Chapter 1: Bad Boy With A Tainted Heart
Chapter Text
Steve really hated these parties. Like, he really hated them.
They were just glorified pageant shows, with each person showing off their new watch or dress, hoping to impress someone slightly richer and snobbier than themselves.
Naturally, Steve would never be caught dead at one of these places, but seeing as he had the unfortunate luck to be born a Harrington and engaged to one Tommy Hagan, he didn’t exactly have a choice.
As it was, hanging off Tommy’s arm and trying to appear “docile” and “submissive” all evening while insults were constantly hurled his way was just par for the course for Steve at this point.
Maybe he would have wanted more for himself years ago, when he was still stuck in a backwater town in Indiana, unaware that all he needed was actually in that backwater town, but now? Now Steve just wanted a break. A single day to himself, where he didn’t have to endure Tommy’s bullshit and his parent’s bullshit and–well, everyone’s bullshit, really. As his ex would say, “It’s all bullshit”. That hurt like nothing else at the time, but damn if Steve doesn’t understand it now.
As a smooth hand roughly gripped his jaw, Steve figured it didn’t matter what he wanted. He certainly wasn’t going to get a break tonight.
“... are you even fucking paying attention right now Steve?”
Tommy’s voice filtered back into Steve’s head, the noise grating.
What had Tommy been saying?
There was no use in trying to remember, he was already pissed off. Well, this should be good.
Prying the unnaturally smooth hands from his creaking jaw, Steve replied, “Y’know Hagan, I really wasn’t.”
A hand came up to fist in Steve’s collar, forcing his head to swivel, his eyes reluctantly meeting Tommy’s.
Anger was flicking in his eyes, a fire that could easily become an inferno at the slightest provocation. “When I talk to you, you fucking look at me, okay? Look at me, Stevie.”
That grating voice again, slithering into Steve’s ears without his consent, making his name sound like something slimy and disgusting. He hated when Tommy called him Stevie. He thinks Tommy probably knew that and called him it on purpose.
The corners of Tommy’s lips picked up in a cruel mockery of a smile, his fist tightening on Steve’s collar, and Steve could tell that whatever Tommy said next, he wasn’t gonna like it.
“Why don’t you show us that smile,” he made a show of smoothing out Steve’s collar as he said it, his fingers brushing against his throat in a way that was reminiscent of a predator intimidating its prey, the fox reminding the weak little mouse that a single slash of its claws could tear out its throat. “Show everyone that pretty little smile that made all the girls in Hawkins weak for you.”
Steve couldn’t stand it anymore. Couldn’t take that cruel glint in Tommy’s eyes getting brighter and brighter the more he shrunk in on himself.
Stepping back sharply, Steve fled the ballroom, escaping towards the men's restrooms. He didn’t look back, but he could imagine the sharpness in Tommy’s eyes all the same. The way his smile would fall, and be replaced with a mask of cold rage, before that too got swallowed up by Tommy’s inherent need to suck up and be liked. He was probably telling the men they were standing with how unruly Steve is, how disrespectful he is.
He honestly could not give less of a shit what Tommy’s stupid rich friends thought of him.
The second that gaudy ring had been slipped onto his ring finger, Steve stopped caring about everything. His life was a prison, and that ring was the ball and chain keeping him trapped.
In the restroom, Steve took a minute to loosen his tie and just… stare at himself.
No one looks good in public restroom lighting, but Steve knew the paleness of his skin wasn’t due to shitty LEDs. The dark circles that were just barely covered up by copious amounts of concealer; the unnatural thinness of his body, unnoticeable unless someone saw him naked, and it’s not like even Tommy was doing that nowadays. Not that he’d care even if he did see Steve wasting away before his eyes. At most, Tommy would be annoyed at what it’d do to his public image. At most.
Sighing, Steve splashed some complimentary cologne–personally he thought it smelled like shit, and if Tommy was going to force him to stand shoulder to shoulder, then he’d have to smell it too–on his neck and redid his tie, huffing at the crinkle of his collar. For someone so concerned about his social standing, Tommy never particularly cared about being seen roughing up his fiance. He was always such a goddamn hypocrite.
The sounds of the main ballroom assaulted Steve when he stepped back out of the restroom, a hundred nasally voices discussing vapid topics all overlapping and melding into white noise. However, at the sight that greeted him just as he rounded the corner, his own father could be yelling right beside Steve, and he wouldn’t notice.
Right in front of him, just a handful of steps away, stood Tommy and Carol fucking Perkins. Known as an “It” girl, Carol had been a massive bitch even in high school, and it seemed that nothing had changed. The three of them used to be something akin to friends back in Hawkins, but that was before Nancy and Jonathan and the Party and… yeah, before all of that. Now, Carol flaunted her connection with Tommy in front of Steve’s face, knowing how much he hated it. Steve might not love or even like Tommy, but he would never stand for cheating. He’s been through it once before, and he refuses to ever go through it again.
Deciding in one moment how the rest of the night was going to go, Steve marched up to the pair with a fake air of nonchalance, and uttered the words that would undeniable seal his fate:
“So Carol, you’re not working the street corner tonight, I see.”
Tommy’s eyes snapped to Steve’s, burning hate meeting cold defiance.
This was not going to end well for one of them, and Steve had a feeling he knew which of them would be suffering for this.
Carol let out of a scoff of disbelief, disentangling her perfectly manicured hands from where they were teasingly wrapped around Tommy’s tie.
Grabbing his wrist in a punishing grip, Tommy yanked Steve beside him.
Tightening the grip even more, Tommy asked “What the fuck is wrong with you?”
He didn’t bother waiting for a response–not that Steve was going to provide one–and shot an apologetic look towards Carol before bodily dragging Steve out of the ballroom and to the back of the building.
Tommy pushed Steve outside into the dark alleyway, shoving him harder than necessary.
“How dare you disrespect me like that! Who do you think you are, who do you think you’re talking to,” Tommy spit out the words with pure venom in his tone, still painfully gripping Steve’s wrist. He thought he could feel his bones creaking in protest, but maybe he was imagining it. According to Tommy, Steve imagined a lot these days.
Staying silent, Steve simply kept his gaze level, refusing to let Tommy show that he was affected by the vitriol he was being dealt.
Clearly fuming at Steve’s refusal to respond, Tommy slowly released Steve’s wrist. For one foolish, foolish moment, Steve thought that maybe he had gotten off the hook. Maybe Tommy was just going to leave him out here and go back inside. That wouldn’t be too bad, right?
Instead, Steve’s head shot to the side as Tommy slapped him, no doubt leaving behind another nasty bruise that concealer will just barely cover up.
Unlike all the other times Tommy has decided to take out his rage on Steve physically, a deep shout interrupted.
From behind them, a tall man grabbed Tommy’s shoulder, yanking him around and swiftly kicking him in the stomach.
Tommy let out a grunt of pain and fell to his knees, and the man took that as an opportunity to give him a slap of his own, the sound reverberating off the stone walls of the alley. Tommy’s head slammed back, but the man wasn’t done yet. With one final punch straight to the nose, Tommy fell over, curling up on his side as blood poured out of his now surely broken nose.
The man turned to Steve then, his face shrouded in shadows. He could just make out a strong jawline and what looked like blond hair before the man was walking past him, throwing out a “You okay?” on the way.
More than a little breathless, Steve replied in the affirmative, but then thought better of it.
Walking over to where Tommy lay curled up on the asphalt, Steve angled his body and sent a kick right to his crotch, leaving him to groan in pain and curl into himself further.
Steve looked up at the man who was now sitting astride a motorcycle, a helmet obscuring his face.
He stepped over Tommy’s body and took the proffered second helmet, latching it into place and taking his seat on the bike behind the man.
Without even a glance spared for his fiancé, he replied, “Now I’m okay.”
The man’s laughter was drowned out by the sound of the engine roaring as he kicked off, peeling out of the carpark so fast Steve lurched forward and slung his arms around the man’s waist.
This was definitely not how he expected his night to go.
Chapter 2: Told Me I Should Stay Away
Chapter Text
After a few minutes of driving, it suddenly occurred to Steve that he had no idea where he was going or who this man even was. Hell, he could be leading Steve straight to his murder den right now. Besides a little shiver of fear licking up his spine, Steve honestly didn’t even care. There was no way in hell he was able to go back home, and his father would cut him off the second Tommy came crying to him, so why not get murdered by some hot guy. At least he’d get some good eye candy before he went.
Okay, so maybe he’s being a little dramatic, but can you blame him? Steve has had a very trying night and he’s entitled to at least a little melodrama. A voice that sounds suspiciously like Nancy Wheeler says that he is most definitely not entitled to that.
Fuck Nancy Wheeler.
Thoughts of his ex aside, Steve laid his head on the man’s back, turning so he could see the city as they swept through it. He’d never been on a motorcycle before, but it was kind of breathtaking. It was almost like riding a rollercoaster, the thrill that comes with moving far too fast as the wind curls around you. Oddly enough, Steve wasn’t afraid at all. For some reason, he completely trusted the driving ability of this stranger in front of him. He’s probably jumping the gun a little, but the man feels… trustworthy. Familiar, in a strange sense. Steve certainly would have taken notice of him if he was from Hawkins, so that can’t be it, but there was just something about this guy that reminded Steve of something. Hopefully, when they get to wherever it is they’re going–please don’t be a murder den please don’t be a murder den–he’d find out what.
Until then, Steve was content to hold on a little tighter and close his eyes, letting the purr of the engine and the lights of the city fade to white noise.
A sudden jolt kept him from falling asleep, and Steve grumbled under his breath as he raised his head, wondering why they deviated from their smooth sailing.
The looming apartment complex directly in front of them killed any lingering exhaustion.
Right. He let a strange, violent man drive him back to his own place, to a part of the city he wasn’t familiar with.
Steve was so dead.
The man killed the engine, flipping out the kickstand. For a moment, he just sat there, his whole body tense (Steve may or may not have conveniently forgotten to let go of the man’s waist). With a sudden flourish, he yanked the helmet off his head, and swung his upper body around to face Steve.
This had to be a dream.
Or more accurately, a nightmare, because there was no fucking way Billy goddamn Hargrove was staring back at him.
Tommy must’ve really hit Steve for him to be hallucinating Billy Hargrove’s face right now.
He thought that had stopped the first year of their engagement.
No, he will not elaborate on that.
A soft knocking sound alerted Steve back to the present, possibly-real Billy gently rapping his knuckles against Steve’s borrowed helmet.
He cleared his throat, and in a voice Steve hadn’t heard in years, asked “You alright in there, Harrington?”
All of a sudden, the situation came spiraling back to him, and Steve’s body jerked. His hands flew off of Billy’s body, the harsh motion sending him sprawling backwards off the bike and onto the hard pavement. His head crashed into the ground, the helmet thankfully sparing his skull from any further damage.
As he laid there groaning in pain, he could vaguely recognize the sound of Billy hopping off the motorcycle albeit in a much more graceful way and rushing towards him.
“Shit man, you okay?” Billy asked as he ended up sort of straddling Steve. It was a weird position, and probably not intentional, but it still made Steve’s face heat up, bringing back all sorts of memories from high school he’d rather have never thought of again.
Billy’s hands came up to his head, beginning to lift off the likely-banged up helmet, but remembering how red his face must be, Steve slammed his hands over Billy’s, abruptly halting their movement.
Tilting his head a little, Billy furrowed his brow and looked down at Steve. The helmet’s visor was too tinted to see through from Billy’s perspective, but Steve still felt like they were making direct eye contact. It was distinctly uncomfortable, but not terrible like he’d expected. His poor face was probably looking like a tomato by now.
Slowly, like it would literally kill him to go any faster, Billy slid the helmet off Steve’s head. Even in the poor street lamp lighting, he knew Billy could see every thought that was running through Steve’s head on his face. He’d always been able to do that. It’d been annoying at first, then endearing, then heartbreaking at the end. He knew that Steve had been lying through his teeth that day, but he didn’t fight. Steve still doesn’t know how he feels about that.
Like it was uncanny, Billy clearly read those thoughts on his face, too, because his eyes seemed to shutter, that quiet spark in them dying out. Whatever Billy had been searching for on Steve’s face, he either found it and didn’t like the answer, or couldn’t find anything at all.
Clearing his throat again, Billy seemingly finally realized the position they were in, and hurriedly rose and stepped away from Steve, who was still sitting on the ground, stunned.
Billy reached out his hand, steadfastly looking away. A flash of anger surged through Steve’s body but fizzled out just as soon as it appeared. He didn’t really have any right to demand Billy’s attention, did he? Not after that day. Not like he used to.
Resigning himself to a deeply uncomfortable night, Steve took Billy’s hand, heaving himself up off the ground.
As soon as he was on two feet Billy dropped his hand like it was searing, striding towards the front entrance of what was apparently his apartment building.
The whiplash was killing Steve, truly.
What was he even meant to do? Billy was clearly uncomfortable around him, yet he still knowingly took him back to his place. What did he want from Steve? Was he supposed to follow Billy up to his apartment? Maybe Billy was just offering Steve a ride away from Tommy and that stupid party. Yeah, that was probably it. Steve pointedly ignored the tendril of disappointment that curled around his stomach. He had no right to feel like that, none at all.
Steve had just turned on his heel to find a bus stop when Billy called out from the entrance, “You comin’ in or what, Harrington?”. Billy poked his head out and raised an eyebrow at Steve still standing on the sidewalk.
“Well, I–I thought, I was just gonna…” At the unimpressed look Billy shot his way, Steve sighed and headed up the walkway to join him at the entrance. “Yeah okay, I’m coming.”
Silent following him inside, Steve thought over the situation he was in. What were they gonna do once they got in his apartment? Were they just going to sit awkwardly and make polite small talk until Billy kicks him out? Fat chance. It’s entirely possible that Billy just wants to scream and bitch at Steve for the way he ended things. It wouldn’t be terrible out of line either, a little annoying maybe but still nothing less than what Steve knows he deserves.
By the time they’ve actually reached Billy’s apartment door, Steve’s resigned himself to a night of further abuse.
Chapter 3: I Know This Ain't Smart
Chapter Text
For once in his life, Billy had no fucking idea what to say.
This whole situation is insane!
First, he gets stuck catering some fancy rich people party. Fucking awful. He hates his New York friends so much. Then, as if having to be in the same room as rich assholes wasn’t bad enough, who shows up but Steve fucking Harrington, hanging off Tommy Hagan’s arm, the two looking like the happiest couple this side of the Hudson. It was disgusting. He will not comment on the fact that he had to avoid their side of the room after seeing Steve laugh at something Hagan said.
After all that shit, it’s finally time to leave, and just as he’s throwing the last of the trash into the dumpster, Hagan drags Steve out to the alley. Fucking of course.
Billy was fully prepared to head back inside when he realizes Hagan is pissed, and not like he got in high school when Steve started dating that Wheeler chick, no Hagan is fucking furious right now.
It’s the slap that spurs Billy into action. No matter his feelings about what Steve did, no one gets to hurt him like that, and especially not Tommy fucking Hagan.
Honestly, until Hagan was bleeding out on the ground, Billy wasn’t even sure what he was doing. All he knew was that Steve’s cheek was bright red and this asshole didn’t deserve to breathe the same air as him. God, he hated Hagan. For a variety of reasons.
It took him a while to realize, but as Billy was driving towards his place with Steve snuggling into his shoulder, he remembered one fundamental truth about himself: he was hopelessly, madly, deeply, truly in love with Steve Harrington. Always had been, always will be. Clearly, no amount of distance or time could change that irrefutable fact. Steve would always have Billy’s heart, whether he wanted it or not. And god, Billy hoped he still wanted it. He knew that, despite all the pain Steve put him through these past few years, he’d take him back in a heartbeat. In a second, he’d take him back.
And as he lifted his helmet, and Steve crashed to the ground, Billy remembered another fundamental truth about himself:
Steve Harrington would never love him back.
He had been naive to think otherwise, but the look of… guilt in Steve’s eyes cemented it for him.
Billy had given Steve his heart, and Steve had staked it to his bedroom wall in his parent’s house.
Somehow, he was going to have to be okay with that.
Okay, there is no way he can be okay with this.
What the fuck is he supposed to do when the love of his life is swimming in his own clothes and curled up on his couch! What is he supposed to do??
Not kiss them, for starters. He’s been doing pretty good on that front, except for how his hands twitch uncontrollably whenever a lock of Steve’s hair falls out of place or how he swears he isn’t staring at Steve’s extremely long legs. Nope. He’s not doing any of that.
This is going to be a very long night.
Maybe it was stupid to bring him inside. He can’t just kick him out, not at eleven pm on the wrong side of town. Hagan will probably be blowing up Steve’s phone any minute now, so really he’s just… sheltering Steve for the time being. Yeah. Sheltering.
Of course, he doesn’t exactly want to let Steve go back to Hagan. He’s never wanted that, but every time Steve turns his head just so and the slowly darkening bruise on his cheek catches the light, Billy just wants to go back and beat the shit out of Hagan some more.
He’s still considering the pros and cons of it when Steve finally speaks up.
“It’s uh… it’s been a while, huh?”
Billy levels a deadpan expression at Steve for that one.
He winces, and apologizes. “Yeah that’s… my fault, I know. I’m sorry, Billy, I-I don’t… I don't really know what to do, right now, so–yeah. Sorry.”
“Jesus man, I’ve had your dick in my mouth,” Steve chokes on his coffee at that, “do we really gotta dance around each other like that?”
Steve swallows and messes with his hair a bit. “I know, but–”
“We fucked, you left, and now we’re here, yeah? Not really all that much to it,” Billy said, doing his best to ignore how the words left a sour taste in his mouth.
Steve’s eyes closed at that, his face all screwed up like he was trying real hard not to cry.
Shit. He’s making Steve cry. This night really fucking sucks.
Before he could even attempt to backtrack, Steve was out of his seat, walking very fast towards the bathroom.
Billy punched the cushion next to him twice, then got up to follow him.
They really needed to talk.
Chapter Text
Steve looks awful. Logically, he already knew he did (public bathroom lighting is a bitch), but something about being in his ex’s home, wearing his ex’s clothes, staring into his ex’s mirror in his ex’s bathroom while avoiding his ex was just… particularly pathetic. He feels so incredibly aware of himself, like he can literally feel each and every clogged pore on his face. He grips the sides of the pedestal sink and continues staring into his reflection. He hadn’t noticed earlier how bloodshot his eyes were or how cracked his lips had gotten, but he’s sure as hell noticing it now. What the hell happened to him?
Oh, right. Tommy happened.
Fuck Tommy Hagan.
Steve ran a hand through his hair (days unwashed, but dry shampoo and the fear of god can work wonders), sighing with a deep rattling breath. His heart felt it was trying to break out of his ribcage and land in the sink, all sad and bloody. He wouldn’t even mind that happening; it’d give him a fantastic excuse to escape this situation.
He’s starting to genuinely believe he might be cursed.
God, he was pathetic. This kind of shit is probably exactly why Billy clearly didn’t spare a single thought towards him or their relationship. ‘We fucked, you left, and now we’re here’? Seriously? How lame did Steve look, crying and shaking like a kid as he broke things off when there had been apparently nothing to break off. Had they even been dating? They kissed and fucked and drove together and cuddled at the drive-in, but they had never said anything about it. No confessions, no bouquets of flowers, nothing. One traitorous tear fell down Steve’s face as he thought about it. He had spent years pining after a relationship that had never existed. Christ, his life literally cannot get any worse than this moment.
Two swift knocks immediately proved that statement wrong.
knock knock
Silence. Maybe if Steve held his breath and didn’t make a noise, Billy would forget he was in here and go to bed or something, just anything to let Steve slip away without having to look at him again.
knock knock knock
Fuck. He can’t look Billy in the eye after realizing what he had. There was no way.
“I’m being nice by not just walking in, but this is my bathroom so I’m just gonna go in anyway,” came Billy’s muffled voice through the door.
FUCK.
As he heard the door knob start to turn, Steve pushed away from the sink, rapidly wiping his face and trying to lock all his feelings up tight. He’d gotten good at that with Tommy, but Billy was different. He always had been.
The door opened just as Steve managed to stop looking like a kicked puppy, and he whirled around as Billy slowly stepped into the bathroom. For some reason, he shut the door behind him, so now they were both just… standing in the bathroom. Alone. Together.
Billy seemed to realize this around the same time Steve did as the tips of his ears turned red.
Clearing his throat, Billy looked at a vague point above Steve’s head. “So–the fuck’s with the runnin’ away thing? Had to piss real bad?”
Sigh. “Maybe I did. It’s none of your business,” Steve huffed, “not like it ever was in the first place, apparently.”
That drew Billy’s attention back down towards Steve. What the hell does that mean? He said as much, brows pulling together in his universal “I’m both pissed off and not sure what’s happening” look he’d perfected after spending too much time with New Yorkers.
Steve crossed his arms, looking off to the side. “Exactly what I said. My business was never yours. We just fucked, remember?”
“Is that what this little temper tantrum is about? Did I offend your delicate sensibilities by bringing it up, princess?” Billy couldn’t resist sneering at Steve, the old taunt flowing out of his mouth so easily.
Steve glared back at Billy, finally looking at him. “Fuck this. This night has been shitty enough, I’m not dealing with this.”
The vitriol was easy to fall back into, like a bed of roses hiding thorns. It hurt, but it’s what they knew best. Their shared language.
“Am I too hard to deal with, princess? Gonna run back to fucking Hagan again?” Billy practically spit the words out, cursing Tommy as he said his name.
Stiffening, Steve drew himself up, adrenaline starting to course through him the angrier he got. “Shut the hell up. You don’t know anything.”
“Aw, did I upset you? Did I hurt your feelings? I know everything I need to know,” Billy continued, his tongue working faster than his brain as he tried chasing the anger on Steve’s face, “Like how King Harrington gets hit by his little boyfriend. Want me to slap you, pretend I’m Hagan?”
What little color there was drained from Steve’s face as he felt his heart leap up into his throat. What the fuck. Billy had always been a bully, but he’d never been so cruel before, especially not to Steve, not once they started… nothing, apparently. The world seemed to rapidly come into focus, to sharpen in front of him. They had been nothing, and they were nothing now. They would always be nothing. Billy hadn’t changed. He thought he might’ve, when the man was beating Tommy half to death in an alleyway, but maybe he just wanted to hit somebody. Maybe he hadn’t even realized it was Steve at first. He probably would’ve lended Tommy a hand if he had known.
Maybe this was it. The half-dead torch Steve had been carrying for Billy for years had finally burned out. This was the end.
Without speaking another word, Steve roughly pushed past Billy, sending him slamming into the sink as he rushed past. He heard Billy groan and curse, and a tiny, minuscule sliver of guilt wormed its way into his heart, but he refused to look back, to stop.
Steve grabbed his phone from where it had been charging on the coffee table and headed for the door. Billy was shouting from behind him, but a severe kind of calm had fallen onto Steve, like a thick blanket of snow. It covered everything and left him numb. He tugged the door open, intent on walking as far away as possible before hopping the closest bus. A sheet of rain greeted him outside, the sharp cold breaking through the fog in his brain. Everything he had shoved away when Billy said what he did came rushing back. All the hurt, anger, betrayal; it was almost overwhelming. He might’ve been crying, but any tears were mixed in with the storm beating down on him. The rain was deafening, and he became extremely aware of his shorts and thin t-shirt. It couldn’t be helped, there was no time to stop. He’d just have to deal with the inevitable cold.
A hand slammed into his arm, roughly yanking him backwards. It took the wind out of him, both the force and the searing heat bleeding through his soaked shirt. A second hand gripped his shoulder, forcibly spinning him around. He quickly became aware of shouting, just barely audible over the rain:
“FUCKING STOP, STEVE! STOP!”
Like a persistent itch he couldn’t get rid of, there was Billy fucking Hargrove again. Soaked through and screaming himself hoarse for no good reason.
Steve tried to throw off his grip, but he had become increasingly weak over the years, and couldn’t manage it. Instead, he just stood there, shaking and crying and screaming too.
“WHAT DO YOU WANT FROM ME! LET ME GO!”
Billy violently shook his head, water flinging from his hair. “SO YOU CAN GO BACK TO THAT ASSHOLE? HELL NO.”
“WHAT DO YOU CARE? I’M NOTHING TO YOU. WE ARE NOTHING!”
Falling silent, Billy reared back at that. He looked incredibly hurt. Steve swore he saw a few tears running down his face amidst the rain streaking across it. For a few moments, they stood in silence, rain crashing down around them. Both were breathing heavy, chests heaving with the effort talking to each other took. Finally, Billy opened his mouth again, but never in a million, billion years could Steve have predicted what came out of it.
“I FUCKING LOVED YOU! AND YOU LEFT! LIKE I MEANT FUCKING NOTHING,” his face finally breaking out into tortured expression as he screamed.
No no no no no. This isn’t happening. This isn’t happening. It can’t be happening, because that would mean Steve had been wrong about everything. Wrong about the depth of their relationship, about Billy’s true feelings, about how relieved he thought the other man was going to be when Steve left. He never really felt loved by Billy, not with all the arguments and sneaking around. Both men had their own reasons for keeping their relationship secret, but Steve had always assumed Billy had also been ashamed of him. He had nothing in Indiana besides his family name and a stupidly big house, for all the good both had done him. Who would want to admit to dating him?
Something must have shown on Steve’s face hinting at the mental spiral he was going through, because Billy’s softened, just slightly. He sighed before tugging at Steve’s arms, gently leading him away from the sidewalk and back towards his apartment. Blindly, Steve let himself be led. He could barely think about anything else other than how majorly he had fucked up.
Notes:
the girls r fighting omg
Chapter 5: Can't Deny, I Love The Guy
Notes:
tw for use of the f slur (it's by billy and he's making fun of himself for how gay he is)
tw for light suicidal ideation (its literally one line steves going through it)
(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)
Chapter Text
Twenty minutes later, Billy and Steve were back in the living room, sitting on opposite ends of the couch, silently dripping rainwater onto the few towels Billy had turned up. The silence was oppressive, and the tension thick enough to be bludgeoned to death with a nail bat.
“Did you mean it?”
Billy choked on his breath, not expecting Steve to be the one to break the silence. “Uh–Did I mean what, exactly?”
Steve closed his eyes, terrified of whatever answer he received. “When you said you loved me. Did you mean that?”
All at once that anger from earlier came rushing back. How dare he ask him that. How fucking dare Steve Harrington for asking if he really loved him. It was some stupid, insecure girlfriend bullshit, but what pissed Billy off was the genuine uncertainty in Steve’s voice. How the hell could he not have known? Billy practically had “huge fag for Harrington” plastered across his forehead back in Hawkins. That’s why he had been so scared of being affectionate; he felt like his step-dad was constantly breathing down his neck, ready to beat the shit out of the both of them.
“Fucking of course I meant it, the hell? You knew that,” the and you still left went unsaid.
Steve sucked in a shuddering breath and let out a wet-sounding laugh, though there was no mirth in it. He turned his head to finally look at Billy, his half-dry hair frizzing up and forming a curly halo around his tear-streaked face.
“I didn’t,” Steve’s lips curled into a thin, wry smile. “I thought you were ashamed of me.”
Billy’s heart all but stopped in his chest. There was no universe where he had ever felt an ounce of shame towards Steve, not even a speck.
Steve continued speaking even as it felt like Billy’s world was crumbling around him, “I never knew what you really thought of me. We didn’t talk about it. I didn’t care, I was willing to get whatever I could take from you.”
Steve turned his gaze to the wall, voice becoming quieter as he got lost thinking about their past. “When my dad told me he’d made a deal with Tommy’s family for us to get married, I thought I was going to die. I wish I had died then.”
Billy nearly stopped breathing at that. The mere thought of existing in a world without Steve in it somewhere was debilitating.
“I didn’t want to leave you, but my dad wasn’t someone I could just… disobey, not then at least. He controlled my whole life. I would have been lucky to make it out of Hawkins if I had tried anything. I couldn’t bring that onto you as well.” He smiled sadly, “I knew how much you hated Hawkins, you would’ve been miserable staying there for me. With me. I figured making you hate me would be the easiest for you. You wouldn’t be sad about me leaving if I had pissed you off enough,” Steve scoffed, murmuring under his breath about how that clearly hadn’t worked.
How does someone even respond to that? The two of them have been more honest with each other in the past half hour than they’ve ever been. Billy’s traitorous heart picked up again, beating with a passion. He didn’t want to think about it, didn’t want to even entertain the possibility, but… Steve hadn’t wanted to leave. Steve hadn’t wanted to leave Billy.
Before he could try to talk himself out of it, Billy was standing, damp towels falling to the floor. Steve looked up in shock, barely getting out a confused huh before Billy was suddenly a lot closer than he had been before. The two looked into each other’s eyes, Steve’s heart rising to match Billy’s as they both held still. Neither knew exactly what was happening, and both were terrified of somehow ruining it all over again.
Slowly, so slowly a glacier could move faster, Billy reached out a hand, ghosting over Steve’s cheek. He could feel Steve’s shiver through his hand and watched as patches of red bloomed across his face. He was afraid to even breathe too loudly and risk startling them out of this extremely fragile moment, but he swallowed his fear and opened his mouth.
“Everything’s fucked right now, and we need to talk about this more once we’ve gotten some sleep,” Billy took a deep breath, willing this to go the way he hoped it would, “but I love you now just as much as I did in Hawkins, and I don’t want to let you leave me again.”
Instantly, tears welled up in Steve’s eyes again, a few silently spilling over. He felt like he could barely breathe. He angled his head to gently press against Billy’s shaking hand, bringing up his own to cover it, like he was afraid Billy would take his hand away if he wasn’t holding it up.
“Please don’t leave me alone,” he whispered, the words barely audible to both men. “I’m sorry, I’m so sorry, I love you, too. Don’t leave me.”
As more tears hit against Billy’s hand, he let loose a breathy laugh before softly knocking their foreheads together. “I’ll never leave you again.”
It was a promise, fragile as their new kindled affection and bright as Steve’s laugh when Billy accidentally shook some rain droplets onto his face.
He’s always been a bit of a shit liar, and Billy would know that better than anybody, but if there’s one thing he’d never be able to deny, it’s that he really loves this guy.
Notes:
not me managing to update this fic exactly (to the day) two years from when i started it. truly i am unmatched.
does anyone even care about harringrove anymore. is that still a thing.
