Work Text:
Steve, like most ordinary children not yet consumed by society, didn't understand the point of homophobia. His parents couldn't help with this situation either: they were too in love with each other, and their child was far in the background. Richard and Diana mostly just ignored Steve, and he would have had to do something critically serious for them to tear their attention away from one another.
So it's not at all surprising that no one ever had the "gays are bad" talk with him. The older he got, the more he heard such statements around him, but that couldn't make him love girls. When he was ten, Steve awkwardly admitted this to Carol and Tommy. They had been friends for so many years, so he hoped it meant something.
"That's weird," Tommy pondered. "But you've always been weird, so this doesn't really change much."
"It does!" Carol squealed, enjoying that she was still taller than her friends. "Now I have someone to talk to about boys."
"Ew, Carol, why do you even need to discuss them? You just fought with Jason yesterday."
"I'm multi-tasking, Tommy," she smiled, showing off her knocked-out tooth. That fight happened before Jason, and her opponent had lost two whole teeth.
Steve smiled. He liked his friends. Maybe they didn't quite understand him, but they tried.
"So, do you like someone?" Carol clarified.
"Uh."
"That's a yes! Who is he? Do we know him?"
The pause probably lasted almost a full minute.
"Jonathan Byers."
"Sweetie, you have terrible taste."
"But he's so cute and mysterious! And his hair!"
Steve smiled dreamily while his friends laughed at his silly crush. He wished he could openly tell everyone about his feelings, but even at that age, he perfectly understood the disgusting consequences that could lead to. So Harrington buried that part of himself as deep as he could.
Carol and Tommy helped him craft the image of such a staunch heterosexual that it sometimes made Steve nauseous. They wove webs of gossip, wore masks, and acted as if the school belonged to them. It didn't. In high school, Harrington felt much more confident in the gay bars of Indianapolis, which he occasionally visited with his friends.
Tommy and Carol were his heterosexual cover, shielding him from this goddamn world. Steve's first kiss wasn't with a sweet girl, as everyone assumed, but with a guy he didn't even see a second time. He wanted to build long, healthy relationships but couldn't imagine doing it in Hawkins.
"You need a girlfriend, Steve," Carol suggested. "Preferably a bit younger, so you won't have to sleep with each other."
"Fucking expectations. Why can't I just stay unavailable?"
"Because rumors could start, and you know it."
So Steve started dating Chrissy, who didn't want a relationship, but her mother insisted. They had known each other for years, so it wasn't a problem. She was sweet, pretty, but Steve couldn't love her. In such moments, he wished he could stop being queer and become a walking stereotype. Unfortunately, that was impossible.
They dated for about a year, and then Jason appeared in her field of vision, so it was decided to quietly break up. Steve didn't like him; his taste was for weird guys like Jonathan, Eddie, and other freaks he met outside of Hawkins.
Everyone assumed Harrington lost his virginity to Chrissy, but only Carol and Tommy knew just how mistaken everyone else was. In the summer of 1982, sixteen-year-old Steve met a nice guy named Peter, whom he talked to for about a week before he fucked him. And that's when Harrington started compiling a mental list of the guys he was interested in that way.
"You know, I just want Jonathan to fuck me. Is that too much to ask?" Steve said miserably. "Or Munson. I like his tattoos. Oh, and Andy! Going to swimming practice with him is such a pleasure!"
"Steve, sweetie," Carol patted his head. "Stop, or I'll make Tommy fuck you to make you feel better."
"Tommy isn't my type."
"Hey!" Heterosexual-Tommy looked at his friend indignantly. "I could be a good lover!"
"No, you couldn't," Steve brushed him off. "Besides, straight guys are nice to look at, not to fuck. So don't interfere with my suffering."
And in the fall of 1983, Steve started dating Nancy, whom he would have preferred to just be friends with, but his friends fiercely insisted it was necessary for safety. And he understood that perfectly, hearing the rumors circulating about other students. Harrington tried to seem like a typical jock with no hidden depths because it was easier. He hoped Nancy would be his shield until the end of school, and then they'd part ways, just like with Chrissy.
Unfortunately, November 1983 happened. Will went missing, Barbara, as it turned out later, died, and his relationship with Nancy was falling apart. Oh, and monsters existed! Although, of course, that worried him less.
"I called Jonathan a fag," Steve covered his face with his hands. "Why am I such an idiot?"
"Because everyone expected you to," Tommy shrugged. "But you should have fought better, not admired him."
"But he's so attractive!"
"And he smashed your face."
At one point, Tommy suggested spray-painting the wall with insults aimed at Nancy and Jonathan. But he backed off when Steve reminded him that the relationship had been fake. Harrington was supposed to feel more emotion about it, but he couldn't. He had never liked Wheeler romantically, even though that was a huge secret.
In the fall of 1984, little changed. Tommy and Carol still protected him from any attacks, even though they had all decided to be less aggressive. Steve and Nancy finally broke up, but he kept looking at Jonathan, who remained so distant to him. And then Billy appeared.
Hot asshole Billy with gorgeous hair. Steve first tried to stay away from him, but that didn't save him from a fight at the Byers' house. His face was smashed, but that didn't stop Hargrove from being sexy. You can't command the heart, or the dick, as they say.
Billy kept proving to everyone that he was a great alpha male, although literally no one needed that. Steve tried to exist in this world until he sensed strong bisexual vibes from this jerk. He probably should have guessed earlier.
"Billy just pulls my pigtails," Steve told them.
"What? What are you talking about?" Tommy looked at him in surprise.
"He likes me! And he's trying to get my attention."
"He beat you up."
"Why are all guys such idiots?" Carol rolled her eyes, sighing tiredly.
Billy, in all his glory, tried to corner him in the shower room, and Harrington decided that kissing him was the best solution.
"You're a fag," Billy mumbled.
Carol was about ready to kill them both.
"So what?" Steve still didn't back down. He liked looking at Billy. At his smile, his eyes, and that... hair. "You like me, don't you?"
"You're crazy, Harrington."
"Come on, I'm not blind, you can't fool me," he stepped even closer. "Want me to suck you off? But then you'll definitely have to admit you're not straight."
Billy had a big dick, and Steve wanted this idiot to just take him and fuck him roughly. Obviously, they had to get there first. Harrington softly lowered himself to the shower floor and resolutely took the cock in his mouth. Hargrove grabbed his hair and was predictably rough the whole time. And that's what they both needed. Steve liked being slightly breathless, he liked the strong hands on his body.
He liked it when Billy kept acting like an asshole towards him.
"Can't believe King Steve is a fag," Billy muttered, as if he hadn't just brought him to orgasm.
"Then be a good subject and fuck your king, Billy."
Hargrove rarely obeyed, but this time he listened for some reason. And he listened until the beginning of summer. It was strange to have a regular partner, even if nothing romantic connected them. But what could Steve do if Billy remained so hot, and John was still dating Nancy?
Anyway, they drifted apart in the summer, and Steve fully immersed himself in his job at the mall. Robin was fun and seemed to expect him to start flirting with her, to her chagrin. To her delight, it didn't happen. After all, Robin didn't have a dick, and for Harrington, that still mattered.
"You suck, jerk," she was fully into her announcement, though, obviously, Steve wasn't really flirting with anyone.
Summer was supposed to be quiet, but his favorite kid, Dustin, returned from camp dragging a Russian code. Why did that little shit even come to him? On the other hand, otherwise, he would have gone alone. Anyway, that led to him and Robin vomiting from drugs in the mall bathroom.
"Did you get it all out?"
"Think so. Ask me something?"
"When was the last time you wet yourself?"
"Today."
"Ew, Robin," he laughed, trying to push the memory of the recent torture away. His face still hurt. "Now you ask me."
"Have you ever been in love?"
"Yeah, Nancy Wheeler."
The lie came easily, as if he had even convinced himself. It was easier than telling the truth. And who even needed it? The truth about his feelings for Jonathan? About his prolonged sex with Billy? Steve was still planning to exist normally.
"She's such a prude," Robin giggled.
"Trust me, she's not."
"Do you still love her?"
"No," he shook his head. Never loved her romantically. "I like someone else now," of course, Steve was talking about Jonathan. "She's so cool and talented. Really smart, you know? I'm not even sure we're friends, but I love spending time with her."
They occasionally hung out in a trio: him, Jonathan, and Nancy, and that was enough to remain secretly in love. Sometimes Tommy and Carol joined, and loving from afar became even easier.
"Oh."
"You okay, Robin?"
And then she started nervously babbling something about Mrs. Click's class, Tammy, and the attention Robin paid to that class. And in that moment, Steve understood: she was the same.
"Tammy was looking at you, and I wanted her to look at me," Robin quietly admitted.
Harrington didn't know the right answer, but he could comfort her. Because she wasn't as alone as she thought.
"I could never look at Tammy the way she wanted," Steve replied. "I'm gay."
"What? Don't joke like that! You dated Nancy."
"I just wanted to be safe," his voice sounded almost plaintive. And Robin understood.
"Me too. Wow. That's so weird. Steve Harrington is gay. When did you figure it out?"
"At ten. Jonathan Byers seemed cute to me."
"Seriously? He stole your girlfriend!"
"You're one to talk, person in love with Tammy Thompson."
They bonded, and Steve felt way too good for someone who had recently been tortured. But they got out, Billy died, and Harrington couldn't help but grieve. Yes, they just fucked, but there was still something more between them. Maybe they could have become something.
"You okay?" Robin asked him.
"He's moping because Jonathan is leaving, and his last fling died," Carol informed her, having easily figured out Robin was a lesbian.
"Wait, what?"
"Yeah-yeah, our mutual friend decided that fucking Billy was a good idea. For about half a year."
"Jesus, asshole, are you in your right mind? He beat you up! He bullied you!"
"Lay off, ladies," Steve waved them away. "He was hot, okay? Everything else faded into the background."
"Boys," Carol and Robin muttered simultaneously.
He didn't care; he was more worried about Jonathan, busy Jonathan, who had a girlfriend and was leaving. Why did this always happen to him? He could fall for anyone. But no!
"Well, have a good trip, Byers," Steve gave him an awkward smile.
"Yeah, thanks," Jonathan pursed his lips. "It'll be strange not living in Hawkins."
"But you'll finally get out of this hole."
"Yeah, I guess you're right. Anyway, we'll all still stay in touch. At least, I hope so."
"Me too, Byers."
Steve wasn't planning on going to college, continuing to watch over his nuggets. Carol and Tommy got into some Indiana university together, fully intending to visit on weekends. So he and Robin stayed, finding jobs at the video store. The work was easy and much nicer than scooping ice cream.
It seemed Steve could finally afford to live peacefully. However, his nuggets couldn't exist without problems. Not only did they bother him at work, but they also constantly chattered about Eddie Munson. And believe him, he wasn't jealous, he just wanted to kiss that dumb senior who couldn't seem to graduate. Steve had eyes, and he could perfectly see how hot Eddie was. He liked his loud speeches and jester's actions. There was definitely something to it.
Eddie seemed gay, and Steve didn't, but he was. So how could you say with absolute certainty that Munson liked guys? Harrington was walking through a minefield, and it worried him. Robin saw his anxieties but couldn't help. And how could she? They were in the same boat.
"Chrissy is dead, and they're blaming Eddie!" Dustin burst in like a hurricane. "But he's innocent!"
And those were two terrible pieces of news. Steve still talked to Chrissy occasionally, and she was so sweet and good that his heart clenched. How could she be dead? Why did another person from his circle die? Harrington wanted to cry, but he tried to hold himself together. No one needed his tears.
Nevertheless, he finally got to see Eddie up close. He was so beautiful, but fear was easily readable in his eyes and actions. He was, truly, considered a murderer. How disgustingly that sounded.
"Can't believe you've been involved in this for so long, Harrington," Eddie glanced at him.
"Me neither," he admitted. "Who would've thought I'd be performing babysitting duties?"
"Dustin sings your praises. Lucas, and even Mike. You mean a lot to them. I just always thought you were messing with them."
"Well, yeah, I drive them around town and make sure they don't die."
"Yeah, but it didn't fit my worldview. I thought of you differently."
"Oh, you think about me, Eddie? Watch, I might let you ask me out."
He needed Carol, who would smack him on the head for this light flirting. She always did that when he started acting less than typical heterosexual. Hawkins lived on stereotypes, and they all had to play by its rules.
Eddie looked at him in surprise, as if Steve had said something stupid. Perhaps he had, but it was too late to change anything. One said it, the other heard it.
"Don't worry, Stevie, I won't stop the ladies from getting your heart."
"What, you're not even going to try to get it yourself?"
"That's not funny anymore, Harrington," Eddie grimaced. "I remember you calling Byers a fag. I'm not exactly burning with desire to get under your hot hand either."
"I shouldn't have said that," Steve pursed his lips. "It was so hypocritical of me."
"Hypocritical?"
Carol would have advised him to deny everything and walk away with his head held high. Tommy would have suggested starting a small fight, but they weren't here now, and Steve had to think for himself, even if he didn't feel as safe as with his friends.
"I couldn't even fight properly because I was staring at his pretty face," Steve whined pathetically.
"God, Harrington, you're as much of a freak as the rest of us," Eddie laughed loudly. "I might have thought it was a joke, but no jock would joke like that."
"Former jock."
"If you say so," a pause. "It's just surprising to be on the same side. Maybe I'm in the Twilight Zone."
"Welcome to my world," he smiled slightly. "So, can I ask you on a sort-of date while we're hiding from Jason and trying to defeat Vecna?"
"Sounds metal."
Steve missed kissing, even if it wasn't as rough as with Billy. With Billy, he felt like he was choking in a good way. Kissing Eddie turned out hesitant and gentle, which didn't match his image. On the other hand, Harrington wasn't complaining. Munson was so strange, and that was exactly what he needed.
He didn't need Eddie to die heroically. He had a type, right? Billy sacrificed himself in that stupid mall, and Eddie protected Dustin. Two assholes! Was it really so hard to stay safe?
Robin understood him, and Carol and Tommy skipped classes to check on the crumbling Hawkins and on him. Suddenly the Byers returned along with Mike, El and some strange guy who reeked of weirdness stronger than Eddie. They all needed a break. Max was getting better, but the situation was still far from ideal.
"You should have gotten out of this town ages ago," Tommy shook his head.
"Yeah, at least followed that Byers of yours," Carol added.
"Come on, guys. Who's going to watch the kids? They have absolutely no sense of self-preservation!"
"Of course, it's all about your nuggets," she rolled her eyes. "I should have guessed."
Steve spent most of his time with Robin, Tommy, and Carol. It was easier because they knew his secrets. It was so simple not to pretend with them. He wished he could tell everyone about himself, but how? Harrington felt like a liar somehow. Robin and Steve were a duo of queer idiots pining for their crushes. On the other hand, one of them had made significant progress with Vickie.
"What's up, Will? Robin?" Steve watched the two of them whispering.
"Nothing much!" Byers nervously tucked a strand of hair behind his ear.
"He knows about me," Buckly said unexpectedly. "We were, uh, discussing it, Steve."
"He knows?"
"Yeah-yeah, Robby and I are platonic soulmates for a reason," Harrington rolled his eyes. "For your information, I've also invested in her relationship. I was maybe happier than she was."
At least one of them had to find their other half. Steve suspected Will was gay and was almost certain of his crush on Mike. But he knew how to keep other people's secrets and not pry.
"And you're okay with it?" Will checked, just in case.
"Well, it would be hypocritical if I weren't. After all, I've been in love with your brother for a long time."
"You what?"
"Hey, shh, don't yell!"
"Ew, is this how Mike felt? I don't want to act like him."
"Believe me, for that you need to become a pubertal sore with a crisis."
"What?"
"What 'what'?"
Steve never thought that of all his nuggets, he'd have so much in common with Will. On the other hand, he also never thought he'd tell him about himself. But it was easier to say it to other queer people. That's what happened with Robin, the only one of the three to enter a relationship.
"I'm a guru now," she declared. "I'm a queer guru."
"I've had more relationships," Steve protested.
"You have no taste. You fucked Billy. Therefore, I'm disqualifying you."
"Fair."
"You did what?" Will's voice went high.
"What do you expect from me?" he winked. "Billy was so hot, and your brother started dating my fake ex-girlfriend."
"I can't imagine how you convinced everyone you were straight. You're so gay."
"Well, mini-Byers, it was a team effort."
Without Carol and Tommy, he would have gotten nowhere. He would have done something stupid in front of everyone, and it would have outed him. Now, amazingly, a much larger number of people knew about his orientation, though it was still a small handful. And at least two of them were dead.
"Do you think Mike likes me?"
"Mike is a jerk, but he cares about you," Robin answered diplomatically. "I'd say yes, but it's hard to be a hundred percent sure. Romantic feelings are easily confused with platonic ones. Besides, Mike might not understand his own feelings."
"My gaydar says he's bisexual," Steve chimed in. "And I was right about Billy, Eddie, and Vickie. Triple strike!"
"El and Mike broke up again, and I don't know if it's for good. I really don't want to ruin everything," Will covered his face with his hands. "It's so complicated."
It really was. That's why Steve said nothing to Jonathan about his feelings, even though he and Nancy had taken a sort of break. Long-distance dating didn't work out, so they decided to try being apart for a while. They weren't seeing anyone else yet, and Harrington suspected they might get back together at some point.
"I wish I could simplify everything," Robin said sadly. "But we're playing roulette. Either the feelings are mutual, or they're not, which makes you unconsciously drift apart. I've stepped on that rake myself."
"Have you tried asking how Mike feels about queer people in general?" Steve asked.
"And you just go around telling everyone your real opinion," Will rolled his eyes.
"He's your friend. Listen, how about this idea. Tell Mike about me and see how he reacts."
"About you? I can't do that."
"Relax, I'm not going to date him, god forbid. I'll survive if he says I'm disgusting."
Steve was 99% sure Mike would react positively, but he had to calm Will somehow. And it seemed like a decent idea. Obviously, things happened roughly as he expected. For the next few days, mini-Wheeler stared at him in disbelief, as if trying to find the lie. In a way, it was even pleasant to watch.
"Why are Will and Mike acting so strange?" Jonathan asked, stopping by his work at the radio station.
Robin was enthusiastically hosting a podcast about rabies in another room, so they were alone for now. Steve loved looking at him. He wished Jonathan would come by all the time.
"They're weird, nothing new."
"They're weird even for themselves. Do you know something?"
"Why do you think that?"
"I'm almost sure your name has been coming up way too often in their conversations lately."
"I'm their cool babysitter, what can I do," Steve shrugged.
He was also trying to figure out how best to behave around his crush. Harrington didn't want Byers to stop talking to him altogether. On the other hand, Steve knew that at the very least, he had a positive view of queer people. Was Jonathan among them? That was the debatable question.
"You've been their babysitter since they were, what, thirteen?" Jonathan sighed. "Look, I'm not accusing you, I'm just worried about Will. Something's going on, and I don't understand it. How can I help then?"
"Relax, Johnny, your help isn't needed in this matter, unless you want to be my Suzie."
"Your Suzie?"
"Dustin's girlfriend. He's still worried I'm alone."
"I still don't quite get it."
"I'm gay, Byers. Surprise!"
"Actually, that makes no sense whatsoever."
As if anything in this life made sense. Steve wished he could be heterosexual, like Tommy, and plan a wedding with a beautiful girl. But, unfortunately, the universe didn't give him that chance. Although, honestly, he wouldn't have said no to marrying Jonathan.
"I have no reason to lie about something like that," Steve shrugged.
"You called me a fag, and now you're telling me you're gay?"
"Listen, I shouldn't have said that, okay? I was just playing my role as King Steve. And he was supposed to say something like that to keep me safe."
"How did you even build a reputation as a ladies' man?"
"Carol and Tommy helped me. Actually, they did most of the work. Plus, I had a fake relationship with Chrissy. The relationship with Nancy was the closest thing I had to normal heterosexual dating. But I never liked her romantically, so we both had to pretend we were in love," he remembered the conversation at the party before their breakup.
King Steve was a fake, and now he was ready to admit it. Harrington wanted so badly to stay safe that he hurt others. Back then, it worried him much less. Now it was easier for him to open up to people, even if most of them had no idea about his true orientation. Steve just didn't see the point in lying now. They shared common traumas and nightmares. They could understand each other.
"Never thought you'd tell me this," Jonathan muttered. "I, uh, support you and all that, I'm just surprised. Wait, what did you mean when you mentioned Suzie?"
"Relax, Byers, I'm not going to ask you out," Steve winked at him.
"Yeah?"
"I'll wait for you to ask me," a pause. "Kidding. Great wisdom says straight guys are only nice to look at. If they shower, naturally."
"I'm bisexual," Jonathan said quickly. "Since we're confessing here. Yeah. Didn't think I'd say this to you. But yeah. Seems like too many queer people per square meter."
"Oh."
"Yeah. Oh."
For some reason, Steve didn't think their conversation would go in this direction. Jonathan is bisexual? A nice development, but it didn't guarantee mutual feelings. With Eddie and Billy, he somehow got lucky, but now? God forbid, Jonathan was literally the ex of his fake ex-girlfriend. Not that Nancy knew about his true feelings. Maybe she should be let in on it too.
"Thanks for telling me," Steve smiled at him. "Like, you weren't obligated to come out just because I did."
"It's fine, I trust you," Jonathan pursed his lips. "And for your information, I'm not asking you out just yet."
"'Just yet'?"
"Don't want to break up with you for the same reason as with Nancy."
"Then I'll keep in mind that someday you'll ask me out. I hope it'll be romantic. I have standards, Byers."
"Somehow I doubt that."
Their palms awkwardly touched, and Steve felt that sexual electricity he had told Dustin about. For some reason, Jonathan didn't pull his hand away, but gave him a gentle smile, and Harrington realized: there was no going back.
But he didn't mind. After all these trials, they all deserved good things.
