Thorin here? He never, in all of Bilbo's countless lives, sought him out in Rivendell. Thorin's unreadable eyes deny him answers.

"Would you mind it if I join you?"

Ah, so he must suspect that Bilbo's meeting someone. "Not at all."

They stroll together, listening to the sounds of a waterfall. The flowers are blooming, and occasionally, Bilbo stops to enjoy their sweet smells.

"You like it here," Thorin says abruptly.

Bilbo looks up, but of course, Thorin's profile reveals nothing of his thoughts.

"Yes," Bilbo agrees. He has no reason to deny the obvious. "I think it's peaceful. And how do you find it?"

"Not as awful as expected."

"High praise, coming from a dwarf."

Thankfully, Thorin finds his remark humorous and not offensive. His lips twitch into a smile. "You, too, are not how I expected you to be."

"What do you mean?"

Thorin takes a slow breath, his gaze momentarily turned inwards. "When Gandalf said we were to meet a hobbit, I thought it would be someone soft, untempered, untried. But you, you are a warrior. You are like mithril weave — soft-looking, but strong and unyielding under pressure."

"Well. Thank you, I think. I will pretend it was a compliment."

"It was."

They walk some more. Even as Thorin fidgets with a strip of leather and lapses into silence at odd intervals, Bilbo doesn't mind his presence. Perhaps, it is the familiarity. By the time they make the final turn around the gardens, the sun has dipped behind the treetops, so slow is their pace.

As their newly-formed habit, Thorin escorts him to the dining hall. Not all dwarves are present. There's an opening between Bofur and Nori, and Bilbo moves to take that seat, it being a while since he talked to either dwarf, but stops as Thorin touches his arm.

"I was hoping you would sit with me," Thorin says when Bilbo looks at him.

Bewildered at the seemingly unceasing attention, Bilbo murmurs, "All right."

This sets a new pattern for their interactions: the mornings through middays, Bilbo trains, sharpening his skills. The afternoons and evenings he spends with Thorin. If being under scrutiny will dissuade whatever concerns the dwarves have, well, it is no hardship. At least, this time, he's watched openly.

As time marches on, their conversations lose the stiff formality, become effortless, their silences — comforting. Midsummer rolls around.

This night, Thorin is quieter than usual. He glances at the sun every so often, frowning, and hums in acknowledgement of a story he asked Bilbo for but does so in the wrong places. And when the time for the evening meal nears, and Thorin proposes they make another turn around the fountains, Bilbo stops.

"If gardening is boring you," he says with some irony, "lettuce romaine calm and chives another topic."

"What? Oh. No." Thorin frowns harder and rubs his brow. "Forgive me, Master Baggins."

Bilbo sighs. "All will be fine. Lord Elrond will read the runes, and you will have your answers."

"I, yes. I suppose that did weigh on my mind, but that wasn't what kept me distracted." Thorin shifts his weight, inhales. "Master Baggins, I—"

"Thorin, Bilbo, here you are!" Gandalf strides from around a corner, and Thorin closes his mouth with a snap, his expression hardens.

"It's time," the wizard says. "Lord Elrond will see you now."

The reading of the map is tense, and their hurried departure in the predawn light is even more so. They release the ponies at the base of the Misty Mountains — the roads are too narrow to ride. It's for the best. Bilbo would have hated for them to die during the stone giants' battle. He sends Myrtle off with a fond pat and a slice of apple — he started keeping snacks for her lifetimes ago and hasn't noticed it becoming a habit for some cycles. He hopes that elves on patrol will find the ponies soon.

Of course, even a day ahead of schedule, the Company can't miss the thunderstorm, but they avoid the worst of it and shelter in a different cave to wait it out. As luck would have it, Bilbo doesn't need to sneak around: there's a trapdoor in the floor. It opens, and they fall into the underground town. Soon after, Bilbo tumbles off a bridge, cushioning his landing with a goblin. And finds the ring. He doesn't put it on, no matter how tempting. Creeping out of the caves is not too difficult when Gollum is distracted with his meal. He finds the Company and hears Gandalf ask,

"Where's Bilbo?"

"He fell." Thorin swallows, not looking at the wizard. "In Goblin-town, he fell into the depths of the mountain."

Bilbo rounds a tree without delay. "I found my way out."

Thorin's face changes. As if a thundercloud passes, the tight lines of his mouth relax, his eyes are wide and shocked. "I thought you lost," Thorin says, taking a step toward Bilbo.

Bilbo glances over his shoulder. "We must hurry. I heard baying." As if on cue, the wargs start howling.

"Run!" Gandalf shouts, and off they go.

The trees, the burning cones, the fighting. Bilbo would have liked very much to kill Azog right then and there, but going head to head with the massive orc in open battle... He needs a distraction, a chance to slip under Azog’s guard. He does manage to cut the pale orc's ankle, but the wound is too shallow to hamper, more is the pity. An eagle snatches Bilbo up before the orc retaliates.

Beorn's house is a brief reprieve, just for one night. They come to the shapeshifter's house in groups of twos and threes. As always, Beorn finds Bilbo charming. Fleetingly, Bilbo thinks about parting with the Company here. They won't be able to escape Mirkwood in time for Durin's day without him unless Thorin agrees to Thrandruil's terms, but isn't disposing of the ring more important?

Across the table, Thorin puts a serving of potatoes on Bilbo's plate, a slight smile quirking his lips as he replies to Dwalin. The king is healing well, Óin said; the bandages over his chest just peak in the neckline of his tunic. No, I will see it through, Bilbo decides, before embarking on my own mission.

In the morning, Bilbo waits for the Company in Beorn's garden. It's plainer, wilder than beautiful, carefully refined gardens of Rivendell. Somehow, Bilbo likes it better. He wishes the flowers were in bloom, but it's too early for daffodils and too late for pansies.

Bilbo sits down under a cherry tree and closes his eyes, enjoying the sunlight on his face, the sounds of life not stifled with the encroaching darkness. He hears footsteps, a quick inhale.

"Here," Thorin says, offering a thin strip of leather; a pack is slung over his shoulder. "For your hair."

"Hm." Bilbo tugs on a lock and is surprised to find it reaching past his chin. "I suppose it's getting rather long.” Not quite so long as to require a ribbon to keep it out of his face, but close to it. He takes the strip. The brown leather is soft and supple, with runes and vines etched in its length.

"May I braid it?" Thorin asks hesitantly.

"If you want."

His pack joins Bilbo's at their feet, and Thorin sits behind him. Gentle fingers slide through Bilbo’s hair, and in no time at all, twin braids run from his temples to just behind his ears, joining in the middle.

"Thank you," Bilbo says, half-turning, and catches Thorin's burning gaze. He licks his lips.

A fat bumblebee cuts its path between them. Bilbo leans back. He hasn't realised he moved forward.

Loud voices announce Bofur and Bombur's arrival. The charged tension that has been building up between them dissipates just as the rest of the Company spills out of the house. All dwarves carry massive packs — Beorn sends them off with more provisions than they took from Rivendell.

The dwarves side-eye Bilbo’s hairstyle, trade glances with Thorin. There are ill-hidden smirks and some nudges that leave Bilbo somewhat wrong-footed. What's all this about? No matter. Bilbo doesn't dwell on it for long. The shadow of Mirkwood is looming.

Mirkwood and its depressing darkness, the broken roads and the constant gloom, the promise of an enemy behind each twisted tree and every scraggly bush.

They huddle close for the nights, too unsettled for songs or stories.

Bilbo’s tossing and turning in his bedroll, unable to fall asleep. A feeling has taken root in his heart, fragile and tender like the first shoot of a snowdrop nestled beneath the melting crust. He can’t decide if he should squash it. It’s pointless anyway; he should have given up on happiness by now. Why hasn’t he? He knows better. Shivering, Bilbo sighs. The blasted forest does nothing to improve his mood.

"Cold?" Thorin murmurs, rising on his elbow on the bedroll next to Bilbo’s. "Come here." He holds his arm up in invitation, and Bilbo doesn't hesitate. His head pillowed on Thorin's shoulder, and with the weight of Thorin's arm across his back, he thinks, This is nice. And probably exceeds the boundaries of friendship.

They sleep beside each other every night until the day an elven patrol comes upon them just as the giant spiders start attacking, and finally, Bilbo can't avoid the ring any longer. He puts it on and plummets into icy bleakness.

In the dungeons of Mirkwood, Thorin presses to the bars at first sight of Bilbo. He reaches out and touches Bilbo's cheek.

"I feared I lost you." His voice is barely a whisper. "When they rounded us up, and you weren't there." He stops, his thumb caressing Bilbo's skin, and swallows. "I thought the worst."

Bilbo takes hold of Thorin's wrist.

"I hid. I have a way to stay unnoticed."

"Good. I'm glad you were safe." They are so close, they breathe each other's air, and Thorin's gaze falls on his lips.

The urge to kiss the dwarf is overwhelming. If not the bars, he would have done it. Alas, or maybe, luckily, the bars are in the way. The sound of light footsteps interrupts the moment.

"Hide," Thorin whispers, and Bilbo does, their fingers catching as he steps back, reluctant to let go.

He whiles away the days until the elven feast in indecisive pondering of Thorin's situation. The shoulds and shouldn't are driving him to losing appetite and sleep.

"Don't be a fool. Don't get attached; it will not last," Bilbo mutters, pacing the length of a rarely used storage room, but it's too late for that, and really, why not? He could be happy if only for the moment. He'd been through much, so doesn't he deserve it? But then when it starts over... And on and on it goes, his thoughts are running in a circle.

He visits the Company and passes messages to Thorin, and—Bilbo can't help himself—can't stay away, he's gotten used to their walks in Rivendell, and really, he should have noticed earlier that their walks weren't information gathering. What kind of moron is he to miss that he was being courted? In hindsight, that was rather obvious.

"Thorin," he says, just to confirm, but can't get the words past his dry lips.

"What's wrong?" Instantly alert, Thorin takes hold of Bilbo's hands. He does it often.

"It's nothing, never mind. Just being silly." Bilbo shakes his head. He smiles. “I know a way out."

Notes:

I finally gave in and cut the chapter in half. The second part should be up within a week. Thank you for the comments! Even if I don't reply right away, I greatly appreciate it! ❤️

Chapter 12

Notes:

"Ha! Bet you didn't expect me to update so fast!" says Afrokot, talking to her screen like a crazy person. Her demented grin has started worrying her family.

 

For the full experience, play I See Fire about halfway through the chapter.

Chapter Text

The Company reaches Lake-town sailing on a barge. Thankfully, through Bilbo's foresight and effort, nobody is injured this time. Again, they are led to the Master. Dwalin speaks up in their defence, announcing Thorin's name. Whispers of a prophecy spread like a wildfire, but Bard's warnings fall on deaf ears. Remembering the dragon, the heat of his breath, the stench of burning meat, Bilbo can't look at the bargeman. If the dragon comes to Lake-town, it will ignite like kindling.

The celebration in the tavern is rich in promises and toasts to shared wealth and cooperation, and though tired, Bilbo cannot sleep. Unease gnaws at his stomach. He dozes for a few short hours when the merriment winds down and dreams of mountains of scalding gold, cascading down, burning, burying him underneath its weight. He wakes up with a gasp, ill-rested.

As before, the townsfolk send them off with well-wishes. At the base of the mountain, the Company searches for the stairs, which Bilbo finds once more. He endures the arduous climb without complaint. His fast heartbeat he can write off as the exertion. The stairs end, the daylight wanes and disappears. They search in vain for the keyhole, but, of course, the sunlight doesn't show it.

"Wait," Bilbo says as the dwarves give up and begin descending. "The last light of Durin's day. I think it is a riddle. The day will end at midnight. Just wait for the moon to rise."

The moonlight shines. The keyhole is revealed.

"Quickly!” Balin says. “Before it disappears."

And under the expectant gazes of the Company, Thorin Oakenshield, the rightful King Under the Mountain, unlocks the door to his kingdom. Reluctantly, the door slides open.

Thorin's breath shudders out of his chest in a great exhale. He looks at him with such warmth in his eye, it steals Bilbo's own breath away.

"Thank you, Bilbo."

Bilbo nods. "This is it." He flexes his fingers. "My part of the Quest. What—" He clears his throat, his heart beats too fast now, it almost hurts "—what should I look for?"

"You don't have to. You've done so much for us. Without you, we'd never make it here. We would still be rotting away in that accursed dungeons. If the dragon is alive—" Thorin says, but Bilbo interrupts him.

"I choose to see this through." And Thorin nods, accepting.

"Look for the most wondrous gem you've ever seen. It shines like starlight, like ten thousand sparks of white radiance, shot with glints of a rainbow."

"Right. Right. Wondrous starlight and rainbows. Got it."

Thorin hugs him, pressing Bilbo to his chest. Reluctant to let go, he whispers something in Khuzdul. Perhaps, it is a prayer. They part. And Bilbo walks into the darkness. His every step, he feels as if his feet have turned into logs, too heavy and unyielding.

Pull yourself together, he thinks, it's just a dragon. You've been through so much worse. But fears aren't rational. No matter how many times he died or how horrible his deaths, there is just something primal, an instinct wired into the marrow of his bones that scream to turn away and hide, to not get closer. He doesn't think. Instead, he counts footsteps. On step one hundred fifteen, Bilbo reaches the treasury.

Do not wake up the dragon. Just find the Arkenstone and bring it to the dwarves. Should be easy.

There's only one problem: there are too many blasted rocks on square footage. The piles of gold and riches stretch wider than the Great Smials of Tuckborough. It will take ages to sift through, and anyway, how will he know the Arkenstone from all the other gems? He picks the two closest to him. They look the same — just shiny rocks — and Bilbo puts them down.

"Impossible," he mutters but starts searching, careful not to disturb the coins. And still, Smaug awakes and rises in an avalanche of gold. Bilbo's skin turns clammy; his heart stutters in his chest as he forgets to breathe and freezes. The dragon speaks.

"Come out, thief. I know you are here. I smell the dwarves on you. Did Thorin Oakenshield send you for his precious jewel? Of course, he did, do not deny it. I'm almost tempted to let you have it. Let you watch it take his mind as it has done to his grandfather, let greed consume him, hollow him out." The dragon sighs. It sounds wistful. "Ah, but I do not stand for thievery."

As Bilbo doesn't want to be roasted for the second time, he talks and flatters and prevaricates, but in the end, he doesn't have a choice but use the ring. The dragon fire hits the gold beside him, heating it in an instant. Pain scalds his feet. They start to blister, but Bilbo runs, and stumbles in his rush, and falls.

A rock about the size of his two fists lies right before him. It shines with an inner light. This must be it, the Arkenstone, Bilbo decide. It looks all right, but not enchanting or mesmerising, or even all that pretty. He doesn't understand what's all the fuss about, but it is big. Maybe its value is in its size? He stuffs it in his pocket and keeps crawling away from the dragon, whose every step feels like the earth is trembling.

The dwarves rush inside to his rescue, distracting Smaug, and then they run in different directions.

Thorin reaches Bilbo, grabs his shoulders in a cruel grip, and looks him up and down, his hair wild and gaze too hard and glassy. "Did you find it?"

"What?" Bilbo asks, uncomprehending.

"The Arkenstone, did you find it?" Thorin demands. Dread creeps over Bilbo, becoming all he feels.

"We have a bigger problem at the moment, Thorin. There's a dragon after us." He pulls away and turns to leave, but Thorin's sword is in the way, the point pricking Bilbo's coat.

"Did you find the Arkenstone, burglar?"

He doesn’t recognise his voice. It can’t belong to Thorin.

Smaug's words ring in his head, crooning of madness in the line of Durin. Bilbo's tongue sticks to the roof of his mouth. With shaking hands, he tries to push the blade aside, but Thorin keeps it steady. "Thorin."

The dragon interrupts their stand-off. At least, he's good for something.

But then there is no time for thoughts. Instead, there's a dash across the mountain as Smaug catches a column with his tail, and it collapses. They split, but soon enough, Bilbo reunites with the whole Company. The room is a dead end. It is a tomb. The passage forward had collapsed, and those who sought a way out died here of starvation — dwarrowdams, faunts, infants. The mummified, desiccated corpses stare at him with empty eye sockets, scream silent screams with gaping mouths. They lie together under a thick blanket of cobwebs and dust. Bilbo swallows, hard and painful, but Thorin only spares them a glance, he is so focused on planning. And something in Bilbo's chest twinges, far stronger than the stitch in his side.

The plan is mad: the dwarves want to lure Smaug into the great forge and drown him in gold.

"It won't work," Bilbo says, shaking his head. "He's a dragon. No heat can harm him, and the gold itself? If anything, it will just make his hide thicker.”

"You've a better idea?" Dwalin asks. "We are all ears."

But he doesn't.

"We have to try." Thorin's eyes are desperate and wilder by the minute. "I refuse to die cowering and clawing at my throat for air in my last moments."

And so the plan gains traction. The execution is flawless. A golden Thrór meets Smaug and collapses in a cascade of liquid gold that turns the dragon into a shiny statue, just for a moment. Then Smaug shakes himself, and gold slides off his hide in golden clouds.

It fails, as Bilbo has predicted. Instead, it makes the dragon angry. And even worse, the dwarves slip a careless remark between their taunts, and not a moment later, Smaug takes off for Lake-town, departing with a stream of fire.

“And the lake will shine and burn ," Bilbo murmurs. "What have we done." What a disaster.

Bilbo stands up, dusts off his pants, comes out from behind a column. He isn't sure what to do. Should they run to Lake-town and try to fight the dragon there? They'll never make it in time to be of any use and, likely, will only find a ruin.

"The worm will return," says Thorin. He stares through the pieces of the broken gate left in the dragon's wake. Gusts of flames light up the night sky farther and farther away. "We must prepare."

Which means they find the armoury and don proper armour as everyone still has what weapons they started out with. For Bilbo, it means a gifted mithril shirt. His Thorin makes a brief come back, but all too soon, he disappears, and in his place is an uncaring stranger wearing beloved face insists they watch for Smaug’s return. They see him fall into the lake. The dragon does not rise.

"He is dead. Smaug is dead," Bilbo whispers, staring at the only bright spot left — the burning island floating in the black canvas of merged lake and sky. Blood rushes in his ears, deafening him to the outside world. The prophecy came true. He turns around.

The dwarves are laughing, relief and happiness written across their faces, all but Thorin’s. In the moonlight, Thorin is whiter than snow. His lips are bloodless, and his words become the first that Bilbo hears.

"Enemies will come for us. For Erebor's treasures. We must prepare." His skin glistens with cold sweat; the glinting of his eyes makes Bilbo shiver. "We must prepare!"

Till morning light, they fortify the gates, and in the morning, Thorin demands the Arkenstone be found.

A kind of madness Bilbo hasn't seen before overtakes the Company. Without rest or breaks for meals, they go through the treasury while Thorin makes grand declarations about his birthright. They put jewellery on, and Nori is the most ridiculous of all the dwarves. He wears a white gold tiara and loops large golden earrings to hang off on his ears and dons three necklaces, each with a heavy chain, his pockets overflowing with gems.

What little time Thorin does not spend pacing over the mountains of gold, he spends in the throne room. He sits on his grandfather's throne, alone and brooding. His cheeks have hollowed, and heavy shadows lie under his eyes.

"Have you found the Arkenstone?" he asks as soon as Bilbo comes into view.

Bilbo shakes his head and offers him a bowl. "I've made you soup."

The bowl clatters on the floor, spilling thin broth, leeks and carrots and a handful of precious grains over the dusty stone. The back of Bilbo's hand is smarting where Thorin struck him. He stares at the dwarf without recognition.

Thorin stands up. A sorry piece of onion gets squashed under his boot. He doesn't notice. This feels a little, Bilbo thinks, like being gutted.

"Until the Arkenstone is in its rightful place, there's no time for any other matters or concerns."

Bilbo sighs. "Just, don't you think starving yourself is counterproductive?"

His words are met with silence and a heavy stare. Bilbo retreats. Of course, he knows their search won't yield results. He contemplates giving the damned rock to Thorin, pretending that he's just found it, but if the mere idea of it has driven Thorin so far into insanity, what will it do to him in his possession? Bilbo fears.

The morning of the fifth day after Smaug's death, a delegation from Lake-town comes a-knocking. The Company greets them from the battlement above the blocked gate.

"Hail and merry-meet, king under the mountain," Bard says, bowing. "I'm glad to see you all alive! Lake-town didn't fare well under the dragon’s wrath, however. We've come to seek aid you so generously promised to provide. We have a lot of mouths going hungry and not at all the means to feed them. Will you honour our agreement, Thorin-King Under the Mountain?”

The Men who came with him all look exhausted, some sporting bandages or singed hair. They make a sorry sight, but Thorin bristles and refuses, scorning the idea of an alliance. An angry scowl on his face, he orders a retreat into the mountain and will not hear a word in contradiction. With threats of war, the Men return to settle in the ruins of Dale.

In mere days, the food is running out. No one has come prepared for a siege, but nobody, least of all Thorin, listens to reason.

"The weather is getting colder!” Bilbo says later as Thorin once again sits on his throne. “Think of the children of Lake-town. How will they survive?"

"They shouldn't have come." Thorin's voice is even, and his gaze is absent. Bilbo wonders what sights he sees on the far wall.

"They are just thieves, vultures who came to scavenge expecting our corpses. But no!" the king exclaims, coming to life and focusing on Bilbo with an intensity of a box of Gandalf's fireworks that his Took cousins once set aflame. "We are of sterner stuff! They don't deserve a single coin! We have reclaimed our kingdom; now we will defend it! I sent word to Dáin. He will come soon and with an army."

"But Thorin, what about lost crafts and a permanent home?" Bilbo murmurs. "You used to say that was the most important reason for the Quest."

"It is important. With enough gold, my people will never go hungry again." Momentarily, Thorin's features soften.

"And what about people of Lake-town?" Bilbo tries.

Like a book snapped shut, Thorin's expression closes off. "They aren't my concern."

And everything that Bilbo says after falls to deaf ears.

Days go by. The dwarves work in shifts. Most go through the treasury while one or two are watching for external threats. Thorin's patience is running out. He snaps at everyone, demanding Arkenstone, and soon resorts to threats.

"If anyone should find it and withhold it from me," Thorin says, his voice deceptively calm, "I should be avenged."

He storms off, disappearing between the mountains of gold. The Arkenstone has never been so heavy in Bilbo's pocket.

Balin, the sanest of the lot and least affected, shakes his head and sighs. “Mahal preserve us, Thrór's curse befell him."

"Is there a cure?"

"None that I know of."

Bilbo bites his lips. "What if we find the Arkenstone?" he asks with trepidation.

And Balin sighs again, his shoulders slumping. "I fear it will only worsen."

Just then, Bofur runs by and shouts. "Elves approach!"

The dwarves scramble to the battlement above the gate and watch the Elvenking arrive in all his elven glory on a magnificent elk and with an entourage clad in matching silver armour and black cloaks that stream behind them. They cut an impressive picture. In comparison, the Men who accompany them look even more bedraggle. If only they'd come in friendship.

Of course, Thrandruil's arrival makes the situation worse. The Elvenking's demanding the return of elven treasures is like pouring oil on an open flame.

"Prepare for war," declares Thorin in retaliation.

Bilbo spots Gandalf in the crowd gathered before the gate, but the wizard's presence goes largely unnoticed.

That night, Bilbo hangs a rope off the battlement and climbs down. He sneaks across the plain and into Dale and finds the largest tent around. Inside, the Elvenking holds court.

"I will speak with Bard and Gandalf only," Bilbo says right after greetings.

"To evade my guards" — Thranduil studies him with a dangerous glint in his quicksilver eyes — "you must have considerable skill. I wonder was it you who let the dwarves out of my dungeons?"

Gandalf steps between them. "You will not touch my hobbit."

Thranduil inclines his head. "Then you should keep a better track of him, lest he becomes a pest.”

Bilbo clears his throat. "I'm here to negotiate a truce with people of Lake-town only."

"Speak, halfling.” Bard regards him calmly. “What does your treacherous king have to offer in reparation for the ills his actions brought?"

Craning his neck to look the Man in the eyes, Bilbo steels his spine. "I'm here as myself, not as a mouthpiece of the dwarves. As per our contract with the Company, I am entitled to a share of the wealth. I took a precious jewel that Thorin values above all else, the Arkenstone, as payment. Give it to Thorin in exchange for gold with an agreement to cease all hostile actions, and no war should ever be between you. Your people have suffered greatly, but so did his. If I can, I will help to broker peace.”

Bard frowns, considering his offer. "Pretty words, but what does the King Under the Mountain has to say? Will he agree to it?"

His nails biting into his palms, Bilbo replies, "What I decide to do with my reward is my own business." He slams the Arkenstone onto the table. "Do you agree?"

Bard spares the jewel a glance, no more. "Very well. We will try your way."

"Thorin is ill. There's something wrong with the lot of them, none of the dwarves are themselves, but he seems the most affected," Bilbo says, retreating to the shadows.

"You should stay here, Bilbo." Gandalf's worry exudes off him in waves.

"I, I have to go. They are my friends. I can't just leave them."

The wizard doesn't stop him, which, later, Bilbo will regret. Now, however, he is hurriedly pulling himself up the rope. His arms are burning by the time he makes it to the top. His palms are red and rubbed raw. Quietly, he tiptoes inside and curls up on his bedroll, his back to unforgiving stone. He is alone. The dwarves are either in the treasury or sleeping in the watchtower. And Bilbo? Bilbo longs for Thorin. His Thorin, not the imposter sitting on the throne.

The morning comes, and Bard with it, but the negotiations do not go as expected.

"You—you great betrayer! You worthless worm, a snake! I should have known!" Thorin spits insult and accusations, but worse than that, he grabs Bilbo's shoulder, wrenching his arm with his strength, and slams Bilbo against a wall. Dazed, Bilbo scrambles to get his feet under him as Thorin drags him to the battlement and in one move hurls him over it, and only Thorin’s hands around his neck prevent him from plummeting down. His bruised heart shatters.

The Company does nothing to interfere. Oh, they mutter and murmur, and Fíli even shouts, "Uncle, no!” and something in Khuzdul, but not a single one of them stops Thorin. He is their king. Just or not, his word is the law.

Dangling over a long drop, Bilbo claws at the hands slowly strangling the life out of him. Distantly, he hears Gandalf's voice, but the words are indistinct, meaningless. The madness in Thorin's bloodshot eyes is the last thing Bilbo sees as his vision darkens and fades.

Betrayed, angry, hurt, and heartbroken, he cries bitterly into his knees.

When Gandalf comes, he declines the offer of sharing in an adventure. In fact, in the most unhobbitish way possible, Bilbo tells the wizard to shove his offer up his arse and marches inside his smial with the image of Gandalf sputtering in indignation firmly committed to memory.

Come evening, Dwalin knocks on his door anyway. Sighing, Bilbo steps aside lest the dwarf tramples him in the quest for promised food and resigns himself for yet another raucous dinner with unwelcome company.

And later, he aims a kick at Gandalf's shins, but the wizard sidesteps, moving deceptively quickly for his age, and Bilbo loses his balance. His pride hurts worse than his tailbone. Perhaps, it is unfair to blame Gandalf. It's not his fault that Thorin went insane and killed Bilbo. Bilbo doesn't care. It all — the ring, the cycles, endless deaths, his inability to die once and for all — it all began with the wizard and his adventures.

"Come now, my dear hobbit," the old goat says, extending a hand, "is it any way to greet your guest?" His eyes are twinkling with good humour.

Ignoring the wizard, Bilbo gets to his feet on his own. He brushes off his breeches the dirt and dust that heavy boots have trailed into his formerly spotless hallway and glares at the Maia. "I wasn't aware I invited any guests at all."

An awkward silence following his statement doesn't last long as the dwarves unpile themselves from his welcome mat and turn to question Gandalf. Bilbo doesn't care. He marches into the kitchen and fixes himself a cup of tea, then goes outside and smokes his pipe. The Company can find their own dinner; they did before, and they will do again. He does not care.

When Thorin shows up on his doorstep and bestows Bilbo with unimpressed, judging looks and unmerited condescension— The heart he thought was wrenched out of his chest and shredded with a grater gives a painful lurch. And Bilbo just can't take it anymore.

"He looks more like a grocer than a burglar," Thorin says. The dwarves laugh.

Oh, yes, a grand joke. Everything before him tints red, and Bilbo punches that long, majestic nose. Thorin's head snaps back. Bilbo's vision whites out as pain bursts into life in every broken bone of Bilbo's knuckles — he forgot to take the density of dwarven bones into account. He jumps on one foot, clutching his arm to his chest, while every damn of the thirteen dwarves plus one irate wizard invading his home erupts into shouting.

Ignoring their demands for an explanation and calls for a justification and whatever else they want from him, Bilbo bolts into his bedroom and locks himself inside, refusing all and any interactions. After a while, even Gandalf tires of admonishing the door and leaves him with a parting, "I am disappointed in your behaviour."

Like you have a foot to stand on, you meddlesome old bastard, Bilbo thinks with resentment. If it wasn't for you and your cursed scheming, I wouldn't be caught in this mess.

It is, perhaps, undeserved. Bilbo might even concede that blaming Gandalf isn't fair, but there's nothing fair about this situation. Besides, Bilbo ceased to be reasonable the moment Thorin let him go. He doesn't feel like reason is warranted any longer. He thinks he's due for at least a token reparations.

Sitting on his bed with his back against the headboard, he listens to the racket of his 'guests' and fumes. Bilbo seethes. His hand hurts like murder, keeping him awake. He should see a healer, but that would mean going past the dwarves and—

It is the middle of the night. The smial is dark and silent. Bilbo lights a candle and finally surrenders and searches for his medical supplies.

There's a tincture he took when he broke his toe uncountable years past. Bilbo takes it. Its bitter taste coats his throat and numbs his tongue. His dreams are strange, distorted things, and when he wakes, it is the start of a new cycle.

He skips this summer, needing a reprieve. He goes camping in Bindbole Wood. He fishes on the Water. It's nice and peaceful, and when the summer ends and the Quest for Erebor looms ever closer, Bilbo thinks he's all right to try again. It's as the dragon said, a sickness, and Bilbo knew the dwarves were ill, and Thorin most of all. But as the time approaches, his nerves are strung tight.

Another summer, evening, feast for dwarves. He fumbles with the dishes, spills the salt. His answers are distracted and disjointed. The dwarves leave him be, content to have the food and drink aplenty.

Then Thorin comes. The knocking on the door falls into a sudden lull like thunder.

"He's here!" Gandalf says.

The Company stands up, the chairs scraping over the polished floor in their hurry. Bilbo drops a skillet.

"Blast it!" he curses, jumping backwards. His toes are splattered with cooking oil, but that's the most he suffers. Throwing a rag at the spillage, he mops it up and is the last to greet the dwarven king.

Stopping in the doorway, Bilbo looks at his... Who? He doesn't know how to define him. Friend? Murderer? Beloved? All would fit, but that's not a comprehensive list of Thorin's titles. A lump blocks Bilbo's throat that he can't swallow.

"But where's Bilbo?" Gandalf asks, searching the hall. "Ah. Come, dear hobbit, let me introduce you to the leader of the Company."

The dwarves crowding the way between them part and turn around, and Bilbo finds himself a target of fourteen pairs of eyes.

"I." He swallows. "Hello. Welcome." He meets with Thorin's gaze and knows Thorin sees a stranger. "Please, come inside. The supper’s on the table.” He can't. It's worse than lack of recognition. He won't. "Excuse me, I need to—" Pivoting on his heels, Bilbo hurries into the kitchen.

"What just happened?" he hears Thorin ask, and Gandalf's thoughtful, "I'm not sure," before the door cuts off whatever else is said.

He lets the door support his weight and ground him in the moment. Bilbo bends forward, hands on his knees, and forces his lungs to expand and fill with air.

I can't, I can't, I can't, tolls in his head, and Bilbo bites his knuckles. "Pull yourself together, you silly old thing," he mutters. "Nothing will resolve itself without you. Can't put it off forever."

To cut his losses, climb through the kitchen window and run off into the night is oh, so tempting. The buzz of conversation seeps through the gaps and cracks. The night is quiet otherwise, Bagshot Row is empty.

"I faced down a dragon. Twice. I can do it."

With that, he slips into the room and hovers at the edge, behind the wizard. The explanations go as they always do, with shouting and speeches, and when the moment comes for Bilbo to step in, he does come forward.

"A burglar," Gandalf says, and Bilbo murmurs, "I will do it."

Before long, Balin brandishes the contract.

"It's just the usual — summary of out-of-pocket expenses, time required, remuneration, the funeral arrangements, and so forth."

Bilbo unfurls the scroll, and Bofur comments, "There's a section on the causes of death."

"Yes, yes. Lacerations, evisceration, incineration," Bilbo quotes aloud. "That one's the most unpleasant death by far. Beats even falling from great heights," he mutters, picking up the quill and scribbling his signature at the bottom. He misses the looks sent his way and the frowns.

"All right," he says, straightening and returning the contract to Balin. He never looks at Thorin, only in his general direction. "Good night. I'll see you in the morning."

On silent feet, he hurries away and outside through a side door. It's not a back door because of its location.

It's late, he realises. The moon is high and very round, like a wheel of cheese. The Gamgees are already asleep — no lights are in their smial.

Bilbo's puffing on his pipe when he hears singing. Of course, he knows the lyrics. He blinks, his eyes are stinging, but he keeps them dry. Enough crying.

Later, there’s the sound of his front door opening and closing, and heavy footfalls, and a heavier exhale.

"Would you mind my company, Master Baggins?" Thorin asks. Bilbo's heart clenches.

"No, of course, not." He forces his fingers to relax before he breaks the pipe and gestures at the space beside him. The bench dips down under Thorin's weight. Bilbo stares resolutely ahead.

"I understand that you don't know us, and that may be the reason why you are so uncomfortable in our presence." For once, his voice is low and even, not laded with censure and contempt that Bilbo half-expected given his usual performance.

"But, if you are to go on this Quest, I need to know that you will be able to work with us," Thorin continues. "Where we are going, we will need to rely on each other, and I can't have one member of the Company shying away from the rest. Are you..." he pauses. Out of the corner of his eye, Bilbo sees Thorin tilt his head to study his profile.

"Do we scare you? I can assure you, whatever rumours you might have heard, they aren't true. We aren't greedy mongrels Men like to paint us as.”

"No, that's not—No! I'm not—" Bilbo shakes his head. His short curls fly over his forehead, glinting like liquid gold in the candlelight spilling from the windows behind them. "What nonsense!" Indignantly, Bilbo straightens up and looks at Thorin with fire in his eyes. "I'm not afraid of you."

And at this moment, Thorin is mesmerised.

"It's not fear I feel. I—It's complicated." Bilbo debates explaining, but how is he to convey 'You went insane and killed me, but I still love you' without coming across as bloody barking? "I will get over it. No need to worry."

A moment passes, then another. Bilbo's foot starts tapping. Thorin takes out his pipe, and wordlessly, Bilbo offers him his pipe-weed pouch and stands up.

"Good night," he says to Thorin's shoulder.

He settles down in his bed. His pillow is too flat. He fluffs it. Now it's too puffy. The blanket makes him hot. Without it, it’s chilly. The night is over all too soon, and Bilbo slept, perhaps, an hour.

The Quest starts well. All are alive in Rivendell. Though Bilbo can't quite look at Thorin still, he makes it work — there are Bofur and Dori to talk with if Bilbo wants company. Not that he does. They did betray him, too, as he remembers. And anyway, what reason would he have to build friendships with the dwarves? None, that's what. He is their burglar, nothing more. He keeps alone and to himself and minds his own business. And if he keeps forgetting his resolution and in quiet moments finds himself gazing at Thorin with painfully conflicted heart? What of it? He does so with discretion.

All are alive at Beorn's. And here, Bilbo leaves them.

Chapter 13

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

The first time Bilbo travels on his own, he goes as far as Rohan. With Beorn's generously provided supplies, his pack is full, and since the shapeshifter dealt with the orcs chasing the Company, there's no immediate danger on the roads. Besides, he isn't helpless, either.

He doesn't say goodbye. He leaves at dawn a day before the Company is set to go to Mirkwood. It's easier than he imagined: no floorboard creaks, no one snaps awake and hurries to stop him.

The way on foot is slower than it would be if Bilbo had a pony, but he is unwilling to risk asking Beorn for one. Soon, Bilbo reaches Anduin and walks along the shore. He isn't fast. He knows if the Company wanted to catch up to him, they would have done so. They don't, and Bilbo squashes budding disappointment and all regrets. It's for the better.

He takes his time, keeping his pace unhurried, but walks from dawn till dusk and moves through the shallow water, stopping only for the nights. The wall of trees stays a constant on the horizon to his left. He fishes in the evenings, gathers frostbitten berries from sparse bushes, and sleeps under a starlit sky. It almost feels like a ramble but for the loneliness and the persistent unease that clings to him like tree sap to needles. Weeks pass without Bilbo meeting another soul. The world has never felt so empty.

The season grows colder, harsher, but Bilbo doesn't dare start a fire in after dark, not with the evil-occupied Dol Guldur so damn close. Instead, Bilbo trudges determinedly ahead under the moonlight when the sky is clear or hides under a bush and hugs his pack when it is not and stays awake despite exhaustion. He dozes at middays when the sun is strongest. As his pack lightens, Bilbo grows thinner; his clothes hang looser on his frame.

He travels south. More and more often, wargs howl in the distant forest, and on those nights, Bilbo rests one hand on the pocket housing the ring and the other on Sting’s hilt. And more and more, he hears whispers masquerading as his voice. You were nothing to him. He killed you once. He will do it again and again. And why shouldn’t he? What are you? Unlovable. Pitiful. Useless. Worthless. You will never succeed. Bilbo shuts them out.

Eventually, with his dwindling supplies threatening to run out, Bilbo is forced to decide: venture to a settlement or risk foraging in a forest. There should be several of both along the way, as he recalls.

Another week passes without any change in the scenery before Bilbo realises he must have misremembered the map, or perhaps, the one he thought about belonged to another age, not that the reason matters. He walks and walks, but all there are to see are open plains, and even those soon turn barren on his left. The Brown Lands are nothing but a dusty desert.

Still, it worries Bilbo, this emptiness. He crosses Anduin over a shoal in the North Undeep, thoroughly sick of fish and with barely a handful of nuts left in his pack. The grassy plains on this side of the river aren't any different. The winter season started and left nothing to harvest. He'll have to find a village soon, he decides, but Bilbo is in Rohan. These lands are populated scarcely.

He walks and walks and sleeps in fitful bouts in open fields without any shelter. It is too vast and too deserted, and too foreign, and too much. Bilbo’s nerves are strung out. He twitches at every noise, be it a rustling of the grass or a vole scurrying into its burrow.

“I am the only person left in Middle-earth, doomed to walk for all eternity and never reach a destination,” he says aloud just to hear someone’s voice.

One day, a thunderous sound cuts into a jumble of images his mind decided to torment him with. Bilbo wakes up and spots a cloud of dust in the distance. It is fast approaching. His every instinct screams at him to hide, and he looks around, but of course, finds nowhere to go. His heartbeat picks up speed to rival the galloping horses as he panics. The ring slips on his finger like it waited for Bilbo to give in. It did.

He runs, but the horses outpace him. It is a herd without riders, and even were there people, they wouldn’t—couldn’t—see him. In desperation, Bilbo crouches and throws his arms up to protect his head. It doesn't help him. As hooves stamp on his invisible form, Bilbo cries out in pain. It's over soon enough.

Back in his smial, Bilbo groans into his palms. "That was so stupid. What was I even thinking?" And that’s the heart of the matter — he wasn’t.

The Quest starts over and repeats. Bilbo departs the Company at Beorn's. His pack is heavier, his rationing tighter. He braves the Brown Lands, following the river for fear of not finding any water. The trek through the hills of Emyn Muil is harsher still — brambles and thorny bushes catch his clothes and scratch his skin, dried creepers prickle his feet. The hills are steep, the climb is hard and slow. But what comes next is worse a hundredfold: the Dead Marshes.

An ever-changing mist unfolds over the endless pools and mires. At nights, candle flames float over the dark water, luring Bilbo like fairy lights. The flames are dancing, their outlines insubstantial and smudged, and Bilbo looks at them too long.

He watches merry dancing flames, and in a trance, he follows. One squelching step, then two, and three, and he is at the edge of boggy ground. His feet are wet and chilled, turning numb.

The candle flame is hovering above an ethereal face, which rises to the surface from the depths. It casts its features in a greenish tint, and mesmerised, Bilbo can't turn away. He studies the softly arching eyebrows, the long, thin nose, and the clouded, opaque eyes that seem to stare back the longer Bilbo watches. They look into his soul. Bilbo leans closer and closer still ... A quiet splash. The water fills his nose, his lungs—

"Not good," he says and sighs. The sound of his own voice is startling. He grew unused to hearing anything but whispers of the ring.

"This isn't working." He needs someone with him to snap him out of the trance, for company, and to keep him sane. He rubs his face. "All right, the dragon first, then deal with the ring, I get it."

The wizard comes, then the dwarves in the evening. And Thorin, who he soundly ignores — as much as he can ever do while still maintaining some semblance of politeness, at any rate. The Quest commences.

At the Trollshaws, Bilbo poisons the trolls. He throws Belladonna roots into their cauldron. Come morning, he leads the Company to the troll hoard. The trolls were turned into stone as they were — lying on the ground, curled around their stomachs. And Bilbo not quite smiles, but satisfaction curls in him like a well-fed cat. The dwarves seem disturbed for some reason.

In Rivendell, he inquiries after acquiring a bow to replace the one he got in Bree and practices archery.

"I'll pay for it, of course," he says, and Forgam, who is again his training partner, procures a bow tailored to Bilbo’s size.

"It is a gift, my friend,” says the taciturn elf, refusing payment and leaving Bilbo baffled when he realises Forgam has meant that word. Friend. He thinks about it and, with a warmth spreading through his chest, realises that they have, indeed, become friends while Bilbo wasn't looking.

Their friendship formed over silent bouts in the sparring ring only Bilbo can remember and carried over into this life, facilitated by his familiarity. It strengthened while they were fletching arrows in the mornings and loosening them into targets side by side in amiable competitions at middays and often well into the evenings. It’s a relationship he plans on keeping.

For a far less explicable reason, Thorin asks him for a walk around the gardens. Bilbo declines.

"So," Bofur says, finding Bilbo the day after in a gazebo overlooking the waterfalls. He lands on Bilbo’s bench and continues, “Our king is broodier than normal. Your doing?"

“Whatever do you mean?" Bilbo murmurs, frowning.

Bofur gives him a funny look. "Pardon my saying, but you aren't dense. Quite the opposite of that is my impression."

And Bilbo sighs. “Thorin did invite me for a walk, but to accept it would be unwise.” Not now. Maybe never. “I don’t want to give him the wrong impression. My last relationship ended... poorly." To put it mildly. "I'm not looking for another. I'm not sure if I ever will."

Bofur just nods. "Understandable. He will get over it, don't worry."

So Bilbo puts the matter out of his mind. Thorin does not outright ignore him, but neither does he seek his attention. Bilbo tells himself that he is glad. He isn't.

Their journey goes on, as usual: the Goblin Town, orcs and wargs, the flight on eagles, and Thorin's gratitude. He does not hug Bilbo, not this time. Bilbo pretends he neither misses nor wants it. Awkward and stoic as Thorin is, the dwarf's words are nonetheless heartfelt, though, in this life, they aren't even friends. It's for the better.

Mirkwood, and he avoids the dwarves. Bilbo gets them out, arranges things with Bard. The meeting with the Master of Lake-town is an inevitable and unpleasant matter. And Erebor. The dragon. It isn't any easier this time — the dragon is enormous, as ever, his voice — a sly and smug cadence. The memory of flames causes Bilbo's hands to tremble long before he comes into the treasury, and when Smaug spits gusts of flames, he almost doesn't move away in time. His arm gets singed. The fire is so hot, it sears clothes to his skin. He doesn't feel the pain until much later.

He finds the Arkenstone and gives the gem to Thorin right away. It doesn't matter, in the end. Gold sickness takes the dwarves' minds in mere hours.

Lake-town burns, but Bard does kill the dragon. He comes to ask for aid, and Thorin threatens him with war.

Not seeing any other recourse, Bilbo offers his share of the treasure in recompense, and Bard, of course, accepts, but Thorin doesn't. It does come to a screaming match with Bilbo doing all the screaming from the other side of the blocked gate. It’s for both of their safeties. Bilbo isn't willing to risk getting killed again, and this time he would have fought back. No matter Thorin’s actions, Bilbo doesn't want to hurt him.

"I won't allow you, nor anyone else, to steal from Erebor! Her gold belongs to dwarves!"

Bilbo stares through a gap between the stones. Surely, Thorin can’t renege on the contract. He says as much and adds at a high volume, “It is my payment, you thick-headed dolt!"

Thorin's eyes harden farther, turning to flint, his face's flush with angry colour. "Take care how you speak to the king, halfling."

"Good thing then you are not my king," Bilbo retorts, with bitterness and echo of heartbreak.

They do not come to any positive arrangement.

As elves and Men marshal their forces, a word goes out of an army on the move. It is, however, not the anticipated dwarves of the Iron Hills. Azog, the pale bastard, comes with a horde of orcs and goblins. The pending war with Erebor is put on hold — all other races unite to stand against the foul creatures.

It starts with elves loosing hails of arrows. Too soon, however, the orcs descend the hills, filling the valley, and force the allied armies to meet them in a melee or risk being pinned to the Erebor’s gate.

Later, he will hear how King Dáin led his legions, splitting the enemies’ attention between two fronts, but, for now, Bilbo loses himself in the fighting. For all the skirmishes, this is his first real battle. He uses his small size to his advantage, hiding behind and weaving among the tall Men and, at some point, elves. The battle goes on, seemingly forever. The cries of the wounded and dying ring along with the clashes of steel, the twangs of bowstrings, the snarls. It's easy to forget himself and just keep going.

A cheering breaks amid the field and spreads like ripples in a pond. The surviving orcs and goblins turn tail and run, and those, who can, chase after them, but for many, the war is over.

Bilbo finds himself standing among the corpses in a mixed group of dwarves, elves, and Men. He looks around and doesn't recognise their faces, neither living nor dead. Never before has he caused nor seen so much death.

“All right there?" asks the young, fiercely red-haired dwarf, whose back Bilbo has guarded for the last… however long.

He looks concerned, Bilbo thinks with some delay and nods.

"You, master hobbit," the dwarven lad says, "are a damn fine warrior to have at my side. It was an honour." He bows.

"Likewise," murmurs Bilbo. He shifts, glancing around. His stomach rumbles. He is too hot, but his clothes are chilly and unpleasantly damp. They cling to his skin beneath the armour. He shivers. "I should—”

A groan interrupts him. One of the fallen Men is alive. “—help the wounded."

“Aye,” the dwarf agrees.

They do just that, and the elves and Men join them. They search for survivors till nightfall, helping those who could be saved to the healers. Thus night rolls in.

Later, Bilbo will remember the moment he receives the news with startling clarity. After a while, most everything starts to blur and fade, and only this moment will stand out: the torches illuminating parts of the hastily constructed tents and throwing the rest into wavering shadows; the icy water in the barrel he used to splash his face with; the dented metal cup in his hands;  his thoughts about supper.

"Bilbo!" calls Bofur, and Bilbo turns. "Come, quickly." Bofur limps forward, his usually cheerful countenance exchanged for one befitting a funeral, not a celebration. A heavy bandage covers one of his legs from knee to ankle.

Bilbo’s insides freeze. "Who?"

"It's Thorin. He.” Bofur twists his hat in his hands. “There isn't much time left."

Bilbo swallows. "Who else?"

"The princes. They—didn't make it."

The cup falls to the ground, splashing water on his toes.

“I thought you all were safe inside the mountain,” someone says in Bilbo’s voice while he is floating a step away from his body.

Nothing seems quite real. This isn't the first or even the second time when one of the dwarves died. Why does it feel so catastrophically monumental now? He searches for and cannot find the answer. His heart is racing, pulsing in his temples, Bilbo notes with clinical detachment.

And meanwhile, Bofur is saying, "Come. Thorin’s asking for you."

On wooden legs, Bilbo stumbles after Bofur. They pass the other members of the Company, who all as one lower their eyes upon seeing Bilbo and murmur apologies, even Bifur, whose words Bilbo doesn't understand but guesses at the meaning. And Bilbo waves them off. It doesn't matter now.

Bofur pulls a tent flap open, holding it for Bilbo, but doesn’t follow him inside. Abruptly, Bilbo snaps back into himself, and everything comes into focus.

Thorin is lying on a pallet. His torso is bandaged, but bloodstains bloom on the cloth in several places. His eyes are closed and his face — stark white and waxen. His breaths are harsh and laboured. They rattle in his lungs, come out with a wheeze. Thorin looks already more than half-dead, Bilbo realises with a sinking feeling in his chest. Somehow, he hoped for a miracle.

Balin is here, too. There's a heaviness to his eyes, the set of his shoulders and the angle of his head that scream defeat. He sees Bilbo, sighs, and silently leaves, pausing only long enough to squeeze Bilbo's arm on his way out.

"Thorin," Bilbo says.

His eyes open slowly, clouded with pain. Thorin blinks and squints. The lantern sitting on the ground near his head isn’t enough to illuminate the whole tent. Bilbo moves closer.

"You came," Thorin rasps and coughs in the next moment. Weakly, he covers his mouth with a handkerchief, and Bilbo startles, recognising belladonna flowers embroidered at the corners, now stained with blood.

Punctured lungs, Bilbo decides, blinking rapidly.

"I wasn't sure that you would," Thorin says after the fit has passed. "I wronged you. Please, forgive me."

"That's all right, Thorin." Bilbo's lips are numb. The tips of his fingers are tingling. He disregards it. “Don’t worry about it. You will get better. Just, please, get better."

"I wanted to see you one last time,” Thorin says. “Please, I beg you to forgive my selfishness as well. I couldn’t—”

"It's all right, Thorin," Bilbo repeats. His hand finds Thorin's, twines their fingers. "It's not the last time you see me, I promise."

Thorin sighs and closes his eyes. "In the Halls of Mahal, I will meet with my family." He smiles — the slightest curving of his lips — and his expression easies, relaxing as the last of his strength leaves him.

"Nothing lasts," Bilbo whispers. “Rest, now. You will see me soon.”

He sits beside the dwarven king. The other dwarves come and go. Some sit with him, some only staying for a moment. Time passes. Bilbo doesn't move until the last of rattling breaths cuts off. He stands and goes outside. The sky has lightened to a greying pallor. His eyes are dry, but there's aching in his chest, and he is calm but tired.

"Bilbo," Gandalf calls, and Bilbo turns to greet the wizard. "I haven't seen you in the battle. I'm glad you are unharmed."

"Yes, I am fine. Why wouldn't I be?" At Gandalf's searching look, he shrugs. "The others aren't. Thorin..." And suddenly, the numbness falls away, like a pall is yanked off, and anger floods him. He wants to scream and to destroy, and maybe fight and kill more orcs and goblins, and— "Why couldn't you heal him? You did so at the Carrock."

The wizard hangs his head, his shoulders rounding. “Thorin wasn't so grievously wounded then. Magic—” Gandalf sighs. “There are wounds that even magic cannot heal. He would have been a strong king. I mourn his passing.” Gandalf’s large hand gently touches Bilbo's shoulder. “I’m sorry for your loss, my dear fellow. I didn't realise you were such close friends."

"We weren't," Bilbo says, deflating. "Not that it matters." As if he couldn't mourn a stranger.

“Time heals all,” the wizard says. “Come, you need food and sleep. It won't do any good for anyone if you forget to care for yourself."

Bilbo nods and follows.

Time passes, failing to heal anything. Bilbo drifts through days, feeling a little like he does while wearing the ring. He doesn't understand himself. This time, the deaths do not feel real. He keeps expecting to see Kíli and Fíli talking, laughing with Ori or whispering between themselves. He sees them in every dwarven lad of similar colouring.

He drifts after the members of the Company, who all have their tasks in the newly established kingdom, but dwarves outside their small group throw him strange glances. He is an outsider, seemingly muscling into the circle of Erebor’s heroes. Those who fought alongside him or saw him on the battlefield set the others straight, but they are a minority among the dwarven army. It doesn't bother Bilbo.

He stays only long enough to attend the funerals, and even that is out of consideration for Gandalf. The wizard will go to Beorn with him, and there Bilbo will presumably spend the winter before departing for the Shire. It is, of course, a falsehood. He has another plan: as soon as Gandalf leaves him, he will take the same road he did before and hope for the best. It doesn't feel right to ask any of the dwarves to accompany him.

That's what he does after ensuring that his part of the treasure goes to the people of Lake-town and into rebuilding Dale. He only takes a handful of gold coins to buy provisions if need be.

This time, Bilbo even makes it past Dead Marshes. It does surprise him, but the endless field of mires ends.

The sky is grey; the earth is dark and dry. He struggles to reach the mountains. It's hard to get past orcs — they do patrol the area quite often. Shadows glide over the mountain tops, and farther in the distance, a single spire rises high above the landscape. As Bilbo has expected, Mordor is always shrouded in darkness. The clouds never part, no matter day or night.

Looking at the towering mass of ash and sooty stone, for one deranged moment, Bilbo thinks of trekking straight across the mountain range and knocking on the gate. But madness passes, and shivering, he starts to search for a gentler curve to climb.

He travels in what passes for daylight, and while he spots the Mordor-orcs patrols, they aren’t as numerous as during the nighttime. Orcs do, after all, prefer the total darkness over greyish twilight. This far sough, the nights are cold, but days are autumn-mild and almost pleasant.

The aura of evil permeates everything like smog — the rocks, the earth, the scraggly, twisted vegetation, and the air. It's sick and heavy, like in Mirkwood, but hundredfold more awful. The atmosphere gets progressively oppressive, and Bilbo struggles more and more to get up and move.

He sleeps in fits and bouts, the constant fear prevalent on his mind so strongly and for so long, all other feelings dull to nonexistence. He is so very tired but can't rest. With scratched arms and legs, with bandages on bleeding feet, he makes so little progress! There are no maps for hidden paths, no helpful indications of directions. Without sun and moon, and stars — the sky is always full of roiling, angry clouds that never bear fruit with rain — sometimes, it's hard to know in what direction he is going. His food runs out, as does the water. Though he finds a rare stream, Bilbo hesitates to drink, but thirst eventually wins out. The taste is foul, and he gags, but he had worse. He must endure. The lack of food is more concerning. He doesn't know how long it's been — the days became an endless looped ribbon — and Bilbo is unsure how long is left to go.

He can't avoid the orcs forever, either. One night, they come too close to his path. He hides behind a largish rock and prays to be unnoticed, but in the end, he has to fight. He overcomes all three of them and puts on pieces of their armour, filthy as it is, to better blend in and forges on ahead with barely any  idea of directions.

His wandering eventually leads him to a set of stairs and his first sight of Barad-dûr. Orodruin is closer. It is a plain away — dark, barren, covered with ash and crawling with orcs and goblins, and covered with their tents and fire pits. And standing in the shadow of the passage, dizzy with hunger, Bilbo doesn't know how he will make the way across. Despair fills his heart. He bites his knuckles.

A sudden pain — a stab into his back. His limbs grow heavy, unresponsive. He cannot move. His mind is fading, also. He slips away as everything is spinning. The last he hears is a loud hissing noise.

And waking up, he feels so glad for it. A sense of overwhelming relief washes over Bilbo. The dwarves are alive! He can start over! So he does.

Notes:

The chapter was getting too long, so I cut it in half. The second part should be up in 2 to 5 days. I'll answer all comments after posting it, but for now - thank you! Your words are read and cherished. ❤️

The hills of Emyn Muil is a vast, seemingly impenetrable maze of rocky crags, and the Dead Marshes is the swampland through which Gollum leads Frodo and Sam in LOTR. I use this map for references.

Chapter 14

Notes:

Ha! I beat my deadline! *happy dance*

Enjoy. ;)

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

All the way to Erebor, Bilbo keeps his distance and thinks about Smaug and Lake-town, the burned-down town on the lake.

When the feast in the tavern goes underway, Bilbo slips away. The bargeman opens the door at his third knock, already frowning.

"What?" he barks. "You and your dwarves haven't done enough?"

"Bard," Bilbo says. "I need the arrow."

“What arrow?”

Bilbo gives him an exasperated look. He should know better than to ask questions with obvious answers.

“The last black arrow that can kill a dragon.”

Bard startles and, after a sharp inhale, demands in a harsh whisper, “How do you know about it?"

"You are the descendant of Girion. Who else would have it?"

Bard’s frown deepens. “But how did you know there's an arrow to have?"

"A lucky guess."

Bard gives him an evaluating look and finds his stature lacking while Bilbo stares at the bargeman and doesn’t even blink.

"Who will take on the dragon? You?”

“I have to try."

"And if you fail?"

"Then I will fail trying."

"No.” Bard shakes his head. “I cannot risk it. If the dragon comes to Lake-town, at least we have the wind-lance. That arrow is our only chance."

Bilbo sighs, consciously relaxing. "All right. Good night. I won't bother you again."

He turns, descends the stairs, melts into the shadows, and only then he hears a click — Bard closes the door.

The hard way it is.

Bilbo waits until the town is asleep and comes into the bargeman’s house, picking up the lock with lock picks pilfered from Nori. He finds the arrow in the last place he looks, disguised as a rod for pots and pans above a kitchen table. Of course, Bard couldn't have stashed it in a closet. The ring is on his finger once again. As quietly as Bilbo can, he takes the crockery off and pulls the arrow down, but it is heavier than he expected. Its metal fletching hits a skillet with a clang.

"Who's there?" Bard storms into the kitchen in his sleep attire but brandishing a knife.

Bilbo freezes, but Bard's gaze sweeps past him — the power of the ring hides everything Bilbo thinks of as his, the arrow included. Tiptoeing to the front door, he leaves and hears,

"Damned halfling!"

He hides. Invisible and cold, Bilbo waits for morning and is the first to climb into their boat. He sits behind a backpack, wrapped in a blanket.

"Where is your halfling?" Bard demands as the Company walks through the crowd of well-wishers.

"Not here." Thorin stops and turns, demeanour equally hostile. "What's it to you?"

"He stole from me!"

Thorin shrugs. "I am not his keeper."

Alfrid, the Master’s attendant, speaks up then, and Thorin moves away while he distracts the bargeman. The Company boards up the boat and raws away, and finally, Bilbo slips off the ring.

"Master Baggins!" an astonished voice wakes him up. "I thought you left us! Uncle, look who's here!"

Bolting upright, Bilbo rubs his face. Their boat has stopped. "You thought I'd leave you at the last moment?" He raises his eyebrows, smiling wryly. "Not a chance."

"What did you take from the bargeman?" Thorin asks with an air of curiosity about him.

"Oh, nothing much.” Bending down, Bilbo fishes his prize from the bottom of the boat. “Just this black arrow."

Surprised exclamations go around the Company.

"You think we will need it," Thorin says, offering him a hand to help climb out of the boat, which Bilbo accepts, darting a glance at Thorin's face. His expression is tense but curious.

“I am going to face a dragon,” Bilbo says mildly. “I take this kind of threats seriously.”

He uses a piece of rope to fasten a sling and gets the black arrow on his back along with his backpack. He walks straight to the hidden staircase.

“You coming?" Bilbo throws over his shoulder, and the dwarves fall into step behind him.

The climb with the extra weight is harder, but Bilbo makes it to the top. Inside the Mountain, he picks up a coin and waits for Smaug to wake up and search for the intruder. The dragon doesn't disappoint. He rises on his hind legs, exposing the only vulnerable spot — a missing scale right over his heart.

Invisible, Bilbo positions the arrow. His knees are weak, but his hands are steady as he braces himself and throws the coin at the dragon. And just as Bilbo wanted, Smaug lunges at him and straight onto the arrow. The arrow slides into the dragon’s chest. Blood spurts, running down the metal shaft. It drenches Bilbo's hands, arms, splatters his face and chest as Smaug trashes around, howling with pain.

The arrow pierces deeper into the dragon’s heart, just as he planned. The only thing Bilbo didn't take into account, however, is that he is in the way of Smaug’s not inconsiderable weight. He almost doesn't make it. He jumps to the side and runs but slips and falls, sliding down with a cascading mountain of gold. Behind him, Smaug roars, his voice is even more sinister in the shadow-filled world. His tail hits a pillar and takes it out, but finally, all goes quiet.

Bilbo pulls off and hides the ring. His heart still beating in his throat, he dares to stand up and turns to look at Smaug, who’s laying still, unmoving. Bilbo stares. He stays like that, just looking at the dragon's corpse until the Company arrives, expecting trouble. They stop and stare, too.

"The dragon—” Thorin starts. "It's," he says and stops, uncomprehending.

"Dead,” Dwalin finishes for him. “Smaug is dead. Master Baggins killed him."

"The hobbit. Killed a dragon."

"Yes, yes, I did." Bilbo turns around. His coat and his arms are wet and sticky and gleaming black in the torchlight. His face is speckled, and a thick line bisects his cheek — he rubbed it, forgetting Smaug's blood. The Company keeps staring.

"But you'll have to dispose of the corpse on your own. It will start reeking soon. Well, more than it already does," Bilbo amends. "I think you will need to pry off the scales before chopping it up into smaller pieces. It should be easy to burn them in the lava."

The dwarves all still look at him in silence.

"You know what? I think I need a wash." Bilbo turns around and trudges farther into the mountain with vague memories of where to find clean water.

"Did it just happened," he hears Bofur say, "or am I drunk and hallucinating?"

"It did," is Thorin's answer.

The shock is wearing off, replaced with elation. They celebrate.

And Bilbo sits alone on the dusty floor of a guard tower, shaking and laughing. His tears mingle with the dragon’s blood.

* * *

Clean and calm, his equilibrium restored, Bilbo finds the dwarves in the treasury. The dragon's size has been significantly reduced — they followed his suggestion. The dwarves pulled tarps around Smaug's corpse and old, moth-bitten rags to soak up the blood, all to keep their damned treasure in pristine condition.

"What now?" Bilbo asks.

"Master Baggins!" Kíli exclaims, and leaving their gruesome task, the dwarves hurry to his side.

His hands are shaken, shoulders slapped, he even gets a hug — Bofur, Bifur, and the younger dwarves, exuberant and giddy and relieved, all show their gratitude through physical affection. It's nice, but Bilbo looks at Thorin. A golden circlet crowning the dwarven king, he stands aloof and farther back, his eyes are glinting. It started, Bilbo thinks, shivering with dread.

This time, a delegation of Lake-town people comes to inquire not of recompense but the promised alliance and the shared wealth. Thranduil is with them, accompanied by an elven escort, and even were Thorin inclined to share the Erebor's treasures with the Men, the Elvenking's presence would have stopped him. Of course, he turns them all away.

"What cause do you have to demand anything of us? The Lake-town was unaffected by the dragon."

"We came in the hope of renewing the ties your kingdom once held with us,” Bard says, for he is a favourite of his people and their chosen spokesman. “We’d like, in time, to rebuild Dale."

An ugly snarl curves Thorin’s features. "You chose to ally with honourless vultures and came in the hope of seeing us burnt, and with us gone, to scavenge our kingdom’s wealth. But no! The dwarves live! We killed the dragon, and Erebor and all her treasures belong to her people once more!" He leans over the rail of the battlement. His eyes are burning with a manic fire. "You won't get anything from us!"

The Men do not threaten war, though Thranduil does. Bilbo knows it won't matter in the end. The orcs are coming.

“Go,” Thorin scream at their retreating backs, “scatter like vermin! We will show you the taste of dwarven steel! Îsh kakhfê ai’d dur-rugnul! Imrid amrâd ursul ra zaishkhaqwi ai durugnul!”

The ravens fly in two directions — the Iron Hills and to Ered Luin. The dwarves search for the Arkenstone, and, heeding Thorin's demands, Bilbo does so too. He finds it. Staring at the gleaming rock, he can't decide—

"Master Baggins? You found it," a quiet voice takes away the choice. Ori walks over, eyes round and unblinking, his hand outstretched, and Bilbo's fingers curl around the gem. He wants to hurl it at a pillar, smash it with a hammer, throw it into a lava pit. He grits his teeth.

"Yes, it would seem so."

Presenting Thorin with the Arkenstone, Bilbo is bestowed awed looks.

"First, you found me a sword, then you protected my life and stood against one of my worst enemies; you freed us from a prison, killed the worm, and now this." Thorin holds the Arkenstone up, his face illuminated by its strange glow. "What can't you do?" he whispers. "Tharkûn was right to recruit you. You are our lucky fourteenth number.”

"Yes, well.” Bilbo wets his lips, gaze sliding down and to the side. He doesn't want the praise, the recognition. Nor does he like the look in Thorin's eyes — possessive and covetous. "I am uniquely qualified to deal with all kinds of threads,” he says at last and swallows. “The elves are coming. We should prepare."

Returned to its ‘rightful’ place in the back of Thorin’s throne, the Arkenstone shines like a lantern. Bidding Bilbo to follow, Thorin strides to the treasury. There, he gifts Bilbo a mithril shirt, insisting Bilbo put it on right away, his gaze riveted to Bilbo's body, and even as the familiar weight settles over him, Bilbo shivers, suppressing the urge to run and hide. This Thorin is a stranger. After the unsettling encounter, Bilbo goes out of his way to avoid him, wandering the halls like a restless spirit and waiting for the armies to arrive.

The battle soon commences, and this time, when the Company joins the fray, Bilbo is at Thorin's side. He can't be in three different places, however. The orcs overwhelm Fíli and Kíli, cutting them off their allies on the Ravenhill. Across the field, powerless and useless, Bilbo watches arrows pierce their bodies.

"No!" Thorin's scream rings over the battlefield.

Azog directs his horrible grin at the dwarven king, as grotesque and smug as ever, and hatred ignites in Bilbo’s blood. He almost drops his sword, so startled is Bilbo by the strength of the emotion. As Thorin charges at Azog, killing enemies standing in his way with brutal strikes and slashes, Bilbo follows in his wake, guarding his back. He couldn’t help the princes. He swears to keep Thorin alive.

The battle ends with Thorin beheading Azog. A blond elf Bilbo saw many times before but whose name he can't recall hearing shoots another large, pale orc who bears a significant resemblance with the Defiler. Without leaders to directs them, orcs and goblins soon scatter to the hills, pursued by the allied armies.

And on the battlefield, heedless of his injuries, Thorin stumbles to his nephews. He steps on corpses, slips in bloody puddles, but picks himself up, leaning on his sword. He doesn’t seem to notice when Bilbo ducks under his arm and shoulders half his weight. They climb the Raven Hill, where the princes lie together, still in death, and Thorin falls to his knees.

"I failed you. My boys." With trembling hands, Thorin touches their stark-white faces. Tears stream down his cheeks. "How can I live without you?" He switches to Khuzdul, hugging Fíli and Kíli, and weeps. Bilbo watches him, helpless and lost.

"I'm sorry," he says, crouching down next to the dwarf.

And Thorin looks at him, so broken, it shatters Bilbo’s heart anew.

"How am I supposed to live without them? It shouldn’t be like this. It was supposed to be me—Tell me, why did Mahal spare my worthless life? Why punish them for my transgressions?"

"I'm so sorry, Thorin," Bilbo says again, the words inadequate and lacking. They won't bring any comfort, no matter how many times Bilbo repeats the sentiment. He puts a hand on Thorin's shoulder, and Thorin just folds over, falls on Bilbo’s chest, still hugging his dead nephews, and cries.

Bilbo tips his head back, blinking. His own eyes are wet. He swallows and strokes Thorin's hair like Belladonna did—Bilbo distantly remembers—after Bungo’s death.

"Shh." It will be all right, you will see. The words are hovering on the tip of his tongue. He holds them back. They will not help. Instead, he hums the lullaby Thorin sang to him once, lifetimes ago. Thorin cries harder.

Balin and Dwalin find them like that. By then, Thorin's calmed down and slipped into shock. Balin urges him to get up. "Come, laddie. Let's find Óin and get your injuries treated."

"I don't deserve it," Thorin rasps. "Not..." He trails off, his expression anguished. Balin tugs him up.

"Dwalin and I will take care of them," Bilbo says. "We will be right behind you."

The following days are, perhaps, the hardest of his lives. The last time he mourned the boys, Bilbo was alone, but now there's Thorin, alive and wracked with guilt and grief.

The funerals are held in three days’ time; the fallen dwarves are returned to the stone in the crypts deep under the mountain. Thorin buries the Arkenstone with Fíli.

Standing with the Company, Bilbo feels awkward and out of place. Thorin avoids his eyes, barely even look at him when he thanks Bilbo for saving his life, again.

Afterwards, Bilbo stalls. The Men of Lake-town get the funds to rebuild Dale as gratitude for their help in the battle and a gesture of goodwill. The treaties are drawn. Thranduil departs with his coveted gems but sans any satisfaction of gaining them. ("You can have them. Take all the pretty rocks you want. I do not care for fiddling matters anymore.” Thorin waves a hand, and Balin goes to fetch them. "I wish you to find happiness in their possession.") Through all of that, Thorin becomes a ghost. Shadows lie under his eyes and in the hollows of his cheeks. The Company worries. Bombur tries to feed him, as does Bilbo.

"It wasn't your fault, Thorin," Bilbo says. For once, they are alone in the throne room, and Thorin sits not on the throne but on the first step of the dais.

"You've never called me by name."

"What?"

"Before." Thorin leans forward, rests his chin on his fist. “I was always Master Oakenshield."

"Forgive me my presumption, King Under the Mountain."

"Please, don't. I do not want to hear such formality from you. You, or any other member of the Company. It's Thorin."

Bilbo nods. “Thorin,” he says. “You need to forgive yourself."

"How can I?"

"It wasn't your fault."

“But it was! I shouldn't have brought them with me!” Rising to his feet, Thorin hurls the crown he only wears at Balin’s insistence. It hits the floor and clatters, rolls a few turns and stops, quickly forgotten. Neither of them spares it a glance.

"They were my responsibility!" Thorin says. "What good am I?.." With a wordless exclamation, he turns and kicks the heavy stone throne. It does not move. With a roar coming straight from his soul, Thorin pushes it with all his strength and, finally, tips it to the side. The throne’s mighty crash is deafening. Thorin kicks and beats the glorified carved stone chair until his limbs grow weak, his sudden burst of energy petering out. Only harsh, stilted breaths break the ensuing silence. And Thorin stands there, utterly defeated.

Tentatively, Bilbo approaches.

“Thorin,” he whispers. He touches Thorin’s arm, and the dwarven king crumbles, sinks to his knees, and hides his face in his hands.

Bilbo sinks down beside him and, for a long time, hugs him while Thorin grips the front of his coat with white-knuckled fingers, his whole body shaking as he sobs. (He will apologise once more, afterwards, and Bilbo will hush him: "I understand." They will not talk of it again.)

Dís comes to Erebor. She screams at Thorin, her voice echoing in the grand hall, and falls into his arms. The other dwarves file out of the room, leaving them to grieve together.

The next day, Thorin refuses to be officially crowned and passes the title to his sister. Bilbo finds him on the battlement.

"I can’t stay here,” Thorin says. "I do not trust myself not to fall prey to gold sickness. I can't take that risk."

"Where will you go?" Bilbo asks, studying Thorin’s profile as he watches a caravan of carts drive up the road to the gate. At last, the dwarves are coming home.

Thorin sighs. “Back to Ered Luin. Some of our people might remain there.”

Bilbo bites his lips, but Thorin needs a purpose, and so he says, “I have a task I must complete. I would welcome your help.” He outlines the matter, and a spark of life starts to glimmer in Thorin's eyes.

"You do not want to tell others? The wizard may be of some help."

Bilbo shakes his head. "The fewer people are aware of the ring, the better."

"But you trust me," Thorin says, his gaze unreadable.

The words catch Bilbo off-guard. He blinks. "I, yes. I suppose I do."

Catching Bilbo’s hand, Thorin squeezes his fingers briefly.

"Thank you." The short phrase contains so much gratitude that Bilbo can’t regret his decision, but doubts linger in the farthest corners of his mind.

What if? What if?.. — a near-silent not quite whisper.

They gather supplies and depart with a group of dwarves going to Ered Luin. Though the members of the Company want to join them, Thorin talks them out of it.

"Dís needs reliable people. I could wish for no one better to watch her back and help her. You are no simple miners or bankers anymore; you are the Lords of Erebor."

And so they are to travel in the company of strangers, and Thorin sheds the regalia of royalty, returning to wearing his old, worn coat. He looks freer for it.

They pass through Mirkwood with an elven escort, who keep their distance while leading their group along well-travelled and fairly well-maintained roads. The few detours they have to make are uneventful. In barely a fortnight, they reach the border of the forest.

"My thanks," Thorin says, bowing his head. It is the first time he addresses the elves directly.

The blond elf Bilbo knows from the battle inclines his head as well. He seems to think it over, and as Thorin starts to turn away, he murmurs, "I'm sorry for your loss. I hope wherever you are heading, you will find solace."

Thorin doesn’t speak a word until the morrow. He and Bilbo leave the dwarven group behind soon after. They do not owe anyone an explanation, but they provide one anyway.

"I wish to visit an old friend. He lives not far from here,” Bilbo says, and Thorin nods with weight and meaning, standing at his side. There is no one to contradict or stop them. They travel down the river, and Anduin is murmuring and whispering and roaring in turns.

Despite his better judgement, Bilbo allows himself to grow close to Thorin. They are alone for leagues in all direction, with only silences and grief for company. All Bilbo wants is for Thorin to feel better. It is impossible to put aside the loss, he knows, but time will heal all wounds to scars if given half a chance. One evening, sitting beside a campfire, he asks,

"Tell me about them. What were they like as faunts?" There's no need to clarify about whom he speaks.

And staring at the fire, Thorin starts talking, his features softening and eyes glazing with memories of happier times.

In many ways, the journey isn't easier together, but Thorin's unobtrusive presence keeps the loneliness at bay. They fall into a rhythm of walking, fishing, camping. The closer to the fortress of Dol Guldur they get, the more uneasy Bilbo feels. He fears starting fires, but Thorin teaches him a stealthy way to make it, digging two deep, connected pits. Still, they cook their food only before sunset and douse the fires for the nights. They slip into the habit of sleeping back to back, of course, for warmth and not for any other reason. And if Bilbo wakes up curled at Thorin's side, encircled in his arms, neither of them acknowledges it.

Between the two of them, they carry enough provisions to pass through Brown Lands without hunger. Emyn Muil and the Dead Marshes are easier to endure in company.

"What is this foul sorcery?" Thorin says, staring at floating candlelight above the muddy water of the swamp.

"It’s not real," Bilbo murmurs, grasping his hand and tugging him forward. "Don't look at it. It will entrap you.”

Keeping each other safe, they travel as far as Mordor's plain. They ambush a group of orcs and kill them for the armour, and in a daring move, they brave Cirith Ungol and its steep steps. The constant danger and the whispers of the ring keep Bilbo silent, short of breath. He fears the unknown threat that took his life before. The steps run out, changing to steep stretches of sharp rocks. They climb them and come to a set of tunnels.

"Webs," Bilbo whispers, not daring to make any unnecessary noise.

"We should search for another way," Thorin mouths, understanding the reason for Bilbo's hesitation.

They find another tunnel, more crumped, rough-hewn, with a lower ceiling. They almost make it outside when the hair on Bilbo's neck stand up. He whirls around, and here it is — a giant spider the like of which he has never seen, descending noiselessly upon them.

"Thorin!"

“Mahal preserve us!”

Running is pointless. They make a stand, unsheathing glowing elven swords.

Thorin hacks off the spider’s leg, and Bilbo pierces its thorax. The spider shrieks and flails. One of its many legs catches Bilbo in the chest and sends him flying through the air. His back connects with solid stone. He falls. His consciousness deserts him for a moment.

"Bilbo?" Thorin is crouching before him. The spider is nowhere to be seen. "Are you wounded?" He pulls the hobbit's coat open, revealing his mithril shirt.

"I'm fine," Bilbo mumbles, feeling woozy, and when he raises his hand to check the back of his head, blood coats his fingers. He pulls a handkerchief out of his coat pocket and—a clang. Thorin’s gaze slides to the floor, where the ring is glinting, innocuous and simple and enticing. This is the first time Thorin sees it.

Snatching it up, Bilbo stuffs it back into his pocket, and as his skin comes in contact with the golden band, the ring's voice screeches in Black Speech.

Strong fingers catch his wrist. The look in Thorin's eyes is anything but reassuring.

"You should have shown it to me earlier." His voice is unnaturally calm. His grip is bordering on painful. "Let go. I need it!"

"Thorin," Bilbo says, but Thorin's other hand finds his throat and squeezes so suddenly, he stops mid-word. Thorin’s bloodshot eyes are wide and glazing over. He leans so close, their noses almost touch.

"If I had it, I would have had the power to save them. My nephews would have been alive if not for you, halfling!"

Somehow, this latest of betrayals strikes him hardest. As Thorin's fingers tighten their hold, Bilbo wants to scream about the unfairness of those claims. He claws at the dwarf's arm with his free hand, but Thorin's eyes are ripe with madness.

"Give it to me!" he shouts in Bilbo's face.

Never, Bilbo thinks, grey spots converging on his vision. It will destroy you.

He dies clutching the trice-damned ring.

Notes:

Îsh kakhfê ai’d dur-rugnul! Imrid amrâd ursul ra zaishkhaqwi ai durugnul! — May my excrement be poured upon the naked-jawed (ones). Die a fiery death, and I will spit upon your grave.

You can find Khuzdul lessons at Khuzdul for Durins and The Dwarrow Scholar.

Cirith Ungol is a pass or cleft through the Ephel Dúath — a mountain range also known as the Outer Fence — located near Minas Morgul. At its heart is an Orc stronghold, near the caves of Shelob's lair.

Chapter 15

Notes:

The chapter was getting too long, so here's the first part.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

Waking up, Bilbo rubs his neck with unsteady hands. He climbs out of his bed, goes to fix a cuppa. He pours water into a kettle, puts it on the stove, tries to start a fire. The flint falls to the floor. Four times.

“Blast it!”

Bilbo sits down on a chair, hands on his knees, and sighs.

It takes a while before he braves the simple task again, and when he pours boiling water over tea leaves, he studies his cup and saucer. He chose a fine porcelain set, with dainty cherry blossoms and a gold trim. A present from aunt Primrose to his mother on her coming of age, Bilbo recalls. He picks it up and hurls it at the far wall. The shards rain down on the floor, clinking softly.

He is unbelievably, perhaps, unjustly, angry. Stalking out of the kitchen, Bilbo picks up his pipe and weed pouch and goes outside to wait for Gandalf there. He sits on his bench, fuming, his thoughts racing, going in circles.

I can't believe it! The gall! And when I saved his life and kingdom! That weak-willed bastard!

He didn't think that cycle would be the last, far from it. He didn't want it to be, not when it would have meant Kíli and Fíli were dead permanently, but Bilbo expected to find a path to Orodruin and die at an orc's blade, caught sneaking through the plain and overwhelmed, or on the Mount Doom’s treacherous side, not at the hands of his—Bilbo cut's off that thought, biting his tongue until his mouth fills with blood.

He is too heartsick and too tired of it, and so he chooses anger. He fumes and steams like a boiling pot, stocking the fire of his temper with all injustices he suffered through his endless life. Halfway through the morning, long before Gandalf makes an appearance, Bilbo empties his pipe, uncaring where the ashes fall, and stomps back into his smial. He throws the pipe down with such force, the handle cracks. Bringing out pots and pans, he clangs them onto the kitchen table and starts cooking more out of habit than hospitality. He doesn't know how the evening will turn out, but he doubts anyone will be in a mood to appreciate the food.

The day can't pass soon enough. Bilbo doesn't bother cleaning up. His usually spotless kitchen is full of dirty dishes when he hears the first knock on the door. He thrusts his knife into the cutting board and goes to greet Dwalin and, with a tight smile, gestures him into the dining room, where Bilbo set up the table with the best crockery, arranged to perfection. His pride allows nothing less.

Soon, other dwarves follow: Balin; the princes — Bilbo’s heart lurches at the sight of them, full of life and smiles and laughter, and for a moment, he rethinks his plan, but the memory of Thorin's crazed eyes rises before him like a spectre.

The 'Ris and the 'Urs and Gandalf come next. Taking their coats and weapons, Bilbo throws them into a pile in the coat closet. He hides in the kitchen on the pretence of last-minute preparations. After a moment with nothing to do, he does whip up half a dozen pies and puts the first three into the oven. He brings them to the dining table when the last, long-awaited dwarf knocks on his desecrated door.

"Excuse me," Bilbo murmurs as the Company rushes into the hall. Nipping into the kitchen, he follows suit.

Bilbo is wearing his cheeriest apron, the one with apples he embroidered himself, which might explain why Thorin deviates from the script.

"He looks more like a cook than a burglar," Thorin says with barely a condescending glance at Bilbo. “Are you sure we came to the right place?”

Mindful of the density of dwarven bones, Bilbo welcomes the Prick Under the Mountain with his favourite cast iron. His hands are shaking, and his palms are sweaty, but Bilbo puts a lot of feeling into the swing. It still takes him aback when Thorin reels back, stumbling. Blood gushes out of the dwarf’s long nose, now crooked at an angle.

The ensuing clamour is worth every second of his satisfaction, even when the dwarves, coming to Thorin’s defence, take action a little too vigorously, and a large fist flies at Bilbo's head. A brief shock of pain, and Bilbo wakes up in his bedroom to the morning light streaming through his open window.

This evening, Bilbo decides, he will try his luck with a skillet. It leads to similar results, but despite the somewhat lacking ending, this is the most fun Bilbo has had in a long while, and so he is unwilling to stop. He chooses a kettle next and a brazier after that.

When the dwarves fail to deal a fatal injury, which happens fairly often, Bilbo hastens the next cycle himself. After his many different horrific deaths, taking a lethal dose of medication is no hardship.

He goes through all of his cookware and some of his pottery before he feels like he can let go of the memories of his deaths at Thorin’s hands. But the look on the dwarf’s face when Bilbo hits him with a porcelain milk jug wrapped in his mother’s doilies will always make Bilbo smile. It alone is worth a dozen deaths.

Almost, the sane part of his mind amends, but Bilbo doesn’t listen, resolving to cling to his good mood like melted wax to the front of Gandalf’s robe — another occurrence he’s determined to remember. Bilbo will savour these memories when the dwarven king inevitably falls to madness.

He is past caring, or so he tells himself.

Still, as his ire cools, he realises that it’s time to get down to business. Slowly, carefully, Bilbo gathers the shreds of his sanity, and finally, without anger to sustain him, he allows himself to cry.

He hates that blasted ring. He can’t destroy it soon enough.

Thus goes the morning, but by midday, Bilbo pulls himself together. Come evening, there’s no trace of his break-down. Bilbo returns to his usual behaviour, and once again, he is a perfect host. He greets the dwarves with courtesy and unfailing politeness. The feast contains a lot of food they like — hard cheeses, meats, and pies. The Company is nothing if not appreciative.

When Thorin comes, as it always happens, he looks at Bilbo down his nose and addresses Gandalf, “He looks more like a grocer.” He turns to Bilbo. “What weapon do you use?”

And Bilbo says, “All of them.” It’s true enough. After a pause for the Company to digest his words, he adds, “Though I prefer poison.” He gestures to the dining room, noting the widened eyes and slackened jaws of the younger dwarves. Kíli and Fíli, in particular, have paled considerably. “Supper is this way. I saved the mushroom soup — my speciality — just for you. I hear it is to die for.”

“M-master Boggins,” Kíli stammers.

“It’s Baggins,” Bilbo says. A smile slices his face, thin like a sickle. “Please, follow me,” he addresses Thorin. “You must be starving.”

The evening goes well. Bilbo signs the Contract without reading it and, bidding the Company good night, turns in early. And in the morning, he finds his smial spotless. No mud is on the floors, no dirty plate in sight, and even all the doilies are in their places. His eyebrows climb up in surprise, but he is grateful, and so he posts a letter to his cousin Fortinbras and arranges for the Gamgees to look after his garden. By the time the dwarves wake up, Bilbo has packed all he needs and cleaned out the larder.

“No mushrooms this time, I’m afraid.” He smiles at the ’Ri brothers when they come into the dining room and find a spread of breakfast dishes. “But I fried eggs with sausages and cheese.”

The dwarves thank him and proceed to eat with much appreciation of his culinary talents.

In Bree, as usual, Bilbo buys a bow and a sword. He knows they will do until the troll hoard and Rivendell. He trains at every opportunity. The dwarves join him. For what it’s worth, he wins respect by besting all who challenges him to a duel. He does it absentmindedly, however — his focus is thousands of leagues away.

He doesn’t go out of his way to stay aloof and unapproachable, and soon, Bilbo and the Company are on friendly terms. Not once, and not a single one of them calls him halfling.

Bilbo poisons the trolls and raids their hoard, and later, he shoots orcs and wargs and meets the elves. In Rivendell, he forges a quick friendship with Forgam and spends most of his time practising archery and dual-wielding with the elf. He doesn’t notice at first, but their bouts in the training yard acquire spectators.

“Your friends are here again.” Aiming, Forgam looses three arrows so fast, his arm is nothing but a blur. All hit the centre, less than a hair’s breadth between them.

“Show-off,” Bilbo mutters, a corner of his lips kicking up. He glances at the bushes, and sure enough, the top of a blond-haired head is sticking over the foliage. Leaves rustle to its right, revealing Kíli’s position.

Bilbo takes aim, sends an arrow flying. It hits dead centre. He continues, loosing another four. A curved line with arrows a hand’s width apart smiles from the target.

Forgam snorts. A blink of an eye later, his target sprouts another cluster of arrows, this one to the right of the centre.

They continue for a time, Bilbo drawing a straight line and two triangles above it, and Forgam creating another cluster with a wavy line beneath.

“A sloop,” the elf says, and Bilbo hums in agreement.

“A river,” he returns.

Forgam raises an eyebrow. “Obviously. But which one?”

Bilbo levels him a flat look but takes a stab at his mental map. “Ninglor.”

Forgam’s other eyebrow shoots up, joining the first one under his hairline. “I’m impressed.”

The bushes rustle as Bilbo and Forgam collect the arrows.

“Another round?” Bilbo asks, returning to the starting line. The elf inclines his head, and they continue.

As days roll by, their spectators grow in number. Whispers turn to muttered suggestions and not so quiet cheers. Soon, the bushes can’t accommodate the Company at all, and on the day Dwalin joins Fíli, Kíli, Bofur, Bifur, Ori and Nori for their daily entertainment, he takes one look at limbs and heads sticking out of the foliage, snorts, and plants himself beside a fence right there, in the open.

Bilbo waves in greeting, receiving a nod in reply. One round later, the rest of the present dwarves migrate to sit around Dwalin.

By midsummer, all dwarves of the Company come to the training yard, and most of them practice with their weapons.

Time flies. He feels like he just started a new book and, turning a page, jumped from prologue to chapter five; like Bilbo left the Shire only yesterday, and already, the ring rest in his pocket, and now, he blinks and, having dispatched a number of enemies, he is standing up to Azog, defending Thorin. The eagles swoop before he has a chance to try his luck with killing the Pale Orc.

On the Carrock, the dwarven king embraces him, and suddenly, Bilbo comes alive. He has been only half-existing up to this moment, as if he wandered around in a waking dream, going through the motion but never truly living.

Inhaling the familiar scents of leather, fur, metal, and something that his brain has long ago dabbed uniquely Thorin, Bilbo is taking the first full, deep breath in this circle. Time slows down to its normal speed. A lump is lodged at the base of his throat, making it hard to swallow. His chest constricts. Bilbo feels like crying. Of course, he doesn’t, but when he steps back, his eyes are glistening with unshed tears. He looks away and is the first to start descending.

At Beorn’s, Gandalf finds him sitting in the garden. The wizard stops beside him, lights up his pipe. Bilbo follows suit. The dusk enfolds them in a quiet cocoon, softening the world. The last sun rays spill crimson ink over the dark and jagged line of Mirkwood trees.

“You used to be such a gentle and carefree lad,” Gandalf murmurs, pensive and a little sad. “What forced you to grow up into a hardened warrior, Bilbo?”

“What didn’t?” Bilbo laughs, the sound void of mirth. He knows every curve of every road and every loose stone on all the paths from here and to Erebor but can no longer recall most of his childhood nor his parents' voices.

"Life happened, Gandalf," he repeats himself, echoing another cycle.

“I’m sorry it was so unkind to you.”

And Bilbo sighs and shrugs. “It’s not your fault, but thank you.”

He glances at the wizard, who exhales the smoke, reminding Bilbo of a dragon. He shivers and extinguishes his pipe.

* * *

The way through Mirkwood is relatively quick. Bilbo leads the Company straight to the elves for a brief respite from all the walking. There, he allows himself the weakness of Thorin’s company — Bilbo missed him so much that something deep in his soul hurts; he chooses to ignore it — and then, of course, he springs the dwarves out.

Lake-town, the odious Master, and the last black arrow. This time, Bilbo comes prepared, and on the morning of their departure, Bard is none the wiser he’s missing anything, black or otherwise.

The secret passage, Erebor, and Smaug. The dragon’s death is calculated if no less nerve-wracking. As soon as it is done, Bilbo runs through the treasury for the Arkenstone. He finds it just as the dwarves spill out of the tunnel and stop to stare at the unexpected sight — the dragon dead and Bilbo as its slayer. The dwarves’ obvious regard and admiration, while flattering, is fleeting: the cursed gold takes their minds hostage.

He doesn’t hold the Arkenstone for long. While every other member of the Company is searching for the damned gem, clad in jewellery and with their pockets overflowing with gold, Bilbo is in the armoury. He picks up a hammer. The first hit cracks the Arkenstone into three large pieces. It breaks with a melodious, crystalline sound, like chiming in the wind.

“All right,” he says. “Let’s end this.”

Bilbo hits the pieces once again and then some more. He doesn’t stop until a fine layer of shiny dust is coating the floor. Using an old, barely holding together broom, Bilbo sweeps it on a sheet of parchment, treks deep into the mountain and sends the folded parcel to its final rest — into a lava pit. It doesn’t cure the dwarves, but the act is satisfying. That night, Bilbo sleeps without dreams, and in the morning, standing on the battlement, Thorin curses and swears at the delegations from Lake-town and Mirkwood.

Bilbo looks skywards, sighing, and prays for patience. Frankly, he is quite fed up with this whole bloody business.

The Company returns to the treasury and their fruitless search, but Thorin’s countenance is sharp and watchful. He walks the mountains of gold, silent and observing, and when an hour has passed, he disappears in the labyrinth of halls. Returning shortly, Thorin pulls Bilbo aside.

“This is silver steel,” he says, unfolding Bilbo’s mithril shirt. “It was made by my forebears. Take it. Put it on.”

“Thank you,” Bilbo says, doing as he is bid.

Thorin inclines his head, his gaze takes Bilbo in, heavy like a physical touch.

“It is a token of my appreciation. True friends are hard to come by.” Thorin glances at the Company. The dwarves are on their knees, sifting through chalices and bejewelled hair combs, circlets and beaded hair chains, and always coins, countless golden coins. When he looks back, his eyes are hard as stone. “I have been blind, but now I begin to see. I am betrayed!”

“Betrayed?”

“The Arkenstone,” Thorin whispers, leaning closer. He shoots another sideways look at the Company. His breathing quickens, skin pale and beaded with sweat, Thorin lowers his voice farther. “One of them must have taken it. One of them is false.”

“Thorin,” Bilbo tries, knowing the futility of it. “The Quest is fulfilled. You have the mountain. Surely, gold isn’t more important than the lives of your people, the people of Lake-town, and your honour.”

Then— Bilbo watches Thorin’s lips move, it’s he who speaks and no one else, but Bilbo hears Smaug. It must be a trick of the mind. The dragon is dead. There’s nothing left of him. But even as he thinks it, Bilbo notices the unmistakable sibilant undertone to Thorin’s words, the echoing duality.

“This gold is ours, and ours alone. By my life, I will not part with a single coin.” Thorin steps back, slowly shaking his head, and closing his eyes, Bilbo admits defeat.

Words cannot reach him.

As soon as night has fallen, leaving only Bifur and Dori awake to keep watch on the battlement, Bilbo enacts his plan.

“Thorin,” he says, finding the dwarf in question in the throne room. “Come, I’ve something to show you.”

“Is it the Arkenstone?” the dwarven king demands.

“Perhaps. I’m not at all well-versed in gems, you know.”

Thorin frowns but stands up. “The Arkenstone is like no other. You can’t mistake it for a lesser gem.”

“Mm.”

Bilbo leads him through the treasury, but as they come to the secret passage, Thorin stops.

“There’s nothing there.”

“Not anymore. I think whoever took the Arkenstone hid it afterwards. Not very well, of course, since I’ve found it.”

Thorin looks at Bilbo, looming over him, and even in the near darkness, Bilbo notices how his eyes narrow with suspicion.

“Is that so?” the dwarf asks but doesn’t wait for confirmation. “Know that if you, too, betray me, I will not be merciful.” He takes three steps ahead, and Bilbo makes his move.

A swift and quiet turning of his wrist, and a metal baton slides into his hand. He clobbers Thorin over the head with all his might. The dwarf stumbles and crumbles to the stone floor. He stills and does not stir. Exhaling, Bilbo mutters,

“I hope I didn’t give you a concussion.”

He ties Thorin’s wrists together and, awkwardly shouldering the dwarf onto his back like a particularly large and unwieldy sack, Bilbo carries him outside, muttering about enormously dense and heavy dwarven bones.

Depositing the dwarf beside the entrance to the mountain, Bilbo wipes his forehead, check that Thorin is still breathing, and sits cross-legged a safe distance away. Bilbo props his cheek with his fist, resting his elbows on his knees, and settles in for the long wait.

The moon has risen in the sky when Thorin groans.

“Bilbo? What’s going on?” He looks around, features reflecting his confusion. “Why are we here?” He moves his arms as if to help himself get up and, noticing the rope, Thorin freezes. His eyes are wide as he demands, “What is the meaning of this?”

“Feeling better? Or do you still believe gold to be more important than the lives of your people?”

“I…” Thorin frowns, blinks, and his expression shifts into horrified understanding. “Mahal,” he murmurs, pain written clear across his face as he reflects on the recent days. “I have succumbed to gold sickness.”

“More like gold dickness,” Bilbo mutters under his breath. “Yes, you have. Are you all right now, or do I need to hit you again?”

“My mind is clear.” Thorin swallows, avoiding Bilbo’s gaze.

“Perfect.” Bilbo claps his hands and gets to his feet. “I didn’t fancy lugging you all the way down the mountain. You weigh a lot, you know.”

Untying Thorin is a matter of moments. Accepting Bilbo’s help, the dwarf stands up and rubs his wrists and then the back of his head.

“Thank you. I appreciate your assistance if not your method.”

Bilbo shrugs. “It worked, didn’t it?”

“Indeed.” Thorin glances at the hidden passage, but there’s only a smooth surface of the wall. Without anything to hold it open, the door slid shut. “I doubt anyone will look for us here. We will have to go to the front gate.”

They start descending.

“While we are down there, I figured you can parley with Bard and Thranduil, now that you are you again,” Bilbo says, chancing a glance at Thorin, whose sour face expresses his opinion of dealing with the Elvenking clearly enough, but the dwarf climbs down after him and trudges all the way to Dale with neither comments nor complaints.

Watchmen spot them long before they approach the ruins, but nobody impedes them as they go through the camp, and only near Thranduil’s tent an elf steps forward.

“Halt. State your purpose.”

Thorin weighs him with a contemptuous glance. “Thorin Oakenshield of Erebor and Bilbo Baggins of the Shire, here to speak with Bard of Lake-town and” — his lips twist — “your king.”

Another elf glides into the tent, returning shortly after. “You may enter.”

The Elvenking is lounging on a throne at the back of the pavilion, for calling it a tent is a major underestimation of its size. Of course. Why Bilbo has expected something different, he doesn’t know.

There is a set of tables with refreshments — fresh vegetables, wine, and cuts of fragrant cheese and meats. Another table holds a handful of unfurled scrolls, and Bard and Gandalf stand beside it.

“Bilbo!” Gandalf exclaims, striding forward and opening his arms for a hug, which Bilbo readily accepts. “How good it is to see, my dear fellow!”

The wizard looks harrowed, aged by decades; shadows lie under his puffy eyes, and there’s a purple bruise near his hairline. His hair and beard are tangled and knotted. Dirt stains his clothes in places as if he attempted to clean them and was interrupted before he could finish the task. He smells like thunderstorm and smoke.

“I’m glad you are all right as well,” Bilbo murmurs, stepping back and darting a glance at the Elvenking, whose frozen features might as well be cut from marble.

“Thorin.” Gandalf moves to the dwarf, clasping his forearms.

“Tharkûn.” The wizard lets him go, and Thorin looks at the others present. “We’ve come to parley. No one of Erebor desires war.”

“Then you are ready to return what I requested?” At Thranduil’s even voice, Thorin clenches his jaw. His hands form fists, and Bilbo would bet anything on Thorin’s nails making deep indentations in his palms.

“We must put aside our grievances,” cuts in Gandalf. “A war is coming, whether you want it or not. An army of orcs will arrive tomorrow. We must prepare to defend against them.”

“And where will they come from?” Thranduil asks, arching a thin eyebrow and turning his head at an angle to look down at the tall wizard.

“The cesspits of Dol Guldur has emptied.”

“What are you talking about?” Bard says, joining the conversation while wearing one of his heaviest frowns.

Rising from his throne, Thranduil makes a dismissive sound, pairing it with a careless wave of a long-fingered hand. He glides to one of the tables and pours two goblets of wine, for himself and Bard.

“Clearly, you know nothing of the wizards. They are like winter thunder on a wild wind, rolling in from a distance, breaking hard in alarm.” The Elvenking takes a measured sip, casting Gandalf a condescending glance. “But sometimes, a storm is just a storm. My scouts have seen nothing.”

“Are you sure?” Bilbo asks. “Have you heard from all your scouts recently?”

Thranduil pauses, his expression stilling.

“The White Council confronted the Enemy not two days past,” says the wizard. “He fled, but he has summoned his full strength. Orcs bred for war are on the move. If you do nothing, if you don’t take this threat seriously, they will crush you and take over Erebor. We must not let it happen.”

Evidently, Thranduil doesn’t like this answer.

“Say I believe you, and this army you are so adamant exists does so outside of your overeager imagination. Why should I help the dwarves? They have trespassed on my lands, refused my terms of a peaceful agreement, and then fled from their detainment before a resolution could be reached.”

“Oh, so it wasn’t your greed that saw the dwarves in the dungeons?” Bilbo scoffs, fed up with dealing with people as obstinate as they are tall. Really, does height influence the mind?

“They were trespassing.”

“Because you closed the borders, is that it? Then put up a blasted sign!” Bilbo throws his hands up in exasperation. “Maybe then honest travellers won’t fall into your trap or, Eru forbid, mistake you for a reasonable and just ruler!”

Thranduil narrows his eyes into slits; his gaze and voice become icy. “I do not need to justify myself to you.”

“Peace,” Gandalf says, getting between them. “Squabbling now will not help anyone.”

Bilbo takes a deep breath, clenches and relaxes his fingers. “All right.” He nods to Gandalf and glares at Thranduil. “You won’t lose anything if you get ready for war with the orcs and they fail to attack, but you will if they catch you unawares.”

“The dwarves of the Iron Hills are coming,” Thorin says, regarding the Elvenking with a heavy stare. “They should arrive on the morrow.”

“Excellent news!” Gandalf exclaims. “All must unite to withstand the threat.”

“I offer your people aid in rebuilding Dale,” Thorin says to Bard. “Join us in the upcoming battle against the enemy, and I will sign a treaty right here and now.”

“Agreed,” Bard says, offering a hand. They clasp forearms, sealing the deal.

Glancing at Bilbo, Thorin steels himself, his already ramrod straight back tenses farther.

“In the interests of cooperation,” he says, regarding Thranduil through heavy-lidded eyes, “I will ensure that you receive the gems you so desire, regardless of the battle’s outcome.”

The Elvenking is silent, and Bilbo thinks he will have more demands, but finally, he answers, “I accept.”

The tension thrumming in the air like a too tightly strung bowstring breaks. Bilbo exhales.

Reluctant allies at best, they plan, and then, they send a raven.

The moon is full and bright, high in the cloudy sky, when Thorin and Bilbo leave the camp. As the distance to the gate of Erebor shrinks under their feet, Thorin’s steps slow; his posture rigid, fear seems to roll off him in waves.

“Thorin?” The dwarf cants his head in Bilbo’s direction, his gaze remaining on the mountain. “It’s all right to be afraid. We can stay outside tonight.”

For a moment, Thorin pauses, considering, but all too soon, he shakes his head.

“No. But promise me” — he turns to Bilbo, his eyes wide and searching — “if I lose my mind again, you will stop me. It won’t be so easy — I’ll expect it.”

Bilbo catches and gently squeezes Thorin’s fingers, offering support. “If that ever happens, I swear I will find a way to free you of the madness.”

Glancing at their hands, Thorin returns the gesture. “Thank you.”

They resume walking.

Nori spots them first, shouting an exclamation in Khuzdul. A rope is thrown over the battlement, and Bilbo goes first. The dwarves pull him up and over the ledge in record time.

Leaning on the cold stone, Bilbo watches Bombur and Nori and notices a change — their eyes are clearer than they’ve been since the Company first stepped into Erebor.

The news of an alliance meet joyful exuberance, but Thorin cuts the questions short.

“Get some sleep,” he says. “We all need to be well-rested for the battle.”

He squeezes Bilbo’s shoulder before going into the halls, a murmured ‘thank you’ said under his breath.

Bilbo returns to his chosen spot in the armoury. The night is short. The morning comes too soon. His dreams are full of blood and suffering — nightmares interlace his memories from previous cycles, mesh and overlap, creating an infinite line of violent deaths.

He is watching Azog force Thorin to his knees. An abyss lies between them, and though Bilbo wants to run, he is frozen to the spot. His arms are forced behind his back, his hands tied together — Bilbo feels a rope biting into his skin when he tries to pull his wrists apart. The Pale Orc raises a wickedly curved sword and grabs Thorin’s hair—

Bilbo wakes up with a stifled gasp, a scream trapped in his throat. His eyes fly open just as Azog’s sword comes down and Thorin’s head lands on Fíli’s corpse in a shower of blood.

Sweat-drenched hair sticks to Bilbo’s forehead, the ends falling and clinging to his cheeks. He pushes them aside. All he can think about is how Fíli and Kíli looked slumped at the Defiler’s feet, so devastatingly young and small in death.

He crawls to his backpack and finds his tiny sewing scissors. He feels like change is in order, and maybe it’s a superstition, but Bilbo hopes by doing something new, he will entice some luck to come his way. He cuts his hair, shortening his curls to a half handspan at the longest.

“Master Baggins!” Kíli gasps when Bilbo comes to meet the Company beside the gate. “What happened?”

“I found scissors.”

Impossibly, the dwarf’s expression turns even more horrified. “You did this to yourself?!”

“Yes.” Bilbo nods, biting down on a smile. “Would you like me to cut yours? I am a decent barber.”

“No!” Kíli all but runs to his brother’s side. Grabbing Fíli’s arm, Kíli furiously whispers into his ear while waving his free hand at Bilbo.

Chuckling, Bilbo turns to inspect the gate. The early morning hours were clearly productive: a chunk of stone of Bilbo’s height has been moved aside, opening a passage that can be quickly blocked. Beams reinforce the rest of the makeshift wall, minimising the risk of a collapse. He hums in approval.

The other dwarves give him sidelong glances, but no one else comments on his new haircut.

Bilbo catches Thorin’s gaze, and the dwarven king frowns. He is radiating tension, the anticipation of a fight written in the set of his broad shoulders, the rigid line of his spine, but his eyes are clear, not clouded with madness; the dark circles have diminished a smidge, suggesting that Thorin had fallen asleep at some point. He is still pale, but not sickly so, and that is as good as it can get on this fine winter morning. Bilbo nods, concluding his inspection. He will take mildly tired but sane and thank Eru very much for it.

Outside, a line of people is nearing the bridge, steadily walking over the rubble-littered road. Balin greets the women-folk, children and elderly, directing them to Bofur, who leads them to one of the more well-preserved halls.

Bard comes last, making a beeline for Thorin.

“Thank you for doing this,” he says as they clasp forearms in greeting.

Thorin dips his chin, his eyelids sliding down in a lazy blink. “We can’t risk orcs sweeping through Lake-town while all its defenders are here.”

As the dwarves gather together, Bilbo whispers a fervent thank Eru: all of them are in proper armour, the angular planes of polished steel gleaming in the torchlight. He pulls Thorin aside, and, standing side by side, they watch the Company.

“Fíli and Kíli must stay behind,” Bilbo murmurs, lowering his voice even as Thorin tilts his head down.

“They will not like it.” Thorin’s voice is equally low and intimate, a soft agreement where Bilbo half expects a harsh reproach.

“Tough,” Bilbo mutters, glancing at the siblings. The last moments of his dream flash before his eyes. “They must.”

Appearing at Thorin’s other side in the time it takes Bilbo to blink the chilling images away, Balin agrees, “They are the heirs to the throne. If something happens to you, Thorin, they will continue the Durin line.”

Thorin sighs — a great gush of air pushed out of his lungs. “You are right, but they still won’t like it.”

He goes to his nephews. A few murmured words, and Bilbo hears Kíli’s protest: “But uncle, we can’t just stay behind, safe behind these walls, while our kins die for us. It’s not in our blood.”

And Thorin’s response: “What is in your—our—blood is duty. And duty to our people demands our line to continue, unbroken. You will lead Erebor, you and your brother. For that, you must survive.” He points at them in turns. “If all else fails, you are our last line of defence. If we are overrun, if enemies storm Erebor, protect the people under your watch, lead them out through the secret passage.” He grips their forearms, looks from one pale face to the other. “Swear to me you will do as I ask.”

Fíli swallows thickly. “I swear. I swear it, irak’adad.”

And Kíli nods and echoes his words.

“I’m proud of you, mizimîth.” They hug, their foreheads touching — a circle of heavy plated armour topped with two dark and one blond head.

The minutes tick by as they stay still, suspended in the moment of closeness, and Bilbo watches them across the hall, caught in the orbit of their family, a cruel fist clenching his heart.

Bard comes into his line of view, breaking the spell. Bending low, he goes outside, and Bilbo turns away, runs an unsteady hand over his face. He must be ready. He follows the bargeman.

“Itrid ’urmu,” says Thorin, the last to come through, just before the passage is blocked.

The sun is cheerful on its way up the cloudless expanse of light blue sky when the Company and Bard trek to Dale, cold air nipping at their skin, reddening their cheeks.

A perfect day for a ramble down the river with a basket slung over an arm and berry pies packed for second breakfast, Bilbo muses idly, to distract himself of what is to come, not a day for an epic battle.

But all is silent. No bird is circling over the hills, no rodent scurries under the bushes. The very air tastes of ashes and anticipation.

They hide inside the burned-out buildings, Men, dwarves, and elves alike, and wait. But not too long. The morning mist has just dissipated when with the pounding of a hundred heavy feet and paws, the enemies come pouring into the empty valley.

They wait, and only when the enemies are all laid out in the space between the shell of Dale and Erebor do they move. The elves, light and fleet-footed, go first, raining death from the higher buildings. A horn rings out, piercing and mournful. The dwarves of the Iron Hills and Men of Lake-town kitted out in dwarven armour come out of hiding, attacking from three sides and pressing the enemy’s army to the mountain.

It is a brutal battle, and much of it Bilbo perceives in snatched glimpses: the glint of sunlight on a falling sword as he ducks under an attacker’s arm and skewers him through the armpit; the whizzing of an arrow flying over his head as an elf runs past him; Dáin’s surprisingly high, hoarse voice shouting, “For the King!”

The Company keeps together at first, but of course, as they cut into the enemy lines, the dwarves get separated, and only Bilbo and Dwalin are at Thorin’s side. As Bilbo came to expect, time dilates and contracts in turns, inevitably losing meaning and leaving only deep-seated, aching fatigue in its wake when the battle is over.

Sweat is pouring into his eyes. The sun is blazing, too warm and too bright and unbearable. It seems indecent for it to illuminate so much blood and suffering. And Bilbo’s arms are heavy, almost impossible to lift, his feet are leaden, but he pivots and thrusts, turns and slashes. Over and over, he sidesteps, evades, backstabs, and hamstrings. The flow of enemies eager to take Thorin on is without limit, and Bilbo’s always close, here to protect him. And then—

Azog.

Bilbo finishes his latest foe, pulling Sting out of a goblin’s flesh, and turns around. His heart just about stops at the sight that greets his eyes. The Pale Orc, a gruesome smirk firmly in place, is towering over Thorin, who’s bleeding — there’s a gash in his sword arm. And Dwalin is nowhere close.

Bilbo sees them in profile, watches Azog deliver a powerful blow, which Thorin manages to deflect, but the dwarf is tiring, his arms are straining to hold his sword against the relentless assault of his sworn enemy’s unmatched strength.

All thoughts flee Bilbo’s mind. He sprints forward, circling the combatants on silent feet until he is behind the Defiler. He aims for the orc’s kidney — Sting slides into Azog’s back like a knife into butter, all the way to the hilt, and—

Bilbo doesn’t know what happens next. The back of his head explodes with pain.

Everything goes dark.

Notes:

Don't worry, I won't leave you hanging for too long! The second part is coming as soon as I edit it.

Fortinbras Took II is the current Thain in the Shire.
A sloop is a one-masted sailboat.
Interactive map of Middle-earth
Cognitive recalibration for the win. *dons sunglasses indoors and throws a peace sign up* If it works for Marvel, it works for me.
Khuzdul translations:
irak’adad — uncle
mizimîth — jewel that is young, plural form
Itrid ’urmu — watch the worm, meaning Alfrid. Where else would he be if not hiding inside the mountain?

Chapter 16

Notes:

I waited 4.5 years to post the part with Bilbo's break-down and the line about gold sickness. It was a long wait. -)
Bet some of you didn’t expect Bilbo to survive past TBOFA. Surprise!
Consider this chapter a fluffy bandage, like applying a cotton disk to a gunshot wound.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

Bilbo returns to consciousness lying on a pallet. A bandage is encircling his head, and when he carefully traces it, the back of his head feels bruised, pain lances from the points of contact. Bilbo groans, screwing his eyes shut.

He is still tired, his throat is parched, and he feels filthy wearing the same clothes he went into the battle in, but the need to know the outcome — who lived and who didn’t — overcomes everything else. And so, slowly and taking care not to turn his head too much, Bilbo sits up.

The tent flaps open before he masters the strength to stand, and Thorin walks in, frowning at the ground. One of his arms is freshly bandaged; his hair is wet, and he is sans the armour. The battle must be over.

The dwarf looks up and startles. “Oh. You are awake.” He stops a few steps away from Bilbo, picks up a waterskin and a small vial from an overturned box that stands in for a table. “Drink this,” he says, giving first the vial and then the waterskin to Bilbo. “Óin couldn’t give you anything for the pain until you regained consciousness.”

“Who,” Bilbo starts to ask, his voice scratchy, and Thorin interrupts him:

“Nobody you know. The Company all made it.”

Sagging from overwhelming relief, Bilbo drinks the potion. He washes its bitter herbal taste with lukewarm water, puts down the waterskin.

“You should rest,” Thorin says, hovering nearby. “Don’t fall asleep until Óin has checked you, though. You may have a concussion.”

“All right,” Bilbo murmurs, laying down. Screwing his eyes shut, he breathes through a spike of the headache — his head does not appreciate the movements — but soon, it lessens. The tent is silent, only the sounds of camp life come through the thin walls. He thinks he is alone, but when he blinks an indeterminable time later, Thorin is still here, standing in the same spot. The dwarf shifts his weight from foot to foot under Bilbo’s gaze.

“If you are staying, you should sit,” Bilbo says. He casts around for a chair or any other furniture to offer, but the tent is bare. Scooting to the side of the pallet, he pats the opened space.

Thorin lands beside him gingerly.

“Tell me what’s happening, please,” Bilbo murmurs when Thorin fails to start a conversation.

“Hmm.” Taking a deep breath, Thorin starts talking, “The people of Lake-town are returning to their homes…”

He rambles, updating Bilbo on the state of the army, the supplies Dáin brought with him that, along with what the dwarves of the Blue Mountains will carry when they come to Erebor, should be enough to tide them over the winter.

Bilbo hums to show he hasn’t fallen asleep, but the words are like waves washing over a shore, Thorin’s voice calm and smooth. He drifts until Thorin’s thumb drawing circles on the inside of his wrist rouses Bilbo out of the meditative state he’s fallen into.

“…And Dís wrote that the first caravan will arrive in four weeks,” Thorin concludes. He stands up moments later when Óin enters the tent.

“Ah, Master Baggins is awake! Excellent! Thorin — out, please. Do not impede his recovery.”

Thorin nods and with, “I will see you later,” leaves Bilbo bewildered as to the purpose of his visit. Bilbo has thought he was here on Óin’s order. It seems he’s mistaken.

“Impetuous dwarrow, hm,” Óin mutters, arranging his tools on the edge of the pallet. “Next time, don’t let him hide from Dáin, laddie. He can’t avoid his kin forever. Now! How is your head?”

Turns out Bilbo does have a mild concussion. He gets a strong-worded lecture on the importance of wearing helmets, which he endures with chagrin, and a recommendation to rest. Since it is already evening, Bilbo doesn’t protest, and soon he falls asleep.

He meets the Company in the morning and helps where he is allowed to.

In the following week, the dwarves move into the mountain. A healing wing is cleaned of dust and cobwebs. Repaired as well as can be, it opens to the wounded in the battle. The dead are, meanwhile, collected and returned to the stone.

Though the dwarves work fast and employ the Men of Lake-town’s services, the living quarters take longer to prepare. While most of the Iron Hills’ army inhabits the barracks, Bilbo is afforded a spacious guest room in the royal wing, which he doesn’t know what to do with. It’s warm and well-appointed with stone furniture and better-preserved bedding, but Bilbo doesn’t plan to stay. He barely spends any time there, filling his days with any task he can find. He feels such room is undeserved.

As days progress, he notices that more and more dwarves stop to stare at him. The looks of appraisal and awe make his skin itch. Eventually, he corners Bofur.

“And Master Baggins—” the miner is saying to his audience of younger dwarves when Bilbo spots him. He changes tack, however, as soon as he spies Bilbo’s approach. “Here he is, lads! Looks like you will hear this story later.” As the dwarves disperse through the chamber, he jumps off the barrel he was sitting on and smiles at Bilbo.

Bilbo plants his hands on his hips. “Just what are you telling people?”

“Only the truth!” Bofur exclaims, raising his arms in surrender.

Bilbo regards him with a healthy dose of scepticism. “What kind of truth can make the cook find me just to give me seconds?”

Bofur’s expression turns serious and a touch crestfallen.“Bilbo, you are an outsider who went on the Quest of Erebor when a lot of our kinsmen didn’t. You killed trolls, and countless orcs, goblins, wargs and one whole dragon.” He grasps and squeezes Bilbo’s shoulders to emphasise the importance of his words. “You make the impossible seem easy. You are a hero, Bilbo.” Then he smirks, “Besides, you are on a first-name basis with the royal family and aren’t afraid to call Thorin on his bullshit. That alone inspires respect.”

“Huh.” Bilbo blushes. “I didn’t think of it like that. I just do what needs to be done, that’s all. I’m nobody special.”

Bofur sighs. Releasing Bilbo’s shoulders, he pats his arm. “Trust me, you are. Now,” he says, glancing at the dwarves who attempt to look busy a dozen feet away, “would you care to tell how you found the troll hoard, or should I continue?”

“Sorry, no. I’ve got messages for Balin here.” Bilbo pats a satchel he’s taken to carrying around the mountain. “Urgent business, I’m told.” Hurrying down the corridor, Bilbo finds Balin in truth and avoids any other people.

All this sudden recognition feels undeserved, unearned. And even though Bilbo knows all members of the Company are part of the nobility now, he can’t get rid of the thought that he stole the spotlight from the true heroes.

The sooner I leave, he decides, the better.

Two weeks later, Bilbo meets Dís, properly, this time. Their introduction happens when no one is drowning in grief, nor anyone is throwing hurtful accusations.

Dís storms into Erebor like a whirlwind, pulling Kíli, Fíli, and Thorin into a fierce embrace. Then, there are laughter and tears and loud exclamations in Khuzdul. Seeing Thorin and Dís together, smiling and at ease, Bilbo marvels at their resemblance. He didn’t see it last time.

When the formalities are out of the way, Bilbo is engulfed into a brief if enthusiastic hug, and when Dís steps back, she takes Bilbo’s hands between hers and looking him in the eyes — hers are sky-blue, just like Thorin’s — says, “Dwalin wrote all about your journey. Thank you for saving my idiot brother. The Durins are in your debt.”

Bilbo shakes his head. “You don’t owe me anything.”

Pursing her lips, Dís releases him and nods. “I will find a way to repay you.” She looks at Thorin. “Now that I’ve seen you for myself, where’s my favourite dwarf, hm?”

And Thorin rolls his eyes. “This time of day, Dwalin is in the barracks. I will show you the way.”

“Perfect.” Dís links her arms with Thorin and Fíli, who in turn grabs Kíli. As they start walking, Bilbo hears her say, “What’s that rumour I hear—” she switches to Khuzdul, a rapid stream of words Bilbo doesn’t recognise, and smiling, he continues on his own way to Bard for talks about planting sprouts on the mountainsides.

With the arrival of the first of dwarven caravans, life spreads through Erebor. Children play in the cleaned and deemed safe areas, the marketplace once more fills with craftsmen who open their shops, and some enterprising soul even starts a tavern. Slowly, Erebor heals, and Bilbo sees the seeds of the future, imagines the splendour of a thriving kingdom it will one day become. He is glad for it, happy to see the dwarves of the Company alive and well, doing things they like.

The ties with Lake-town hold, the treaty signed in Dale sees the burned city start to rebuild. One day, it, too, will be restored. As per the agreement with Mirkwood, the elves send provision and escort the caravans through the forest, and with Gandalf having departed to mediate, everything is going smoothly.

Watching dwarves and men work side by side, Bilbo commits everything to memory. This is the outcome he will strive for when something inevitably goes wrong and ends this cycle.

It’s time to move on.

Bilbo packs his backpack, says goodbyes to all but two dwarves, and goes in search of the suddenly elusive pair. After checking everywhere else, he finds them in the tavern.

Walking between groups of rumbustious warriors, Bilbo inches closer to a corner table where Thorin sitting with Dwalin. Bilbo is just behind a pillar when his ears pick up Thorin’s question,

“What do hobbits like?”

“Food? Flowers? How in Mahal’s name should I know?” Dwalin answers and, after a short pause, asks, “What have you tried?”

“I offered him gems, but he refused to take them.”

Of course, I did, Bilbo thinks. What would I do with gems?

“You didn’t take it as rejection?” There’s open curiosity in Dwalin’s tone.

“I thought to try one more time in case he just doesn’t want anything associated with the curse.”

“Could have told you that from the start.” Chancing a glance, Bilbo sees Dwalin bringing a tankard to his lips. The dwarf makes three long gulps. “Not beads?”

“I planned to, even sketched a design, but you saw how he shorn his curls,” Thorin says. His tone is mournful.

Oh. Bilbo’s skin is suddenly too tight and hot, and there’s buzzing in his ears. That does explain his strange reaction.

Dwalin snorts. “Try throwing knives. His are” — he curses in Khuzdul and finishes in Westron, “He might appreciate it better.”

Taking a deep breath and willing the burning in his cheeks to go away, Bilbo rounds the pillar.

“Bilbo! Please, join us. Would you like a drink?” Dwalin exclaims with uncharacteristic joviality.

“No, thank you. I just came to say goodbye. I'm leaving on the morrow.”

Thorin’s face falls, and all he says is, “Oh.” His cheeks are flushed, and his eyes are slightly unfocused. This is the most carefree state Bilbo has ever seen him in. Thorin must have had a lot to drink, he realises with a start.

Finishing his ale, Dwalin puts his empty tankard on the table to join the long line of its brethren. “Time for me to go.” Muttering in Khuzdul words meant for Thorin only, he squeezes Thorin’s shoulder.

“Bilbo.” He nods. “Farewell, my friend. Mahal willing, we will meet again.”

As Dwalin departs, silence stretches between them. One of the groups at the main part of the cavernous room breaks into a song, and others join in. The laugher and drunken exclamations ring through the tavern.

Thorin clears his throat. His face is downturned, and looking up at Bilbo from beneath his eyebrows, he says, “Back to the Shire?”

“No.” Then words fall out of his mouth before Bilbo can think it through: “First, I have a task I need to finish.”

“Hm.” Thorin sets his elbow on the table and props his temple on his fist. “And it can’t wait?”

I cannot trust anyone else with it is the honest answer. Bilbo glances at his feet, looks back at Thorin. “It’s something I must do.”

“And afterwards?”

Bilbo sighs. Life afterwards — after the ring has been destroyed. What a strange concept.

“I’ll go home. I think I miss it. Not so much the comfort of my smial, but the… brightness, I suppose, of Shire lands. It is —” he chews his lips, searching for the right word to describe it “— untainted. Like the opposite of Mirkwood, you know?”

“I understand.” And then, Thorin proves that Bilbo is not the only one prone to split-second decision-making as instead of wishing him good luck as is good and proper, Thorin asks, “Can I come with you?”

“To the Shire?”

Thorin nods. “And for your secret task.”

“I-it’s not an easy task. It may take months. I might be wrong, but aren’t kings supposed to stay in their kingdoms? Shouldn’t you be here to oversee the settlement and whatnot?”

For two long breaths, Thorin is silent, and then, he says, “You must have missed the announcement this morning. I abdicated in Fíli’s favour. His coronation will happen in two months, after the last caravans’ arrival.”

Bilbo blinks. That’s news to him, and he suspects he is the last to hear about this decision, but, well—

“If you are sure.”

“I am.”

“All right.” He shifts in place, his right foot hitting something sticky, which Bilbo chooses not to check. He glances at the half-full tankard in Thorin’s hands, takes in the strength of his grip, and nods. “Then I guess I’ll see you in the morning.”

“Good night, Bilbo,” Thorin murmurs.

And Bilbo nods again and turns around, and marches to his room. If he meets someone on the way there, he doesn’t notice. His mind is simultaneously empty and buzzing with thousands of half-formed thoughts and speculations. His backpack is waiting at the foot of his bed, carefully packed and full of provisions. There’s nothing left for him to do — Bilbo is as prepared as he can be. He barely sleeps, and when he dozes off, he dreams of Thorin’s crazed eyes, the ring, glinting and enticing, and fingers on his throat. He wakes up gasping.

It’s late, or maybe it’s too early to be awake, but Bilbo won’t be getting any rest. And so he does what he should have tried before, but for some reason, the thought has not occurred to him until now. Bilbo puts the ring on a chain, cuts up a velvet pillow, and sews a pouch right over the golden band, doing four rows of stitches on each side. He hangs the chain around his neck and hides it under his shirt. There’s no way for him to use it — not that he intended to — but unless he takes scissors to its new home, the ring will not get out.

When Bilbo leaves, Thorin is already waiting outside his room. Dressed in his old coat and simple clothes, Thorin looks just like he did when Bilbo first saw him. The expression he greets Bilbo with, however, couldn’t be more different.

“Ready?” Thorin asks, flicking his gaze over Bilbo. A soft smile curves his lips.

Bilbo nods. Quietly, they depart. The hour is early, and only guards posted at the gate see them out. Outside, the sky has just started to brighten.

Thorin leads him to a pair of ponies, their saddlebags bulging with provisions.

“Mm. I didn’t think of that,” Bilbo murmurs.

“I am a former king,” Thorin says, giving him an arch look, and Bilbo fights a blush.

They make good time reaching Anduin. They travel during the days and at nights stay close to the ponies. The extra blankets Bilbo finds in one of the saddlebags help endure the cold, but Thorin still moves his bedroll close to Bilbo’s. A week into the journey, without talking about it, they end up sleeping intertwined.

One evening, as they pass through the Brown Lands, Thorin asks,

“What is our destination?”

They are sitting shoulder to shoulder in a barren field full of dust and not much else, with only the starlight and the light of the moon to illuminate their camp. The rare patches of withered grass and occasional twig are not enough for a decent fire.

Conceivably, though there are easier paths to take, they could be heading to any of the southern kingdoms. Turning to see Thorin’s reaction, Bilbo finds him already looking back.

“Mordor.”

Thorin blinks. Bilbo watches the slow sweep of his eyelashes, sees his pupils expand, swallowing the blue of his irises.

“One does not simply walk into Mordor.”

“That's not a problem,” Bilbo says. The moonlight’s reflection in Thorin’s eyes is fascinating, and Bilbo finds he doesn’t want to look away. “It’s the going all the way to the top of Mount Doom that’s the issue.”

Thorin’s gaze flicks to Bilbo’s mouth, and Bilbo’s tongue darts out to lick his lips.

“Why do we need to go there?” Thorin asks.

And Bilbo turns away. He makes a deep inhale and whispers, “I have a magical item that can be destroyed only in the fires of Orodruin.”

“All right,” Thorin says after a moment. One of his hands covers Bilbo’s and stays that way. “Then we will find a way to the top of Mount Doom.”

Bilbo leans on Thorin’s shoulder. They sit in silence broken only with the occasional nickers of their ponies until the moon is high and Bilbo’s eyelids can’t stay open. He doesn’t remember falling asleep. When he wakes up, warm under a mountain of blankets, his head is pillowed on Thorin’s chest.

* * *

The journey to Emyn Muil passes quicker than ever before, spent in comfortable silences and chatter. And there, at the base of the craggy hills, they set the ponies free.

It all goes well. Too well, Bilbo thinks, worrying his lips with his teeth. They have enough food and water in their backpacks to last through Mordor. He knows the paths to take and dangers to avoid. Something must go wrong. It can’t be so easy.

And then the whispers start.

At first, it is an indistinct murmur, like foul water gliding over rocks, ominous and cloying; a quiet susurration of dry, brittle leaves swept on the wind over a forgotten graveyard; the clicking of spiders’ feet as they pursue sentient prey. But as the days progress, the whispers form words. Louder and louder, a sibilant voice that reminds Bilbo of Smaug takes shape, just on the verge of hearing.

Worthless, ignorant halfling, it taunts. You will die.

“Shut up, shut up, shut up!” Bilbo mutters into his knees, pressing his hands over his ears as if they could muffle something that is inside his head.

You will never make it.

“Bilbo?” Thorin’s voice is sleep-rough. He rubs his eyes, raising on his elbow. “What’s the matter, amrâlimê?”

He will kill you again like he did before. Why not save yourself? Kill him first. Do it now, and Thorin won’t have a chance to stop you.

“Nothing.” Bilbo shakes his head. He screws his eyes shut and, pushing at his temples with his fingertips, draws slow circles, willing both a headache and the damned voice away. “Nothing I can’t handle.”

Thorin sits up. Cautiously, as if approaching a wild cat, he reaches for Bilbo and drapes his arm over Bilbo’s shoulders.

“Come here, lukhudel,” he murmurs. “Whatever is troubling you, I’m here for you, always.”

For a long time, Bilbo breathes. His racing heartbeat slows down while Thorin cards his fingers through Bilbo’s hair, giving him something to focus on outside the blasted whispers in his mind. The greyish horizon over the Dead Marches brightens with daylight.

“It’s the damned magical ring. It’s evil, Thorin. You can’t imagine how so. It twists your thoughts, perverting every good intention, corrupts everything in you to suit its purpose.” Raising his head, Bilbo meets Thorin’s eyes.

“It has a part of the enemy’s soul,” he mouths the words, not daring to vocalise them so close to Mordor. “I must destroy it.”

“You will.” Thorin’s hold tightens, supporting and reassuring. There’s an unwavering conviction in his voice and gaze, an unshakeable faith. It gives Bilbo the strength to continue.

The whispers do not stop, but he ignores them.

By some miracle, they pass Cirith Ungol and the caverns with spiderwebs without meeting the dreadful spider. They run into orc patrols and kill them, taking their armour. The farther into Mordor they go, the less they speak.

Fear and anxiety are Bilbo’s constant companions. A weight of dread settles in his stomach, an anticipation of a failure finds a permanent home lodged like a stone in his throat. The foul voice denies him rest, whispering threats and false promises even in his sleep, and what little time Bilbo dozes off for, nightmares plague him.

And still, they go forward. Clinging to the shadows and moving with purpose, they cross the plain leading to the foothills of Orodruin. It is harrowing, and every moment of it, Bilbo’s heart beats double-time, his palm is sweaty on Sting’s hilt. The stench of the armour they are wearing is unbearable, but reach  Orodruin they do, and slowly, they start ascending.

The higher they go, the warmer the air becomes. Thin and clogging, it fills Bilbo’s lungs with ash until he starts coughing. He judges it halfway up when they make a stop and discard their helmets. Raising a waterskin to his lips, Bilbo gulps a few mouthfuls of clean water.

Breathing hard and fast, he opens his eyes and finds Thorin looking at him from an arm’s length away. His face is streaked with soot and smeared with dirt and sweat, but despite the long climb and higher temperature, his skin is bleached of all colour.

Thorin’s eyes are glinting with the familiar light that Bilbo learned to hate. His gaze darts to Bilbo’s chest, where the ring rests in its velvet prison. Hesitantly, as if reluctantly, his hand raises—

And Bilbo has a choice — a dagger on his hip that he can use in seconds. He doesn’t think, just lunges forward.

He grabs the back of Thorin’s head and crushes their mouths together. It is a brutal, forceful kiss, borne of desperation. Their teeth clash, and Bilbo moves a hair’s width away, adjusts the angle. He swipes his tongue over Thorin’s lips,  feels Thorin’s hands grasp his shoulders, fingers digging in so hard, Bilbo is sure to find bruises later. Thorin’s lips part. Their tongues tangle, battling for dominance, and Thorin dives into the kiss like all he wants is to devour Bilbo.

Bilbo doesn’t know how long it lasts, but gradually, the fervour gentles into passion, then warmth, and when they part, they don’t move far, resting their foreheads against each other. His fingers are tangled in Thorin’s hair, and Thorin is holding Bilbo like he never wants to let him go. They breathe each other’s breaths, returning to their senses.

“All right?” Bilbo murmurs, flooded with relief at seeing Thorin’s flushed cheeks.

“Yes, uzfakuh. I’m good. Let’s go.”

And they continue up the winding path of crumbling, porous rocks.

The chain around Bilbo’s neck is suffocating. The ring seemingly gains pounds with every dozen steps he makes. The closer to the top they get, the worse the heat of the volcano affects them. Bilbo tears his jacket into strips and wraps his aching, blistering feet in thick bandages.

They travel through a grey fog, and at long last, Bilbo sees the mouth of Orodruin. Sweat pouring into his stinging eyes, Bilbo can’t quite believe it. There are only a dozen footsteps left.

The pounding of a relentless headache in his temples becomes unbearable. His vision swims, his limbs grow heavier than ever, the voice is screeching in his ears, loud and demanding, and Bilbo falls to his knees. He starts to crawl.

Strong arms pull him up, and for a moment, he is unsure where he is. Who is with him, and even who he is himself. A voice — so different to the dark, harsh words endlessly rumbling in his ears like a rockslide — says,

“Bilbo! Come on, amrâlimê, just a few more steps.”

And Bilbo snaps back into reality. He nods, swallows around his dry throat, bites his cracked lips. It is only a few steps. A few more steps and all his suffering will end. Only, these steps seem so impossible to make they may as well be leagues in length.

He tries to move forward and stumbles. Back to his bruised, skinned knees it is.

“Come, sanûrzud. We must continue,” Thorin’s says, pulling Bilbo’s arm around his shoulders and bearing most of his weight, and Bilbo doesn’t know how he can hear Thorin’s voice, the ring is just so loud in his ears.

But step after excruciating step, he goes up. And at the top, as Bilbo looks into the churning lava, Thorin doesn’t let him go.

His hands are shaking when Bilbo frees the chain from under layers of clothes and armour. His fingers spasm on the warm metal links. He doesn’t want to let it go. Why should he? He can—

“I hate you,” Bilbo says, opening his fist.

As if the time has slowed, confined in the velvet pouch, the ring floats down like a feather on a summer breeze, and Bilbo sways and—

Please, Eru, let it work!..

—consciousness deserts him.

* * *

Bilbo wakes up hearing the chirping of birds and feeling sunlight on his face. It paints the inside of his eyelids orange. He is afraid to open his eyes — to confirm his hopes or shatter the illusion of freedom. His breath quickens. Fear seizes his insides, dipping its claws into his heart. But then, he notices a weight on his chest — an arm is slung over his breastbone, palm covering the hollow of his throat. His ears pick up the sound of steady breathing, the soft inhales and long exhales of peaceful sleep. He opens his eyes and realises:

It’s over.

Notes:

Khuzdul translations (source)
amrâlimê -  my love
lukhudel - light of all lights
uzfakuh - my greatest joy
sanûrzud – perfect (true/pure) sun

Initially, this fic was going to end like this:
Grimy, his clothes covered in soot, Bilbo crawls down the mountain and collapses under a sickly tree. It’s over.
He wakes up to the chirping of birds and the feeling of sunlight on his face.

Aren't you glad I added more lines to it? xD

*clears throat* I was going to say that this story is over, and it is, but then ideas started cropping up, and. So, there's going to be a couple vignettes about Bilbo's life at some point in the future.

Bilbo: shows up in the Shire over a year later, buff and armed to the teeth, and with an equally menacing dwarf in tow. Sees Lobelia trying to make off with his stuff. Smiles.
“Hello, Lobelia, dear. I hear you like my silver spoons, hm?”

And also a short gen fic with a Dragon!Bilbo. I'll post both as a part of this series.

Updates about my writing progress are on this tumblr.

Thanks for reading! It was a joy to share this story with you. =)

Series this work belongs to: