Chapter Text
Thorin was dead and it was too late to atone for his mistakes.
His sister-sons, his little boys whom he raised since infancy have perished alongside him. Their last memories were of their mad uncle, bullheaded and obsessive. They didn’t pass peacefully, recalling them play-fighting as children, singing and learning the musical instruments in adolescence, but perishing with a bite of of cold ice, cruel eyes of orcs aimed at them and with ears filled with Thorin’s pained cries. He had failed his sister even more than he had failed the boys.
Thorin promised Dis to bring them home. Now he didn’t know if they had a home at the end, if Erebor had been reclaimed or not. He didn’t know anything much as he stared dumbly at the marble columns of Mahal’s Halls. His grandfather had tried to nudge more than a few sentences out of him with no avail. Thorin’s mother delighted in questioning Fili and Kili about their adventure, that, after their own father had gotten enough of rib-crushing hugs and teary kisses to their hair.
He didn’t dare to bring up the memories and yearning for his undead wife in Thorin’s presence. Thorin tried not to think too much about that fact. He tried not to think of many things.
“Brother, you cannot keep torturing yourself so” Frerin sat beside him
“I can see the disappointment in my forbearers” Thorin sighed “The line of Durin never could hide their true feelings, not in their eyes”
“I personally see more sympathy than judgement” his brother grinned as Fili tried to reenact the ordeal with the trolls, Kili enthusiastically adding on details “You had set on a grand quest, and as ravens croaked from the land of the living, the Mountain had been reclaimed”
“At what cost?” Thorin clutched an acorn in his hand, trying to suppress the ache in his heart “So many people died: the elves, men, dwarrow. Dis is left alone, she is suffering, and all of us are just sitting here, doing nothing!”
“At least they aren’t moping, or sighing like lovesick pebbles” Frerin smirked “Or mopingly sighing, just like you are doing right now”
Thorin sighed in exasperation, thus riling up his brother even more. He couldn’t help it, his ever present heartache. Whenever the mood was up and he felt the warmth of his family’s smiles and jests, Thorin thought less of his failures, but more of how he wished to see another pair of lips smiling among those whom he loved.
Those lips were trembling with unshed tears last time he saw them, pushed tightly together as the tiny creature tried to put his whole mass on Thorin’s wound. He tried so desperately to make him smile at him one last time, but even at that he failed.
“Ah, here he goes again-” his brother punched him “Thorin, please! I love you, but you have the shortest patience amongst all dwarrow. Just wait another hundred years or so, and your love will join you in the Halls. Here time moves strangely, it’ll feel like no time passed at all since the last time you met!”
“We will never meet, Frerin” Thorin clutched the acorn even harder “Not unless I beg Mahal to let me visit the Gardens of his Wife”
“You don’t mean…”
“He was a hobbit, our burglar” the dwarf felt tears prickle somewhere on the back of his eyelids “He was…he was undeserving of the fate I bestowed on him”
“Boys told me how he chased your Company on his own two feet, if I recall” Frerin shook his head, laughing “I just, it never occurred to me that it was that fussy pampered halfling that caught your eye! Never would have thought, never! Thought you loved ‘em rugged”
“Master Baggins was rugged…in his own peculiar way” Thorin found himself smiling “Outwitted trolls, orcs, dragons and elves, mind you”
“You are just like the boys, always ready to sing odes to the burglar”
“He won them over too” the dwarf grinned “I bet they miss the handfuls of berries and crabapples he always snuck them”
“And death caps” Frerin snorted
“Especially death caps”
They were hit with the faint smell of wildflowers. Thorin stilled. Mahal’s Halls were not supposed to smell like a meadow after it rained. The dwarf’s heart ached as he caught a faint whiff of honeysuckle. He used to put those flowers in Thorin’s hair whenever they stumbled upon the bush. Frerin was shaking his shoulder. The smell grew stronger, and Thorin thought Mahal had set to torture him with the future that never had a chance to happen.
“It isn’t our fault that other races have sensitive stomachs, Master Oakenshield!”
The voice was soft, reverberating off of the caverns. The echo of it sounded endless, ancient, as old as trees and the wind, as deep as the sky. Thorin’s head turned. There, smiling at them, stood a humble hobbit lass. She wiggled her bare toes, as if seeking soil but being met with the cold stone.
Lass scoffed, clearly disappointed.
“What did you forget here, lassie?” Frerin bowed in greeting “It is no place for you Shire folk”
“Indeed” she was freckled and red-haired, in a wide flower-brimmed sunhat “I was visiting someone dear to me, and decided to see how you are faring”
Thorin caught her eyes. Her form shifted, trying to maintain its confined appearance. He knew she was something bigger, grander. Thorin felt as if a bucket of cold water was dumped on him, his soul trying to escape through the soles of his feet but failing. Everyone startled when he dropped to his knees, forehead lowered to the cold hard ground, clutching the hem of her dress.
“I am sorry for hurting your child-” he gasped, finding it hard to speak “Oh, Green Lady, I am sorry…I have no right to be in your presence, but you must know, you must-”
“I know, child” she laughed “Rise, rise, there is no need for your tears”
“I cannot” Thorin sobbed
“Why not?” the hems of her dress lengthened, spilling like a river
“Because I am ashamed” the dwarf clutched onto the fabric regardless, and it felt like rose petals under his coarse fingers
Gentle hands lifted his chin, and Thorin found himself looking at an ageless woman, tall as a willow, lush and soft. Her red hair spilled around, interwoven with leaves and flowers, and her eyes were as loving as a mother’s. There was kindness and liveliness in her, and Thorin found himself unable to tear his gaze off of her.
“Children of my husband are just like him” she smiled “Stone that you are made of always retains the marks left on it, and that is your folk’s fault as much as it is a strength”
“To love deeply, blindly and eternally is a great thing. But chiseling those feelings, you manage to cover them over with gashes of doubt, regret and guilt” she continued “My Dear is still carrying the burdens of his past, and it saddens me, as it saddens to see this trait in his beloved creations…There are just some things you are unable to fix, even if you are one of the greatest of beings, of Valar. So many battles, so many deaths, so many children in the afterlife, asking why it had to happen that way…“
She shook her head. Thorin listened to her, but her words were like wind, escaping his head the moment he caught them. He was a mere mortal; how could he grasp the sorrows of Valar? The Green Lady still held him, making Thorin startle as her saddened expression lit up with mischief.
“But, my dear, sometimes, the Fate throws you something unexpected” her eyes crinkled “A slip of a stitch, a loophole in her tapestry”
She had dimples and crow’s feet in the corners of her eyes. There were blades of grass and dirt on the hems of her robes. Green Lady clutched his shoulder pads like an excited faunt. He frowned, head filed with fog.
“You have landed yourself in a loop, Thorin Oakenshield. A slip made by the dark sorcerer, sabotaging every step of the journey, managing to drag my own dear child down with you. Poisoning forests and rivers, the mountains, filling them with orcs and spiders” she shuddered “Do you understand what I want from you? Do you know how one fixes a loophole?”
“I am not a weaver-” Thorin breathed in a scent of honeysuckle, eyes watering “I am only a dwarf…I am…I-“
“You need to unwind the whole row and start over, dearest!” her smile reminded him of Bilbo “There is no reason to wallow in pity, not if you have a chance to fix it”
“I don’t deserve it! My nephews, Fili and Kili, they’re here too early. Let them return to their mother, please-” Thorin pleaded, shaking his head “Green Lady, I-“
Yavanna’s eyes narrowed, and Thorin cowered under her gaze like a guilty pebble. The Halls smelt like static air before the thunderstorm.
“Unlike the stones on the mountainside that must hold each other up, flowers shamelessly compete for every ray of the sun. And do you blame them? Do you tell them that aching for the caress of the thing that gives them life is selfish?”
“…no” Thorin mumbled, chastised
“Of course not! You marvel at their bright petals, at their grace as they continue to reach upward. You take their need of light and rich soil as a given. Because they are made that way, to need something shamelessly, just like every other living thing. The problem with you dwarrow is that you all think that love has to be earned by great deeds or sacrifice, but that is simply absurd. You don’t cherish a tree just on the days when it gives you shade and fruit. You don’t love a river just when you manage to catch a fish”
“I just-“
“Thorin Oakenshield” Yavanna grasped his hands “If I lost my One and had a chance to reunite with him, I would forsake the Valar themselves just to see his eyes again”
Thorin tore his gaze from the endless pastures of her eyes. His family was looking at him. Frerin grinned in that boyish way Thorin loved, Thror smiling proudly. Countless faces, old and young, less and more known, but not the two he held the dearest. There, a little to the left, merry and buzzing with liveliness despite the circumstance-
His nephews nodded enthusiastically, each clutching the arm of their father. Thorin’s eyes met his. There was a silent understanding, an approval. An acceptance of a sacrifice of being separated from his sons for the chance to see them live and return much later, much older.
Yavanna was already looking at him as he turned. She was at her full height, face set in serene and satisfied expression, blinking off the dew on her downturned eyelashes. Despite her eternity and agelessness, there was something youthful in her gaze, a hint of mischief and playfulness.
She leaned in, placing a hand on his forehead. It smelled of freshly toiled soil.
“Take a lesson from the hobbits and be selfish for once, hm?”
She grinned, and as he lost the ground underneath his feet, Thorin finally understood why someone as coarse and stubborn as Mahal chose a dew covered rose for his spouse instead of just another gem.
