Actions

Work Header

All of you

Summary:

“So I’m not…” Bilbo began and was surprised to hear his voice shake. He swallowed hard and folded his hands together tightly, pressing his fingertips against his knuckles to help him focus. “I’m not… broken or bad?”

“Of course not!” came from the others, the ‘Ri brothers and the two princes being the loudest.

“You’re not broken or bad,” Thorin said firmly, but kindly. “You are Bilbo Baggins of Hobbiton and you are the fourteenth member of this company. You are you.”

Notes:

Many thanks to my sister for beta-reading this story!

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Work Text:

Bifur was trying to fly again.

It had been five days since they barely escaped death with the help of giant eagles, then had to flee into Beorn’s home chased by orcs (again), wargs, and a bear who turned out to be their host. Thankfully, Beorn was quite more amenable on two legs and allowed them to stay. Once all the injured had recovered, Bilbo knew, they would set out again, but even those foreboding thoughts couldn’t put too much of a damper on his mood. They were safe, had somewhere comfortable and warm to sleep, and there was enough food to fill the biggest bellies, most of which Bilbo didn’t even have to force himself to eat.

The only things missing were his favourite pipe as well as his favourite cup and saucer, and his most comfortable fluffy robe. On the other hand, had he brought them along, they probably would have been badly damaged or even destroyed by now. That wasn’t something Bilbo wanted to contemplate for long, so he brought his thoughts on a different track and counted the number of purple flowers in Beorn’s garden again.

Once his heartbeat had slowed down again and he no longer felt like he was a shapeless entity just barely clinging onto his body, Bilbo looked back up to the roof of Beorn’s stables, on top of which stood Bifur, flapping his arms like a bird. Bilbo had no idea how he’d got up there. Evidently, neither did the other dwarves.

“Bif’, we’ve talked about this already,” Bofur said. He was standing right below Bifur and was looking up to him. Next to Bofur, Bombur was tugging on the loose threads of his gloves, as he usually did when he was nervous. “Just because you flap your arms doesn’t mean you can fly.”

Bifur shouted something in Dwarvish, which made the others laugh.

Every time they laughed in response to something unusual Bifur did, Bilbo froze and braced himself for thinly veiled mockery, but the laughter never turned malicious. They laughed, yes, but it didn’t sound insulting or derisive. Instead of making fun of Bifur, they seemed to be having fun with him.

It never failed to make him smile, even if part of him was still waiting for the next apple to fall from the tree to be rotten.

“Would it—if I—to you?”

Bilbo almost jumped up from his seat and whipped his head around to see Ori standing next to him. Even though all the dwarves were terribly noisy, Nori included, he had been so lost in thought that he hadn’t heard Ori approach. Unfortunately, he had not caught what Ori had said either. Bilbo raked his brain for something polite to say without giving away that he hadn’t heard Ori, but he doubted his usual go-to comments about the weather, gardens, the latest harvest, or the markets would work with a dwarf.

He was saved from his increasingly panicked floundering when Ori exclaimed, “I didn’t mean to startle you!” Since Bilbo was focusing on Ori’s nose, he saw it redden as the dwarf blushed. “I only wanted to know if I could sit down next to you.”

Bilbo looked at the empty space next to him on the bench, then back to Ori. “Of course,” he said with a smile that wasn’t forced.

Out of all the dwarves, he liked Ori the most. They shared a love for books and stories of all kinds. Even though Ori preferred historical accounts over poetry and songs, which Bilbo liked best, they were more than happy to listen to each other and seamlessly went from one topic to the next.

It was the first time since the death of his father that Bilbo had found someone sharing his enthusiasm about literature. Most hobbits cared little for books or reading as a whole—and even less about tales from lands beyond the Shire. Talking with anyone other than his parents or Took cousins about such stories had never gone well.

“You are scaring your cousins with all this talk about trolls and dragons.”

“You don’t really believe in this silly stuff, do you? Someone at your age should know better.”

“Is that acceptable teatime conversation in Tookland? Goodness, no wonder their children are so… rowdy.”

So Bilbo usually swallowed down the words that wanted to burst out of his mouth and learned instead what topics were appropriate. The weather of today, the last few days, or the near future, read from clues like the colours of that day’s dawn and other signs Bilbo memorised. The latest harvest. The markets. Gossip about neighbours, in which he never participated voluntarily, but was dragged into anyway without realising what they were doing until after the fact.

But that wasn’t enough.

“It’s not proper for the Baggins heir to flap his hands around like that. Fold them in your lap. Grasp one with the other.”

“Stop it with all that squirming!”

“It was only a cup and not even an expensive or old one. Why are you so distraught?”

“You’re not a faunt anymore, Bilbo. You can’t cry every time something upsets you. Use your words.”

Even worse were the comments not directed at him but passed around in conversation, sometimes even when he was in hearing range as if he was invisible. Calling him odd, weird, a freak, or worse.

He trained himself out of the behaviours that elicited the most criticism, but no matter how hard he tried, there was always something wrong with him that other people commented on. His parents had tried their best to shield him from comments such as these, but they would inevitably resume once his parents were in another room and Bilbo was alone with his Baggins relatives. Somehow, even though Bilbo never told them about the comments out of shame, Bungo and Belladonna still found out about them. More than once, they left a party hosted by his father’s relatives early because of something negative someone said and at some point, his father even threatened to cut all contact with his parents if they did not stop.

But while the comments from Bilbo’s paternal family stopped for the most part after that, it did nothing to quell the comments from the other children, who either avoided him or tricked him into doing something so they could laugh at him for doing what they had asked him to.

At, not with.

Not like it was right now in Beorn’s garden. The dwarves were laughing with, not at Bifur.

Bilbo found himself smiling again, “It’s nice to see how everyone treats Bifur,” he said to Ori without thinking.

In the Shire, people would have criticised Ori for not putting down his notebook while talking to someone, but Bilbo had learned that Ori could write and converse at the same time, so he didn’t mind. “What do you mean?” the dwarf asked.

“They’re all so kind,” Bilbo said, feeling like he was pointing out something obvious. “They’re laughing but there is nothing mean about it.” Bilbo looked up to the roof again where Bifur was still standing, flapping his arms like wings. Now he was also trying to mimic the cry of an eagle. “No one is making fun of him or mocking him.”

“Of course not!”

Bilbo looked back to Ori with a frown. He had not heard Ori this upset before and wondered what he had said that elicited such a strong reaction.

Ori put away his quill and closed his notebook. “There is no reason for anyone to mock him! No dwarf ever would!” Then, after a pause, he leaned a little bit closer, but still well outside Bilbo’s zone of comfort.

For all their rambunctiousness, straightforward nature, and lack of tact when compared to hobbits, all the dwarves were surprisingly considerate of other peoples’ personal space. From what Bilbo had observed, dwarves were far more open with touch than hobbits, not just with the type of personal contact that was considered appropriate out in public, but also the length of contact and who touched whom. That said, they always seemed to know when someone did not want to be touched and who did not want to be touched in certain places at all without asking.

This applied to Bilbo too for the most part. At first, everyone but Ori, Fíli, and Kíli had given him a wide berth anyway. As they all warmed up to each other, though, the dwarves somehow knew what amount of touch he was comfortable with even though Bilbo never told any of them and tried his best to hide all signs of discomfort.

“I know that some of the others were… rude to you in the beginning, but no dwarf would ever make fun of someone for something like that,” Ori repeated. “Have any of them given you a reason to suspect they’d behave that way?” His voice was soft but firm and there was an undertone to it that reminded Bilbo very much of Ori’s older brothers.

Bilbo blinked at Ori’s nose a couple of times in surprise. “No, they haven’t…”

Ori sighed, his shoulders lowering. “Good... I didn’t expect they would, but if they did...” With the last few words, that undertone to Ori's voice was back again. Once provoked, Bilbo knew, the ‘Ri brothers had a temperament as fiery as their hair. He had no doubt that, had his response been affirmative, Ori would have rebuked the others just as strongly as his older brothers when they protected him.

The two of them sat in silence for a few moments before Ori asked, “What brought this on, then?”

Bilbo frowned. “Brought what on?” Back home people would have called him rude for repeating what someone else said, but he genuinely had no idea what Ori was talking about.

“When you said that it’s nice that the others aren’t making fun of Bifur, it sounded like… you were expecting them to.”

“Well... yes,” Bilbo said carefully, still frowning.

“But why?” Ori asked. “Why would anyone make fun of another person because of something they have no control over?”

Bilbo reached down to nervously play with the buttons of his waistcoat and only remembered that he had lost them in the Misty Mountains when he found empty buttonholes. Instead, he rubbed his hands together. “Obviously, Bifur has a good reason for his behaviour,” he began. His gaze was drawn up to the stable roof again, where Bifur was still standing. The sunlight hit the blade of the axe stuck in his head, making the metal shine bright enough to hurt Bilbo’s eyes. “He’s an exception to the rules.”

“Rules?” Ori repeated, the confusion now audible in his voice.

“How everyone is supposed to behave.”

Bilbo wished that he had brought his pipe. The familiar motions of lighting it and smoking the pipeweed would have calmed him down and kept his hands busy. He had to force them to stay in his lap and folded them together like he had been taught, else he would have started gesticulating wildly.

“It is our duty as members of a functioning society to function correctly ourselves. That means behaving like the people around you behave. Every kind of social context requires different behaviour. You know how you are supposed to behave in any given situation by planning ahead, observing the behaviour of other people, mimicking that, and gaining experience. It’s like—”

Loud laughter interrupted the conversation. Bilbo and Ori looked over to the others. Bifur was still on the roof, but he’d stopped flapping his arms and was laughing heartily. It was easy to see why.

Some of the dwarves seemed to be trying to build a tower by climbing on each other’s shoulders. Bombur was at the bottom carrying Glóin, who was carrying Bofur, who was doing his best not to fall over while Nori climbed up their backs. Most of the other dwarves not directly involved stood nearby, but far enough away that, should the tower topple over, they wouldn’t get hit. They were calling out suggestions or criticisms and were egging the four on, just as Bilbo would have expected.

“Ori!” Nori shouted over to them. “Come help! You’re the lightest of us!”

Ori shook his head with a sigh but jumped to his feet all the same and bid Bilbo goodbye before joining the others.

Bilbo leaned back and watched the shenanigans. Beorn probably had a ladder they could have used—that was probably how Bifur had made it up there himself—but somehow, he’d grown to like the chaos brought by the dwarves he considered his friends.

Just as Ori was about to climb up to follow his brothers, Bifur shouted something in Dwarvish and then, undeterred by the yelling that Bilbo didn’t understand either, jumped right on top of the dwarf tower. The tower swayed and almost managed to keep balance but then fell apart. Ori jumped away in time, but the others weren’t so lucky. Had Bilbo not known that dwarves were incredibly tough and hardy, he might have worried that someone was seriously injured, but after the dwarves on top got pushed away by those they were lying on, they all stood up no worse for wear, cursing and laughing.

Bilbo put a hand in front of his face to cover his growing smile and to muffle the sounds of his own laughter, even though no one was paying attention to him anyway. Or so he thought until he felt the prickling sensation of someone’s eyes on him and turned his head.

Thorin was looking in his direction with his intense bright blue eyes. A shiver ran down Bilbo’s spine. For once, it wasn’t because someone was looking at him, but rather because that person was Thorin.

He still remembered how it had felt when Thorin had hugged him on top of the Carrock. How warm Thorin had been. How nice he had smelled underneath the blood and dirt. How wonderful it had felt to be enveloped in the dwarf’s strong arms, to be pressed against his firm chest, just tight enough to be soothing…

Bilbo was glad his hand hid his reddened cheeks and quickly turned away again.

Logically he knew that relationships between two or more people of the same gender were common and fully accepted among dwarves—in fact, they even acknowledged more than two genders. He’d seen Dwalin and Nori flirt with each other and once or twice even engage in public displays of affection. Had heard Óin speak of his husband, too.

And yet…

Conflicting emotions warred in his chest. The familiar shame and fear, but also more positive feelings, a giddiness and warmth that he couldn’t or rather did not dare to name. Dwarves were accepting of men who felt something inappropriate—no, yes, no?—for other men. They had been quite shocked, in fact, to hear that relationships other than between a man and a woman were forbidden in the Shire but relieved to hear that Bilbo didn’t share the opinion and prejudices of his fellow hobbits.

The same hobbits Bilbo would have to return to at the end of this journey should he survive it. Had he been a dwarf, he could have experienced love like Dwalin and Nori or Óin and his husband. Somehow, that was worse than never knowing what could have been.

Bilbo tried to push away those thoughts and counted Beorn’s purple flowers again, but it took him several attempts before he managed to get rid of the mental image of Thorin with flowers woven into his hair.

-------

Hours later, while the members of the company sat together for a tasty dinner, from which only Gandalf and their host were missing, Ori looked at Bilbo from across the table and said, “I’ve been thinking about our conversation this afternoon…”

Bilbo paused in motion, his forkful of mushrooms hovering halfway to his mouth. He had learned long ago that statements such as Ori’s weren’t actually statements, but rather openings for something more, so he waited for Ori to continue, which the dwarf did after a few moments, “You were speaking about the rules of conduct that are necessary for society to function.”

It was not a question, but experience had also taught Bilbo that he was supposed to give an indication that he remembered. This rule had always confused him. It was obvious that he would still remember; it had only been a few hours and not only was he not that forgetful, he doubted Ori was either. Still, he nodded, ate his mushrooms, and put his fork down, since it was rude to continue eating while talking to someone.

“You were going to say more before Nori interrupted us. Some kind of comparison?”

Bilbo was under no delusion that most of the others weren’t listening. It made him uncomfortable, though he couldn’t say why, so he emptied his cup of cider and retraced his words. “You know how you are supposed to behave in any given situation by planning ahead, observing the behaviour of other people, mimicking that, and gaining experience. It’s like a recipe list. Only instead of ingredients like butter, berries, or mushrooms—” He gestured to their plates, which also gave him an excuse to look down rather than at Ori. “—it’s a list of acceptable and appropriate behaviours for every social situation. Where to look, what to say, who to touch and for how long, what amount of touch and close contact is absolutely necessary, what topics are appropriate, which ones to avoid, how to stand and talk, what you’re supposed to do with your hands or your face…”

He practically felt all the others stare at him. His own eyes flickered upwards for a moment to double-check but immediately focused elsewhere as he accidentally met Ori’s. Before anyone could say anything, he continued speaking, the words bursting from his mouth with next to no conscious decision on his part. “I’m glad that the rules among dwarves are much kinder than those in the Shire. When I was still a tween and went to the biggest market in the Shire with my parents, one of the stalls was manned by a fisher and his son, Bovo. He must have been only a couple of years older than me. He… wasn’t all there but he was very nice and knew so much about fish! I always liked listening to him describe all the different kinds he’d seen during his last trip with his father.” The smile that had gradually spread across his face as he talked faded again. “Whenever Bovo wasn’t with his father, the other tweens treated him very cruelly. They laughed at him, mocked his way of speaking, and played tricks on him. Most of the adults turned a blind eye to their behaviour and talked poorly about him, even when he was close enough to hear them. I tried to be especially kind to him whenever we went to the market but that hardly could have compensated for the cruelness from everyone else. After my parents died, I stopped going to that market. I hope Bovo is doing alright…”

Aware that he had far exceeded the appropriate amount of time allotted for one person to spend talking at once and that he had drifted away from the immediate question, Bilbo stopped talking.

There was silence for a few moments before the room erupted into noise. Bilbo winced and reflexively pulled his shoulders up, like he was trying to cover his ears with them. As always in noisy environments, Bilbo had trouble understanding what the others were saying, though he managed to discern a few words and sentence fragments, even if he couldn’t reliably tell who had said them.

“Why would—” Bombur?

“—dishonourable!” Glóin?

“—how dare—”Dori?

“Mahal’s design—” Balin?

“—not right—” Fíli.

“—just because—different?” Kíli.

“—fucking pricks—” Bofur.

“That is horrible!” Ori.

“Atkât!” Thorin. His rich deep voice cut through the noise, silencing the other twelve dwarves just like he had done in Bag End.

Bilbo’s eyes flickered to the head of the table where Thorin was seated and found the dwarf looking at him with an expression bereft of all the obvious signs Bilbo had learned to associate with particular emotions.

“Hobbits ridicule others simply for having different minds?” Thorin asked in an equally neutral tone.

“Not all of us,” Bilbo said defensively. It felt like all eyes were on him and that Thorin and the others were judging him. “My parents and I never did. Compared to the hobbits of Hobbinton, people in Tookland and Buckland are more open-minded and accepting of those of us who are different.”

“Peace,” Thorin said and held up his hands, palms towards Bilbo, a placating gesture dwarves apparently shared with hobbits. “I did not mean to imply that you are like those hobbits.” His voice dropped, then, both in volume and level, as he said, “I dare say you are extraordinary among your kind.”

Bilbo felt his cheeks heat up and hoped that it wouldn’t be obvious in the low light of the central fire. He knew dwarves saw better in the dark than hobbits did, but from what the others had told him, the darker it got the less colours they could differentiate. Still, to be safe, he ducked his head, letting his hair fall into his face. It was longer than he was used to, but he found himself liking the feeling. It would be even better if he had beads like the dwarves, which he could then fiddle with or make jingle by shaking his head. When he went back to the Shire, he’d unfortunately have to cut his hair again; it wasn’t acceptable for male hobbits to keep their hair this long.

“No wonder they always act like we’re pissing in their porridge!” Nori said. As usual, he ignored when Dori hissed his name in admonishment for the crude language. “If they don’t tell us their stupid rules, how the fuck are we supposed to know about them?”

“As if you’d follow their rules if they told you!” Bofur said and laughed.

“Never said I would,” Nori drawled. “But it would be a lot funnier to break their rules on purpose than accidentally.”

“They don’t tell you the rules,” Bilbo said. “At least not most of them.”

He saw some of the dwarves exchange looks. Studying their faces and comparing their expressions to the mental library he had constructed for each of them, Bilbo would guess that they were confused, so he elaborated, “Gentlehobbits are taught what behaviour is appropriate for our station, but most of the rules are unspoken. I can't remember seeing any other child being... instructed or scolded as often as I have. I was, however, the Baggins heir and the Baggins clan is strongly associated with being respectable. It would make sense if the rules for future clan heads are stricter and that the rules for my family are even stricter than that.”

Unable to keep still any longer, he reached up to the lowest buttonhole on his coat, which was under the table and thus out of sight for everyone, and started tugging on it, keeping his eyes on the plate in front of him. “Then again, whenever I misbehaved, my grandmother Laura said that it must be the Took blood that makes me so unruly and wild. She sometimes told me that I should try to be more like my father, then I’d be a good child…”

Silence.

Bilbo braced himself for another explosion of sound like the last time, but when no one said anything for several moments, he cautiously lifted his head and found that everyone was staring at him again.

Dori and Nori were looking at him with the same kind of expression they usually had when interacting with Ori, whose own expression mimicked his brothers’. Glóin’s and Fíli’s expressions were similar; Bilbo had seen it before when Glóin talked about his son and Fíli about Kíli. Bofur, Bifur, and Dwalin looked angry to varying degrees and Bilbo hoped they weren’t angry with him. Balin looked lost in thought, stroking his beard as he often did when giving a matter full attention and consideration.

He had no idea what the remaining four dwarves were thinking. If he had to guess, which in the past had led him astray more often than not, he’d say that Bombur and Kíli were sad. The corners of their mouths were downturned and their eyes were shinier than those of the others, though there were several other possible reasons for that. Óin was shaking his head, mumbling something Bilbo couldn’t parse, and Thorin…

Thorin looked like he had just had an epiphany. His eyes were wide and his mouth was open a little, reminding Bilbo of his father’s expression whenever he solved a particularly difficult riddle.

It was not Thorin who broke the silence, however, but Balin. “I hope you won’t mind me asking you some more questions about this topic,” he said, still stroking his beard.

“…no, not at all,” Bilbo said after a few moments of hesitation. While he was worried that Balin wanted to know more about his past misbehaviour to criticise him, he thought he knew Balin well enough to know that the dwarf wouldn’t do that.

Balin smiled at him, easing some of those worries. “You said you never saw any of your peers being instructed or scolded as often as you were. Have you ever had the feeling that your peers had a much easier time learning the rules and following them?”

Bilbo frowned and replied, “Yes, a lot of times.”

A lot didn’t cover it.

When he’d been younger, it had frustrated him to no end that the other children seemed to grasp the rules and intricacies of social interaction much quicker than him. His cousins never seemed to struggle with the right timings during conversations or with interpreting social cues Bilbo couldn’t even identify most of the time. They never seemed exhausted after family gatherings or parties, nor did they need several days of solitude and quiet afterwards before feeling up to the company of people other than his parents.

They seemed to know how to insert themselves into conversations without interrupting them. How to speak about a topic without rambling and to switch between different subject matters instead of lingering on one topic for too long. How to tell when someone was serious or joking. How to know whether people were being sincere or mocking. How to know when they were overstaying their welcome.

It all looked so easy when other people were doing it, but for Bilbo it was anything but—conversations left him exhausted. He always had to dedicate at least half of his mind to the rules. If he didn’t, people would think he was weird… well, even weirder.

“—like a lot?”

He’d been so lost in thought again that he had missed what Balin asked him. Bilbo blinked a couple of times and sought for something to say that would mask his confusion, but then Balin already spoke again.

“I know you and Ori spend a lot of time talking about hobbit and dwarf tales, fables, myths, and stories, both fictional and factual.”

Bilbo felt his face heat up in embarrassment and nodded to show Balin that he was listening this time.

“Are stories and historical accounts something you like a lot?”

“He likes poetry and songs best,” Ori interjected. “He told me once that he’d like to translate Elvish poetry into Westron so people can read them without having to understand Quenya or Sindarin."

Normally when elves came up in conversation, there was much grumbling, scowling, and cursing. Dwarves and elves really didn’t like each other, Bilbo had come to learn, so he did not talk about them with anyone other than Ori, Fíli, or Kíli. There was grumbling now, too, but only a little.

“There are many records of dwarven poetry in Erebor’s library,” Thorin said with an undertone that Bilbo couldn’t identify. “Not all of it is in Khuzdul. You could read those poems… if you’d like.” Thorin added the last three words as if they were an afterthought. He sounded almost… nervous, but that wouldn’t make any sense, so Bilbo figured he was misinterpreting something.

Then Thorin’s words registered.

“Really?” Bilbo perked up and looked at Thorin with wide, excited eyes. “But Ori said not everyone is allowed access to the library…”

“You are more than welcome there,” Thorin said, looking at Bilbo with a smile. Ever since the Carrock, Thorin had been smiling at him a lot and each time it made Bilbo forget how to control his facial muscles and body.

Bilbo managed to return the smile and said, “Thank you.” He felt giddy with excitement and just barely managed to keep his hands and arms still.

Time almost seemed to pause as the two of them smiled at each other from across the table. Bilbo had almost forgotten that they weren’t alone until Balin spoke again.

“I recall more than one occasion when you were so absorbed in a task that you didn’t hear us approach or talk to you.” Bilbo sunk down a little on the bench, but before he could apologise, Balin gave him a kind smile and said, “It’s commendable that you can dedicate all your attention to something. Not everyone can do that.”

“I can’t,” Kíli said. “I’ve lost count how many times I was heading somewhere, dead-set on doing a particular task, and by the time I’m there I’ve forgotten what I meant to do. Or I remember a different task and go do that instead. Amad, Uncle, and Fee helped me figure out the best ways to stay on task. I break my duties down into smaller steps, try to give them an interesting or fun spin to help me stay engaged, and keep a list of the things I have to do each day as a reminder.”

“We always tell him to take pride in the steps he does complete even if he doesn’t manage to get through all of them,” Thorin said, “and that with only a few exceptions, it is fine if he does something the next day or even the day after.”

“Just as it is perfectly alright to be so engrossed in something that you forget other things you meant to do,” Balin said. “Unless the other things are eating, drinking, or resting.”

“That has happened to me before,” Bilbo admitted, then immediately regretted it. He’d been scolded about this before.

“You’re old enough to manage your needs by yourself, Bilbo!”

“No one should have to remind you to eat. What are you, five?”

“When was the last time you drank something, Bilbo? Well, no wonder you’re dizzy and have a headache!”

“You’re an adult, Bilbo. Really, if you can’t take care of yourself by now, when are you going to learn?”

“You spent all night reading? What a silly thing to lose sleep over.”

There was no mocking, chiding, or criticism coming from the dwarves, though. He hadn’t expected them to react like that, not really, but old habits die hard and old anxieties were even more tenacious.

Some of them looked amused, others concerned, and the oldest two ‘Ri brothers were regarding him again with that expression he’d seen often enough to recognise it even when it was directed at him and not their youngest brother.

“I’ve been lost in a good book before, too,” Ori said to Bilbo with a smile.

“He’d spend the night in the archives if we’d let him,” Nori said and nudged Ori with an elbow.

Ori blushed and since he was still smiling, he must not have taken it as scolding or making fun of him. Bilbo found himself smiling too, happy to hear that Bifur’s, Kíli’s, and Ori’s quirks were accepted and accommodated rather than held against them.

He wished it was like that in the Shire.

 “I promise that after this next question, I won’t be bothering you any longer about this topic,” Balin said. “I—”

“You’re not bothering me,” Bilbo blurted out. It was incredibly rude to interrupt someone, but he wanted Balin to know that he truly wasn’t bothered.

Everyone had been incredibly nice and kind to him since this conversation began. By now Bilbo had accepted that they weren’t judging him and his oddities, even if he hadn’t internalised that just yet. It was still hard to believe after years of feeling like everyone was watching his every move and word, waiting for him to mess up so they could criticise and mock him.

“I’m happy to hear that,” Balin said, a sentiment that was echoed by several of the other dwarves. “If you end up changing your mind, just let me know, and if you ever feel like not talking for a bit, that’s alright. Don’t force yourself to do something you don’t actually want to do.”

Bilbo’s expression must have given some of his surprise away judging by the fact that everyone was staring at him with those concerned looks they’d repeatedly given him throughout the evening. Avoiding all the eyes that were on him, Bilbo fixed his own on a spot on the wall next to Balin’s right ear and, in lieu of anything better to say, mumbled, “Thank you.”

Someone—Bilbo guessed Thorin but couldn’t be sure—cleared their throat and Bilbo’s skin stopped crawling from all those eyes on him. He couldn’t help but sigh and hoped no one had heard it.

“I remember a conversation we had a few weeks ago about the differences in our senses and perception,” Balin finally continued where he had left off. “One of the things we noted was that hobbits have a sharper sense of hearing than dwarves. I am wondering however whether you can remember ever hearing something your relatives either didn’t hear or hadn’t noticed before you mentioned it?”

Bilbo frowned. The previous questions all had made sense to him and fit within the overarching topic they had established at the beginning. This question did not fit, however. Either Balin had changed the topic for some reason or there was a link here that Bilbo couldn’t figure out. It wouldn’t be the first time Bilbo missed something like that and besides, it would be rude to ask Balin what this was all about.

“Yes.” He started fiddling with the buttonholes of his coat again. “My parents used to say that I have ears like a bat. I was much more sensitive to sounds than them but that wasn’t always a good thing. Sometimes I could barely stand to share meals with them because it was almost painful for me to hear them chewing their food. My father liked sugar in his tea and I always had to brace myself when he stirred it in because his spoon would clink and scrape against the teacup. And sometimes even when I heard what someone said, it took my mind a while to correctly interpret the words. If my attention was somewhere else, it was even worse.” Bilbo shrugged. “It’s mostly minor things like that."

“Minor things can quickly accumulate and turn into something bigger,” Thorin said. Bilbo turned to look at him in surprise. “Do you find it difficult to block out sounds around you? To understand what someone is saying if there are people nearby having their own conversations?”

“…yes…”

“Are you also sensitive to smells? Are there any scents that you cannot stand but don’t seem to bother other people as much as you?”

Bilbo felt torn between confusion and profound relief that someone else seemed to understand. “I really do not like most perfumes,” he replied. “The flower ones are fine, but when they mix together different flowers, I get nauseous. One of my aunts wore a perfume so strong that the smells lingered in our smial for days afterwards.” He almost felt sick because of the memory. “I also have a strong dislike for raspberries—not just the smell, but also how they feel in my mouth.”

 “How do you feel about wool?”

“If I wear something underneath it’s fine, but I can’t stand the feeling of it on my bare skin. It’s… itchy. My mother once bought me a shirt made with goat wool from a market in Dale, though, and it was so soft I never wanted to take it off again.”

Thorin nodded, as if anything Bilbo was saying made any logical sense. “In Erebor we traded with the Zirinmazân, the Ironfists, in the far east. They produce nôs-wool, which is made from goats. It was the only type of wool Frerin was able to wear.”

“Your brother?” Bilbo asked, even more confused.

It was the first time he had heard the name since the night Balin had told him about the battle in which Thorin’s grandfather and brother had lost their lives, alongside Balin and Dwalin’s father and countless other dwarves. Bilbo had no idea what it must have been like, to lose family members so violently and suddenly. His own parents’ deaths had been the opposite—slow, drawn-out, and gradual. His father fell ill one harsh winter and held on until the coming spring; his mother died eight years later from an infection which she fought for several months before finally passing in her sleep. He’d known they would die soon but when the moment came all the preparation in the world would not have been enough.

To have that happen suddenly and during battle when you had to fight for your own life? He couldn’t imagine it—just like he couldn’t figure out why Thorin was bringing up his brother now.

It almost sounded like…

…but that couldn’t be, could it?

“My brother knew practically everything about all the gemstones found in Middle-earth and beyond. When it came to jewel making, there was no one more skilled than him,” Thorin said. “His mind worked differently than mine or my sister’s. He was… the Khuzdul term is difficult to explain. It is a combination of our word for mind and a particular type of tool used for precision work in jewel making, fittingly enough. He was sensitive to certain sounds, textures, tastes, and other sensory stimuli. When he was working on a gemstone or piece of jewellery, he was so absorbed in his task that he forgot all time and bodily needs. I had to pull him away from his workstation more than once.” There was no annoyance in Thorin’s voice, only amusement, fondness, and a faint note of sadness.

“And just like you, he struggled with the unspoken rules of social conduct. While my sister and I learned how to hold conversations naturally and with little concerted effort, Frerin had to work hard for that knowledge. Dwarf society is generally very accommodating when it comes to physical or mental differences, but there are still expectations for how nobles, and the royal family in particular, are supposed to behave. The rules were stricter for me as the heir of the heir, but my brother had to face these expectations too. He constructed elaborate routines for every kind of situation with the same parameters you talked about before. He studied how other people interacted and categorised all nuances. Where to look, what to say, who to touch and for how long, what topics are appropriate, how to stand and talk, and so on. He said that those routines took so much mental labour that he was usually exhausted at the end of the day. He told me once that it was such a relief to pass the guards in front of the royal quarters because it meant he could take off his masks and just be himself.”

Thorin leaned forward. Their eyes met for a moment—long enough for Bilbo to notice that they seemed even brighter than normally—before Bilbo’s gaze shifted down to Thorin’s nose. “I believe you might be like my brother.”

…could it be?

Was Thorin right? Was Bilbo like Frerin? Was he…

“So I’m not…” Bilbo began and was surprised to hear his voice shake. He swallowed hard and folded his hands together tightly, pressing his fingertips against his knuckles to help him focus. “I’m not… broken or bad?”

His parents had always told him that he wasn’t.

“There is nothing wrong with you, dear,” he heard his father’s voice in his head. “Never let anyone tell you otherwise.”

“You are our son, Bilbo, and we love all of you,” he heard his mother say.

He’d tried to hold onto their words after their deaths, but it had become harder and harder to ignore every word of criticism, the thinly-veiled mockery, or the stares that seemed to follow him from the moment he stepped outside of Bag end.

“Of course not!” came from the others, the ‘Ri brothers and the two princes being the loudest.

“You’re not broken or bad,” Thorin said firmly, but kindly. “You are Bilbo Baggins of Hobbiton and you are the fourteenth member of this company. You are you.”

Bilbo only noticed he was crying when he felt the teardrops fall on his hands. He unclenched them and wiped away the tears. Someone offered him a handkerchief; he only realised it had been Dwalin when he registered the tattooed runes on the dwarf’s knuckles.

The others were silent, giving Bilbo the time to calm down again. The tears stopped flowing after a minute, but it took Bilbo a little longer before he found the capacity to speak. “Thank you,” he mumbled. As he looked up his eyes were immediately drawn to where Thorin was sitting.

When Thorin noticed him looking, he gave Bilbo a warm smile and Bilbo caught himself thinking, he looks even more beautiful when he smiles. Then the individual segments of that thought registered properly. He felt his cheeks heat up and quickly looked down in the hope that no one had seen him blush.

A man being interested in another man was fine among dwarves, he knew that, but carefully-constructed routines and instincts were hard to ignore—and he didn’t know what the others, what Thorin, would think should they find out. He had overheard enough to know that Thorin was theoretically attracted to people of all genders, but maybe it was frowned upon for a dwarf to be in a relationship with someone who was from another species. Not to mention that Thorin was king. Surely there were rules...

Once Bilbo was certain his blush had disappeared, he looked up again. It took him a few moments to realise why his vision was moving side to side. He’d started rocking left to right and back again without noticing it. Bilbo froze, feeling the beginnings of panic rise up his spine, but no one so much as looked at him.

It would take some time to get used to this—the lack of judgment, the easy acceptance and acknowledgement.

“The more I hear about hobbit society, the less I like it,” Bofur said as he reached for his tankard of mead.

“As if you liked it at any point,” Nori said and winked at him.

“I like plenty enough about them!” Bofur protested. “Their food, their pipeweed, their purses…”

“Not as much as Nori does, I reckon,” Dwalin said, which made most of the dwarves, including Nori himself, laugh. Bilbo found himself smiling too.

Once everyone had calmed down again, Bofur continued. “First they try to tell grown people they cannot love each other, as if that’s any of their business. Then they’re making fun of people for things they can’t always fully control and telling them that they can’t be themselves. As members of this company, it is our duty to keep each other safe. I say we keep Bilbo after our quest is over.”

Bilbo’s mouth fell open, though he was too flabbergasted to say anything and simply stared at Bofur as if the dwarf had lost his mind. He waited for someone to protest or point out how silly that idea was, but no one did. In fact, far too many of the others looked thoughtful, as if they were actually considering the idea.

“There’s a section on the return journey in the attached and appended conditions of the contract,” he reminded them. For all its obvious bias towards the dwarves, Bilbo liked the contract. In comparison to some of the ambiguous and incredibly vague documents he had read back home, the dwarves’ contract detailed very clearly what was expected from him and left next to nothing unanswered. He’d said as much to Balin at one point in their journey and Balin had been quite pleased by the compliment.

The dwarf in question nodded and quoted from memory, “Return Journey is deemed outside the Terms of Reference encompassed herein, and accordingly Burglar shall return to his place of residence by his own means, guidance, expertise and expense, but with such directions, advice and goodwill as can be offered by the Company.”

Bilbo thought that would end this discussion, but the argument was apparently not as conclusive as he would have thought.

“Well, this member of the Company advises the Burglar to stay with us in Erebor,” Bofur said.

“It would be, in fact, quite negligent if we advised anything else,” Nori said.

It didn’t surprise Bilbo that the two of them were talking about this matter as if they were taking it seriously. They both were jokesters who loved to give dry, sarcastic comments with thankfully enough of a tell that even Bilbo could usually figure out when they were joking and when they weren’t. Usually. It looked like they were being serious right now, but that made no sense.

What did surprise Bilbo was that Dori, who disapproved of most of Nori’s jokes, seemed to agree with him. “You would be better off living somewhere where people appreciate you.”

“And where you can be yourself without having to mask all the time!” Kíli said.

Maybe, Bilbo wondered as almost all the remaining members of the company began to nod along and offer more reasons why Bilbo should stay, they aren’t joking after all.

He would have expected the mere idea of leaving his familiar and familial home with all his favourite things and comfortable routines to douse him in cold panic, but instead he felt warm all over. They cared enough about him that they wanted him to stay. They wanted to protect him even after he fulfilled the task he had been hired for.

It was nice to imagine what it might be like to live among dwarves—to live with his friends and to live as himself without the many costumes, the masks, he hid behind all his life.

Kind of like the games of make-belief he had played as a child in which he fought against dragons and went on adventures, back when adventures had been something fun and not something from which you might never return. It was its own kind of make-belief to think about a life in Erebor when it was more than likely that the only thing they’d find at the end of this road was death by a dragon.

Still, it was nice to imagine what it might be like to live with his friends who liked him for who he was and not who he pretended to be.

If Thorin would even allow it.

Yes, Thorin had given him permission to go into Erebor’s library, but that didn’t automatically mean that Thorin would permit him to stay for any longer than necessary. After the Carrock and his apology, Thorin had been much kinder, friendlier, and open with Bilbo, but that didn’t have to mean anything, either.

He looked over to Thorin, trying to gauge whether this discussion—serious or not—was offending him, and was surprised to find a small smile on his face. Not quite used to the sight yet, Bilbo halted long enough for Thorin to notice him staring. The dwarf’s smile widened and his bright blue eyes focused on a spot right between Bilbo’s own, looking back at him without forcing the discomfort of eye contact on him. That thoughtfulness made Bilbo feel warm all over again.

“We still have a long journey ahead of us,” Thorin said. He looked at each member of the company one by one, ending again with Bilbo, and held up his tankard as if making a toast. “More than enough time to convince him of our goodwill.”

It took Bilbo a little bit of time to understand what Thorin meant. Mouth falling open, Bilbo stared at the dwarf in shock as the others around them cajoled and cheered. That sounded like Thorin wanted him to stay in Erebor too…

He didn’t need a looking glass to know that his face was red. There was no way Thorin hadn’t noticed, not with the way he was still looking at Bilbo even as he brought his tankard to his lips.

Heart racing, Bilbo hid behind his own tankard and felt a smile lift up the corners of his mouth.

----

“Bilbo.”

Bilbo tore his eyes away from the giant bees buzzing around Beorn’s garden and looked to his left.

“Thorin,” he greeted the approaching dwarf.

It was the day after the big conversation, as Bilbo had named it in his head. The day after he learned that he wasn’t weird, bad, or broken after all. That there were other people like him and that Thorin’s brother had been one of them.

Everything and nothing had changed since that revelation. The dwarves treated him like they had before finding out that his mind was different. Though Bilbo had tried to hide his eccentricities, they had picked up on most of them anyway. Now he knew why. They were so used to noticing and accommodating other people’s physical and mental needs that they’d done the same thing with Bilbo.

Just this morning during breakfast, when Bilbo tried to fish out the small pieces of apple in his porridge without drawing too much attention to himself, Bombur, sitting next to him, said, “My wife can’t stand the feeling of something crunchy in otherwise soft food, either.” His voice had not changed from its usual cheerful cadence, as if this was something ordinary—and for him and the other dwarves it truly was.

Maybe it would become normal to Bilbo too, one day. Even if he returned to the Shire after all this was done, the other hobbits wouldn’t be able to take that away from him, the knowledge that he was neither alone nor broken, no matter what they said.

If… when had that become ‘if’ and not ‘when’?

He couldn’t examine this thought for much longer as Thorin came to a stop next to him. When he didn’t immediately sit down, Bilbo looked up at him in confusion.

“May I sit with you?” Thorin asked.

“O-of course,” Bilbo replied, feeling his cheeks heat up with a blush.

“My brother was alright with physical touch as long as it wasn’t sudden or brief and he could see the person touching him. Is it like that for you too?”

Bilbo considered the question. No one had ever asked him that nor had he ever thought about it this explicitly before. Finally, he replied, “That sounds alright.”

Thorin smiled and sat down right next to him, so close that their legs were pressed together, and he could feel the dwarf’s body heat. The bench, like all the furniture on Beorn’s homestead, had been made with his giant frame in mind. There would have been more than enough space for Thorin to sit without touching him, which meant that it had been deliberate.

Bilbo’s cheeks were burning now. He ducked his head to hide it, but probably not fast enough for Thorin not to see it.

For a few minutes, they sat together in comfortable silence. Usually, Bilbo would have tried to find something to talk about, even if it was as inane as the weather. He’d been told that it was rude to let silence fester if it was only him and someone else, as that person might find it rude if he said nothing. He didn’t feel that urge now and knew that dwarves, and Thorin especially, liked quiet as much as Bilbo himself did.

After a short while, though, curiosity made him break the silence. “If it doesn’t bring you too much pain, could you... tell me more about your brother? It’s just... I’ve never... heard about someone like me and I... would like to know more about him. If that’s alright. If not, it’s... fine, of course…”

In the Shire, someone would have scolded him for stuttering through his words and for rambling so much. It was instinctual to tense in anticipation, even though he knew no one here would chastise him or make fun of him for that. Still, Bilbo felt embarrassed and nervously started to fiddle with the hem of his shirt.

“My sister and I talk about Frerin often to keep his memory alive. We have also told Fíli and Kíli many stories about their other uncle,” Thorin said. He was still smiling, Bilbo noted as he looked over to him. “Frerin was very similar to them in character. He liked to play harmless pranks and frequently pulled Dís and me into them. Like Kíli, he was a very empathetic person. Once he learned what different emotions looked like for each of us, there was no hiding how we felt—he was very sensitive to the emotions of other people, much more so than any of us. His own emotions were always intense and he sometimes had trouble regulating them. He liked to joke that he was compensating for me and my sister. She and I are alike in temperament. While we are more reclusive and introverted, Frerin was outgoing and social. He loved being among people but he needed alone time every couple of days just to recuperate and build up his tolerance for other people again.

“When Dís was very young, Frerin loved taking care of her and was even better at recognising what she needed than our parents and grandparents. He said her needs were straightforward and simple. Eat, sleep, attention, hygiene. He knew what she was crying for usually even before our parents did.” Since Bilbo was still looking at Thorin, he noticed when the dwarf’s expression turned sad. “He died long before Fíli and Kíli were born. He would have loved them like they were his own children.”

“As you do,” Bilbo said.

“Their father died shortly after my sister gave birth to Kíli. I have helped her raise them since. They are my heirs.” The shadows disappeared from Thorin’s face as he smiled again. “They still have some growing up to do before Fíli sits on the throne.”

Thorin’s tone of voice was one Bilbo hadn’t heard from him before. Was he… joking? Or teasing?

“They have given me most of my grey hairs,” Thorin continued, “but I know that they will make their mother and me even prouder than we already are.”

Bilbo smiled. “You and your sister have done a great job raising them. They’re good boys.”

“Most of the time.” Bilbo was fairly certain now that Thorin was joking.

Laughing, Bilbo wordlessly conceded to that point. They were adults by the standards of dwarves but sometimes they reminded Bilbo of his tween cousins.

After some more pleasant silence between them, Thorin turned towards Bilbo again. “What about you?”

“Me?” Bilbo asked in confusion.

“Do you like children?”

Bilbo thought about the question. Most of his Baggins relatives were annoyed that he always took a while to reply to them. They accused him of either not having listened or being distracted. Even after he demonstrated that he had listened, they chided him for keeping them waiting. Or, which was worse, let just enough annoyance show to make it clear to Bilbo what they were thinking, but not enough to be impolite themselves. His grandmother Laura had done that a lot.

Dwarves, he’d come to learn and appreciate, were very straightforward. If they didn’t like something, they told you. Thorin didn’t look annoyed. He simply sat there and waited for Bilbo to bring his thoughts into order.

Was this another—quirk?—Bilbo shared with Frerin and others like them?

“It depends on how old they are,” Bilbo finally replied. “Most of my cousins have children and some of those children have their own children already. I am fine with the younger fauntlings for a few hours at a time, but I could never handle them around the clock. They’re… messy, unpredictable, and chaotic. All that noise, the bodily fluids…”  He shuddered.

Thorin chuckled. “You’re not wrong about that. Thankfully they grow out of that phase comparably quickly.”

“Once my cousins’ children got older, it became much easier for me to deal with them. I still wouldn’t want to care and be responsible for them the whole day, but I could probably do it if I had to. For some reason, once they’re past toddlerhood and before their tweens, my cousins’ children enjoy spending time with me.”

Maybe because he had no idea how to talk to children, so he treated them like adults, which they seemed to like. Or maybe because in Hobbiton at least, he was one of the few adults who would read them stories about trolls and dragons, and who was willing to act out those stories with sticks as swords and pot lids as shields.

“It’s a lot of fun playing with them,” he said with a smile, which faded again as he mumbled, “They’re usually a lot less judgmental than tweens or adults, too.”

They tolerated difference much better than older hobbits. If they noticed Bilbo’s oddities, they either didn’t think too much about them or found them funny, but not in a mocking kind of way. That changed as they got older, at least for the hobbits of Hobbiton. The Tooks and Brandybucks were much more open-minded.

Thorin had nodded along as Bilbo spoke. “For Frerin it was the other way around. He liked how simple the minds of babies and toddlers are. It gets more complicated as children age and become their own person. Nonetheless, he wished to have children of his own one day.”

Since Thorin had never spoken about nephews other than Fíli and Kíli, Frerin must have died before he could fulfil that wish. He had been young for a dwarf, if Bilbo remembered right; the equivalent of a tween and not yet an adult. Too young to have children. Too young to die. Bilbo lowered his head and together the two of them sat in respectful quiet for a few heartbeats.

Then Thorin continued, “I have never felt the urge to father children myself. Some of the nobles in my council aren’t happy with that. They believe that it is my duty to sire children to keep Durin’s line alive, as if my sister wasn’t a daughter of that same line. I never listened or cared for their arguments, nor for the people with the capability to give birth they introduced me to in the hope that I would be interested in them. Fíli and Kíli are my heirs and that is final. You have mentioned before that you are the head of the Baggins clan. Have you faced the same pressure?”

“Goodness, no. I have more than enough Baggins relations to become the head of the clan after me. My heir is Otho Sackville-Baggins, one of my cousins from my father’s side. We don’t place as much importance on direct succession as dwarves do.”

That was not to say that Bilbo’s relatives had never tried to pressure him into fathering children, but once his... peculiarities had become widespread knowledge and certain rumours had made their rounds through Hobbiton (and beyond), those comments stopped for the most part.

Thorin looked intently at Bilbo for long enough that he grew a little uncomfortable even though Thorin wasn’t making eye contact. Then he finally picked up the conversation again as if there had been no pause. “Have you ever thought about it?” When Bilbo looked at him in confusion, he clarified, “Having children.”

Even Bilbo noticed the note of nervousness about Thorin, though he couldn’t figure out the reason for it. “Not really, no. Even when I was still a child myself, I never imagined what it would be like to have children. At most I thought about babysitting my cousins’ fauntlings, but I generally didn’t think about the topic at all. Then once I got older and gained actual experience being around younger children, I quickly realised that it wasn’t for me. Besides…”

Bilbo paused, though there was no reason to. After all, dwarves accepted relationships between people of the same gender, so he knew that Thorin wouldn’t judge him for his predilections. Even so…

He had never talked about it with anyone other than his parents, who had assured him that it was perfectly natural for a boy to have a crush on another boy, no matter what anyone else said. Most hobbits didn’t share his parents’ opinion on relationships between people of the same gender. No one would speak about it out in the open with polite company, but even then the disgust and disapproval whenever the possibility was so much as hinted at had taught Bilbo very quickly to never let anyone else know.

There was no danger letting Thorin know, but still Bilbo’s heart began to race and his hands to shake. Had he been alone, he might have started swaying back and forth in an effort to release some of the anxiety. But Thorin was watching him with a light frown, so Bilbo forced his muscles into stillness and only allowed himself to start nervously tugging on the buttonholes of his coat. At some point he would have to ask Thorin if that was another common quirk of people like him.

“Besides, I never thought about fathering children anyway because… well, because I… I’m what we call a confirmed bachelor in the Shire.”

He didn’t expect Thorin to understand the term and was proven right when the dwarf asked, “A confirmed bachelor?”

Bilbo had to push the words out of his mouth. “A person who has not been married yet and is unlikely to in the future. That is a rarity in itself in the Shire, since most people marry young and have children quickly, but in… certain contexts, it may also be a… somewhat polite and indirect way of indicating that the person in question might be… interested in people of the… s-same g-gender…” He turned his head away from Thorin and dug his nails into his palm, so that he could focus on something other than the growing panic in his chest.

Thorin was silent for what felt like hours to Bilbo but was probably less than a minute before he asked, “Can I touch you?”

The question brought Bilbo up short and stopped him from spiralling even deeper. He frowned but nodded and turned his head again to see what Thorin was doing. The dwarf moved slowly, telegraphing his movement, and put a hand on Bilbo’s thigh. It was heavy and its warmth immediately seeped through Bilbo’s trousers into his skin. After apparently waiting for Bilbo’s reaction, Thorin gently squeezed his thigh. He could almost have wrapped it completely around Bilbo’s leg if he wanted.

“There is nothing wrong with romantic or sexual interest in one or several people of the same gender,” Thorin said, his voice a soft and deep rumble. “It is a disgrace that the people around you made you feel like you couldn’t be yourself. I'm sorry you had to hide who you are.”

Bilbo felt heat rush to his cheeks. He was staring at Thorin’s hand, which was still resting on his thigh, and tried his best to not start crying. “T-thank you,” was all he managed to say. His voice was shaking. It had taken him far too much effort to get those two words out.

Thorin must have noticed how close Bilbo was to completely withdrawing into himself and gave him the time to compose himself again. At no point did he remove his hand from Bilbo’s leg. Its weight and warmth were like an anchor, keeping Bilbo’s consciousness tethered to his body.

Bilbo had no idea how much time he had lost before he came fully back to himself. He blinked, moved each finger after the other, and then curled them into the fabric of his shirt. It took him a bit longer to remember how to speak and then it was only a murmur. “I’m sorry.”

“You have nothing to be sorry about,” Thorin said immediately and firmly. “It is understandable that this topic overwhelmed you. Frerin was prone to exploding outwards while you withdrew into yourself. I apologise if I overstepped or made you uncomfortable.” His hand twitched, then he raised it a little, as if he wanted to withdraw it. Without thinking, Bilbo covered it with his own.

A heartbeat later, Bilbo realised what he’d just done and froze, head to furry feet. He tried to tell his hand to move but it refused to cooperate. Would it be dramatic if he took out his little letter opener and cut it off? He could run away then before he embarrassed himself any more, if that was even possible. “I’m s-sorr-y,” he managed to stutter out.

“You have nothing to be sorry about,” Thorin repeated. Bilbo thought his eyes were playing tricks on him because there was no way Thorin was really lacing their fingers together, but he didn’t think he could hallucinate the feeling of the calloused hand holding his own.

He was blushing again. His head was probably red like an apple; he was thankful he didn’t have to see it for himself.

They sat together like that for some time and Bilbo waited anxiously for Thorin to draw away. A small part of him feared that Thorin would laugh or make fun of him, even though he knew Thorin wouldn’t do that.

Thorin said, “We really should keep you with us.”

Bilbo frowned. It took him a little time to make sense of the comment, but then he remembered Bofur’s and Nori’s words, as well as the others’ agreement, from the evening before. “I’m still not sure whether they were serious or joking.”

“They were completely serious,” Thorin said, “and I have to agree with Bofur. The more I hear about hobbit society, the less I like it.”

“It’s not that bad,” Bilbo said, somehow feeling the need to defend his home and people even though he wasn’t too fond of them, either. “As I said, hobbits in Tookland and Buckland are much more open-minded than the hobbits in Hobbiton. There are exceptions there, too. My father would never have treated anyone badly because of who they are or who they loved. Both my parents knew about… all that and they still loved me.”

“I’m glad your parents were by your side,” Thorin said softly and applied gentle pressure to their joined hands. It drew Bilbo’s attention. He had almost forgotten that they were still doing that. Normally, he would have been hyper-fixated on the skin contact and almost nothing could have distracted him from it.

The words jumped from his tongue before his mind could stop them. “Ever since they died, the Shire doesn’t feel like home anymore.” He thought he had trained himself out of the habit of oversharing information, but it was hard to remember all that sitting so close to Thorin and holding the dwarf’s hand.

Thorin said nothing for a few moments, then murmured, “Ered Luin never felt like home. Even if I lived there for seven hundred years, it wouldn’t.”

Copying Thorin, Bilbo squeezed his hand and hoped it would bring him comfort just as it had for Bilbo. It seemed to have worked—Thorin smiled at him and squeezed back.

“I know Erebor won’t be the same as I remember it. It will take a while for us to repair all the damage caused by the passage of time and that cursed worm, but maybe one day it will be like the Erebor that lives on in my memories.”

“I hope so, too,” Bilbo said. “I hope our quest will be successful and that you can return to your home.”

“Who knows,” Thorin began, that nervousness back in his voice, “maybe you’ll like it enough to stay for a while.”

Bilbo ducked his head. “I would only get in the way of everyone.”

Not I don’t want to leave the Shire forever, nor I don’t want to live in a mountain with dwarves.

If, not when.

“Nonsense. But even if you did, none of us would mind,” Thorin said, saving Bilbo from the confusing mess that were his thoughts. “I did mention that you have permission to go into the library. You certainly wouldn’t be in anyone’s way there. You might even be able to help Ori and the other scribes sort through all the records. And…”

Bilbo waited for him to continue speaking, but when Thorin stayed silent for too long, he lifted his head and regarded the dwarf again. He looked even more nervous now. His cheeks were flushed a little and his gaze was rapidly jumping from one point to another and then back again. He was also rubbing the hem of his tunic between the fingers of his free hand, something Bilbo had seen Kíli do several times before.

He had no idea why Thorin would suddenly become so nervous. Had Bilbo done something wrong for him to react like that?

Thankfully he didn’t have to guess much longer as Thorin looked at him again, his eyes fixed on Bilbo’s forehead. “And maybe… once reparations are on their way and depending on my schedule and yours, maybe… maybe I could join you in the library every now and then and… translate some of the Khuzdul poetry for you… if you’d like…”

That sounded like...

Bilbo’s heart began to race again. He opened his mouth, then immediately closed it again.

It couldn’t mean... had he misinterpreted? They were still holding hands, but that... was there another explanation for that? Among hobbits, only parents and children, as well as couples, held hands… he hadn’t seen any of the dwarves do that before. For all that some of them acted like children, none of them were, and the only couple, Dwalin and Nori, weren’t the touching sort of people, he really couldn’t imagine them holding hands just like that… Did holding hands mean something different to dwarves? But then Thorin wouldn’t be so nervous, would he? But it couldn’t be… there was no way Thorin meant it like that… but they were still holding hands.

He was torn out of his mind when Thorin spoke again. “As you know, while dwarves come of age at 40, we are only considered adults at 65 or even 70 years of age.” Confusion about the sudden change in topic slowed down Bilbo’s thoughts and heartbeat. “My brother died with 48, long before such things as marriage become important, but dwarves of that age are no strangers to crushes or even lasting love and neither was he. Erla, the daughter of a minor lord, caught his attention. When my brother’s duties and his mental state permitted, they spent much time together. It was obvious to everyone who saw them that they liked each other, but Frerin was unsure whether she liked him in return. He wasn’t shy with other matters, but in this he was uncharacteristically timid and none of my parents’ assurances encouraged him to confess his feelings to her.”

Why was Thorin telling him all this now, after what he had just said?

“Imagine our surprise when on a day like any other, my brother sat down at the table for our traditional family dinner and told us that Erla suggested that the two of them could go down to the thaikû ‘ibîn, the gemstone mine, together. Frerin was very confused by the suggestion since she was an apprentice engineer, who only worked with a handful of gems and those only after they have been polished. She knew of Frerin’s fascination with gemstones, of course, but she was only interested in them the same way most dwarves without a particular calling are. To us, it was quite obvious what her motive was, but Frerin had no idea. Can you guess why?”

Bilbo was thoroughly confused now. Was this a test? Thorin probably wouldn’t laugh if he got it wrong, but still an uncomfortable feeling settled in the pit of Bilbo’s stomach. “…you’re supposed to be interested in what your friends like…” he said, cautiously choosing each word. At least that was what his parents had taught him. Bilbo didn’t really have friends when he was a child, but that lesson had helped him out a couple of times when he didn’t know what else to say.

Thorin was smiling, so Bilbo figured his answer hadn’t been completely wrong at least. “That’s more or less what Frerin said when our mother asked him the same question. Our father then asked Frerin to describe how Erla was acting immediately before and while she was making the suggestion. Frerin had a sort of library in his head in which he recorded the facial expressions, as well as gestures and other such signs from everyone he frequently interacted with—”

“So that’s… normal, then?” Bilbo interrupted. “For people like… him… or me?”

If Thorin was annoyed by the interruption, he didn’t let it show. He nodded and said, “The extent can vary, but overall, yes, that is common. But what is normal? My brother enjoyed eating food with different textures, you dislike it. Both of you had or have problems with sheep wool, but others with the same condition can wear it just fine but might struggle with something you can wear without a second thought. There is no ‘normal’. Not for people like you, my brother, or Kíli, and not for people without such difficulties. Mahal formed each individual dwarf from stone and no stone is the same as another. There is a Khuzdul saying: Mahal ma mahtashgami, Mahal makes no mistakes, and neither did your Maker when she created you.”

Bilbo squeezed his eyes shut to stop himself from crying again. It took him a while to calm down. As he sat there just remembering how to breathe, Thorin silently sat next to him holding his hand, grounding him with the contact and the warmth. With a shaky exhale, Bilbo opened his eyes and turned his head to look at Thorin again. He felt the urge to apologise, but remembered what Thorin had said, so he swallowed the words down and smiled.

Thorin smiled back. He quickly seemed to find what he was waiting for—some indication that Bilbo was alright?—and continued. “Frerin said that Erla had been acting nervous the entire time they’d been together that day and only got more and more nervous the closer they came to the crossing where they would part ways. Shortly before they reached that part of the mountain, Erla suddenly stopped walking. Frerin asked her why she had stopped and instead of answering his question, she suggested that the next time they met, they could go to the thaikû ‘ibîn together, if Frerin would like. My brother said she wasn’t looking at him when she made that suggestion. Instead, she was staring up to the crystal lamps above their heads. That was unusual, he told us, as she normally tended to look at his mouth or chin, which were eye-level to her. She was also stuttering a little, which was equally unusual, and when he looked at her, he noticed that where her beard didn’t cover them, her cheeks were red.

“Our father asked Frerin what his answer to Erla had been and Frerin said that he’d agreed to go to the mines with her. He also said that immediately after he told Erla that, her cheeks became even redder and she giggled as she said goodbye and practically ran away, much to Frerin’s confusion,” Thorin continued. “Our parents told Frerin that based on what he had just told us, they were certain that Erla had asked him out not simply as a friend, but with… romantic interest.” He was looking away once more, but Bilbo had already seen that the tip of the dwarf’s nose and his cheeks were pink again.

Nervous… looking away… stuttering… blushing…

Just like Thorin, now and when he suggested—

‘She suggested that the next time they met, they could go to the gemstone mine together, if Frerin would like.’

‘Maybe I could join you in the library every now and then and… translate some of the Khuzdul poetry for you… if you’d like.’

Bilbo startled and stared at Thorin. If Erla had asked Frerin out ‘with romantic interest’, then Thorin… “You’re asking… me out? Romantically?” His hands were shaking and his heart was racing again.

He saw Thorin swallow hard before he turned to look at Bilbo again. “I would like to court you,” he said, then added with a wry smile, “romantically.”

“Court me,” Bilbo repeated faintly.

“Yes.” Thorin lifted their joined hands up to his face and, after waiting for protest which did not come, kissed Bilbo’s knuckles.

Bilbo felt himself blush. “I have no idea how dwarven courtship works...”

For... obvious reasons Bilbo had never courted or been courted by anyone in the Shire, but he had seen enough prospective couples to know the basic steps. Walks through the village with chaperones. Flower bouquets composed of a small array of acceptable flowers with minor variations depending on how well the man knew the woman—such a shame that the women didn’t give the men flowers, too. Visits to each other’s families to receive their blessing and for the two clans to hash out all particularities.

Even if he had not been interested in men only, he didn't think he would have enjoyed the process at all... but if dwarven courtship was like that except for the flowers, he’d manage to get through it. That was perhaps something that united Bilbo with other hobbits. He knew he would willingly go through all of that because of the hope that lay at the end of the road.

“It is very simple,” Thorin said. The way his lips moved against Bilbo’s knuckles sent shivers down Bilbo’s spine, but in a good way. “Spending time together. Exchanging gifts and—”

“What kind of gifts?” Bilbo asked, immediately nervous.

“If possible, gifts made by your own hand.”

Bilbo’s face must have conveyed some of his distress at that information because Thorin smiled and kissed Bilbo’s knuckles again. “That includes poetry and other written craft.”

“Oh… well, that’s alright, then,” Bilbo said, feeling a little silly now.

“Gifts by your own hand, family treasures, or objects with great significance. In the days of old, it was custom for members of the royal family to gift their intended or intendeds items made from mithril, though that has become rarer after the loss of Khazad-dûm,” Thorin continued and gave Bilbo another smile. “As I was saying, spending time with each other, exchanging gifts, and, most importantly, exchanging kisses and other light intimacies.”

Bilbo was blushing again. Hobbit courtship did not allow… intimacies. At most, the two people who were courting could hold hands or exchange kisses to the cheeks and all that only under supervision. Though it was apparently also seen as scandalous if the couple wasn't caught doing something they weren't supposed to do, which made no sense to Bilbo at all.

“Does that sound good to you?” Thorin asked.

“The k-kissing or…?”

“Everything,” Thorin said. “We would only go as far as you are comfortable, I promise. It would be alright if you don’t want to kiss just yet or ever—”

“No!” Bilbo blurted out. His mouth was making sounds with little conscious directions. “Kissing… sounds good. Yes. I’d be… alright with that. Only… I’ve never done it before.”

An emotion Bilbo couldn’t decipher flashed across Thorin’s face. “I’d be more than happy to show you how,” he said, his voice a deep rumble. He let go of Bilbo’s hand, gently cupped his cheek, and leaned closer, but his lips did not touch Bilbo’s yet. “If you’d like.” He was so close that Bilbo felt him breathe.

“I’d like that,” Bilbo said.

Thorin closed the distance between them and kissed him.

Kissing Thorin was even better than good. It felt wonderful. The gentle pressure of lips against his own. The soft scraping of Thorin’s beard against Bilbo’s skin. The warmth of the large hand cupping his cheek. After a few moments, Thorin opened his mouth a little and tilted his head. Following Thorin’s lead, Bilbo did the same and found that it was even better that way.

Thorin drew back, wrapped his arms around Bilbo, and drew him tight against his broad, firm chest. That way, Bilbo was at the perfect height for resting his head on Thorin’s shoulder.

“Was that alright?” Thorin asked. His voice was even deeper now than it usually was. A not so small part of Bilbo was giddy because he had caused that.

“Yes,” Bilbo said against Thorin’s neck. This close, he could feel Thorin shiver and wondered whether he had caused that, too.

He didn’t immediately notice that he had started to tap random rhythms onto Thorin’s back but once he did, he forced his fingers into stillness and was glad that his face was hidden.

“You don’t have to stop,” Thorin said in a casual tone that set Bilbo’s nerves at ease. “Frerin also had to keep his hands busy. As a child, he used to tug and chew on my or our parents’ braids. Once he got older, he carried fidgeting devices around instead. It’s nothing unusual.”

“Oh…” Bilbo murmured. He hesitated but then allowed his fingers to move again.

“I know it will take time for your mind and body to shake off the years of conditioning and suppression but know that none of us would judge you for who you are,” Thorin said. “We like you with all your quirks. I like you the way you are.”

Bilbo smiled even though Thorin couldn’t see it. “I like all of you the way you are, too.” He was blushing once more and wondered whether Thorin was able to feel it. “I… like all of you…"

Thorin took a deep breath before asking, “Would you permit me to court you?” He was sounding nervous again.

“Yes,” Bilbo replied immediately.

Thorin kissed the top of his head and whispered something in Khuzdul, then in Westron, “Thank you.”

“No,” Bilbo said. “Thank you. For telling me that I’m not broken but simply different. That it is alright for me to be myself. For liking me the way I am. All of me.”

He was a little disgruntled when Thorin drew away, but that displeasure disappeared quickly when Thorin kissed him again.

Notes:

I had this idea a while ago after reading a few stories set in the modern day in which characters learn they are autistic. I wanted to transfer this premise from the real world to Middle-earth and maaaybe project a little on to Bilbo and Frerin while I'm at it. I've also included some autistic traits that I don't personally have, as well as experiences or quirks that are the 'opposite' of mine but I know from friends and fellow autistic people.

Nôs-wool is a reference to the Mongolian word for wool, ноос 'noos'. Mongolia is one of the two leading producers of cashmere wool.