Actions

Work Header

Catskins

Summary:

AU- Everyone Lives/Nobody Dies
On the road to Erebor, Thorin and Bilbo found love, but after Bilbo's betrayal before the battle their relationship shattered. At the battle, Thorin was never fatally wounded and so never reconciled with Bilbo. Fearing that Goldlust still clouded Thorin’s mind, Bilbo chose to stay near Erebor (despite his banishment) in order to better protect his friends. Set two years post-BotFA, Bilbo works in the kitchens disguised as a dwarf below and Thorin rules with regret above

Notes:

A hobbit-ish retelling of the fairy tale "Catskins"

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Chapter 1: 1. Soup

Chapter Text

 

Sweat dripped down his face. Bilbo resisted the temptation to reach up and press firmly on his face to ensure the sap there had not simply melted off. This was one of the fatal flaws in his rather ingenious plan.

 

If by “ingenious” one took to meaning “highly foolish.”

 

“All right there, Baldor?” Óskur called as he sailed passed and out the ever-swinging doors. He was young, maybe about as young as they assumed Bilbo to be, and wickedly light on his feet. Even though he balanced half a dozen platters, Bilbo knew he was unlikely to drop them. “The water too hot for you? You look like you’re trying to birth a boulder!”

 

Bilbo scowled, flicking soapy water at Óskur’s retreating back. The young dwarf laughed as he disappeared down the hall.

 

Standing all night in front of the enormous tub of scalding water meant Bilbo’s hands were already pruny. He was soaked all down his front from scrubbing honey off the large ruglach serving platters.

 

Bilbo had just set aside the last fork in his sink, carefully wiping his brow with one sudsy forearm, when Óskur wheeled back into the kitchen. He was grinning from beneath his short black beard when he dumped a new armful of plates and utensils into his sink.

 

“Maraddanûn,” Bilbo grumbled, wringing out his dishtowel over the sink as he prepares to wash the next round of dishes. He didn’t have the slightest idea what the word meant, but he’d heard enough dwarrow mumble it upon being given an unwanted task that he thinks it must be appropriate for him to utter as well.

 

“Mahassûn!” Óskur laughed and rushes off to collect the next course of appetizers – dozens of tiny red potatoes, scooped out and filled with a sort of soured cream or fresh cheese.

 

Behind him, Óilvur – Óskur’s much older cousin – paced. On the quest, Bilbo had not realized that Bombur’s enormous braid had been as much a feature of practicality as of presentation. Many of the dwarrow here in the kitchens kept their beards tightly plaited out of the way or else (like Bilbo) shamefully short. One didn’t work in the kitchens if they had much other choice in life, after all. Óilvur’s long gray and black beard was plaited into a single tight braid, and though it was usually tucked neatly beneath an apron or into a belt, it swung wildly in front of his chin now.

 

“Where is he?” He had muttered the words about twenty times and Bilbo was half tempted to dump a pot full of his dirty dishwater over the sous chef the next time he asked. “Where is he?”

 

Unable to take it, Bilbo tried to reign in his temper as he asked, “Who, sir?”

 

Óilvur rounded on him, beard swinging. “If you’ve time to ask questions, you’re not working hard enough to keep your position, dishwasher.”

 

Bilbo rolled his eyes, bit his tongue, and tried to ignore the increasingly frantic chant of “where is he.”

 

Óskur reappeared, dumping more plates into Bilbo’s sink. He reached for the next dish to bring out to the nobles in the dining hall only to have Óilvur slap his hand away. “More time between courses! Nipar still hasn’t arrived to make the night’s soup.”

 

“Óilvur,” Óskur started, and Bilbo could hear the mirth in his voice even as Óskur dropped to a whisper, “Nipar is drunk. I saw him in the buttery.”

 

Bilbo wished he could have seen the look on Óilvur’s face, but contented himself with listening to the spluttering curses he let forth instead. Thinking himself safe under the cover of Óilvur’s howling and Óskur’s maniacal laughing, Bilbo allowed himself a quiet muttering.

 

“Even I could make better soup than that drunk.” Óskur’s laughter came to an abrupt and alarming halt, though Óilvur continued his rampage.

 

“Where am I going to find a soup chef at this hour?” A glance over his shoulder, showed the older cook tugging raggedly at his hair and beard in despair. “I will be disgraced! I will be dismissed from the kitchens – from Erebor herself! Our family will carry this shame for generations to come!”

 

A hand came down heavy on Bilbo’s shoulder, making him jump and splash soapy gray water over the edge of the sink. Óskur was grinning unnervingly.

 

“Cousin,” He said, all too politely, “Baldor here can cook.”

 

Bilbo squawked, trying and failing to shove Óskur’s hand off his shoulder even as Óilvur ceased his howling to fix Bilbo with a hard stare. “Him? Is this true?”

 

“Well, I-“ Bilbo started, wiping his hands on his shirtfront to dry them even as he found himself nodding gingerly. It was true enough that he could cook, as any respectable hobbit could. Even the wealthiest of hobbits cooked for themselves most of the time, only hiring cooks for large catered events when it simply was not feasible to feed a hundred guests by yourself.

 

Óilvur was scoffing, however, pulling back, “ I cannot let my dishwasher serve the king.”

 

Bilbo tried to school his face into something impassive. Of course the king would be in attendance at the feast going on upstairs. He was host and ruling lord; it would be improper for him to abandon his guests to their meal now.

 

“What is taking so long?” Bilbo’s eyes widened and he spun back around to face his sink as Bombur stuck his head around the corner from one of the adjoining kitchens. Had his old friend seen him? He must not have, or if he had, then he would not have recognized him, not beneath everything he wore in disguise. “The guests are beginning to murmur.”

 

“Nothing,” Óilvur piped up quickly. He reached out to grab Bilbo’s elbow firmly. “The soup will be done in fifteen minutes.”

 

“Thirty minutes,” Bilbo hissed, keeping his chin down and praying Bombur would disappear before he had to turn around fully.

 

“Twenty.” Óilvur growled, pulling Bilbo away from the sink as Bombur nodded and turned away to shout instructions to the small army of dwarrow manning the spits mounted over the half dozen fires. The smell of caramelizing meat had been making Bilbo’s stomach growl for the better part of the evening.

 

“Óskur, this was your idea, you help him” Óilvur snarled, “If anything goes wrong tonight I will have you both banished for good.”

 

Óskur moaned and Bilbo tried to keep his stomach from roiling. He’d already been banished once and the thought of repeating the experience, or worse, being discovered, was enough to make his knees feel weak. There wasn’t time to contemplate that now though.

 

“How many guests are up there?” Bilbo asked even as Óilvur abandoned them to their task, rushing to oversee the rest of his staff.

 

“Maybe twenty five,” Óskur said, rushing them toward the pantry as they spoke. “The delegation from the Iron Hills has already been here some weeks, so it’s only the King’s family and counsel and Lord Dain and his chief officers.”

 

Bilbo sighed and shook his head and started pulling lettuce and cucumber from the larder shelves, motioning for Óskur to do the same. “We have stock already made, don’t we? And potatoes already peeled? Oh, and grab those onions too, no, not the yellow ones the green ones.”

 

There was a single station free and Bilbo had Óskur leave their burden with him and go in search of the potatoes, chicken stock, and butter, while he began chopping the remaining vegetables. He was nearly done when Óskur returned and Bilbo set him to chopping the rest while he began to simmer the butter and vegetables in a large skillet.

 

“Baldor, that don’t look like soup,” Óskur grumbled. He might have been light on his feet, but the dwarf was not especially deft with a paring knife.

 

“Less talking, more chopping,” Was all Bilbo deigned to respond with. Óskur dumped the rest of the greens into Bilbo’s pan and set the broth on to boil at Bilbo’s instruction.

 

The onions were beginning to sizzle and pop and Bilbo’s spoon was just beginning to dent the softening potatoes when Óskur set him with a funny look. “How do you know all this, Baldor?”

 

Bilbo instinctively reached up to touch his face. He would never grow accustomed to his fingers meeting coarse hair instead of smooth skin when he did so, and he subtly pushed his short beard more firmly against his face. Standing over the hot pan was making him sweat even more than usual and he prayed that it would not be enough to loosen the sap keeping the false beard in place.

 

“My father was a digger,” he admitted finally, with the appropriate amount of bashfulness. He’d learned long ago that one of the few jobs lower than working in the kitchens, was toiling in the ground. Produce was something you traded for, not grew yourself, if you were a respectable dwarf. It was enough to shut Óskur up for the moment anyway.

 

His assistant kept his silence as they poured the vegetables into the boiling broth and simmered it, adding salt and pepper and stirring vigorously until the soup was thick and smooth. Óskur still looked unnerved even as the other servers began to gather, pouring the soup into a large set of silver soup bowls.

 

“It’s green,” Óskur hissed, voicing the concern that seemed to be written across every serving dwarrow's face, even as the lot of them carefully chopped tiny ringlets of chives onto the soup.

 

“It’s what we have,” Bilbo huffed, “You haven’t even tasted it!”

 

“His lordship will not be pleased,” A server murmured, even as she carefully lifted her platter.

 

“His lordship will try it, and he will like it.” Bilbo said stubbornly, drawing himself up to his full height, even as dread began to build in the pit of his stomach.

 

It was a green soup, the color of spring peas still on the vine. What had he been thinking? Dwarrow were not known for their vegetable dishes, and what dishes they did have were pink with beets or orange with sweet potatoes. The greenest they had was the occasional wilted green baked into a tart or hidden beneath a slap of meat. It was never so obviously displayed.

 

As the servers left, Óskur agreeing to serve the King himself lest the results be disastrous, the dread only grew in Bilbo’s heart. What if they knew? What if they guessed that no dwarf would present their king with such a dish? What if he were cast out of the mountain again over such a stupid offense? Bilbo piled the pots and pans he’d used to cook and buried himself in the dishes that had piled up in his absence.

 

He almost did not notice Óskur’s return. The floor seemed dropped out from under Bilbo’s feet. Óskur was white as a sheet and for the first time since Bilbo had met him, he looked like he might trip over his own feet.

 

“What is it?” He demanded, wiping his hands on his already soaked shirt again.

 

“The King.” Óskur started. He seemed to choke on the words and Bilbo fought down the urge to shake the young dwarf. “He likes the soup.”

 

Bilbo stared, uncomprehending. “What?”

 

“The King likes your soup, Baldor.” Óskur repeated, almost shrill in his panic. “He wants to meet the chef.”

 

“I can’t!” Bilbo didn’t realize he was nearly shouting in alarm. “I can’t! Óskur, we have to do something.”

 

“There is nothing to be done,” Óilvur had appeared, overhearing enough of the conversation to jump in, though he too looked unnerved. “Make yourself presentable before he arrives.”

 

“Sir,” Bilbo leaned forward, desperately, mind racing to find a way out. The others might not see through his disguise, but Thorin might. He’d be lucky, then, to escape with his life. At worst, he’d end up with his head on a spike for daring to break his banishment unwarranted.

 

“Sir, you cannot present his majesty with a dishwasher,” Bilbo finally spluttered, attempting to imbue the title with all the disdain Óilvur normally said it with. “It would be a disgrace.”

 

Óilvur paused, suddenly hesitant, so Bilbo plunged forward. “Tell him you made the soup, sir. Please, it would only be right. To produce a dish that his majesty favors would be a credit to you and your family, where I would make you seem like a fool for allowing me near food preparation.”

 

Finally, Óilvur gave a stiff nod, smoothing his plaited beard with one hand and squaring his shoulders, allowing Bilbo to turn back to the mountain of dirty dishes in his sink with shaking hands.

 

Thorin was coming to this very room.

 

Bilbo was elbows deep in suds when the young herald opened the kitchen’s swinging double doors.

 

“His majesty, Thorin III, son of Thrain, son of Thror, King Under the Mountain.”

 

Bilbo, as one with the rest of the kitchen staff, turned to face the doors, sweeping into a low bow as several people strode into the room. Head ducked low, Bilbo only saw the hems of tunics embroidered with shimmering thread and the fur trimmed edges of long robes trailing over the ground and boots with intricate patterns tooled into their leather. He heard the rest of the staff rise, and turned quickly back to his sink, breathing hard.

 

He knew in his head that he was well hidden. His hair fell past his shoulders now, hiding both his face and his pointed ears. His furry feet were well hidden beneath heavy boots. Even his face, turned away though he was, was half hidden beneath a false beard. Besides, there was no reason for Thorin, King Under the Mountain, to be searching for a traitor amongst his kitchen staff. There was no reason for him to be looking for Bilbo at all.

 

“Your majesty,” Bombur had joined the rest of his staff upon the King’s arrival, and he sounded fond, though restrained in his greeting.

 

“Be at ease,” It was as though someone had turned Bilbo’s heart into a bird, the way it fluttered and scrambled against his ribs. It was a startling realization that this was the first time he’d heard Thorin speak since their altercation before the battle, and that had been a very, very long time ago. “You are the chef then?”

 

“I am a chef to be sure, but I was not your soup chef this evening, majesty,” Bombur chuckled. There was a shuffling of feet before Bilbo heard Óilvur’s stammering.

 

“It is an honor, your majesty,” Bilbo peered behind him, barely turning his head though his hands still scrubbed the same silver platter over and over. Thorin (for it could only be Thorin in those long blue robes, even if Bilbo could not see his face) was circling poor Óilvur. He almost smiled, remembering how the king had once circled him that first night in Bag End.

 

“The soup,” Thorin said finally, “It was green.”

 

“Yes, majesty,” Óilvur’s voice was high and breathless in fear.

 

“Why?” The pause was almost palpable and for a moment Bilbo feared Óilvur would crack and reveal him.

 

“Our usual soup chef was indisposed. I made the soup using what ingredients were readily available at hand.” Óilvur stammered. Thorin let out a long breath. If Bilbo did not know better, he would have called it a sigh. Behind him, a familiar voice murmured something he could not quite make out. When next Thorin spoke, he sounded as though he were speaking from the far end of a long tunnel.

 

“I thank you and your staff for an excellent meal.” It was formal, and though not ungrateful, the King’s mind must have been elsewhere. He paused again, before adding, “And the soup. You will make it for me again tomorrow.”

 

There was a chorus of “yes, your majesty” and “thank you, your majesty” and “it is the highest honor, your majesty” which followed the King as he and his escort left the kitchens. It wasn’t until the doors swung shut behind them that Bilbo allowed himself to breathe, slumping forward over the dirty sink.

 

--

 

The wages of a dishwasher, even a royal dishwasher, were not enough for a full house in Erebor, not even truly an apartment. The room Bilbo rented had no window or any fireplace. Instead the small square room had a set of sconces set high on the stone walls. Bilbo had a small wooden stool he used to reach them, needing the extra height to light the oil in them, but that night Bilbo was too exhausted to bother.

 

This deep in the mountain, no outside light filtered in, leaving the quarter of the city in perpetual darkness, pierced only by what light the dwarrow there could make themselves. In the dark, Bilbo climbed the stone steps to his room, unlocking and then firmly relocking the door behind himself. It was only when he’d done up all three of his bolts that he carefully pulled his feet from their heavy boots.

 

He sighed gratefully at the feeling of the cold stone floor beneath his feet. It was only Blotmath (or âfdohyar, he supposed he ought to call it now) but the temperatures were already low enough to have him shivering if he slept without most of his clothing on. The cold was good for one thing, at least, since it marked the lull in work between the Durin’s Day and Mahalmerag.

 

Bilbo felt his way forward in the darkness until he found the small table beside his bed. By touch alone, he found his flint box and carefully lit the tallow candle he kept there. In its thin wavering light, he poured water from the tin jug into the stone basin set into the wall. Then, using the jug’s reflective surface for a mirror began carefully pulling the beard from his face and rinsing the sap from his chin. Absently, the thought of how he would need to sneak into the stables soon to cut more of the ponies’ fur for his beard. Not for the first time, Bilbo wished dearly for his golden ring.

 

After the battle, he’d given it to Gandalf for safe keeping, wrapped tightly in cloth so that the wizard never touched it with his bare skin. He would not pretend to understand Gandalf’s caution around the piece of jewelry, but he did not need to. The blasted thing was gone, for better or for worse, and Bilbo did not expect to see it again.

 

Face clean, Bilbo sat on the edge of his bed. From the drawer in his bedside table, he withdrew a well-worn wooden box. It was small enough to sit comfortably in the palm of his hand, lid sliding open rather than lifting up. Unadorned, it was a thing of function rather than beauty.

 

Gingerly, Bilbo slid opened the lid. He ought to toss the box and all its contents into the Running River, but he never could quite bring himself to. The ring, silver caging in deep blue stone beneath with the single cirth (rarur, he’d learned), Bilbo kept for practical reasons. Ring of the line of Durin or no, he would be able to buy passage out of the mountain with it if he ever needed to. Thorin had not known the significance of exchanging rings in the Shire when he’d given it to Bilbo, only saying it was the first part of his payment for saving his life. Still, Bilbo kept it.

 

The bead, Bilbo could admit was entirely sentimental. Whatever dwarrow claimed, Bilbo knew few would recognize the silver bead that had held one of Thorin’s few braids once. By now even Bilbo understood the significance of the gesture and he allowed himself the small token because the thought of destroying it felt cruel.

 

And last, though Bilbo could hardly look at it, a shard of gemstone. It seemed to glow from a light of its own making, catching meager candlelight and spinning tiny rainbows from it. The Arkenstone itself had cracked beneath one of Smaug’s enormous talons when Bilbo had first stolen it, and he’d kept the broken shard without thinking. Though at first Bilbo had fretted over what the dwarves would think of the damage, he allowed himself to chuckle now. Even managing to reclaim the damn stone would be marred for the line of Durin since it was already damaged. Thought he hoped not to be cruel, Bilbo was not above a little guilty joy in frustrating the people who had hurt him.

 

Perhaps there would be no quiet now, not now that Thorin’s attention had been on the kitchen. If there was hope in the thought, hope that his charade might end and end favorably, it was drowned out by fear and reason. Thorin would not look to the kitchens again and he would not discover Bilbo.

 

The foolish hobbit would do better to worry about the problems at hand. Teaching Óilvur how to recreate the soup would be trouble enough without worrying about royals who may or may not still be mad as a march hare.